Hello everybody,
This will be a long post but I will try to make it as short as possible.
I pay a great deal of attention to the scroll fluidity and smoothness. It is a vital factor for me in a android device.
Attracted by the hardware specs I fell in the trap with the S6 and the Note4. Even after rooting, custom rom and everything. It just wouldn't be fluid.
Now to be clear: I need to specify my definition of fluid.
Fluid and reactive scrolling for me is when you feel that you are almost moving a physical piece of paper behind a glass. It follows your finger seamlessly and has a physically coherent inertia.
This type of scolling is not a dream. Try for instance a brand new nexus, or better . . . . . the LG G5 ? With the governor set to (surprisingly) conservative. The scrolling is smooth like CRAZY. (Even way better than iPhone, no jokes)
Now I have the Note 7 for 14 days. If I like it I keep it, if I don't I'll send it back.
I really wanted to try the note 7 by myself.
I am incredibly surprised that there is almost ZERO stutter! Wow!
BUT because yeah there is a but: The scrolling is weird! Not natural at all. Sometimes it decelerates and re-accelerates. Doesn't always follow the touch. Bad inertia. It's just overall a good but very weird and uncomfortable experience.
I noticed that this is not always the case OO
I indeed noticed that this might be dure to some kind of process from samsung that seem to take over the scrolling.
Or it could also be simply drop frames. . . . but that would be weird since the scrolling is . . . . . smooth besides being not reactive.
So I ran GPU profiling. And indeed we're way off the charts!
Note 7:
For comparaison, LG G5:
However, as mentioned earlier, it doesn't happen all the time.
So I created a very basic app that only displays a list of images from the web to isolate the normal behavior of the Note 7: The Scrolling is so smooth, no weird behavior, no weird acceleration, nothing.
But sometimes this "process" would activate and throw the render time off the charts, and the scrolling would be weird again !!!!
I have a couple of video that showcase the difference.
Note 7: Smooth scrolling - Demo App
As mentionned some times the "process" would activate and screw with the scrolling inertia. (And cause drop frames at the same time).
Note 7: Weird behavior - Demo App
In all other apps, except my Demo App and rare exceptions, the scrolling is in weird mode.
Note 7: 9Gag for example:
For comparaison, this is 9Gag on the G5
I think rooting + custom kernel could fix the issue. Potentially with a different governor. But I cannot root my phone . . . . since I might send it back if I hear experiences that rooting doesn't help.
So my question is:
If you are a user with the same feeling about scrolling on the Note 7.
Could you please tell me if rooting + custom rom / kernel / governor helped solve it ?
Or is it still . . . . weird, and off the chart in GPU profiling ?
Rooted users, could you post pictures of GPU profiling when scrolling in FB, or any long list ?
That would help a LOT. And let me know if I want to keep the Note 7.
I currently have the G5, I love it. But I'm lurking towards the amazing screen, stylus, and gear VR of the Note 7.
Plus ironically . . . . the browsing experience on the note is just . . . incredible OO
Info: I am on the Exynos / European Version
Note: Please do not answer this post to simply tell me that this is an insignificant detail, that Touchwiz brings a lot more feature over stock android etc. . . . Yes sure, whatever. It doesn't matter, this is not the point here. Please comment only if you want to help, or discuss in a constructive way. Thank you
Shock_N745 said:
Hello everybody,
This will be a long post but I will try to make it as short as possible.
I pay a great deal of attention to the scroll fluidity and smoothness. It is a vital factor for me in a android device.
Attracted by the hardware specs I fell in the trap with the S6 and the Note4. Even after rooting, custom rom and everything. It just wouldn't be fluid.
Now to be clear: I need to specify my definition of fluid.
Fluid and reactive scrolling for me is when you feel that you are almost moving a physical piece of paper behind a glass. It follows your finger seamlessly and has a physically coherent inertia.
This type of scolling is not a dream. Try for instance a brand new nexus, or better . . . . . the LG G5 ? With the governor set to (surprisingly) conservative. The scrolling is smooth like CRAZY. (Even way better than iPhone, no jokes)
Now I have the Note 7 for 14 days. If I like it I keep it, if I don't I'll send it back.
I really wanted to try the note 7 by myself.
I am incredibly surprised that there is almost ZERO stutter! Wow!
BUT because yeah there is a but: The scrolling is weird! Not natural at all. Sometimes it decelerates and re-accelerates. Doesn't always follow the touch. Bad inertia. It's just overall a good but very weird and uncomfortable experience.
I noticed that this is not always the case OO
I indeed noticed that this might be dure to some kind of process from samsung that seem to take over the scrolling.
Or it could also be simply drop frames. . . . but that would be weird since the scrolling is . . . . . smooth besides being not reactive.
So I ran GPU profiling. And indeed we're way off the charts!
Note 7:
For comparaison, LG G5:
However, as mentioned earlier, it doesn't happen all the time.
So I created a very basic app that only displays a list of images from the web to isolate the normal behavior of the Note 7: The Scrolling is so smooth, no weird behavior, no weird acceleration, nothing.
But sometimes this "process" would activate and throw the render time off the charts, and the scrolling would be weird again !!!!
I have a couple of video that showcase the difference.
Note 7: Smooth scrolling - Demo App
As mentionned some times the "process" would activate and screw with the scrolling inertia. (And cause drop frames at the same time).
