Related
I just want to know the difference
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
There is no difference. If you unlock bootloader you can gain root.
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
SanderTheNinja said:
There is no difference. If you unlock bootloader you can gain root.
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course there is a difference. Rooting lets you have complete admin rights on your phone, eg access to write files to the system partition for example or delete all the files. Or uninstall system apps.
Unlocking lets you flash an entire new rom or a custom recovery.
OP - There is plenty of info elsewhere, don't be lazy, just do some reading
with an unlocked bootloader, then you are able to root your phone and install custom roms and overclock and root stuff.
an unlocked bootloader is something you must do before having full access to your phone
scott_doyland said:
Of course there is a difference. Rooting lets you have complete admin rights on your phone, eg access to write files to the system partition for example or delete all the files. Or uninstall system apps.
Unlocking lets you flash an entire new rom or a custom recovery.
OP - There is plenty of info elsewhere, don't be lazy, just do some reading
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean, you can only get root if you unlock your bootloader.
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
Root
Rooting a device is a method to gain full access to the operating system. With root you can do all the administrative stuff, write to locations normally restricted to the system and customize your device deeper.
Root enhances your privileges and you are able to change almost anything inside of your rom.
The rooting, however, affects ONLY your operating system (Android)
Unlocked Bootloader
In most devices, the Bootloader is the instance that calls the operating system (Android) and manages direct access to the device's partitions. Having an unlocked bootloader enables you to flash custom roms, custom kernels, recoveries and so on.
Bootloader and Rooting Teamplay
Often it is the case, and so, too in our devices, that a locked bootloader also locks write access to several partitions like the system partition. This is the reason why rooting is not able without unlocked bootloader. Rooting needs write access to the system partition (for storing the superuser binary and the superuser app)
Without unlocked bootloader, only a temporary half-root can be achieved.
Thanks alot guys
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
How to unlock bootloader ,but the way that I can lock it again
prdonja said:
How to unlock bootloader ,but the way that I can lock it again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do some research. There are hundreds of posts on this topic.
scott_doyland said:
Of course there is a difference. Rooting lets you have complete admin rights on your phone, eg access to write files to the system partition for example or delete all the files. Or uninstall system apps.
Unlocking lets you flash an entire new rom or a custom recovery.
OP - There is plenty of info elsewhere, don't be lazy, just do some reading
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
19 months after the question was asked, i just happened to be wanting to answer the same question for myself, so I searched and found this thread...
I am happy he asked the question, as it was the first answer I saw in google search... so maybe he could also have done a search 19 months ago, but his question was useful to me, and your response seemed rude and unnecessary. You never know who may benefit from a little generosity.
Mark.
scott_doyland said:
Do some research. There are hundreds of posts on this topic.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know that you're not rude (even though you sounded so). You replied what was correct and appropriate.
But my research for the question in question (pun unintended) on google pointed me straight to this very thread.
So, it would be greater if someone had posted some more good links besides their rude looking remark (again, not rude, but just looking so).
theq86 said:
Root
Rooting a device is a method to gain full access to the operating system. With root you can do all the administrative stuff, write to locations normally restricted to the system and customize your device deeper.
Root enhances your privileges and you are able to change almost anything inside of your rom.
The rooting, however, affects ONLY your operating system (Android)
Unlocked Bootloader
In most devices, the Bootloader is the instance that calls the operating system (Android) and manages direct access to the device's partitions. Having an unlocked bootloader enables you to flash custom roms, custom kernels, recoveries and so on.
Bootloader and Rooting Teamplay
Often it is the case, and so, too in our devices, that a locked bootloader also locks write access to several partitions like the system partition. This is the reason why rooting is not able without unlocked bootloader. Rooting needs write access to the system partition (for storing the superuser binary and the superuser app)
Without unlocked bootloader, only a temporary half-root can be achieved.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this useful info
I agree. It is the autumn of 2014, and I've been reading webpages until my eyes are bleary. This is the 1st thread that actually explains how the two concepts relate rather than descending into buttonology. I think the OP's question hits the nail on the head (well, one of them at least) and he doesn't need to be treated in a demeaning manner.
