Develop Bugs

Electrostatic vs. Adhesive Screen Protectors

Hello All,
I know that I want a PET or other glass-like screen protector. Generally speaking, I never used screen protectors because they never really held up all that well and on top of that they never had the feel or look of the real thing. Now I have a scratch on my screen that is not normally visible, but I know its there.
I have run into a debacle because I know that while I am good at putting on screen protectors, I am no expert and the PET ones are harder to get perfect than the rubbery ones (which I now despise). So, recently I have seen that there are some PET/Silicone/ Electrostaic Hybrid screen protetctors and then there are still the PET with Adhesive.
Does anyone have experience with the electrostatic type and how good are they at staying on and bubbles?

I have no idea what is PET, or the different types. However, if you are talking about the one I got:
http://www.handhelditems.com/crystal-clear-screen-protector-p-135710.html
my experience is that this has great clarity, can get bubbles during applications, and they rarely come off by itself. On the many devices I've used this type of protector on, only one came off. It started in one corner, and over the course of a month with gradual lint build up the screen protector eventually got ruined. I could've washed it and reapplied for that month, but I had a spare so I was lazy. You can reapply the protectors as needed to get the application right. The bubbles that occur aren't the same as the rubbery kind. Air bubbles can easily be pushed out after application. The problem is dust that prevent the protector from adhering to screen, causing a little bubble. If the dust is really small, the bubble goes away over a day. Or, like me, you can live with it. You try getting something the size of an iPad dust free.

Bought Electrostatic - LOVE THESE!
Ok, as a preface I have owned and used screen protectors before.
I had an iPhone before the EVO and used the Griffin Ultraclear hard Protetctors ad the PowerSupportUSA products of every variety on my previous iPod products (iPod Mini 1G, 4G, Nano 1G, 5G, Shuffle 1G, Touch, iPhone) not to mention an invisible shield one or two. I gave up on the films towards the end of my Touch ownership. They always felt horrible and I could never get one absolutely perfect (didn't help that they usually were not perfectly cut).
For the Evo, I tried the InvisibleShield the first day because I remembered just how well the InvisibileShield had held up on my 5G. Well I think that they have changed the formula, or rather that 3M has since then because the smooth feel and smooth look of the original are most definitely gone. The new variety is rubbery (even after days of use) and is not cut well enough to be a perfect fit (it never covered edge to edge). So i skipped it. Well it seems that with this large of a glass screen, you are much more liable to getting scratches (versus using and unprotetcted iPhone/Touch screen) and I got a few ultra hairline ones that are barely if ever visible to the naked eye and just knowing that they are there bothered me. So I needed to think of getting a screen protector.
Seeing as how air moves and its nearly impossible to get a screen protectors on without any bit of dust, I decided on getting the electrostatic variety so that I could rinse if it came off or needed to be reapplied.
I bought These: Electrostatic Screen Protector - Clear Hard
- Hard variety (PET)
- Very Clear
- Silicone Layer (helps the scratches and dents heal themselves and give sturdiness to the PET)
- Electrostatic layer (holds the screen protector onto the phone)
Six pack delivered for $4? I could do much worse.
Well as it turns out, they are PERFECTLY cut and cover every inch of screen and no more. It went on smooth as butter and I got no bubbles or dust or fingerprints or anything (used a credit card to smooth it down). These were by far the easiest I have had. Not only that, but the electrostatic holds on just as strong as the sticky variety and will not get the gunk on the sides sticking to it! I have taken my TPU case on and off a bunch and had no lift whatsoever. As a bonus, THEY SHOW FINGERPRINTS MUCH LESS THAN THE GLASS SCREEN DOES!
So at $0.65 each, they are killer and having a few backups is nice as well as giving one to a friend.
Cheers!

Thanks for that post. I'm expecting my EVOs (I ordered 2) in within the next week. I've been trying hard to find cases and screen protectors without much luck, but I'm going to go ahead and order those screen protectors you mentioned since you recommend them.

Yep i ordered the same ones and love them. i have loved these from the start. they are quite easy to put on and stay on well.

