Develop Bugs

Warning about ATT's new screen protector for captivate...it SUCKS!!

So when I bought my captivate I bought the ATT screen protector and it was very nice.
If I were to leave a mark due to hitting with my nail on the screen, the mark will slowly disappear back to normal. It was also full size all the way to the home button etc.
After many months I decided to replace it as it was coming off on the sides but the quality was still great.
Well, first red flag was that the new version is no longer full size. Only covers to the lower part of the actual display area but I was assured that it was the same material...
Yeah, same material my A$$! That thing sucks...it became a mess of horrible screen patterns like I was looking at some Nasa Mars photos or something.
I took it back and the bastards wanted to charge me $5 bucks to replace it again!
I express my deepest feeling in some not very forum appropiate wording and left.
Bought an invisi shield even though opinions are mixed about it and so far I love it.
Screen looks perfect with non of the horrible patterns I was getting with the ATT ****.
Just a warning.
Regards

Yeah, I'm using a invisishield
Had one since day one of phone purchase. No complaints.
Love my otterbox too

that sucks I was thinking of getting one, thanks for the heads up.

10Stars said:
that sucks I was thinking of getting one, thanks for the heads up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you can find the original one (full lenght) you should be fine but if it is the small one run away from it. I couldnt take that more than a week.

The invisi-sheild is pretty good I had one and loved it, but I just replaced it with the ATT screen shield last week and mine comes all the way down and covers my buttons and is actually a pretty decent protector. Maybe they were out of stock and gave you one that 'works' for your phone. The rep did bring me the wrong one initially....

That's not good. I HATED my InisiSheild. The ATT screen protector was the only screen protector I've been able to stand.
Good thing I have two spares...

Mr.Immaculate said:
That's not good. I HATED my InisiSheild. The ATT screen protector was the only screen protector I've been able to stand.
Good thing I have two spares...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lucky you as it was very nice indeed.

Mr.Immaculate said:
That's not good. I HATED my InisiSheild. The ATT screen protector was the only screen protector I've been able to stand.
Good thing I have two spares...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree on the Zagg. It was absolutely terrible, but it was free, so I can't really complain. Anyway, I gave up on screen protectors altogether.

Screen protector? What's that? Lol. Seriously, I've never used one and I've dropped my phone face down on both gravel and pavement. My screen still looks brand new. I think screen protectors on these phones are just a waste of money, and I hate the idea of having another layer to distort the image.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA App

I ran without a screen protector... Right up until I picked up gash in the upper right corner of my screen.
All it takes is one grain of sand.
The old AT&T screen protectors are the best compromise I've found between the crystal clarity of running naked, and having at least some protection.

Mr.Immaculate said:
I ran without a screen protector... Right up until I picked up gash in the upper right corner of my screen.
All it takes is one grain of sand.
.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This.
I don't know how you people keep saying after months of screen protectorless use, your phone looks brand new.
I went protectorless for a couple months, and after that short a period of time I picked up a few noticeable scratches. They aren't deep enough to be seen in use, but they are there.
I'll keep my screen protectors. Can't really tell the difference anyway.

You agree with a post that is stating the opposite of what you are saying? That is cool LOL

If you want the original At&t protectors, search for the brand Real Look. One of my packs from At&t had the Real Look branding on the stuff inside the pack. I also suggested Real Look to a buddy with an iPhone 4, and when he got his, it's the same great material.
I will never use another brand of screen protector as long as Real Look makes one for my phone.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA Premium App

I don't know if I just got a bad batch, but the ones I got from AT&T a few months ago suck. Really rainbow...y and they have the annoying hole for the proximity and light sensor.

Had my captivate since July of last year, 3 days before release. Never used a screen protector and when I wipe it off it looks like I just peeled the DONT TXT AND DRIVE thingy off. Guess I'm just lucky.

