[Q] Rattle around camera - AT&T, Rogers, Bell, Telus Samsung Galaxy S III

Is the rattle sound I hear near the camera housing on my S3 normal? Everything seems to be working fine. Just making sure and asking here since this is the only place where I can get real answers.
Thank you all,
AJ

That doesn't sound normal to me... there is no noticeable rattle on either of the Galaxy S III's I have access to. How long have you had the phone for?

kennkcna said:
That doesn't sound normal to me... there is no noticeable rattle on either of the Galaxy S III's I have access to. How long have you had the phone for?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
about 5 months. My old S2 had it too. Someone told me a long time ago that it was the Auto Focus and that it was normal on it.

On my moto photon the lens rattles. If you start the camera app it stops.
Sent from my MB855 using xda premium

So this would be considered normal then? I'm hoping so LOL.

asjdwf said:
about 5 months. My old S2 had it too. Someone told me a long time ago that it was the Auto Focus and that it was normal on it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just double checked, my old Galaxy S II LTE (aka Skyrocket) has a noticeable rattle when you shake it but I'm not hearing it on the S III (perhaps it's more subdued?). A quick Google search however shows that several other people have experienced the same thing and the general consensus seems to be that it's nothing to worry over.

kennkcna said:
I just double checked, my old Galaxy S II LTE (aka Skyrocket) has a noticeable rattle when you shake it but I'm not hearing it on the S III (perhaps it's more subdued?). A quick Google search however shows that several other people have experienced the same thing and the general consensus seems to be that it's nothing to worry over.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I just finished looking too. Thanks all
AJ

Try dropping it a few times see if the rattle will stop
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium

So it comes and goes now. Checked some of my buddies phones and there's don't do it but the att stores s3's all do it. So frustrating. LOL
This plus I can't upgrade to Jellybean because it kills data connection to my phone and battery drain!!
AHHHH
AJ

Send it in if ur not happy,, dosens samsung give u a year manufacturer warranty?
sent from outside ur window

I just shook my phone and heard the power button rattling back and forth. Put you finger on it and it stops.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app

Related

Camera wont focus... Brand new Evo... Not rooted

I bought an evo on release date and it had a few problems so I took it back and got a new one. About 2 hours after I got my new one home I heard it making a really fast clicking/tapping sound. (click click click tap tap tap) I thought the sound was coming from my speaker so I put it up to my ear after a few seconds I looked at the speaker and noticed that it wasnt the speaker but that it was the camera. I could see the lens physically moving back and forth really fast. Naturally I started the camera app to see what would happen. I snapped a picture and noticed that it was very blurry. I then went to camera settings and changed them and its still very blurry. Its almost as if the camera just refused to focus (looked like I needed glasses)... Naturally, the next step I took was to try to record a video... Same thing very blurry but sound is perfect. Next I tried the front facing camera. It was fine.
I have tried re-starting it a bunch of times... tried cleaning the lens...
About 4 or 5 hours later I took another picture and it was fine. Now the problem is intermittent and if I take 10 pictures 3 or 4 will be in focus and the others wont.
1. My phone is not rooted
2. I have not dropped it
3. It has not gotten wet.
4. Babied it the whole time I've had it.
5. Tried turning off auto focus and using manual
Any suggestions?
Take it back.
Sent from my mind using XDA App
Happened with my first EVO take it back
Same thing just happened to me on my Evo that is over a month old. Only happens intermittently though. After a reboot, it seems to be fine for a while.
mine is blurry too. is there any hack for it? im not covered by sprint for this. Maybe deal with htc directly? any ideas hackers?
wht the hell are you not covered by sprint? of course you are covered so take it back.
both of you guys take the damn things back... seriously why are you even here asking for help... the only help you will get is sprint repairing or replacing it
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
wht the hell are you not covered by sprint? of course you are covered so take it back.
both of you guys take the damn things back... seriously why are you even here asking for help... the only help you will get is sprint repairing or replacing it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
dont ask me why just answer the damn questions lol
oh and resets can sometimes cure it for a while I think.
mine has been taking crisp pics all day now
If it's a defective phone and you havent voided the warrenty take it back anyways, it is HTC's warranty not Sprint's
Ive had my evo for almost two years and I installed the cm9 rom for it and the camera was having this problem so I went back to my backup and same problem. It wont focus. It acts like its focusing but just wont. Also I've opened the phone several times so a replacement is out of the question.
Every 004 I've had, had this issue. Unless I use CM7 camera software, or Sense 3 (?) Camera software.
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
Weird. Someone in the Evo LTE forum just had a camera hack completely bust their cam. Even after RUU. I didn't think it was possible. Apparently I'm wrong.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
abowlby said:
Every 004 I've had, had this issue. Unless I use CM7 camera software, or Sense 3 (?) Camera software.
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have cm7. Is there a camera I can flash or something to get it working.
Accidental double post
Tapatalk 2
jimmiekain said:
I bought the original evo 4g from best buy on release day. The camera all day long made a whining mechanical sound as if it was moving in and out. Exchanged it and the 2nd one did the same thing.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Firmly push in on the external camera lense.
This thread....it has came back to life !!!
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium

VZW GNex. Will getting a replacement fix this?

So I'm one of the unfortunate users that has the stupid mic muting issue. I've just been dealing with it and waiting to see if a update from vzw ends up fixing it. Well, it's been five months and still no update. I rooted my phone immediately after the first time I ran into the problem. I'm on the 4.0.4 radio now and it's still there.
So has anybody had luck switching out devices? It sucks because my screen is beautiful and the call muting issue is the only one I have. Should I go through the hassle of getting a replacement?
Edit* crap, can a mod move this to q/a.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Xparent Blue Tapatalk 2
I've never had this issue on my LTE GNex. I don't believe its a common issue. I would definitely get it replaced.
what exactly happens that mutes it, and for how long? does it happen when you are not holding the phone?
reason i ask, is the microphone is a tiny hole on the bottom of the phone, and if you hold the phone like many do, with a finger underneath, even slightly blocking this hole will completely mute the microphone out.
cancerouspete said:
what exactly happens that mutes it, and for how long? does it happen when you are not holding the phone?
reason i ask, is the microphone is a tiny hole on the bottom of the phone, and if you hold the phone like many do, with a finger underneath, even slightly blocking this hole will completely mute the microphone out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To all Verizon Galaxy Nexus users who have no idea what issue we are talking about, read the following:
http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=24019
It basically happens on full signal (with LTE and/or CDMA turned off and on), stationary or moving, under bluetooth + speaker + ear piece while physically holding the phone or not, makes our voice turn into a choppy robotic sound and we can hear them but the other party can't hear me.
Only resolution to this problem is hang up and call again.
There is a huge variation among devices, some has this issue as soon as 5 seconds into a phone call, some have it well into 15 mins or even 40 mins into a call. Some happens basically on every other call, some happens once in a bluemoon.
Yes, we've all tried every single ROMs and radios. And yes, we are not holding it wrong to cover our mic with our finger tips.
And yes, it is not user error because it happened to all 2 new gnex and 2 refurbished replacements STOCK without any apps on it. I got mine to happened on pretty much the entire state of california (I travel very frequently from SoCal to NorCal)
The only reason a few might not face this issue is simply because 1) either they picked the cream of the crop out of all these affected devices 2) not using the GNex as a phone as much as some of us do.
I simply do not use GNex for business purposes...
To OP, getting a replacement might help a little but no promises.
Man I'd have replaced it long ago. I would imagine it's hardware related or they would've pushed an OTA to fix it. I read somewhere that Verizon stated an update would be sent out that would fix it, but I'm not buying it.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Yeah I'm just scared to swap it out and receive one with a ****ty screen. Plus I have a invisible shield on here. And there's no guarantee it will be resolved. Has anyone had any luck with swapping them out? I really don't want to switch to a different phone. I've waited for a nexus device to hit verizon for so long.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Xparent Blue Tapatalk 2
Ya know, honestly, I'm not all that impressed with the phone. I've only had it a couple weeks, but it doesn't do anything better than the Epic 4G Touch that I came from. The E4GT was awesome, the Sprint network, not so much. The camera and battery life were just so much better and I'm struggling with that.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
bangdrum said:
Edit* crap, can a mod move this to q/a.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Xparent Blue Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gotcha Bro
FNM
I just got off the phone with VZW about this very issue. They said they have a release tentatively scheduled for May, but "tentatively" could end up being August. It's a known issue so, there's no workaround for it and getting a replacement probably won't help.
The only thing they could possibly offer is switching to another device altogether. Spec-wise, the Galaxy Nexus is at the top for me so I don't want another phone. (frustration)
Alas, depending on what's important to you, you may just be better off waiting for the update. :-(
blackdiamond01 said:
I just got off the phone with VZW about this very issue. They said they have a release tentatively scheduled for May, but "tentatively" could end up being August. It's a known issue so, there's no workaround for it and getting a replacement probably won't help.
The only thing they could possibly offer is switching to another device altogether. Spec-wise, the Galaxy Nexus is at the top for me so I don't want another phone. (frustration)
Alas, depending on what's important to you, you may just be better off waiting for the update. :-(
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is why I'm glad I asked. I don't want to bother with getting a refurbished phone for nothing.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Xparent Blue Tapatalk 2
