Ok first off I'm not good with drawing up papers or writing letters, but I think that its bull**** that the CDMA variant of the GN has been dropped by AOSP due to the closed source of some of the drivers I am guessing is used for the LTE radio that since I'm on Sprint I'm not even able to turn on yet anyway. Also isn't this what some of you developers bought the phone for? Or I should say isn't this what you want. I just dont think its fair for Sprint/Verizon to sell a developer phone with closed source software I think that this phone should be supported or maybe we the consumer should be a little more mindful on what we financially support from our carriers and Google. If I dont have all of my facts together on this please enlighten me so I can get it together, but if you feel like I do lets get something in the carriers and Googles hands about this.
Who do you plan on petitioning?
By the way, CDMA is closed source and Google has no license to redistribute the binaries.
Good luck. CDMA is Qualcomm's baby, heavily patented and strictly licensed.
Exactly, who do you plan to petition? Google can't make the CDMA parts open-source, it's not their fault.
martonikaj said:
Exactly, who do you plan to petition? Google can't make the CDMA parts open-source, it's not their fault.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On a side note and to be fair, GSM parts are closed source too. Google just has a license to redistribute.
In reality it doesn't matter all that much. It's a developer phone and the support behind it is endless on that end. As long as google releases the images for GSM and the developers can use the source as a base for the roms on our phones I don't see it as a major concern. The only thing we really rely on verizon for are the radio updates which can be pulled from verizon's updates and installed via recovery anyway. I could be wrong but my rom is based on the GSM 404 image and it works great and I don't think they'll update it for the verizon 404 since the only big difference seems to be the radios.
yeah I get that my thing is that we can be heard if we make some noise but thats what I was getting at I was wanting to learn more about why support stopped and maybe is it a possiblity of getting something going to start a petition. I dont want to take Qualcomm's baby I just want to be able to baby sit every now and then?
utcu said:
In reality it doesn't matter all that much. It's a developer phone and the support behind it is endless on that end. As long as google releases the images for GSM and the developers can use the source from that to port it to our phones I don't see it as a major concern. The only thing we really rely on verizon for are the radio updates which can be pulled from verizon's updates and installed via recovery anyway. I could be wrong but my rom is based on the GSM 404 image and it works great and I don't think they'll update it for the verizon 404 since the only big difference seems to be the radios.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Er...we don't port GSM anything to Verizon.
adrynalyne said:
Er...we don't port GSM anything to Verizon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You know what I meant. lol. As long as they have the GSM image to use as a base for the rom. I'll edit my post to make more sense.
jakdillard said:
yeah I get that my thing is that we can be heard if we make some noise but thats what I was getting at I was wanting to learn more about why support stopped and maybe is it a possiblity of getting something going to start a petition. I dont want to take Qualcomm's baby I just want to be able to baby sit every now and then?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Support didn't stop. Google still provides the factory images. In reality, nothing has changed. Being in AOSP doesn't mean updates still won't have to be approved. Even ROM developers haven't been stopped from creating ROMs. I'm not sure what you expect will change if they reversed their decision.
utcu said:
You know what I meant. lol. As long as they have the GSM image to use as a base for the rom. I'll edit my post to make more sense.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know of any dev doing such a thing. They build from AOSP.
You see, the cdma code is still there. Just the proprietaries are not complete.
bozzykid said:
Support didn't stop. Google still provides the factory images. In reality, nothing has changed. Being in AOSP doesn't mean updates still won't have to be approved. Even ROM developers haven't been stopped from creating ROMs. I'm not sure what you expect will change if they reversed their decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I say support I mean building from source I'm know they will continue to update the phone its just that now I actually like android since ICS and want to develop for it more but I just hate limitations ..... the last time I fooled with a 'droid phone it was the EVO 4G and it made me hate android and roll with a IPhone4 but fruity phones are boring and hyped up.
Why does it matter? We can build Sprint from AOSP.
adrynalyne said:
Why does it matter? We can build Sprint from AOSP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can we .... ? didn't know that please go on .....
The code is there. You just have to flesh out the device tree yourself, and create your own vendor with proprietaries pulled from your device.
jakdillard said:
Can we .... ? didn't know that please go on .....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can pull the closed source drivers strait from the phone and build cm9 ,aosp, aokp whatever you want
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
adrynalyne said:
The code is there. You just have to flesh out the device tree yourself, and create your own vendor with proprietaries pulled from your device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok. Let's try to explain this differently. AOSP for the CDMA Nexus exists. You can pull it, compile it, etc...HOWEVER certain "binaries" (drivers,blobs, radios. Call them what you please.) Aren't included. This isn't a problem. We have most of these anyway. They are included in OTA's and factory images. Google is no longer providing factory images so we have to pull them out of OTAs or use older ones. There really is no issue here and I'm certain Google is fighting for this to change.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Google is still providing factory images for the CDMA Nexus devices. They released factory images for the Sprint Nexus S about a month ago and I'm sure we will continue seeing factory images for Verizon as OTAs are released. The only one you won't see factory images for is the Sprint Galaxy Nexus since that firmware is created, managed and updated by Samsung, not Google.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Smokeey said:
Ok. Let's try to explain this differently. AOSP for the CDMA Nexus exists. You can pull it, compile it, etc...HOWEVER certain "binaries" (drivers,blobs, radios. Call them what you please.) Aren't included. This isn't a problem. We have most of these anyway. They are included in OTA's and factory images. Google is no longer providing factory images so we have to pull them out of OTAs or use older ones. There really is no issue here and I'm certain Google is fighting for this to change.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK I like this explanation better
oldblue910 said:
Google is still providing factory images for the CDMA Nexus devices. They released factory images for the Sprint Nexus S about a month ago and I'm sure we will continue seeing factory images for Verizon as OTAs are released. The only one you won't see factory images for is the Sprint Galaxy Nexus since that firmware is created, managed and updated by Samsung, not Google.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you sure that the updates are distributed by samsung for the sprint galaxy nexus. Could of sworn it was google who did that.......?