Wow, 1 year after last post, I thanked he asked this question! Was thinking as same as u, loll
fredphoesh said:
19 months after the question was asked, i just happened to be wanting to answer the same question for myself, so I searched and found this thread...
I am happy he asked the question, as it was the first answer I saw in google search... so maybe he could also have done a search 19 months ago, but his question was useful to me, and your response seemed rude and unnecessary. You never know who may benefit from a little generosity.
Mark.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Root vs bootloader
If i have an unlocked bootloader can i install apps that require root. Will they still work even though im not rooted?
Deogracias said:
If i have an unlocked bootloader can i install apps that require root. Will they still work even though im not rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not an expert, but here's my understanding from months of reading up on this: Unlocking the bootloader lets you install a program known as Recovery, which is another program that lets you install operating systems, e.g., stock Android, CyanogenMod. Whether you have root or not is determined by settings made after the operating system is installed. So unlocking a bootloader is different from root. You can have either one without the other. However, I am also left with the impression that software that helps you unlock the bootloader also give you root (and perhaps vice-versa). This dual functionality is designed into the software, but they are separate things which don't have to both happen.
I just reviewed my answer and realized that it doesn't really address the quoted question very directly. Unfortunately, there is no "delete" function. So hopefully, it helps a bit. As further info, I unlocked bootloader, changed the Recovery, and replaced the native Android OS from Koodo with CyanogenMode. However, I did not root. Hopefully, someone else can chime in with further experience.
I've been wondering about this for years, as well. I don't feel confident doing things to my phone that I don't understand. I'm sure I'll never have a thorough understanding, as I'm not a programmer, but even a rough one would suffice. This is the same reason why I will only attempt certain operations on my car -- if I muck it up, I'm boned.
I rooted my phone (or maybe unlocked the bootloader?) a couple years ago, and never got around to doing anything else with it, because I couldn't figure out how to "do a recovery" (still don't know what that means, exactly). Or maybe I unlocked the bootloader, and never rooted it? I'm still confused. I see LOADS of folks who throw the terms around, whom I suspect, actually have no clue. I have a Verizon S4 MDK 4.2.2, and I just now finished the process -_- Better late than never? Now, I'm trying to decide if it's worth the headache, and possible risk, of installing custom ROMs, etc. Also, I know my phone is "SO old!!' and blah-blah-blah. At least if I screw things up now, I can get a new phone with a new contract, etc.
I really wish Verizon weren't such dirtbags about the locked bootloader thing.
No
SanderTheNinja said:
There is no difference. If you unlock bootloader you can gain root.
Sent from my Wildfire S using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Heee is full difference between rooting and unlocking bootloader
Rooting - Administrative access to the entire file system including the ability to change system files such as installing system-wide ad-blocker by modifying the host file on your device, or uninstalling system apps, such as bloatware that comes pre-installed on your device. Without root, one can only see files in root directory instead of editing them. Some alps and mods only work with root.
Unlocking bootloader- To understand this term, one need to know the meaning of bootloader first. In simple terms, bootloader is like a person which checks many functions at the time of boot. It's on of the most important part and boots the first. Unlocking bootloader means asking that person to give us rights to do some modifications in our device like flashing custom recovery, rom etc.
prdonja said:
How to unlock bootloader ,but the way that I can lock it again
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ADB
Fastboot Mode
PRODUCT NAME - tuna
VARIANT - maguro 16gb
HV VERSION - 9
BOOTLOADER VERSION - PRIMELC03
BASEBAND VERSION - I9230XXLH1
CARRIER INFO - NONE
SERIAL NUMBER - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
SIGNING - production
LOCK STATE - unlocked
When it says unlocked, is it talking about my SIM or my bootloader?