Thnikk said:
I don't know if I just got a bad batch, but the ones I got from AT&T a few months ago suck. Really rainbow...y and they have the annoying hole for the proximity and light sensor.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
These are the Real Look screen protectors. I find that the rainbow effect disappears when the screen is on, so that is really not an issue. Also, I don't really think the cutout for the proximity sensor is that bad, it's a really small area that is barely noticeable, and I'm sure probably is there for a reason.
To me, the Real Look screen protectors have an unbeatable finish for keeping clean, smooth, and even scratch free. If you like the natural feel of gorilla glass, give them a shot, because these really do feel like the gorilla glass when they are clean. IMHO, they have the best scratch resistance of any crystal screen protector that I have ever used on any device. In the past I used matte screen protectors because I always hated scratches in glossy ones, but these have solved that problem.
I'm not trying to flame, I just think it's a bit unfair to be that nitpicky about a great product. Did you notice any of the positive qualities of these?

I dont know what brand it is but i use the screen protector that came with my otterbox. didnt use on on my first captivate, could definitely see some marks on screen, no problems with one in place.

I have also used Realook brand protectors. I thought they worked really well. The only reason you could tell I was using one was the horrible job I did installing it. They say they are washable and reusable, but after trading in my phone for a warranty issue I decided not to even try to reuse it. I just ordered a new one. $10 for 2 of em. I almost wasn't going to use one and I read a post from someone who says that he can see a bunch of microscopic scratches on the glass from keeping it in his pocket. The way I see it, I would rather cover it and not take any chances.

Go to best buy they have a military grade polyurethane they wrap around your phone it is the best screen protector phone protector ever
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA Premium App

I have a Skinomi brand protector on my captivate and it seems much better than the many others I have seen. Been on the phone since I got it (around release) and it doesn't have a single bubble or imperfection. Awesome stuff!
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App

I want to buy Galaxy Nexus

I want to buy Galaxy Nexus, but i want to know how it is the glass without invisible shield. Is like Gorilla Glass? Thx!

Yes, this has NEVER been discussed in this forum before:
Let's try searching first.
Don't mean to be rude, but this has been discussed since the day the phone came out.

martonikaj said:
Yes, this has NEVER been discussed in this forum before:
Let's try searching first.
Don't mean to be rude, but this has been discussed since the day the phone came out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean there is a search function on the forums?!?! No way! :O
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus

So buy it already...an put a screen protector on it and Enjoy!

xTee said:
I want to buy Galaxy Nexus, but i want to know how it is the glass without invisible shield. Is like Gorilla Glass? Thx!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been using mine since release day with no screen saver and I've had zero issues. I carry my Gnex in my shirt pocket everyday. But they can be scratched, as can Gorilla Glass, if you are in a sandy environment. A lot of posts you'll see about scratched screens are from carrying the phone in a pock with something like a credit card. A bit of sand gets between the two and you can have scratches.
Good luck.

I keep my phone in my pocket without a screen protector, and sometimes there are headphones and a couple times a key, and I haven't had a scratch yet. But like other have said, if you are in an environment with materials that are harder than glass, then there is a good chance you will get a scratch without a screen protector

Will you bother with a screen protector/case?

As the title suggests. I know it has reinforced gorilla glass but I will still be wary of picking up scratches even though I'm sure the phone can handle most things thrown at it. I am just not comfortable with spending so much cash without putting a screen cover on for that extra peace of mind.
I was not aware of how strong gorilla glass is until I saw someone jabbing their galaxy s2 screen with stanley knife on youtube recently.
I also have a gel case for my SG2 and I have never dropped it in the year that I've had it but I just feel that when buying something at first, you need to take that bit of 'extra' care of it - does anyone else feel this way?

case definitely, screen protector never

I always order an cheap ass TPU case from ebay. That works good.

Looking at some clips on Youtube, then no, i don't think i'll bother with a screen protector, but yes for me for a case, not dropped my Desire in the 20+ months i've had it, but you never know.

craftycarper1 said:
Looking at some clips on Youtube, then no, i don't think i'll bother with a screen protector, but yes for me for a case, not dropped my Desire in the 20+ months i've had it, but you never know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you remember any clips in particular? I'm still not convinced about the gorilla glass - although I want to be, simply because I HATE applying screen protectors -_-

This one makes me think i won't bother with protector........turn the volume down though.

Just a leather pouch, no screen protector. Don't really like cases, they make the phone HUGE (and it's already big.. ).

Definitely, I like to keep my phones as clean/new looking as possible.