Note 7: Weird behavior - Demo App
In all other apps, except my Demo App and rare exceptions, the scrolling is in weird mode.
Note 7: 9Gag for example:
For comparaison, this is 9Gag on the G5
I think rooting + custom kernel could fix the issue. Potentially with a different governor. But I cannot root my phone . . . . since I might send it back if I hear experiences that rooting doesn't help.
So my question is:
If you are a user with the same feeling about scrolling on the Note 7.
Could you please tell me if rooting + custom rom / kernel / governor helped solve it ?
Or is it still . . . . weird, and off the chart in GPU profiling ?
Rooted users, could you post pictures of GPU profiling when scrolling in FB, or any long list ?
That would help a LOT. And let me know if I want to keep the Note 7.
I currently have the G5, I love it. But I'm lurking towards the amazing screen, stylus, and gear VR of the Note 7.
Plus ironically . . . . the browsing experience on the note is just . . . incredible OO
Info: I am on the Exynos / European Version
Note: Please do not answer this post to simply tell me that this is an insignificant detail, that Touchwiz brings a lot more feature over stock android etc. . . . Yes sure, whatever. It doesn't matter, this is not the point here. Please comment only if you want to help, or discuss in a constructive way. Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Custom Rom developers often put different scrolling methods in their Roms and have the option to choose which one you like. The scrolling on the N7 reminds me of this, it's seems to me they've decreased the "friction" of the scroll. I'm pleasantly surprised that the N7 has virtually no stutter, but yes I have noticed a difference in the friction of the scroll.
Haha for real you quoted my whole post ? ^_^
Could you edit, for readibility ? Thx
B3501 said:
Custom Rom developers often put different scrolling methods in their Roms and have the option to choose which one you like. The scrolling on the N7 reminds me of this, it's seems to me they've decreased the "friction" of the scroll. I'm pleasantly surprised that the N7 has virtually no stutter, but yes I have noticed a difference in the friction of the scroll.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh Thanks for the info :good: I didn't know that. Very interesting indeed.
Any idea why this spike in the orange bar ?? (too much work on GPU, according to the tool)
Shock_N745 said:
Haha for real you quoted my whole post ? ^_^
Could you edit, for readibility ? Thx
Oh Thanks for the info :good: I didn't know that. Very interesting indeed.
Any idea why this spike in the orange bar ?? (too much work on GPU, according to the tool)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea. I'm sure Samsung are trying to eliminate lag and stutter by doing something at a kernel level.
B3501 said:
No idea. I'm sure Samsung are trying to eliminate lag and stutter by doing something at a kernel level.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you by any chance have a custom Kernel on your device ? (if you have a note 7)
If yes could you check if this "tweak" is still there ?
Shock_N745 said:
Do you by any chance have a custom Kernel on your device ? (if you have a note 7)
If yes could you check if this "tweak" is still there ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, full stock.
Update:
I decided fu** my withdrawal rights. I'm going to try and root it and sell it on eBay if I don't like the result . . . . . .
AND . . . . . . it solved it Thank you sooooo much HydraKernel / HydraRom.
The GPU profiling is still off the charts when the weird "process" activates" . . . . but processor use overall in incredibly low compared to stock. Wow. And most important, eventhough weird result in profiling are still here. Scrolling is finally buttery smooth :
So I can 100% recommend HydraKernel / HydraRom.
I'm still figuring out how to get the secret mode on the browser though if anybody has an idea (as well as web-sign in): Both using iris would be awesome.
Related
I have a live wallpaper on, but it still shouldnt be that laggy. My sensation could handle a lot that was thrown at it without being all that laggy. Even with live wallpaper off it's a little laggy. Keyboard in landscape mode? Laggy. Swipe from one home screen to another? Laggy.
Any fix for this!? I just can't wait until CM9 now to fix all this stuff!
I don't know man. I came from a Sensation (running CyanogenMod 7) and the Nexus blows it out of the water in terms of speed and smoothness...and the Sensation was pretty ****in' fast running stock Android.
Well I still think my Nexus is better. I love it to death! But the sudden lag kind of kills it. I don't know what the deal is either.
I read some of the live wallpapers are laggy but not all of them
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Hi monkey hung
I too noticed some laggyness to begin with the Live Wallpaper turned on. Sounds like your last phone was an iPhone 4?
I've been playing around with settings and have a few concepts on what might be going on:
1. First of all, under: Settings > Developer Options, there is a setting called "force GPU rendering". I haven't tried this with the Live Wallpaper on yet, but perhaps this might help the 2D UI laggyness? Let me know what you find.
2. Disable your Live Wallpaper, I did, it saved battery life and things are much snappier.
3. Close your unused apps. I know ICS is meant to deal with old apps much better now, however, I find my Galaxy Nexus to be snappier when I close down the 30 odd applications I have left in a suspended state. It doesn't take long to swipe them off from the home screen using the right "Application" touch button down the right hand corner of the screen.
