Related
So I've had my Gnex for about 2 weeks now, was in a commuter case the whole time. Today, I drop it on the pavement, no sharp objects or rocks protruding out. It dropped from my hand, about waist level, and went forward about a metre or two. And guess what, the screen is completely cracked! cracks running from the bottom to the sides, to the top, a small chunk of screen missing right above the notification LED. Otterbox, I'm very very dissappointed!! Samsung too.. I dropped my desire z multiple times on pavement/concrete, no harm done. Unbelievable...
so let this be a warning to commuter users! anyone have similar experiences?
I have the same case and dropped my phone multiple times. My phone has survived every accidental drop with no scratches, cracks, etc......yet. The Commuter case is also in good condition with no blemishes on it other than the usual lint.
Ugh so I just had bad luck.. it was the very first time I dropped it too.
Random Select said:
I have the same case and dropped my phone multiple times. My phone has survived every accidental drop with no scratches, cracks, etc......yet. The Commuter case is also in good condition with no blemishes on it other than the usual lint.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used the commuter, the case itself has cracked but nothing on the phone.
gnewylliw said:
So I've had my Gnex for about 2 weeks now, was in a commuter case the whole time. Today, I drop it on the pavement, no sharp objects or rocks protruding out. It dropped from my hand, about waist level, and went forward about a metre or two. And guess what, the screen is completely cracked! cracks running from the bottom to the sides, to the top, a small chunk of screen missing right above the notification LED. Otterbox, I'm very very dissappointed!! Samsung too.. I dropped my desire z multiple times on pavement/concrete, no harm done. Unbelievable...
so let this be a warning to commuter users! anyone have similar experiences?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
may be it was cracked before? lol
hp13 said:
may be it was cracked before? lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol nah.. i would have seen. I went back to where I dropped it today... flat concrete, no protrusions/ pebbles. but judging from the screen cracks it looks like there was one area of impact, and a small chunk of screen is missing from there, and most of the cracks radiate from there outwards. really scratching my head here..
anyways, I bought a new screen.. if that one cracks I'm just going to be sad.
I use the same case and dropped my phone a few times hard and it was fine. I too am thinking it must have been some hard protruding debris the screen fell in to. One more reason for me to get a glass screen protector.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
2manycells said:
I use the same case and dropped my phone a few times hard and it was fine. I too am thinking it must have been some hard protruding debris the screen fell in to. One more reason for me to get a glass screen protector.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
were any of your drops face down and onto pavement/concrete? i looked at a video where the guy did a 4-foot face-down drop with no screen onto a block of flat cement and the lcd didn't even work afterwards
My question is; did Otterbox ever claim that your phone would be invincible with the Commuter? If the company said that, there would be no more Otterboxes. In nearly any case, a fall could shatter the screen. It happened on my iPod touch, on my original Droid. It doesn't matter what case is on. Glass smacking the floor with result in a fall.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
wyattyoss said:
My question is; did Otterbox ever claim that your phone would be invincible with the Commuter? If the company said that, there would be no more Otterboxes. In nearly any case, a fall could shatter the screen. It happened on my iPod touch, on my original Droid. It doesn't matter what case is on. Glass smacking the floor with result in a fall.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
were they in otterboxes?
Both were in Commuters.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
falls onto flat surface? facedown? I'm trying to get an idea of if this kind of thing would happen if it were dropped onto a flat suface, or because there was a small rock or something that actually impacted the screen. i'm leaning towards the protrusion idea
attached some pics. the missing chunk is just at the bottom of the screen protector. the chunk of glass below that originally looked fine, just two cracks on either side, but it's white now- guess it got loose over the weekend.
any forensic glass experts? opinions?
I returned my commuter case last week, thing is a lint collector/insanely bulky vs the reviews it has on Amazon.
Yes two of the drops were face down...one on solid concrete and the other on the hardwood floor. It seemed to be saved by the lip on the case which I admit is pretty thin compared to say my ballistic case.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
ahh so the commuter saved them then? I want to know that my case was caused by an errand pebble, not the commuter failing to protect the screen with the lip. I don't want to smash my new screen again. then I'll be the biggest idiot in town..
