android pie + root = corrupted? - Google Pixel 2 XL Questions & Answers

android pie + root = corrupted?
I have been on DP4 for a while now and just did P OTA sideload and went to flash magisk. upon rebooting it looped and went into a recovery mode stating that the android system was corrupted..
Went ahead and formatted, attempted to flash the factory image and got an error stating that fastboot could not create an image for user data..
the version of twrp im running is 3.2.1-2 and magisk 16.7.
After running deuces bootloop recovery, resetting the data after the first boot im able to get the phone back up but i cant get magisk to work without it corrupting the damn thing. any thoughts?

Cosmo100292 said:
android pie + root = corrupted?
I have been on DP4 for a while now and just did P OTA sideload and went to flash magisk. upon rebooting it looped and went into a recovery mode stating that the android system was corrupted..
Went ahead and formatted, attempted to flash the factory image and got an error stating that fastboot could not create an image for user data..
the version of twrp im running is 3.2.1-2 and magisk 16.7.
After running deuces bootloop recovery, resetting the data after the first boot im able to get the phone back up but i cant get magisk to work without it corrupting the damn thing. any thoughts?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-2-xl/how-to/quick-2xl-upgrade-reference-8x-oreo-to-t3826330
Twrp 3.2.2, magisk uninstaller and magisk 16.74 might be helpful. Check that thread out.

Thanks! I'll give that a shot tonight

Related

Tried flashing Lineage OS but ended up stuck in a boot loop.

I unlocked the bootloader following Motorolas steps. I then flashed the latest version of TWRP avaiable on the development forum and then flashed Lineage OS + the root zip they provide and gapps. I couldn't figure out how to get out of the bootloop so I've since gone back to stock. Any idea what I was missing?
TWRP:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mo...recovery-unofficial-twrp-moto-z-play-t3495629
Lineage:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-z-play/development/rom-unofficial-cyanogenmod-14-1-t3495644
Did you read the notices and entries on the Linage last pages of the thread that people are having it fail on the install, the latest release? That would be a clue...
I even tried flashing Pure Nexus but that too was stuck on a loop. I left it for about 10 minutes as it was loading. :/
I did the same thing like you on my first attempt, on my second I was able to install Lineage OS successfully. I'll provide the steps I did.
First attempt steps:
1. Unlocking the bootloader using Motorola website
2. Installing TWRP from the same link in your post.
At that point I tried booting the phone, but the phone was booting to TWRP only, tried wiping, format data from TWRP with no luck.
3. From TWRP flashed Lineage OS zip file and GAPPS nano package (the latest version of TWRP is able to see SD card).
At that point I was able to to boot LOS only after executing "fastboot erase user data". Doing the same from within TWRP was not doing the job. The problem was that after each reboot the phone was getting into bootloop again and "fastboot erase userdata" was necessary.
4. At that point I noticed that TWRP thread starts with warning that you have to install a patcher to disable this "verity" feature of the bootloader may be. And I installed the patcher "Verity_FE_patcher.zip"
The patcher didn't fix the issue and went back to stock Nougat using the guide below:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-z-play/how-to/moto-z-play-reteu-firmware-otas-t3557917
First I tried "flashall.bat" , but it didn't wor.k and I flashed all the files manually using the guide . The phone booted normally and I updated it with one OTA update.
Second attempt steps:
1. I wanted to install the verity patcher before anything else and I boot TWRP 3.1.0.1 without flashing it. It booted normally and I realized that the SD card was formated and the patcher zip file is not there. I reboot the system and the phone got in bootloops again even the TWRP was not installed. I coppied the patcher zip, LOS zip, GAPPS zip on SD card . I tried to boot (without flashing) TWRP again, but for some reason TWRP was not able to boot.
2. I flashed TWRP
3. Booted TWRP and flashed verity patcher.
4. Wiped from TWRP and boot the system
At that point I was able to boot the stock firmware with TWRP installed and I was able to restart the phone normally.
5. Flashed LOS and nano GAPPS
Now everything seems to work properly.
Hope this will help.
Thanks. I'll give this a shot tonight. Our first attempts sound very alike.