4. I've noticed that dragging my finger along the screen does not give the same smooth/matte feeling of the iPhone 4. As a matter of fact, it almost jitters/vibrates across the contour glass. If I touch with a less contact force, I tend to find the performance of touch screen to be smooth, rather when I apply more force it tends to jump across the surface of the screen creating a jagged touch slide. I've also noticed the higher sensitivity of the accelerometer. If you have a very steady hand you can see the extra performance, if you hand is un-steady, it almost looks worse than the previous phone, but in reality, it was simply my inability to hold the device in one spot that gave the poor performance, really this a reflection on how responsive the phone is to my dodgy movements.
Thanks but I had HTC Sensation with CM7. I think you must have mistaken when I made topic about my girl friend having an iPhone 4 haha
berglh said:
1. First of all, under: Settings > Developer Options, there is a setting called "force GPU rendering". I haven't tried this with the Live Wallpaper on yet, but perhaps this might help the 2D UI laggyness? Let me know what you find.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
please don't go around suggesting people to do this. They are developer options for a reason.
Force GPU Rendering is only likely to introduce bugs as some apps don't handle it well. Wait for the developers themselves to enable GPU rendering. In addition, GPU rendering adds extra memory overhead to the app (8MB vs 2MB).
By suggesting this, you only end up with people who post back at the forum complaining that App X or App Y no longer works.
berglh said:
Close your unused apps. I know ICS is meant to deal with old apps much better now, however, I find my Galaxy Nexus to be snappier when I close down the 30 odd applications I have left in a suspended state. It doesn't take long to swipe them off from the home screen using the right "Application" touch button down the right hand corner of the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This doesn't "close" anything. It just removed the application from your app switching list. FYI.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
I agree!
Im running an Unlocked version on tmobile. Its very laggy. It takes 2 seconds for screen to rotate to landscape and back, and overall its just slow. Even the data keeps fading from hspa to 3g Im beginning to fall in love with its for its beauty but performance wise my galaxy s2 was way faster and smoother. Is an update going to address this? Any input would be appreciated.
davidbart said:
Im running an Unlocked version on tmobile. Its very laggy. It takes 2 seconds for screen to rotate to landscape and back, and overall its just slow. Even the data keeps fading from hspa to 3g Im beginning to fall in love with its for its beauty but performance wise my galaxy s2 was way faster and smoother. Is an update going to address this? Any input would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The rotation delay is intentional.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
I'm experiencing the same thing you are but the delay is intentional. If my screen was rotating all the time I would get really annoyed!
Also, the switching between 3G and 4G is intentional. 3G uses less battery... it kicks over to 4G when you're actually using the data connection.
My galaxy nexus is almost perfectly responsive. It lags on occasion, but I find it to be much smoother and more responsive overall than just about any other android device I've used. (including the galaxy S II)
davidbart said:
Im running an Unlocked version on tmobile. Its very laggy. It takes 2 seconds for screen to rotate to landscape and back, and overall its just slow. Even the data keeps fading from hspa to 3g Im beginning to fall in love with its for its beauty but performance wise my galaxy s2 was way faster and smoother. Is an update going to address this? Any input would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your phone is laggy, then it's probably something on it you're running that isn't optimized for ICS. My phone runs just fine and easily outclasses any other phone I've used (and I've used pretty much every high end gsm phone that has come out here in the states). FYI your data isn't "fading from hspa to 3g", the phone idles on UMTS and when it's transmitting data it goes to hspa. This is very normal. Do a search on it if you want to know more.
kwazi said:
please don't go around suggesting people to do this. They are developer options for a reason.
Force GPU Rendering is only likely to introduce bugs as some apps don't handle it well. Wait for the developers themselves to enable GPU rendering. In addition, GPU rendering adds extra memory overhead to the app (8MB vs 2MB).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, we are really going to miss that 6 MB with the 1 GB available to the GN. My last phone was an Xperia X10 with only 384 MB of RAM, yes it was chuggy, but comparatively this amount of allocation is small and the feature seems to work well thsu far. I hardly think they are going to miss it, but your point on the Development Settings is valid to a certain degree.
kwazi said:
By suggesting this, you only end up with people who post back at the forum complaining that App X or App Y no longer works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would rebut this by saying that most of my paid apps either don't work at all or don't work correctly due to the fact I'm running Ice Cream Sandwich prior to turning this option on on my own phone. There are many other reasons that apps are going to fail, particularly on Android. In retrospect, a disclaimer to this effect might have been appropriate considering the ramifications of the advice, and I direct this at hung monkey:
If you are not smart enough to draw the correlation between enabling the 2D acceleration and most of your apps suddenly not working, then you should probably not turn it on.
I have turned it on, it fixed the laggyness of the default Live Wallpaper, I haven't tested how much it saps the battery yet. Turning it on has only resulted in an improvement to my phone thus far.
davidbart said:
Im running an Unlocked version on tmobile. Its very laggy. It takes 2 seconds for screen to rotate to landscape and back, and overall its just slow. Even the data keeps fading from hspa to 3g Im beginning to fall in love with its for its beauty but performance wise my galaxy s2 was way faster and smoother. Is an update going to address this? Any input would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I read about your "laggy" screen rotate. That is intended so it doesn't accidentally change orientations.
matt2053 said:
This doesn't "close" anything. It just removed the application from your app switching list. FYI.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't be so sure that it doesn't. For example, if I load a relatively heavy game in to memory, such as Pocket Legends or NFS Shift, and I multitask, the app is suspended. I can use the app selection menu to resume that app, and quite quickly I might ad, much faster than the time it takes for the game to load in memory.
