Is internal audio/system sounds recording possible? - Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro Questions & Answers

I like to play games and want to record internal audio for games to post it on youtube but i am unable to find any app to record internal sounds and record screen at same time. In redmi 4(santoni) latest miui developer rom there is a option of recording system sounds in miui screen recorder and it works perfect but this option is not available in redmi note 5 pro stable / dev rom.
Can anyone make this option available in miui screen recorder for whyred?

RN5 doesn't have internal audio record support in default screen recorder. But Mobizen Screen Recorder support it, and surprisingly without the need to root. But still I don't really trust the app, so if you choose to use it, better restrict the mobile data/wifi access.

Desmanto said:
RN5 doesn't have internal audio record support in default screen recorder. But Mobizen Screen Recorder support it, and surprisingly without the need to root. But still I don't really trust the app, so if you choose to use it, better restrict the mobile data/wifi access.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you sure about mobizen? Or it needs the external headphones from them? I think only samsung and lg support internal audio recording in mobizen. Hmmm

t0per666 said:
Are you sure about mobizen? Or it needs the external headphones from them? I think only samsung and lg support internal audio recording in mobizen. Hmmm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very sure, no external device needed. At least it is recording the internal audio in RR 6.1. Play some music and cover the speaker, the volume stay the same in the recording result. RN4 actually has supported the internal audio recording by default. The feature disappear in RN5. Somehow Mobizen can do it without the need to root or disabling the SELinux.

Desmanto said:
Very sure, no external device needed. At least it is recording the internal audio in RR 6.1. Play some music and cover the speaker, the volume stay the same in the recording result. RN4 actually has supported the internal audio recording by default. The feature disappear in RN5. Somehow Mobizen can do it without the need to root or disabling the SELinux.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I triedin pe pie but it only records via mic not internally. Can you show me your recording using mobizen?

Desmanto said:
RN5 doesn't have internal audio record support in default screen recorder. But Mobizen Screen Recorder support it, and surprisingly without the need to root. But still I don't really trust the app, so if you choose to use it, better restrict the mobile data/wifi access.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for replying. But for me mobizen recording with mic only, no internal sound option is there. Which version you were using and on which rom.

Adi_777 said:
Thank you for replying. But for me mobizen recording with mic only, no internal sound option is there. Which version you were using and on which rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use the mobizen for Samsung it will record internal audio but the drawback is that you cannot hear the gameplay sound while playing it which is not suitable for games like PUBG

t0per666 said:
I triedin pe pie but it only records via mic not internally. Can you show me your recording using mobizen?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Adi_777 said:
Thank you for replying. But for me mobizen recording with mic only, no internal sound option is there. Which version you were using and on which rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am sorry, I can't reproduce the internal audio recording result anymore. Strange that last time I tried it, covering the speaker won't lower the volume. Now it does (so now it is mic recording). Probably when I test it before, I am still on RR the old build from July. The latest build from august probably patch it up. I don't know, but sorry I don't wanna to go back to previous RR build just to test this. As I am not using it. I am using the latest version of mobizen at the time I test it.
leo_pard2331 said:
Use the mobizen for Samsung it will record internal audio but the drawback is that you cannot hear the gameplay sound while playing it which is not suitable for games like PUBG
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What ROM do you use? I only try it for a while, as I caught the app is running background all the time. Since I don't need it, uninstall is the best solution.

Desmanto said:
I am sorry, I can't reproduce the internal audio recording result anymore. Strange that last time I tried it, covering the speaker won't lower the volume. Now it does (so now it is mic recording). Probably when I test it before, I am still on RR the old build from July. The latest build from august probably patch it up. I don't know, but sorry I don't wanna to go back to previous RR build just to test this. As I am not using it. I am using the latest version of mobizen at the time I test it.
What ROM do you use? I only try it for a while, as I caught the app is running background all the time. Since I don't need it, uninstall is the best solution.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Last time i used it i was on Masik 2.5

Thank you for helping guys. I think there is no solution for this problem right now.

