Since we have the Oreo firmware, and since Cedric has official Pixel Experience is it possible to port over to G5S?
JarlPenguin said:
Since we have the Oreo firmware, and since Cedric has official Pixel Experience is it possible to port over to G5S?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just wait linage is released so developers have the working source code have some patience they are already in development
Pixel Experience is on the way!
JarlPenguin said:
Since we have the Oreo firmware, and since Cedric has official Pixel Experience is it possible to port over to G5S?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I own the @montanalab channel on the telegram, and we have an exclusive test group where some devs release private builds, to get feedback and stabilize the roms as fast as possible. Pixel Experience is already being compiled and we will begin testing soon. As soon as the ROM goes public it will be published first in @montanalab and then here in XDA.
Related
Hello,
Will the Motorola Moto G5 get official support for LineageOS like for example the Motorola Moto G4 Play?
Stefan22 said:
Hello,
Will the Motorola Moto G5 get official support for LineageOS like for example the Motorola Moto G4 Play?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's up to the person who builds it to update all their github.com repositories with all the sources for building and then submit it to lineageos
This has apparently been done but no reply has been received - either because not all the sources have been made available or the request has not been processed
TheFixItMan said:
It's up to the person who builds it to update all their github.com repositories with all the sources for building and then submit it to lineageos
This has apparently been done but no reply has been received - either because not all the sources have been made available or the request has not been processed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I take it's the same as Resurrection remix OS!?
aaronboy205 said:
I take it's the same as Resurrection remix OS!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
each rom will have its own requirements to become official - check either their website or github for details
Is it likely it will ever get official support? I need a new phone (coming from Moto G falcon with Lineage 14.1), Moto G4+ and G5 are more or less the same price in my country, and if I haven't gone for the G5 yet is because I'm not sure it will be getting that support. Or do you think Moto G5 custom ROM scene will be at some point as good as Moto G4's?
isaacnoroncaasi said:
Is it likely it will ever get official support? I need a new phone (coming from Moto G falcon with Lineage 14.1), Moto G4+ and G5 are more or less the same price in my country, and if I haven't gone for the G5 yet is because I'm not sure it will be getting that support. Or do you think Moto G5 custom ROM scene will be at some point as good as Moto G4's?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Keep your Falcon if it still works
Cedric is far from being a bad device, but I would have wait a little more if my own falcon had not died too soon.
Cedric doesn't have a big enough community for any efficient dev teamwork.
I have been using the Lenovo P2 for quite some time now. We have all received nougat on our P2 and we know that Lenovo follows a rather annoying one update policy for it's devices. Hence I believe the future of this device is faded, at least from Lenovo's point of view and would like to know which is the best official ROM for Lenovo P2 right now?
Define "official"... I think the only official ROMs are Lenovo's...
Latest to me
IshtaNoob said:
Define "official"... I think the only official ROMs are Lenovo's...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A ROM which is capable of being a daily driver and has support from the developers
Tahir Baig said:
I have been using the Lenovo P2 for quite some time now. We have all received nougat on our P2 and we know that Lenovo follows a rather annoying one update policy for it's devices. Hence I believe the future of this device is faded, at least from Lenovo's point of view and would like to know which is the best official ROM for Lenovo P2 right now?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Best depends on your perspective of your usage & requirements.
Though I'd say
Offical LOS 14.1
which is getting weekly OTAs & monthly security patches. pretty stable as stock.
AOSIP 8.1 by Shubham
almost stable may be better in feature than LOS, I've used it for quite a while but its SE Linux is Permissive which causes some apps non functional.
Beside these two i also used LOS15.1 , RR & other Oreo ROMs they are currently under development but can be used as daily drivers because all major bugs like volte, nfc ect. has been solved in almost all Oreo ROMs for P2. But again SE Linux is not Enforcing in these ROMs so you'd need to root to make some apps run.
It'd say you'd try yourself which suits your requirements best use it as your daily driver.
amansehdav said:
Best depends on your perspective of your usage & requirements.
Though I'd say
Offical LOS 14.1
which is getting weekly OTAs & monthly security patches. pretty stable as stock.
AOSIP 8.1 by Shubham
almost stable may be better in feature than LOS, I've used it for quite a while but its SE Linux is Permissive which causes some apps non functional.
