Develop Bugs

Has anyone tried DirtyUnicorns?

Seems that there are DU builds for the HTC 10 (pme). Here: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/pme/
Has anyone tried them? If yes, what are your impressions? :laugh:

errikosd said:
Seems that there are DU builds for the HTC 10 (pme). Here: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/pme/
Has anyone tried them? If yes, what are your impressions? :laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is AOSP based compared to LOS (CM) which the majority of the ROMs posted are.
DU is a great ROM. I found that it lacked some important features that I like, but a very solid ROM.

Yes i tried on Sprint but there was no data...even after entering the apn in

errikosd said:
Seems that there are DU builds for the HTC 10 (pme). Here: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/pme/
Has anyone tried them? If yes, what are your impressions? :laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Encryption was not working, even with a full data format prior to flashing.
Any other opinions?

I have been running the weekly and official builds with nebula eas kernel for about 5 weeks or so. I personally feel its the best non-sense based ROM for my usage. It does lack some customisations most others have but makes up for it by being super stable, fast, battery friendly and just works as its supposed to with bull. I use superSU, substratum and A.R.I.S.E audio mod with selinux permissive without dramas.

mrrflagg said:
I have been running the weekly and official builds with nebula eas kernel for about 5 weeks or so. I personally feel its the best non-sense based ROM for my usage. It does lack some customisations most others have but makes up for it by being super stable, fast, battery friendly and just works as its supposed to with bull. I use superSU, substratum and A.R.I.S.E audio mod with selinux permissive without dramas.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it come with root or Magisk out of the box?
To reverse the question, can I use it as clean Android without root, passing SafetyNet? Thanks!

errikosd said:
Does it come with root or Magisk out of the box?
To reverse the question, can I use it as clean Android without root, passing SafetyNet? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It comes WITHOUT root. So you can choose your preffered method or no root at all.
I don't know about safetynet as I am not using android pay or anything that relies on it to pass.
Also I have not had any encryption issues as someone earlier replied

mrrflagg said:
I have been running the weekly and official builds with nebula eas kernel for about 5 weeks or so. I personally feel its the best non-sense based ROM for my usage. It does lack some customisations most others have but makes up for it by being super stable, fast, battery friendly and just works as its supposed to with bull. I use superSU, substratum and A.R.I.S.E audio mod with selinux permissive without dramas.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What firmware and TWRP Version are you using with it ? With the Nougat firmware and latest TWRP, I get the encryption issue..

Scutariu said:
What firmware and TWRP Version are you using with it ? With the Nougat firmware and latest TWRP, I get the encryption issue..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
401.4 FW and 3.1.0 TWRP. What kind of encryption issue? I did have once only rebooted into recovery and it asked for the password but I just rebooted in recovery from TWRP and it never happened again.

mrrflagg said:
401.4 FW and 3.1.0 TWRP. What kind of encryption issue? I did have once only rebooted into recovery and it asked for the password but I just rebooted in recovery from TWRP and it never happened again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried several combinations, with older/latest firmware.
Every time, It would ask for the encryption password on bootup.
Even if I haven't set one up.. With data format prior to installing
Anyway, got sick of re-setting apps on my phone, just installed Maximus HD ROM, and that's that ?

Dirty Unicorns
errikosd said:
Seems that there are DU builds for the HTC 10 (pme). Here: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/pme/
Has anyone tried them? If yes, what are your impressions? :laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The 4-8-17 build is Android 7.1.2 and so far it is running really well. I am surprised that there​ is not a thread in the ROM section for DU.

morr22066 said:
The 4-8-17 build is Android 7.1.2 and so far it is running really well. I am surprised that there​ is not a thread in the ROM section for DU.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think it was the DU team's decision to close all and not allow any XDA threads. Someone correct me if I am wrong.
No idea why though.

morr22066 said:
The 4-8-17 build is Android 7.1.2 and so far it is running really well. I am surprised that there​ is not a thread in the ROM section for DU.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A quick question.
What variant , firmware and TWRP are you using?
Everytime I try that rom..it encrypts itself with an unknown password, and upon restart I'm unable to access my phone

Encryption
Scutariu said:
A quick question.
What variant , firmware and TWRP are you using?
Everytime I try that rom..it encrypts itself with an unknown password, and upon restart I'm unable to access my phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have had that happen when switching from a sense based ROM to LOS or AOSP and it's a "pita"... Anything that I want to keep gets moved to my SD card before I reboot to recovery.
I read through several threads and tried several possible solutions so I can't remember exactly which one worked.
I am currently on Verizon, official Nougat with the flashed us unlocked "patch", TWRP 3.1.0-1. If you are on Verizon or Sprint you need to patch the image with a missing image that is found in the us unlocked model (there are threads discussing it where you can find the file).