Related
http://www.droid-life.com/2012/02/0...ons-lte-galaxy-nexus-to-be-a-developer-phone/
I'm not sure whether this is legit...or whether its just a mistake..LETS HOPE ITS JUST A MISTAKE OK GUISE?
Seriously though, we've been through enough with this phone
Yeah fingers crossed this isn't true...
Sent from my Gummy Nexus
If this is true, I'm going to be seriously pissed. I gave up an unlimited data plan at AT&T to get the GN because I wanted a phone that should be future-proof with respect to OS updates for 18-24 months.
I'm still within my 14 days with Verizon. I hope we get this straightened out before my return period is up...
Seems pretty clear. It's a bit too official in too many places consistently to be a "mistake".
Verizon pushed them too far, and took away too many things for Google to consider it a Nexus reference platform.
---------- Post added at 12:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 PM ----------
ssmug said:
If this is true, I'm going to be seriously pissed. I gave up an unlimited data plan at AT&T to get the GN because I wanted a phone that should be future-proof with respect to OS updates for 18-24 months.
I'm still within my 14 days with Verizon. I hope we get this straightened out before my return period is up...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You could've kept your unlimited plan and bought unlocked GSM... Verizon wasn't your only option lol.
Seriously, this is a lot of uproar about nothing IMO.
The page stating CDMA devices aren't supported is for building AOSP builds for target devices. It has nothing to do with OTA updates.
You'll notice another Nexus CDMA device missing, the Nexus S 4G. Guess where it gets its updates from and always has (it's not Sprint)?
krohnjw said:
Seriously, this is a lot of uproar about nothing IMO.
The page stating CDMA devices aren't supported is for building AOSP builds for target devices. It has nothing to do with OTA updates.
You'll notice another Nexus CDMA device missing, the Nexus S 4G. Guess where it gets its updates from and always has (it's not Sprint)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm new to Android phones (but not tablets), so I don't know exactly what those listing mean, but I sure hope you're right!
ssmug said:
I'm new to Android phones (but not tablets), so I don't know exactly what those listing mean, but I sure hope you're right!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are merely targets you can pass in when building a a ROM from AOSP source that configures the source for that target device automatically and the accompanying instructions for flashing the rom you've build (From source) to that device. Along with this are the required vendor binaries (blobs) to place in the build directory for the closed source libraries for specific hardware for each device.
The sensational headline does grab attention, but that page has never had anything to do with updates.
I think even if Google drops support there will be lots of mods like cyanogen.
DonXoB said:
I think even if Google drops support there will be lots of mods like cyanogen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Forgive me if this is a naive question, but would they be able to update the OS from the GSM updates?
I think Google means to pull the LTE radios, it seems like VZW to be concerned about those being OS'ed for security reason...hmmm
martonikaj said:
You could've kept your unlimited plan and bought unlocked GSM... Verizon wasn't your only option lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is what I did. Best $700 I've ever spent!
krohnjw said:
They are merely targets you can pass in when building a a ROM from AOSP source that configures the source for that target device automatically and the accompanying instructions for flashing the rom you've build (From source) to that device. Along with this are the required vendor binaries (blobs) to place in the build directory for the closed source libraries for specific hardware for each device.
The sensational headline does grab attention, but that page has never had anything to do with updates.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that's worse. So there won't be devs aosp built on this phone anymore ?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Verizon must have really pissed off Google.
martonikaj said:
You could've kept your unlimited plan and bought unlocked GSM... Verizon wasn't your only option lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I knew someone would say that! I don't use that much data (although I'm not in an LTE area, but I am near one), and if I did have LTE, I don't really stream or tether, so it wouldn't be too big a deal. (And my company gets a 25% discount at Verizon and 5 GB for the price of 2 GB.)
Still hurt to leave it, especially since I got the GN specifically for what I thought would be guaranteed OS support...
I still have until Tuesday to return it and go back, though...
Hi all. I just got my GNex from Verizon. I've heard things about this phone on the CDMA side being abandoned by devs. Is this true? If so, should I get a different phone (I still have 9 days to take it back)? I'm coming from a DX, so I love hacking and flashing.. If this phone is still a keeper...can someone point me in the right direction to a thread for rooting and ROMs and flashing (oh my!)?
Thanks all
-Path
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Where did you hear that this phone was being abandoned?!
Keep it, you will be glad you did.
It is not being abandoned, Google is just dropping official support for it. That's it.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Miscellaneous posts from people lol
I thought it was odd considering I bought this phone because it was known for being hackable..
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Here is a thread to get you started for unlocking and rooting...
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1400871
Check out this forum for all kinds of ROMs.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=1455
joshnichols189 said:
It is not being abandoned, Google is just dropping official support for it. That's it.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Google just dropped it as a developer phone. the updates will still be rolling out.Google stated that clearly. the update might take a bit longer than the GSM nexus..but v will still get it....
trust me the nexus will see updates quicker than anybody.
the nexus will see official version 5.0 android os... None of the Droid line ups will see official android 5.0 version on them..trust me
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
PathologyX said:
Hi all. I just got my GNex from Verizon. I've heard things about this phone on the CDMA side being abandoned by devs. Is this true? If so, should I get a different phone (I still have 9 days to take it back)? ...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Take it back. Get the GSM version. Get anything else.