Beside these two i also used LOS15.1 , RR & other Oreo ROMs they are currently under development but can be used as daily drivers because all major bugs like volte, nfc ect. has been solved in almost all Oreo ROMs for P2. But again SE Linux is not Enforcing in these ROMs so you'd need to root to make some apps run.
It'd say you'd try yourself which suits your requirements best use it as your daily driver.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey! Have you tried out the pixel experience ROM. It looks promising. Not sure about the updates and stuff as there are not a lot of people talking about it on p2. Hence the stability and reliability of that pixel experience ROM is unsure. Here is the link- https://download.pixelexperience.org/
Tahir Baig said:
Hey! Have you tried out the pixel experience ROM. It looks promising. Not sure about the updates and stuff as there are not a lot of people talking about it on p2. Hence the stability and reliability of that pixel experience ROM is unsure. Here is the link- https://download.pixelexperience.org/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm already experiencing pixel in LOS 14.1
amansehdav said:
I'm already experiencing pixel in LOS 14.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe LOS 14.1 on nougat 7.1.2. The pixel experience ROM is on Oreo 8.1.
Tahir Baig said:
I believe LOS 14.1 on nougat 7.1.2. The pixel experience ROM is on Oreo 8.1.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunatily you can't use location in the pixel xperience rom
potatoman4321 said:
Unfortunatily you can't use location in the pixel xperience rom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is volte, fingerprint scanner working fine? Also is there any other issues or bugs in pixel experience ROM?
Tahir Baig said:
Is volte, fingerprint scanner working fine? Also is there any other issues or bugs in pixel experience ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't use volte,
Yes fp scanner working fine after encryption,
Not that I know about.
Tahir Baig said:
Is volte, fingerprint scanner working fine? Also is there any other issues or bugs in pixel experience ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pixel experience is not updated for a while and it is not going to be updated, I think. You can go with AEX or Cardinal rom as these two have developer support now. Cardinal rom is official too, so OTA updates will be available. If it is nougat, only Lineage rom have weekly updates. :good:
Hi
I would love to start developing Rom for Albus. Does anyone want to work with me to try to develop the Pixel Experience?
Sounds great,but what a shame that I don't have much time
Tester
Crix.Ful92 said:
Hi
I would love to start developing Rom for Albus. Does anyone want to work with me to try to develop the Pixel Experience?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you need someone to test, you can talk to me. Telegram: +55 86 999416164.
maybe @dlproject and @Junior Passos and @davidsonsjesus and @rahulsnair are up for the task? What do you guys say?
pixel experience is awesome! i would love to have it and I'm pretty sure the community would to. Oreo or Pie it would be amazing. maybe it would be wise to wait for the release of kernels and such from Pie 9.0 for ALBUS since the current kernel is limited to android 8.0 but that would be you guyses call, if the current set of tools allows Pixel Experience to be experienced than bring it on! pretty please!!!!!
You can have the pixel experience rom using project treble.
But the vendor is outdated it. And the only man who is create rom on project treble is the developer from lineage 15.1.
In order to use the leatest version of any rom for excample AEX, Pixel Experience and other rooms the kernel must be update to the leatest security fix.
I was succsesufull flash AEX Oreo but can't update because to the older version of the security path.
Sectorian said:
You can have the pixel experience rom using project treble.
But the vendor is outdated it. And the only man who is create rom on project treble is the developer from lineage 15.1.
In order to use the leatest version of any rom for excample AEX, Pixel Experience and other rooms the kernel must be update to the leatest security fix.
I was succsesufull flash AEX Oreo but can't update because to the older version of the security path.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
could you please elaborate more specifically? I understand that project treble separates the firmware files in two categories, the essential (aka hardware) and the substantial (aka software), so we would get the essential of ALBUS and combine with the substantial of PIXEL 2, is that what you are suggesting? But for the "fusion" to work both firmwares must be on the same security patch.. is that what you mean or did I understand it incorrectly?
xcaninox said:
could you please elaborate more specifically? I understand that project treble separates the firmware files in two categories, the essential (aka hardware) and the substantial (aka software), so we would get the essential of ALBUS and combine with the substantial of PIXEL 2, is that what you are suggesting? But for the "fusion" to work both firmwares must be on the same security patch.. is that what you mean or did I understand it incorrectly?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. We have only one treble relase for the LOS 15.1 and the security patch is only to octombre. If you use version in augost you will have a bootloop.
I ask the dev in LOS 15.1 to update the treble version so we can use the vendor but he don't response.