2manycells said:
Yes two of the drops were face down...one on solid concrete and the other on the hardwood floor. It seemed to be saved by the lip on the case which I admit is pretty thin compared to say my ballistic case.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had a very similar drop and result last week. I had mine in a diztronic case and an xo skin, and the screen shattered. I guess I should get a tougher case, but if the same thing happened with the commuter, and so many people use diztronic with no problem, it might have just been bad luck/physics. Like you, there didn't seem to be anything out of the ordinary about my drop.
Truthfully the commuter is advertised as a light duty case and the defender the heavy duty. You could upgrade to a ballistic or Agesis case, but neither case may help if the screen hits a rock. I'm going to be getting the glass screen protector for that reason.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
No case will protect the phone from a direct impact on the screen.
Even a small pebble on the ground that sticks up higher than the case's lip will crack it. Falls from less than 2 feet probably wont matter if you have a screen protecter or an otterbox defender, but a shoulder - height fall is probably the end of your device if the screen is directly impacted.
was this outside too?
yankeelaw said:
I had a very similar drop and result last week. I had mine in a diztronic case and an xo skin, and the screen shattered. I guess I should get a tougher case, but if the same thing happened with the commuter, and so many people use diztronic with no problem, it might have just been bad luck/physics. Like you, there didn't seem to be anything out of the ordinary about my drop.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm thinking about having my phone naked....... well, sort of. What I mean is, I was thinking of adding the SGP Glas for the front. So now the front will be protected. Then I would have a bumper protecting the sides of the phone. For the back I would have an invisible shield, Even if I do happen to drop it I can easily buy the back panel since its cheap. Do you think this would be a smart way of having my phone feel naked and having great having protection?
I just love the naked slim body of the phone. I do have a diztronic case even though the case has very little bulk, its still does not the feel the same.
Looking for some advise
What I would buy to do this is...
SPIGEN SGP Samsung Galaxy S3 Screen Protector
http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Prote...7726&sr=8-1&keywords=galaxy+s3+tempered+glass
Black bumper
http://www.amazon.com/Plastic-Bumpe...=1347180178&sr=1-10&keywords=galaxy+s3+bumper
Fort he Back of the phone
http://www.amazon.com/ArmorSuit-Mil...=1-8&keywords=galaxy+s3+invisible+shield+back
You don't need to protect the screen at all, gorilla glass is much stronger than your flimsy plastic sheets you put on it. If something can scratch gorilla glass, that "screen protector" will not stop it at all. A weaker object can't protect a stronger object.
What you need to protect is the phone's back. I use my phones naked always. I've never had much problem. However with SGS3, my phone's back is covered with scratches. I don't remeber having any other phone with a backplate this vulnerable.
aydc said:
You don't need to protect the screen at all, gorilla glass is much stronger than your flimsy plastic sheets you put on it. If something can scratch gorilla glass, that "screen protector" will not stop it at all. A weaker object can't protect a stronger object.
What you need to protect is the phone's back. I use my phones naked always. I've never had much problem. However with SGS3, my phone's back is covered with scratches. I don't remeber having any other phone with a backplate this vulnerable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah Gorilla glass can be scratched.
I'm sure if I did this to gorilla glass without a screen protector.... it would be destroyed.
http://www.youtube.com/user/ZAGGTV?feature=pyv&ad=6270281533&kw=galaxy s review&v=XYmBDUkFdC4&lr=1
I'm also using SGP glas on my S3, but I use with Samsung's slim case. This thing add literally no thickness at all! And it protects back and the camera. I thought about using SGP ultra bumper case but I'm worried about camera lens since it doesn't provide any kind of protection around.
http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/cell-phones-accessories/ETC-2PKSCEGSTA
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
zen0s said:
I'm also using SGP glas on my S3, but I use with Samsung's slim case. This thing add literally no thickness at all! And it protects back and the camera. I thought about using SGP ultra bumper case but I'm worried about camera lens since it doesn't provide any kind of protection around.
http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/cell-phones-accessories/ETC-2PKSCEGSTA
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG LOOKS SO PERFECT.