Do Nexus's come bootloader unlocked, I mean; they are dev friendly.
Don't make fun of me, I'm only curious and trying to start learning about android and maybe even develop things considering I do know alot about graphics.
Thanks in advance.
Edit: I forgot it meant bootloader (blonde moment?), but is this regular for nexus devices?
I'm almost certain it's talking about your bootloader but to be certain reboot your device. If you see an unlocked padlock under Google when you turn on your device your bootloader is unlocked.
063_XOBX said:
I'm almost certain it's talking about your bootloader but to be certain reboot your device. If you see an unlocked padlock under Google when you turn on your device your bootloader is unlocked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah it is, I know that; i edited my post after realizing that.
But what I'm asking is; Is it typical for nexus devices to come with unlocked bootloaders or not?
I got my from i wireless and I believe it is a imported device.
It's not. Probably was returned/refurbished.
Haaah.
What are the chances that it's rooted and how can I check?
I traded in my One S and got this phone as a replacement.
Strange that it came in the original boxing with everything.
Thanks man.
If it doesn't have superuser then it isn't rooted.
Thanks.
I'm gonna be a noob and ask one more question.
Is it easy to brick your phone from rooting?
Or SuperSU. Try rootchecker. "Is it easy to brick your phone from rooting?" Not from rooting but perhaps flashing if you tend to jump into things..
brainfart moments can give you a softbrick pretty easily, but with fastboot and (we arent quite fans of this like the fascinate people were) ODIN you would have to realllllly screw up and probably try to completely brick it. make sure you have fastboot set up and working correctly before doing anything questionable. it will save your ass lol
edit: speaking of fastboot, i would probably use it to format and reflash all partitions with the latest stock image before messing around since it sounds like your phone has been screwed with before you got it (you never know what other people did to it). theres a really good guide about resetting to stock in either the general or q/a section here. dont worry about relocking the bootloader, there isnt really a way to unlock it wrong... it either works or doesnt. since you sound pretty tech savvy, please dont use toolkits, learn fastboot. it seems like toolkits are a one click problem, not a one click fix lol.
electro` said:
Thanks.
I'm gonna be a noob and ask one more question.
Is it easy to brick your phone from rooting?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Practically impossible. You'd have to not read anything and then willfully do something to ruin your device. And even then it's almost certainly recoverable so not bricked.
It seems nearly impossible to brick your device. x.x
I installed ParanoidAndroid last nigh but for some reason I tried installing a mod and I lost the status bar and home buttons.
I was so pissed off, I had to unroot my device and reflash the stock rom.
I'm going to try using CyanogenMod 10.1 and see where it gets me. It will probably be better considering you can make alot more customizations to your device ui and such.
Thanks 063_XOBX.
Hello everyone.
I'm new to the Nexus world, I have already flashed my Galaxy S4 and S2, and I did flash my Asus Transformer, but I am completely new to this.
When you say that in order to relock your bootloader you just have to send a command through fastboot, will this leave the bootloader as LOCKED, just as if you hadn't done anything? Or will it leave it to something such as RE-LOCKED?
I mean, is there any way they can know what you have done? If so, is there anything like Triangle Away?
Bootloader is always re-lockable? I mean, can they send an OTA that disables you to relock the bootloader so your warranty is void?
Thank you very much.
vagaerg said:
Hello everyone.
I'm new to the Nexus world, I have already flashed my Galaxy S4 and S2, and I did flash my Asus Transformer, but I am completely new to this.
When you say that in order to relock your bootloader you just have to send a command through fastboot, will this leave the bootloader as LOCKED, just as if you hadn't done anything? Or will it leave it to something such as RE-LOCKED?
I mean, is there any way they can know what you have done? If so, is there anything like Triangle Away?
Bootloader is always re-lockable? I mean, can they send an OTA that disables you to relock the bootloader so your warranty is void?