I'll get a leather slip pouch as I have with my desire s and iPhone 3g before it. The HTC ones are really nice quality.
I'm unsure about screen protector, I have one on my desire s but never drop it and gorilla glass looks very resistant
Sent from my HTC Desire S using XDA

craftycarper1 said:
This one makes me think i won't bother with protector........turn the volume down though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Impressive what the screen can take! Think ill stick to just a case after watching a video like that

twistedh said:
Impressive what the screen can take! Think ill stick to just a case after watching a video like that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My thoughts exactly. Don't think i have the balls to be able to test the screen myself though

craftycarper1 said:
My thoughts exactly. Don't think i have the balls to be able to test the screen myself though
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have got a sudden urge to get out a kitchen knife and give it a go on my sg2! but ill resist

Yes to both! I've had my SGS2 for nearly a year in May, I've not dropped it heavily but last week I was caseless and big drop from my hands and got two nasty dents on the bezel and scratches on the back plastic! Will learn my lesson and never take it out caseless again! I was horrified when I saw them
The white version will only show dents more than the grey/black version!

I'm incredibly obsessive about protecting anything I spend more than £100 on.
So, yeah.. Soft case and screen protector for me.

I'm going for a nice pouch, I don't like the added weight and seize of a case.
Sent from my HTC Desire using XDA

I've pre-ordered the official HTC screen protectors - not a clue how good or bad they are though.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk

chrisjcks said:
I've pre-ordered the official HTC screen protectors - not a clue how good or bad they are though.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They'd have to be amazing for the price they cost.

I don't think I'll bother with either initially, the phone's large enough without adding more to it. Might invest in a rubber cover when I get bored of the stock white colour later on.

PsiAdster said:
They'd have to be amazing for the price they cost.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only £4.xx for 2 screen protectors, i certainly wasn't gonna pay recommended retail price of £10.99
http://www.handtec.co.uk/product.php/6535/htc-one-x-screen-protector---2-piece--sp-p730-
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk

I hate cases. I don't think I've ever had one on any phone I've owned. Screen protectors however, for me, are a must.

Screen protector, no screen protector?

Do you guys use a screen protector on your phone or not? How bad have you scratched the screen?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

bendirkss said:
Do you guys use a screen protector on your phone or not? How bad have you scratched the screen?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I personally prefer no screen-protector. The reason is it feels much better. And the screen is generally pretty strong. And I've only got two little scratches personally. Unless you throw your phone full-speed at the asphalt ground, a screen protector isn't really needed.

Better safe then sorry.
--------------------------------------------------
If I have helped you.... hit that sexy thanks button. ^_^

bendirkss said:
Do you guys use a screen protector on your phone or not? How bad have you scratched the screen?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I run without one and I have on every single phone with a glass screen. The only time I used one the phone had a plastic screen which is very prone to scratches.
As stated before, I prefer the feel of glass, it's very nice and how the designers intended it be used. Also as stated, glass is pretty tough. You really have to try to scratch it, I think at least.
I've had 3 smartphones that had glass screens, my first one, a Samsung Moment (slider phone) I slid it open while driving a golf cart (stupid stuff you do in security). The phone flew pretty well, slid I'd say... 20-25 feet, on the face, and I picked it up. The plastic bezel was of course nicked or scratched, but the glass was flawless.
Also, every screen protector I've seen gets lint/dust/crap under the edges. They stay on very well if applied right, but I'd say getting a small piece of sand stuck under that edge would be just as bad as anything else.
Lastly, the biggest issue with glass isn't so much scratches as it shattering. Those protectors may help with shattering, I don't know personally. I'm pretty sure if you drop kicked your phone by accident and the screen hit a decently pointed object, it'd be done for.

I believe that having screen protector helps protect the screen from shattering. I personally have it on just because I like to keep my phone nice and mint. That's a reason why I have OtterBox on too
Swyped on my Galaxy Nexus running AOKP with Franco Kernel

Thanks for the responses. I am running a pretty standard size case on it. I used to have an invisible shield. The screen just doesn't look mor feel the same.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

bendirkss said:
Thanks for the responses. I am running a pretty standard size case on it. I used to have an invisible shield. The screen just doesn't look mor feel the same.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what it's gonna feel like if you have the protector on.