I heard that project treble is way harder to work with then anybody anticipated and that it is currently a nightmare to be avoided. I say it's worth trying though since it's opportunity. What's the name of the dev? Ping him here in this topic
Crix.Ful92 said:
Hi
I would love to start developing Rom for Albus. Does anyone want to work with me to try to develop the Pixel Experience?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
SoonTM
https://forum.xda-developers.com/z2-play/development/rom-pixel-experience-t3859477
Is there any way to get android p beta based custom ROM for Lenovo zuk Z2 Plus
DEV JC said:
Is there any way to get android p beta based custom ROM for Lenovo zuk Z2 Plus
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As far as I have read here in XDA. We have to wait for Android P GSI release, after which developers can start working on ROM for respective devices.
That still hasn't happened yet !! So you have to wait for that to happen before development can start.
There are rumors that LineageOS and Resurrection Remix ROM team has got their hands on that. But then again, I am not sure. It just talks happening in internet. But if that is true, expect ROMs based on those distributions tree to get P sooner than others.
Some flagship devices are getting Android p beta too
Mi mix 2s, nokia 7 Plus... And some others...
DEV JC said:
Some flagship devices are getting Android p beta too
Mi mix 2s, nokia 7 Plus... And some others...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are business partners of Google. So those hardware makers will get much early access to up coming code compare to general public. As far as I am aware, this code is still not open source, so legally also devs cant modify or work on this.
Regarding devices, OnePlus, Pixel, Nexus devices and many more will get much early access to this beta.
As far as I know, code will become open source with GSI release and that will start the development for custom ROM !!
NaXal said:
As far as I have read here in XDA. We have to wait for Android P GSI release, after which developers can start working on ROM for respective devices.
That still hasn't happened yet !! So you have to wait for that to happen before development can start.
There are rumors that LineageOS and Resurrection Remix ROM team has got their hands on that. But then again, I am not sure. It just talks happening in internet. But if that is true, expect ROMs based on those distributions tree to get P sooner than others.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I was also wondering the same thing and this helped to answer my questions about what's happening.
I think Android P GSI is released now.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/le...t/oxygen-os-beta11-port-z2plus-t3815067/page7
Hi!
If I understand things correctly, my Moto G5 phone is born with an Android OS version that only accepts 32bit code, although the hardware is 64bit?
Why did Moto do that? It sounds like selling a car with a 6 or 8 cylinders engine, and only use 4 of them...?!
And on top of that, I discovered they stopped updating that (primitive 32bit) Android 8.1.0 OS in February 2019...
Should I switch to a custom 64bit ROM? NB!: Stability and robustness is more important to me than fancy new features...!
I found 2 lists of 'Best ROMs for Moto G5'. The shortest recommends 8 here:
https://romsx.com/best-custom-roms-for-moto-g5/
So which should I choose?
NB: Moto G5 only has 16 GB.
Hero002 said:
Hi!
If I understand things correctly, my Moto G5 phone is born with an Android OS version that only accepts 32bit code, although the hardware is 64bit?
Why did Moto do that? It sounds like selling a car with a 6 or 8 cylinders engine, and only use 4 of them...?!
And on top of that, I discovered they stopped updating that (primitive 32bit) Android 8.1.0 OS in February 2019...
Should I switch to a custom 64bit ROM? NB!: Stability and robustness is more important to me than fancy new features...!
I found 2 lists of 'Best ROMs for Moto G5'. The shortest recommends 8 here:
https://romsx.com/best-custom-roms-for-moto-g5/
So which should I choose?
NB: Moto G5 only has 16 GB.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You will have to ask Motorola for the answer to the first part
As for custom 64bit roms:
Lineage 17.1
Lineage mint (based on lineage 17.1)
ASOP android 10
Are the latest custom roms for this device (see dev section)
All will have the same issue with regards to camera/video recording not working fully
TheFixItMan said:
You will have to ask Motorola for the answer to the first part
As for custom 64bit roms:
Lineage 17.1
Lineage mint (based on lineage 17.1)
ASOP android 10
Are the latest custom roms for this device (see dev section)
All will have the same issue with regards to camera/video recording not working fully
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for your reply!
But what about ROMs that have been more tested in real life, where camera and video etc. work?
Yes - it is Motorola that should answer my first questions. I don't expect any answer from them... But others might have a comment...
Hero002 said:
Thank you for your reply!
But what about ROMs that have been more tested in real life, where camera and video etc. work?
