Tablet advice. - AT&T, Rogers, Bell, Telus Samsung Galaxy S III

So I cracked my Transformer Prime's screen and I think it knocked the camera loose as well. I was wondering what you would do in my situation. I'm leaning towards selling it and the keyboard dock as is for 250 starting bid on eBay and going for a 16gb Nexus 7. Then again the 10.1 Note is around the corner and would be outstanding for class. I also figured the Nexus 7 wouldn't have a terrible resale value if we see the 10.1 Note or perhaps a 10.1 Nexus tablet. I really like Sammy and wouldn't mind switching to their tablet line. Thoughts?
sent from the next best thing

I see nexus 7 as a separate class from regular tablets, its a really cool 200 tablet for fun and games though I doubt I'll ever use it for serious note taking or textbook reading like I do with my iPad. That's why for now I'm keeping my iPad and n7. Though the note looks amazing for note taking so once that comes out I might even sell my iPad for it .
So that's why I say if you can keep a full sized tablet for serious work and just buy n7 for play and light browsing. The n7 is cheap enough that it actually seems feasible to have possibly the note and n7 in your case.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium

Think I'm going to have to get a Nexus 7 till I see the note or Nexus 10. I can't believe I cracked my screen. thanks for the input.
sent from the next best thing

jerrygooch said:
Think I'm going to have to get a Nexus 7 till I see the note or Nexus 10. I can't believe I cracked my screen. thanks for the input.
sent from the next best thing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds good ,that's what I would do if I was in your situation and yeah that sucks. Can't you warranty it possibly?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium

unleashed12 said:
Sounds good ,that's what I would do if I was in your situation and yeah that sucks. Can't you warranty it possibly?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Out of warranty unfortunately. :-/
sent from the next best thing

I'm still holding off on the tablets. The nexus 7 almost got me to jump and I think I would have if they had included a sd card slot for more storage. I'm not a big cloud person for media I have on a hard drive and with storage prices what they are its a stupid decision.

As a transformer user I would say check out the tf300t or the infinity tf700 since u are already familiar with Asus. I would switch to a galaxy tab if they had a foldable keyboard doc exactly like Asus. But the keyboard is the main selling point for me.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2

Aridon said:
I'm still holding off on the tablets. The nexus 7 almost got me to jump and I think I would have if they had included a sd card slot for more storage. I'm not a big cloud person for media I have on a hard drive and with storage prices what they are its a stupid decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's my one major issue. Granted i only add a few games and essential apps as well as tons of books. All my music is on Google music and I'm rarely without internet. Idk seems like Google is really pushing to do away with expandable storage.
cavsoldier19d said:
As a transformer user I would say check out the tf300t or the infinity tf700 since u are already familiar with Asus. I would switch to a galaxy tab if they had a foldable keyboard doc exactly like Asus. But the keyboard is the main selling point for me.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I think I may keep with the transformer line. I just have to generate some cash. My problem with the Prime was GPS (not a major concern), really weak WiFi, and terrible (really bad) disk I/O speeds. I know the tf300 and tf700 fixed the WiFi and GPS.. but I really don't want to suffer with such bad read/write speeds. The whole system locked up when I install an app. Even with custom kernels to try and fix the issue.
sent from the next best thing

jerrygooch said:
Yeah, I think I may keep with the transformer line. I just have to generate some cash. My problem with the Prime was GPS (not a major concern), really weak WiFi, and terrible (really bad) disk I/O speeds. I know the tf300 and tf700 fixed the WiFi and GPS.. but I really don't want to suffer with such bad read/write speeds. The whole system locked up when I install an app. Even with custom kernels to try and fix the issue.
sent from the next best thing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can personally vouch for the tf300. No WiFi or GPS issues. Its been working great so far. But keep in mind that the 300 is the value model that gets u the best bang for your buck. Its not a high end model like the tf700 is supposed to be. My only major complaint about the 300 is that asus provides an app that unlocks the boot loader for u so u can flash custom ROMs. The downside is that the app sends your serial no. to asus and then permanently voids your warranty. So far all efforts to defeat this has failed because the process is ridiculously complex and encrypted. You can root without voiding your warranty though.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2

cavsoldier19d said:
I can personally vouch for the tf300. No WiFi or GPS issues. Its been working great so far. But keep in mind that the 300 is the value model that gets u the best bang for your buck. Its not a high end model like the tf700 is supposed to be. My only major complaint about the 300 is that asus provides an app that unlocks the boot loader for u so u can flash custom ROMs. The downside is that the app sends your serial no. to asus and then permanently voids your warranty. So far all efforts to defeat this has failed because the process is ridiculously complex and encrypted. You can root without voiding your warranty though.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How are the I/O speeds? The prime had horrible lag when downloading an app or anything else that required lots of reading and writing.
sent from the next best thing

jerrygooch said:
How are the I/O speeds? The prime had horrible lag when downloading an app or anything else that required lots of reading and writing.
sent from the next best thing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seems to be fine to me. No noticeable I/o issues. The 300 does have the new quad core tegra 3 processor and upgraded ram type. So it can certainly perform better than the prime.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2

Related

Too late to buy this?