Scotch tape is your friend in getting screen protectors on without a bit of dust

Childofthehorn said:
Hello All,
I know that I want a PET or other glass-like screen protector. Generally speaking, I never used screen protectors because they never really held up all that well and on top of that they never had the feel or look of the real thing. Now I have a scratch on my screen that is not normally visible, but I know its there.
I have run into a debacle because I know that while I am good at putting on screen protectors, I am no expert and the PET ones are harder to get perfect than the rubbery ones (which I now despise). So, recently I have seen that there are some PET/Silicone/ Electrostaic Hybrid screen protetctors and then there are still the PET with Adhesive.
Does anyone have experience with the electrostatic type and how good are they at staying on and bubbles?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a steinheil ultra crystal protector on my EVO, and its static. As long as you make sure there is no debris under it, it will stay on for a long time with no lifting. I have shown my phone to quite a few people, and not one of them can tell I have a screen protector on it. Even when I point it out to them, they still cant see it. It's very thin and I applied it perfectly so their a no bubbles. Took me about 30 minutes to get it perfect. If you use a piece of scotch tape to pick up debris under it, that works pretty good. This biggest thing is to make sure your edges are perfectly clean. Even the slightest bit of debris under one of the edges of the screen protector, and it wont be long before it starts peeling. I'm very satisfied with my steinheil. Going on 5 weeks now and it looks flawless. Id take a picture but you wouldnt be able to see it anyways. I thought it was a scam spending $13 on a screen protector! I used to order them from china for 50 cents. well, never doing that again! I've only ever used 1 adhesive type screen protector, and it was terrible. the clarity was awful.

OneStepAhead said:
I have a steinheil ultra crystal protector on my EVO, and its static. As long as you make sure there is no debris under it, it will stay on for a long time with no lifting. I have shown my phone to quite a few people, and not one of them can tell I have a screen protector on it. Even when I point it out to them, they still cant see it. It's very thin and I applied it perfectly so their a no bubbles. Took me about 30 minutes to get it perfect. If you use a piece of scotch tape to pick up debris under it, that works pretty good. This biggest thing is to make sure your edges are perfectly clean. Even the slightest bit of debris under one of the edges of the screen protector, and it wont be long before it starts peeling. I'm very satisfied with my steinheil. Going on 5 weeks now and it looks flawless. Id take a picture but you wouldnt be able to see it anyways. I thought it was a scam spending $13 on a screen protector! I used to order them from china for 50 cents. well, never doing that again! I've only ever used 1 adhesive type screen protector, and it was terrible. the clarity was awful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have not seen these yet. where did you get yours and do you know if they offer an anti-glare

xlrdxrevengex said:
Have not seen these yet. where did you get yours and do you know if they offer an anti-glare
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Their anti-fingerprint screen protector is also anti-glare per the product description on their website.
http://www.sgpstore.com/product_info.php/cPath/23_33/products_id/1463

remedy22 said:
Their anti-fingerprint screen protector is also anti-glare per the product description on their website.
http://www.sgpstore.com/product_info.php/cPath/23_33/products_id/1463
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks for the link. Can anyone find this brand cheaper

xlrdxrevengex said:
thanks for the link. Can anyone find this brand cheaper
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think so.
But these are $13 well spent. Believe me.
~fb

[Q] Screen protector or not?

Do you or do you not? I personally think its overkill. Screens are getting stronger and stronger and granted theres never going to be a 100% solution but for the time being my Folio case does a good job of protecting however inconvenient it is ;-)

I use a screen protector. While there are options for more and more durable glass, that is not a guarantee that the device you are using has it. My g2 for instance has 2 scratches on the screen and I was generally careful in my handling of it. if it is not known to be gorilla glass then i would get some form of protection, either a case of a screen protector. The thing that pushed me over the edge with the xoom is that I decided to go caseless for now. None of the cases out right now appeal to me.
Sent from my Xoom using XDA App

I am not worried about protection as much as I am with the extreme glare and fingerprints. I had the same issue on my Samsung Captivate and Invisible Shield helped dramatically. I ordered the same for Xoom and hope it has the same results.