Thank you very much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It is my understanding there is no counter, like on Samsung devices, regarding unlocking your bootloader or flashing custom ROMS, etc... Nexus devices are meant to be hacked/slashed/rooted so i don't think Google would disable you from re-locking it. Plus someone would find a way around it anyway.
railed said:
It is my understanding there is no counter, like on Samsung devices, regarding unlocking your bootloader or flashing custom ROMS, etc... Nexus devices are meant to be hacked/slashed/rooted so i don't think Google would disable you from re-locking it. Plus someone would find a way around it anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok! Thank you very much
I suppossed Google wouldn't want to disable you from doing that because, as you said, they are made to be modified, but just wanted to make sure, as I'm new to this. What I didn't know was that relocking it left it as stock, so that's great
Thanks
vagaerg said:
Ok! Thank you very much
I suppossed Google wouldn't want to disable you from doing that because, as you said, they are made to be modified, but just wanted to make sure, as I'm new to this. What I didn't know was that relocking it left it as stock, so that's great
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. Quite a few posts on here I've seen people unlock bootloader, flash custom stuff and find screen errors (dead pixels, light bleed or w/e) or GPS issues and they reflashed the stock image and re-locked bootloader and returned to store no problem.
railed said:
No problem. Quite a few posts on here I've seen people unlock bootloader, flash custom stuff and find screen errors (dead pixels, light bleed or w/e) or GPS issues and they reflashed the stock image and re-locked bootloader and returned to store no problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, so there's no reason to worry about that, which was my main worry.
Thank you very much
The question is pretty much straight
Why does HTC S-On the devices when they allow us to unlock bootloader?
HTC says that the main idea of unlocking bootloader is that you can unleash our own phone.
Why can't they just S-OFF the devices when unlocking the bootloader ?
Can anyone fill me in
Thanks
MJ999 said:
The question is pretty much straight
Why does HTC S-On the devices when they allow us to unlock bootloader?
HTC says that the main idea of unlocking bootloader is that you can unleash our own phone.
Why can't they just S-OFF the devices when unlocking the bootloader ?
Can anyone fill me in
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
S-off opens up access to pretty much everything and so allows more control. With that are the risks of totally bricking your device. Staying S-on still gives you some protection from mucking things up and the freedom to flash roms/recoveries/kernels.
I agree though, as people are responsible for their actions and so must know the consequences of modding their devices, they should just give another level of access to remove s-off. The warranty is void once you unlock the bootloader anyway.
More info around s-off/NAND/partitions etc:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2619392
gsmyth said:
S-off opens up access to pretty much everything and so allows more control. With that are the risks of totally bricking your device. Staying S-on still gives you some protection from mucking things up and the freedom to flash roms/recoveries/kernels.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now I simply voided my phone's warranty without any use.
Damn it HTC.
MJ999 said:
Now I simply voided my phone's warranty without any use.
Damn it HTC.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you unlock it? Do you have s-off?
MJ999 said:
Now I simply voided my phone's warranty without any use.
Damn it HTC.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use sunshine to get s-off.
MJ999 said:
The question is pretty much straight
Why does HTC S-On the devices when they allow us to unlock bootloader?
HTC says that the main idea of unlocking bootloader is that you can unleash our own phone.
Why can't they just S-OFF the devices when unlocking the bootloader ?
Can anyone fill me in
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can still unleash some of your phone by just unlocking, which is probably why they gave the option. You can still flash a custom recovery, you can still root, you can still flash custom ROMs.
S-OFF you can flash different firmwares, you can resize partitions, you can convert to other models. Why would the majority want these? And by the looks of some of these threads, why would even some of the majority of "flashers" need it? Root + Custom Recovery + Custom ROM should be enough to satisfy most.
S-ON then just protects the phone from more serious changes that might lead to more serious damage if *you* don't know what *you're* doing.
BerndM14 said:
You can still unleash some of your phone by just unlocking, which is probably why they gave the option. You can still flash a custom recovery, you can still root, you can still flash custom ROMs.
