Hi guys I was just wondering if I unlock and root my stock GSM Nexus, not installing CWM or any custom roms at all just keeping it stock (aside from Superuser, root). Does that stop or affect the OTA updates from google at all.
I did a search but its all basically about putting on CWM and flashing roms and pretty much all rooting help apps I found seem to want to install cwm as well so I'm curious if once I root it is my only way of updating is manually flashing roms myself
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1441478
Ahh damn my search skills must suck but I still have to say that the answer was a little vague too
Rooting will not affect OTA updates. If you make any changes to anything outside /sdcard/ it'll cause problems. Manual update will not wipe the device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess it means your fine and update will work as long as you don't go modding the original files ?
The thing is that i asked this question several times, and every time i get different answer..
I have also rooted my phone and unlocked bootloader, without any custom cWM or custom rom.. I have changed bootanimation (its in system, so its outside sdcard).
Will i be able to get OTA update, to see it and to install it ?
Thanks in advance
Laynee1 said:
The thing is that i asked this question several times, and every time i get different answer..
I have also rooted my phone and unlocked bootloader, without any custom cWM or custom rom.. I have changed bootanimation (its in system, so its outside sdcard).
Will i be able to get OTA update, to see it and to install it ?
Thanks in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should still get your OTA updates. They may break the root on your phone though but thats not really a big deal.
Sent from my XT860 using XDA App
Laynee1 said:
The thing is that i asked this question several times, and every time i get different answer..
I have also rooted my phone and unlocked bootloader, without any custom cWM or custom rom.. I have changed bootanimation (its in system, so its outside sdcard).
Will i be able to get OTA update, to see it and to install it ?
Thanks in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You get a different answer because there are a lot of people who have no clue what they are talking about, passing on wrong information.
First of all, there is a difference between "getting" an OTA update notification, and having it install. Those are two separate things. You will get the OTA update notification. Whether or not it will install depends on many things, and it changes with every update. The update has a series of "asserts" or verifications that it runs through to make sure all the files it is going to update are there. You wanna know which files it checks? Don't be lazy - open up an OTA zip file and look at the updater-script file and go through it. There you will see yourself what files need to be stock. Doing it yourself is the only way to learn. Trusting a bunch of xda members who don't know what they are talking about is not the way to learn...
Having said all that, having an unlocked bootloader or having root will in no way impact your ability to receive OR install an OTA update.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Thanks to both of you... The thing is that i really look forward to get 4.0.3 .. I dont want to flash custom roms, i want it all stock .. Im not asking about ETAs or smt.. Im just wishing for 4.0.3 . I heard that a lot of things are settled into 4.0.3.. Lags are gone, bugs are fixed..
Laynee1 said:
Thanks to both of you... The thing is that i really look forward to get 4.0.3 .. I dont want to flash custom roms, i want it all stock .. Im not asking about ETAs or smt.. Im just wishing for 4.0.3 . I heard that a lot of things are settled into 4.0.3.. Lags are gone, bugs are fixed..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unlocking or rooting does not mean you are going to flash custom ROMs...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
The only thing that will affect OTA is when you load a custom recovery onto the phone. THAT'S THE ANSWER!
Edit - These things also can affect OTA
Modifying or removing a file that is checked/patched.
Having a different radio installed.
Having a different bootloader installed (possibly).
Having a different kernel installed.
Have modified your build.prop to show a different version.
efrant said:
Unlocking or rooting does not mean you are going to flash custom ROMs...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ye i know .. I have unlocked bootloader and rooted phone.. But i dont want to flash any custom rom.. I wanna keep it stock.. Just , im saying i cant wait for OTA 4.0.3
jd1001 said:
I have seen this questions posted a number of times from the same user. The only thing that will affect OTA is when you load a custom recovery onto the phone. THAT'S THE ANSWER!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
..and an incorrect one at that. That is not the only thing.
Having a custom recovery will:
Prevent being able to install the OTA
Not stop the ota notification or being able to download it.
Other things that will break your ability to install an OTA, even if you do not have a custom recovery loaded (you can still get notified and download):
Modifying or removing a file that is checked/patched.
Having a different radio installed.
Having a different bootloader installed (possibly).
Having a different kernel installed.
Have modified your build.prop to show a different version.
You can install an ota if you modify the udapter-script if you know what you are doing even in the above scenarios (using a custom recovery).
adrynalyne said:
..and an incorrect one at that. That is not the only thing.
