Hi everyone,
I have a rather sticky problem. A few hours ago I decided to disable a few of the services that I wasn't using on my phone in the hope of some more free memory and battery saving. The services where things like Stocks (including it's widgets and tools), weather, some pre-installed apps like Sound hound and a few others. As far as I could tell none were critical system services. After finishing I rebooted my phone to check the outcome....and it was not pretty....
Phone boots and everything seems to be loading fine (interface, startup apps, notifications), but my desktop is blank, none of the three soft buttons work and the only thing that works is the power button (to reboot). ah, actually the main menu (sliding from top) works, it slides down but whatever I select from it, the menu closes and nothing would happen. I assume I disabled a service that was in dependency with HTC Sense service and now that service is failing to load...?, correct me if I'm wrong.
At this point I have no clue as to what to do except to try to see if I can root the phone again, any ideas on how I can fix this without rooting the phone?
(I have no backup, no version info...nothing..., I wasn't expecting anything like this to happen while messing with non-critical app services so I did not go through the "backing up everything" procedure... sadly... )
Would much appreciate help/advise/pointers with respect to the following:
The problem: multi windows does not work. Long press on the “back” key just does not have any effect whatsoever.
Yes, multi-window toggle is on. Yes, cleared data, cache, restarted, used garlic and holy water, etc, to no avail. Yes, I’ve read through the forums extensively, and did not find any info related to my problem.
Tried to install multi-window manager from the play store, same nothing. Checked apk, permissions, etc. – all seems to be in fine order. The only thing that seems suspicious is that /data/data/com.sec.android.app.FlashBarService is empty – which kind of suggests to my amateurish mind that something somewhere does not get started. Checked that services framework is up, but that’s about the limit of my diagnostic skills on Android.
Oh yeah, running latest OTA version of AT&T 4.2.1 Note 2 stock, rooted.
Any ideas?
Thanks.
Really strange issue just started occurring today as far as I can tell. I am on a Google Pixel XL, unlocked, rooted (with Magisk), running latest 8.1 with Feb security patch. This morning I have started experiencing a very strange issue with making phone calls with my phone. Regardless if I use a home screen direct dial shortcut, attempt to dial from within contacts, from call log, etc...I experience a VERY long delay between attempting to place the call and the call actually being made. Upwards of 30 sec or even much longer. I just used the stopwatch app to time a 3 min 10 sec. delay between the time I attempted to make a call by pressing the phone icon next to a recent call in the call log and when the phone actually "dialed" the call. Between the pressing of the button and the actual making of the call - there was no indication the phone had even accepted the input. I have never seen this behavior and it just started today. I have frozen my Call Control app (spam call filtering), Cleared cache and data for the "Phone" app. Disabled Advanced LTE Calling. I'm at a loss...the last app update on the "Phone" app was Feb 7, 2018
Anyone else experienced this or any suggestions? I have searched the forums and reddit and there appear to be some similar issues being reported - but nothing widespread. Any suggestions welcomed.
EDIT: The issue does not occur when booted into safe mode. So now I am hunting for which most recent app update is causing the issue. Good times.
Thanks!
S
sb1893 said:
Really strange issue just started occurring today as far as I can tell. I am on a Google Pixel XL, unlocked, rooted (with Magisk), running latest 8.1 with Feb security patch. This morning I have started experiencing a very strange issue with making phone calls with my phone. Regardless if I use a home screen direct dial shortcut, attempt to dial from within contacts, from call log, etc...I experience a VERY long delay between attempting to place the call and the call actually being made. Upwards of 30 sec or even much longer. I just used the stopwatch app to time a 3 min 10 sec. delay between the time I attempted to make a call by pressing the phone icon next to a recent call in the call log and when the phone actually "dialed" the call. Between the pressing of the button and the actual making of the call - there was no indication the phone had even accepted the input. I have never seen this behavior and it just started today. I have frozen my Call Control app (spam call filtering), Cleared cache and data for the "Phone" app. Disabled Advanced LTE Calling. I'm at a loss...the last app update on the "Phone" app was Feb 7, 2018
Anyone else experienced this or any suggestions? I have searched the forums and reddit and there appear to be some similar issues being reported - but nothing widespread. Any suggestions welcomed.
