Related
WARNING: Following any of these instructions WILL void your warranty,
and could possibly cause irreparable harm to your device (i.e. bricked)
If you do Not understand these risks, stop here and do Not proceed.
If you do Not know how to use Odin, stop here and do Not proceed.
This guide is ONLY for SGH-T999 variants that are ALREADY RUNNING android 4.3
If you do Not have a SGH-T999 variant, stop here and do Not proceed.
If you are Not currently running android 4.3, stop here and do Not proceed.
I am not responsible for anything that happens to your device. YOU chose to follow this guide.
I have the SGH-T999V (samsung galaxy S3, canada, Videotron)
I flashed the full 4.3 firmware from samsung-updates.com as soon as it became available ... and then I tried to root it the usual ways
However knox prevented the superSu app from running, and it closed immediately, and obviously root was Not available to any app
This method will obtain ROOT and REMOVE the knox garbage
note ... altho it is optional to remove knox, I have Not tested without removing knox and do Not know if root will work using this method (guide) with knox still installed !
I did NOT create this method ... I simply found it, read thru user comments, and used it
FULL CREDIT goes to
@upndwn4par for the method ... the thread is here
@Kaito95 for the Knox Removal script ... the thread is here
@Dees_Troy for the TWRP recovery
@Chainfire for SuperSu
as you can see, this method was for the AT&T, Rogers, Bell, Telus Samsung Galaxy S3 ... I747 variants, I believe
So here is how I achieved a successful root on 4.3 using the above method, with adjustments for our T999 variant
Using Method #2
1. Download required files
a) download Odin 3.07 to your PC
b) download the latest TWRP recovery for your device, in TAR format, to your PC
click on your device here
scroll down on your device page to the section called Download - Odin Flashable Tar
below that, click on the Select the latest .tar file from here link
scroll to the bottom of the files and click on the latest TAR version
note to d2tmo users ... thanks to @Perseus71 it has been noted that 2.6 versions may have issues on your device, and it is recommended that you choose the 2.5.0.0 TAR version
example: Mine looks like this: openrecovery-twrp-2.6.3.0-d2can.tar
note to T999V users ... both d2can and d2tmo work for our device ... I personally use d2can
c) download SuperSu 1.65 zip to your DEVICE
c) download Knox Removal zip to your DEVICE
2. Reboot into Download mode ... VolumeDOWN + Power + Home
Run Odin
make sure that re-partition is NOT checked!
click the PDA button and point to the TWRP recovery TAR file that you downloaded above
connect your device to the computer ... wait briefly
the COMM port in top left box should turn blue
click Start
when it is done, PASSED, and phone has rebooted, disconnect device
3. Reboot into Recovery mode ... VolumeUP + Power + Home
Flash (install) the Knox Remover zip
Flash (install) the SuperSu zip ... it is version 1.65, current is 1.80, so it will prompt us to update later :good:
Reboot System
4. Update SuperSu from the Play Store
5. Open SuperSu
it should prompt that it needs to update the binary
accept and let it update the binary the Normal way
6. Reboot
7. Enjoy rooted 4.3, knox-free :laugh: :good:
thanks again to @Perseus71 for noting that it is possible that the default Enforcing mode of SElinux may cause issues with the ability and/or performance of some root apps despite being granted root permission
if you are experiencing similar issues, he recommends that you check out the SELINUX Status Changer app.
[I have Not personally tested this app]
reserved
in case
You may also wish to mention the SELINUX Status Changer. Here's the Thread.
With it enabled, root won't be stable.
Ahem. First ?
EDIT - TWRP 2.6.x.x has trouble remounting and formatting /Data. You may wish to reccomend version 2.5.0.0
Perseus71 said:
You may also wish to mention the SELINUX Status Changer. Here's the Thread.
With it enabled, root won't be stable.
Ahem. First ?
EDIT - TWRP 2.6.x.x has trouble remounting and formatting /Data. You may wish to reccomend version 2.5.0.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi and thanks for your input
I just looked at that SELINUX Status Changer thread and will keep an eye on it ... but for now I won't add it cuz:
the dev says it is pre-alpha version
Mine is Enforcing and root seems stable and hasn't had any problems, yet ... 4 days so far
SElinux is here to stay, and there's a big difference between proper (Google) implementation and samching implementation ... root blocked by samching, but not by standard android enforcing #BAM
congrats on being first, lol
what kind of things are you referring to when you say that root won't be stable?
what is your device d2 id?