Having a custom recovery will:
Prevent being able to install the OTA
Not stop the ota notification or being able to download it.
Other things that will break your ability to install an OTA, even if you do not have a custom recovery loaded (you can still get notified and download):
Modifying or removing a file that is checked/patched.
Having a different radio installed.
Having a different bootloader installed (possibly).
Having a different kernel installed.
Have modified your build.prop to show a different version.
You can install an ota if you modify the udapter-script if you know what you are doing even in the above scenarios (using a custom recovery).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well thanks for correcting me eventhough I wasn't actually wrong in what I said.
Thanks for adding those bits too I had no idea that other mods could affect OTA although I have read here a few times that the bootloader won't affect OTA. There should be an actual topic on this because with all the information floating around it is confusing.
Just a nuance in your choice of words...
Having a custom recovery will not prevent you from installing an OTA, but it will prevent the OTA from installing automatically on its own - you can still manually flash it through your custom recovery...
The second list should be items that "may" affect OTA, rather than "will", since it is dependent on the individual updater-script...
I think we're on the same page though...
danger-rat said:
Just a nuance in your choice of words...
Having a custom recovery will not prevent you from installing an OTA, but it will prevent the OTA from installing automatically on its own - you can still manually flash it through your custom recovery...
The second list should be items that "may" affect OTA, rather than "will", since it is dependent on the individual updater-script...
I think we're on the same page though...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Totally agree! Sometimes it's just frustrating becaus eeveryone thinks they know the right answer when in actual fact people post rubbish that is incorrect. I am guilty of it too but I always go back and edit when I make a false statement.
danger-rat said:
Just a nuance in your choice of words...
Having a custom recovery will not prevent you from installing an OTA, but it will prevent the OTA from installing automatically on its own - you can still manually flash it through your custom recovery...
The second list should be items that "may" affect OTA, rather than "will", since it is dependent on the individual updater-script...
I think we're on the same page though...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. Any signed ota package...the above will affect it. Going by what JBQ said, where every ota should include radios...I'd say I worded it ok.
Also, there is a darn good chance that the custom recovery will stop the install even manually...if it checks the recovery version for an update. That is fairly common. That said, if you remove asserts and know what you are doing, then sure you can flash manually.
This is the sort of uncertainty I am talking about. We should create a new topic and nail it down finally!
Here is a way to nail it down:
If you have modified your system in any way aside from rooting, then your chances of being able to install an ota update are greatly diminished.
adrynalyne said:
Here is a way to nail it down:
If you have modified your system in any way aside from rooting, then your chances of being able to ota are greatly diminished.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ha ha ha sorted!
adrynalyne said:
No. Any signed ota package...the above will affect it. Going by what JBQ said, where every ota should include radios...I'd say I worded it ok.
Also, there is a darn good chance that the custom recovery will stop the install even manually...if it checks the recovery version for an update. That is fairly common. That said, if you remove asserts and know what you are doing, then sure you can flash manually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No OTA update to date has checked the recovery. In fact, every OTA update to date has forced a flash of the stock recovery.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Here we go again!
Related
Sorry if this question has been asked before, but i could not find any.
So i got the Nexus beast yesterday, and it's already blazing me off with it's greatness. But i got a few problems though:
1. I got the jakjuxw, not the jakju, will i get the same updates as the jakju OTA, but only a week later or so?
2. I did not root the phone before starting using it, but i regret that now. Is there any way i can root it and NOT lose all of my apps and data? I have spent so many hours to customize this device and i dont want to start all over (yes i know about app backup's, but they are slow)
3. If i root but stay with the stock rom, will i still be getting the original OTA updates or does i have to flash the roms manually and wipe the phone every time?
I'd appreciate it if anyone could answer all the questions =)
Baguett said:
Sorry if this question has been asked before, but i could not find any.
So i got the Nexus beast yesterday, and it's already blazing me off with it's greatness. But i got a few problems though:
1. I got the jakjuxw, not the jakju, will i get the same updates as the jakju OTA, but only a week later or so?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure about this, it probably depends on what they want to release. I don't think there's any kind of guarantee they'll get the same updates, but there's also probably no reason why they wouldn't.
2. I did not root the phone before starting using it, but i regret that now. Is there any way i can root it and NOT lose all of my apps and data? I have spent so many hours to customize this device and i dont want to start all over (yes i know about app backup's, but they are slow)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need to unlock the bootloader to root, and unlocking the bootloader wipes the device. Sorry. Someday an exploit might be found for ICS that allows you to root without unlocking.