EDIT: The issue does not occur when booted into safe mode. So now I am hunting for which most recent app update is causing the issue. Good times.
Thanks!
S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Update: No idea what is going on - but I think I resolved the issue accidentally. I connected my Pixel XL to my computer to try to capture a logcat while the issue was occurring to see if I could find a clue as to the offending app. However, I was unable to reproduce the issue while running the logcat. I disconnected from my computer and now the issue is resolved. Phone calls can be made and respond immediately. This is after multiple reboots, clearing cache, data on phone app, etc did not resolve the issue and it could be readily reproduced.....not sure why the simple act of connecting to computer and running a logcat could have resolved. But oh well.
sb1893 said:
Update: No idea what is going on - but I think I resolved the issue accidentally. I connected my Pixel XL to my computer to try to capture a logcat while the issue was occurring to see if I could find a clue as to the offending app. However, I was unable to reproduce the issue while running the logcat. I disconnected from my computer and now the issue is resolved. Phone calls can be made and respond immediately. This is after multiple reboots, clearing cache, data on phone app, etc did not resolve the issue and it could be readily reproduced.....not sure why the simple act of connecting to computer and running a logcat could have resolved. But oh well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And....issue has recurred. This time after making successfully making call over lunch while connected to Bluetooth system in my car. After that first call...all other calls were impacted by the 30 sec to 2 min delay before going thru. I've tried installing older version of Google Connectivity Services and that did not resolve the issue as well as using the Pixel Launcher (I normally use Nova). Once again, I was able to clear up the issue by simply connecting my phone to my computer via USB. (Didn't even run any commands within ADB this time - just connected phone and was able to make immediate calls again.) So now I think something related to connecting to my car bluetooth system is the culprit. But that car bluetooth version hasn't changed in a long time. And this has never happened before this morning. (I did use bluetooth in the car to make a call this morning when I first noticed the issue.) I'm at a loss. I'll keep playing with it I guess. Hopefully whatever got messed up gets corrected with another update soon.
sb1893 said:
And....issue has recurred. This time after making successfully making call over lunch while connected to Bluetooth system in my car. After that first call...all other calls were impacted by the 30 sec to 2 min delay before going thru. I've tried installing older version of Google Connectivity Services and that did not resolve the issue as well as using the Pixel Launcher (I normally use Nova). Once again, I was able to clear up the issue by simply connecting my phone to my computer via USB. (Didn't even run any commands within ADB this time - just connected phone and was able to make immediate calls again.) So now I think something related to connecting to my car bluetooth system is the culprit. But that car bluetooth version hasn't changed in a long time. And this has never happened before this morning. (I did use bluetooth in the car to make a call this morning when I first noticed the issue.) I'm at a loss. I'll keep playing with it I guess. Hopefully whatever got messed up gets corrected with another update soon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The saga continues. The issue occurs immediately after the first call I attempt when connected to my BMW bluetooth system. From that point on, I experience a 30 sec to 3 min delay between attempting to make a call and the Pixel XL actually initiating the call. The quickest way I have found to resolve the issue is to plug the phone into a charger for a few seconds and I am then again able to place calls. I have verified that the BMW bluetooth software is up to date and has not been updated in over a year. (Again - this issue just started happening yesterday...and I've been on Feb security patch for several weeks). I just cleared cache from within Titanium Backup. Will see if that improves the situation. Very weird. I also was just able to recreate the issue using just a simple Plantronics headset. So I continue to think it is something related to the Bluetooth stack on the phone. But I am not sure how to check to see if any of that has been updated via app update since I upgraded to Feb security patches. (I reproduced the issue at my desk using the headset after clearing cache.)
S
Any news on this? This is absolutely killing me. Sometimes a hard reset stops fixes it, sometimes now. I bought this phone for almost $1,000 in April last year and it can't make phone calls. Pretty bad bug to say the least.