CDMA is pretty **** to begin with, but Google has admitted that AOSP Android cannot fully support CDMA. You cannot use the Android source to create a working CDMA build without proprietary blobs, delivered by Google, if the carrier permits it.
Google's support for CDMA depends on carriers permitting it. On a Nexus device.
Think about that.
You wont find any shennigance like that in the GSM world because the system is not ass-****ed enough to begin with to allow such carrier-control. GSM is open. GSM is the freedom you want.
Yes. Like the poeople here will tell you: For now the CDMA devs can hack a release together just fine. They can give you a working ROM based on hacking blobs and Android source. But no, but there are no guarantees it will remain that way. One day, you might be out of luck.
The CDMA/Verizon Galaxy Nexus is a carrier-neutered Nexus. It's not the real goods. And it never was. Think about the months delayed release, because a carrier had objections to what Google put on a "clean" developer phone.
The result is carrier bloatware, and Android features like tethering removed.
The CDMA/Verizon Nexus: It's not what you want. It wasn't when it was announced, and with AOSP support taken back, it definitely isn't now.
Just return that POS and get anything else. I've had non-Nexus phones miles more open than the "Verizon Nexus". It's a joke. It's the laughing-stock of the internet.
I have to have Verizon though :\
Where I live, GSM carriers (ATT is really the only one) get horrid service..
So, knowing that, what's your opinion?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Keep it...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
PathologyX said:
I have to have Verizon though :\
Where I live, GSM carriers (ATT is really the only one) get horrid service..
So, knowing that, what's your opinion?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Please don't listen to this guy he has been trolling these boards for a couple days now, makes me wonder if the mods are on vacation
(Last part of that was a joke/sarcasm of course)
Verizon is just as hackable, you will have no shortage of ROM's for at least a year or year and a half.
Okay, good to know
Thanks for all of your help/suggestions (minus the troll.. gtfo)
I'll keep it then ;D
Now let's see if I can hack this one worse than my DX xD doubtful
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
josteink said:
Take it back. Get the GSM version. Get anything else.
CDMA is pretty **** to begin with, but Google has admitted that AOSP Android cannot fully support CDMA. You cannot use the Android source to create a working CDMA build without proprietary blobs, delivered by Google, if the carrier permits it.
Google's support for CDMA depends on carriers permitting it. On a Nexus device.
Think about that.
You wont find any shennigance like that in the GSM world because the system is not ass-****ed enough to begin with to allow such carrier-control. GSM is open. GSM is the freedom you want.
Yes. Like the poeople here will tell you: For now the CDMA devs can hack a release together just fine. They can give you a working ROM based on hacking blobs and Android source. But no, but there are no guarantees it will remain that way. One day, you might be out of luck.
The CDMA/Verizon Galaxy Nexus is a carrier-neutered Nexus. It's not the real goods. And it never was. Think about the months delayed release, because a carrier had objections to what Google put on a "clean" developer phone.
The result is carrier bloatware, and Android features like tethering removed.
The CDMA/Verizon Nexus: It's not what you want. It wasn't when it was announced, and with AOSP support taken back, it definitely isn't now.
Just return that POS and get anything else. I've had non-Nexus phones miles more open than the "Verizon Nexus". It's a joke. It's the laughing-stock of the internet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Claiming misinformation as fact - check
Trolls numerous CDMA GN threads - check
Listen, bud, the *only* things missing are the blobs, which can be extracted, no need for any hacking ATM, by users.
The fact that you need to result to swearing just goes to show how juvenile you really are.
Bloatware? Two apps? Hardly a big deal unless it is you trying to make a point by drastic exaggeration. Those on these boards who have the phone are running ROMs that doesn't include them so it is opt-in.
Tethering removed? That is just an outright fabrication by you.
Enjoy your GSM and let the OP enjoy twice the storage capacity of your phone and four times the transfer speed of yours.
mutelight said:
Claiming misinformation as fact - check
Trolls numerous CDMA GN threads - check
Listen, bud, the *only* things missing are the blobs, which can be extracted, no need for any hacking ATM, by users.
The fact that you need to result to swearing just goes to show how juvenile you really are.
Bloatware? Two apps? Hardly a big deal unless it is you trying to make a point by drastic exaggeration. Those on these boards who have the phone are running ROMs that doesn't include them so it is opt-in.
Tethering removed? That is just an outright fabrication by you.
Enjoy your GSM and let the OP enjoy twice the storage capacity of your phone and four times the transfer speed of yours.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Funny thing is, on ICS the bloatware can be "Disabled" which is basically the same thing as freezing the app in TiBu which also removes it from your app drawer and stops it from running, essentially removing it from your phone.
Oh and I think what he means in terms of tether is that you have to pay to use it, which is the same with any other carrier just with the CDMA model it is pre built in that it is blocked.
Either way this guy is just an obvious troll.
Me a troll? Come on. Sorry for spreading the good word of freedom around the Nexus forums then.
If anyone should be called a troll at this point it should be Verizon. So far they've completely butchered the Nexus program, and nobody is even pointing a finger at them.
Good job. Really. I'd be surprised to see Google even bother with a non-standard carrier anytime again, if the Nexus program isn't sabotaged enough to be dead by then.
I'll piss off. Enjoy your carrier-approved, carrier-branded Nexus.
---------- Post added at 10:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:00 PM ----------
miketoasty said:
Oh and I think what he means in terms of tether is that you have to pay to use it, which is the same with any other carrier just with the CDMA model it is pre built in that it is blocked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On all carriers I have had, I pay for data. How I use it is entirely up to me. Tethering is a phone-level function and not anything the carrier can or should control.