3. If i root but stay with the stock rom, will i still be getting the original OTA updates or does i have to flash the roms manually and wipe the phone every time?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you keep stock recovery, you'll still get OTA updates when rooted. If you use custom recovery like ClockworkMod, you'll have to do them manually (but you won't need to wipe). In both cases, applying the update will probably cause you to lose root and you'll have to re-root. This is easy if you've unlocked the bootloader.
If you root by using some future exploit, you might find that the update you just installed removed root and closed the hole that allowed you to gain it without unlocking the bootloader, and now you're left stuck without root. I'd say just unlock the bootloader now and be done with it. It'll be a pain, but then you don't need to worry about it again.
phazerorg said:
If you keep stock recovery, you'll still get OTA updates when rooted. If you use custom recovery like ClockworkMod, you'll have to do them manually (but you won't need to wipe). In both cases, applying the update will probably cause you to lose root and you'll have to re-root. This is easy if you've unlocked the bootloader.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok thanks
Just unlocked it and rooted it, but i think im gonna install the official google 4.0.2 rom, i wil get the OTA updates then too right?
edit: how am i able to flash a rom without CWM? Also do i really not need to wipe my phone if i use CWM? i had to do it on my Desire.
Baguett said:
ok thanks
Just unlocked it and rooted it, but i think im gonna install the official google 4.0.2 rom, i wil get the OTA updates then too right?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, but the updates will probably unroot you. You should be able to just re-root after. If using CWM you can probably flash superuser right after flashing the update and not lose root at all. This is what I always did with my Nexus One when I still had the rooted stock ROM.
edit: how am i able to flash a rom without CWM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the ROM comes as images (like the Google factory images) you can flash with fastboot. The Google ones come with a script that uses fastboot to do it for you.
Also do i really not need to wipe my phone if i use CWM? i had to do it on my Desire.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I meant installing updates here... you don't usually need to wipe if you are installing updates to your current ROM, such as OTA updates to the stock ROM. You need to wipe if you're changing ROMs. It's probably no different than your Desire.
As the topic says I wonder how I do root by phone too still be able to get OTA updates. I've just seen the video at the ROOT INFO tab, but I have been given to understund that OTAs won't be possible with custom recovery. So my questin, is there another way to do this?
sopidos said:
As the topic says I wonder how I do root by phone too still be able to get OTA updates. I've just seen the video at the ROOT INFO tab, but I have been given to understund that OTAs won't be possible with custom recovery. So my questin, is there another way to do this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To, my personal knowledge... yeah you can root your device and still RECEIVE OTA's to your device, however when you need to install them... you'll need to flash the stock recovery so that it installs, then you can just go ahead and flash the custom recovery back that's what i'd do anyway.
Ok, I wound this http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1644167 just now. Will this do the thing without screwing up the stock recovery?
Historically it's always been the advice to NOT use OTA updates when rooted as they do more harm than good. If you're going custom I'd stick with that
sopidos said:
Ok, I wound this http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1644167 just now. Will this do the thing without screwing up the stock recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is new to me, i can't comment on it but from what i've read, yeah it seems to push the files to the device without the need of a custom recovery, personally i prefer the custom recovery way because you can carry on many different tasks which stock recovery can't
That link doesn't work, it's for the AT&T model (One XL)
EddyOS said:
That link doesn't work, it's for the AT&T model (One XL)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I thought this, but the title made me think differently.
Sent from my now amazing HTC One X thanks to TeamVenoms ViperX rom
Just got rooted using qbkings method...go qb! I do not have a custom recovery. Should I downloaded triangle away even though I don't have a custom recovery? And is it alright to rake any future ota updates since im rooted....or will that brick my phone. Also will tje same hold true if I make any modifications including the multi windows one. Thx
islandjat said:
Just got rooted using qbkings method...go qb! I do not have a custom recovery. Should I downloaded triangle away even though I don't have a custom recovery? And is it alright to rake any future ota updates since im rooted....or will that brick my phone. Also will tje same hold true if I make any modifications including the multi windows one. Thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Triangle Away is always handy to have - custom recovery or not.
Rooted will not allow OTA updates as they do a root check. However, there are ways to get updates without OTA - they're usually on here before then. Same with your modifications question.