I'm considering buying the Nexus now that it is 400 dollars but I'm not sure if I should wait for the next best phone. Suggestions?
Edit: I'm concerned that I will get a phone that has banding issues/purple tint. I've read a ton of threads about this issue and it is concerning.
Hattricked said:
I'm considering buying the Nexus now that it is 400 dollars but I'm not sure if I should wait for the next best phone. Suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A lot of us here will tell you that the next best phone won't happen until the next nexus and none of us know when that'll be as there hasn't been any formal announcement.
I've got my galaxy nexus a little less than a month ago and I have no regrets.
You could pretty safely buy this for $399 and hold onto it for the next Nexus. The resale price won't be much lower. Or just hold onto the GNex why not.
Got my nexus 4 days ago, and I'm really glad i chose this phone. Haven't experienced any lag yet, and I have been running the most heavy 3D games available for android.. so you should definitely not be concerned about performance.
It's also easy to root, there's lots of development going on, it has a big super amoled hd display etc.. this phone will also be getting android jellybean when it's released.
Yes, there is several phones getting higher scores than the nexus in benchmarks, but performance-wise, there's actually not many areas where this phone could be improved. I don't really see the need of quad-core cpu's yet.
So, yea... I totally recommend you this phone!
edit: If camera is one of the most important things you're looking for in a smartphone, this phone's probably not for you... personally I take like 2-10 pictures a week .. so I really don't care about the cam..
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
It really depends on what you use the phone for. Do you watch movies more than you take pictures? Do you use the speaker to listen to music? That's just two of many factors you have to look at. Do you root and flash roms? Overall this phone is a good device should you over for some time. I for one get tired of phones and have to change every 5-6 months. I love the gnex but I think the camera and speaker volume could be better.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
ddgarcia05 said:
It really depends on what you use the phone for. Do you watch movies more than you take pictures? Do you use the speaker to listen to music? That's just two of many factors you have to look at. Do you root and flash roms? Overall this phone is a good device should you over for some time. I for one get tired of phones and have to change every 5-6 months. I love the gnex but I think the camera and speaker volume could be better.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The speaker problem can be fixed with apps like Volume+, after installed it my speaker is quite loud. But the camera is really a concern.
I recommend this phone for almost everyone, the only exception is if you really need a good camera on the phone. This camera is average at best.
That said, I would buy this phone again today. The One X is really a temptation, but I know that being an Android geek that loves updated software I would regret to buy a not Nexus device. Did this 2 times and it was a pain in the ass, now I just buy phones from the Nexus line.
I am kind of in the same boat, lol. I just got the HTC One S, tho. I would like to switch to verizon for coverage reasons, but there seem to be issues with the 4G/3G connections. I played with one at the verizon store by my apartment, and it had a lot of issues. And I have read about the problems with data dropping, which it seemed to be doing at the store. I also love the loudness and clarity of the speaker on my one s. The one s camera has some fun things to it, tho. However I generally turn the pixel size down to under 5M anyway. Good luck with your decision. Maybe I will get the HSPA+ one and sell whichever one I don't like later.
I think I would miss having the MicroSD slot (even though I don't really use it). I don't have LTE in my area so that isn't really an issue for me. I'm slightly nervous about the display. I've read a lot about the banding issue that a lot of people have as well as the purple tint that others have. The prospect of fast updates sounds good (still waiting for ICS for my skyrocket...) but I'm not sure how much I really want the nexus.
The next best android phone comes out way too frequently. I personally wouldn't use this as a deciding factor. Do you like the gnex or not? Does it have features that will satisfy you? Does it have the community support that you want or need?
Day 2 with the Nexus. Only issue I have found is the signal. Love it besides that!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
indyred99 said:
Day 2 with the Nexus. Only issue I have found is the signal. Love it besides that!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just curious, are you using AT&T or T-Mobile?
Hattricked said:
Just curious, are you using AT&T or T-Mobile?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Verizon.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Just got my Sprint Nexus on Sunday and so far I'm psyched about it. I wanted a sexy looking device along with performance and the SG3/EVO LTE didn't have the look factor I wanted. I can sacrifice .2 ghz of a processor and don't find the camera all that bad on the Nexus. Plus Sprint was giving me 70 bucks for my Evo and 50 bucks through Google Wallet. So technically, after all is said and done, I'd pay $70 for the Nexus.
Sold my HTC inspire for $250 Bought my Nexus for 200 I made 50 bucks
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
indyred99 said:
Day 2 with the Nexus. Only issue I have found is the signal. Love it besides that!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Upgrade to the newest radios and see if that helps.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Hattricked said:
I'm considering buying the Nexus now that it is 400 dollars but I'm not sure if I should wait for the next best phone. Suggestions?
Edit: I'm concerned that I will get a phone that has banding issues/purple tint. I've read a ton of threads about this issue and it is concerning.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
honastly you cannot go wrong with this phone, I love the freedom that it has provided to me with being a pentaband phone. You will always be waiting for the next best phone. Unless your looking forward to all the graphicly intense games in the pipline for tegra 3.
But if your a normal user IE social networking, email, music streaming, and casual gaming. This phone should not disappoint, look at it this way.
if your picking this up now, for cheap I can only imagine what next years nexus will be priced at around this time next year.
Droid316 said:
Upgrade to the newest radios and see if that helps.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will try that soon. I have been reading up on how to root/unlock this phone. Came from the revolution and got this phone as a replacement after 4 revos.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
A nexus always has the latest OS and the Galaxy Nexus has few bugs... You really can't beat this device. The HTC One X is a bit better, but it will always be on par or behind on upgrades. So, if you upgrade every year, sure wait.... If you upgrade every 2, then go with Nexus, it'll take longer for it to feel like an old device due to quicker software updates.
I bought mine a week ago. No regrets. I spent a year on Windows Phone and couldn't have asked for a better way to cone back to Android.
I'd heard some complaints about they camera, but mine is very good. I do have the international version. No blurriness or off colors.
The phone is fast. Nothing else to say about it. No lagging or stuttering, fast app switching, beautiful screen. I noticed pixels on the Galaxy S Pentile display, but this one is beautiful.
Oh yea, I've left the phone stock. I'm sure I'll mod it in the future, but right now I haven't found a reason to. It runs exactly how I want it to.
I say buy the phone.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
If the price 400..take it!
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2