Related

Video/ Sound stereo/mono recording

I'm on a HTC 10 full port ( Real Sense 8.0 & 8.0_g (S.Team) DualSim (S.Team) and everything works like a charm. But I found out, that comparing to the stock ROM, when shooting a video, the sound doesn't record in STEREO mode. I need help finding the right place in the system to modify and turn this feature on, please. Stock rom has it on. ALso, where to find the file to modify and make sound recording apps to stereo record also? Device is Desire 816dug ( Dual sim Qualcomm version
@kinghunki , maybe you can help?
please help me
EDIT:
Latest v.3.0.0 S.Team rom works fine with the stereo recording when shooting video. my last question is - how to make our device record stereo sound in Sound Recording apps? Even on stock roms they are mono. What part of System needs to be modified?
Mango Polo said:
I'm on a HTC 10 full port ( Real Sense 8.0 & 8.0_g (S.Team) DualSim (S.Team) and everything works like a charm. But I found out, that comparing to the stock ROM, when shooting a video, the sound doesn't record in STEREO mode. I need help finding the right place in the system to modify and turn this feature on, please. Stock rom has it on. ALso, where to find the file to modify and make sound recording apps to stereo record also? Device is Desire 816dug ( Dual sim Qualcomm version
@kinghunki , maybe you can help?
please help me
EDIT:
Latest v.3.0.0 S.Team rom works fine with the stereo recording when shooting video. my last question is - how to make our device record stereo sound in Sound Recording apps? Even on stock roms they are mono. What part of System needs to be modified?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting.
I'll look into it when I've got a chance.
bigsupersquid said:
Interesting.
I'll look into it when I've got a chance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
our device has awesome recording quality. if give it a stereo breathe, it might become even better. what files of the rom take care of this?
Mango Polo said:
our device has awesome recording quality. if give it a stereo breathe, it might become even better. what files of the rom take care of this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's a couple xml files in /etc that may take care of it.
Like I said, I'll have to look into it further.
bigsupersquid said:
Interesting.
I'll look into it when I've got a chance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
bigsupersquid said:
There's a couple xml files in /etc that may take care of it.
Like I said, I'll have to look into it further.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
as I remember, someone said, when I was wearing a cyanogen rom. on my galaxy s4, which had stereo recording on stock roms., so that forum member answered my question in this way - As basis, AOSP or Android Original roms don't support 2 mics recording. That's all I know.
thanks for taking an interest on this!

Lineage OS recording app

Where does LineageOS recording app saves files?
Sent from my Nexus 5 CAF using Tapatalk
Good question.
For sound records: internal sd>music>soundrecords
For screen records: internal sd>movies>screenrecords
I'm using lineage os 14.1 on ze551ml, when i try to use screen recording after the recording the video can't play even in vlc player.
screen recorder freezes after pressing stop in not bar.
Anyone have found a internal audio recorder like rec me on Android 6.0 but on this build 7.1.1?
guizzzmo said:
Anyone have found a internal audio recorder like rec me on Android 6.0 but on this build 7.1.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you not have this?
jhedfors said:
Do you not have this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes i have. But it record microphone only. I want to record a live podcast on YouTube so i need to record internal audio source.
I have try the internal audio plugin for Android 6.0 but it don't work anymore.
guizzzmo said:
Yes i have. But it record microphone only. I want to record a live podcast on YouTube so i need to record internal audio source.
I have try the internal audio plugin for Android 6.0 but it don't work anymore.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. By "internal", I thought you meant "included".
The recorder freezes while recording
Does anybody know plans for file formats or reasons for choosing .wav? I think .ogg / .mp3 is better than .wav.
Hi guys,
I am running LineageOS 14.1 on oneplus one. I'm not able to find the native screen recording app which used to be in the status bar dropdown menu. Nor able to find in the settings anywhere.
Could anyone please let me know where I can find the screen recording app??
Many thanks in advance,
Regards,
Ranga
crazyranga said:
Hi guys,
I am running LineageOS 14.1 on oneplus one. I'm not able to find the native screen recording app which used to be in the status bar dropdown menu. Nor able to find in the settings anywhere.
Could anyone please let me know where I can find the screen recording app??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sound and Video is done with the same app -- Recorder.
Learned tonight if you long press on the screenshot tile, it will start video recording. (Using xposed module GravityBox[N], not sure if it is applicable without that module.)
Also was not aware that the recorder app also did video.

