Related
Hello All
Just came across this forum and a thread on the pink screen issue.
Do you reckon this one has the same issue?
All of the phones are the exact same and have the exact same "issue". I use my phone on maximum brightness all the time so I never notice it. It's only noticeable if you use the phone on the lowest brightness setting (Why anyone would buy an AMOLED phone just to use it on the lowest brightness is beyond me)
abc27 said:
All of the phones are the exact same and have the exact same "issue". I use my phone on maximum brightness all the time so I never notice it. It's only noticeable if you use the phone on the lowest brightness setting (Why anyone would buy an AMOLED phone just to use it on the lowest brightness is beyond me)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is that true? Does everyone have a pinkish screen if u run it in the lowest brightness? (Havent gotten my Desire yet.)
borgen92 said:
Is that true? Does everyone have a pinkish screen if u run it in the lowest brightness? (Havent gotten my Desire yet.)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes i'm fairly sure they do. But at anything over the lowest brightness it doesn't occur. Again, why you would buy an AMOLED to use it on lowest brightness is beyond me
abc27 said:
All of the phones are the exact same and have the exact same "issue". I use my phone on maximum brightness all the time so I never notice it. It's only noticeable if you use the phone on the lowest brightness setting (Why anyone would buy an AMOLED phone just to use it on the lowest brightness is beyond me)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check the appropriate thread: there is a huge difference between handsets. Most are like this, some are totally unaffected and some are basically defective.
Yes poor answers, I do not have any pink even on the lowest brightness settings. This means your device is defective and you should get it replaced as many others have done. And yes there is a thread dedicated to this issues:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=656128
OnlinePredator said:
Yes poor answers, I do not have any pink even on the lowest brightness settings. This means your device is defective and you should get it replaced as many others have done. And yes there is a thread dedicated to this issues:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=656128
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry is that a yes to me?
Can you post an image of your phone?
look in the sticky post enough examples there...
Sent from my HTC Desire using the XDA mobile application powered by Tapatalk
Im a total OCD for these kind of things. pink issue, dust under screen, dead pixels etc... I don't have the pink issue. It was one of the biggest concerns for me when I ordered the phone. I had seen sample photos from the nexus one that had pink etc. I think there are two issues. A screen issue, and a camera issue? anyway, I don't have pink in my screen at low setting (which I use ALL the time indoors to consevre battery) or any other setting. I also don't have pink in any pictures or videos I made with the phone.
mcgon1979 said:
Im a total OCD for these kind of things. pink issue, dust under screen, dead pixels etc... I don't have the pink issue. It was one of the biggest concerns for me when I ordered the phone. I had seen sample photos from the nexus one that had pink etc. I think there are two issues. A screen issue, and a camera issue? anyway, I don't have pink in my screen at low setting (which I use ALL the time indoors to consevre battery) or any other setting. I also don't have pink in any pictures or videos I made with the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you think of the examples i posted?
I only notice the off-pink tint in GMail. Nothing major tbh.
I cannot see any pink on your photos at all, but I went to my brightness settings and copied what you did in the screen shots and YES my gray looks like it has a red/pink/rose tint at the VERY lowest setting. At 5% brightness it's fine, gray. at 0% setting it has the rose tint. This is NORMAL and a limitation of the display technology (pentile matrix). If this is what you mean, your screen is normal. It's only certain shades of gray that will be affected by this and normally only at minimal brightness settings. I thought you meant you had a pink blob on the screen centre etc? If you just mean the gray menu and ntificaiton bar etc appearing slightly rose coloured at lowest setting, this is normal. I presume the grays are fine when the you move the brightness bar up from 0% to 5% or 10% setting?
mcgon1979 said:
I cannot see any pink on your photos at all, but I went to my brightness settings and copied what you did in the screen shots and YES my gray looks like it has a red/pink/rose tint at the VERY lowest setting. At 5% brightness it's fine, gray. at 0% setting it has the rose tint. This is NORMAL and a limitation of the display technology (pentile matrix). If this is what you mean, your screen is normal. It's only certain shades of gray that will be affected by this and normally only at minimal brightness settings. I thought you meant you had a pink blob on the screen centre etc? If you just mean the gray menu and ntificaiton bar etc appearing slightly rose coloured at lowest setting, this is normal. I presume the grays are fine when the you move the brightness bar up from 0% to 5% or 10% setting?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah its fine when its not on the lowest setting.