I know it's kind of a old thread but wanted to update my experiences.
I am on my second replacement now and I'm sticking with it. I've had the issue maybe 3 times in the month I've had it. My first replacement had a terrible screen, crappy signal, and the muting issue happened just as frequently as before if not more.
I'm assuming this will never be spoken of by Samsung since we've already had the phone almost a year with no acknowledgement. I just hope the next nexus is a different manufacturer (HTC especially) since every Samsung phone I've had has had issues with the actual phone part. My first being the fascinate and now this. Especially since if I want to upgrade from now on ill end up paying full price.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
bangdrum said:
I know it's kind of a old thread but wanted to update my experiences.
I am on my second replacement now and I'm sticking with it. I've had the issue maybe 3 times in the month I've had it. My first replacement had a terrible screen, crappy signal, and the muting issue happened just as frequently as before if not more.
I'm assuming this will never be spoken of by Samsung since we've already had the phone almost a year with no acknowledgement. I just hope the next nexus is a different manufacturer (HTC especially) since every Samsung phone I've had has had issues with the actual phone part. My first being the fascinate and now this. Especially since if I want to upgrade from now on ill end up paying full price.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have had the same problem.
I've gone through 2 replacements and still the same issues have occurred. The update that was supposed to fix this was released in May and it fixed nothing. I called Verizon several times asking what will be done about this. Their answer is that another update will fix this. I frankly don't believe it.
Verizon also told me that Samsung is aware and they're "actively" working on a fix.
Being that I use this phone to make business calls, I can't have a phone that I can't depend on. Their answer: We can give you the RAZR. Not the RAZR Maxx - the RAZR.
I said that won't work because the RAZR doesn't compare to my phone as far as specs go. It's worth 200 less than my phone on their website.
The only phone that compares to mine is the Galaxy S3. Not to mention, I flat-out don't like the RAZR (or the RAZR Maxx). They said they couldn't give me the S3 because the phone was just released.
So, in short, I'm VERY upset with Verizon, because I don't feel like I'm being treated fairly. I'm willing to wait for this so called fix they will push out since my warranty is until December and they claim they'll get it right this time. But if this doesn't work....well, I feel sorry for whichever Customer Rep catches my evil side lol.
Yeah they are gonna get an earful tomorrow when I call. I've had the phone maybe 18 days and it didn't start this until day 11 and ever since its been non stop. I don't think any of us should suffer through calling 10-15 times per 30 minute conversation.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
donnieseech said:
Yeah they are gonna get an earful tomorrow when I call. I've had the phone maybe 18 days and it didn't start this until day 11 and ever since its been non stop. I don't think any of us should suffer through calling 10-15 times per 30 minute conversation.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good luck with that. I'd be interested to know how that works out for ya. Hopefully you'll get a decent answer.
blackdiamond01 said:
I have had the same problem.
I've gone through 2 replacements and still the same issues have occurred. The update that was supposed to fix this was released in May and it fixed nothing. I called Verizon several times asking what will be done about this. Their answer is that another update will fix this. I frankly don't believe it.
Verizon also told me that Samsung is aware and they're "actively" working on a fix.
Being that I use this phone to make business calls, I can't have a phone that I can't depend on. Their answer: We can give you the RAZR. Not the RAZR Maxx - the RAZR.
I said that won't work because the RAZR doesn't compare to my phone as far as specs go. It's worth 200 less than my phone on their website.
The only phone that compares to mine is the Galaxy S3. Not to mention, I flat-out don't like the RAZR (or the RAZR Maxx). They said they couldn't give me the S3 because the phone was just released.
So, in short, I'm VERY upset with Verizon, because I don't feel like I'm being treated fairly. I'm willing to wait for this so called fix they will push out since my warranty is until December and they claim they'll get it right this time. But if this doesn't work....well, I feel sorry for whichever Customer Rep catches my evil side lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exact same story they told me. I'm in my 5th device. 1st one camera broke completely and signal issues. 2nd one screen had a nasty yellow tint on half the screen. 3rd one had the worst screen I had ever seen. I wish I would have taken pictures to show. 4th one was great till the ear speaker completely went out and the speaker broke. 5th one that I currently have has a beautiful screen with no issues so far.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium

[Q] Mic issues on calls, any ideas?

I received a T989 as an insurance replacement for my old T959 Vibrant. I love this phone.
However, it seems that no matter what firmware I run, I have microphone issues. I have tried noise suppression on and off for every rom I have tried.
I have found that if I hold the phone right up to my mouth, it will sound fine for the person on the other end of the call, but by doing this, I have the earpiece further away from my ear, and it is hard for me to hear the other person on the call.
I got lucky a on a few roms where it seemed like the issue went away, but as I updated, it would resurface. Going back to roms that have worked before result in the issue as well. I suppose that if I had it working fine, I should have left it alone, but the call to flash is too great to resist.
While using the speakerphone, the mic works perfectly and picks up what I am saying crystal clear, although my wife sometimes complains of an echo, but that is most likely due to the location of the noise suppression mic on the top of the phone that is so close to the earpiece speaker. Why would the phone mic work great on speakerphone but like crap on normal calls?
Is there a way to increase the sensitivity of the normal mic while using the phone for normal calls? Would it somehow be possible to switch the profile mode of the mic to think it is on speakerphone when it really isn't? Is this more of a hardware issue than a rom/kernel problem?
Should I just call up asurian and ***** about it and have them replace it? I have only had it since the beginning of August, but I think they only give you a 30 day warranty on the replacement that they send out. I really don't want to have to shell out any more cash to replace it again, especially if it is going to cost another $130.
Anyone have any ideas?
Thanks for any and all help.
Nevermind.
It turns out the warranty for the replacement is longer than I thought, so I am getting it exchanged. The only catch is that since it has been over 30 days since the original exchange, there is a $5 warranty fee, but that isn't too bad.
Surprisingly, the rep said that the manufacturer has not listed this issue as a defect...funny, considering there are plenty of people on this board who would disagree.
If you changed your pic, the phone would've worked....
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
born2gethard said:
If you changed your pic, the phone would've worked....
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wow, there aren't not too many okies around here that don't like the Thunder. I'm from chicago and have lived here for 3 years and I like them (even if the Bulls are the team I grew up with). I was spoiled during the Jordan era.
HeavyA said:
wow, there aren't not too many okies around here that don't like the Thunder. I'm from chicago and have lived here for 3 years and I like them (even if the Bulls are the team I grew up with). I was spoiled during the Jordan era.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Weird dude. I was born in elk grove and lived in roselle. Go cubbies!
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
born2gethard said:
Weird dude. I was born in elk grove and lived in roselle. Go cubbies!
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Small world. I grew up in Rockford...yeah yeah, a little further NW than Elk Grove, but still.
And yes, the north side is the only side.
Eamus Catuli
did changing out phone fix this problem? i processed a warranty on my t989 and got another t989. same problem here with new phone now. no mic audio unless speakerphone or headset. wierd thing is it did work a couple times intermittently but now nothing no matter what i do. different roms. nothing.