[Q] Record internal audio - Android 8 rooted

Hey guys,
I've been looking for a solution to record internal audio on my OP5T with Android 8 and Magisk.
RecMe with "Internal Audio Plugin" isn't working. I can't enable the plugin (because of Magisk?).
SCR Pro isn't working either, because Android 8 is not supported.
Does anyone have an idea how to record internal audio?
Thanks in advance.
Seems that it's definitely impossible since 7.0
Only Samsung devices can do this...
Use Acr app.. It is working like charm
Hey Baldesarra!
Have you had a chance to try out the "Call recorder -ACR" app? Because it works perfectly on my OnePlus 5T (not rooted, Android 7 still). Frankly I'm a little afraid to install that update to Android 8 on the off-chance it'll make the ACR app to stop working )) Call recording is too essential for me. Let me know if it still works on Android 8, because it looks like it should, a very HQ app.
Although I just now noticed you wanted to record internal audio in general... ACR is for auto-phone call recording, not sure if it can record all internal audio.
be carefull with RecMe its send a lot of data when it starts to record.
rsheptolut said:
Hey Baldesarra!
Have you had a chance to try out the "Call recorder -ACR" app? Because it works perfectly on my OnePlus 5T (not rooted, Android 7 still). Frankly I'm a little afraid to install that update to Android 8 on the off-chance it'll make the ACR app to stop working )) Call recording is too essential for me. Let me know if it still works on Android 8, because it looks like it should, a very HQ app.
Although I just now noticed you wanted to record internal audio in general... ACR is for auto-phone call recording, not sure if it can record all internal audio.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think OP meant screen video recording with internal audio from the device. Not call recording.
atef3a said:
I think OP meant screen video recording with internal audio from the device. Not call recording.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Right. Figured that out after I wrote that
Out if context, ACR not working for me. Can someone please share their settings?
Any updates on this?
lol even S9/S9+ cannot run any call recorder apps, it's worse than this case IMO.
Call record app by Skvalex (https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1441643) records internal audio. which means that Skvalex broke the barriers of "internal audio record from Anroid 7.0+ is nearly impossible". So, if the same "internal audio" recording technique used for screen record with internal audio, it may work.
使用twrp将Internal Audio Plugin apk移动到system/app,重启系统就已激活。
安卓8.1亲测!
DU Recorder from playstore works fine.
Sent from my OnePlus 5T using XDA Labs
Any updates on this?
vegetaz said:
Any updates on this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately not
If you install fooview as a system app there is an advanced setting option to record internal audio.
It's currently working on my OP5T OOS 5.1.4 rooted with Magisk. The only downside is normal audio is off when the app is recording and the resolution is a bit weird imo at the moment but internal audio recording works.
darsh79n1 said:
Use Acr app.. It is working like charm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
its for recording Call and its not internal audio recorder...
---------- Post added at 07:21 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:18 AM ----------
jaymv said:
使用twrp将Internal Audio Plugin apk移动到system/app,重启系统就已激活。
安卓8.1亲测!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
do you have any flashable zip file?
I achieved to record and live my screen with internal audio using these apps :
-https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mobzapp.recme.free
-https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mobzapp.screenstream.trial
-https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mobzapp.internalaudioplugin
Internal audio plug-in must be a system app to work, you can use app systemizer from magisk repo to move it to priv-app
PS : I'm using a OnePlus 5T OOS 5.1.5 (Oreo 8.1) magisk v17.1
Record Internal Gameplay Audio Android /No cut Earphone /No Root
Recording internal audio in Android is restricted by Google.
But you can able to record your internal audio of your Android by the trick which I made recently with the help of this trick you can record your internal audio without rooting the device or cutting your earphone so for more information check out my channel on YOUTUBE ( KT ANDROID) and search for the video corresponding video.
Hope you liked it!!

Any call recording solutions for Android P / Pixel 2?