LOS
Scutariu said:
A quick question.
What variant , firmware and TWRP are you using?
Everytime I try that rom..it encrypts itself with an unknown password, and upon restart I'm unable to access my phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Lineage is wiki spells things out pretty well.
https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/pme/install
Here is another thread on twrp issues
https://forum.xda-developers.com/htc-10/how-to/guide-fix-pin-pattern-password-t3538438

morr22066 said:
The Lineage is wiki spells things out pretty well.
https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/pme/install
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It was not related to the data partition.
The format user data was done prior and after flashing it.

There is a DU Oreo-based build for the HTC 10: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/?device=pme
For the time being it is under "RC". Downloading now, will report back!
Edit: ROM is very nice and is flying by. Only downside is that camera app is VERY slow... Also, woofer is not working (as expected).
What I like the most is that it is AOSP, i.e. no LineageOS stuff like AudioFX, etc. Customisation features are nice and the experience is close to Pixel with Stock OpenGapps. If the camera app is fixed, then this would be perfect (I believe it will, since this is the first RC release)!
Further notes: Capacitive buttons backlight is off by default (can't find any standard option to turn on, maybe with a kernel tool?) and notification LED does not work either. Don't mind for the capacitive buttons too much, but the LED is a real problem.

errikosd said:
There is a DU Oreo-based build for the HTC 10: https://download.dirtyunicorns.com/?device=pme
For the time being it is under "RC". Downloading now, will report back!
Edit: ROM is very nice and is flying by. Only downside is that camera app is VERY slow... Also, woofer is not working (as expected).
What I like the most is that it is AOSP, i.e. no LineageOS stuff like AudioFX, etc. Customisation features are nice and the experience is close to Pixel with Stock OpenGapps. If the camera app is fixed, then this would be perfect (I believe it will, since this is the first RC release)!
Further notes: Capacitive buttons backlight is off by default (can't find any standard option to turn on, maybe with a kernel tool?) and notification LED does not work either. Don't mind for the capacitive buttons too much, but the LED is a real problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea I'm having that sane problem with the touch key lights not working n it bothers me a bit. I didn't notice if the led was working or not. Keep me posted if u figure out the the key problem plz.

Query regarding oxygen os GSI port

Hello,
Is it possible to flash gsi oxygen os 5.1.6 rom on our device?
The rom is located in the thread below:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...ly-roms/gsi-oxygen-os-5-1-6-boos4721-t3859240

arun356y said:
Hello,
Is it possible to flash gsi oxygen os 5.1.6 rom on our device?
The rom is located in the thread below:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...ly-roms/gsi-oxygen-os-5-1-6-boos4721-t3859240
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am waiting for a reply to this thread as well. If someone tries please let us know.
UPDATE:
I got it to boot using AEX 5.8 vendor, but after setting up it keeps crashing and shutting down.

varunbiday said:
I am waiting for a reply to this thread as well. If someone tries please let us know.
UPDATE:
I got it to boot using AEX 5.8 vendor, but after setting up it keeps crashing and shutting down.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It needs device specific modifications I guess. We need devs to look on this rom.

arun356y said:
It needs device specific modifications I guess. We need devs to look on this rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes! I'm sure devs can find ways to get everything working, it'll be an awesome port for our device. I hope this happens

arun356y said:
Hello,
Is it possible to flash gsi oxygen os 5.1.6 rom on our device?
The rom is located in the thread below:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/pr...ly-roms/gsi-oxygen-os-5-1-6-boos4721-t3859240
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
answer : yes.
i did experimented with it, got everything to work except the gcam no 3rd party cams. rom is very snappy and responsive but haven't don any gaming on it.
I had to work on h2os so haven't work further on this and i have exams coming up, gonna be busy till december and also fixing gcam is not my cup of tea, so if any one want to work on this i will upload the files and details regarding this.

Dhananjay_Yadav said:
answer : yes.
i did experimented with it, got everything to work except the gcam no 3rd party cams. rom is very snappy and responsive but haven't don any gaming on it.
I had to work on h2os so haven't work further on this and i have exams coming up, gonna be busy till december and also fixing gcam is not my cup of tea, so if any one want to work on this i will upload the files and details regarding this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will be happy to try it, although I don't have any previous knowledge regarding this.
@narshi shukla bro please you take up the project, you have more experience.