I have a portfolio case. Idont believe there is a need for a screen protector. Gorilla glass is strong. plus i dont believe there be casual scratches like with a phone and keys in my pocket

I think with most new devices having gorilla glass, its only precautionary to get a screen protector. I have had a droid X since release and have never had a screen protector and the screen is just like the day i got it. But we are talking about a 800.00 device, so then its not a bad idea to cover your investment.

I normally go without a case but for my Xoom I will get one just to help with the fingeprints.
Dave
Sent from my Xoom using XDA App

Screen Protector and Silicone Case FTW

once stienheil releases an anti glare/fingerprint protector I think ill make a purchase because as stated, the fingerprints are terrible on this and they don't wipe off very easy.

I totally love the Frogz antiglare screen protection I have on my iPhone. Happy with it. Have 2 left. =]
Though not antiglare as none were available, I did bought 3x screen protection and of course they are cheap. As soon as they arrived, I tried to carefully apply to my Xoom but I failed after every attempt which resulted in me wasting all 3. Waste of money. ="(
The screen protections (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dl...5Wo6dic%3D&viewitem=&sspagename=STRK:MEWNX:IT) I received were not perfect fit for Xoom as they are claimed to be.
I'm waiting for Frogz or other to start selling antiglare for Xoom...

I would say it's overkill.
Back in those days with plastic resistive touch screen, a screen protector was necessary. But nowadays, a typical glass surface (even for non-Gorilla glass) is hard enough that it's rather hard to scratch it. If you drop your device, the glass may shatter, and screen protector is not going to help with that. And if you hit the screen hard with something sharp and strong enough to dent it, it will probably dent through the protector too. I have been using my HTC Desire without any screen protector for almost a year now, and it is still completely scratch-free.
Another reason not to use a screen protector is that they tend to be less oil- and fingerprint-proof. While Apple is the only company advertising that they have an oleophobic coating on their screens to make them more fingerprint-proof, the fact is that most glass screens has such a coating, even though it was not advertised. And most cheap screen protectors don't (can't speak for all of them, probably some more expensive ones have such coating... I don't know). I've tried some screen protectors and I found that oil and fingerprint left on the glass are much easier to remove than those left on the screen protector.
That being said, if you really really hate glossy screen, you may want to put an anti-glare type screen protector on your device. I have one on my iPad. This type of screen protector does create some sparking effect with white background, or make the texts blurry. But they don't look too bad for me, compared to the shiny glare of the iPad...

Are we sure that it uses Gorilla Glass? Ive seen a lot of people alluding to that but no actual statement, and its not on the official Corning list.
I like Steinheil as well, I've had good luck on my phones with them but they are slow to get new sizes out sometimes.

I want something only to reduce glare and fingerprints.
If installing it ends up screwing with touch sensitivity, I'll stick to stock.
Sent from my Xoom using XDA App

When I had an iPod touch, I thought screen protectors would ruin the experience. I soon learned two things.
1. Glass is a finger print magnet.
and
2. You never know when something unexpected will come into contact with your screen. After getting a few scratches from dropping my iPod between my car seat, I decided to get a screen protector.
I got a screen protector from Verizon the day I got my Droid, and put it on right there at the counter. The metal casing of the phone is dinged up, scratched, paint is chipped, etc, but the screen is flawless.

FWIW, I've only put a Body Glove case around my EVO, but have dropped it 4-5 times (in fact, the BG case is warped at one corner after the last drop- been pretty clumsy lately ). Despite leaving my screen unprotected (and it's not GG) these 9 mos, it's still quite pristine despite all the drops and the zillions of touches (and debris, had a cold a couple of months ago!).
So. I have the silicone case (which does prevent me from using all but one iPad stand out there I tried), but no screen protector.

arrtoodeetoo said:
I got a screen protector from Verizon the day I got my Droid, and put it on right there at the counter. The metal casing of the phone is dinged up, scratched, paint is chipped, etc, but the screen is flawless.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Funny, my Droid looks the same, with no screen protector!