And least of all disable or strip free, built-in tethering from the phone. Jesus christ that is invasive to the point of being illegal where I live.
Sorry. There is a free market out there, and there **** like this is not accepted. I thought people buying Nexus-devices would be aware of things like that.
I guess that defines a troll around here, being European.
josteink said:
Me a troll? Come on. Sorry for spreading the good word of freedom around the Nexus forums then.
If anyone should be called a troll at this point it should be Verizon. So far they've completely butchered the Nexus program, and nobody is even pointing a finger at them.
Good job. Really. I'd be surprised to see Google even bother with a non-standard carrier anytime again, if the Nexus program isn't sabotaged enough to be dead by then.
I'll piss off. Enjoy your carrier-approved, carrier-branded Nexus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What did Verizon do in all this mess other than put their name on the back and put some (Removable) bloatware on the phone?
You don't back up your points at all but whine about how terrible this phone is, obvious troll is obvious.
miketoasty said:
What did Verizon do in all this mess other than put their name on the back and put some (Removable) bloatware on the phone?
You don't back up your points at all but whine about how terrible this phone is, obvious troll is obvious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They stripped the built in, free Android-tethering and replaced it with a for-pay service?
In the rest of the world, you'd return the phone over a defect like that.
josteink said:
On all carriers I have had, I pay for data. How I use it is entirely up to me. Tethering is a phone-level function and not anything the carrier can or should control.
And least of all disable or strip free, built-in tethering from the phone. Jesus christ that is invasive to the point of being illegal where I live.
Sorry. There is a free market out there, and there **** like this is not accepted. I thought people buying Nexus-devices would be aware of things like that.
I guess that defines a troll around here, being European.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are free to use data as you wish, as it is pre defined in your agreement you make with the carrier when you use their network. Verizon has tethering in their contract as a paid service. I understand it may be different where you live but here in the states that's just how it is.
The tethering is usable once you enable a tethering plan to your account so why would they remove it?
Yes there is a free market out there but there are also contracts we sign so we can use these phones, and like I said it may be different around here than it is out there.
Enjoy your phone and we will continue to live in our idiotic bliss.
---------- Post added at 04:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:08 PM ----------
josteink said:
They stripped the built in, free Android-tethering and replaced it with a for-pay service?
In the rest of the world, you'd return the phone over a defect like that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Read above post, and they stripped nothing, just added a message (If you don't pay for the service) that you need to pay for it before you use it.
josteink said:
They stripped the built in, free Android-tethering and replaced it with a for-pay service?
In the rest of the world, you'd return the phone over a defect like that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you don't have the technical knowledge, then don't speak of what you do not know.
They stripped nothing. They have a provisioning apk in place for legit users. Its easily bypassed and we leave it out of aosp.
josteink said:
Take it back. Get the GSM version. Get anything else.
CDMA is pretty **** to begin with, but Google has admitted that AOSP Android cannot fully support CDMA. You cannot use the Android source to create a working CDMA build without proprietary blobs, delivered by Google, if the carrier permits it.
Google's support for CDMA depends on carriers permitting it. On a Nexus device.
Think about that.
You wont find any shennigance like that in the GSM world because the system is not ass-****ed enough to begin with to allow such carrier-control. GSM is open. GSM is the freedom you want.
Yes. Like the poeople here will tell you: For now the CDMA devs can hack a release together just fine. They can give you a working ROM based on hacking blobs and Android source. But no, but there are no guarantees it will remain that way. One day, you might be out of luck.
The CDMA/Verizon Galaxy Nexus is a carrier-neutered Nexus. It's not the real goods. And it never was. Think about the months delayed release, because a carrier had objections to what Google put on a "clean" developer phone.
The result is carrier bloatware, and Android features like tethering removed.
The CDMA/Verizon Nexus: It's not what you want. It wasn't when it was announced, and with AOSP support taken back, it definitely isn't now.
Just return that POS and get anything else. I've had non-Nexus phones miles more open than the "Verizon Nexus". It's a joke. It's the laughing-stock of the internet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
u mad
......
josteink said:
... It's the laughing-stock of the internet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd return it asap.. who'd ever want to be the laughing stock of the internet!?
Google, I hope you're reading/listening to this:
It kind of irritates me that I bought this phone for the "Pure Google Experience" only to find out its not really that "True" experience with all these different regional builds.
People are on 4.0.2 for over a month now I believe, yet we Canadian users, as well as many others across the world are still on 4.0.1 and have been duped into believing the "Galaxy Nexus" is a true Google device. Well, it is, but it isn't at the same time. My yakjuux build from what I hear is updated from Samsung, not by you, and that irritates me.
Sure, I can flip over to yakju myself, but really, why should I have to do that??a
I mean is it so hard for Google to do, what the likes of Microsoft has been doing for many, many years? That is make one build, let's call it base yakju, then through the initial install process, ask the user what region/carrier/language/radio he/she has and have the unit download the "region packs" accordingly??
The dreaded Microsoft doesn't sell 15 different "regional versions" of Windows, its the exact same build, but with language packs that are set up after the initial install process.
That way everyone gets an update at the same time, in this case, by you Google not by Samsung, as it is believed is happening with my phone (although unconfirmed because we haven't received an update yet!)
Anyway, there are many that will say you can do it yourself, and while this is true, one shouldn't have to. Nor should we have to wait for updates as a regional build when the "original" yakju builds get updated quickly.
I'm coming from a Galaxy S, and I stated I will never buy a carrier build phone again because of fragmented updates across the world, of which Canada never seemed to get one... I said I'm going pure android. That is why I bought the Nexus.
Unfortunately, its starting to feel like the exact same experience.
Sorry if this bothers someone. That was not my intention.