No screen protector for me, but I always do my best to not keep any keys or anything else in my pocket when I put my phone it it

Dragn4rce said:
Better safe then sorry.
--------------------------------------------------
If I have helped you.... hit that sexy thanks button. ^_^
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I guess, but the screen feels less clean and glossy. When the protector goes on, it feels kind of matte in a sense. And also the screen is very strong in general. You're not really gonna scratch it that bad. Also, its curved so that helps as well.

EpiclyEpic said:
I guess, but the screen feels less clean and glossy. When the protector goes on, it feels kind of matte in a sense. And also the screen is very strong in general. You're not really gonna scratch it that bad. Also, its curved so that helps as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And then u scratch it and say to urself every time u see it, "why the fu did I tell myself to go out with no screen protector!?!?!"
BTW, They do have cornering glass as screen protectors. So now u have no excesses.
--------------------------------------------------
If I have helped you.... hit that sexy thanks button. ^_^

How resistant to scratching is glass vs a microscopic grain of sand?
My 1st glass fronted smartphone went without a screen protector because I'd seen lots of videos on YouTube of people going nuts with keys and knives and scissors testing and supposedly proofing the amazing scratch resistance of glass screens. Regardless I was always super careful not to have anything else in the same trouser pocket but STILL I got a scratch on the glass in the same week I'd bought it and have not a darned clue how it happened.
Could feel the scratch under finger every time I used the thing thereafter. Very annoyed.
Always bought a screen protecter for every new smartphone after that one.
Better safe than sorry.

2old4toys said:
How resistant to scratching is glass vs a microscopic grain of sand?
My 1st glass fronted smartphone went without a screen protector because I'd seen lots of videos on YouTube of people going nuts with keys and knives and scissors testing and supposedly proofing the amazing scratch resistance of glass screens. Regardless I was always super careful not to have anything else in the same trouser pocket but STILL I got a scratch on the glass in the same week I'd bought it and have not a darned clue how it happened.
Could feel the scratch under finger every time I used the thing thereafter. Very annoyed.
Always bought a screen protecter for every new smartphone after that one.
Better safe than sorry.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well it's science, since sand is harder than our glass, it will scratch it. Keys aren't as hard as our glass. That's how it works. That includes gorilla glass by the way
Swyped on my Galaxy Nexus running AOKP with Franco Kernel

Screen protector. Oleophobic coating just isn't enough. If it were gorilla glass, different story
from north of the equator using my nexus

I never put my phone in my picket with anything else. Its always alone. I'm very anal
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus

This might seem overly obvious, but one of these is really the way to go as it protects your phone far better than a crappy 'stick-on' protector, for the sake of a few dollars you add a significant level of additional protection:
Flip Cover

termin8tor said:
This might seem overly obvious, but one of these is really the way to go as it protects your phone far better than a crappy 'stick-on' protector, for the sake of a few dollars you add a significant level of additional protection:
Flip Cover
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The flap gets annoying
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus

bendirkss said:
The flap gets annoying
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed. Also even though you don't put your phone with anything, there's always little things like sand that always scratch it. Trust me on this one
Swyped on my Galaxy Nexus running AOKP with Franco Kernel

kyokeun1234 said:
Agreed. Also even though you don't put your phone with anything, there's always little things like sand that always scratch it. Trust me on this one
Swyped on my Galaxy Nexus running AOKP with Franco Kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya I'll probably get one on. I fins the real cheap ones actually feel better than the expensive wet applied ones.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus

kyokeun1234 said:
Agreed. Also even though you don't put your phone with anything, there's always little things like sand that always scratch it. Trust me on this one
Swyped on my Galaxy Nexus running AOKP with Franco Kernel
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha, yeah I know the feeling. I got my Galaxy Nexus a few days ago because my Sony Xperia had a massive scratch across the screen. It happened when I left hotel keys in my pocket with the phone. Right now I'm hugely paranoid about ruining another touch screen.

Is there actually a point for screen protectors?