I don't have a screen protector, and I don't plan on getting one. I don't have one on my og droid and I've had it since launch with no issues. Plus I can never get those things on right lol
Sent from my Xoom using XDA App

I think the answer to this is yes unfortunately.
I haven't had it out of the house, haven't knocked it, dropped it, poked it or anything else and I already have a spot on the screen that I can't get off with Microfiber/Distilled water.
Thats pretty darn annoying.

Screen protector

What screen protector are you using/plan on using? I got the zagg for the Incredible 2 as I don't think there's too many made for the phone yet aside from on eBay. It's my first zagg, and its alright. Would prefer something less sticky feeling though.
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA Premium App

Gorilla Glass. No screen protector needed.

bsteenson said:
Gorilla Glass. No screen protector needed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe not for fear of scratches, but one is definitely still desirable to help keep the buildup of various gunk on the screen down. All of those skin oils from fingers and the side of one's face add up over time, not to mention if the user has makeup, hairspray, hair gel, or any other number of products that get on the screen. If all of that isn't promptly cleaned off, it can become increasingly difficult to remove.
I'm considering picking up an Incredible 2, and if I do, I'll be picking this up:
http://www.amazon.com/Seidio-Ultimate-Screen-Guard-Incredible/dp/B004XC6LMM/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1305296213&sr=8-2
After years of using every type of screen protector known to man, I've found Seidio's to be some of the easiest to apply (and reapply if necessary), they don't reduce the "feel" or touch sensitivity of the screen, and they last (the packages typically come with two, but I've never had to replace the first one I put on). I used them on my Droid X and currently have one on my Droid Pro.

bsweetness said:
Maybe not for fear of scratches, but one is definitely still desirable to help keep the buildup of various gunk on the screen down. All of those skin oils from fingers and the side of one's face add up over time, not to mention if the user has makeup, hairspray, hair gel, or any other number of products that get on the screen. If all of that isn't promptly cleaned off, it can become increasingly difficult to remove.
I'm considering picking up an Incredible 2, and if I do, I'll be picking this up:
http://www.amazon.com/Seidio-Ultima...6LMM/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1305296213&sr=8-2
After years of using every type of screen protector known to man, I've found Seidio's to be some of the easiest to apply (and reapply if necessary), they don't reduce the "feel" or touch sensitivity of the screen, and they last (the packages typically come with two, but I've never had to replace the first one I put on). I used them on my Droid X and currently have one on my Droid Pro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will take a look at that one thanks. I agree I feel like a screen protector is worthwhile just in case. I removed the zagg though and am using the one that came with the otterbox case now, which has a texture nearly identical to the bare screen. I didn't like the slight tackiness of the feel on the zagg.
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA Premium App

bsweetness said:
Maybe not for fear of scratches, but one is definitely still desirable to help keep the buildup of various gunk on the screen down. All of those skin oils from fingers and the side of one's face add up over time, not to mention if the user has makeup, hairspray, hair gel, or any other number of products that get on the screen. If all of that isn't promptly cleaned off, it can become increasingly difficult to remove.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't know about this phone, because I've only had it a couple of weeks. But based on 16 months experience with the original Motorola Droid, I'd give the screen a quick huff of breath to provide a little moisture then wipe away with a microfibre cloth. I could polish that sucker until it was like brand new with only a little effort. After 16 months that Droid screen is still as smooth, slick and damage-free as the new Inc2 screen fresh from the box.
If you want a screen protector go for it, but I seriously can't see any need or benefit.

I originally had the VzW screen protector that came with the "starter kit". It was an anti-glare style.
I hated it. It was only as big as the LCD so it did not cover the buttons or the top, etc...
The anti-glare washed the screen out IMO.
I ended up ordering the Seido ones bsweetness mentions above - I could not be happier!

Currently have the one from VZW that is the anti-glare one. Probably the same one nayr and others have had. I don't have any issues with it, but I may be a bit more forgiving I guess.

Never used a screen protector on my Eris. It never had a scratch on the display. It was very easy to give it a quick wipe if needed. I had used keys on my Eris' display to show people why screen protectors really aren't all that better than a bare display.
The tempered glass on the I2 is much better than what was on my Eris. I still don't use a screen protector. I've taken a blade to the glass and it wouldn't scratch. It's easy to wipe off. No special cloth or cleaner required for typical use. Occasional cleaner might be needed with rough use.
Nothing will protect your display from a drop. That's my only worry.