Loose frame, random reboots, screen issues, camera failure and screen flickers

Hello about a month ago I purchased two of these devices one was for my friend one was for me. Mine had a loose frame that when you would push slightly on the bezel near the volume button you can hear it goin in and creaking as if it was not solid. I compared to the other device I bought and with other s4s and it felt more solid than mine so I changed for another. My girlfriends on the other hand lives in New York and she bought one on her own terms from a store I purchased mine through online. My exchanged device came in and with a purple tint on bottom half.of screen its slight and noticeable on grey backgrounds while brightness is low. My phone also randomly rebooted once and has had multiple camera failures..it seems to have gone away tho for me. On the other hand my girlfriend has now exchanged her phone once because it was rebooting constantly and having other problems and now the phone that they gave her for a replacement has tons of random reboots while doing pretty much anything it's very random I have been on the phone with her and it suddenly rebooted on her causing our call to end. She is also complaining about camera failure and reboots aren't seeming to fix it.. As it comes back and anytime she switches to front camera..so pretty much all of our devices have issues and even the exchanged ones do too. And they were purchased in diff states and one in store the other online. I have had every galaxy phone since the s2 including the note series and I have never experienced so many problems out of the box and I was an early adopter for all the other devices. I converted my girlfriend from the iPhone to this phone and now all she is having problems and is getting frustrated because she says that she's been in important calls and her phone has just rebooted for no reason amongst other problem she is facing. Her first device didn't have the camera failure and neither did my first device but now both of our exchange devices are giving us, failures.. Not really sure what to do I'm already out of buyers remorse I feel like calling to mobile to get yet another one but not sure if it will give it to me.. I'm a huge fan of samsung galaxy 9 but this phone has more issues than I thought and they are real issues this isnt just lag were complaining about or that thephone isnt quick enough or something dumb these are real problems. while on my vacation I had to deal with random camera failures..my gf with tons of reboots and camera fails.. These are issues that now make you go out of your way for the phone instead of the phone making itself go out of the way for yourself. It's honestly unacceptable.. So I want to know how many people with the T Mobile version: have experienced any of this. Take off the battery of the phone and just press around the plastic frame and see if you hear any pops like mine did.. Or has anybody had continuous camera failure whether resolved or not has it happened.. Random reboots to? I am aware that a new kernel or rom could fix this problem but my girlfriend lives in New York and she doesn't have the time to do this or knowledge and really shouldn't have to. So it's been at least four of these devices that have had issues from purple tint to loose frame to reboot to camera failure...really disappointing. Will T-Mobile send me a new one even out of buyers remorse?? I love this phone and so does my girl but we like using our cameras everyday and can't deal with these other apparent issues...what to do?
O forgot to mention that the phone flickers the screen while hit by Sunlight.. While keyboard is up and in white backgrounds as well as using the camera.. Screen looks like its blinking really fast..I know this issue is in ALL s4s but thought I'd throw it in to another set of problems... This one I can deal with though..reboots and camera failure?? Can't deal with that
These issues I've experienced personally and I'm speaking of my experiences only I don't make up stuff or use other members issues to add to mine. Those issues are present for me and my girl and we have now exchanged our phones twice.. We would be getting our 3rd s4 if we exchange again.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app
Insurance??
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda premium
I don't have any.. But either way I shouldn't have to use insurance for this is how it is out of the box.. No root no mods just purely stock..
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app
I was going to say return it and get a new one I think you just have a defective device I had one I returned new one is perfect.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda premium
xxjrsmith3xx said:
I was going to say return it and get a new one I think you just have a defective device I had one I returned new one is perfect.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah t Mobile is going to send me a new one now my third s4
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app
But this has happened on all of my devices so I'm starting to think that it's an issue with everyone because I didn't get any of these problems till about 3 weeks into having the phone and I haven't dropped it or anything not even flashing rooting
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app