Yes - it is Motorola that should answer my first questions. I don't expect any answer from them... But others might have a comment...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All 64bit roms will have the camera issue as Motorola have not released updated camera libs
The roms I listed above are the latest roms which will have the camera bug minimised but you will still experience issues in some apps like only being able to take a certain amount of photos before the app freezes, camera not working in low light, green tint, video not recording/saving and so on. You can use various other apps but nothing is perfect and you may still experience issues
The only fully functioning custom rom with no bugs will be the 32bit lineage 14.1
TheFixItMan said:
All 64bit roms will have the camera issue as Motorola have not released updated camera libs
The roms I listed above are the latest roms which will have the camera bug minimised but you will still experience issues in some apps like only being able to take a certain amount of photos before the app freezes, camera not working in low light, green tint, video not recording/saving and so on. You can use various other apps but nothing is perfect and you may still experience issues
The only fully functioning custom rom with no bugs will be the 32bit lineage 14.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is the most useful information I have yet seen about custom ROMs - thank you!
But according to https://forum.xda-developers.com/g5/development/7-1-x-lineageos-14-1-moto-g5-t3611973 LineageOS 14.1 for Moto G5 is:
ROM OS Version: 7.1.x Nougat
Last Updated 2018-03-18
And the 'stock' OS on my Moto G5 is Android 8.1.0 updated in February 2019.
My intention was to UPgrade my OS, not DOWNgrade it... !
So THAT LineageOS 14.1 doesn't really seem relevant.
And on https://download.lineageos.org/ there doesn't seem to be a version for Moto G5(?) There are versions for G4 and G6, but not G5. (Neither under Lenovo - the actual producer.)
But thanks anyway!
Hero002 said:
That is the most useful information I have yet seen about custom ROMs - thank you!
But according to https://forum.xda-developers.com/g5/development/7-1-x-lineageos-14-1-moto-g5-t3611973 LineageOS 14.1 for Moto G5 is:
ROM OS Version: 7.1.x Nougat
Last Updated 2018-03-18
And the 'stock' OS on my Moto G5 is Android 8.1.0 updated in February 2019.
My intention was to UPgrade my OS, not DOWNgrade it... !
So THAT LineageOS 14.1 doesn't really seem relevant.
And on https://download.lineageos.org/ there doesn't seem to be a version for Moto G5(?) There are versions for G4 and G6, but not G5. (Neither under Lenovo - the actual producer.)
But thanks anyway!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only official versions will be on the lineageos website
There is no difference between an official and unofficial version except the official versions are built on the lineage servers every week with any lineage side changes (not device side unless merged by maintainer)
However official versions have to meet certain criteria in terms of everything that works in stock rom must work in the unofficial lineage build submitted to become official.
As the camera doesn't work as it does in stock in lineage 17.1 it will never become official in its current state
They are listed under Motorola because that is the company that makes the phones
Lenovo is the parent company that owns Motorola
TheFixItMan said:
Only official versions will be on the lineageos website
There is no difference between an official and unofficial version except the official versions are built on the lineage servers every week with any lineage side changes (not device side unless merged by maintainer)
However official versions have to meet certain criteria in terms of everything that works in stock rom must work in the unofficial lineage build submitted to become official.
As the camera doesn't work as it does in stock in lineage 17.1 it will never become official in its current state
They are listed under Motorola because that is the company that makes the phones
Lenovo is the parent company that owns Motorola
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you.
But I am not 100% sure about whether you are confirming that the stock ROM on Moto G5 is the newest available Android OS version where everything works?
Hero002 said:
Thank you.
But I am not 100% sure about whether you are confirming that the stock ROM on Moto G5 is the newest available Android OS version where everything works?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock rom will be the latest os version where everything works 100%
All 64bit custom roms have camera issues due to no updated propriety sources
TheFixItMan said:
Stock rom will be the latest os version where everything works 100%
All 64bit custom roms have camera issues due to no updated proprietary sources
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's sad.
So when I want to buy a phone in the future:
Which other smart phone brands will probably not leave their customers with 'a choice between plague or cholera'...?
Hero002 said:
That's sad.
So when I want to buy a phone in the future:
Which other smart phone brands will probably not leave their customers with 'a choice between plague or cholera'...?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Samsung will have the most community support as they are the most popular phones
Google pixel will obviously have longevity
Xiaomi might be the best budget choice other than later Motorola models