Being an andoid novice, and not much a coder, I was wondering if any one had any information about 2way call recording on Toro.
Right now I am on Purity Rom using AK's dummy ED kernel...
I do have call recording working using ALSAmixer and CallRecoder by skvalex (much thanks to him for a great app). Now let me preface this that it does work, sometimes. I can recorded both sides of the call SOMETIMES. I can always hear myself, but it seems 1/2 the time I can hear the other party and 1/2 the time they sound like they're quite distant, barely audible. So I did some research and, experimented w/ the standard api settings, none of which work, and I was curious as it says for 2way call recording it requires a kernel path:
1) is 2 way call recorded an API issue in the ROM, or in the kernel, or in both? (I found this, but not being a programmer, I don't know what it all means... http://developer.android.com/reference/android/media/MediaRecorder.AudioSource.html#VOICE_CALL )
2) where is the source for the kernel patch so that I can maybe inquire to the kernel developer to see if they can implement it
3) are they any known functioning kernels/roms for Toro that allow uplink/downlink recording?
Any information would be appreciated.
Related
For those has problem in recording telephone conversation on SGS2 can try this patch, I am using Leomar GB 2.3.4 ROM with this CWM-patch taken from Chinese ROM. Good 2way voice quality using Ultimate Voice Recorder 2.71 other telephone recording software should work too.
Remember backup your ROM before testing in case you may get infinite loopback after flashing
ronlkh said:
For those has problem in recording telephone conversation on SGS2 can try this patch, I am using Leomar GB 2.3.4 ROM with this CWM-patch taken from Chinese ROM. Good 2way voice quality using Ultimate Voice Recorder 2.71 other telephone recording software should work too.
Remember backup your ROM before testing in case you may get infinite loopback after flashing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, 2 questions, is this not a "call recording" app itself ? and does it needs kernel support ?, thanks.
ronlkh said:
For those has problem in recording telephone conversation on SGS2 can try this patch, I am using Leomar GB 2.3.4 ROM with this CWM-patch taken from Chinese ROM. Good 2way voice quality using Ultimate Voice Recorder 2.71 other telephone recording software should work too.
Remember backup your ROM before testing in case you may get infinite loopback after flashing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will try it and post my experience here.. I hope this must be a addon to the phone app...
this is just the lib files you still need recording app to do the recording. You can use Cris ROM and patch with this lib. You should get clear voice conversation in the recording
I´m already recording phone calls without this hack, just installed an app (callrecorder) and its working really good, clear voice on both sides.
Bajo76 said:
I´m already recording phone calls without this hack, just installed an app (callrecorder) and its working really good, clear voice on both sides.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yep same here...
just install newest Total Recall v1.7.6
select recording method "C" (you can try trial before buying it, if it works!)
worked on KE2 stock and now on KF3 ... so no hack or what so ever...
Conversation impossible if call recording active and BT audio device used.
This patch can't resolve it
DaFileFather said:
worked on KE2 stock and now on KF3 ... so no hack or what so ever...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried it in car ?
Option A in TR can record other side in any case, but not me.
d8389 said:
Conversation impossible if call recording active and BT audio device used.
This patch can't resolve it
Have you tried it in car ?
Option A in TR can record other side in any case, but not me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never use bt..
But I think v1.8.0 fixed that!
Try it and let us know...
Sent from my Nokia 3310
MIUI ROM
Does it work with MIUI recording?
Bajo76 said:
I´m already recording phone calls without this hack, just installed an app (callrecorder) and its working really good, clear voice on both sides.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here, Hacking code is not needed..This apk works flawlessly and doesn't mess with anything else.
does this work with kh3 odex??
CallRecorder TotalRecall obstructs the operation of SIP/VOIP and Bluetooth headphones when use it for bidirectional recording on mode "C"
Hi there!
I am looking for an software to record my calls. Unfortunatelly I wasn't able to find a proper one. I need a software which doesn't use the mic for recording..
Any ideeas, please?
If you have root. CallRecorder.apk
Sent from my HTC Wildfire S A510e using xda premium
Hi there!
I instaled ecorder 1.0.45 alpha on my Wildfire S with a stock 2.3.5 ROM and rooted. It seems to record 2 way from line, but the other way sounds to be distorted from time to time (in call and in the recorded file).
It records the conversation only if I chose Kernel with 2-way call recording patch (even if my phone doesn't have such patch). If I chose Standards Android API, CallRecorder will generate a 0 bytes file..
Here's what I`ve done.
1. Temp rooted my wildfire s.
2. Installed CallRecorder.apk
3. Both sides recording works like a charm
helbet said:
Hi there!