[Off Topic] I trust this communities opinion on this....

So I have went to the pages where this is more directed to but I want an unbiased opinion and who else should I ask.... YOU GUYS! I've had my epic 4g touch for a while now and am thinking of getting a tablet of some sort. I've watched damn near every review video on The asus TF700, samsung galaxy note 10.1, sony xphia s, yada yada yada.. I basically want to know which 9-10 inch tablet you would get and why. Anything to help me not go crazy... cause right now Im on the verge... The asus has a lot of quality issues, but has the best display, the note is just not what I need as far as stylus and productivity goes... I just want a good media consumption device that is good quality, fast, good picture and will last. future proof if you will. Any help is much appreciated.
So on that note... what do you guys think about the sony xperia tablet S?
RussellEstridge25 said:
So I have went to the pages where this is more directed to but I want an unbiased opinion and who else should I ask.... YOU GUYS! I've had my epic 4g touch for a while now and am thinking of getting a tablet of some sort. I've watched damn near every review video on The asus TF700, samsung galaxy note 10.1, sony xphia s, yada yada yada.. I basically want to know which 9-10 inch tablet you would get and why. Anything to help me not go crazy... cause right now Im on the verge... The asus has a lot of quality issues, but has the best display, the note is just not what I need as far as stylus and productivity goes... I just want a good media consumption device that is good quality, fast, good picture and will last. future proof if you will. Any help is much appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I've heard, the best 9-10 inch tablet is the Asus TF Infinity which is the TF700.
I've heard that the note is plagued with issues but I've never heard of the TF700 having them. I know the TF201 has issues with Wifi and GPS but not the TF700 that I know of...
I got an acer iconia a500, yeah, its a bit older now but just about every port you could want is on it, its easy to root, and its a workhorse, got mine on craigslist in the box for $180
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
I would go with the tf700 infinity, even though I took mine back after wanting to upgrade from my Nexus 7. I don't understand how people use such a big tablet I have a laptop for everything my tablet won't do. Anyway its a great tablet though and it's getting Jelly Bean like right now, and it's pretty much stock Android no touchwiz or anything if you prefer straight up Android. I just researched this all and the infinity came out on top for me, or you could wait till the holidays and see what comes out. But that's you can always say that with tech.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
I have the galaxy tab 2 and of i would buy another it would be the asus everyone else is talking about. Grant it i love my gt but it lags here and there and just little hiccups.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda app-developers app
I appreciate your input guys, I also was interested in the asus TF700 but have heard there are some quality issues... maybe you can confirm. I have heard there is a problem with some of the sceens becoming un-flush and squeaking in some spots, coming loose or something, light bleeding, dust getting under them, there is one review from mobiletech on youtube comparing the asus TF700 and the samsung galaxy note 10.1 and the asus all of a sudden got some lines through the middle of the screen right through the photo she was showing. And its was about 2-3 months old. So my worry is after time or after the warranty is up, something like that will happen and i'll be F'd.
So on that note... what do you guys think about the sony xperia tablet S?
Media consumption, fast reliable I only can think of Asus Nexus 7 its 7" but what the hell...
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk v.2.4
Crazy as it may sound, I'm waiting to see how windows 8 tablets turn out. If I can slap a keyboard on a tablet and run ms office, I'm sold.
Otherwise, the a500 due to the price and rom availability.
Sent from my SPH-D710
IPad anyone..?
Lol.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using XDA
coiledwire said:
Crazy as it may sound, I'm waiting to see how windows 8 tablets turn out. If I can slap a keyboard on a tablet and run ms office, I'm sold.
Otherwise, the a500 due to the price and rom availability.
Sent from my SPH-D710
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dude. It's an amazing experience. Been fortunate enough to have a couple different windows 8 slates and a surface in my possession for a couple weeks now. Seriously freaking awesome. I've been an android guy for years but do not think I will buy another android tablet (phones are another story, will not switch for the foreseeable future) after rocking this windows setup.
My fav thing to do with the more powerful slates is to install steam on them, load up all my games, then plug in an xbox controller and play games on an airplane... Boredom = never now.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
^^^ that's what I'm talking about! Lucky to have a preview of these slates, must be nice.
Sent from my SPH-D710
Oh no, trouble in paradise!
http://www.engadget.com/2012/09/29/modbook-pro-to-launch-with-ssd-storage-up-for-pre-order-october/