Racermanz said:
Any news on this? This is absolutely killing me. Sometimes a hard reset stops fixes it, sometimes now. I bought this phone for almost $1,000 in April last year and it can't make phone calls. Pretty bad bug to say the least.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No - but I'm at least somewhat encouraged to know I am not the only one dealing with the issue. Today I flashed factory images (but preserved my data by removing the -w from the flash-all.bat)...that did not resolve. I've tried the reset app preferences, reboot suggestion I found elsewhere - no dice. Google pushed a new Phone app yesterday - that also did not resolve. I've even tried uninstalling Magisk completely and dropping back to 15.4 - also no help. I'm running out of ideas. I've taken to carrying a charging cable in my car...so if I absolutely need to make a call when the phone isn't behaving, I can just quickly plug it in...which does clear up the issue temporarily. Also keep a charging cable at my desk now...so I'm limping along..but for an issue that just appeared out of nowhere this week...it's been pretty frustating to deal with. Also - I no longer believe being currently connected to Bluetooth is related to the issue. I've been able to get the issue to occur today while not connected to any bluetooth devices.
Try
settings>system>developer options>media>disable USB audio routing
DR3W5K1 said:
Try
settings>system>developer options>media>disable USB audio routing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks bros. This is such a strange bug. Right now it works before I have turned off USB audio routing. I have turned off USB audio routing. I will report back if this DOESNT work. If I don't post again we can assume this works.
Thanks DR3W5K1, great name bro.
DR3W5K1 said:
Try
settings>system>developer options>media>disable USB audio routing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just tried to toggle on, which looks to mean Disable. Then rebooted. No luck. Issue still occurs. Thanks for the suggestion. Willing to try anything even to just eliminate as possibility at this point.
Well - I have found a better workaround. When you attempt a call, if you get no response, you can toggle Airplane mode "ON"....You will then see the call you attempted fail. When you turn Airplane mode back "Off" you can can successfully make calls again. Better than having to plug into a charger cable to get the attempted call "unstuck"....still no idea what is going on....but this workaround at least is more palatable, portable, and take a few seconds...hope someone can figure out root cause soon and a proper fix becomes available.
EDIT: Even better workaround. Toggling Mobile Data OFF and ON has the same effect of clearing the issue. And works better when connected to Bluetooth in car as those connections will be maintained vs. using Airplane mode toggle. So - issue seems to be related to Mobile Data somehow - but I have already had Advanced Calling / LTE, etc...turned off as one of my first steps in troubleshooting this issue.
Has OP been down the road of looking at any and all apps installed that are interacting with the Phone permission? I remember snapchat was causing weird beeps for people when making calls until the permission was manually revoked.
Maybe some app is having a bad interaction?
Try changing the network mode in the secret menu dial *#*#4636#*#* to get there
The.Yield said:
Has OP been down the road of looking at any and all apps installed that are interacting with the Phone permission? I remember snapchat was causing weird beeps for people when making calls until the permission was manually revoked.
Maybe some app is having a bad interaction?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have tried that. Sorry for not mentioning it in this thread. At one point I revoked "Phone" permission from all apps other than Phone, Carrier Services, and Contacts. Rebooted. Issue still occurred.
DR3W5K1 said:
Try changing the network mode in the secret menu dial *#*#4636#*#* to get there
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ahhh...I had forgotten about this secret menu. Looks like I could permanently toggle off VoLTE, WifiCalling, etc...here. But - not sure I want to go that route...I'm OK at present with Toggling Mobile Data via Quick Settings tile. And hopefully this issue eventually gets solved as mysteriously as it was introduced via some update.
Having the same problems on OG Pixel XL 8.1 with February security patches. All apps latest up to date.
Have tried uninstalling latest Phone app update. Clearing Phone app cache, etc nothing works. Network mode change, SIM reinstall, Network type change.
Only airplane mode toggle will fix it.