How to flash magisk

As this is the only root option I can find for 8.x I need some help. When flashing in twrp and rebooting my phone just goes right back into twrp. I remember this happening way back when (when first getting my pixel xl) but I've been out of the game so long now I cannot remember how to fix it. Bravo to the team who cracked this thing back open!
danielson2047 said:
As this is the only root option I can find for 8.x I need some help. When flashing in twrp and rebooting my phone just goes right back into twrp. I remember this happening way back when (when first getting my pixel xl) but I've been out of the game so long now I cannot remember how to fix it. Bravo to the team who cracked this thing back open!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go here:
[Guide] Pixel XL Android 8.1.0 (OREO) Unlock/Lock Bootloader + Install Stock Images/Custom kernels/TWRP Recovery/Systemless ROOT +[URL="https://source.android.com/security/bulletin/pixel"] May Security Patch
Do #7 or #8 your choice
danielson2047 said:
As this is the only root option I can find for 8.x I need some help. When flashing in twrp and rebooting my phone just goes right back into twrp. I remember this happening way back when (when first getting my pixel xl) but I've been out of the game so long now I cannot remember how to fix it. Bravo to the team who cracked this thing back open!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How about a bit more info?
What version of TWRP are you running?
I am running TWRP 3.2.1.2 - Which I ran via fastboot: Fastboot boot trwp.img, then installed the zip of the same TWRP from within the original twrp boot with Fastboot from the storage of my phone. This is the only way to correctly install twrp.
What version of Magisk are you trying to use?
I am using V16.0 - I ran this after fully installing twrp. It installed no errors and I am showing rooted and passing all the security checks.
So i got it to work with v16.4. Had it rooted for a few hours and then installed the xposed module. Mistake. It got stuck in a bootloop, so i rebooted and reflashed my rom. That worked to get the phone booted back up and works fine, but now whenever i try to resintall magisk it just sits at the loading screen. Do i need to go back to completely stock and start over?
danielson2047 said:
So i got it to work with v16.4. Had it rooted for a few hours and then installed the xposed module. Mistake. It got stuck in a bootloop, so i rebooted and reflashed my rom. That worked to get the phone booted back up and works fine, but now whenever i try to resintall magisk it just sits at the loading screen. Do i need to go back to completely stock and start over?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You didn't say what 'ROM' you are using.
Suggestions: a. Search ROM thread for Magisk related problems. b. Search Magisk thread for 'ROM' related problems.
Flash stock 8.1 firmware. Boot into system. Enable usb debugging. Reboot into boot loader, fastboot boot the twrp image, from TWRP flash magisk. ( I use 16.4). Reboot into system. If that works you know nothing is wrong with your phone. You have to reboot into the system at least once before flashing Magisk no matter what rom you're running.

Damn Root......