I don't get why people think of selling there SIII for the nexus 4

I don't understand why people will sell there galaxy S III for the nexus 4. Galaxy S III comes with a with micro sd slot, bigger display, better front facing camera, and LTE.
I understand that the LG nexus is a nexus phone and always get update faster, wireless charging, and quad core. But I don't think it still outweighs the SIII. I think the SIII is still superior.
For those people that don't have either phone yes it be more difficult to choose mainly because the Nexus 4 Price is amazing for what it offers. but for those people with SIII how is this even debatable.
Is there something im missing?
much better processor. hspa+ 42meg compatible. no bloatware. possibly a better screen. wireless charging. I think you pretty much answered your own question. lol. not having lte isnt a huge deal breaker for me since I am near wifi almost always. Tradeoff is the 4 will probably have outstanding battery life. 16 gig is enough storage for me.
The fact that the nexus 4 doesn't have lte is a deal breaker for me. I didn't think lte was a huge thing until it finally came to me are, and now there is no way I would ever consider a phone without it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda app-developers app
iceman4357 said:
much better processor. hspa+ 42meg compatible. no bloatware. possibly a better screen. wireless charging. I think you pretty much answered your own question. lol. not having lte isnt a huge deal breaker for me since I am near wifi almost always. Tradeoff is the 4 will probably have outstanding battery life. 16 gig is enough storage for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CPU is a quad core which is nice I agree but most the stuff on android don't utilize it, so its pretty pointless until later. No bloatware, we can already use custom roms or titanium to get rid of it. Not sure what to say about the screen I never seen it personally not going to judge it either. Wireless charging is cool I guess, but I doubt it charges faster then a direct connection. We can toggle off LTE and get pretty amazing battery life with the SIII both devices are both the same size battery. I agree16 gb is enough for me, but I like the fact that the SIII allows us to add more storage if we ever choose to. Maybe its because its new and its over hyped, i must admit at first I was like I want it. But I really thought about it and I realize its not worth it.
yamahakid said:
The fact that the nexus 4 doesn't have lte is a deal breaker for me. I didn't think lte was a huge thing until it finally came to me are, and now there is no way I would ever consider a phone without it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats how I feel.
LTE is great. Those that say its "not ready for prime time yet" must not have it in their area or haven't tried it yet. I'd love to get the N4 but 21mbps HSPA on ATT in San Diego nets me all of 1mbps down and that's a no go. If its 42 mbps then maybe.
sent from my Dark PA Nexus
yamahakid said:
The fact that the nexus 4 doesn't have lte is a deal breaker for me. I didn't think lte was a huge thing until it finally came to me are, and now there is no way I would ever consider a phone without it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 no Lte no way,16gb no where near enough space for me, shoot my 32gb sd card is almost full, no bloat not even an issue can be easily removed with titanium backup, my s3 dual core/2gb ram loads everything just fine, in my opinion I have yet to see another android manufactures phone screen that looks better than the s3, I have a nexus 7 and screen looks washed out compared to my s3, only other phone worth considering selling s3 for right now is the note 2 if you can deal with the size.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
The nexus 4 is nice and all, but it doesn't really do anything the s3 can't . And with the dev support we have here, we really don't need to wait for updates.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda premium
If I wasn't getting the note 2 tomorrow, I'd be on the nexus 4, such a good price
Sent from my JellyBean Galaxys3
The fact that it is an lg phone should be plenty enough to keep me and it gets away. No thx
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
3 main reasons I wont switch to a Nexus 4
1- I need 32g minimum
2- Its made by LG
3- Glass on the the back ? WTF ! I hate scratches.
Well it's a quad core.
Nexus line means direct support. First to get updates. Maybe I don't have to flash roms to get better battery life. Stock Android look.