I use Seidio screen protectors for my DroidX and my wife's Inc2 and I have been very happy with them
http://www.seidioonline.com/product-p/spm1htncs.htm
It's so clear that I don't even remember that I have a protector on sometimes
I buy the 2-pack just in case, I still haven't used the second one for my DroidX

Realook is hands down the best screen protectors i've used. It's too bad that they don't make it for the inc 2 yet.
They're completely invisible when applied, they feel exactly like the glass. I ended up purchasing the zagg invisible shield even though I hate how they "stick" when you try and use the phone. Although it gets better when you use it over time.

I think i'm just going to do without one untill a realook is available. Those things are the best thing since sliced bread when it comes to screen protectors.

Zagg InvisibleShield. 100%
(i work for Best Buy so I'm biased)
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA App

Check out the Carbon Fiber Skin!
Their screen protectors are pretty badass too.
http://www.skinomi.com/htcdrin2p.html

otter box commuter case, naked screen.

TheAtheistReverend said:
Check out the Carbon Fiber Skin!
Their screen protectors are pretty badass too.
http://www.skinomi.com/htcdrin2p.html
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't care for cases, but that carbon fiber one I might actually consider.

nimdae said:
I don't care for cases, but that carbon fiber one I might actually consider.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I feel the same way about skins, but that has me reconsidering. Take a good look at the edges of the raised areas though-where there are seams. They're easier to see in the silver version, but I think it would look better in the black...
Sorry this is a little off-topic

I have a full skinomi carbon fiber skin on my gTablet and it worked out great. So, I decided to get the skinomi screen protector for my Dinc2. It turned out HORRIBLE.
Skinomi sent me replacements 2 separate times and each one was defective. I tried out the Clarivue screens and I'm really happy with them. They stick extremely well and are like glass. Yes, you have finger prints but doesn't bother me.
clarivue.com/htc-incredible-2-screen-protector.html

SGP just released their Inc2 films. Sadly only UC and UF. No UOptics or UOleo. Seriously considering it just to make the metal/glass edge not as steep...

I just received both the anti glare and the crystal boxwave protectors after a lot of deliberation. to those using the verizon antiglare protectors who are afraid of the rainbow effect of ag screen protectors, don't hesitate to get the boxwave antiglare. The rainbow effect is barely noticeable. Very happy with these protectors (enough to actually post in this forum).

When I had my D1, people always asked me how I kept my screen safe. I laughed, mentioned gorilla glass, and then pummeled the screen with my key. The look of horror on their face was priceless, almost as good as the amazement when I showed them that the screen was fine. That's why I never understood the whole rugged thing. I mean, my little buddy was a champ, and all I used was the standard hard case Vzw gave me. Of course, I haven't tried that with my Dinc2 yet, seeing as I've had it less than a month, but I can imagine a similar result. That hasn't stopped me from getting a screen protector this time around, though

Opinions on Screen Protection?

I am considering switching from the LG G2 to a N5, and I wanted to get some opinions on the matter. I have scoured the internet(including xda) for hours, and I keep getting wildly varying reports from different sources. My concern is that the N5 is very easily scratched.
https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/nexus/WBQyoSwdQTw
I used a screen protector on the Photon before saying "screw it" and going naked, and I've used the G2 naked for 5 months. Both screens are still in pristine condition, despite being older revisions of Gorilla Glass(GG1 and GG2, respectively).
My concern is that the N5 is for some reason abnormally easy to scratch. I baby my phones a bit, but not excessively(I put it in a separate pocket with the glass to my thigh, I try not to beat the thing with my finger, nothing crazy...). I figure with the fact that I work in some pretty dusty climates, if dust/sand were an issue, my G2 would be far from pristine. I enjoy the naked feeling, but I'm not sure I feel right purchasing a $40 Tempered Glass protector(that I may need to replace a few times over a year, plus it appears to be a struggle to apply with the fact that the display has a dimple in it). Even though I won't use plastic again, it was nice when it got scratched because it was a few bucks to replace, not 10-15% the cost of the whole phone.
So basically my question is to the people rolling naked(well that sounds wrong...), what are your experiences? I really don't agree with protectors, but my OCD doesn't agree with tiny scratches. Thanks!