If I then kill it with the Task Switcher, it then has to load from the start, like the suspended session was terminated when I removed it from this list. Even Google themselves said that if you like to manage your apps, then this is how you can end them, but ICS will do a good job of managing it for you anyway, the controls are there if you want them.
This behavior does not match your allegation, would you please care to shed some light?
Cheers!
I concur with the Op - the phone by comparison with my Samsung Galaxy S2, it does seem a bit laggy when scrolling between screens - I have everything setup exactly the same way as on the SGS2.
I'm not technical but I can only hope that these reasons of laggyness come down to the apps,etc. haven't been optimised for ICS yet?
When scrolling up and down the twitter, facebook or google reader apps, it just isnt as smooth as the Galaxy S2 or even the Galaxy S1.
Otherwise, very beautiful UI.
Live wallpapers need to die a horrible death. Worst Android feature ever.
To the OP, use a normal wallpaper instead and you'll see an improvement in the overall speed of the UI.
case0 said:
Live wallpapers need to die a horrible death. Worst Android feature ever.
To the OP, use a normal wallpaper instead and you'll see an improvement in the overall speed of the UI.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree! This phone lags really bad with all the live wallpapers except for the Phase Beam one. TURN THEM OFF and its by far the smoothest phone.....lol
I use wp clock and havent noticed any lag versus having it off....
Hi everyone,
I have my GSM Galaxy Nexus for nearly 2 months, and I'm really pleased with this phone, which replace my old yet good Galaxy S. The device is snappy, smooth, I can play every games and watch nearly every movie files I want etc, perfect for me, especially with its huge wide screen.
That said, I always try to find a little thing to reproach to my phone. Not so easy, but even so, I find something which can be a bit annoying.
We all use our launcher a lot, obviously, it is like the core/bridge app of our Android device. I noticed that the 4.0 launcher has some performances problems, let me explain you how to easily reproduce them (close all your apps in order to have the best performance as possible) :
-The transition between the app-drawer and the desktop panels can be not so smooth as it should with such a powerful device. Try to go in and out the app-drawer, you will notice that sometimes it lag, sometimes not. I asked myself why it behave like that, and I may have found the problem. When you enter in the app-drawer or when you flip your panels on the desktop or in the app-drawer, you surely have notice this little blue bar at the bottom at the screen, which indicate you where you are. If you try to go in/out the app-drawer while this bar is on the screen, the transition will be laggy. Just wait it disappear, and it will be smooth (if not, do it 2-3 more time, and it should be good).
-When you clicked on a widget in the app-drawer, a message will pop out about how to add it to your homescreen blablabla. It also notice that if you try to flip your panel in the appdrawer or the desktop while the message is on the screen, everything will be laggy, especially in the app-drawer, it will have horrible performance, but as soon as this message disappear, everything become smooth like before.
Why ? It don't know. At first, I thought the problem comes from the launcher, but maybe not. Indeed, if messages like the one I talked about above appear anywhere while you're using your device, like in the Web Browser for example, it will lag, maybe less than in the launcher, but it will.
So what ? Maybe the launcher is not fully hardware accelerated, or it lack optimizations ? It may be the case, but I try to run CM9 on my old Galaxy S, and it doesn't have such problems (the performance will depend on the old hardware itself), it is also the same on a friend's Galaxy SII, its launcher is butter-smooth even if you do want I explain.
Is the OMAP4460 or the PowerVR SGX540 too bad to run it correctly ? I doubt it is the case, since my 2 years old Galaxy S run it good. Indeed, even if I overclocked my device to 1400MHz with the "performance" governor, only the 1st case problem will be partially solved, the 2nd one will still make your device run like crap.
Since those lags can appear everywhere if above conditions are met, the problem may be that our phone can't run correctly if there are 2 "layers" on the screen, the message on foreground and your launcher on background for example. It is probably the case, and even if I study IT, I can't explain it really well, sorry
I obviously try a lot of ROMS : Stock 4.0.2/3/4, AOKP, CM9, ARHD, with stock and custom kernels, and they all have the same problem. If you want to have better performance, try to put the minimal CPU frequence to 700MHz, you will maybe lose 30 minutes of battery, but it is globally more usable if you want my opinion.
Do you experiment the same problems ? Have you any ideas about how to solve them ? Thanks to read me !
PS : The Galaxy Nexus also has performances problems if you are using it in landscape position. Everything will be less smooth and snappy. The best example is if you use the app-drawer, it back absolutely unusable.
Since upgrading to nova launcher prime my UI is very fluid. Landscape is still choppy but less so.
bow chicka wow wow.
I forgot to say that I also tried Nova and Apex, it has the same problems
i wannna confirm this that am i the only one who is experiencing lag on sgn2 .
my friend bought it last week but his phone is buttery smooth..
ps: i have no applications installed and power saving mode if off.
please help
does this lag exist on some pieces og sgn2.
i mean there are some that lag and some are butter smooth.
My note 2 is the fastest note in the world....
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda premium
When does it lag? I mean, lag occurs when you do what ? Mine is also lagging bit when im scrolling trough call logs, and some other occasions..
