Related
After days of deciding..
Yes!! i have risked my device warranty for the sake of fun and excitement. HAHA LOL
For those who asked if we can flash Treble GSI (Generic System Image) on our device. The answer is Yes, FOR ME AT LEAST!
No complicated steps or whatsoever.
I just followed the steps from this link and downloaded the GSI of my choice. CREDITS TO ALL THE DEVELOPERS WHO WORKED FOR THIS PROJECT.
https://www.xda-developers.com/flash-generic-system-image-project-treble-device/
TRY THIS AT YOUR OWN RISK! I will not be held accountable to whatever happens to your device. This post is just to prove that indeed our device is treble enabled.
Some important things to note:
- You have backup of your data
- You have a working ADB
- There might be functionalities that is not working at the moment (Read the changelogs of your GSI choice before downloading)
- The notch looks bad on these builds (Android P might be able to fix this when it arrives)
- Your device should be in stock ROM (no heavy modifications such as xposed , magisk etc..) ROOT Not needed
- You should put your device on factory reset before trying this.
I have attached some screenshots of my test.
LINK TO Treble-Enabled Device Dev
https://forum.xda-developers.com/project-treble/trebleenabled-device-development
THANK ME LATER! PEACE OUT!
good job!
Yes great job hows the camera working for you
grodri19721 said:
Yes great job hows the camera working for you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lineage includes a very basic camera. just photo and video no portrait mode etc..
Lineage also has no gapps, i dont have twrp to flash gapps still figuring out how to install it.
I switched to the PixelExperience rom its great and with gapps included.
illustrasszo27 said:
Lineage includes a very basic camera. just photo and video no portrait mode etc..
Lineage also has no gapps, i dont have twrp to flash gapps still figuring out how to install it.
I switched to the PixelExperience rom its great and with gapps included.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
android p preview 2 developer?
Everything functional?, no bugs?
el canario said:
android p preview 2 developer?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. Its Android 8.1
There is no gsi for Android P yet.
DocRambone said:
Everything functional?, no bugs?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only bug i have notice so far in PixelExperience is sometimes mobile data does not turned on when you toggle it in the quick tiles. you have to restart your phone then it will work after that.
illustrasszo27 said:
The only bug i have notice so far in PixelExperience is sometimes mobile data does not turned on when you toggle it in the quick tiles. you have to restart your phone then it will work after that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have the Z version with 845-chipset?
DocRambone said:
You have the Z version with 845-chipset?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No this is the lower version. with snapdragon 636
im still waiting on android P rom XD
Is the status bar at the top still messed up on the pixel experience ROM?
hands0m3 said:
Is the status bar at the top still messed up on the pixel experience ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. same as with lineage. for me its tolerable since no information is being shown at that part of the status bar.
Do you think changing the dpi would help with that
hands0m3 said:
Do you think changing the dpi would help with that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure bro. One thing i tried is changing the display size in settings. It looks better but everything looks so big. so i reverted to the default one.
Sir could you possibly upload the stock recovery.img of our device.? im stuck on TWRP and i cant flash regular OTA update from there
jrd1990 said:
Sir could you possibly upload the stock recovery.img of our device.? im stuck on TWRP and i cant flash regular OTA update from there
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What ROM are you using right now? i think you can extract it from the image of that ROM. sorry if this not as helpful.
he is on Stock Rom and he would like one guy put the stock recovery.img here
Excellent job. Thank you. I understand the camera is basic, but how is image quality? Looking forward to Google Camera port tests. And perhaps the ZE620KL fully ported so can make use of the landscape camera. Not a huge deal, but would be nice, no?
As visible on screenshot, Asus Camera is properly visible in the launcher (because of being put to vendor by Asus), but does it run well?
Hi,
I don't want to get into a debate about which custom ROM is the best. (The one you pick is likely the best for you right?) What I do want to get a handle on is people's experience with custom ROMs and Android Pie.
Is there a custom ROM that has done a better job at integrating the features of Pie after moving on from Oreo, and that currently is at an acceptable useful level?
There are a few out there currently, and they seem to have been working for a bit, but is it worth it to flash a daily driver to a Pie based ROM at this stage, or wait for awhile?
Thanks for your help,
Clay
Gromit1996 said:
Hi,
I don't want to get into a debate about which custom ROM is the best. (The one you pick is likely the best for you right?) What I do want to get a handle on is people's experience with custom ROMs and Android Pie.
Is there a custom ROM that has done a better job at integrating the features of Pie after moving on from Oreo, and that currently is at an acceptable useful level?