Does this material also feel like the phone is still naked?
rayoubi said:
OMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG LOOKS SO PERFECT.
Does this material also feel like the phone is still naked?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's the closet you can to naked feeling! I love it, they come in breeze & diamond pattern. I personally like the diamond, it gives me more grip. Definitely give it a try!
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
should be in accessories thread
Does using a screen protector take away the essence of the S3's beautiful screen? I am very careful about keeping my phone away from coins, keys, etc. and am confident about not getting the screen scratched; my only concern is the finger oil marks that are left on the screen.
Will a screen protector resolve this issue?
I am confused.
Why not using a pouch like this one? http://mobil.idealo.de/preisvergleich/OffersOfProduct/3276708_-slimcase-leather-xl-bugatti.html
Using a similar case since I have my s3 (bought it at launch) and haven't got a single scratch yet and still have the pure device when I interact with it.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Just go full naked, every time u pick it up or look at it you get remember how beautiful the design is.
Gesendet von meinem Nexus 7 mit Tapatalk 2
Tectas said:
Why not using a pouch like this one? http://mobil.idealo.de/preisvergleich/OffersOfProduct/3276708_-slimcase-leather-xl-bugatti.html
Using a similar case since I have my s3 (bought it at launch) and haven't got a single scratch yet and still have the pure device when I interact with it.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
because if I dropped it when its out of the punch im screwed.
Be careful with samsung ultra slim in 0.3mm
I got them ( there are 2 differents in package) and both suffer hot temperatures! I have no photo atm but i can clearly say that they deform themeselves if exposed at some high temperature(for example when you play game or any sort of thing that increase battery temperature)
they are curved now and dont fit well..
So i gone with the tpu ,always samsung offcial, and all is awesome (but you lose the naked but protected feel xD)
When i read naked i thought you meant to take the motherboard out and put it in a transparent case/shell to show the insides....
Why not try a Zagg invisible shield. I'vehad one on my SGS since the beginning and also on my GTab. It'll be the first thing I get on my next mobile upgrade. You can get maximum protection (front, back, sides) or just front protection.
Www.zagg.com
Sent from my GT-P7500 using xda app-developers app
Why bother with a $15 skin for the back when you can buy a brand new replacement battery door for $7?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/180945887795?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649
Here's my "slim" setup.
vw671 said:
Why bother with a $15 skin for the back when you can buy a brand new replacement battery door for $7?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/180945887795?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649
Here's my "slim" setup.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My gawd i like that setup, wat bumper is that?
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
htcsnap93 said:
My gawd i like that setup, wat bumper is that?
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.ebay.com/itm/140807159498?var=440071001120&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649
rayoubi said:
Nah Gorilla glass can be scratched.
I'm sure if I did this to gorilla glass without a screen protector.... it would be destroyed.
http://www.youtube.com/user/ZAGGTV?feature=pyv&ad=6270281533&kw=galaxy s review&v=XYmBDUkFdC4&lr=1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it wouldnt
there are plenty of videos of people scraping keys,knives, and other sharp objects across the screen with no effect, even sandpaper which resulted in very faint scratches
my phone has flip case... and the screen's scratched to ****. If gorilla glass is scratchproof then i'm the king of mars
So then, is a screen protector absolutely essential? I'd rather have the screen naked, then use a screen protector.
I have, however, got a pretty nice body for the phone that covers and protects the back well.
I dropped my Nexus 5 cased in a spigen ultra fit on its corner. The corner of the phone got roughed up when I took off the case to check. Hard cases don't absorb well in my opinion.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Duly noted, tpu seems safer than hardcase, sorry about your phone though
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
It sounds like the case did its job. You dropped the phone while it was wearing the case and the phone did not crack, right?
Thanks for the case recommendation!
herosemblem said:
It sounds like the case did its job. You dropped the phone while it was wearing the case and the phone did not crack, right?