Tell us when is your note lagging?
icsakhil said:
i wannna confirm this that am i the only one who is experiencing lag on sgn2 .
my friend bought it last week but his phone is buttery smooth..
ps: i have no applications installed and power saving mode if off.
please help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Base from my experience of Rooting and installing custom roms on my SGS2 and SGN2 these lags are ROM dependent. My stock Note2 had lag before and when you pressed the home buttom it takes about half a second for the screen to go to home. After installing a custom ROM this lag was gone. This was also the same for my Galaxy S2 phone before. Try searching for custom roms that tweak the performance of the phone. Hope this helps.
same is the case with me..
i have read somewhere on xda that this lag is permanent. i mean there are users who have flashed a custom stock rom then also they are experiencing lags.
games like subway surfers MC4 are also a bit laggy. :crying:
If you're specifically referring to the home button lag. Its because of S Voice. You can go into S Voice > Settings and disable the 'Double Tap Home Button to Launch' shortcut. After that it should respond quicker.
I believe it happens because the phone waits after you press the home button once, in case you intended to launch S Voice with a second press. Then when it senses no second press, it goes to the homescreen.
ap27 said:
If you're specifically referring to the home button lag. Its because of S Voice. You can go into S Voice > Settings and disable the 'Double Tap Home Button to Launch' shortcut. After that it should respond quicker.
I believe it happens because the phone waits after you press the home button once, in case you intended to launch S Voice with a second press. Then when it senses no second press, it goes to the homescreen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no not the home button lag. I am reffering to call menu lag and a bit laggy games likes MC4 DARK KNIGHT RISES etc
Seldom lags with power saving mode off
Mine rarely lags with power saving on. Don't know what the fuss is about.
Sent from my GT-N7100
Well even my iPhone lags. So no question my Note 2 does. When? On lots of occasions, scrolling through call logs, scrolling through contacts, and I am not going to mention how many apps are there in my phone which lags, just two for example, Score Mobile, Facebook etc.
@OP: Absolutely nothing to worry about. If you see some reply like 'what the hell, mine doesn't lag at all', just ignore them as they are rubbish and blind fanboyism
Sent from my GT-N7100
jujuburi said:
Well even my iPhone lags. So no question my Note 2 does. When? On lots of occasions, scrolling through call logs, scrolling through contacts, and I am not going to mention how many apps are there in my phone which lags, just two for example, Score Mobile, Facebook etc.
@OP: Absolutely nothing to worry about. If you see some reply like 'what the hell, mine doesn't lag at all', just ignore them as they are rubbish and blind fanboyism
Sent from my GT-N7100
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Orly? What most define as lag and what is truly lag are two different things. The internal emmc is the bottle neck in these fine pieces of technology. There are many cases where the storage cannot populate the ram fast enough so to the uninformed that is considered lag. And in reality that is not the case. Same applies to desktops and laptops. If it is not in the ram, or cached, chances are you will have to wait. Even the iPhone hangs a lot in these cases and apple optimizes their animations to make illusion it is not lagging. I swear some people's expectations are so unreal they will never be met. Hopefully Samsung is going to utilize ssd controller tech in their flagship phones that are coming up. Usb3 is definitely supported on A15 chip sets and rumor is Samsung might squeeze some form of sata in there. Even sata 1 should give us about 70MB/S throughput which would be a very welcome boost for usability. Sata 2 would give about 250MB/S throughput but I just don't see that happening yet.
Anyways, my expectations are realistic and yes I do notice the occasional hang here and there but in reality it is not lag. It is just the bottleneck of whatever,sometimes data coming over wifi or cwllular, waiting to populate the ram/cache so the CPU can utilize it.
Sent from my GT-N7100
android overall view "lags" as the erxperts r still working on it...well ive hav games and apps loaded on my note 2 an ive not exp the lag tht i usd to face in my s2...but i think note 2 is better than my s1,s2 in terms of lags
rocky23 said:
android overall view "lags" as the erxperts r still working on it...well ive hav games and apps loaded on my note 2 an ive not exp the lag tht i usd to face in my s2...but i think note 2 is better than my s1,s2 in terms of lags
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the fps of games is lower than sgs3
So i have a top of the line tablet with octacore, 3gb of ram and the latest KitKat 4.4.2, I don't use energy saving either. And no matter what browser I use the experience is never satisfactory.
Chrome is pretty good but it has 0 functionality. We use our fingers not a mouse! And still laggy in certain situations (same goes for Samsung stock browser).
UC browser HD is very good too in terms of scrolling, but when you're typing text is lagging behind and switching and creating tabs stutters horribly.
And Firefox, the mother of lag. When you scroll down a page really fast it takes the browser up to 5 seconds to render the damn page! While you are already looking at it. Try it out for yourself, you scroll then you only get a gray page, then everything plops in very blurry and then after another few seconds stuff gets rendered and is finally sharp.
I know that every browser has this issue to some extent. But most render much faster than firefox so it doesn't appear as an issue. Anyway can't android keep a Web page in memory completely? I have 3gb of it!
Or maybe I'm doing it wrong or you guys can suggest me a different browser with good usability and smoothness? Thx in advance
Unfortunately it's not smooth and it seems that it will never be. Only next browser seems to be little better from others.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk
Maybe you should try Dolphin Browser, imo its quite smooth and not laggy...
Gesendet von meinem SM-P600 mit Tapatalk
I use Opera ,,very fast and smooth..