There are a few out there currently, and they seem to have been working for a bit, but is it worth it to flash a daily driver to a Pie based ROM at this stage, or wait for awhile?
Thanks for your help,
Clay
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pie roms are mostly very stable now, pixel experience and havoc, both of which I tried worked perfectly for me, no problem. You should just try it
Gromit1996 said:
Hi,
I don't want to get into a debate about which custom ROM is the best. (The one you pick is likely the best for you right?) What I do want to get a handle on is people's experience with custom ROMs and Android Pie.
Is there a custom ROM that has done a better job at integrating the features of Pie after moving on from Oreo, and that currently is at an acceptable useful level?
There are a few out there currently, and they seem to have been working for a bit, but is it worth it to flash a daily driver to a Pie based ROM at this stage, or wait for awhile?
Thanks for your help,
Clay
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yah There are so many roms out there but i will suggest you to go With Pixel Experience
i have switched many roms from last 2 months But whenever i switch I have never get the smoothness that i get from PE
Latest version of PE (https://forum.xda-developers.com/redmi-note-5-pro/development/rom-pixel-experience-t3830197) has almost no more bugs and it uses Android 9: PixelExperience_whyred-9.0-20181119-0216-OFFICIAL.zip
It's updated to recent security patches and works great.
Definitely usable for daily uses!
I'm using AOSP Extended Pie. So far, so good. It hasn't blown up my daily driver yet, so <fingers crossed>.
Sent from my Lenovo TB-8504F using Tapatalk
I tried pixel experience, it's good but no customization options, now I'm on crdroid and it works perfectly
hassan_eldhraawy said:
I tried pixel experience, it's good but no customization options, now I'm on crdroid and it works perfectly
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
does PUBG works without glitches in CR-Droid ???
MCAOSP as good as it gets
chiudikas said:
MCAOSP as good as it gets
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you currently have it? Can you share some screenshots?
rasik107 said:
does PUBG works without glitches in CR-Droid ???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Theres glitches in some game like mobile legend. In pubg i didnt really noticed it
lawong said:
Theres glitches in some game like mobile legend. In pubg i didnt really noticed it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok.. will try Cr-Droid once !
I'm using syberia. beautiful. I love miui more so I can't say anything.
LeekGeek said:
Do you currently have it? Can you share some screenshots?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
here
rasik107 said:
does PUBG works without glitches in CR-Droid ???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it's working very smooth, I didn't notice any glitches
I'm using LineageOS 15.1 as daily driver. Yesterday I tried AOSPExtended Rom 6.0 and Havoc-OS. In my opinion AOSPExtended runs great but I didn't find an privacy manager like LineageOS. As second I tested Havoc-OS. Havoc-OS has implemented privacy manager. But In the Pixel Launcher in Havoc-OS I didn't find a option to deactivate the Google search bar.
But both ROMs looks very great.
OT: For my personal use, I don't want GoogleServices and PixelLauncher. F-Droid and Yalp store is enough for me. For my tests with Havoc-OS, of course, I replaced the Pixel Launcher with another Launcher from F-Droid.
Revolution OS Pie is very smooth and stable and has an awesome battery life
MCaosp best custom ROM Android Pie so far I have tested. Well-balanced. 120k on antutu and lots of drums.
Hi my device is Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 can i install ROMs for whyred?
Thanks
dracul89 said:
Hi my device is Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 can i install ROMs for whyred?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No dual camera on back... Not whyred... So... Unless u want to brick ur phone... Check it first....
OOS 9.0.2 is the best
I'm not a huge fan of MIUI, so I would like to try some GSIs. Is there a GSI that's stable for daily use and with no bugs?
I've found that by now most of them are if you add the two manual vendor fixes required for Bluetooth and brightness.
The one downside though is that you lose VoLTE access and that MTP is broken if you're coming from a Oreo-based MIUI build.
Phh-treble AOSP is a base for almost all available gsi roms. Since PHH is the leanest purest AOSP of all, my guass would be that any derivative adds some bugs. BTW, phh 108 has December security patch, that matters in some cases (see a list of known critical issues disovered and fixed recently)
Pixel dust or havoc are better than phh
Shlyify said:
Pixel dust or havoc are better than phh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.
Stidza said:
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MIUI has been good to me so far.
Stidza said:
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So pixel dust, this rom dont have a ton of features...... both have less than miui. But these romes are not stable, i had problems with some apps on every gsi.... I dont recommend them. Better stay on miui and wait for normal custom rom for our max 3.