@narshi shukla
bro we know u worked really hard for miui and on other roms.....and we r relly thankful to u....
I hope you can have a look at this rom

@narshi shukla Please take a look on this

Gagandaywal said:
@narshi shukla Please take a look on this
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have already looked on this, not only this but various other similar ports, including pie ones.
The major issue is camera, which seems near impossible to fix, so it won't make sense as we already have proper Oreo and nougat ports of this rom
and pie ports(both miui and oos/h2os) won't boot on our device without proper pie vendors, which our device don't have, the treble flag is disabled on treble pie roms, enabling it causes various crashes and makes rom boots but its unusable,waiting for senior devs to fix it or any workaround.

narshi shukla said:
I have already looked on this, not only this but various other similar ports, including pie ones.
The major issue is camera, which seems near impossible to fix, so it won't make sense as we already have proper Oreo and nougat ports of this rom
and pie ports(both miui and oos/h2os) won't boot on our device without proper pie vendors, which our device don't have, the treble flag is disabled on treble pie roms, enabling it causes various crashes and makes rom boots but its unusable,waiting for senior devs to fix it or any workaround.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for seeing this post and replying. I think we can count on OOS Pie coming for the OP3 soon, it has the same chipset so it should be much easier to port

What is the most stable GSI for this phone?

I'm not a huge fan of MIUI, so I would like to try some GSIs. Is there a GSI that's stable for daily use and with no bugs?

I've found that by now most of them are if you add the two manual vendor fixes required for Bluetooth and brightness.
The one downside though is that you lose VoLTE access and that MTP is broken if you're coming from a Oreo-based MIUI build.

Phh-treble AOSP is a base for almost all available gsi roms. Since PHH is the leanest purest AOSP of all, my guass would be that any derivative adds some bugs. BTW, phh 108 has December security patch, that matters in some cases (see a list of known critical issues disovered and fixed recently)

Pixel dust or havoc are better than phh

Shlyify said:
Pixel dust or havoc are better than phh
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.

Stidza said:
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MIUI has been good to me so far.

Stidza said:
I don't need a ton of features, I just want a stable ROM without bugs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So pixel dust, this rom dont have a ton of features...... both have less than miui. But these romes are not stable, i had problems with some apps on every gsi.... I dont recommend them. Better stay on miui and wait for normal custom rom for our max 3.

MrColdbird said:
MIUI has been good to me so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just so far I'd say :silly:! When you start getting random pesky ads, your first action would be to search for a custom ROM! (BTW, I'm on a Redmi 7, and am waiting for custom ROMs)!

This is one is very good (AOSiP)
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085

palmdude said:
This is one is very good (AOSiP)
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mi-max-3/how-to/guide-beginners-guide-to-gsi-aosp-rom-t3910085
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am considering buying the phone. However, MIUI is out of question.
Does the rom that you mentioned have bugs on Mi Max 3?

Development [ROM][13][ENCRYPTION] Official LineageOS 20 for A72

Link to original thread: A52 4G forum

Updated to Lineage 19.0!

Hey man! Everything is working great as far as I can see right now. Only one big drawback is the fingerprint scanner not working on Galaxy A72. It's not that it's registered and then it's failing. You can't even register it sadly.
Any fixes soon? Or is there a workaround which I am supposed to do, that I don't know about?
Thanks!

nadtonii1 said:
Hey man! Everything is working great as far as I can see right now. Only one big drawback is the fingerprint scanner not working on Galaxy A72. It's not that it's registered and then it's failing. You can't even register it sadly.
Any fixes soon? Or is there a workaround which I am supposed to do, that I don't know about?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry, sadly I only own A52 which makes it really hard for me to fix it on A72.

Simon1511 said:
Sorry, sadly I only own A52 which makes it really hard for me to fix it on A72.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are some suggestions.
Google Camera does not start, crashes. On GSI it helped to turn on the vendor Q.
In the screen settings, can you add a graph of picture saturation settings?
And is it possible to add a system backup to Lineage Recovery?

Realees56 said:
There are some suggestions.
Google Camera does not start, crashes. On GSI it helped to turn on the vendor Q.
In the screen settings, can you add a graph of picture saturation settings?
And is it possible to add a system backup to Lineage Recovery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1. Which version of GCam? BSG works fine for me.
2 & 3: No, such features don't exist.

Simon1511 said:
1. Which version of GCam? BSG works fine for me.
2 & 3: No, such features don't exist.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also BSG
Is it by any chance due to the rise kernel?

