Related
Here is an article about how rooting and jaikbreaking may legally come to an end in the near future.
www.noticeorange.com/StoryBody?id=4...RpY2VvcmFuZ2VyDQsSBFNpdGUY2ZLqAQw&font_size=9
Sent from my DINC2 in Yuma, AZ
Looks like there is a petition to sign... Will this do any good?
Don't think it will stick. To many means to move information.
Sent from my ADR6350 using xda premium
Not really much of an article .... I'll believe it when someone more reputable writes about it.
Jizzylax said:
Not really much of an article .... I'll believe it when someone more reputable writes about it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How about the Electronic Freedom Foundation?
https://www.eff.org/press/releases/help-protect-gadget-jailbreakers-and-video-artists-legal-threats
Considering how many people root/jailbreak, s**t will hit the fan if this passes.
this crap will never pass and if it does we will see some real sh*t hit the streets just like the sopa and pipa crap pirates will never stop just like the internet will never rest is like a hydra cut one head two more come out.
I rooted before they ever will make it illegal, so what will I have to do. I "don't" know how to unjailbreak lol
Sent from my Incredible 2 using xda premium
mdspace said:
How about the Electronic Freedom Foundation?
https://www.eff.org/press/releases/help-protect-gadget-jailbreakers-and-video-artists-legal-threats
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Who?
.........
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA App
Would be a bummer to not be able to use our phones that we bought.
LOL - ha ha. Tried, just try to enforce it in India, China & a few other countries and see what happened.
With CDMA only devices, it might be easier to attempt a crackdown - but, GSM devices that are sim-based, forgetaboutit ...
If this happens, pigs can fly too.
Some instances of altering game consoles for pirate gaming could be understandable cause it does hurt the companies (not that they are in pain) but I don't know off hand of anything or anybody that is hurt by my phone being rooted. HTC is aware its being done and aside from voiding the warranty they have not started any criminal procedure that I know of. I don't see this happening but I doubt they could enforce it. Hell an American developer would only have to post thru a foreign board member. Seriously let's focus our legal money/manpower on real issues.
AgalychnisCallidryas said:
Considering how many people root/jailbreak, s**t will hit the fan if this passes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Considering how many people use the internet, SOPA almost passed.
If this bill is real, there's a good chance it could get passed. Sure, lots of people root their phones, but in the grand scheme of things, considering how many people do -not- root their phones, the number of people who do is pretty minuscule.
Kinda like marijuana or alcohol. If it's legal, people are gonna do it legally. If they make it illegal, they'll do it illegally.
BTW, Apple tried this a few years back, it failed miserably.
Would there even be a way to know if someone rooted their cell? I'm not sure what would change if they couldn't...
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA App
good thing HTC is being cool and providing a way to unlock their phones for us. can't be illegal if the manufacturer provides it
What can we do to get GW accepted in more places? Or places that take paypass to get the darn machines working??? :banghead::banghead::banghead:
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Use it. That's about it. To be honest though, there really isn't a big demand for the technology at the moment. Few people have devices that can use the technology, and fewer still actually bother with it even if they have a capable device. The physical wallet isn't going anywhere anytime soon because it contains many things that your phone probably won't be privy to for a long time. Why bother with Google Wallet when you can just as easily pull out the credit card that your google wallet uses anyway, and not have to worry about whether or not the place you're at has NFC support?
I would LOVE for Google Wallet to catch on (and get a few more features <.<; ) and I think it will-- in a few years. For now, however, Google Wallet hasn't really proven itself to businesses and the average user as anything more than a gimmick.
I won't even bother using it until I can link it to my debit card.
More and more places accept paypass all the time. Google wallet isn't the only thing that uses it btw. I've never had an issue with a paypass machine myself.
I FINALLY found a place in my town where it works. It was a McDonalds, heh. Too bad I almost never go to McDonalds....
lordkaosu said:
I won't even bother using it until I can link it to my debit card.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This I would like to link it to other cards other then citi cards....
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
The feature I like the best is that it's not linked to my atm/debit card or my personal credit cards. That its only linked to the Google card and I have to put money into it makes me feel very safe and secure. I would have never activated Google wallet if it linked to my personal banking and credit info. This is by far the safest rout.
Sent using a cell phone....