Sent from my SM-P600 using XDA Premium HD app
Boat Browser and Habit Browser both are smooth and offer a lot if functionality.
Sent from my SM-P600
Thing is, some sites are "busy" and others are not.
Sent via my Note 8
Freakstyler said:
Boat Browser and Habit Browser both are smooth and offer a lot if functionality.
Sent from my SM-P600
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then maybe we just have different perceptions boat browser is not smooth at all on my tablet... Maybe I have to do a video or something because boat browser is one of the most laggy browsers I've tried :/ not as bad as firefox but pretty annoying.
nearly all browsers are laggy, there is so much ad crap loaded these days.
Once the page has loaded mine is smooth, so depends on you internet speed I guess.
My Ipad is the same.
Many ram doesn't mean will smooth. Because it use power of GPU and app can be use it and resoluiton.
Opera i see very smooth. Chrome and fire fox lag like hell.
clouds5 said:
Then maybe we just have different perceptions boat browser is not smooth at all on my tablet... Maybe I have to do a video or something because boat browser is one of the most laggy browsers I've tried :/ not as bad as firefox but pretty annoying.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We must... I've tried just about every browser on my P600.... Boat is about as fast as they come... ( I have recently started to use Habit a little more due to lower CPU use, and a few nice features).
Boat both Tablet and Phone versions have been used daily for 6months, it simply doesn't lag... I can pinch to zoom, pan, scroll all completely with ease and without any lag, stutter or hiccup. Even browsers like Opera were too slow for me, I could see the text blur for a second before becoming sharp when zooming, panning or scrolling quickly. I don't have any such issues with Boat. Others like Chrome and Firefox just aren't even close.
I have of course optimized my tablet in numerous ways (without root) such as developer option animations, and Nova launcher etc.
Feel free to try other browsers mentioned here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2516754
If you are receiving lag on boat, you are doing something wrong or you have a problem with your tablet...
Thx for your lengthy post. I'd like to believe then, that I have different settings or something... I tried to make a video and compare boat browser and UC HD (which is smooth but has other issues).
I used n4g.com and Watson.ch both are big pages with lots of images. It's not that apparent in the video though because it's not 60fps (duh) but I think you can see the difference
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMsG3DVLW_g
Oh well ..
On an IPAD , you cant really scroll completely like you can in Android ...
On Android the faster you move your finger the sooner it reaches the bottom of the page .. But on IPAD it only scrolls to an extent , hiding the fact that its still loading the rest of the webpage in the background . IOS is really good at hiding a lot of other things too and I actually like that and dont mind that since the experience is nice .. The only reason why I dont like IOS is because of a lack of a file browser , no usb pen drive connectivity , expandable storage , and itunes for doing anything and very little customization ..
The UI on an IPAD is really smooth and thats how its been ... plus ios talks in low level language ( Objective - C ) to the hardware directly where as Android has a middle man ( JAVA ) in between itself and the hardware
I have a surface pro .. and thats really really smooth for anything but its too heavy ..
So I have realized there is no happy place yet
Ideally I would wish there will be an os that has Flexibility of Android , Smoothness and optimization like IOS and Power of The Surface pro .. with Accurate Stylus support .... Oh well I can only dream .. but its funny that such technology still does not exist in 2014 .
No happy place :crying: wurde
:laugh:
We have some amazing browsers out there... It would just be nice if they were a bit smoother overall. And somehow it feels like it's simple a matter of better code and not hardware limitations... That's what's bugging me!
clouds5 said:
Thx for your lengthy post. I'd like to believe then, that I have different settings or something... I tried to make a video and compare boat browser and UC HD (which is smooth but has other issues).
I used n4g.com and Watson.ch both are big pages with lots of images. It's not that apparent in the video though because it's not 60fps (duh) but I think you can see the difference
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMsG3DVLW_g
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problems... I can see the differences in your video, I'm not sure it's a huge difference but I can notice it.
Can you try the Mobile version of Boat instead of the Tablet version, for some reason I mainly stuck with the Phone version, although I have both loaded. I will try and also post a video at some stage of the varying browsers on mine to also show the difference, but it may take a few days...
Also UC browser (which has a reputation for being one of the fastest) seems to work fairly well on your video. What were/are your other issues, perhaps it's easier to address those issues than trying to get the other browsers working as fast for you.
clouds5 said:
So i have a top of the line tablet with octacore, 3gb of ram and the latest KitKat 4.4.2, I don't use energy saving either. And no matter what browser I use the experience is never satisfactory.
Chrome is pretty good but it has 0 functionality. We use our fingers not a mouse! And still laggy in certain situations (same goes for Samsung stock browser).
UC browser HD is very good too in terms of scrolling, but when you're typing text is lagging behind and switching and creating tabs stutters horribly.
And Firefox, the mother of lag. When you scroll down a page really fast it takes the browser up to 5 seconds to render the damn page! While you are already looking at it. Try it out for yourself, you scroll then you only get a gray page, then everything plops in very blurry and then after another few seconds stuff gets rendered and is finally sharp.
I know that every browser has this issue to some extent. But most render much faster than firefox so it doesn't appear as an issue. Anyway can't android keep a Web page in memory completely? I have 3gb of it!