I haven't had any problems with twrp 2.6.3 for d2can
THAT is something I WILL add, for your specific device
any particular reason you're recommending all the way back to 2.5 instead of just earlier 2.6 version?
cLogic said:
what kind of things are you referring to when you say that root won't be stable?
what is your device d2 id?
I haven't had any problems with twrp 2.6.3 for d2can
THAT is something I WILL add, for your specific device
any particular reason you're recommending all the way back to 2.5 instead of just earlier 2.6 version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have D2TMO AKA SGH-T999. Yes this is specific to my variant. I tested all the 2.6.x versions to establish that the /Data Problem exists in all these versions.
As to Root, well, Certain apps such as Nandroid Manager, and other apps have difficulty performing Root operation despite SuperSU granting it. @Aerowinder has a lot of stories. May I suggest you please visit the D2TMO Leaked 4.3 Rom thread in development for more details ?
Perseus71 said:
I have D2TMO AKA SGH-T999. Yes this is specific to my variant. I tested all the 2.6.x versions to establish that the /Data Problem exists in all these versions.
As to Root, well, Certain apps such as Nandroid Manager, and other apps have difficulty performing Root operation despite SuperSU granting it. @Aerowinder has a lot of stories. May I suggest you please visit the D2TMO Leaked 4.3 Rom thread in development for more details ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
fair enough ... thanks again for your input ... OP updated
Did this to the letter and soft bricked as soon as I flashed the mod zip in twrp. Stuck on pulsing samsung logo.
Had to reflash. Tried twice just to be sure.
(T999) (root, 4.3 stock)
trepoman said:
Did this to the letter and soft bricked as soon as I flashed the mod zip in twrp. Stuck on pulsing samsung logo.
Had to reflash. Tried twice just to be sure.
(T999) (root, 4.3 stock)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what do you mean ... bricked as soon as you flashed mod zip? you mean the knox removal script?
not sure how that's even possible
if you see the pulsing logo, then you rebooted
your T999 is rooted?
meaning it was before, or everything was fine after you did it twice?
cLogic said:
what do you mean ... bricked as soon as you flashed mod zip? you mean the knox removal script?
not sure how that's even possible
if you see the pulsing logo, then you rebooted
your T999 is rooted?
meaning it was before, or everything was fine after you did it twice?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The native tether mod. Knox remover worked fine.
Phone is rooted, stock 4.3.
Flashed tether mod in twrp recovery, which succeed but phone would not boot past the pulsing Samsung afterwards (10 minutes of pulsing, never booted past that) nor would it boot to recovery. I could get to boot loader luckily. I pulled the battery and tried again, same thing. Flashed stock 4.3 in Odin to get phone alive, tried flashing tether mod again, exact same result and same solution. HTH.
So close to clicking buy now on a nexus 5...
trepoman said:
The native tether mod. Knox remover worked fine.
Phone is rooted, stock 4.3.
Flashed tether mod in twrp recovery, which succeed but phone would not boot past the pulsing Samsung afterwards (10 minutes of pulsing, never booted past that) nor would it boot to recovery. I could get to boot loader luckily. I pulled the battery and tried again, same thing. Flashed stock 4.3 in Odin to get phone alive, tried flashing tether mod again, exact same result and same solution. HTH.
So close to clicking buy now on a nexus 5...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ummm .. not sure what this tether mod is that you are talking about, but it's not part of this guide, lol
this guide simply flashes the knox removal script (to delete knox files) and superSu (to root)
cLogic said:
ummm .. not sure what this tether mod is that you are talking about, but it's not part of this guide, lol
this guide simply flashes the knox removal script (to delete knox files) and superSu (to root)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Confounded facts. Always kicking my ass.
This is what happens when I stay up too late and try to do too many things. Linked from another thread and had too many tabs open.
Delete.
Thanks for the post. Sadly, no dice for me. I was directed to this post after creating my own. I've really held off asking for help, but only conclusion I can come to is I got one of those phones that just flat out won't root. Tried everything I can think of. Samsung Galaxy s3, SGH-T999v, 4.3, Wind (Canada). The Odin steps worked, when I boot into recovery, just get the stock android recover menu (original issue I've been having). Nothing seems to work in the slightest.
So I followed this to the letter and it all went well. Except, while the device seems to be rooted, SuperSU seems to be granting permissions to apps, Root Check Pro reports the device is rooted... I still can't use any apps that require root access. GameCIH doesn't work. ROM Manager doesn't work. Nothing wants to work.