Linking it to debit would help acceptance a lot I think. And perhaps digital ids but that may be a ways off unless governments step in and push that. But as is, it is probably too easy to hack, fake or manipulate digital ids. But it would be sooooo freaking awesome to get other cards working with this tech. Car insurance, health insurance, club, grocery store cards/ids. A true digital wallet would be awesome. Would have to get a leather case for my nexus then.
let it be.
@rbiter said:
Linking it to debit would help acceptance a lot I think. And perhaps digital ids but that may be a ways off unless governments step in and push that. But as is, it is probably too easy to hack, fake or manipulate digital ids. But it would be sooooo freaking awesome to get other cards working with this tech. Car insurance, health insurance, club, grocery store cards/ids. A true digital wallet would be awesome. Would have to get a leather case for my nexus then.
let it be.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah ductape case is better LOL jk
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
Like another person said the acceptance of Google wallet isn't the issue it is updating them because I think MasterCard only card that some have built-in got lectured at wall greens that they won't turn it on but what's point in having it displayed anyway next iPhone 5 is supposedly going to have it so demand should increase and public awareness of it should increase I swear one place kept hitting cancel on me on purpose because they thought I was scamming them.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Was able to link my food stamps to it. Been on a spending Bender ever since.
Went straight to the strip club where, surprisingly, they have pay pass. Then off to cigarette depot for some smokes. Bought me a carton, no more loosies for me. After that, got some lotto tickets @ 7-11. Then off to white castle.
I even got enough left on my "IL Link" card that I can sell the rest of the funds to one of my baby mommas for fifty cent on the dolla.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
rboone18 said:
Like another person said the acceptance of Google wallet isn't the issue it is updating them because I think MasterCard only card that some have built-in got lectured at wall greens that they won't turn it on but what's point in having it displayed anyway next iPhone 5 is supposedly going to have it so demand should increase and public awareness of it should increase I swear one place kept hitting cancel on me on purpose because they thought I was scamming them.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's probably another "issue". If iPhone doesn't have it is no good or not cool.
let it be.
Basically companies have to pay for the machines that they use to accept credit cards etc. The only way for this to get HUGE and FAST is for Google to become contracted with certain businesses to provide them with these PayPass scanners, even if they have to produce their own Google Branded versions. This way they have control and can distribute them. Otherwise ATM we are stuck with places that have the PayPass machines. Most companies go cheap and get those ugly looking grey plastic card machines that aren't very advanced, just for the fact they are cheap. Google will have to make the move though, businesses will not pay the dough to switch to these machines.
thos25 said:
After that, got some lotto tickets @ 7-11.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol, I'm up to around 170ish transactions using Wallet at this point, but the one thing I can never buy is Lotto tickets at 7-11. They tell me you can't buy them with a credit card.
I use mine all the time...
McD's, 7-11, CVS and even Whole Foods. There's an app for MC Paypass locations and I've found everywhere that's on the list generally accepts them. I have to agree with it being limited. Google Wallet needs to stop treating this like a hobby and add cards other than Citibank. GW needs to mature a lot before ISIS or even Apple arrives on the scene.
---------- Post added at 04:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:41 PM ----------
krichek said:
Lol, I'm up to around 170ish transactions using Wallet at this point, but the one thing I can never buy is Lotto tickets at 7-11. They tell me you can't buy them with a credit card.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LOL... I've heard the clerks tell people they can't use credit cards. I just ambush them and hit the terminal with my phone and if they ever say anything I can just show them the pic of the GW Prepaid and point at the "DEBIT" in the graphic. After all I can't control how their POS terminal processes it and by the time they notice it's too late.
krichek said:
Lol, I'm up to around 170ish transactions using Wallet at this point, but the one thing I can never buy is Lotto tickets at 7-11. They tell me you can't buy them with a credit card.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
clearly you aren't on food stamps or you would know how to work those angles. Lol.
And, I was being sarcastic about everything I said. just to make sure everyone knows. But you can bet that someone will figure out how to link their food stamps to this. Here in Illinois food stamps are on a debit card called "Illinois link". And like most states, there are people who use them that know how to work the system to get all sorts of crazy stuff.
This morning I was at the gas station behind a guy who used his link to buy candy and soda not just for him but for his buddy too. Wearing 200 Jordans, gold chains, about 250 worth of clothes on, a gold grill, and diamonds in his ears. Talking on an iphone 4 the whole time. Then watched him get into his relatively new Lincoln Navigator with 20+" wheels. Then I had the privilege of following him on my way to work. His stereo booming the two blocks until he pulled into the govt housing authority homes, where I wouldn't be surprised if he lived.