Why not just flash yakju? You don't even need to unlock the bootloader (or so I've heard).
Oretoise said:
Why not just flash yakju? You don't even need to unlock the bootloader (or so I've heard).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You've heard wrong.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Oretoise said:
Why not just flash yakju? You don't even need to unlock the bootloader (or so I've heard).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its a matter of principle for some people.
And you have to unlock your bootloader. You can relock it after of course.
greeced said:
Google, I hope you're reading/listening to this:
It kind of irritates me that I bought this phone for the "Pure Google Experience" only to find out its not really that "True" experience with all these different regional builds.
People are on 4.0.2 for over a month now I believe, yet we Canadian users, as well as many others across the world are still on 4.0.1 and have been duped into believing the "Galaxy Nexus" is a true Google device. Well, it is, but it isn't at the same time. My yakjuux build from what I hear is updated from Samsung, not by you, and that irritates me.
Sure, I can flip over to yakju myself, but really, why should I have to do that??a
I mean is it so hard for Google to do, what the likes of Microsoft has been doing for many, many years? That is make one build, let's call it base yakju, then through the initial install process, ask the user what region/carrier/language/radio he/she has and have the unit download the "region packs" accordingly??
The dreaded Microsoft doesn't sell 15 different "regional versions" of Windows, its the exact same build, but with language packs that are set up after the initial install process.
That way everyone gets an update at the same time, in this case, by you Google not by Samsung, as it is believed is happening with my phone (although unconfirmed because we haven't received an update yet!)
Anyway, there are many that will say you can do it yourself, and while this is true, one shouldn't have to. Nor should we have to wait for updates as a regional build when the "original" yakju builds get updated quickly.
I'm coming from a Galaxy S, and I stated I will never buy a carrier build phone again because of fragmented updates across the world, of which Canada never seemed to get one... I said I'm going pure android. That is why I bought the Nexus.
Unfortunately, its starting to feel like the exact same experience.
Sorry if this bothers someone. That was not my intention.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed on all points! Google, sadly, is becoming a an organization that lacks focus in its endeavors.
I also come from a galaxy s and i have a yakju, international gsm, carrier free.
When i first heard that vodafone pt would have galaxy nexus carrier locked for sale, i thought right away that that couldnt be a good thing, so i went and ordered a sim free international version even more certain that what i needed was the one where no carrier touched, only Google. That worked out fine. There was no yakju variants known at the time, october or early november last year.
The move about dropping support on cdma devices was not so good, but thats on the carrier and lte fw.
Edit: re read op, and it seems he has a carrier unlocked phone.
If you wanted to escape regional builds, you should ask yourself why they exist. Different basebands for example, you probably are aware of this since you're from Canada.
I dont care about otas and etas, as long as source is available. Thats why i bought it in the first place.
Yes I can't believe why Google is allowing this. The nexus doesn't seem like a nexus now- it's just a phone that is unlockable.
It is the same case for me in Hong Kong. I finally decided not to flash yakju but to start using ROMs the second week I bought the phone.
Google needs to change this policy. They aren't going to let the nexus get more and more out of hand and less Google! As we Hongkongers like to say, give us back the "Google son"!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
greeced said:
It kind of irritates me that I bought this phone for the "Pure Google Experience" only to find out its not really that "True" experience with all these different regional builds.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How could there be no regional builds when people in the world don't even speak the same language?
Sorry for my sarcasm, but you get the idea. We have different networks, systems, AC power plugs... the list goes on and on. Just look at what 'X' means in different countries.
But I agree that they can do a lot more to make it easier.
Google has always held the belief that the Nexus line is for developers. It is for the most part a stock platform for which a developer can test their products on. However, Samsung and the carriers have mass marketed the phone as a consumer phone. It really is not and the Nexus brand has changed forever.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Eventually, google/samsung have to please the carriers that are selling the phone, else they won't want to carry it.
how do i know what region my gnex is frmo?
zeekiz said:
Eventually, google/samsung have to please the carriers that are selling the phone, else they won't want to carry it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is true only in the us. The rest of the world has working GSM networks and thus freedom from carrier dictated nonsense.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Oretoise said:
Why not just flash yakju? You don't even need to unlock the bootloader (or so I've heard).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're missing the point of his post.
Sent from a yakju GSGN
josteink said:
This is true only in the us. The rest of the world has working GSM networks and thus freedom from carrier dictated nonsense.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But then you are looking at the fact that they then have to supply smaller retailers with the handset, which also means they would have a lower scope of user adoption, as well as the cost of additional advertising.
By pleasing selected network providers, it ensure that the handset is in the hands of not just enthusiasts, but also the general user. The handset will have a higher adoption rate due to the higher availability, as well as the network providers will be more proactive in advertising the phone, overall this not only increases profits, but saves money by relying on the front end to advertise to attract users.
Business is business at the end of the day.
HRodMusic said:
how do i know what region my gnex is frmo?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://market.android.com/details?id=de.cbruegg.officialupdate
martonikaj said:
https://market.android.com/details?id=de.cbruegg.officialupdate
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wow thank you kind sir!
so i guess im yakju, thats the good one right? does that mean my phone is not canadian?
HRodMusic said:
wow thank you kind sir!
so i guess im yakju, thats the good one right? does that mean my phone is not canadian?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LOL. Read the app man. If it says "updated by GOOGLE" then you're good.
Its not about being Canadian vs. not. More like 100% stock Google vs. 99% stock Google.
efrant said:
You've heard wrong.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You do NOT need to unlock boot loader to flash yakju, from personal experience.
martonikaj said:
LOL. Read the app man. If it says "updated by GOOGLE" then you're good.