FYI mobile data toggle does NOT fix it for me, only airplane toggle. I wonder if network data toggle will only fix it if you are on a network provider currently doing calling over mobile data. Im on TMobile with great LTE coverage, but the mobile data toggle doesn't work for me.
tesla45 said:
Having the same problems on OG Pixel XL 8.1 with February security patches. All apps latest up to date.
Have tried uninstalling latest Phone app update. Clearing Phone app cache, etc nothing works. Network mode change, SIM reinstall, Network type change.
Only airplane mode toggle will fix it.
FYI mobile data toggle does NOT fix it for me, only airplane toggle. I wonder if network data toggle will only fix it if you are on a network provider currently doing calling over mobile data. Im on TMobile with great LTE coverage, but the mobile data toggle doesn't work for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting....I'm on Verizon and I do believe that they route calls over Mobile data at times. I'm going to stay tuned, but likely done with much more deep investigation at the moment. I've spent enough time down this particular rabbit hole and the Mobile Data toggle is workable for me (not ideal, obviously)...hopefully a permanent fix materializes soon. Thanks to all for their suggestions and moral support. Much appreciated.
OK WORKAROUND FOR ANSWERING CALLS UPDATE:
Found this floating on some other forum, not sure where after this mad dash of a search I did this morning, but original credit to them...
When you receive a call and the phone is active and unlocked, press the power button to lock the phone and bring up the blue call management screen. Now you can swipe to answer.
This seems to work for more than one test call as I've tried this multiple times in a row.
NO REAL WORKAROUND FOR MAKING CALLS YET (outside of airplane mode toggle, or using Google voice/hangouts to place calls).
GOOGLE SUPPORT - THIS IS CLEARLY A SOFTWARE ISSUE, not a 3rd party app issue either since the problem goes away for answering calls when you press the lock screen or toggle airplane mode for placing calls. Please STOP ASKING CUSTOMERS TO invest hours of time (or money) FACTORY RESETTING PHONES, or REPLACING/BUYING NEW PHONES.
MY HUNCH is there is some core google service that isn't being used in SAFE MODE, but starts being used on NORMAL BOOT that is causing all these issues. I really DOUBT its a 3rd party app.
Install the stock again clearing all the data. Don't restore anything with titanium or install any extra apps. Then make a call.
tesla45 said:
OK WORKAROUND FOR ANSWERING CALLS UPDATE:
Found this floating on some other forum, not sure where after this mad dash of a search I did this morning, but original credit to them...
When you receive a call and the phone is active and unlocked, press the power button to lock the phone and bring up the blue call management screen. Now you can swipe to answer.
This seems to work for more than one test call as I've tried this multiple times in a row.
NO REAL WORKAROUND FOR MAKING CALLS YET (outside of airplane mode toggle, or using Google voice/hangouts to place calls).
GOOGLE SUPPORT - THIS IS CLEARLY A SOFTWARE ISSUE, not a 3rd party app issue either since the problem goes away for answering calls when you press the lock screen or toggle airplane mode for placing calls. Please STOP ASKING CUSTOMERS TO invest hours of time (or money) FACTORY RESETTING PHONES, or REPLACING/BUYING NEW PHONES.
MY HUNCH is there is some core google service that isn't being used in SAFE MODE, but starts being used on NORMAL BOOT that is causing all these issues. I really DOUBT its a 3rd party app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And all this time, I thought my problem was only on the delay in placing calls. I just tested and confirmed that I am also having the same issue of being unable to answer calls. I also verified that the workaround you describe above works perfectly for me for answering calls. Also - I appreciate the suggestion to restore to fully factory reset, wiping data, and test prior to installing any apps....BUT I am not willing to invest that amount of time when I have viable workarounds. I agree that this is almost certainly a Google software issue in some core app or service and I'm hoping that we will see a resolution shortly...(maybe in March Security patches? - but I'm not holding out hope as I haven't seen that much widespread concern about this issue elsewhere.)