So...I guess that probably contributed to my sarcasm this morning.
At any rate, won't be surprised if food stamps are on Nfc within a year or two.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
thos25 said:
So...I guess that probably contributed to my sarcasm this morning.
At any rate, won't be surprised if food stamps are on Nfc within a year or two.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hate to say it, but that is a way for nfc to get a big push. Otoh, nfc is usually in high end phones, even subsidized ones so the other side of the equation is "dafuq?"
let it be.
Wilsonium said:
Google Wallet needs to stop treating this like a hobby and add cards other than Citibank.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They would love to but if you don't have cooperation, then it can't happen. Too many of those companies are trying to compete with GW so they will not allow it.
thos25 said:
clearly you aren't on food stamps or you would know how to work those angles. Lol.
And, I was being sarcastic about everything I said. just to make sure everyone knows. But you can bet that someone will figure out how to link their food stamps to this. Here in Illinois food stamps are on a debit card called "Illinois link". And like most states, there are people who use them that know how to work the system to get all sorts of crazy stuff.
This morning I was at the gas station behind a guy who used his link to buy candy and soda not just for him but for his buddy too. Wearing 200 Jordans, gold chains, about 250 worth of clothes on, a gold grill, and diamonds in his ears. Talking on an iphone 4 the whole time. Then watched him get into his relatively new Lincoln Navigator with 20+" wheels. Then I had the privilege of following him on my way to work. His stereo booming the two blocks until he pulled into the govt housing authority homes, where I wouldn't be surprised if he lived.
So...I guess that probably contributed to my sarcasm this morning.
At any rate, won't be surprised if food stamps are on Nfc within a year or two.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I work with the side of providing free services to some of those people and the best part is a fair number of them tend to be the most demanding and presumptuous people I've met... just plain rude. Not sure what it is about paying for something that makes you nicer. Maybe we just don't appreciate something as much if its free. This doesn't apply to everyone but I see it often enough that it bugs me. Okay I'm done with my rant haha
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
fatttire said:
I work with the side of providing free services to some of those people and the best part is a fair number of them tend to be the most demanding and presumptuous people I've met... just plain rude. Not sure what it is about paying for something that makes you nicer. Maybe we just don't appreciate something as much if its free. This doesn't apply to everyone but I see it often enough that it bugs me. Okay I'm done with my rant haha
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hear ya. I used to live directly across from govt projects. I would always see aarons and rent a center trucks there dropping off big screen TV's. I even see several 50"+ televisions on the trash curb. Aside from that it wasn't a horrible place to live. if you don't mind loud music, large groups of 50+ people fighting with everything from broom sticks to tire irons, and weekly shootings that is.
But yeah. My sister is a cashier @ Walmart a and says a large portion of the people are rude. I've seen it myself standing in line behind many of them.
And don't get me wrong. A good deal of those people are in legitimate need of assistance. They are grateful for the help and do what they can to become self sufficient as time goes on.
But a significant portion of the people are not deserving, are rude, dishonest, and generally don't deserve anything they get.
and as for the comment about how putting food stamps on these devices would probably drive Google wallet. It probably would. And even though it is only on high end phones, you can bet your bottom dollar that a lot of people on welfare have high end phones.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Recently I saw that apps are now discriminating against root users(not allowing download/play). Do you think if apps would universally start doing this, would it cut down piracy or just push more root users to download illegally?
I for one believe it will have the latter effect, what do you guys think of this?
AT&T SGS3
TEAM BAKED ROM Blackbean 5
Ktoonsez KT747 Kernel
Medical MJ supporter
I think if ppl would just stop acting so self-entitled, and stopped stealing ****, this would not even be an issue... Unfortunately - the world is full of idiots.. Only takes a few to ruin a good thing for all of us.
Dankest said:
Recently I saw that apps are now discriminating against root users(not allowing download/play). Do you think if apps would universally start doing this, would it cut down piracy or just push more root users to download illegally?
I for one believe it will have the latter effect, what do you guys think of this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So what are some example apps that are denying access if your phone is determined to be rooted? I've never run into one, and I can't imagine any popular app would resort to something so easily worked around.
(the workaround: temporarily move/rename the 'su' binary out of the PATH to "hide" it, since that's the method almost all apps would use to detect if you're rooted.)
To install a pirated app is allow unknown sources...anyone can do it, idk why they are discriminating....