I roll naked.
I also don't use a screen protector
I've had my N5 since launch day. I would say I "baby" my phone in that I don't do anything with it that is particularly hard on it. If I shine a flashlight on it or have it outside on a sunny day I can see a few "microscratches" that reflect light but are completely smooth to the touch. Apart from that I don't notice anything, even under bright fluorescent lights in my office.

I don't know why this gets brought up so much. If you're worried so much about scratches then get a protector. If you don't like plastic then get glass... You'll wish you did after replacing several plastic ones. The issues you bring up regarding the glass ones and the dimple on the screen has been long fixed and is no longer an issue. Just spend $35 for a Spigen or ~$20 for a Nillkin glass screen protector and be done with it. Its hardly a waste of money and the protectors are more durable than the actual screen.

You dont really need a screen protector but I have an Invisible Shield on mine and its great, I have one really dense scratch on it that you can only see when the screen is on and you look carefully, that will go away when I peel it off. If you are buying a screen protector make sure it goes with the case you get, some cases might peel off the edges of your protector and ruin it.

Dont really think a screen protector is necessary. I have not used one on my old Note 2 or my htc evo before that. N5 has GG3 which does make it a more scratch resistant. Not running a screen protector

I like the HD clear screen protectors by Halo. They have the best edge to edge protection compared to several others that I have tried on my N5. Amazon link - http://goo.gl/hU0NPg

iloome flex. All I have to say.

People say you dont need it, until you **** up your screen, looking at my screen right now, its got some fat scratches, except it doesn't, cause the scratches are on the screen protector.

If there's any chance you could get sand or dust in your pocket at any time GET A SCREEN PROTECTOR!
It only took a really small amount of dirt/sand getting in my pocket during a camping trip to hammer my first N5 with scratches.

Tempered glass is great option, u will avoid both scratches and have better protection for the screen in case u drop it, which I do, not often but occasionally

I use MediaDevil Magicscreen Screen Protector on my Nexus 5 http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00GCG3MY2/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I bought the Spigen Case Slim for the N5 and it came with a free screen protector!!! It works like a charm, for the price of the two, £7 it was a bargain!!! The screen protector is very good also...
It's very clear and your finger doesn't get stuck by no means...

While GG3 is more scratch resistant to keys/knives, I believe it's not more resistant to dust which is the biggest issue when it comes to scratches. My first N5 I didn't have a screen protector on it because I ended up RMA'ing it. It already had some micro-scratches. Again, you can't feel them and barely see them unless you look for them but they're still there so it depends on how much you care about that. I also keep my phone by itself in my pocket with the screen to my leg and they still happen because of the dust. I've been using a screen protector ever since I received the 2nd phone.

How does the glass hold up?

I've have my 2XL since October 21. I've had ZAGG glass curve on it since nearly day one. I've just cracked my third one. None of the times I've cracked it I've dropped it. Both times I've pulled it out of my pocked and noticed a chip in the middle on the side and it spiders out from there over the next few days. I've had glass protectors on my last couple of phones (S4, Moto X Pure) and never had issues with either of them cracking. Sure I replaced due to wear over time, but never because they broke.
I'm not sending Zagg another $10 for a new one. So I'm wondering how the factory glass holds up. Can I just go naked? Is it just the crappy edge only adhesive on the zagg curve? Looking for other peoples experiences and willing to listen to any advice others may have. I'm going to be pissed scratching up the factory screen and I really don't think I can go back to a "film" type protector.