I instaled ecorder 1.0.45 alpha on my Wildfire S with a stock 2.3.5 ROM and rooted. It seems to record 2 way from line, but the other way sounds to be distorted from time to time (in call and in the recorded file).
It records the conversation only if I chose Kernel with 2-way call recording patch (even if my phone doesn't have such patch). If I chose Standards Android API, CallRecorder will generate a 0 bytes file..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It craps out a lot even overclocked to 806 mhz.
Garbles the conversation.
Unfortunately IT is the best solution out there.
Thanks a lot d33ps1x
d33ps1x said:
It craps out a lot even overclocked to 806 mhz.
Garbles the conversation.
Unfortunately IT is the best solution out there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a lot d33ps1x!
I realise now that is a hardware problem... Marvel is not powerfull enough to record a conversation...
I had a HTC Touch Diamond with Windows Mobile and 128 MB RAM and this was not a problem!
Hi nz_ranger!
nz_ranger said:
Here's what I`ve done.
1. Temp rooted my wildfire s.
2. Installed CallRecorder.apk
3. Both sides recording works like a charm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi nz_ranger!
Don't you have garbled conversations when CallRecorder is in use?
Witch version are you using?
My phone is rooted and S-OFF with a stock ROM.
@nz_ranger
Which version. I've had no luck with any version using wav, flac, mp3, etc.
Hi guys,
Version 1.0.45 alpha full
set to record in .mp3
No garbled conversations, but you got to have some spare internal memory I guess in order to record flawlessly. Mine is 25MB
Hi there!
New version here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1441643
It seems that a patched kernel is necessary for Wildfire S..
I will test it..
did you try androrec ?
here is it : AndroRec Free Call Recorder
it works for me perfectly... no lag or anything...
Hi!
Does androrec record 2 WAY FROM LINE ?
L.E. - Already tried.. It dowsn't record 2 way from line... It records both ways from mic.. Useless!
helbet said:
Hi!
Does androrec record 2 WAY FROM LINE ?
L.E. - Already tried.. It dowsn't record 2 way from line... It records both ways from mic.. Useless!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you will need to turn on the speaker in order to do a 2-way recording.
Hi,
What custom rom/kernel supports 2 way call recording?
ObiWan_C said:
I think you will need to turn on the speaker in order to do a 2-way recording.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In short, it doesn't work. I use stuff like this to go back when someone tells me number or gives directions .. So it's pretty important for it to work for the incoming voice and in noisy areas.
Sent from my HTC Wildfire S using XDA App
Did you manage to find out a way to record call on both sides using WFS rooted? I have ROM 4.1.2 thunderbolt V2.1.1 and have installed CallRecorder version: 1.4.5. Using Kernel option , voice is distorted from time to time. Can you suggest a way?
I'm pretty sure it needs to be enabled as a kernel module in order for it to function correctly. Have you tried looking at The dev sections kernels? If it's not their you could try to find a how to compile the kernel module and politely ask a kernel dev to see if they can help
Sent from my HTC Sensation XE with Beats Audio Z715e using Tapatalk 2
Has anyone tried either of these app to see if call recording is supported out of the box won't out any kernel mods?
https://market.android.com/details?id=com.skvalex.callrecorder&hl=en
https://market.android.com/details?id=com.dsoft.android.callrecorder
Looks like call supporting is listed.
For Qualcom chips looks like kernel support is needed
http://forums.acsyndicate.net/showthread.php?3051-SGS2-skyrocket-kernel
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1411383
Nice plant!
Call Recorder - Total Recall by Killer Mobile is pretty good.
Extensive UI, and good customer support.
It's in the MP, with a free trial period I believe.
Recordings both sides as clear as a bell.
No kernel mods needed. There is also a Quick Set Up for the SE4GT.
Have never tried the 2 apps in your links though.
TotalRecall
I use TotalRecall and it is awesome.
No bugs.
Ok I tried both in my OP and both work. Thanks guys
I use RecordMyCall
Anyway for:
1. Recording calls directly from line.
2. In-Call background music.
3. In-Call voice change.
May be there's custom kernel's having in-call permission, but which one is stable for these functionalities and if possible how to do that with rooted stock kernel and rom.
Hey is there anybody who can help...?
I found a in-call recorder app but it was paid so does not use that. The in-call voice change is impossible in this phone I guess. I have tried searching it, but does not found any app that can change voice in call!!!
Sent from my GT-S5360 using Tapatalk
Ok you can also use "all call recorder", it's a free app supporting record from both parties... But with this phone the other party voice recording is restricted ... I think we can't record other party voice with the stock kernel (with paid or free recorder). So I asked for custom kernel if any supporting in-call access!
Is our phone incapable of call recording !