Sent from AT&T SGS3
zmore said:
So what are some example apps that are denying access if your phone is determined to be rooted? I've never run into one, and I can't imagine any popular app would resort to something so easily worked around.
(the workaround: temporarily move/rename the 'su' binary out of the PATH to "hide" it, since that's the method almost all apps would use to detect if you're rooted.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Look up chaos rings by a little company called square enix. Looks like they are trying to crack down on app piracy(maybe Cuz of ff3 pirates?).
AT&T SGS3
TEAM BAKED ROM Blackbean 5
Ktoonsez KT747 Kernel
Medical MJ supporter
I could care less about that kind of stuff if companies want to do that then they don't deserve my business or anybody else's business for that matter. Then just watch how fast the companies change their ways when nobody is buying their products
Galaxy SIII via XDA premium
some people cant afford to buy certain apps, like a 99$ navigation map for example. There are many different points of views...
Apple deserter said:
some people cant afford to buy certain apps, like a 99$ navigation map for example. There are many different points of views...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So ppl can afford $400 - $600 (retail) and $200-ish smartphones, $50 - $100 a month contracts... yet they can't afford a $0.99 app.... please... that's total bs.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
G-Man. said:
So ppl can afford $400 - $600 (retail) and $200-ish smartphones, $50 - $100 a month contracts... yet they can't afford a $0.99 app.... please... that's total bs.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well said... I set up my "online" credit card for Google Play at $100. Its been like over an year now, n I still have cash left in it... And not one pirated app on my phone. Most of the apps are like a $ or two... and they are more like 1 time buying with free updates for life (well, many of them).
All it takes is a $ or 2 for an you love... so what's the big deal when you are paying like $100 something each month to the cell phone service provider.
Apple deserter said:
some people cant afford to buy certain apps, like a 99$ navigation map for example. There are many different points of views...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Think about what you just said.
"...stealing is justified because the person who wants to steal feels that they are unwilling to pay the cost for the item...there are many points of view..."
Yeah...and the entitlement mindset "you have something that I feel that I'm entitled to and I don't care if I do something that's wrong...all that matters is that I get it...."...that's a point of view.
I've never understood people who use this rationale....stealing is stealing no matter how you justify it to make yourself feel better while you are doing it.
Apple deserter said:
some people cant afford to buy certain apps, like a 99$ navigation map for example. There are many different points of views...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's the threshold for stealing? If it were only $50 then it wouldn't be ok? $25? If you can't afford a new car you couldn't just go steal one and have it be ok. And everyone knows "You wouldn't download a car."
If I don't want to pay what it's offered for then I just do without. People should look into dropping their entitlement complex.
On another note, I don't buy into the whole "It's not available in my locale" argument. Maybe I just don't fully understand it being in the US. I've seen many ways to fool your phone/the market to seeing a new locale (for free), and most apps I've ever bought have a direct buy version anyway.
Doesn't say anywhere that you have to pay for the apps. Me downloading an apk isn't theft. The original copy is still left intact. Pirates raid ships and steal. They don't make copies.
Sent from the future on my Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 3
bootloopz said:
Doesn't say anywhere that you have to pay for the apps. Me downloading an apk isn't theft. The original copy is still left intact. Pirates raid ships and steal. They don't make copies.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really?
bootloopz said:
Doesn't say anywhere that you have to pay for the apps. Me downloading an apk isn't theft. The original copy is still left intact. Pirates raid ships and steal. They don't make copies.
Sent from the future on my Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the app isn't offered for free by the developer and you obtain a copy without paying then you're stealing. If you want a warm fuzzy because you're stealing something that can be copied then go ahead and tell yourself that. You are still taking money out of the dev's pocket through theft.
Nick D said:
If the app isn't offered for free by the developer and you obtain a copy without paying then you're stealing. If you want a warm fuzzy because you're stealing something that can be copied then go ahead and tell yourself that. You are still taking money out of the dev's pocket through theft.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This argument only stands if you intended to buy the app in the first place and if there weren't so many cases in which piracy increased sales rather than decreased them.
Of course, the opposite is true as well. There are a number of games out there where it was simply more prudent to pirate the game if you wanted to, you know, play it whenever you wanted (Cough, Ubisoft games, cough).