Thanks for taking the time to reply
Some people are saying that my purple screen issues documented here:
Matt08642 said:
So I am on my second Galaxy Nexus, and I'm on my way to a third tomorrow.
My first one was absolutely awful, with blacks looking bright purple (Phone 1: http://i.imgur.com/2bjUZ.jpg ) and now OTHER elements looking purple (Phone 2: http://i.imgur.com/1EI0V.jpg ). That's not all. My first one was somewhat free of screen banding, but this one is riddled with it in every menu: http://i.imgur.com/j2oxB.jpg
How common are these issues? I'm getting kinda fed up here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are nothing more than standard AMOLED behaviour. They are saying that terrible colors like I am experiencing are normal if the phone is dim.
Is this true? Does anyone have ANY color issues at ANY brightness?
Well... I don't have ANY issues at ANY brightness fyi.
anton2009 said:
Well... I don't have ANY issues at ANY brightness fyi.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to know there are some phones out there that look great all the time
I'm not leaving the store tomorrow until I am certain the screen is perfect!
When you look at the phone in the store tomorrow, and you go to settings, don't get scared away by what appears to be "banding" in the background image. It' just a poor quality image google has chosen to use as the background. See?
anton2009 said:
When you look at the phone in the store tomorrow, and you go to settings, don't get scared away by what appears to be "banding" in the background image. It' just a poor quality image google has chosen to use as the background. See?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow, why the hell would they use that AWFUL image?
Tomorrow I'll mostly just be looking for purple colors on low brightness.
EDIT: Here's a new picture showing that the screen is still purple http://i.imgur.com/uaRwP.jpg
Wauw that looks bad. I'm currently struggling with a grainy (gray) screen, but looking at other nexuses that seems normal. On light i can however see darker spots and lines on black screens (including boots and black images) but seeing other topics crawled with the same issue I don't put much trust in a device without it...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
amonfog said:
Wauw that looks bad. I'm currently struggling with a grainy (gray) screen, but looking at other nexuses that seems normal. On light i can however see darker spots and lines on black screens (including boots and black images) but seeing other topics crawled with the same issue I don't put much trust in a device without it...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oddly enough, neither of my Nexus' have had the grainy screen problem, just this discoloration
I received my 2nd Nexus today after the firsts' volume buttons stopped working. The new one has purple where black used to be, like yours, but doesn't make the experience any worse. However, when I pull the notifications area down on low brightness, the screen dims further - does this happen on yours? It's quite annoying...
Mine is okay. Not perfect but okay. There is still a little bit of purple (not that extreme like uours) but after a few days you barely notice it
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
3ddyz said:
I received my 2nd Nexus today after the firsts' volume buttons stopped working. The new one has purple where black used to be, like yours, but doesn't make the experience any worse. However, when I pull the notifications area down on low brightness, the screen dims further - does this happen on yours? It's quite annoying...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
on low brightness the notification tray is almost an opaque black
Same here but top bar gets even darker when notifications area is pulled down, even when brightness is set to 0. Whites are a LOT better tho.
Edit: just noticed that when taking photos, the brightness of whats being photographed affects the screens brightness. Also, top half of pages on tapatalk are a lot brighter than the bottom halves, it's strange and quite annoying once you notice it...
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
I am a bit disappointed in the HTC 10. My 3.5 year old Nexus 4's display is much brighter. At about 15%, the Nexus 4 is brighter than the HTC 10 at 50%. At 100%, the HTC 10 is only as bright as the Nexus 4 is at 50%. I get that it's not an OLED, but damn it, a 2016 LCD in a top-price-bracket phone is worse than a 2012 phone's mid-tier LCD?
Another issue now, I set the navigation buttons on the bottom to be always on and they change their brightness all the time. Sometimes they are visible (minimally), other times the glow so faintly as to be only barely perceptible even in a dark room. I hate to think how bad they are in sunlight.