Realees56 said:
Also BSG
Is it by any chance due to the rise kernel?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, it shouldn't be related to the kernel.
I'll investigate soon.

Simon1511 said:
No, it shouldn't be related to the kernel.
I'll investigate soon.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course it's a pity lineage recovery won't have a backup function, it's inconvenient to flash twrp every time.
And the colour saturation setting as on oneui is missing. I don't understand why you chose LOs, there's nothing in it at all, you can't even choose colours in styles. I was sitting on GSI 12A CrDroid before your firmware, great firmware in terms of customization. Never used google services. Never used google services.
Unfortunately when upgrading to GSI v402 the phone is extremely hard to start. About 8 times on reboot out of 10, 8 times caught bootloop. And this is on any v402 firmware.
In any case your firmware is better, even without having to patch separately the boot for magisk in order to run it on 12A GSI

Realees56 said:
Of course it's a pity lineage recovery won't have a backup function, it's inconvenient to flash twrp every time.
And the colour saturation setting as on oneui is missing. I don't understand why you chose LOs, there's nothing in it at all, you can't even choose colours in styles. I was sitting on GSI 12A CrDroid before your firmware, great firmware in terms of customization. Never used google services. Never used google services.
Unfortunately when upgrading to GSI v402 the phone is extremely hard to start. About 8 times on reboot out of 10, 8 times caught bootloop. And this is on any v402 firmware.
In any case your firmware is better, even without having to patch separately the boot for magisk in order to run it on 12A GSI
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you're unhappy with lineage feel free to build any other ROM on your own, the device trees are all on my Github.

friend! please don't stop developing this system, it's the best I could find for me a72, as soon as I can I'll send support through paypal

¿Funciona en Samsung A71?
Translated by GT: Does it work on Samsung A71?

usuario888 said:
¿Funciona en Samsung A71?
Translated by GT: Does it work on Samsung A71?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. As the thread says, this is exclusively for A52 4G and A72.

Is this Rom still in development I have the A72 4G. Want to load the custom OS

GoldenJet said:
Is this Rom still in development I have the A72 4G. Want to load the custom OS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, it is.

tried this rom its quite unstable loads of issues, still its the only rom at the moment. I reverted to stock.
Ok this was posted in haste and a bit in irritation what I meant is simply this is not useable as stable rom,
Its unstable and has issues. This is not meant as a revieuw or judgement of said rom. Its the first and currently only one avalible and kudo's to the creator. Its listed as development. Its just a quick feedback for those like me that just like to know if its stable or not.

Spacecabbie said:
tried this rom its quite unstable loads of issues, still its the only rom at the moment. I reverted to stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Would you mind telling me about the issues you experienced?
From my point of view (and from what others told me) it runs pretty stable and mostly bugless on both A52 and A72.

I have it running for weeks now as second device. Only real issue is fingerprint sensor and camera, could not find any gcam mod that would work properly. Apart for it - runs stable.

Simon1511 said:
Would you mind telling me about the issues you experienced?
From my point of view (and from what others told me) it runs pretty stable and mostly bugless on both A52 and A72.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry Muyst have missed this,
Also edited initial post cause it was imho blunt and to negative. Sorry about that I have nothing but respect for mod creators.
I din't extensivly test but:
Vingerprint reader but this was known.
I had some screen issues (swiping up from bottem wouln't work so couln't close apps.
pixel launcher kept crashing (yes this might not be rom related but nova launcher also had issues)
General instability possibly all related to screen.
There where some other issues but as said my intention was not to extensivly screen it the above combined with the other small issues made me decide to remove it again.

I was using lineage os 19 in my Samsung Galaxy A72. It's better than pixel plus ui rom. It has 90hz screen refresh rate. But this rom has the following bugs also:
1. Proximity sensor not working at all;
2.Fingerprint or face unlock not working;
3. No safety net pass.