Why is this happening? Because every step seemed to go flawlessly. Also, I have no idea how to put it back to stock if I wanted to try and start over lol.
[EDIT]
Oh yeah. Pertinent information. Samsung Galaxy S3 T999V through Mobilicity (Canada) running 4.3.
Used the 2.5 tar rather than the 2.6.
Also set SElinux to permissive.
ksec said:
Thanks for the post. Sadly, no dice for me. I was directed to this post after creating my own. I've really held off asking for help, but only conclusion I can come to is I got one of those phones that just flat out won't root. Tried everything I can think of. Samsung Galaxy s3, SGH-T999v, 4.3, Wind (Canada). The Odin steps worked, when I boot into recovery, just get the stock android recover menu (original issue I've been having). Nothing seems to work in the slightest.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
are you sure you're running stock 4.3 ? baseband MK5 ?
re-do the Odin steps, except uncheck the auto reboot option .. so that it stops after successfully pushing the recovery tar
unplug the phone from the pc .. it should still be in download mode
pull the battery
then put it back in
boot into recovery immediately
if you see the TWRP recovery, great!, complete the guide and you'll be knox free and rooted
if that worked then there are two files that you seem to still have that are putting stock recovery back on normal boot .. post results here and I'll find them for you
Ergonyx said:
So I followed this to the letter and it all went well. Except, while the device seems to be rooted, SuperSU seems to be granting permissions to apps, Root Check Pro reports the device is rooted... I still can't use any apps that require root access. GameCIH doesn't work. ROM Manager doesn't work. Nothing wants to work.
Why is this happening? Because every step seemed to go flawlessly. Also, I have no idea how to put it back to stock if I wanted to try and start over lol.
[EDIT]
Oh yeah. Pertinent information. Samsung Galaxy S3 T999V through Mobilicity (Canada) running 4.3.
Used the 2.5 tar rather than the 2.6.
Also set SElinux to permissive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
did you go into superSu and update it's binary?
what do you mean, exactly, by apps won't work ?
do they run? you said they are being granted permission.
how were they installed?
we're they restored using Titanium?
the 2.5 TWRP was recommended for tmobile users.. we are T999V, can use d2can 2.6.3.0 or d2tmo 2.6.3.1
cLogic said:
did you go into superSu and update it's binary?
what do you mean, exactly, by apps won't work ?
do they run? you said they are being granted permission.
how were they installed?
we're they restored using Titanium?
the 2.5 TWRP was recommended for tmobile users.. we are T999V, can use d2can 2.6.3.0 or d2tmo 2.6.3.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I updated the the SuperSU binary.
The apps will open but when it attempts to do anything requiring root access it is denied or fails.
SuperSU and Knox were installed through the TWRP recovery boot thing as the guide specified. Other things were either installed from the app store or downloaded APK files. I didn't have Titanium at the time I attempted rooting my phone. Wasn't mentioned in the guide so I never got it. I have the basic version now from the play store now. As I'm sure you can tell, I've never rooted my device before. Always had a friend do it for me.
Should I just restore to a stock install (not sure how to do this) and then try again? Especially now that I know the 2.5 warning was specifically for T-Mobile users? Or can I just put the 2.6X version on my phone and try again? lol
it's working
@ cLogic
Thanks a lot man, thanks to you I successfully root my sgh-t999v (stock android 4.3)
I've managed to use GooManager from the Google Play store to install latest TWRP and to flash the 4.3 mod.
Having issues when trying this. I followed all the steps and received no errors. But when the SuperSu ap tries to open on my phone it crashes, the ap only phone is stable.
I have Tomo G3 4.3 Stock rom
Flashed the TW 2.5.0.0 version
Rebooted into the touch recovery
Ran Knox removal
Ran SuperSu
Booted
Knox is not in my list off apps
SuperSu does show
Cant not open supersu, updating binarys does not work since the app crashes.
(Edit)--> Redid the whole process but did not let the phone reboot during the TW flash and the Zip installs. Seemed to of fixed the issue. (Edit)
Thanks added
I flashed Stock 4.3 via Odin before coming across this guide and now my device seems to be stuck at the boot screen. My question is, if I haven't completely booted, can I reflash using the modified version of 4.3 (root, deodexed, knox removed)? Do I have any other options right now?