I understand that some people are morally outraged by piracy... but much like so many other things in life, not everyone is. I used to pirate like nobodies business.. but now that I make more money, I typically only pirate the game if I am unsure about it and it doesn't have a demo. If I like it, I go buy it. If not, I get rid of it. I also typically pirate games that have an obscenely restrictive DRM embedded... not because I want to play it but just because screw those guys for putting it in there. DRM increases piracy, not hinders it.
However, copyright infringement is not theft. It is not stealing. Nothing is removed from anywhere. No money is removed from the dev's pockets because it was never there in the first place. If the item couldn't be pirated, that person wouldn't magically have more money because a whole lot of the people that pirate do it because they can't afford it in the first place.
Not to mention, there are companies who don't consider piracy a bad thing: http://www.gamespot.com/news/angry-birds-dev-says-piracy-may-not-be-a-bad-thing-6349485
Not to mention all of these industries who are trying to fight piracy so hard are doing it in the utterly wrong way. People pirate movies? Ok, rather than make movies easy to obtain online and permanently owned just like a dvd copy... they make it abnormally difficult, with higher prices and restrictive licensing and DRM. They make movie ticket prices skyrocket. In short, they make it annoying as all hell to acquire a legitimate digital copy. On the flipside, you can go to google, type in the name of a movie (Say... I dunno, The Avengers), pull up a torrent site, hit download and bam, you now have a digital copy without drm you own.
Music is much the same way, though it is improving. It isn't a whole lot better but I have forsaken pirating music and simply listen to Pandora or Spotify.
TV shows are in the same bracket as movies. It would be so simply to, the night of or the day after showing a new episode, put it up for sale for a dollar or two for people to buy and own. Make it quick, cheap and simple and people will FLOCK to it. But they don't. So everyone just goes and watches Hulu or pirates it.
Games are a more unique sector. They have numerous methods of easily obtaining the games but these methods are getting more restrictive, with licensing and "If you piss us off, you lose everything you bought from us" rules. Origin does this, Steam... yeah, not a very good thing. Why spend all that time worrying about that if you only play single player? Just go pirate it, then nobody can take it from you, right? So we have easy methods of quickly obtaining games, but they keep adding on to their list of rules and restrictions. Steam is the best of the bunch and even they will remove all access to the hundreds to thousands of dollars of games you spent if you break a rule. Even they don't allow anything but arbitration suits. You know the times that most games make the largest amount of sales and profit on Steam? During the Summer Sale and Winter Sale. Dev's love those sales because sales skyrocket to the moon and beyond. Their profit skyrockets for a few weeks. These sales make it obvious what the problem is for a lot of people... money. Is it worth the money? Yeah... less games are these days than ever. Yay, $64.94 after tax for a new game... with 4 hours of gameplay! Awesome, I totally feel that was worth my money! I am definitely going to go buy Gears of War 2 now for another 4 hours of fun!
Is piracy wrong? According to society, yes. Is it even remotely as harmful as the corporations play it out to be? Not hardly.
Forbes:
"This is a negotiation where at any time, your customer could just go download the damn movie for free, and they’re doing you a favor by even considering picking it up legally. And you have the nerve to think it’s on YOUR terms? That’s not how negotiation works. It may not be right, but it’s reality, and they have to face it.
Yet movie companies threaten to put Netflix out of business by charging them huge amounts of money to have access to their content. Netflix is in the forefront of the war on piracy, and the studios don’t even seem to understand it. It’s incredible."
Nick D said:
And everyone knows "You wouldn't download a car."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. Yes I would. If I could, I most certainly would.
Everything in the world should be open source. Open source coding languages are being used to code these apps. For the most part. So why is it right for someone to charge money for something they built using free software? If I were a dev, I'd open up all my code to the community so we can all improve upon it.
Sent from the future on my Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 3
I used to pirate apps...when i was a dumb teenager with little money. Now, i buy ALL my apps, how hard is it to pay 0.99$ for most apps, or even 5$ for the most premium, you not only get regular updates and you also say thank you to the guy that spent time and money to bring you something cool. If people were not so lazy or had higher goals in life than working for a fast food or grocery store, maybe they'd didn't care to pay that little price. The only thing i still pirate is movies, and it's strictly for convenience because here in Canada, our Netflix sucks pretty bad, our video store rent movies for 1/4 of the price of buying it new, and i live a good 30 minutes away from the closest video store. So i have no choice to download if i want to see a movie. But i regularly go to the theaters.