I let my epic 4g bounce around in my pocket for 2+ years without a scratch, and my GS3 has been doing the same. Since I'm not an idiot, I don't keep my keys in the same pocket as my phone, so why would I ever need a screen protector?
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app

Are you asking why you should put a screen protector on or asking a rhetorical question?

metalfan78 said:
Are you asking why you should put a screen protector on or asking a rhetorical question?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2

Actually, yes a screen protector would benefit you. Even if you have gorilla glass, sand is STILL stronger and will scratch your screen. I keep nothing in my right pocket but my phone and I have a few micro scratch lines. It truly does suck to rely on screen protectors but at the end of the day, another layer of armor above your screen is never a bad thing. You can't put a price on that. Spending the few extra bucks on an invisishield to keep your phones resale value is priceless.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda premium

Well... i think in order for sand to scratch your phone should you have a few grains in your pocket, I believe that would require you either being in an area where sand is a part of the environment, or where you work with sand....

haven't used one is over 20+ years and never had a problem or damaged screen !

I have a screen protector cause I like to play the "what if" game.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi

I mean if you DONT care about scratches on your screen then there isn't really a point. But if you do, like the guy said there ^^^ you can play the what if game.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app

It really depends on how you like to see your screen - scratch free or full of scratches. Cause one thing I guarantee you: it will scratch!
See, Gorilla Glass 2 is a sh#t when compared with GG1. For instance, I had my TF101 for almost a year, no screen protector, and I guess I could chop onions in there without having scratches. On the other hand, I have my S3 for nearly a month and I can spot some scratches. Well I guess in part they're my fault, I shouldn't had drunk in New Years's Eve as it would save my S3 a fall. However, apart from that I had always been very carefull, even more as I was waiting from my screen protector and case to arrive (I also got some "bruises" on the back case, true story! Don't drink unless you have an obex case or something like that, seriously... ).
The point is. For more carefull you can be accidents always happen, you can't avoid them. So, the only way to preserve your smarthphone would be to have a nice screen protector and a tight case. In my opinion, unless you're thinking in getting drunk, go to the beach, go camping, etc. you won't need an obex or a griffin, a diztronic or a zoogue would do the job.

Might as well slop Vaseline on your screen if you're going to put a screen protector on it.
Seriously, put your protected phone next to a nonprotected one with the screen on and tell me it's worth it.

$5 warranty exchange through tmobile fixes any scratches in a heartbeat... and its cheaper than buying a screen protector. Just sayin
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2

Why do people get so pissed off about stuff like this? If you don't like them don't use them, but don't give others **** for using one. As for the difference in screen quality, you clearly haven't used very available screen protector, have you? My JustLikeGlass is crystal clear, I can't see or feel a difference. I have actually put two on so was able to compare back to back.

Personally I don't like screen protectors, but I've noticed that the cheap ones off ebay gives much better feeling than Copter or likewise.

I think screen protectors are still worth it. Even though the gorilla glass is suppose to be scratch resistant, I still see people with many scratches on their screens.

DAvid_B said:
Might as well slop Vaseline on your screen if you're going to put a screen protector on it.
Seriously, put your protected phone next to a nonprotected one with the screen on and tell me it's worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the dry ones are not bad.
the responce on my gs3 with otterbox defender case+screen combo is still better than some other phones ive tried
the screen protector is not sticky so can always remove to clean case etc

Is there actually a point for this battle of the minds thread?
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

not really just some people trying to force there opionions on others.
some people me included buy phone cases with screen protecters that can take a beating becaue of the type of work we do.
one day can be working in a hospital,another a pub another a house and another indutrial
we are genurally spread thin so need phones to keep in contact and without a reliable case+screen protector we cant do our jobs.
without guys doing what we do then you would have no electricity so no internet either
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

DAvid_B said:
Seriously, put your protected phone next to a nonprotected one with the screen on and tell me it's worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you inspecting them with a microscope? As I can't tell the difference between a protected and unprotected screen.

I see no point in screen protectors because when u have it on it looks like its full of scratches until u replace it and the screen protectors scratch more easy. Gorilla glass doesn't get scratched easily by keys just watchout for sand but that scratches pretty much everything
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2

I don't think anyone is forcing any opinions on other people and this is a pretty interesting thread.
I personally hate screen protectors. I never used one on my S2 but towards the last month I had it before I got the S3, I got this pretty small scratch on it and every time I looked at it it pissed me off. Almost nobody I showed it to was able to notice it, but since I knew are it was I always noticed it. Now I have one in my Susie day 1 (2 months now) and I'm sick of it. I'm debating on taking it off. I can notice a difference.
Type R-blood