Thanks for the case recommendation!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah it did its job but didn't at the same time. I am disappointed but oh well
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
locke84 said:
Duly noted, tpu seems safer than hardcase, sorry about your phone though
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try the Spigen Neo Hybrid case. It's a TPU case with the a hard plastic bumper aroud the edge. Pretty nice case IMO.
thefsfempire said:
Try the Spigen Neo Hybrid case. It's a TPU case with the a hard plastic bumper aroud the edge. Pretty nice case IMO.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will check it, thanks
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
You can't expect a plastic sleeve to offer any protection.
If you want it safe from drops, IMO, you need dual layer protection.
That's why I went with a Neo Hybrid, too. Plus, it looks awesome (especially the champagne one).
Excreted from my Nexus 5
[Guide] Headphone/Earphone Buying
Neo Hybrid is nice but makes the phone way too bulky for my liking on one-hand usage.
Then your only option are cases that do not protect well from drops. It's a compromise we all make, though I'd hardly call the neo hybrid bulky.
There are a thousand cases for a thousand different preferences. I just don't think anyone should delude themselves by thinking a plastic sleeve can save a phone from a good drop.
Excreted from my Nexus 5
[Guide] Headphone/Earphone Buying
I agree with OP. I also own a Spigen Ultra Fit which has left noticeable scratch marks on the corner of my phone and I have never dropped it! Seems like this is a common problem with the Ultra Fit.
It depends on what you're willing to sacrifice. I'd rather have some protection and slim phone then full and bulky device
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
As a materials engineer, there are two things to consider:
- Hard materials are good for wear or scratch resistance, but they don't use to have a good resilience or fracture toughness: they don't absorb energy, so are not a good choice for impact resistance applications.
- In the other hand, soft materials as foams or silicon/tpu are not good for scratch or wear or impact with a sharp tool (this is what hardness really means), but they are very good absorving energy and have a high fracture toughness.
So when chosing your case you have to take into account your personal situation: do you usually drop your phone? Or are you more worried about scratching it with keys or coins?
And that's why composite materials should appear also in this field, to combine a shock absorber in the inner part of the case and a harder coating on the outer to protect against scratches.
I don't trust this "anti-shock" cases which are extremely rigid and slim.
^awesome post. Now I wish I knew that before all of this happened
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
I have the same case but my scratched up two corners badly. It even scratched by the volume rocker. Oh well. Rather have a scratch then a cracked screen.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
That is true bud, was looking around for a soft case to protect against drops more, but couldn't do it. Guess I have to live with it.
Sent from my Nexus 5
esskayy said:
I agree with OP. I also own a Spigen Ultra Fit which has left noticeable scratch marks on the corner of my phone and I have never dropped it! Seems like this is a common problem with the Ultra Fit.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the problem with the Ultra fit case, it grips so tight that every time you pry off the case it will scuff the phones matte finish in the corners. I didn't like this and stopped using it in favor of the softer and more protective Diztronic TPU case which is slightly bulkier but hey, one of life's many little compromises and one Im ok with.
Sent from my Nexus 5
herosemblem said:
It sounds like the case did its job. You dropped the phone while it was wearing the case and the phone did not crack, right?
Thanks for the case recommendation!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is like saying you never get sick because you take a vitamin every day. There's no way of knowing if it was the case that prevented the screen from fracturing without doing several drop tests in a controlled way. It could have easily been the angle of the fall, distance, or floor surface that saved the screen.
Hard plastic doesn't absorb the shock at all really because it's not flexible. This is why the higher end cases like the spigen neo hybrid have a dual layer protection of TPU.
Mr. Sprinkles said:
This is like saying you never get sick because you take a vitamin every day. There's no way of knowing if it was the case that prevented the screen from fracturing without doing several drop tests in a controlled way. It could have easily been the angle of the fall, distance, or floor surface that saved the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With what you said in mind, what is the take-away lesson then?
herosemblem said:
With what you said in mind, what is the take-away lesson then?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correlation does not imply causation.
Hi guys,
I just installed the Spigen GLAStR Nano Slim Tempered Glass Protector. I bought it off Amazon and it came pretty quick despite the holidays. I've attached pictures of the glass on my Nexus 5. Sorry I didn't get pictures of the installation process. I didn't want to risk getting dust underneath, so I had to do it quick.