Its not about being Canadian vs. not. More like 100% stock Google vs. 99% stock Google.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yea, its just i got my phone off craigslist, ive always wondered were it came from, over seas, or from my canadian neighbors =D
btw whats your speeds like in bellingham?
greeced said:
Google, I hope you're reading/listening to this:
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're posting on XDA and hope Google reads this?
I'm just happy that we have access to the latest ICS versions (through ROMs and AOSP). If I have to flash them instead of getting OTAs, then so be it. I can live with that.
I am 100% sure we are much better off than those still stuck on Gingerbread, Froyo, Eclair and even Donut. We and the Nexus S crew are still the first to get our hands on ICS, which we've been able to enjoy over the past 4 months whilst everyone else has to wait patiently. We'll also have first dibs on Jellybean too
Is it ideal that we already have version fragmentation on ICS? Not really, but considering the baseline version recommended for mass use hasn't seemed to have surfaced yet, I wouldn't really consider that a problem. Once that's out in the wild, I would expect most people will get OTA'd to the latest version and all will be well.
Regional builds MAY get it slower due to Samsung handling the OTAs, however I think they only did this to offload some of the pressure of single-handedly applying a global update. Even though my Nexus was shipped as yakju, I do hope Sammy pulls their finger out and updates the regional builds as fast as Google will.
I have a few questions specific to the Sprint version of the galaxy nexus:
1. Updates - who provides them? Does google have to go through sprint? Or can you download them direct from google like you can with GSM/Verizon? If google direct, does google provide up to date versions? They don't for verizon (who is still on 4.0.2)
2. If google doesn't provide them direct, what are the chances that the modding community can provide a pure google experience with a fully up to date copy of android? I mean no modifications at all beyond what you would otherwise find in the pure google release.
3. Do third party ROM's and google direct ROM's have access to the ## codes? E.g. ##DATA, etc.
4. Does the stock nexus include bloatware (e.g. crappy NASCAR alikes, amazon mp3, sprintzone, etc)
5. The Verizon CDMA has connection issues, can the same be said about Sprint?
6. I've heard about some problems with some screens looking like crap, has this been the case with the sprint version?
bump
1. I believe Google supplies updates to all of the nexus phones.
2. Even with direct updates from Google the modding community will just about always provide better update support for any android phone. Not too mention the tweaks and mods that truly push the power of the phone.
3. No bloatware at all on the Sprint galaxy nexus.
4. I have had no connection issues.
5. This screen is beautiful, but some people seem to notice things in pentile screens while others do not.
I started using smartphones with a blackberry curve, then a Samsung moment, then an HTC Evo 4g, then the HTC Evo 3d and now my SAMSUNG galaxy nexus (I still prefer the nexus prime name as it would have gone well with my transformer prime). This is by far the best phone out of the bunch.
sent from my sprint nexus prime
I missed number 3, but I don't know so it doesn't matter.
sent from my sprint nexus prime
Rakeesh_j said:
I have a few questions specific to the Sprint version of the galaxy nexus:
1. Updates - who provides them? Does google have to go through sprint? Or can you download them direct from google like you can with GSM/Verizon? If google direct, does google provide up to date versions? They don't for verizon (who is still on 4.0.2)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Google makes the updates for the software, then hands it to (and continues to work with) Sprint to develop the kernel and radio stacks to work with the update. The update gets tied up in that process, exactly how it does with Verizon. Updates will be slower because of it.
2. If google doesn't provide them direct, what are the chances that the modding community can provide a pure google experience with a fully up to date copy of android? I mean no modifications at all beyond what you would otherwise find in the pure google release.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People will take the update files from GSM and take the changes and add them to new CDMA ROMs, but they will still be using the old radios from the previous updates (because those aren't included in the GSM ROMs of course). So basically it's a hack job that just makes you feel better because you have the updated build number, but isn't really an update. Often the updates for GSM don't do anything to fix the CDMA model, and its purely cosmetic. Fixes that the CDMA version need will only come in the CDMA update.
3. Do third party ROM's and google direct ROM's have access to the ## codes? E.g. ##DATA, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Short codes are just pinging your carrier and returning the data. Shouldn't be ROM specific.
4. Does the stock nexus include bloatware (e.g. crappy NASCAR alikes, amazon mp3, sprintzone, etc)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Shouldn't have any Sprint apps (Verizon includes 2 tools). Any that are included can be disabled.
5. The Verizon CDMA has connection issues, can the same be said about Sprint?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dunno. Different networks and software versions (slightly). The radios are probably of the same quality though.
6. I've heard about some problems with some screens looking like crap, has this been the case with the sprint version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sprint version has the same screen tech/process/manufacturer as the other models. It'll be subject to the same inconsistencies and "issues" that people see. Its the same production line.
martonikaj said:
People will take the update files from GSM and take the changes and add them to new CDMA ROMs, but they will still be using the old radios from the previous updates (because those aren't included in the GSM ROMs of course). So basically it's a hack job that just makes you feel better because you have the updated build number, but isn't really an update. Often the updates for GSM don't do anything to fix the CDMA model, and its purely cosmetic. Fixes that the CDMA version need will only come in the CDMA update.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I'd assume they'd still have the android core fixes at least? Take for example the API additions and calendar app changes from 4.0.2 to 4.0.3.
martonikaj said:
Short codes are just pinging your carrier and returning the data. Shouldn't be ROM specific.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think that's true on GSM but CDMA is different. For example, if you load CM9 to an HTC Evo or an HTC Hero, you lose access to those codes.
Don't suppose anybody could test this for me? E.g. load AOKP or CM9 to their galaxy nexus and try them.