I've been using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex for many years across many devices but it seems like it's no longer working since Pie. Tried a couple others and they're also only recording my side of the conversation only.
Is there anything out there working on non-rooted P?
auto call recorder works perfect. I think call recorder from skvalex works also.
It does not work on Android P.
[KB] Android 9 (P) Call recording issues.
There is no way to record interlocutor's audio properly at the moment. You can use Loud speaker to record both side. All call recording apps will be same., This is not limitation of ACR but Android 9 and the phone.
pato said:
It does not work on Android P.
[KB] Android 9 (P) Call recording issues.
There is no way to record interlocutor's audio properly at the moment. You can use Loud speaker to record both side. All call recording apps will be same., This is not limitation of ACR but Android 9 and the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, that's what I was afraid of.
I hate losing functionality in an update.
megapixle said:
I've been using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex for many years across many devices but it seems like it's no longer working since Pie. Tried a couple others and they're also only recording my side of the conversation only.
Is there anything out there working on non-rooted P?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex on Pie and it works perfectly with root. I don't know if it will work without root though. If you are rooted I will give you what settings that I'm using.
murphyjasonc said:
I'm using 'Call Recorder' by skvalex on Pie and it works perfectly with root. I don't know if it will work without root though. If you are rooted I will give you what settings that I'm using.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you detail what settings your'e using? Because even skvalex himself mentioned Android P doesn't record the other party, only yourself.
tracerit said:
Can you detail what settings your'e using? Because even skvalex himself mentioned Android P doesn't record the other party, only yourself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know if it makes any difference but I'm rooted with magisk version 16.7-1674. That build can be found in the Flash kernel thread. I'm also using Flash kernel 3.0. Everything else is stock. Call recorder 3.0 with root add-on 2.03-1.
Audio source: Caf
Format: Flac
Everything else is basically default. I attached a few screenshots. Here is a link to a recording with me talking to an answering machine I just uploaded to Google drivehttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1eDqtDJzMaZi05l7CdY1fUy8teXm8U4LC/view?usp=drivesdk.
You can hear me talking over it saying hello several times. All my recordings are perfectly clear on both sides.
cube acr works without problems
paulyz said:
cube acr works without problems
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On Pie? Rooted or non-rooted?
megapixle said:
On Pie? Rooted or non-rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pie. non rooted
paulyz said:
Pie. non rooted
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doesn't work for me. Same problem as all the other apps, can only hear my side.
"phone recording audio source - voice communication" works for me
Works
ACR on Pie is working fine on my 2 XL, records both sides nice and clear.
Audio Source - Voice_Communication
Recording Format - MP3
Audio Gain - 8DB
HeWhoDaresWins said:
ACR on Pie is working fine on my 2 XL, records both sides nice and clear.
Audio Source - Voice_Communication
Recording Format - MP3
Audio Gain - 8DB
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is recording from phone earpiece speaker with gain. All apps can do that. It is not real call recording
NLLAPPS said:
This is recording from phone earpiece speaker with gain. All apps can do that. It is not real call recording
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm simply telling you my phone model, which app I installed and the settings I used.
It recorded both sides of the call, nice and clear, I am able to hear the entire call.
what part of that is not real call recording?
HeWhoDaresWins said:
I'm simply telling you my phone model, which app I installed and the settings I used.
It recorded both sides of the call, nice and clear, I am able to hear the entire call.
what part of that is not real call recording?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you misunderstood me. It might be acceptable for you or someone else. However,cCall is recorded from the earpiece speaker, gain applied. Real call recording is done by getting audio form Android system not from speaker. Hence, it is not real call recording.
Works perfectly on Pie with Pixel 2 XL rooted!
murphyjasonc said:
I don't know if it makes any difference but I'm rooted with magisk version 16.7-1674. That build can be found in the Flash kernel thread. I'm also using Flash kernel 3.0. Everything else is stock. Call recorder 3.0 with root add-on 2.03-1.
Audio source: Caf
Format: Flac
Everything else is basically default. I attached a few screenshots. Here is a link to a recording with me talking to an answering machine I just uploaded to Google drive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks so much! Was just missing the ROOT module.

Miui 10 screen recording with internal audio

Hi i have a max 3 with miui 10 8.8.3 china rom
the built in screen recorder does not records the internal audio it records via mic from the speaker
Does anyone with differnt rom on their phone could check it for me if they can record the internal audio please and let me know
I would like to record some gameplay.
Thank
Anyone with a mi max 3 could check the screen recording app if it has an option to select system sound please
I got mute and mic option only.
Thanks
k0k3sz said:
Anyone with a mi max 3 could check the screen recording app if it has an option to select system sound please
I got mute and mic option only.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately, no. I'm on 8.8.9 eu rom. Same mic and mute option only.
Have you tried AZ Screen Recorder? It allows in game sound recording.
New android version does not allow to record internal audio.
opasha said:
Unfortunately, no. I'm on 8.8.9 eu rom. Same mic and mute option only.
Have you tried AZ Screen Recorder? It allows in game sound recording.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks
Yeah i tried AZ Screen Recorder aswell and cannot select internal audio
I saw a video on youtube which showed the miui10 features and it mentioned it in the video about the built in screen recorder had the option to select the system sound
Thanks
k0k3sz said:
thanks
Yeah i tried AZ Screen Recorder aswell and cannot select internal audio
I saw a video on youtube which showed the miui10 features and it mentioned it in the video about the built in screen recorder had the option to select the system sound
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try this: http://en.miui.com/thread-2092356-1-1.html
My phone is not rooted unfortunately and i'm not really want to root it tbh
Thanks

Categories

Resources