Or maybe I'm doing it wrong or you guys can suggest me a different browser with good usability and smoothness? Thx in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you use developer options?
Boat browser was stuttering for me a lot also. Seeing this thread reminded me of the force GPU rendering option which I had checked.
I just unchecked it and it seems to be making a difference
Edit: Disregard that, doesn't make any difference.
Hmm. I like the stock browser in 4.4. It's a hell of a lot faster than 4.3 was. XDA and the WSJ are heavy sites; is this slow?
BarryH_GEG said:
Hmm. I like the stock browser in 4.4. It's a hell of a lot faster than 4.3 was. XDA and the WSJ are heavy sites; is this slow?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To me that does seem a tad bit on the slow side. Not so much the page loading but the repressiveness to pinch-to-zoom and finger scrolling seemed a bit laggy.
elsamuraiguapo said:
To me that does seem a tad bit on the slow side. Not so much the page loading but the repressiveness to pinch-to-zoom and finger scrolling seemed a bit laggy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Screen painting is a bit slower than my N3 but that's to be expected considering the enormous difference in display area. Page loading (which is slower than screen painting) is exactly the same on both. So is navigating around a page once it's loaded. I guess I have low standards.
BarryH_GEG said:
Screen painting is a bit slower than my N3 but that's to be expected considering the enormous difference in display area. Page loading (which is slower than screen painting) is exactly the same on both. So is navigating around a page once it's loaded. I guess I have low standards.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have a Note 3 but I have a Nexus 5 and it's no where near that laggy. In fact I'm pretty sure my Note 10.1 2014 is smoother than that as well. But I'm rooted with a bunch of tweaks, custom ROM, and custom kernel.
Here my takes:
1) Boat browser - fastest and best features, support flash
2) dolphin browser - second place, similar features as Boat, support flash
3) Others that support flash.
Try http://finance.yahoo.com and see how fast and how the page display with your browser!!
I've had the Tab S 10.5 for about a month now and the lag while using everyday apps is driving me crazy. My top three offenders are:
1. Chrome
2. Play Newsstand
3. Play Store
I've done the following to help improve things:
- Changed launcher to Nova.
- Disabled bloatware (everything I can without rooting).
- Installed Chrome Samsung support library.
3D heavy games seem to run fine. My last tablet was a HP touchpad running CM11 so I am used to dealing with a few quirks. I stepped up to the Tab S to get away from some of that though. I know Android is infamous for scroll stutter, but it seems to me that a flagship tablet should easily beat out a bootleg touchpad.
Is this on par? Also, does anyone else's tab s get really hot around the touch screen near the Samsung logo? Maybe the Nexus 9 is worth another look. :silly:
Thanks for your comments.
Edit: I've read similar posts on lag. It seems like the argument boils down to: 1. Personal perception or 2. A mysterious "bad batch" of hardware.
i did the same steps,my tab is full of apps and games but i have 0 lag and the browsing is also fcking smooth. In the settings i also turned of features like dual window.
Are you sure you turned off fully power saving mode? About heating,if i play a game like gta or hearthstone i can also feel a warm area under samsung logo but is not hot and pretty common if you play games.
edith and use chrome beta instead of the standard chrome
Chrome lags on the tab s. Happens to most people. To fix over heating i installed a custom kernel that would optimise and prevent heating. Some big games do lag aswell.
thomasovics said:
i did the same steps,my tab is full of apps and games but i have 0 lag and the browsing is also fcking smooth. In the settings i also turned of features like dual window.
Are you sure you turned off fully power saving mode? About heating,if i play a game like gta or hearthstone i can also feel a warm area under samsung logo but is not hot and pretty common if you play games.
edith and use chrome beta instead of the standard chrome
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am already using chrome beta. The stock broswer is smoother.
can you upload a video to see the lag we are talking about?
I want to buy this tablet, and Ive read many posts about lag... but actually, is it very annoying? is there any video to see it?
Latiosman said:
can you upload a video to see the lag we are talking about?
I want to buy this tablet, and Ive read many posts about lag... but actually, is it very annoying? is there any video to see it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only on certain apps. Chrome and a few others. On some games it just lags on loading screen but not during gameplay. Watch a veiw reviews on youtube. Theres some videos talking about the lag. Touchwiz launcher also has lag but can be fixed.
Latiosman said:
can you upload a video to see the lag we are talking about?
I want to buy this tablet, and Ive read many posts about lag... but actually, is it very annoying? is there any video to see it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think it depends on your perception of lag and what apps you mainly use. In my case, Chrome and Newsstand are always up so I see the lag constantly. I wish I had a Nexus 9 side by side for comparison. If I get a chance I'll take a video, but it might be hard to see. I played with a demo model at Best Buy and it seemed faster than mine as well.
I came from a iPad mini 2 (last year's model) to this tablet. As smooth as my iPad was I have to say I have very little if any lag on mine. It's runs beautifully for me. I'm OCD, any bit of lag would drive me up the wall. I really don't notice hardly anything. I'm still running bone stock everything minus using Nova launcher. Don't even feel like I need to root or flash anything. Although I'm going to once there is a root released for my model. Maybe I'm just lucky I don't know. Have had zero issues.