sb1893 said:
And all this time, I thought my problem was only on the delay in placing calls. I just tested and confirmed that I am also having the same issue of being unable to answer calls. I also verified that the workaround you describe above works perfectly for me for answering calls. Also - I appreciate the suggestion to restore to fully factory reset, wiping data, and test prior to installing any apps....BUT I am not willing to invest that amount of time when I have viable workarounds. I agree that this is almost certainly a Google software issue in some core app or service and I'm hoping that we will see a resolution shortly...(maybe in March Security patches? - but I'm not holding out hope as I haven't seen that much widespread concern about this issue elsewhere.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad the workaround helps you too. My emphasis CAPS in my last post was clearly misleading, I was actually suggesting NOT to reinstall/factory reset because I don't believe that solves the problem long term and its a huge ask for a customer (when really Google should be solving this problem for us).
Based on this little workaround its clearly a software problem that Google needs to address, I've raised the issues on many threads in their product forums ... hope it gets to the right people ASAP because I believe lots of Pixel users are running into the problem (both Pixel 2 and 1st gen, another indication its NOT a HW problem).
Keep the workarounds coming folks!
Anyone having issues with their P2XL/Android Pie and location related things?
Examples...
My smart lock (August) no longer auto unlocks when I get home.
My Nest thermostat no longer knows I'm home (and adjusts temp) until I walk in front of it.
My Phillips Hue lights no longer auto turn on when I get home after dark.
Etc etc.
Started around the time Pie was released, but I don't think at EXACTLY the same time (shortly after, I think). My wife has a P1XL and Pie and has the same issues.
I initially chalked it up to needing a fresh install, but I finally got around to doing that with no improvement.
Confirmed all of the location/scanning stuff in Settings is enabled. GPS itself works fine (e.g. no issues with Google Maps).
In fact, if I open the August app, it knows where I am... The change in location simply didn't trigger the unlock process.
I'm guessing either a Pie bug, or these apps needing further updates... But not seeing much in the way of other people's reports has me uncertain.
All related issues (August, Nest, Hue) started at the same time as each other and the same time on both phones (mine and my wife's).
I've tried toggling things on and off, re-installing things without letting Google restore data, minimal installations to ensure it wasn't some sort of app conflict.
At this point, I can't think of anything else to try. Obviously I can reach out to Google... Just not super optimistic about it accomplishing anything.
If anyone can confirm from their end or has any troubleshooting ideas, I appreciate the share in advance.
Thanks.
Edit: Oh, I also turned off battery optimization for those apps and eventually Adaptive Battery was turned off in general.
I recently upgraded from LOS 18.1 to 19.1. I was having issues with battery drain and finally decided to upgrade. The battery issues are completely fixed. A new issue cropped up with my profiles however. I have a "home" profile that disables the lock screen when my phone connects to my home wifi.
Since the upgrade, when my lock screen is disabled, my home and recent apps button stop working. Other things stop working as well like being able to copy paste between apps. My somewhat usable workaround for now has been to enable the recent apps screen when double tapping the home button, for some reason this works. I can return home by tapping the outer edge of the recent apps screen. This is what I'm running for device and OS:
Device - Poco X3 Pro (Vayu)
OS - LineageOS 19.1 microg Oct. 24, 2022 release(from https://lineage.microg.org/)
Recovery - TWRP
I found a bug report on Gitlab for the exact same issue here: https://gitlab.com/LineageOS/issues/android/-/issues/5189
They're reporting it as fixed for the most recent builds, which I'm currently running and still having the problem.
I'd really like to avoid a device wipe and reinstall as I have some MFA apps for work that would be a big pain to get going again. Does anyone know of any fixes? I'm guessing it's permissions related of some kind as it's like the device is only half unlocked or something. I've tried creating a new profile as well as disabling profiles, rebooting, and trying again, nothings worked so far. Should I just open another bug report on Gitlab? Appreciate any help.
This seems to have stopped, but I have little idea as to why. I noticed it stopped after I connected my phone to my PC with a USB to transfer files. After I did that, for some reason the lock screen disable is working fully as intended now. All nav buttons work, copy+paste, etc.