I used the "Hinge Method" to put the screen on. And as you can see I got slight bubbles at the bottom (circled in red), so the installation wasn't perfect. I also have 1 tiny micro bubble in the middle...it's hardly noticeable even with the screen off/on and is probably less than .5mm in diameter. I would still suggest using this method for any screen protector installation.
After about 30 minutes, I used a micofiber cloth-covered squeegee to push out those bubbles that were circled...and they're gone! I just have that tiny ass one in the middle.
Overall it feels great, and its definitely smooth with the oleophobic coating...I haven't put my Cruzerlite case on yet, gonna give it some time for the glass' adhesive to settle in. I will comment on that soon!
Any questions? Feel free to hit me up!
Best,
K
Amazon link: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00GN1L626/ref=twister_B00GN1L3Q0
Tempered Glass w/ Cruzerlite Case On
Hi all,
Just an update here. I let the glass sit overnight and all the bubbles were gone..even that micro bubble in the middle of the screen. This morning, I slapped on my Cruzerlite TPU case, to see if there was any peeling of the glass, or any fit issues.
Initially, it seemed everything was fine. However, after I got to work, I noticed that in the left bottom corner, the case began to push the glass up a little, especially if I pushed on that edge. As such, I decided to remove the case to prevent any more issues.
Spigen's GLAStR screen protector seems like a good one, but I think if they increased the edges 1mm in each direction, the Cruzerlite case would sit on top and sort of seal the glass rather than hit edge-to-edge like in this case, causing the glass to begin peeling. I've attached pictures to show what it looks like with the case on.
Let me know if you have any questions!
K
Thanks for the review. I got one as a replacement from the previous defective ones.
As I have not applied mine yet, can you describe what is the "Hinge" method?
Cheers
MaelstromXC said:
Thanks for the review. I got one as a replacement from the previous defective ones.
As I have not applied mine yet, can you describe what is the "Hinge" method?
Cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sure. The Hinge method is where you take the screen protector and tape it to the phone BEFORE you peel the protective film away.
1) Align the screen protector to exactly where you want it
2) Tape one side of the protector so that you can swing it open like a door (tape in two places..I put a piece near the power button and one a little further down
3) Open up the "door" that you just made and clean your naked screen so there is no lint, dust, hair etc.
5) Make sure the protector aligns just as you want it
4) Then peel the "backside" of the film off so that the adhesive side is exposed and "close the door" so the protector is on the phone
5) Immediately take a squeege and cover it in a micofiber cloth and push out any bubbles you may have
6) Peel away the front of the screen protector
7) Using the squeegee that's inside the cloth (VERY IMPORTANT so you don't scratch the glass), push out any remaining bubbles
8) DONE! ENJOY!
Here's an example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dt9_fZDT-As
Best,
K
Nice review and a +1 for the hinge method. Only way to install a 'dry' screen protector for me!
Just received mine today. Install went great except I noticed an air bubble on the left side about halfway down, right on the edge. Well, when I took a closer look, it was actually a chip in the glass.
Contacted Spigen Support and I am waiting for a response. Hopefully they can help me out.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
eyeisdasteve said:
Just received mine today. Install went great except I noticed an air bubble on the left side about halfway down, right on the edge. Well, when I took a closer look, it was actually a chip in the glass.
Contacted Spigen Support and I am waiting for a response. Hopefully they can help me out.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That sucks! I hope they are responsive. Did you go with the hinge method as well during installation? I noticed that my glass is slightly off to the right.. Didn't get it perfect.. Oh well.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
KTT16 said:
That sucks! I hope they are responsive. Did you go with the hinge method as well during installation? I noticed that my glass is slightly off to the right.. Didn't get it perfect.. Oh well.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't go for the hinge method. But I have used it in the past and it works pretty well.
The chip is pretty small so its not interfering with anything on the screen, as long as it doesn't get worse.
Spigen sent me an email back with a case number and said I should be contacted within 1-3 business days. Hoping for the best!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Saved my phone!