I'm used to an overloaded gs3 so this looks ultra smooth to me [emoji3]
It lags more with multiple user logged in, always reboot of you don't need the additional user
Ripx88 said:
I came from a iPad mini 2 (last year's model) to this tablet. As smooth as my iPad was I have to say I have very little if any lag on mine. It's runs beautifully for me. I'm OCD, any bit of lag would drive me up the wall. I really don't notice hardly anything. I'm still running bone stock everything minus using Nova launcher. Don't even feel like I need to root or flash anything. Although I'm going to once there is a root released for my model. Maybe I'm just lucky I don't know. Have had zero issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For example, this thread's website lags a great deal in chrome beta when scrolling. Other sites aren't too bad. Newsstand is the worst though. Are you using the stock broswer?
This site does lag a little when scrolling. That I do have to admit. For whatever reason it doesn't really bother me however. I've never noticed any scroll stutter on stock android so I attribute it to touchwiz. This thing debloated or running a custom rom probably flys. I imagine any scroll stutter would be gone at that point.
I use the stock browser. I was never a fan of chrome. I know that on touchwiz your going to get the best performance from the stock browser unless there's a fix I'm unaware of which could be a possibility. Newsstand I actually haven't used so I can't speak for it. TouchWiz is just eating up so much ram. I'm like always at 1.5 to 2 gigs of ram with nothing running (other then the tons of unnecessary system apps I can't terminate) That is pretty ridiculous to me. Is touchwiz smooth as stock android? Definitely not. But I really have little to no lag other then scroll stutter on certain sites. I'm still going to root and debloat this thing when it's available for my model so I can truly experience the power of this tablet.
Lol, chrome sucks
It's about time Samsung optimised their flagship device. Had 3 since July and they all lag, stutter when scrolling and render pics poorly. Nova didnt fix the problems and changing some apps like using chrome beta marginally helped.
About time they fixed this via an update rather than just forget about the device and launch more/different models. Samsung will always fail unless it focuses on a core product set and spend the time making the hardware work properly with the software.
I was attacked when I first got my first device for stating lag. Whether an first time user or someone who doesn't want to root (glad I didn't after having 3 replacements), I shouldn't have to kill apps, install different roms and root.
Certain other OS fix problems like these quickly. Where's support from Samsung??
I have the note 4, their es8000 led TV, fridge freezer and various other bits so I'm not a Samsung hater by any means, just someone who expects upgrades to fix problems.
It's hard to determine how much lag is there until you run the same apps side by side with another tablet.
Over Xmas I got a chance to do just that. Ran S 10.5 side by side with my sister's nexus 7 2013. Both running kit kat (hers is 4.4.3 instead of 4.4.2).
Play Store and chrome both run smoother on hers, less jerking and stopping when scrolling. Tapatalk about same. She has Google now launcher, feels faster and smoother than nova launcher on mine. Overall, every thing just feels a little smoother and more fluid.
Granted, the nexus is 1920x1200 so it's pushing fewer pixels around, but the nexus is one year older and I paid $179 for it vs $379 for the S.
I think Samsung slapped on the OLED display and said heh, good enough. Which is true because I bought it
Custom Rom?
I made a rom that is all stock, just a few optimisations. Better performance, better batterylife and so on, here you go:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-tab-s/development/prerooted-stock-touchwiz-rom-t2973107
I'd use only stock browser, if it had a full screen option and some gestures, but nope.
My alternative browser is maxthon pioneer, it has everything but stutters a lot
I've had my S 10 since August....I don't like chrome, never have, but after reading all this I opened chrome and came to this forum and I see no issues at all. NONE, other than I don't like chrome
I'm stock not rooted or ROMed. I have Apex launcher installed since day one and disabled all the Samsung and google bloat I could disable.
I have no issues with this tablet other than posting on some forums is a little quirky but that's just the way things are. I normally use Dolphin with the Jetpack or Boat Browser for tablet.
I love this tablet! Sure beats the stuffing out of my Asus TF700T! What a total POC that is!
Joker87 said:
I'd use only stock browser, if it had a full screen option and some gestures, but nope.
My alternative browser is maxthon pioneer, it has everything but stutters a lot
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just throw in a wipe cache once every few days, and stock browser experience is very smooth, even with the second account logged on, with Facebook, dropbox, carousel and plenty other services in background
Don't worry about the Lag
This lag on Tab S is only temporarily, the Android 5.0 will get rid of 90% of the lag. I know this for fact because I have Note 3 with Touch-wiz it lags often, after installing Android 5.0 I have NOT ONCE run into lag after 1 month of using it.
As of now, the Tab S is supporting android 5.0 cm 12 which there should definitely be no lag but again its unofficial ROM as of now, there are still things they are working on. Samsung's android 5.0 will get rid significant amount of lag, because Android 5.0 have 60 fps animation smoothness, and efficient RAM usage.
I've also heard rumors Samsung is working to refreshing their Touchwiz Interface with slim amount of lag. So, the future is promising.
As of now, if you really can't stand the lag, Install the Android 5.0 ROM for Cm 12, there are afew things not working in their such as Camera, NFC or something else, but the usage should show NO LAG!!!
[email protected] said:
As of now, if you really can't stand the lag, Install the Android 5.0 ROM for Cm 12, there are afew things not working in their such as Camera, NFC or something else, but the usage should show NO LAG!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cyanogenmod for Galaxy tab S??