S-OFF you can flash different firmwares, you can resize partitions, you can convert to other models. Why would the majority want these? And by the looks of some of these threads, why would even some of the majority of "flashers" need it? Root + Custom Recovery + Custom ROM should be enough to satisfy most.
S-ON then just protects the phone from more serious changes that might lead to more serious damage if *you* don't know what *you're* doing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This
When you are S-on/BL locked, your carrier (or HTC/Google) is your system administrator. The carriers take this a bit further, and even manage some of your apps. In a lot of ways, you are a guest on the system, even though you "own" it. However, assuming you just want to use it to make phone calls and post to facebook, for most people this is fine. (my wife's phone isn't even rooted)
When you are BL unlocked, you take over some parts of that sysadmin job, and can now replace parts of the operating system and manage your own apps. You can also disable external control of your device by rooting and turning off certain services. However, the truly critical stuff, the stuff that could keep your phone from booting, are outside of your control. You are now no longer a guest, but you aren't exactly an owner either.
When you S-off, you are taking on the job of being the system administrator entirely. You are 100% responsible for what happens to your phone. Your '44, your Magnum rounds, your foot. Be careful.
gsmyth said:
How did you unlock it? Do you have s-off?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I unlocked my bootloader.
No, I don't have S-OFF
KJ said:
Use sunshine to get s-off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
BerndM14 said:
You can still unleash some of your phone by just unlocking, which is probably why they gave the option. You can still flash a custom recovery, you can still root, you can still flash custom ROMs.
S-OFF you can flash different firmwares, you can resize partitions, you can convert to other models. Why would the majority want these? And by the looks of some of these threads, why would even some of the majority of "flashers" need it? Root + Custom Recovery + Custom ROM should be enough to satisfy most.
S-ON then just protects the phone from more serious changes that might lead to more serious damage if *you* don't know what *you're* doing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know about it, but I just want the H/K Mod, I don't think I need to spend 25 bucks for just the mod.
If anything better comes up, I will try sunshine
and during the meantime some devs might also find another way to S-Off hopefully.
But @BerndM14 don't you think HTC should have asked to you choose S-On or S-OFF when unlocking the bootloader or so ?
MJ999 said:
I unlocked my bootloader.
No, I don't have S-OFF
I know about it, but I just want the H/K Mod, I don't think I need to spend 25 bucks for just the mod.
If anything better comes up, I will try sunshine
and during the meantime some devs might also find another way to S-Off hopefully.
But @BerndM14 don't you think HTC should have asked to you choose S-On or S-OFF when unlocking the bootloader or so ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You wont' hear any arguments from me about that, I've made a post about that ages ago in which I stated that manufacturers should give you the option to have your phone rooted, unlocked and in HTC's case S-OFF, if it's a warranty issue then why not just a bit more for warranty purposes, but we still need the choice. Will they ever do something like that? I doubt they'll do anything like that any time soon but it would be nice and I've said so a long time ago already.
Especially as far as development on the devices are concerned. I don't see why they would share the Kernel source to allow developers to develop for the phone while at the same time expecting the developer to just hack away at the device in order to get the necessary permissions to develop for the device!
BerndM14 said:
You wont' hear any arguments from me about that, I've made a post about that ages ago in which I stated that manufacturers should give you the option to have your phone rooted, unlocked and in HTC's case S-OFF, if it's a warranty issue then why not just a bit more for warranty purposes, but we still need the choice. Will they ever do something like that? I doubt they'll do anything like that any time soon but it would be nice and I've said so a long time ago already.
Especially as far as development on the devices are concerned. I don't see why they would share the Kernel source to allow developers to develop for the phone while at the same time expecting the developer to just hack away at the device in order to get the necessary permissions to develop for the device!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank the GPL for that last one. Android is essentially a very custom distro of Linux, and the Linux community has already shown that they will go after violators. It's how the Linksys WRT54G became the WIFI router to own. IOW, they release it because they have to, but they don't have to make it easy, or usable.