Here's the technical reason:
OTA updates don't contain the entire package, they're old school patch files that take the existing files and make sure that they're the right one before applying the modifications. As a result if anything doesn't match the OTA will fail.
garwynn said:
Triangle Away is always handy to have - custom recovery or not.
Rooted will not allow OTA updates as they do a root check. However, there are ways to get updates without OTA - they're usually on here before then. Same with your modifications question.
Here's the technical reason:
OTA updates don't contain the entire package, they're old school patch files that take the existing files and make sure that they're the right one before applying the modifications. As a result if anything doesn't match the OTA will fail.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
An update here won't do me much good without a custom recovery now that I think about it. Thanks that cleared up those questions.
islandjat said:
An update here won't do me much good without a custom recovery now that I think about it. Thanks that cleared up those questions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Download goomanager from the playstore and install twrp thru the menu takes like 2 mins and its easy peasy
I like to break stuff!
-EViL-KoNCEPTz- said:
Download goomanager from the playstore and install twrp thru the menu takes like 2 mins and its easy peasy
I like to break stuff!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh yeah! Easy peasy!!
I am sorry if this question is answered already, but is there any way one can get the OTA again once the device is rooted? I mean by unroofing and factory reset or whatever means....
After rooting, OTA is still working but you'll probably lose root after it, excepted if your Superuser has an " OTA Survival " feature. In this case, you'll have to flash a stock ROM, and root it.
Sent from my Nexus 7
azvlean said:
After rooting, OTA is still working but you'll probably lose root after it, excepted if your Superuser has an " OTA Survival " feature. In this case, you'll have to flash a stock ROM, and root it.
Sent from my Nexus 7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
be careful if you have a custom recovery, accepting an OTA might screw your device up.
sk8trix said:
be careful if you have a custom recovery, accepting an OTA might screw your device up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for replying.
Will the custom recovery be overridden by the stock one? Or is there any chance of bricking the device?
sriram18981 said:
Thanks for replying.
Will the custom recovery be overridden by the stock one? Or is there any chance of bricking the device?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no sometimes what happens is the files dont install and you either get a reboot screen or some sort of black screen and then you might need to fix things with a toolkit through the pc or some hard kind of fix, t happened to me on a motorola Atrix a while back.
sriram18981 said:
I am sorry if this question is answered already, but is there any way one can get the OTA again once the device is rooted? I mean by unroofing and factory reset or whatever means....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your phone or tablet is rooted but with Stock Recovery the OTA should work just fine as long as you haven't modified any system files that get updated through the OTA. The bigger the update is the more likely it is you will lose root and that the OTA will find modified files. On Nexus devices I've personally never seen more than an error message if the OTA fails. At most I've only ever seen "unexpected contents in" error with whatever (modified) file is the problem. The OTA will always fail if you have a custom recovery but it's not really a big deal, you can always flash the OTA update zip in your custom recovery (TWRP?), more often than not before the OTA even rolls out to your device you can find the OTA zip here or on another website.
is there away to install SuperSU when you have stock recovery? I'm thinking that we have to have either CWM/TWRP to install the zip. or am I having a brain fart on this.....
Thanks for whomever can clear my cobwebs..
You need a custom recovery (TWRP or CWM).
bkeaver said:
is there away to install SuperSU when you have stock recovery? I'm thinking that we have to have either CWM/TWRP to install the zip. or am I having a brain fart on this.....
Thanks for whomever can clear my cobwebs..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can install it if you have the bootloader unlocked.
Use boot command instead of flash to boot into custom recovery and install su.
e.g
Fastboot boot twrp.img
uronfire said:
You can install it if you have the bootloader unlocked.
Use boot command instead of flash to boot into custom recovery and install su.
e.g
Fastboot boot twrp.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, this.
However, why bother keeping stock recovery at all? Stock recovery is effectively neutered once rooted, as you can no longer install an OTA.
uronfire said:
You can install it if you have the bootloader unlocked.
Use boot command instead of flash to boot into custom recovery and install su.
e.g
Fastboot boot twrp.img
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks this worked :good:
so when I go into recovery now I get a image of a htc one with a red triangle and exclamation mark inside of it?? since I have never went into recovery on this phone before isn't it supposed to look like any other stock recovery??? and if this isn't right I have tried flashing the recovery already and still get the same result... can someone expand on this for me pls
bkeaver said:
so when I go into recovery now I get a image of a htc one with a red triangle and exclamation mark inside of it?? since I have never went into recovery on this phone before isn't it supposed to look like any other stock recovery??? and if this isn't right I have tried flashing the recovery already and still get the same result... can someone expand on this for me pls
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have stock recovery.