No matter what I try I am unable to root my P2XL on Android 10......
The process I am taking is to boot up twrp and flash the latest Magisk zip, however it fails right at the end with the error failed to mound system and vendor.....
I have just tried to do it again but with a clean install of the October update but nothing has changed.......
the October update wasn't without issue either as that too failed and I had to factory reset the September image and update OTA.....
anyway, any thoughts or advice on how to achieve it or what might be wrong.......
is there specific TWRP versions I need to boot from etc,,,,
Don't bother with twrp
Just use magisk.
Download the factory pixel image on your PC , unzip the boot.img file and transfer to your phone.
Open magisk manager and install magisk by patching the boot.img file U just transferred.
Copy that new patched boot img back to your PC.
Use ADB to ADB reboot bootloader
Type: fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
That's it
mediaman123 said:
No matter what I try I am unable to root my P2XL on Android 10......
The process I am taking is to boot up twrp and flash the latest Magisk zip, however it fails right at the end with the error failed to mound system and vendor.....
I have just tried to do it again but with a clean install of the October update but nothing has changed.......
the October update wasn't without issue either as that too failed and I had to factory reset the September image and update OTA.....
anyway, any thoughts or advice on how to achieve it or what might be wrong.......
is there specific TWRP versions I need to boot from etc,,,,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Since it has been a few months since I messed with my 2 XL, I followed the upgrade 9x guide in my sig to make sure I didn't forget/skip anything.
I just jumped to 10 last night, root, twrp, and cust kernel.
fastboot latest factory image (I left the -w intact for a clean wipe since going form 9 to 10-but have read it is not necessary)
booted back into bootloader and fastboot boot twrp 3.3.3-0.img
once in twrp I install 3.3.3-0
in twrp installed latest EX kernel for 10
rebooted to system
let it boot up fully for a few minutes
booted into twrp
flashed magisk 19.4
rebooted to trwp (superstition for me)
rebooted to system
checked magisk hide in magisk manager
hit systemless hosts in magisk manager
rebooted
Fresh install of android 10, rooted, with cust kernel.
You mentioned the "failed" notice. I've read several places that TWRP will throw the "failed to mount" warning (or something like that) but that it is a false flag. I got this as well and just continued on.
There may be many diff ways to accomplish this, but THIS method worked for me.
Az Biker said:
[/HIDE]
Since it has been a few months since I messed with my 2 XL, I followed the upgrade 9x guide in my sig to make sure I didn't forget/skip anything.
I just jumped to 10 last night, root, twrp, and cust kernel.
fastboot latest factory image (I left the -w intact for a clean wipe since going form 9 to 10-but have read it is not necessary)
booted back into bootloader and fastboot boot twrp 3.3.3-0.img
once in twrp I install 3.3.3-0
in twrp installed latest EX kernel for 10
rebooted to system
let it boot up fully for a few minutes
booted into twrp
flashed magisk 19.4
rebooted to trwp (superstition for me)
rebooted to system
checked magisk hide in magisk manager
hit systemless hosts in magisk manager
rebooted
Fresh install of android 10, rooted, with cust kernel.
You mentioned the "failed" notice. I've read several places that TWRP will throw the "failed to mount" warning (or something like that) but that it is a false flag. I got this as well and just continued on.
There may be many diff ways to accomplish this, but THIS method worked for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used a similar method:
I used Duece's Script to flash and format data with April image ( I wanted to able to decrypt with pattern lock); rebooted to system; then rebooted back into bootloader and used Duece's Script to flash but not format data with October image; booted back into bootloader and fastboot boot twrp 3.3.0-0.img; in twrp, flashed 3.3.0-0 zip, rebooted to system, and did initial phone set up; rebooted to twrp, flashed caesium kernel and magisk 19.3 and rebooted to system. Everything worked fine. I did get failed to mount" warning in twrp but both the kerkel and magisk worked fine.
Az Biker said:
[/HIDE]
Since it has been a few months since I messed with my 2 XL, I followed the upgrade 9x guide in my sig to make sure I didn't forget/skip anything.
I just jumped to 10 last night, root, twrp, and cust kernel.
fastboot latest factory image (I left the -w intact for a clean wipe since going form 9 to 10-but have read it is not necessary)
booted back into bootloader and fastboot boot twrp 3.3.3-0.img
once in twrp I install 3.3.3-0
in twrp installed latest EX kernel for 10
rebooted to system
let it boot up fully for a few minutes
booted into twrp
flashed magisk 19.4
rebooted to trwp (superstition for me)
rebooted to system
checked magisk hide in magisk manager
hit systemless hosts in magisk manager
rebooted
Fresh install of android 10, rooted, with cust kernel.
You mentioned the "failed" notice. I've read several places that TWRP will throw the "failed to mount" warning (or something like that) but that it is a false flag. I got this as well and just continued on.
There may be many diff ways to accomplish this, but THIS method worked for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, by "checked magisk hide", do you mean that you were able to bypass google's safetynet?
I havn't rooted my P2 XL on A10 since i wasn't sure i will be able to bypass safetynet!
thx
1902 said:
Hi, by "checked magisk hide", do you mean that you were able to bypass google's safetynet?
I havn't rooted my P2 XL on A10 since i wasn't sure i will be able to bypass safetynet!
thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My safety net passes in magisk, but I don't use any apps that I can verify that with.
jlokos said:
I used a similar method:
I used Duece's Script to flash and format data with April image ( I wanted to able to decrypt with pattern lock); rebooted to system; then rebooted back into bootloader and used Duece's Script to flash but not format data with October image; booted back into bootloader and fastboot boot twrp 3.3.3-0.img; in twrp, flashed 3.3.3-0 zip, rebooted to system, and did initial phone set up; rebooted to twrp, flashed caesium kernel and magisk 19.3 and rebooted to system. Everything worked fine. I did get failed to mount" warning in twrp but both the kerkel and magisk worked fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, for TWRP, are you using 3.3.0.0 or 3.3.3.0
I was only able to find 3.3.0.0
Thanks
docluv01 said:
Hi, for TWRP, are you using 3.3.0.0 or 3.3.3.0
I was only able to find 3.3.0.0
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry; an extra 3; I'm using TWRP 3.3.0.0.
---------- Post added at 07:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:37 AM ----------
1902 said:
Hi, by "checked magisk hide", do you mean that you were able to bypass google's safetynet?
I havn't rooted my P2 XL on A10 since i wasn't sure i will be able to bypass safetynet!
thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I DL magisk hide module and use it for two apps, one for comcast business and the other which regulates my home thermostat.
Wow, thanks guys.....you have all laid out pretty well your processes which I will go through later on....
It's strange, as everything is installed and magisk believes it working it just doesn't pass thee root check..
I'll get back to you with my progress...??