We have seen with the Samsung and LG devices that it is possible to lock down a device fully such that it won't boot anything that isn't cryptographically signed. They will do as little as necessary to comply with the license, without giving us the ability to actually use that knowledge. After all, what good is kernel source if you don't have a signing key the CPU will accept?
That is the primary reason I chose the M8. It was one of the few flagship phones that is still able to be fully owned.
In the spirit of preventative maintenance I am seeking to remain untampered on my HTC m8.
I recently discovered how to utilize twrp on my m8 without flashing it [fastboot boot twrp.img]
Now I am asking the question, will rooting the phone with a supersu zip via this "download boot only" temporary nondestructive twrp cause the tampered flag to rise over my device.
Anyone know?
kruc Ire said:
In the spirit of preventative maintenance I am seeking to remain untampered on my HTC m8.
I recently discovered how to utilize twrp on my m8 without flashing it [fastboot boot twrp.img]
Now I am asking the question, will rooting the phone with a supersu zip via this "download boot only" temporary nondestructive twrp cause the tampered flag to rise over my device.
Anyone know?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Answered this question. Here I made a video today. Couldn't wait round for yall to answer.
Here is the answer provided by me for you, of whether or not you can root your phone (and use TWRP) without changing your HTC software status in your bootloader to unofficial and getting the "TAMPERED" label:
https://youtu.be/otec0uREdus
There is no point to this. Aside from TAMPERED and SOFTWARE MODIFIED, you will also never make the bootloader say LOCKED again, unless you s-ff. It will only say UNLOCKED or RELOCKED (with s-on).
That is assuming your intent is to make the phone appear "stock" and not tampered for HTC warranty purpose (although most all our warranties are long expired on this device). I don't seen any other valid reason.
redpoint73 said:
There is no point to this. Aside from TAMPERED and SOFTWARE MODIFIED, you will also never make the bootloader say LOCKED again, unless you s-ff. It will only say UNLOCKED or RELOCKED (with s-on).
That is assuming your intent is to make the phone appear "stock" and not tampered for HTC warranty purpose (although most all our warranties are long expired on this device). I don't seen any other valid reason.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just for fun and learning purpose i suppose
Edit-the following words for OP
I watched the video
You have s-off device and you are worry about the security warning
You need to read a lot about this device
Sent from my HTC M8 using XDA Labs
ahmed.ismael said:
Just for fun and learning purpose i suppose
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OP said for "preventative maintenance". Which to me means he intends to prevent something. But prevent what, is not clear.
redpoint73 said:
OP said for "preventative maintenance". Which to me means he intends to prevent something. But prevent what, is not clear.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry for being inconvenient
did you saw my edit/watch the video ?
He have s-off device and he is trying prevent the security warning/tampered in bootloader screen ( which doesn't make any sense )
Sent from my HTC M8 using XDA Labs
ahmed.ismael said:
Sorry for being inconvenient
did you saw my edit/watch the video ?
He have s-off device and he is trying prevent the security warning/tampered in bootloader screen ( which doesn't make any sense )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't watch the video, but I saw your comment. I agree it doesn't make any sense. Which was basically my conclusion from the start. Even with s-on, there really isn't any point to any of this.
At this point I went in and flashed the twrp which also didnt give a tampon flag. So that is why the video has been taken off.
Haha I meant tampered. Darn auto-correct
redpoint73 said:
I didn't watch the video, but I saw your comment. I agree it doesn't make any sense. Which was basically my conclusion from the start. Even with s-on, there really isn't any point to any of this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
done, 4 of your attacks, in four different threads (this one contains no fewer than three of your superfluous posts I could do without). All been reported in hopes that SANTA CLAUS will give me my CHRIST-MAS wish and BLOCK YOU from seeing me, so I never gotta see you again, lady.