polish_pat said:
I used to pirate apps...when i was a dumb teenager with little money. Now, i buy ALL my apps, how hard is it to pay 0.99$ for most apps, or even 5$ for the most premium, you not only get regular updates and you also say thank you to the guy that spent time and money to bring you something cool. If people were not so lazy or had higher goals in life than working for a fast food or grocery store, maybe they'd didn't care to pay that little price. The only thing i still pirate is movies, and it's strictly for convenience because here in Canada, our Netflix sucks pretty bad, our video store rent movies for 1/4 of the price of buying it new, and i live a good 30 minutes away from the closest video store. So i have no choice to download if i want to see a movie. But i regularly go to the theaters.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You just said pirating is for dumb, broke teenagers. Yet, you pirate movies. You can't have your cake and eat it too. Whether you pirate a 99 cent app, or a $40 bluray, you're still a pirate.
Sent from the future on my Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 3
bootloopz said:
You just said pirating is for dumb, broke teenagers. Yet, you pirate movies. You can't have your cake and eat it too. Whether you pirate a 99 cent app, or a $40 bluray, you're still a pirate.
Sent from the future on my Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe that he is saying that he would buy the movies if it wasn't such an inconvenience where he lives.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1963058
How long till its phones?
Sign it please
Sent from my SGH-T989 on Jelly Bean goodness!
grassyloki said:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1963058
How long till its phones?
Sign it please
Sent from my SGH-T989 on Jelly Bean goodness!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That sucks. It personally doesn't effect me because this is US law and I live in Canada. Regardless, I am not a fan of this law and I am sure MANY people are going to be upset.
Remember that time an online petition changed the world? Man, that was awesome.
Oh wait, that never happened.
What exactly does this have to do with the galaxy s2?
I would read what was said below before going to crazy... some strong points are made
najaboy said:
Jesus H. Christ, this topic is so rooted (no pun intended) in profoundly gross ignorance it's saddening.
1.) Not a single thing pertaining to tablets has changed. Their status under the DMCA remains the same as it was in 2011 and 2010.
2) The proposed DMCA rejection of tablets was rejected not based upon "greater capabilities," but upon the fact that the EFF came with an overly broad and ill-defined definition of tablet.
3) The was no ruling on 28 October. Rather, 28 Oct was the date that the current DMCA exemptions went into effect after being published in the Federal Register on 26 October.
4) In and of itself, rooting a tablet is not illegal. Circumvention of DRM is what's prohibited by the DMCA. What went into effect on 28 Oct are five exemptions to this that will be in effect for the ensuing three years.
5) The Nexus 7 and Nexus 10 ship with unlockable bootloaders and an open source operating system. As such, unlocking and rooting are unactionable under the DMCA. Even though circumventing a locked bootloader on other tablets has always been "actionable," OEMs turn a blind eye to it as that's just the way the Android ecosystem is. Furthermore, the NTIA supported the exemption being extended to tablets, so I don't foresee anyone getting sued for it.
6) Playing fast and loose with terms such as "illegal" makes for great sensationalism, but it also paints this subject entirely out of context. No one has ever gone to jail for rooting a tablet, nor will they. It's entirely a civil matter and the OEMs don't have any incentive to sue anyone for rooting.
7) I have to laugh when I see the fuss about the Copyright Office, as they are not the entity responsible for DMCA exemptions. It is the Librarian of Congress that is tasked with the job. So, as others have said, sending a slacktivist petition to the Copyright Office and bombarding them with misinformed tweets really isn't going to do much good other than get you considered as a whack job.
8) For that matter, whining to the LoC isn't going to do any good, either. This is a process that is governed by statute and the LoC has to act within the scope of that. If you don't like the way things turned out this year, DMCA exemptions will be up for review again in 2015. I'd suggest you attend one of the many public hearings that lead up to the decision making. It's a rather open and transparent process with numerous public hearings and openings for comments in the 12 months preceding the final publishing of exemptions. Hopefully by then, we'll be able to give them a definition of tablet that also doesn't encompass PSPs, e-readers, and laptops
Finally, I would leave you with this bit of sage advice... please, please, please... educate yourself about a topic before having a knee-jerk "the sky is falling" reaction to that topic. I'll reiterate the simple fact that nothing at all has changed as it pertains to anything anyone does here. Things are today just as they were on 27 October 2012 or 2011.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
VoiD_Dweller said:
What exactly does this have to do with the galaxy s2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It starts with tablets then one day it will transition into phones
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
I'll continue to use my hardware however I want to, illegal or not.