After trying to root with Magisk...

After I tried rooting with magisk, Pixel 2XL, 11.0.0 (RP1A.200720.009) And I flashed the patched .img file from magisk, My phone then right there got into a bootloop, I was able to get into the bootloader but nothing else, Now I cant get out of the bootloader and im wondering if there is someway to fix this, I saw a thread on this, Which says I have to change Magisk Manager to Canary but I cant because im stuck in a bootloop AND im in the bootloader, I already unrooted my drive by Flashing the original img but no help...
Any help?
If you flashed a patched img, then flashing back an unpatched boot.img would fix it. You can always download the the full factory image and flash it back.
killer23d said:
If you flashed a patched img, then flashing back an unpatched boot.img would fix it. You can always download the the full factory image and flash it back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
already done, if i flash it again will it work? because im still stuck in the bootloop
Nicster205 said:
already done, if i flash it again will it work? because im still stuck in the bootloop
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if you reflash the factory boot.img then you'll get out of bootloop.
Nicster205 said:
After I tried rooting with magisk, Pixel 2XL, 11.0.0 (RP1A.200720.009) And I flashed the patched .img file from magisk, My phone then right there got into a bootloop, I was able to get into the bootloader but nothing else, Now I cant get out of the bootloader and im wondering if there is someway to fix this, I saw a thread on this, Which says I have to change Magisk Manager to Canary but I cant because im stuck in a bootloop AND im in the bootloader, I already unrooted my drive by Flashing the original img but no help...
Any help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
reflashing the factory boot.img seems useless. you can long-press the power button to force power down. then power up to the fastboot mode,and reflash the full factory image(11 or 10). the nomal methon working on 10 seems dizzy in 11 now.
fwiw, heres the path i used...i hate making it more steps than needed (tranferring boot image to device and back again for magisk patching for example)...
1) flash-all.bat (with wipe enabled - because clean install)
2) Immediately on reboot from 1 and before it gets anywhere near to beginning of setup: fastboot boot twrp-3.4.0-1-taimen.img
3) adb push Magisk-e66b0bf3(20425).zip /tmp
4) adb shell twrp install /tmp/Magisk-e66b0bf3(20425).zip
5) adb reboot
6) after reboot, install canary magisk manager (for whatever reason doesnt install from TWRP flash)
7) open canary magisk manager and enable magiskhide
This is caused by twrp
Use android toolbox, just boot twrp, flash magisk
boot into twrp go to advanced fix bootloop option reboot
Nicster205 said:
After I tried rooting with magisk, Pixel 2XL, 11.0.0 (RP1A.200720.009) And I flashed the patched .img file from magisk, My phone then right there got into a bootloop, I was able to get into the bootloader but nothing else, Now I cant get out of the bootloader and im wondering if there is someway to fix this, I saw a thread on this, Which says I have to change Magisk Manager to Canary but I cant because im stuck in a bootloop AND im in the bootloader, I already unrooted my drive by Flashing the original img but no help...
Any help?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