Im not 100% sure HOW it saved my phone, but im sold on them and will be buying a replacement!
my son likes to hide my phone, last night he hid my phone under my recliner (which hits the floor when rocking) and as i was rocking away i heard CRACK / CRUNCH....looked under the chair to find my phone with two very prominent pressure cracks on the screen...
i thought NO WAY was this ONLY the Nano.TR....as i pulled up the corners, the glasses started breaking and falling apart, but low and behold, not a single scratch or dent on my phones screen!
Completely blown away that my phone's screen didn't crack under the pressure.....sold on them forever!
eyeisdasteve said:
I didn't go for the hinge method. But I have used it in the past and it works pretty well.
The chip is pretty small so its not interfering with anything on the screen, as long as it doesn't get worse.
Spigen sent me an email back with a case number and said I should be contacted within 1-3 business days. Hoping for the best!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So because of the chip in the edge of the protector it ended up just cracking across the screen.
I can't feel the crack but you can see it.
No email back from Spigen yet. Buy I did update them on the hairline crack across.
Still hoping for the best.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Reminds me if my car's windshield... that was a couple hundred down the tube... Lol.. good luck!
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Still no email back from Spigen. Its been almost 7 days with no response. They said I would get an email back in 1-3 days. -.-'
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
It's the first time I try a glass screen protector, this one is very wonderful. There is only a micro-chip somewhere, but I can't see it in normal conditions, I have to examine my screen closely for like one minute to spot it.
Putting it on the screen was very easy, much easier than plastic screen protectors.
It fits nicely with official Google bumper case.
Without a case?
Hey guys, I personally want to buy this Spigen protector (.tr version) because I hate cases on my mobile phone. I'm not going to waste €36 (yes, its the Netherlands) if I also have to apply a case on it. So is this screenprotector drop-proof? If I drop this phone from 1 meter from the surface, would it be able to save the ORIGINAL glass?
Thanks,
Viresh
VireshRamcharan said:
Hey guys, I personally want to buy this Spigen protector (.tr version) because I hate cases on my mobile phone. I'm not going to waste €36 (yes, its the Netherlands) if I also have to apply a case on it. So is this screenprotector drop-proof? If I drop this phone from 1 meter from the surface, would it be able to save the ORIGINAL glass?
Thanks,
Viresh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They recommend a case with this product because they say the protector would crack easily without any case over time.
Ano59 said:
They recommend a case with this product because they say the protector would crack easily without any case over time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you mean by "over time", considering my usage, I have only dropped my old phone (SGS+) once in the two years of intensive usage. As SGS+ is a smart strong boy, it doesn't break, not even a scratch. Would the Glas.tR, 0.4 mm, survive a 1 meter downfall? Thanks in advance yo
VireshRamcharan said:
What do you mean by "over time", considering my usage, I have only dropped my old phone (SGS+) once in the two years of intensive usage. As SGS+ is a smart strong boy, it doesn't break, not even a scratch. Would the Glas.tR, 0.4 mm, survive a 1 meter downfall? Thanks in advance yo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, sorry but I have no idea. It's only written that they strongly recommend using a case along with the glass.
VireshRamcharan said:
What do you mean by "over time", considering my usage, I have only dropped my old phone (SGS+) once in the two years of intensive usage. As SGS+ is a smart strong boy, it doesn't break, not even a scratch. Would the Glas.tR, 0.4 mm, survive a 1 meter downfall? Thanks in advance yo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It depends on how it falls obviously, but I'd say chances are pretty good that the glass screen protector would be cracked or chipped after a fall, especially onto a hard surface like concrete. I have the GLAS.t on my N5 and like you I prefer no case and am very careful with my phone. But even just casual daily use, the screen protector has chipped, and it's been the case with several others too (spanning a variety of different brands as well).
So I would proceed with caution and really consider if it's worth sinking the money into. That being said, if the screen protector chips or cracks after a fall, it's taking damage that would otherwise be applied to your phone, which is its purpose to begin with.
b.spec said:
It depends on how it falls obviously, but I'd say chances are pretty good that the glass screen protector would be cracked or chipped after a fall, especially onto a hard surface like concrete. I have the GLAS.t on my N5 and like you I prefer no case and am very careful with my phone. But even just casual daily use, the screen protector has chipped, and it's been the case with several others too (spanning a variety of different brands as well).