MrColdbird said:
MIUI has been good to me so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just so far I'd say :silly:! When you start getting random pesky ads, your first action would be to search for a custom ROM! (BTW, I'm on a Redmi 7, and am waiting for custom ROMs)!
This is one is very good (AOSiP)
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085
palmdude said:
This is one is very good (AOSiP)
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am considering buying the phone. However, MIUI is out of question.
Does the rom that you mentioned have bugs on Mi Max 3?
Link to original thread: A52 4G forum
Updated to Lineage 19.0!
Hey man! Everything is working great as far as I can see right now. Only one big drawback is the fingerprint scanner not working on Galaxy A72. It's not that it's registered and then it's failing. You can't even register it sadly.
Any fixes soon? Or is there a workaround which I am supposed to do, that I don't know about?
Thanks!
nadtonii1 said:
Hey man! Everything is working great as far as I can see right now. Only one big drawback is the fingerprint scanner not working on Galaxy A72. It's not that it's registered and then it's failing. You can't even register it sadly.
Any fixes soon? Or is there a workaround which I am supposed to do, that I don't know about?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, sadly I only own A52 which makes it really hard for me to fix it on A72.
Simon1511 said:
Sorry, sadly I only own A52 which makes it really hard for me to fix it on A72.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are some suggestions.
Google Camera does not start, crashes. On GSI it helped to turn on the vendor Q.
In the screen settings, can you add a graph of picture saturation settings?
And is it possible to add a system backup to Lineage Recovery?
Realees56 said:
There are some suggestions.
Google Camera does not start, crashes. On GSI it helped to turn on the vendor Q.
In the screen settings, can you add a graph of picture saturation settings?
And is it possible to add a system backup to Lineage Recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1. Which version of GCam? BSG works fine for me.
2 & 3: No, such features don't exist.
Simon1511 said:
1. Which version of GCam? BSG works fine for me.
2 & 3: No, such features don't exist.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also BSG
Is it by any chance due to the rise kernel?
Realees56 said:
Also BSG
Is it by any chance due to the rise kernel?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, it shouldn't be related to the kernel.
I'll investigate soon.
Simon1511 said:
No, it shouldn't be related to the kernel.
I'll investigate soon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course it's a pity lineage recovery won't have a backup function, it's inconvenient to flash twrp every time.
And the colour saturation setting as on oneui is missing. I don't understand why you chose LOs, there's nothing in it at all, you can't even choose colours in styles. I was sitting on GSI 12A CrDroid before your firmware, great firmware in terms of customization. Never used google services. Never used google services.
Unfortunately when upgrading to GSI v402 the phone is extremely hard to start. About 8 times on reboot out of 10, 8 times caught bootloop. And this is on any v402 firmware.
In any case your firmware is better, even without having to patch separately the boot for magisk in order to run it on 12A GSI
Realees56 said:
Of course it's a pity lineage recovery won't have a backup function, it's inconvenient to flash twrp every time.
And the colour saturation setting as on oneui is missing. I don't understand why you chose LOs, there's nothing in it at all, you can't even choose colours in styles. I was sitting on GSI 12A CrDroid before your firmware, great firmware in terms of customization. Never used google services. Never used google services.
Unfortunately when upgrading to GSI v402 the phone is extremely hard to start. About 8 times on reboot out of 10, 8 times caught bootloop. And this is on any v402 firmware.
In any case your firmware is better, even without having to patch separately the boot for magisk in order to run it on 12A GSI
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you're unhappy with lineage feel free to build any other ROM on your own, the device trees are all on my Github.
friend! please don't stop developing this system, it's the best I could find for me a72, as soon as I can I'll send support through paypal
¿Funciona en Samsung A71?
Translated by GT: Does it work on Samsung A71?
usuario888 said:
¿Funciona en Samsung A71?
Translated by GT: Does it work on Samsung A71?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. As the thread says, this is exclusively for A52 4G and A72.
Is this Rom still in development I have the A72 4G. Want to load the custom OS
GoldenJet said:
Is this Rom still in development I have the A72 4G. Want to load the custom OS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, it is.
tried this rom its quite unstable loads of issues, still its the only rom at the moment. I reverted to stock.
Ok this was posted in haste and a bit in irritation what I meant is simply this is not useable as stable rom,
Its unstable and has issues. This is not meant as a revieuw or judgement of said rom. Its the first and currently only one avalible and kudo's to the creator. Its listed as development. Its just a quick feedback for those like me that just like to know if its stable or not.
Spacecabbie said:
tried this rom its quite unstable loads of issues, still its the only rom at the moment. I reverted to stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would you mind telling me about the issues you experienced?