Doggonit said:
Another issue now, I set the navigation buttons on the bottom to be always on and they change their brightness all the time. Sometimes they are visible (minimally), other times the glow so faintly as to be only barely perceptible even in a dark room. I hate to think how bad they are in sunlight.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the nav buttons are based on the screen brightness, so if the screen brightness is at 50% so will be the nav buttons.
i think its pretty bright, rebooting the phone and get that white aboot screen i have to look away. coming out of the camera app, since it goes to 100% brightness in there is pretty bright also (I'm use auto brightness, so only time its at max). i have no problems outside on a sunny day.
afuller42 said:
the nav buttons are based on the screen brightness, so if the screen brightness is at 50% so will be the nav buttons.
i think its pretty bright, rebooting the phone and get that white aboot screen i have to look away. coming out of the camera app, since it goes to 100% brightness in there is pretty bright also (I'm use auto brightness, so only time its at max). i have no problems outside on a sunny day.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Coming from the Nexus 4, I don't trust or use auto-brightness. That said, I almost always have my Nexus 4 on about 15% and that's plenty bright in all but direct sunlight (when really nothing is bright enough, so who cares), at at 50% brightness the Nexus 4 is still much brighter than the HTC 10 at 100%. It really is incredibly disappointing.
I am a retard. I had POWER SAVER enabled! DUR DUR DUR! Retard! Imbecile! Cretin! Dumb donkey!
Doggonit said:
I am a retard. I had POWER SAVER enabled! DUR DUR DUR! Retard! Imbecile! Cretin! Dumb donkey!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hahaha! That'll definitely throw you off! I'm glad you got it sorted out.
Haha I did that. I've also noticed that the auto brightness kind of acts like adaptive brightness
Sent from my HTC 10 using XDA-Developers mobile app
This is one issue that actually affects my user experience. I'm trying to decide between an RMA and switching to a Pixel 2. If black crush is a universal problem, I'll go with the latter but if it only affects a few devices I'd rather RMA and stick with the P2XL. Chime in, black crush/screen bleed - do you have it?
I have it. Very noticeable. Curious if it is widespread or not, as well.
When is it noticeable??
FYI - the Pixel 2 has it as well.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
funcrusher said:
FYI - the Pixel 2 has it as well.
Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I seem to be finding mixed messages on this. Some report this is not an issue on the Pixel 2 and only the XL. I only have an n of 1 for each device - my P2XL has it, my wife's P2 does not. Ultimately, this is what I am trying to figure out - how widespread is the issue, do I play the lottery or exchange for something new or just keep my original XL, though I'd certainly miss the camera and active edge.
Reuben_skelz92 said:
When is it noticeable??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Low brightness, dark videos and images, basically any near black colors get "crushed" to black. I was watching The Croods on a flight the other day and there is a dark scene near the end of the movie where I couldn't make out what was going on because it was so bad. Any dark area of the screen went completely black and/or black and very pixelated. There are a few test images in a thread on Reddit to see if you have it, I'll see if I can link it.
mlin said:
Low brightness, dark videos and images, basically any near black colors get "crushed" to black. I was watching The Croods on a flight the other day and there is a dark scene near the end of the movie where I couldn't make out what was going on because it was so bad. Any dark area of the screen went completely black and/or black and very pixelated. There are a few test images in a thread on Reddit to see if you have it, I'll see if I can link it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok. I only got phone today it's been on auto brightness during the day so haven't noticed anything yet
mlin said:
Low brightness, dark videos and images, basically any near black colors get "crushed" to black. I was watching The Croods on a flight the other day and there is a dark scene near the end of the movie where I couldn't make out what was going on because it was so bad. Any dark area of the screen went completely black and/or black and very pixelated. There are a few test images in a thread on Reddit to see if you have it, I'll see if I can link it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok I do have it. See if on low brightness. Pretty annoying. I noticed it's slot worse with night mode on
I found blacks at low brightness to be quite extreme as well, I'm fairly certain this is something that could be recalibrated in software but I doubt that Google will do anything about it
Yeti12 said:
I found blacks at low brightness to be quite extreme as well, I'm fairly certain this is something that could be recalibrated in software but I doubt that Google will do anything about it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's probably the screen. I don't find it to bad.. but extreme with night mode on
Reuben_skelz92 said:
It's probably the screen. I don't find it to bad.. but extreme with night mode on
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See I don't think it is necessarily the screen as the display has a really high range of greys, so I think it could be fixed to some extent. The bigger problem I have is the ridiculous amount of black smear at low brightness. I never had anything like that on my Nexus 6P, it is dreadful.