Joe USer said:
I'll continue to use my hardware however I want to, illegal or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 I shelled out the cash for my phone, I'll use my phone or tablet any way I please!!
What are the penalties for having a rooted tablet? I seriously doubt the tablet police will come knocking at your door demanding to see your asus transformer tab or whatever
Sent from your mom's house
Haha that would be funny if they did
Chochiwpg said:
That sucks. It personally doesn't effect me because this is US law and I live in Canada. Regardless, I am not a fan of this law and I am sure MANY people are going to be upset.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Feels good to live in Canada right now.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
DigitaL BlisS said:
Feels good to live in Canada right now.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where you living Digital?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
Chochiwpg said:
Where you living Digital?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ottawa, you?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
DigitaL BlisS said:
Ottawa, you?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Winnipeg
the police state is out of hand.
Today at a stop sign an old man was stalled at the 4 way stop, a very popular intersection. Everyone was stopping to ask the old man if he needed help. He said no and was on his cell phone.
Down the road cops were stopping people, I didn't think much of it.
Came back to the intersection hours later and realized the same old man was on his cell phone.
He was an undercover cop or snitch telling the cops who didn't have a damn seat belt on and they were handing out $170 tickets.
Holysmoke99 said:
the police state is out of hand.
Today at a stop sign an old man was stalled at the 4 way stop, a very popular intersection. Everyone was stopping to ask the old man if he needed help. He said no and was on his cell phone.
Down the road cops were stopping people, I didn't think much of it.
Came back to the intersection hours later and realized the same old man was on his cell phone.
He was an undercover cop or snitch telling the cops who didn't have a damn seat belt on and they were handing out $170 tickets.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah ha lol good one
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
rymanh said:
What are the penalties for having a rooted tablet? I seriously doubt the tablet police will come knocking at your door demanding to see your asus transformer tab or whatever
Sent from your mom's house
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
^ This. Except I'm not at your mom's house.
This would be about as enforceable as pirating media. Not that I would ever do that.
Well that sucks but it is a little confusing since didn't like a year or so ago a judge determine that jailbreaking an iPhone what is not illegal. So then its only illegal if it's a tablet. Not that it matters because I will continue rooting my devices and using it how I want
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
Joe USer said:
I'll continue to use my hardware however I want to, illegal or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I paid monry for my tablet. I will root it in another country if I must. In case rooting does get banned, it is likely only the act of rooting, not using a rooted device, that will be illegal. So root it in another country, and you will be fully fine.
Now dish network wants to buy sprint ....
http://money.cnn.com/m/#!/2013/04/15/technology/dish-sprint-bid.json?category=Latest News
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
Epix4G said:
Now dish network wants to buy sprint ....
http://money.cnn.com/m/#!/2013/04/15/technology/dish-sprint-bid.json?category=Latest News
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Beat me to it. This is VERY intriguing. At this point, I'm stuck with Sprint for a couple more years at least, most likely. Any sort of "cash infusion" is welcomed.
In the end, the only major player in my small city is Verizon, I may be jumping ship so I don't have to deal with crappy 3G speeds where 4G can be had. =\
And now Verizon looks like it's going after the Clearwire spectrum:
http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/15/4...re-1-5-billion-to-lease-its-spectrum-says-wsj
PsycloneTW said:
And now Verizon looks like it's going after the Clearwire spectrum:
http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/15/4...re-1-5-billion-to-lease-its-spectrum-says-wsj
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That move doesn't quite compute for me. Doesn't Sprint essentially control ClearWire? I suppose if Sprint needs cash more than it needs spectrum (which if probably the case), then it makes more sense.
MeetFace said:
That move doesn't quite compute for me. Doesn't Sprint essentially control ClearWire? I suppose if Sprint needs cash more than it needs spectrum (which if probably the case), then it makes more sense.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sprint does Control Clear. At least that what I have read
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda app-developers app
Sprint owns clear but they are still run independently of each other. ..2 separate companies .... similar to how Samsung can compete against Apple being sued by Apple and will still sell parts to Apple
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
Epix4G said:
Sprint owns clear but they are still run independently of each other. ..2 separate companies .... similar to how Samsung can compete against Apple being sued by Apple and will still sell parts to Apple
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree, mostly. Except that Samsung isn't selling away their most important asset to Apple, the tech and research behind the screens.
As I understand it, ClearWire only has one thing that people want, and that is the spectrum itself. Unless Sprint can never use the spectrum Verizon wants, this move still confuses me.