From my point of view (and from what others told me) it runs pretty stable and mostly bugless on both A52 and A72.
I have it running for weeks now as second device. Only real issue is fingerprint sensor and camera, could not find any gcam mod that would work properly. Apart for it - runs stable.
Simon1511 said:
Would you mind telling me about the issues you experienced?
From my point of view (and from what others told me) it runs pretty stable and mostly bugless on both A52 and A72.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry Muyst have missed this,
Also edited initial post cause it was imho blunt and to negative. Sorry about that I have nothing but respect for mod creators.
I din't extensivly test but:
Vingerprint reader but this was known.
I had some screen issues (swiping up from bottem wouln't work so couln't close apps.
pixel launcher kept crashing (yes this might not be rom related but nova launcher also had issues)
General instability possibly all related to screen.
There where some other issues but as said my intention was not to extensivly screen it the above combined with the other small issues made me decide to remove it again.
I was using lineage os 19 in my Samsung Galaxy A72. It's better than pixel plus ui rom. It has 90hz screen refresh rate. But this rom has the following bugs also:
1. Proximity sensor not working at all;
2.Fingerprint or face unlock not working;
3. No safety net pass.
How is the current state of GSI in 12X?
Is it usable as daily driver?
ChessPiece said:
How is the current state of GSI in 12X?
Is it usable as daily driver?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Gsi roms are universal, you can install the same rom on a Xiaomi, Samsung, Lg, etc..
I answered you about it here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-compatibilty.4550885/post-88115511
ChessPiece said:
How is the current state of GSI in 12X?
Is it usable as daily driver?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
known bugs: auto brightness, fingerprint, double tap2wake
NOSS8 said:
Gsi roms are universal, you can install the same rom on a Xiaomi, Samsung, Lg, etc..
I answered you about it here:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-compatibilty.4550885/post-88115511
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know what GSI is. I want to know what is currently doesn't work in this particular device, that's why I asked on two different thread because they are two different devices.
nofx161 said:
known bugs: auto brightness, fingerprint, double tap2wake
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. I saw the D2TW issue is stale on PHH's repo.
Thanks for the info!
ChessPiece said:
I know what GSI is. I want to know what is currently doesn't work in this particular device, that's why I asked on two different thread because they are two different devices.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your question is too general, specify for example, Pixel or LOS, A12 or A13, because some have no bugs.
ChessPiece said:
How is the current state of GSI in 12X?
Is it usable as daily driver?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, I tested a lot of gsi's, since there were no custom roms until August 21... They work ok. Battery is better than stock and most of them (crdroid, los, pe, arrow) are more snappy. As written above, the bugs are dt2w and fingerprint sensor, but the most annoying bug is a soundbug, that appears, when using teams or whattsapp. The sound then has some kind of mickeymouse filter. It's high and distorted... And itbwas told many times, that it's solved, but it never was. No matter which base I used. Now I use PA and it's the first time O like this phone...
NOSS8 said:
because some have no bugs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which one for 12x have no bugs? Wanna try it.
alex_pacific said:
Which one for 12x have no bugs? Wanna try it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do not install and will never install GSI roms (too risky).
Here some GSI roms. (prefer A12).
Generic System Image (GSI) list
Notes about tinkering with Android Project Treble. Contribute to phhusson/treble_experimentations development by creating an account on GitHub.
github.com
Voodoojonny said:
Hi, I tested a lot of gsi's, since there were no custom roms until August 21... They work ok. Battery is better than stock and most of them (crdroid, los, pe, arrow) are more snappy. As written above, the bugs are dt2w and fingerprint sensor, but the most annoying bug is a soundbug, that appears, when using teams or whattsapp. The sound then has some kind of mickeymouse filter. It's high and distorted... And itbwas told many times, that it's solved, but it never was. No matter which base I used. Now I use PA and it's the first time O like this phone...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We might be able to fix the sound distorsion by looking through PRs and Issues on phhusson's GSI repo. My last device has this bug too but managed to fix it by modifying some values in build.prop, then the changes ware merged to master.
ChessPiece said:
We might be able to fix the sound distorsion by looking through PRs and Issues on phhusson's GSI repo. My last device has this bug too but managed to fix it by modifying some values in build.prop, then the changes ware merged to master.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah that's interesting. But I guess, PA will be stable very soon and then I think, that many roms will appear with that sources.
Hello 2 everyone. Does someone use gsi of PE 13+ as daily driver? I'm asking, because wondering if it could work as anoying miui....