Beautiful design. Cheap price. Don't use lte that much.
Better screen than s3
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
expertzero1 said:
Well it's a quad core.
Nexus line means direct support. First to get updates. Maybe I don't have to flash roms to get better battery life. Stock Android look.
Beautiful design. Cheap price. Don't use lte that much.
Better screen than s3
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol. First to get updates always makes me laugh. Hours after source is released which is when the nexus line gets their updates I have ROMs released for whatever device I own. So I guess in a way I'm first to get updates too.
1.) Its made by LG. That says enough I would think. I can most here all the complaints a month or two after releases about this not working, this is broken, etc..
2.) Better screen? Not sure how you can state this unless youve personally held the phone in your hand. Spec sheets arent always as they seem . Just remember which company is known for producing the best screens out there.
3.) It really all boils down to personal preference either way. But I'm sure we've all learned that newer isn't always better.
The only reason I'm considering it is because of the price. I would love the freedom of being eligible for an upgrade because att will bend over backwards to keep you. Before I upgraded to the gs3 I was considering moving to Verizon and att pretty much gave me $50 off my bill for the next 6 months and sold me the gs3 for $99.
But without a micro SD card I don't see no need to switch
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
thirsty1258 said:
The fact that it is an lg phone should be plenty enough to keep me and it gets away. No thx
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This...
I'm sure it is a great device, I don't think Google would sully the nexus name with a bad piece of hardware, but the reputation that lg has is not the best in the game.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using xda app-developers app
I'd have to agree with the few that have noted LG - enough said. They have never been the brand I look to for phone tech - Samsung, HTC and Motorola are the only ones to consider.. The few LGs I've used/played with have been less than impressive.
Addition: Google has stated that they are releasing multiple Nexus devices, so if I were to give up my S3, I'd wait for the next Motorola or Samsung device.
I find it silly that people would sell their GS3 for this Nexus 4. No extra storage, no removable battery, no lte, no thanks.
It's great for anyone that doesn't live under LTE coverage and can't get out of their contract/don't want to upgrade and sign another contract.
I also find it funny that these same people who are praising the Nexus 4 are the same ones that knock the iphone (remember when the 4s came out?) Heavy on the fact that it doesn't have a removable battery, no expandable storage and no LTE. All of a sudden it's cool now? Get out of here...
Lg has crappy software support but with this being a nexus that's no longer an issue. Samsung is taking forever just to release 4.1.1 do y'all realistically see Samsung pushing out 4.2 this year? Even then we would wait for att also. There's not doubt that the phone will get this update eventually with cyanogen.
+1 on no chance of getting it because it doesn't have micro sd or removable battery. I could probably handle the battery, but not the lack of micro sd.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
I would be willing to go out on a limb and give LG a try for a Nexus device but...no removable SD is a complete deal breaker for me. Cloud storage is not a good substitute for local storage yet. And 8GB or 16GB just isn't cutting it anymore. I hope the SGS4 has a 32 & 64 GB version with removable storage. I love my 50GB dropbox (thank you Samsung) but it just isn't the same as direct attached storage.
task650 said:
2.) Better screen? Not sure how you can state this unless youve personally held the phone in your hand. Spec sheets arent always as they seem . Just remember which company is known for producing the best screens out there.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Technologically, it is pretty much undeniable that the screen is better. It can't produce as much vibrancy, but it is so much better on color preciseness. I don't notice it that much on my S3, but when I stick it next to a relative's One X it's pretty obvious that the whites aren't white and some other colors are slightly off as well. In day to day use, I don't care. But, seriously... dat screen...