OnePlus 7T India, 11.0.9.1, booting only to recovery / fastboot after incorrect Magisk update

I have OnePlus7T Indian version. I was on 11.0.9.1 and rooted with Magisk Canary version. There was an Update to Magisk which I accidentally installed with OTA option instead of full. Now my phone is not booting. It goes into original recovery mode or fastboot only. How can I recover from this? I tried to flash the magisk patched image file and it shows as flashed but when I reboot I again reach original recovery / fastboot menu only. Please help!!
Problem solved but don't know how. I was trying many things and when I used Tool All in One to flash TWRP the phone rebooted into the system. Not even sure if TWRP is installed or not but everything is working now and phone is rooted. Not sure how it got resolved. Magisk is updated to latest version.
jesrani said:
Problem solved but don't know how. I was trying many things and when I used Tool All in One to flash TWRP the phone rebooted into the system. Not even sure if TWRP is installed or not but everything is working now and phone is rooted. Not sure how it got resolved. Magisk is updated to latest version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most likely changed slot accidentally when it crashed and then corrected on multiple interventions
HueyT said:
Most likely changed slot accidentally when it crashed and then corrected on multiple interventions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi. I am again having same problem. I updated Magisk Manager and Magisk and some other apps and phone was not booting. After many tries it again booted but all the modules in Magisk were off. So I switched them on and rebooted the phone and now it is just not booting. I tried to use Tool All In One to flash a TWRP but now there is no recovery. The phone is either not booting (stuck on Circle dot rotating) or just going into fastboot, does not go into recovery. I was on OOS11. I tried flashing original recovery through the tool but it fails. Any way out of this mess??
jesrani said:
Hi. I am again having same problem. I updated Magisk Manager and Magisk and some other apps and phone was not booting. After many tries it again booted but all the modules in Magisk were off. So I switched them on and rebooted the phone and now it is just not booting. I tried to use Tool All In One to flash a TWRP but now there is no recovery. The phone is either not booting (stuck on Circle dot rotating) or just going into fastboot, does not go into recovery. I was on OOS11. I tried flashing original recovery through the tool but it fails. Any way out of this mess??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
[OP7T][OOS 11.0.5.1 HD65AA/BA] Unbrick tool to restore your device to OxygenOS
Disclaimer: By attempting any of the processes listed in this thread you accept full responsibility for your actions. I will not be held responsible if your device stops working, catches fire, or turns into a hipster and claims to have been...
forum.xda-developers.com
This will wipe your data. Otherwise, you can try manually fastboot flash each individual files of oos11 rom:
⭐[ROM][STOCK] 11.0.9.1-GLOBAL-OnePlus7TOxygen_14.O.35_GLO_0350_2206171459-FASTBOOT
Created my own FASTBOOT Rom can anybody test this out, to see if it works please? Used to "Restore the Firmware" on your phone or when bricked you cannot downgrade or upgrade with FASTBOOT Roms, you must be on the same (Firmware Update Global...
forum.xda-developers.com
HueyT said:
This will wipe your data. Otherwise, you can try manually fastboot flash each individual files of oos11 rom:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I managed to boot the phone but having root problems. After spending a number of hours doing various trials and checking Xda threads I managed to get it to boot again but root was lost.
I again read more articles and learnt that I have to flash recovery to both partitions so I used Tool All in one, changed active slots and flashed the magisk patched image from this thread i think on both slots. But i am not sure. I managed to get root but the Magisk manager was not getting installed.
I tried few other things and finally i am now not able to root again. Phone is booting after I flash a recovery but I am not sure if it will boot if restarted or go into loop.
Can anyone explain the proper procedure and sequence to follow for rooting and which files to use.
I am on OOS11.09.1
jesrani said:
Thanks. I managed to boot the phone but having root problems. After spending a number of hours doing various trials and checking Xda threads I managed to get it to boot again but root was lost.
I again read more articles and learnt that I have to flash recovery to both partitions so I used Tool All in one, changed active slots and flashed the magisk patched image from this thread i think on both slots. But i am not sure. I managed to get root but the Magisk manager was not getting installed.
I tried few other things and finally i am now not able to root again. Phone is booting after I flash a recovery but I am not sure if it will boot if restarted or go into loop.
Can anyone explain the proper procedure and sequence to follow for rooting and which files to use.
I am on OOS11.09.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
[OP7T][Stock/Magisk v23.0] OxygenOS 11.0.9.1.HD65AA boot.img
OnePlus 7T OxygenOS 11.0.9.1.HD65AA Global boot.img Stock: https://mega.nz/file/CV9B2I5A#kIjb0ST0XvAn1yJTMi56hdz1asi-d_LH0uaOCcfrA2g Magisk v23.0 Patched: https://mega.nz/file/eFcygLwb#U0m48VlQekyhrKAEC3Oc56yfxdbjGmGhiwgndU-Grwc Note: DISABLE...
forum.xda-developers.com
HueyT said:
[OP7T][Stock/Magisk v23.0] OxygenOS 11.0.9.1.HD65AA boot.img
OnePlus 7T OxygenOS 11.0.9.1.HD65AA Global boot.img Stock: https://mega.nz/file/CV9B2I5A#kIjb0ST0XvAn1yJTMi56hdz1asi-d_LH0uaOCcfrA2g Magisk v23.0 Patched: https://mega.nz/file/eFcygLwb#U0m48VlQekyhrKAEC3Oc56yfxdbjGmGhiwgndU-Grwc Note: DISABLE...
forum.xda-developers.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi. I already used these boot images but I was still having a problem. I had flashed the stock image to both partitions and then the Magisk patched image also but either I was not rooted or Magisk App not working. Finally got things to work by installing TWRP to partition a I believe. I changed active partition to a and then flashed the twrp recovery. Again changed active to b and booted and had root. I had to install Magisk Canary 25210 version only as other versions did not install. After checking on net it seems this version is faulty. So I installed Magisk Delta, then installed Magisk using Direct Install option, rebooted, checked regular Magisk Manager and showed the same Magisk version. Removed all modules from old Magisk Manager and unstalled the app. Setup Magisk Delta modules, hide, SuList as well as apps like LSPosed, HMA etc and now everything is working again.
I still am not very sure where the recovery is installed, on partition a or b? And if a difference recovery is installed on each partition what happens? I am pretty sure I had not installed TWRP on partition b. I am also assuming that once I set a partition as active and flash a recovery in fastboot that recovery is flashed to that partition, is this correct? Things are working but I don't know if the phone will go to recovery mode from system, I have not tried that. So I am not very clear yet but still got things to work.
jesrani said:
Hi. I already used these boot images but I was still having a problem. I had flashed the stock image to both partitions and then the Magisk patched image also but either I was not rooted or Magisk App not working. Finally got things to work by installing TWRP to partition a I believe. I changed active partition to a and then flashed the twrp recovery. Again changed active to b and booted and had root. I had to install Magisk Canary 25210 version only as other versions did not install. After checking on net it seems this version is faulty. So I installed Magisk Delta, then installed Magisk using Direct Install option, rebooted, checked regular Magisk Manager and showed the same Magisk version. Removed all modules from old Magisk Manager and unstalled the app. Setup Magisk Delta modules, hide, SuList as well as apps like LSPosed, HMA etc and now everything is working again.
I still am not very sure where the recovery is installed, on partition a or b? And if a difference recovery is installed on each partition what happens? I am pretty sure I had not installed TWRP on partition b. I am also assuming that once I set a partition as active and flash a recovery in fastboot that recovery is flashed to that partition, is this correct? Things are working but I don't know if the phone will go to recovery mode from system, I have not tried that. So I am not very clear yet but still got things to work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only data partition is shared. All else have both A and B parts

Categories

Resources