Yeti12 said:
See I don't think it is necessarily the screen as the display has a really high range of greys, so I think it could be fixed to some extent. The bigger problem I have is the ridiculous amount of black smear at low brightness. I never had anything like that on my Nexus 6P, it is dreadful.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah same. I've got a decent unit at normal day usage. Once it gets to lower brightness and night mode is not very nice. The black crush is slot worse with night mode
.but black smear is there with or without.
Wish Google just went with a Samsung panel
Yeah, this is kind of a weird one as it seems to affect both P2s and P2XLs, but not all. Maybe its mostly a software issue but is most pronounced on certain screens for some reason? Idk.
Try this app.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=co.uk.quickdoc.screenbalance&hl=en
mlin said:
Yeah, this is kind of a weird one as it seems to affect both P2s and P2XLs, but not all. Maybe its mostly a software issue but is most pronounced on certain screens for some reason? Idk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is difficult. Also do you trade in for another one? But run the risk of getting worse blue tint or grain or uneven whites... I'm going to give it a week, see if I find it a big deal or not. 90 percent of the time I don't notice because the brightness is higher during the day
mngdew said:
Try this app.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=co.uk.quickdoc.screenbalance&hl=en
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Recommended settings or tops on how to use it? Any reference images or videos to use?
Wow, so I've got a pretty bad unit...
Black Smear: Even on full brightness and slow scrolling. So bad, it even covers Text to the unreadable (It's complete gone and "hidden" under the Black-layer).
Black Crush: Until 40% noticable on Photos. Mostly in Shadows which are normally grey. They turn to a complete Black which looks awful.
Blue tilt: Starting at a very small angle. Pretty extreme and bad, but the other two are more of a dealbreaker for me.
Currently requesting an RMA after resetting my Device. And be sure to be nice to the Support. They did not manufacturer this Device wahtsoever.
Daniel Kng said:
Wow, so I've got a pretty bad unit...
Black Smear: Even on full brightness and slow scrolling. So bad, it even covers Text to the unreadable (It's complete gone and "hidden" under the Black-layer).
Black Crush: Until 40% noticable on Photos. Mostly in Shadows which are normally grey. They turn to a complete Black which looks awful.
Blue tilt: Starting at a very small angle. Pretty extreme and bad, but the other two are more of a dealbreaker for me.
Currently requesting an RMA after resetting my Device. And be sure to be nice to the Support. They did not manufacturer this Device wahtsoever.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry man. That would be horrible having black crush at higher brightness
Ad.Shk2 said:
Recommended settings or tops on how to use it? Any reference images or videos to use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here the original thread about black crush https://www.reddit.com/r/GooglePixe...ck_crush_on_pixel_2_xl_and_possible_solution/
Play with the settings to ur liking.
I don't see anything wrong with blacks or greys during videos or on pictures whether night mode is on or off or brightness is high or low. Can someone post a screenshot or two? I'm curious.
I have noticed this issue since two firmware updates but i usually dont use night mode much that is why did not post anything regarding this.
When the nightmode is on and the brightness level is low lets say around 20% , the pixels are not really off when the bg is black (settings menu/qs). But when the brightness is increased above 40% the pixels go off and ive a true amoled bg.
Does anyone else have this issue?
bobandar said:
I have noticed this issue since two firmware updates but i usually dont use night mode much that is why did not post anything regarding this.
When the nightmode is on and the brightness level is low lets say around 20% , the pixels are not really off when the bg is black (settings menu/qs). But when the brightness is increased above 40% the pixels go off and ive a true amoled bg.
Does anyone else have this issue?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, its the problem off one UI dark mode not A50 problems!
try good lock to make ur bar!
Mahdi2000 said:
yes, its the problem off one UI dark mode not A50 problems!
try good lock to make ur bar!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That can be but it is completely black amoled on my s9+. Maybe software update can fix it in the future. Not a major bug though, just wanted to know if the problem was common.
bobandar said:
I have noticed this issue since two firmware updates but i usually dont use night mode much that is why did not post anything regarding this.