N4 vs GS3 vs Note 2

Have the GS3. I love it. Best phone I've ever had. I'm getting the itch though. I was seriously considering N4. Reviews dont seem to be as positive as I hoped, particularly from those coming from GS3. Which made me look at the Note 2. I love that phone. But is it too big? I don't think it is but I also have the N7, so do I even need the bigger screen? I rarely use my GS3 for anything other than phone calls and texts. Am I wasting my money? I'm thinking I am...but not sure. Anyone else considering either of these phones?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
IMO it's either the s3 or note2. The nexus only has 16 gb of storage with no chance of increasing, has a fragile back that will crack if dropped, and is made by lg which hasn't made many great phones. The camera is only average and also has a halo haze and its not that much faster in real world tests. As for the note, only you can decide if its too big, other than that its actually a little better than the s3.
I've pretty much ruled out the N4 at this point. I'm going to check out the Note 2 tomorrow. If I get the note would that replace my N7? Enough to give me an excuse for getting N10??
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
kingston73 said:
IMO it's either the s3 or note2. The nexus only has 16 gb of storage with no chance of increasing, has a fragile back that will crack if dropped, and is made by lg which hasn't made many great phones. The camera is only average and also has a halo haze and its not that much faster in real world tests. As for the note, only you can decide if its too big, other than that its actually a little better than the s3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't wanna start a flame war and I'm not trying to diss you but I'm just curious as to were you've been getting your info from. From all the people that have gotten the phone I haven't heard them say anything of what you just posted.
From all the reviews I have read, they say it's very smooth, the camera is very good, but not as good as the S3. The back is fragile but not as fragile as people seem to believe. The hardware is very good even though its by LG (it's pretty much an Optimus G) which is a very good phone by the way.
Oh yeah and the screen on that is much better than the S3. I believe the NOTE 2 has the same screen type as the S3 (correct me if I'm wrong)
The only thing that I really see as a downside is the damn storage. I just can't believe Google thinks that 16gb is enough now days. Even though there is the cloud, carriers restrict you on data.
Overall if you just use your phone for text and call I would go with the N4, since storage isn't a priority for you. I'm sure everyone prefers the pure Google experience with timely updates. Plus it's cheap without a contract.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
You bring up some valid points...especially that I'm only using my phone for calls and texts...N4 would be perfect for that. Pure Google...would love that. I guess I was hoping I'd use my phone for a little more. Hence Note 2. As far as the screen, I hear the AMOLED is too saturated with "fake" color. I love that screen to be honest. Fake colors or not, i think they are beautiful. I've yet to see N4 in person...or Note 2. Tomorrow I'm going to the T-Mobile store..hopefully they have both. Note 2 and GS3 both have AMOLED screens.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
I'm actually getting ready to switch to a Note 2 on Verizon as soon as it comes out. I love my S3, but I really want that huge screen, and extra battery life.
I've been with T Mobile for over 10 years, and their customer service is great, but I really want more reliable and consistent coverage. I'm actually rolling the dice on not being able to flash custom ROMs(or just having limited development) in exchange for a better network and LTE.
There's no way I would go with an N4, and that's only because of the 16 gigs of storage. I have a 16 gig S3 and had a 16 gig external SD card, and I still ended up having to upgrade to a 64 gig card. But if your not big into music, movies or games, then you probably don't have to worry about that.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
Why would custom ROMS be limited? Is it Verizon or the Note 2 in general?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
Warrior1975 said:
Why would custom ROMS be limited? Is it Verizon or the Note 2 in general?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I heard VZW has locked bootloader and possibly hasn't been unlocked yet, could be wrong though
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
N4 is a great device in my opinion. I love the vanilla Android and assurance of updates.
However, a lack of a removable battery and expandable storage is a big grippe to me. I like having the option to increase my storage capacities.
If you're worried about the size of the Note II, simply pick one up at the T-Mobile store or anywhere they would carry one. It's definitely a large device, it felt kind of awkward to me, but then again so did the GS3 when I first got it.
The N4 has the best price to performance ratio of any phone out there today, I believe.
That's a huge sweet spot to me.
I think that you'd be happy either way. All of these phones are great and should last you a while.
Warrior1975 said:
Why would custom ROMS be limited? Is it Verizon or the Note 2 in general?
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Locked bootloader and even if it gets unlocked, my understanding is that there is less development on Verizon LTE phones. Might just have to do some research on porting my own ROM's, but I really think I could get used to running TW and just using a different launcher. Once we get root, we can at least do a few mods and use root apps.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
I like the note 2, its a very nice phone very fast, my coworker bought it and he loves it, I wish the s3 had the quad core processor like the euro did, that would make it even better. I kinda feel as if I got a gs2 with a bigger screen. If all you are going to do is calls and text then the note 2 is overdoing it. I would stick with the s3. I love the phone and can't wait to see what's next from samsung.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
I presume you have the money to upgrade. But let be honest, the N4 and Note 2 is not that different in term of overall quality compare to S3. I think you should wait till summer or so since by then something beastly and different will come out.
TJEclipse said:
I like the note 2, its a very nice phone very fast, my coworker bought it and he loves it, I wish the s3 had the quad core processor like the euro did, that would make it even better. I kinda feel as if I got a gs2 with a bigger screen. If all you are going to do is calls and text then the note 2 is overdoing it. I would stick with the s3. I love the phone and can't wait to see what's next from samsung.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct me if I'm wrong but very few apps take advantage of dual core processing at the moment (let alone quad core) and the 2 cores on the US version are pretty fast (faster IIRC 1 for 1).
Hell tons of applications still come out for Windows that aren't multithreaded and multicore/multiprocessor systems have been around for many years now.
hardware wise
note 2>s3>n4
reality wise
s3>note 2>n4