HELP: Ghost Menu

Hey guys so I'm having an issue with a phone, it used to happen once in a blue moon, but now it's happening all the time to the point the phone is almost unusable. It acts as if menu keys are being pressed, when I'm not even touching the phone! This video is a great example, someone has to have seen this. What's the fix?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JdsrgVJM9k
Galaxy Epic SGII - SPH-D710 JellyBean 4.1.2 GB27
nim6us said:
Hey guys so I'm having an issue with a phone, it used to happen once in a blue moon, but now it's happening all the time to the point the phone is almost unusable. It acts as if menu keys are being pressed, when I'm not even touching the phone! This video is a great example, someone has to have seen this. What's the fix?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JdsrgVJM9k
Galaxy Epic SGII - SPH-D710 JellyBean 4.1.2 GB27
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I've read it happens in low signal areas. Here's a thread that may be helpful.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=23032612
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 2
There is a way to disable the menu key and use the search key as menu. It's somewhere in the general forums buried somewhere.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 4
Dypraxxx said:
There is a way to disable the menu key and use the search key as menu. It's somewhere in the general forums buried somewhere.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes here it is
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=39466458
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 2
Oh you guys are awesome.. big thanks for suggesting it, and then finding it
Dypraxxx said:
There is a way to disable the menu key and use the search key as menu. It's somewhere in the general forums buried somewhere.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used that fix for a while, but over time, the problem actually gets worse and the search key will start phantom pressing, too. If you're one of the unlucky E4GT owners who have this problem, eventually ALL the capacitive buttons start randomly phantom pressing. Just a heads up from experience.
I suggest running a custom ROM with a Navbar (softkeys) you can enable, and then disable all the hardware buttons.
sasokutenshin said:
I used that fix for a while, but over time, the problem actually gets worse and the search key will start phantom pressing, too. If you're one of the unlucky E4GT owners who have this problem, eventually ALL the capacitive buttons start randomly phantom pressing. Just a heads up from experience.
I suggest running a custom ROM with a Navbar (softkeys) you can enable, and then disable all the hardware buttons.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No need for a custom ROM. I have a tutorial for any rooted TW JB build using multiple ways to get it done.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2201012
Sent from my SGH-I337 using xda premium
This is how I fixed my fantom menu button, maybe not a good idea but I was tired no to be able to use my phone, so far no problems at all, I opened my phone and placed a piece of magnet sticker on top of a connector that goes to the bottom of the phone, the the piece of magnet is from a business card that I had on the front of my refrigerator so I cut a little piece of it and put it on top of the connector with the plastic side to the connector to make sure not to touch anything, here are some pictures of what i did, if you want to do it (it is on you) , I am just giving my results so far 3 weeks with no problems.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
jc.m said:
This is how I fixed my fantom menu button, maybe not a good idea but I was tired no to be able to use my phone, so far no problems at all, I opened my phone and placed a piece of magnet sticker on top of a connector that goes to the bottom of the phone, the the piece of magnet is from a business card that I had on the front of my refrigerator so I cut a little piece of it and put it on top of the connector with the plastic side to the connector to make sure not to touch anything, here are some pictures of what i did, if you want to do it (it is on you) , I am just giving my results so far 3 weeks with no problems.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not experiencing the issue but for the record, does it affect the button presses in any way after placing the magnetic piece there? Does all 4 of the hardware keys work without any hiccups?
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Everything works normal, just like new, I did removed the magnet and the menu bottom gets crazy so I did place it back and works like it should. I know it is no something that people should do but I did not care about my phone anymore.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
I can also back you up that this works!!!! Thanks sooo much works sooo much better!! Never woulda thought of it on my own. But did you notice any kind of signal issues after you did this
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
1 month and no fantom menu, signal is normal.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
still going?
jc.m said:
1 month and no fantom menu, signal is normal.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How is this working out still? I was contemplating doing it with a piece of rf shielding but that would've short circuited everything:laugh: That is totally genius on your part!
I loaded a custom ROM on mines and went back to EL26 modem (check my latest post to see the logic behind it)
If this works it's good for those who don't want to go the route I did :good:
I can say my problem with the Ghost menu is completely gone, and I totally forgot I had it.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
jc.m said:
I can say my problem with the Ghost menu is completely gone, and I totally forgot I had it.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, I added your solution to my post and thanked you. I hope more people will benefit from your findings :good:
jc.m said:
This is how I fixed my fantom menu button, maybe not a good idea but I was tired no to be able to use my phone, so far no problems at all, I opened my phone and placed a piece of magnet sticker on top of a connector that goes to the bottom of the phone, the the piece of magnet is from a business card that I had on the front of my refrigerator so I cut a little piece of it and put it on top of the connector with the plastic side to the connector to make sure not to touch anything, here are some pictures of what i did, if you want to do it (it is on you) , I am just giving my results so far 3 weeks with no problems.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you confirm that this fix is still working?? There is a guy on Youtube that does a similar fix but he removes the motherboard and sandwiches in some aluminum foil where you have the magnet on this side. I like your fix a lot more since it is obviously a lot easier. Please let us know if this fix is still working. Thanks!
CentralVAHere said:
Can you confirm that this fix is still working?? There is a guy on Youtube that does a similar fix but he removes the motherboard and sandwiches in some aluminum foil where you have the magnet on this side. I like your fix a lot more since it is obviously a lot easier. Please let us know if this fix is still working. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I cannot. I believe the symptoms manifests in low signal environments, with the mobile network running. Turn off mobile data to test.
Some swear by it, but I lack the knowledge to validate it, as I am not an electrical engineer.
Much of this comes down to your tolerance for pain. I just bought the Note 3 due to this exact issue. Others have returned their phones because of it. Some replacements end up with this same problem, or busted power buttons.
If you have the desire to keep your phone and the ability to try the fix, then back up everything on it, and execute the procedure; or find someone who can.
Other options are turning off mobile networks whenever possible, trying to get a replacement, or...
Get another phone. The used marketplace is teaming with good deals on S3s, use an upgrade, get a granny phone. You have choice.
I hope that some of this is helpful.
Good luck!
Sent from my SM-N900P using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
The only REAL fix that I was able to get is sending it back to Sammy and they replaced the PBA(motherboard). This is after sending it back to them two other times and they replaced the LCD screen and mini-jack. I just got it back and gave it to my wife when I got the S3, and immediately she said that in 3g areas it did the phantom menu. After calling and telling them two returns is unacceptable, they expedited the repair, fixed the RIGHT thing this time, and in over a month, there's been zero issues. Not sure if this is an option for anyone as you may be out of warranty, just passing on what finally worked for me. Good luck.
I have had this issue, non-stop, for the past year. It has gotten worse so I contacted samsung and sent my D710 to them to have it repaired.
They replaced the screen, sent it back but immediately (while trying to activate with Sprint) my phone began the phantom menu button. Not only the menu, but I also get phantom search & back key presses. I sent the phone back to samsung, again, and this time they replaced the PBA and still, i have the phantom issue. I called samsung but wont send the phone back a 3rd time. So I visit the sprint store after finding these threads, and the sprint tech replaces my screen again (free of charge) and before I even start my car to leave the parking lot... phantom key presses all over again.
I am convinced there is no fix for this, other than a hardware hack. I tried the magnet trick you guys speak of, but it did not change a single thing. I can trigger the phantom key press by simply sending (or receiving) a text message. It makes it near impossible to have a text-conversation with anybody.
My last resort is to sell the phone on ebay or craigslist to some unsuspecting fool, and replace it with a HTC or some other brand who actually understand RF interference and how stupid it would be to place the 3G antenna anywhere near such a sensitive chip.
Jared King said:
I can also back you up that this works!!!! Thanks sooo much works sooo much better!! Never woulda thought of it on my own. But did you notice any kind of signal issues after you did this
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So Jared is your "fix" still working???

Categories

Resources