Rakeesh_j said:
Well I'd assume they'd still have the android core fixes at least? Take for example the API additions and calendar app changes from 4.0.2 to 4.0.3.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They'd include anything that was part of the GSM OTA that wasn't radio or CDMA specific. So you'd get feature adds, but not bugfixes. Most people are looking for bug fixes, which they don't get. As I said, for the most part these CDMA ROMs that include parts of the GSM OTAs can be pretty useless and are usually just cosmetic.
I think that's true on GSM but CDMA is different. For example, if you load CM9 to an HTC Evo or an HTC Hero, you lose access to those codes.
Don't suppose anybody could test this for me? E.g. load AOKP or CM9 to their galaxy nexus and try them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea, don't like or use CDMA.
Google is the owner for the core of the updates, sprint and Verizon both have minor BS on them that can be deleted, no Verizon issues since day one of release, and load AOKP as soon as you can, mskip(XDA) makes the BEST rooting software on the net for this phone
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Why am I waiting on VZW for 4.0.4? I understood (or misunderstood) the Nexus line to get their updates directly from Google. This played a significant role in my decision to go with the Galaxy Nexus. So, what changed? I'm sure the Nexus One got updates direct from Google...didn't it? Also, I noticed a couple VZW branded uninstallable apps preloaded on it...why is there ANYTHING non-Google preloaded if it's "Pure Google?"
Man, I must have misunderstood something.
Because you are too lazy to root your phone?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
miketoasty said:
Because you are too lazy to root your phone?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1. Root it & put 4.0.4 on it yourself. Eff vzw.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
There wasn't a CDMA Nexus One, so yes it got its updates from Google.
This is actually nothing new, nothing has changed. Its been the exact same with the NS4G on Sprint. Verizon has closed-source radio code that they have to add themselves and test before sending it out. THAT is why you're waiting for Verizon.
As for the apps, just disable them and stop crying. Its the same deal, if a phone is gonna be on Verizon it's gonna have those apps.
If it bothers you that bad, buy a GSM model.
This has been argued/explained at length in many threads, blogs, podcasts and posts.
CDMA Nexii are slightly different. They get updates sent from Google to the carriers(ie Sprint and Verizon). GSM Nexii on the other hand, get updates directly from Google. It was known for a while now that this was the case, which means you didn't do your research.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
miketoasty said:
Because you are too lazy to root your phone?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Shouldn't have to.
Anyway, it's clear that VZW is incapable of responsibly having a Nexus phone in their lineup. I hope they don't get one ever again unless Google manages to get some leverage on them like Apple does.
vash1053 said:
Anyway, it's clear that VZW is incapable of responsibly having a Nexus phone in their lineup. I hope they don't get one ever again unless Google manages to get some leverage on them like Apple does.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apple doesn't have any special leverages over carriers for OS updates when compared to the Nexus. They need Verizon's proprietary code and testing just as much. They need the same with AT&T and Sprint.
We just don't get any leaks on iOS updates, and Apple only releases an iOS update when its ready for everyone. They don't release iOS earlier for their unlocked models because they want to release it for everyone at once. It'd be the exact same deal if Google held the update for everyone and didn't push it till Verizon was done.
And you're right, he shouldn't have to root his phone. If he wants to wait he can wait and he'll get the OTA when its pushed to everyone on the Verizon model. Rooting isn't the only way to get the OTA. It does come w/o rooting if you wait.
vash1053 said:
Shouldn't have to.
Anyway, it's clear that VZW is incapable of responsibly having a Nexus phone in their lineup. I hope they don't get one ever again unless Google manages to get some leverage on them like Apple does.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Like mentioned earlier VZW still customizes android with radios and bloatware. So despite the newest Google android releases for GSM deices VZW still tinkers with the latest version goes through a testing phase then pushes it to end users eventually. The beauty of a Nexus phone is user freedom to customize and use roms with ease. Quit waiting on Big Red, take your phone back flash the latest software yourself.
blowtorch said:
Like mentioned earlier VZW still customizes android with radios and bloatware. So despite the newest Google android releases for GSM deices VZW still tinkers with the latest version goes through a testing phase then pushes it to end users eventually. The beauty of a Nexus phone is user freedom to customize and use roms with ease. Quit waiting on Big Red, take your phone back flash the latest software yourself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
VZW doesn't customize anything. The bloatware is just like 2-3 apps that are Verizon apps.
Radios are handled by Samsung.
Verizon Galaxy Nexus isn't a true 'nexus' device. People will debate with me but honestly it isn't,
1) No images flashed to 4.0.4 (they are archived on Google's website to 4.0.2 now but won't be updated).
2) Carrier has to approve update.
If you want the true Nexus feeling, get the GSM model of the phone.
If you don't want to root / flash your phone, then don't complain about not getting 4.0.4. GSM users have to wait for the OTA as well unless they root and manually flash. You can manually flash 4.0.4 OTA on VZW as well.
But GSM will get it first because they dont have to be approved.
zephiK said:
VZW doesn't customize anything. The bloatware is just like 2-3 apps that are Verizon apps.
Radios are handled by Samsung.
Verizon Galaxy Nexus isn't a true 'nexus' device. People will debate with me but honestly it isn't,
1) No images flashed to 4.0.4 (they are archived on Google's website to 4.0.2 now but won't be updated).
2) Carrier has to approve update.
If you want the true Nexus feeling, get the GSM model of the phone.
If you don't want to root / flash your phone, then don't complain about not getting 4.0.4. GSM users have to wait for the OTA as well unless they root and manually flash. You can manually flash 4.0.4 OTA on VZW as well.