[Q] Galaxy Nexus usability - personal

Hello. I'm planning to get a Galaxy Nexus and I'm wondering if it will suit my needs. What I want to do with it is make it my sole communication and social hub with some productivity tools running in the background.
What I would be doing:
Running apps in the background - Adobe reader, Dictionary, Evernote, MX Player, Currents
- I would be occasionally switching between these apps but I would just like them to run in the background
Frequent app switching - Go SMS, Tweetcaster, Flipboard, FB, Google+, KakaoTalk, Email
Do you think the 1.2 GHz dual core and 1 GB RAM of the Gnex would be sufficient for my needs?
I don't have any intention of rooting it. I also am not planning to get a Nexus 4 after all the scary problems that I discovered with it on the web.
Appreciate your replies. Thanks.
sepisepsep said:
Hello. I'm planning to get a Galaxy Nexus and I'm wondering if it will suit my needs. What I want to do with it is make it my sole communication and social hub with some productivity tools running in the background.
What I would be doing:
Running apps in the background - Adobe reader, Dictionary, Evernote, MX Player, Currents
- I would be occasionally switching between these apps but I would just like them to run in the background
Frequent app switching - Go SMS, Tweetcaster, Flipboard, FB, Google+, KakaoTalk, Email
Do you think the 1.2 GHz dual core and 1 GB RAM of the Gnex would be sufficient for my needs?
I don't have any intention of rooting it. I also am not planning to get a Nexus 4 after all the scary problems that I discovered with it on the web.
Appreciate your replies. Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am not sure what's your intention to keep them all running in the background.
When there is not enough memory, i feel like some apps that are running in the background automatically hibernate. So it takes about similar time to open if you don't run them in the background.
It's only a matter of a second or two as long as they run smoothly, though loading news in Currents is usually not so fast.
I would say galaxy nexus will do the job.
Well, if you're planning to keep the phone longer, I'd suggest something with 2gb of RAM, like an N4. Now if the money is the issue, GN will suffice.
Dixonism said:
I am not sure what's your intention to keep them all running in the background.
When there is not enough memory, i feel like some apps that are running in the background automatically hibernate. So it takes about similar time to open if you don't run them in the background.
It's only a matter of a second or two as long as they run smoothly, though loading news in Currents is usually not so fast.
I would say galaxy nexus will do the job.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just want to save those apps' states. It's like I just want them all minimized all the time.
madd0g said:
Well, if you're planning to keep the phone longer, I'd suggest something with 2gb of RAM, like an N4. Now if the money is the issue, GN will suffice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I love the specs of the N4 but the problems that I found on the internet (auto-reboot, touch accuracy, etc.) are what's holding me back.
This is more a Dev phone. If you don't plan on rooting and unlocking then perhaps you should look into other devices.
If you plan on doing all of what you said on this phone be sure to get an extended battery
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
sepisepsep said:
I love the specs of the N4 but the problems that I found on the internet (auto-reboot, touch accuracy, etc.) are what's holding me back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know 2 people with n4s and haven't heard such complaints, maybe it was the initial 4.2 release jankyness.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
You say you have no intention of rooting. If you did you could install a custom such as xylon and flash a kernel such as ak kernel and your nexus would be a powerhouse. You could also by an extended battery for about 25 dollars to get all day battery life.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Now if the money is the issue, GN will suffice.
namtombout said:
This is more a Dev phone. If you don't plan on rooting and unlocking then perhaps you should look into other devices.
If you plan on doing all of what you said on this phone be sure to get an extended battery
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know it's a dev phone but owning a Nexus S, I just think that the idea of "unskinned" android in Nexus devices really made a difference in the phone's performance.
madd0g said:
I know 2 people with n4s and haven't heard such complaints, maybe it was the initial 4.2 release jankyness.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. Hm. Now that makes me think about the N4 again. What do you think of the N4's viability?
ayo234 said:
You say you have no intention of rooting. If you did you could install a custom such as xylon and flash a kernel such as ak kernel and your nexus would be a powerhouse. You could also by an extended battery for about 25 dollars to get all day battery life.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also don't know how to flash roms because I'm kind of afraid of the instabilities of those. But if you could recommend one that's really stable just like the stock android, then I could learn how to flash and go for that. The reason why I'm worried about it's instability is because I'll be using the phone for both personal and business use.
hufqnjhu said:
Now if the money is the issue, GN will suffice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a "semi" issue.
I bought my wife an N4 and she has had zero issues. It's been running smooth for over a month and a half. It's a nice upgrade over the Gnex. Bigger battery, nice screen, better camera. I would say that if you can afford it, get it. Have you checked the N4 forum to see what people are saying?
Saying all that, I still like the Gnex a lot. I was using an HTC One S, but when I bought my wife the N4 I thought I'd give it a shot. It can do all the things you are planning. I did have some lag on stock, so decided to flash a few different Roms. Running the latest Paranoid Android and it's super smooth.
This was the easiest phone to unlock ever, as a Nexus should be.
Goodluck with your decision.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
About N4s viability : well its a Nexus :]
Android has come so far that even if you won't play with custom stuff or even root, you'll still have a quick, good experience and best software upgradability out there.
As for the money thing, I've bought the GN 2nd hand without any signs of usage for 280€ in December. If I wanted a N4 back then it would have been about 400 (if not a bit higher because of the lack of supply). 120€ minimal price difference wasn't worth it for me, I tend to switch phones yearly (sell one, get newer one 2nd hand when it looses it's max value drop).
No idea what your price on buying the GN is, so I can't really say anything, hope my experience can give you a bit of perspective.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