[A12] Some tested GSI ROMs

Requirements:
-EMUI 9.1
- Stock firmware
- Stock recovery
How to flash :
- Recommended TWRP: Link
1. Corvus Revolt
https://sourceforge.net/projects/tipzbuilds/files/GSIs/CorvusROM/Alpha/20220315/
2. ArrowOS
https://sourceforge.net/projects/gsi-projects/files/v402/ArrowOS-12/
3. OctaviOS
https://sourceforge.net/projects/yilliee-projects/
4. LineageOS 19.0 (AndyYan)
https://sourceforge.net/projects/andyyan-gsi/files/lineage-19.x/History/
5. LineageOS 19.1
https://sourceforge.net/projects/andyyan-gsi/files/lineage-19.x/
6. PixelExperience
https://github.com/ponces/treble_build_pe/releases
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/...plus-a11-gsi-unofficial.4298551/post-86435071

And how does it feel? Suitable for a daily driver? What are pros/cons against A11? Is it worth installing?

luka_bubi said:
And how does it feel? Suitable for a daily driver? What are pros/cons against A11? Is it worth installing?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This list is just info for those who want to try the A12 (A12L).
A12 is just cosmetics, everything important already includes A11 (we are talking about GSI of course).
On some mentioned ROMs RIL doesn't work correctly with selinux permissive, plus some other bugs:
Corvus:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-beta-12-1-phh-corvusos-vs1-0-revolt.4415529/post-86586091
LOS 19.1:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-12-lineageos-19-x-gsi-a64b-64b.4358041/post-86608983
More info :
https://forum.xda-developers.com/f/treble-enabled-device-development-a-ab-roms.7260/

-Alf- said:
This list is just info for those who want to try the A12 (A12L).
A12 is just cosmetics, everything important already includes A11 (we are talking about GSI of course).
On some mentioned ROMs RIL doesn't work correctly with selinux permissive, plus some other bugs:
Corvus:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-beta-12-1-phh-corvusos-vs1-0-revolt.4415529/post-86586091
LOS 19.1:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/gsi-12-lineageos-19-x-gsi-a64b-64b.4358041/post-86608983
More info :
https://forum.xda-developers.com/f/treble-enabled-device-development-a-ab-roms.7260/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for all of these tests, on many devices A12 gsis are buggy. Better remain on A11 for now I think

Incomtus said:
Better remain on A11 for now I think
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Reverted back to my lovely 8.0.0.166 with SuperSu root .
I wish A11,A12 fans a lot of fun and success!

Does anyone here uses A12 (LineageOS 19.0, LineageOS 19.1)? I currently use @AndyYan 's LineageOS 19.1 and mostly it works quite smoothly. I like the cosmetics of A12, the animations are way smother than on previous versions. Also no new lag or crashes. It feels like the battery last less time (but it is possible that I use my phone more this days).
There are two problems that I face with it. The first one was during first boot Andoid asks to enter PIN. If you enter it you run into loop and have to reset the phone. The solution is to skip the phone security part (PIN, pattern, ...) and do that later. The other is with bluetooth. It finds other devices and other devices sees the phone. But pairing always fails. Does enybody have the same problem (and has found the solution)?

luka_bubi said:
But pairing always fails. Does enybody have the same problem
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Known issue on Kirin
luka_bubi said:
and has found the solution)?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, afaik
luka_bubi said:
I like the cosmetics of A12,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried [GSI] dotOS-R-v5.2-OFFICIAL ? Screens can be found here

-Alf- said:
Have you tried [GSI] dotOS-R-v5.2-OFFICIAL ? Screens can be found here
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, not yet- Looks great. I have to try it someday, right now I do not have time to reset my phone. Waiting for vacations

Since i had unresolved issues with A12 and bluetooth I gave up and tried dotOS a try. Well it looks and feels great. I noticed the phone was always hot and it loosed 20% of battery every hour. I did not use the phone at all, only to check the clock every now and then. Now I am back on CAOS11 and hope everything will work.

luka_bubi said:
Since i had unresolved issues with A12 and bluetooth I gave up and tried dotOS a try. Well it looks and feels great. I noticed the phone was always hot and it loosed 20% of battery every hour. I did not use the phone at all, only to check the clock every now and then. Now I am back on CAOS11 and hope everything will work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sorry I wasted your time bro
luka_bubi said:
I noticed the phone was always hot and it loosed 20% of battery every hour.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Strange...

-Alf- said:
I'm sorry I wasted your time bro
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No time was wasted. It is a beautiful rom with unique design features. I would have never had heard about it if it wasn't for your recommendation. Too bad my phone started to overheat and used so much battery while doing nothing. I wonder what was the issue. It is possible to be related with battery management as you have already noticed. Perhaps I will try it later someday.
As for A12 I hope somebody will find the fix for our bluetooth issues.

Lineage 19.1 is a nice rom, but I tested it and PE and the same bug was found: The cam doesn't work when opened by other appsLineage 19.1 é uma bela rom, porém testei ela e a PE e o mesmo bug foi constatado: A cam não funciona quando é aberta por outros apps