But GSM will get it first because they dont have to be approved.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what you stated here and was really my trying point is that veriosn needs to approve the software including the 2 to 3 apps and radios before the push to users ... i don't think anyone can deny that verison's version isn't true nexus
the only real nexus's are the Yakju/Takju builds ... which any gsm version could be converted to
zephiK said:
VZW doesn't customize anything. The bloatware is just like 2-3 apps that are Verizon apps.
Radios are handled by Samsung.
Verizon Galaxy Nexus isn't a true 'nexus' device. People will debate with me but honestly it isn't,
1) No images flashed to 4.0.4 (they are archived on Google's website to 4.0.2 now but won't be updated).
2) Carrier has to approve update.
If you want the true Nexus feeling, get the GSM model of the phone.
If you don't want to root / flash your phone, then don't complain about not getting 4.0.4. GSM users have to wait for the OTA as well unless they root and manually flash. You can manually flash 4.0.4 OTA on VZW as well.
But GSM will get it first because they dont have to be approved.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are updating what binaries they can provide, so don't be so sure they won't be updating images. Your definition of a true Nexus and mine differ.
VZW Galaxy Nexus still gets updates directly from Google. It just has to be put under review/testing from Verizon before it gets pushed.
Plus, who actually depends on the OTA? You're on XDA after all.
---------- Post added at 05:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:43 AM ----------
zephiK said:
VZW doesn't customize anything. The bloatware is just like 2-3 apps that are Verizon apps.
Radios are handled by Samsung.
Verizon Galaxy Nexus isn't a true 'nexus' device. People will debate with me but honestly it isn't,
1) No images flashed to 4.0.4 (they are archived on Google's website to 4.0.2 now but won't be updated).
2) Carrier has to approve update.
If you want the true Nexus feeling, get the GSM model of the phone.
If you don't want to root / flash your phone, then don't complain about not getting 4.0.4. GSM users have to wait for the OTA as well unless they root and manually flash. You can manually flash 4.0.4 OTA on VZW as well.
But GSM will get it first because they dont have to be approved.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The radios are handled by Qualcomm/Verizon. It's a "true" nexus device. It meets all the criteria. Just because it gets a .0.1 revision update a week later (or whatever it was) doesn't mean ****. Seriously? Gonna cry of a couple small bug fixes? As to the CDMA binaries not being available, talk to Qualcomm, they made most of the binaries/radios.
You may not have to wait much longer. Vzw started to push 4.0.4 (Imm76K) last week.
It's in the Vzw Dev forum if you don't want to wait and don't mind unlocking and rooting
You guys are really proud of rooting your phone. Sounds like you need something bigger in your life. I ask a few questions and suddenly I'm lazy & crying. Really, if this is big enough to get upset over, then you need to lay off the internet a little. Go find something worth getting upset over.
No one is upset. In the time it took creating this thread and replying to posts, you could have rooted and been on 4.0.4. I think that's the point everyone's trying to convey.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
meganame said:
You guys are really proud of rooting your phone. Sounds like you need something bigger in your life. I ask a few questions and suddenly I'm lazy & crying. Really, if this is big enough to get upset over, then you need to lay off the internet a little. Go find something worth getting upset over.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No need to meet harshness with harshness.
Its obvious you're upset about this whole thing or you wouldn't have created a thread about it. You need to just decide what's important to you, read up on it, and if you find you don't want to "wait for Verizon" then I'll tell you again to buy a GSM model.
keith.mcintyre26 said:
No one is upset. In the time it took creating this thread and replying to posts, you could have rooted and been on 4.0.4. I think that's the point everyone's trying to convey.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah, well those words conveyed it better.
keith.mcintyre26 said:
No one is upset. In the time it took creating this thread and replying to posts, you could have rooted and been on 4.0.4. I think that's the point everyone's trying to convey.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not really helping... I think what he's trying to get people to understand is that he shouldn't have to root to get the OTA. And all people on XDA do is say "shut up noob, just root your ph0n3".
OP, whether you like it or not this thread is going to turn into a nasty, nasty flame war in a couple pages. Sorry.
martonikaj said:
Not really helping... I think what he's trying to get people to understand is that he shouldn't have to root to get the OTA. And all people on XDA do is say "shut up noob, just root your ph0n3".
OP, whether you like it or not this thread is going to turn into a nasty, nasty flame war in a couple pages. Sorry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its true.
They should really stress the fact that XDA is a development site and not Verizon support forums.
Seriously though, you came on XDA and posted this thread. You could've rooted, unlocked, and flashed 4.0.4 by now.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
martonikaj said:
Apple doesn't have any special leverages over carriers for OS updates when compared to the Nexus. They need Verizon's proprietary code and testing just as much. They need the same with AT&T and Sprint.
We just don't get any leaks on iOS updates, and Apple only releases an iOS update when its ready for everyone. They don't release iOS earlier for their unlocked models because they want to release it for everyone at once. It'd be the exact same deal if Google held the update for everyone and didn't push it till Verizon was done.
And you're right, he shouldn't have to root his phone. If he wants to wait he can wait and he'll get the OTA when its pushed to everyone on the Verizon model. Rooting isn't the only way to get the OTA. It does come w/o rooting if you wait.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apple most definitely has leverage over carriers. If they didn't, you'd see bloatware on subsidized iPhones & updates being pushed at different times. Leaks don't matter because Apple makes their beta iOS builds readily available to those enrolled in the iOS development program.
A lot of fandroids don't want to admit that there ARE benefits to being a control freak, especially when you're one of the richest and most famous companies in the entire world. Apple doesn't order VZW around, but you can be damn sure that VZW doesn't order Apple around either. VZW telling Apple what changes they want made to the OS? LOL, not going to happen.