I too would strongly urge you to rethink the N4 if it's in the budget. Stock vs. Stock, it's a better device than the Gnex, in my honest opinion. Play with one in person, and own it, so YOU can be the best judge of what you're getting. However, if you do decide on the Gnex, stock 4.2 runs very nicely on it (I have the Sprint Version, so 4.2.1.) and I don't think you'll be disappointed, but the N4 will definitely have more longevity than our beloved Gnex. Good luck with either decision you make!
npiper05 said:
I bought my wife an N4 and she has had zero issues. It's been running smooth for over a month and a half. It's a nice upgrade over the Gnex. Bigger battery, nice screen, better camera. I would say that if you can afford it, get it. Have you checked the N4 forum to see what people are saying?
Saying all that, I still like the Gnex a lot. I was using an HTC One S, but when I bought my wife the N4 I thought I'd give it a shot. It can do all the things you are planning. I did have some lag on stock, so decided to flash a few different Roms. Running the latest Paranoid Android and it's super smooth.
This was the easiest phone to unlock ever, as a Nexus should be.
Goodluck with your decision.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just checked the N4 forum and it scared me even more upon reading the post about its screen of death issue. What kind of lag did you experienced with it? It is just on the interface, apps, or app switching? I'm more concerned here about app/task switching from time to time.
madd0g said:
About N4s viability : well its a Nexus :]
Android has come so far that even if you won't play with custom stuff or even root, you'll still have a quick, good experience and best software upgradability out there.
As for the money thing, I've bought the GN 2nd hand without any signs of usage for 280€ in December. If I wanted a N4 back then it would have been about 400 (if not a bit higher because of the lack of supply). 120€ minimal price difference wasn't worth it for me, I tend to switch phones yearly (sell one, get newer one 2nd hand when it looses it's max value drop).
No idea what your price on buying the GN is, so I can't really say anything, hope my experience can give you a bit of perspective.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you experience any issues with it?
jxr94 said:
I too would strongly urge you to rethink the N4 if it's in the budget. Stock vs. Stock, it's a better device than the Gnex, in my honest opinion. Play with one in person, and own it, so YOU can be the best judge of what you're getting. However, if you do decide on the Gnex, stock 4.2 runs very nicely on it (I have the Sprint Version, so 4.2.1.) and I don't think you'll be disappointed, but the N4 will definitely have more longevity than our beloved Gnex. Good luck with either decision you make!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually played with one alongside with the Gnex and I can't really tell the speed's difference in terms of their interface.
sepisepsep said:
I just checked the N4 forum and it scared me even more upon reading the post about its screen of death issue. What kind of lag did you experienced with it? It is just on the interface, apps, or app switching? I'm more concerned here about app/task switching from time to time.
No lag with the N4, sorry. I meant I had some lag with my GNex running 4.2.2. My wife has never had any lag on her N4.
At the end of the day, you can't go wrong with either. I love the GNex, even though it's a bit long in the tooth. All depends on preference.
Good luck.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There sod on every device. Including the iPhone
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
While the g'nex is still a solid device I'd also recommend N4. As for issues scaring you, keep in mind that the g'nex was also plauged with reported issues. Display problems, loose USB ports, failing hardware buttons, ect...
A friend of mine bought a N4 second hand a couple months ago and hasn't had any problems, while I haven't had any problems with my g'nex.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
npiper05 said:
sepisepsep said:
No lag with the N4, sorry. I meant I had some lag with my GNex running 4.2.2. My wife has never had any lag on her N4.
At the end of the day, you can't go wrong with either. I love the GNex, even though it's a bit long in the tooth. All depends on preference.
Good luck.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean what lag did you experience with the GNex.
ayo234 said:
There sod on every device. Including the iPhone
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry but haven't experienced any SoD's with all of my owned devices (galaxy tab, galaxy s, nexus s)
95Z28 said:
While the g'nex is still a solid device I'd also recommend N4. As for issues scaring you, keep in mind that the g'nex was also plauged with reported issues. Display problems, loose USB ports, failing hardware buttons, ect...
A friend of mine bought a N4 second hand a couple months ago and hasn't had any problems, while I haven't had any problems with my g'nex.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. Now that ironically gave me a sense of comfort. Guess those are just really some type of quality issues, huh?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you'll go to Galaxy forums, you'll see tons of problems there, but that doesn't mean every device is flawed. If you sell millions of phones, of course the error rate will be more apparent, specially if it's popular. Same goes for Nexus, buyers of those phones are more aware and they visit sites like xda, so it appears the issues are widespread.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
I had just a little lag scrolling between home screens when I was on stock 4.2.2. No issues switching between applications or anything.
I rooted a couple weeks ago and have been running the latest Paranoid Android. Great battery life and zero lag.
Let us know what you decide. I definitely recommend unlocking and running a custom Rom if you get the Gnex.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
madd0g said:
If you'll go to Galaxy forums, you'll see tons of problems there, but that doesn't mean every device is flawed. If you sell millions of phones, of course the error rate will be more apparent, specially if it's popular. Same goes for Nexus, buyers of those phones are more aware and they visit sites like xda, so it appears the issues are widespread.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I see that but the only reason why I think it's that really widespread is due to the fact that even if you just google N4 problems compared to GNex problems, N4 really does show up a number of it.
npiper05 said:
I had just a little lag scrolling between home screens when I was on stock 4.2.2. No issues switching between applications or anything.
I rooted a couple weeks ago and have been running the latest Paranoid Android. Great battery life and zero lag.
Let us know what you decide. I definitely recommend unlocking and running a custom Rom if you get the Gnex.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With regards to switching apps, on a daily basis, I heard that the GNex sometimes reload the app instead of "restoring the minimized state" of the app. Any experiences?

Categories

Resources