Does anybody in here know about how this affects stocks? It went up almost $1 today!!!! So I was reading and did some research and this article says that it will disappear after a couple days and to sell , I dont understand how all that works anyone w some insight id greatly appreciate it.
Inside the Lab , bout to take over the "World"
BigRitz said:
Does anybody in here know about how this affects stocks? It went up almost $1 today!!!! So I was reading and did some research and this article says that it will disappear after a couple days and to sell , I dont understand how all that works anyone w some insight id greatly appreciate it.
Inside the Lab , bout to take over the "World"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Big, there is no magic formula for how stocks go up and down. I mean, at one time or another, there are methods to follow, but once everyone catches on...typically it stops working. That's not to say that in situations like this, with announcements like this, that the sudden excitement doesn't drive prices up only to come back down shortly thereafter. It happens, and happens often.
But, who's to say in this instance that prices don't hold and potentially go up even further?
For all intensive purposes, the stock market is a zero-sum game (debatable). When I lose, someone else has won.
All in all, I stay away from the stock market. Not because it's inherently bad, but because I haven't spent enough time researching it and getting to know the ins and outs.
MeetFace said:
For all intensive purposes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
intents and purposes. 3 words there even though when most people say it it comes out sounding like 2.
austin420 said:
intents and purposes. 3 words there even though when most people say it it comes out sounding like 2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for this. I can't believe I've been saying this wrong for so long. Myself being a person who takes pride in proper grammar etiquette had to look it up to make sure you were correct. Alas, you are 100% right, and I've probably sounded like an ass at more than a few interviews lol.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk 2
BigRitz said:
Does anybody in here know about how this affects stocks? It went up almost $1 today!!!! So I was reading and did some research and this article says that it will disappear after a couple days and to sell , I dont understand how all that works anyone w some insight id greatly appreciate it.
Inside the Lab , bout to take over the "World"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course it would go up: the prospect that now 2 companies are looking forward to buy CW (one of them at a higher price) makes CW stock a bit more attractive thus pushing people to buy shares, as the amount of shares available go down their price goes up and now whoever owns CW shares is making an extra dollar per share if they decide to sell.
its sprint
fenixjn said:
Of course it would go up: the prospect that now 2 companies are looking forward to buy CW (one of them at a higher price) makes CW stock a bit more attractive thus pushing people to buy shares, as the amount of shares available go down their price goes up and now whoever owns CW shares is making an extra dollar per share if they decide to sell.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
its not clear wire that they want to buy .....dish is trying to buy sprint and verizon wants to lease the clear spectrum . dish offered 25.5 billion for sprint and verizon offered 1.5 billion to lease the spectrum ...vzw is not trying to buy clear that deal is already done with sprint and clear ..
I have no doubt that Dish will win this war - http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...perior-to-softbank-s-investor-omega-says.html
A great read what dish is about & how Ergen has reached this point - http://finance.yahoo.com/news/dish-network-meanest-company-america-194008712.html?page=all
DISH PCS
sling said:
I have no doubt that Dish will win this war - http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...perior-to-softbank-s-investor-omega-says.html
A great read what dish is about & how Ergen has reached this point - http://finance.yahoo.com/news/dish-network-meanest-company-america-194008712.html?page=all
DISH PCS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really hope not. Dish IMHO is the bargain basement satellite. Many complaints of non existent customer service. Would be the beginning of the end for Sprint as this approach seems have been tried by Sprint and failed horribly.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk 2
if dish buys sprint, ill walk.
Offering more cash, keeping it in US, "synergy" with TV offerings... all fine and good sounding as statements I've read around the web for "pro" DiSH (I would actually contest the positive aspects of the TV network/wireless network synergy...)
The fact is, Softbank has Many orders of magnitude in assets overall to continue to support and invest in the network. And the motivation to do it, as a well established tech-forward company. ($4 trillion vs $11 billion...)
As where DiSHs motivations in the wireless business are akin to Comcasts in the ISP business. Not to provide you an excellent data service, but to sell you the bundles, the programing, the advertising, where their true money is made. Bad for the consumer.
I for one, welcome our new Eastern overlords.
I am a customer of both Sprint and Dish already. I guess that wouldn't hurt to combine the two. For me anyway... Though this is clearly a response to comcast teaming with Vzw.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda app-developers app
Seems like a win win either way.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda app-developers app
This
sent from my ginormous Note II