When the nightmode is on and the brightness level is low lets say around 20% , the pixels are not really off when the bg is black (settings menu/qs). But when the brightness is increased above 40% the pixels go off and ive a true amoled bg.
Does anyone else have this issue?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mine is just simply not true black, but I can only see it when I boost the brightness. But to be fair, samsung doesn't really promise a true AMOLED black as they say it's just so it's easier on the eye at night (dark/low light) ambient. But yeah, it'd be better to have a true AMOLED black in night mode.
amrazing33 said:
Mine is just simply not true black, but I can only see it when I boost the brightness. But to be fair, samsung doesn't really promise a true AMOLED black as they say it's just so it's easier on the eye at night (dark/low light) ambient. But yeah, it'd be better to have a true AMOLED black in night mode.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mate, it is true amoled back on flagship devices after s8, i had a true amoled black on my s9+ no matter at what level my brightness was set.
bobandar said:
Mate, it is true amoled back on flagship devices after s8, i had a true amoled black on my s9+ no matter at what level my brightness was set.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well then it sucks. What's the point of having an AMOLED display if the software won't let us have its advantages
amrazing33 said:
Well then it sucks. What's the point of having an AMOLED display if the software won't let us have its advantages
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes , exactly my point
Its named night mode and not dark mode maybe its different
Yep, I agree, however I don't notice any difference depending upon brightness level.
bobandar said:
Mate, it is true amoled back on flagship devices after s8, i had a true amoled black on my s9+ no matter at what level my brightness was set.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah its also amoled black on my a7 2018 and a50 except for the normally white parts in the ui but its okay like most of the ui is still pure black its not like the whole screen is grey
There is s little fix guys. See this video
https://youtu.be/Y398_v3DRkI
Theres no large difference in mah consumption between completely dark mode (pixels off) and dark theme.
To me it seems black parts are true black/turned off. On any level of brightness is the same.
No I think Samsung did it intentionally.. because true black is way more susceptible to burn in.. you can't have UI elements being turned off all the time that would result in very bad burn ins to text and Icones..
Still thay made it dark enough so you won't notice it
And another thing it's the opposite of what you said when the brightest is low it turns off and when it's high it becomes very dark gray technically black but not off.
Also you can't design a decent looking gui if all elements are pure black.
Guys try good lock app via which the notification panel can be adjusted to colors we want
baraa_a_awwad said:
No I think Samsung did it intentionally.. because true black is way more susceptible to burn in.. you can't have UI elements being turned off all the time that would result in very bad burn ins to text and Icones..
Still thay made it dark enough so you won't notice it
And another thing it's the opposite of what you said when the brightest is low it turns off and when it's high it becomes very dark gray technically black but not off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not how burn in works. Burn in occurs at the pixel level. A pixel that's on all the time will burn at the regardless of the colors of the surrounding pixels (black, grey, or whatever)
felixdd said:
That's not how burn in works. Burn in occurs at the pixel level. A pixel that's on all the time will burn at the regardless of the colors of the surrounding pixels (black, grey, or whatever)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Every burn in is different from another.. basically the higher the contrast the worst the burn is
baraa_a_awwad said:
Every burn in is different from another.. basically the higher the contrast the worst the burn is
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think maybe you're confusing contrast with brightness? Again, burn-in occurs at the pixel level, when a pixel cannot return to its initial relaxed state, and is not dependent on whether the pixel beside it is on or off.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screen_burn-in#Plasma,_LCD,_and_OLED_displays for a very brief primer
bobandar said:
I have noticed this issue since two firmware updates but i usually dont use night mode much that is why did not post anything regarding this.
When the nightmode is on and the brightness level is low lets say around 20% , the pixels are not really off when the bg is black (settings menu/qs). But when the brightness is increased above 40% the pixels go off and ive a true amoled bg.
Does anyone else have this issue?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello, on my galaxy a50, there is a similar effect, only at a brightness close to the minimum, a gray gradient appears, part of the screen becomes gray and part black. When you increase the brightness to about 40 percent, the color is aligned. At the same time, the black color remains black on the lock screen at any brightness.