So I would proceed with caution and really consider if it's worth sinking the money into. That being said, if the screen protector chips or cracks after a fall, it's taking damage that would otherwise be applied to your phone, which is its purpose to begin with.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks man
VireshRamcharan said:
So, a fall from 1 meter above on a hard surface, with the glass .tR 0.4mm applied, straight on its front would prevent the ORIGINAL Nexus 5 glass from cracking? (i know the spigen **** will crack)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's no reason to expect any screen protector would save a phone from a drop. Screen protectors are meant for preventing the glass from being scratched. If the drop is sufficient to damage the screen, I strongly feel it would damage the screen through a 0.4mm sheet of glass overlaying your screen.
Cases, however, are what you use to protect phones from drops.
It's "Spigen ultra thin air"
I just think this case is light and pretty, but after using it for the past 4 months.
I have scratches 10 thread around the edges and corners on all sides, including the back cover too.
My device never slip, fall or affected. All scratches are caused by just putting the case in - out.
Do not buy!, the advantage is that pretty only.
Sorry for my english skill and I don't have camera to take the scratches photo.
There's also multiple posts about these types of cases and this one in particular.
Jatiyanon said:
It's "Spigen ultra thin air"
I just think this case is light and pretty, but after using it for the past 4 months.
I have scratches 10 thread around the edges and corners on all sides, including the back cover too.
My device never slip, fall or affected. All scratches are caused by just putting the case in - out.
Do not buy!, the advantage is that pretty only.
Sorry for my english skill and I don't have camera to take the scratches photo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey, this been known since it was released in November. I had it and got rid of it because of this same issue,.
For me it was the Caseologic (Flash issues)
Jatiyanon said:
It's "Spigen ultra thin air"
I just think this case is light and pretty, but after using it for the past 4 months.
I have scratches 10 thread around the edges and corners on all sides, including the back cover too.
My device never slip, fall or affected. All scratches are caused by just putting the case in - out.
Do not buy!, the advantage is that pretty only.
Sorry for my english skill and I don't have camera to take the scratches photo.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me it was the Caseology LG Google Nexus 5 Carbon Fiber Hybrid TPU Armor Case Cover, is really nice and huge, the problem is when taking a picture, the photos with flash come out blurry, since the cover is so close to the flash, it reflects on the body of the cover and the pictures come out really bad. I stopped using it since every time I wanted a night picture I had to take the cover off. Ever since I have been using the "Soft TPU Bumper Frame + Clear Crystal Back Case Cover (ebay)" and the "Hybrid Bumper Case Cover Frame (ebay)". The caseology is a great protection cover, but for me, is like a great car with a bad performance.
NJ_RAMS_FAN said:
hey, this been known since it was released in November. I had it and got rid of it because of this same issue,.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are you use now, what case are slim - light equally. :crying:
Anyone had any bad experience with the quicksand cases?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Jatiyanon said:
What are you use now, what case are slim - light equally. :crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm actually riding naked.
Jatiyanon said:
It's "Spigen ultra thin air"
My device never slip, fall or affected. All scratches are caused by just putting the case in - out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stop taking it off and on.
I don't see the problem. The case is to stop the phone breaking when you drop it.
jimmyjoebob said:
Stop taking it off and on.
I don't see the problem. The case is to stop the phone breaking when you drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean taking it on permanent?
Sometimes I have remove it to clean , right?
jimmyjoebob said:
Stop taking it off and on.
I don't see the problem. The case is to stop the phone breaking when you drop it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Slim cases provide no drop protection at all. Ironically enough they're only good to protect against scratches.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Had Spigen for few weeks and switched to Diztronic.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Spigen slim armor is awesome! Been using for the past 3 months. NO COMPLAINTS!
I've the spiegen "light armour" and it's protected my phone 100%
These cases are meant to be kept on. I've never taken it off and would imagine if I did a few times it may damage as it's a tight fit, which is why fit and leave!
From my mobile telephony device.