BenPope said:
You have stock recovery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so it doesn't give you flash update and wipe and all that anymore.. sorry like I said I have never went into recovery on this phone.. just making sure...
bkeaver said:
so it doesn't give you flash update and wipe and all that anymore.. sorry like I said I have never went into recovery on this phone.. just making sure...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you have to hold volume up and hit power or something.
ok I am good.. thank you... I'm putting everything back to stock because someone bought my phone and I just want to make sure everything is correct on it now.. thanks!!
redpoint73 said:
Yes, this.
However, why bother keeping stock recovery at all? Stock recovery is effectively neutered once rooted, as you can no longer install an OTA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i sold the phone and this is what they requested. I know the OTA wont work and I never keep stock recoveries on my phones but.... I guess they will find out for themselves
and btw thanks everyone for the help. I hit my thanks button but on my browser it it isn't showing it just to let you know....
bkeaver said:
i sold the phone and this is what they requested. I know the OTA wont work and I never keep stock recoveries on my phones but.... I guess they will find out for themselves
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds like somebody that is a bit ill-informed. They want root, but they probably also want OTA (the 2 don't go together, IMO) and heard that you need stock recovery for OTA. I suppose they can change everything back that they modified with root, and unroot or hide root to install the OTA. But it just seems they are making life more complicated than it needs to be.
Also sounds like its a person that wants root, but not willing to do it themselves. But I suppose that's not really your problem!
Option to root and have ota is very easy :
Stock rom (unmodified but rooted)
Stock recovery
And you can ota. The ota will probably delete superuser but that's about it. The ota will not fail because its rooted as long as the stock rom/apps are unmodified
Mr Hofs said:
Option to root and have ota is very easy :
Stock rom (unmodified but rooted)
Stock recovery
And you can ota. The ota will probably delete superuser but that's about it. The ota will not fail because its rooted as long as the stock rom/apps are unmodified
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah this is what I did for them so who knows.. I've never tried it that way but i guess it would work like that
redpoint73 said:
Yes, this.
However, why bother keeping stock recovery at all? Stock recovery is effectively neutered once rooted, as you can no longer install an OTA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rooting doesn't affect ota's, at least not in my experience.
ashyx said:
Rooting doesn't affect ota's, at least not in my experience.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only if absolutely nothing was changed with the stock ROM.
Its more my point there is little point to installing OTAs on a rooted device.
redpoint73 said:
Only if absolutely nothing was changed with the stock ROM.
Its more my point there is little point to installing OTAs on a rooted device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't understand that statement. I still run stock sense, but with a few additions that don't affect ota's. So I still get updates while having things configured the way I want. I can also run things that require root such as titanium backup and a few others.
ashyx said:
I don't understand that statement. I still run stock sense, but with a few additions that don't affect ota's. So I still get updates while having things configured the way I want. I can also run things that require root such as titanium backup and a few others.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because once you accept an OTA, you will be unrooted. You will have to root again, either by installing custom recovery (than back to stock recovery so you can OTA) or the trick of booting custom recovery via adb to flash SU (as described here). Its just a lot of jumping through hoops with little added value.
On the other hand, if you have custom recovery installed, you can flash any of the array of stock rooted or awesome custom ROMs posted here. This includes stock rooted ROMs taken from OTA updates from lots of versions (often posted within days of the OTA starting to roll out), not just your carrier, so you can possibly get an update much faster than waiting for the OTA to roll out from your carrier (although that depends on what carrier version you have). You also don't have to constantly be worried "well, if I change this I won't get OTAs". You can do whatever the heck you want, and isn't that really the whole point of root?
Its just my opinion. And a lot of this may stem from the fact that I'm on AT&T, who are not only agonizingly slow about rolling out OTAs (sometimes 3-4 months or even later than other carriers on my past HTC device) and have even went to the effort to close exploits and prevent unlocking of bootloaders when rolling out new OTAs (on the One X EVITA). In fact there was even a bug (I assume it was a bug - others may accuse that it was intentional) where installing the Jellybean OTA with SuperCID and S-on bricked the phone.
As I said, its just an opinion. But there are many others on XDA that will agree that OTAs have no place on rooted Android devices.
And to be fair, I did cover myself and stated "there is little point" instead of "there is no point"