A must have feature for a smart phone...
Solution for call recording :
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=24547440
*Not from line but sounds are heard clearly.
I hope you will find in-call voice changing app.
I am also looking for this..
Sent from my GT-S5360 using Tapatalk
[Solved]2 way Call recording and others
[Solved]2-way Call recording and other
wtf do u call this thread "solved" for ?
Removed the solved tag
I mainly targeted on call recording both way.
Now I can record both party sounds.
Though there is no kernel support :banghead: :banghead: :banghead: , can you suggest a stable kernel for this.
And if possible low latency audio processing.
I've been using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex for many years across many devices but it seems like it's no longer working since Pie. Tried a couple others and they're also only recording my side of the conversation only.
Is there anything out there working on non-rooted P?
auto call recorder works perfect. I think call recorder from skvalex works also.
It does not work on Android P.
[KB] Android 9 (P) Call recording issues.
There is no way to record interlocutor's audio properly at the moment. You can use Loud speaker to record both side. All call recording apps will be same., This is not limitation of ACR but Android 9 and the phone.
pato said:
It does not work on Android P.
[KB] Android 9 (P) Call recording issues.
There is no way to record interlocutor's audio properly at the moment. You can use Loud speaker to record both side. All call recording apps will be same., This is not limitation of ACR but Android 9 and the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, that's what I was afraid of.
I hate losing functionality in an update.
megapixle said:
I've been using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex for many years across many devices but it seems like it's no longer working since Pie. Tried a couple others and they're also only recording my side of the conversation only.
Is there anything out there working on non-rooted P?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex on Pie and it works perfectly with root. I don't know if it will work without root though. If you are rooted I will give you what settings that I'm using.
murphyjasonc said:
I'm using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex on Pie and it works perfectly with root. I don't know if it will work without root though. If you are rooted I will give you what settings that I'm using.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you detail what settings your'e using? Because even skvalex himself mentioned Android P doesn't record the other party, only yourself.
tracerit said:
Can you detail what settings your'e using? Because even skvalex himself mentioned Android P doesn't record the other party, only yourself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know if it makes any difference but I'm rooted with magisk version 16.7-1674. That build can be found in the Flash kernel thread. I'm also using Flash kernel 3.0. Everything else is stock. Call recorder 3.0 with root add-on 2.03-1.
Audio source: Caf
Format: Flac
Everything else is basically default. I attached a few screenshots. Here is a link to a recording with me talking to an answering machine I just uploaded to Google drivehttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1eDqtDJzMaZi05l7CdY1fUy8teXm8U4LC/view?usp=drivesdk.
You can hear me talking over it saying hello several times. All my recordings are perfectly clear on both sides.
cube acr works without problems
paulyz said:
cube acr works without problems
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On Pie? Rooted or non-rooted?
megapixle said:
On Pie? Rooted or non-rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pie. non rooted
paulyz said:
Pie. non rooted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doesn't work for me. Same problem as all the other apps, can only hear my side.
"phone recording audio source - voice communication" works for me
Works
ACR on Pie is working fine on my 2 XL, records both sides nice and clear.
Audio Source - Voice_Communication
Recording Format - MP3
Audio Gain - 8DB
HeWhoDaresWins said:
ACR on Pie is working fine on my 2 XL, records both sides nice and clear.
Audio Source - Voice_Communication
Recording Format - MP3
Audio Gain - 8DB
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is recording from phone earpiece speaker with gain. All apps can do that. It is not real call recording
NLLAPPS said:
This is recording from phone earpiece speaker with gain. All apps can do that. It is not real call recording
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm simply telling you my phone model, which app I installed and the settings I used.
It recorded both sides of the call, nice and clear, I am able to hear the entire call.
what part of that is not real call recording?
HeWhoDaresWins said:
I'm simply telling you my phone model, which app I installed and the settings I used.
It recorded both sides of the call, nice and clear, I am able to hear the entire call.
what part of that is not real call recording?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you misunderstood me. It might be acceptable for you or someone else. However,cCall is recorded from the earpiece speaker, gain applied. Real call recording is done by getting audio form Android system not from speaker. Hence, it is not real call recording.
Works perfectly on Pie with Pixel 2 XL rooted!
murphyjasonc said:
I don't know if it makes any difference but I'm rooted with magisk version 16.7-1674. That build can be found in the Flash kernel thread. I'm also using Flash kernel 3.0. Everything else is stock. Call recorder 3.0 with root add-on 2.03-1.
Audio source: Caf
Format: Flac
Everything else is basically default. I attached a few screenshots. Here is a link to a recording with me talking to an answering machine I just uploaded to Google drive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks so much! Was just missing the ROOT module.