Here's a thread on this:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3780637
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

DaMadOne said:
I've have my 2XL since October 21. I've had ZAGG glass curve on it since nearly day one. I've just cracked my third one. None of the times I've cracked it I've dropped it. Both times I've pulled it out of my pocked and noticed a chip in the middle on the side and it spiders out from there over the next few days. I've had glass protectors on my last couple of phones (S4, Moto X Pure) and never had issues with either of them cracking. Sure I replaced due to wear over time, but never because they broke.
I'm not sending Zagg another $10 for a new one. So I'm wondering how the factory glass holds up. Can I just go naked? Is it just the crappy edge only adhesive on the zagg curve? Looking for other peoples experiences and willing to listen to any advice others may have. I'm going to be pissed scratching up the factory screen and I really don't think I can go back to a "film" type protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've had mine as long as you have. Screen still looks fine without any scratches that I can see. Granted, I take care of my phone, but I don't exactly baby it either. It's been dropped more than a few times, and wound up in my pocket with car keys, and still no bad scratches that I can see. I think if your an average user, and don't work in a construction zone, you'll be fine without a protector :good:

DaMadOne said:
I've have my 2XL since October 21. I've had ZAGG glass curve on it since nearly day one. I've just cracked my third one. None of the times I've cracked it I've dropped it. Both times I've pulled it out of my pocked and noticed a chip in the middle on the side and it spiders out from there over the next few days. I've had glass protectors on my last couple of phones (S4, Moto X Pure) and never had issues with either of them cracking. Sure I replaced due to wear over time, but never because they broke.
I'm not sending Zagg another $10 for a new one. So I'm wondering how the factory glass holds up. Can I just go naked? Is it just the crappy edge only adhesive on the zagg curve? Looking for other peoples experiences and willing to listen to any advice others may have. I'm going to be pissed scratching up the factory screen and I really don't think I can go back to a "film" type protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd say don't risk it I had my phone since January got Google's screen protector loved it finger prints and smudges where non existent until just a couple weeks ago when I also dropped my phone on the ground and it landed facedown on a rock only the screen protector broke
So I bought a zagg even though a few bad reviews all saying screen breaks too easy I have had this one for a week so far and accedently step on my phone trying to get into the shower did not break my screen so far I'm having no issues except smudges already on day one.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

I have given up on screen protectors for this device.
The only ones that cover the entire device are made from plastic/rubber (aka liquid skin) lol. These make no sense, they offer no actual protection to the screen and they feel like crap and look just as bad on the device.
Than you have the tempered glass protectors. You have the option of partial screen coverage, which also ruins the aesthetics of the curved glass. Or you can get the "full coverage" option that claims to have "3d, curved glass". This is by far the worst option available. These manufactures of this garbage even go as far to list serious flaws of their design as selling points in their descriptions. The most glaring examples being, "with Dot Matrix" and "updated adhesive" This is so ridiculous, the "updated adhesive" is just horrible glue that they use on the top and bottom edges of the protector and the "dot matrix" is a full coverage of spaced out semi clear dots that are sold as being added for extra touch sensitivity, when in reality the dots are only added because the screen protector is not actually curved glass, it is flat glass connected to a top and bottom edge made of black plastic. The curved plastic edges are black for one, if they were actually glass that means they painted or tinted the top and bottom edges for no reason other than to have wasted money. And because there are 3 pieces to the protector, with the top and bottom responsible for adhering the protector to the screen, the "dot matrix" is needed because the middle piece is not actually mated to the screen. Any quality screen protector claiming to be tempered glass, does not need a dot matrix and is fully adhered to the screen with a clear silicone adhesive.
in conclusion, the pixel 2 xl has corning gorilla glass 5, this is the best glass currently available on the market. So being as none of the protectors available actually protect against cracked or broken displays, there is no need to waste your time with a screen protector. the only thing that the horrible protectors actually offer is scratch resistance, so unless you keep your phone in your pocket with coins all the time don't bother wasting your time or money on a screen protector.

Had mine without a screen protector since launch, and my screen has noticable scratches, etc.

Don't risk it. Whitestone is pricey $50. But feels like regular screen and removes the worry about damaging this great investment.
G

+1 on Whitestone

I've had mine since 10/24/2018 and no issues. I haven't ever used screen protectors. I tried on a phone several years ago but after like 3 attempts and still not being able to get it on without air bubbles I gave up. Although, I do have a bumper case that gives it a gap to protect from drops. Between that and the Gorilla Glass I've never had an issue. Plus, if I do have an issue I have the Pixel protect plan to take care of that.