Mine Note II is SGH-I317M with baseband version of I317MVLUCMK5 and KNOX.
I have tried CF-Auto-Root and Root SuperSU but weren't able to root my note II.
I have tried using different version of Odin, reinstalled the USB driver and tried using philz touch and cwm6 root to backup and root.
Nothing worked........Can't even start SuperSU.....
KNOX keep giving me security notice "An attempt to access a secure area on your device without authorisation has been blocked."
I also tried an updated Superuser. Still nothing worked....
Any idea anyone?
Thank you very much.
Stewegg said:
Mine Note II is SGH-I317M with baseband version of I317MVLUCMK5 and KNOX.
I have tried CF-Auto-Root and Root SuperSU but weren't able to root my note II.
I have tried using different version of Odin, reinstalled the USB driver and tried using philz touch and cwm6 root to backup and root.
Nothing worked........Can't even start SuperSU.....
KNOX keep giving me security notice "An attempt to access a secure area on your device without authorisation has been blocked."
I also tried an updated Superuser. Still nothing worked....
Any idea anyone?
Thank you very much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need to disable knox first
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=49860203
Stewegg said:
Can't even start SuperSU
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is really weird, when I did this to my SGH-I747/M it was updated to stock 4.3 so it had KNOX and I got the same message as you but to disable it, all I did was open SuperSU and it prompts me to disable KNOX and then it's "fully" rooted and I could install a custom recovery after that.
I know it worked on the S3 because it's currently rooted running a custom ROM. Are you using the right version of Odin? I was trying to use 1.85 I think it was and it wasn't working at first, I tried 3.09 and it worked like a dream.
Did you remember to go into the Security Settings and turn off Reactivation Lock? I know this can play a factor when rooting with KNOX.
Also, KNOX never goes away, even though I'm running an AOSP ROM now on the S3, it still shows the KNOX counter with 0x1, even with it disabled. I can also not get any ROM's lower then 4.3 to work anymore so I can no longer run RootBox 4.2.2 on the S3.
I'm not sure if it's just me, or just my phone, but since that KNOX update was already on it when I got the phone used, it will not let me go to any ROM's lower then 4.3
VeeDaub said:
This is really weird, when I did this to my SGH-I747/M it was updated to stock 4.3 so it had KNOX and I got the same message as you but to disable it, all I did was open SuperSU and it prompts me to disable KNOX and then it's "fully" rooted and I could install a custom recovery after that.
I know it worked on the S3 because it's currently rooted running a custom ROM. Are you using the right version of Odin? I was trying to use 1.85 I think it was and it wasn't working at first, I tried 3.09 and it worked like a dream.
Did you remember to go into the Security Settings and turn off Reactivation Lock? I know this can play a factor when rooting with KNOX.
Also, KNOX never goes away, even though I'm running an AOSP ROM now on the S3, it still shows the KNOX counter with 0x1, even with it disabled. I can also not get any ROM's lower then 4.3 to work anymore so I can no longer run RootBox 4.2.2 on the S3.
I'm not sure if it's just me, or just my phone, but since that KNOX update was already on it when I got the phone used, it will not let me go to any ROM's lower then 4.3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Where is the Reactivation Lock located?
I can not find it in the Security Settings.
mrevankyle said:
You need to disable knox first
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=49860203
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was following the steps in the post you have posted.
When I tried to flash the DrKetan_MultiTool_AdvanceV5, it gives me an error: E:signature verification failed. and stopped the flash.
Any idea?
Stewegg said:
I was following the steps in the post you have posted.
When I tried to flash the DrKetan_MultiTool_AdvanceV5, it gives me an error: E:signature verification failed. and stopped the flash.
Any idea?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey man i have the same phone as you, just found an easy way to root it after struggling. Just updated to Stock 4.3 Bell Firmware using odin, completely fresh phone.
How to root it:
1. Flash philz recovery in odin "philz_touch_6.19.3-t0lteatt.tar.md5" (Download mode= Vol Down + Home + Power)
2. Reboot back into android once
3. Power off phone
4. Boot into recovery (Vol Up + Home + Power)
5. Goto philz settings->Reroot rom (or something to that effect)
6. Recovery will tell you done, and to reboot and install SuperSU from Play Store
7. Reboot download and install SuperSU from Play Store
8. Open SuperSU it will immediately ask if you would like to disable Knox.. say yes
9. Done
Link to philz recovery tar for our phone i317M
http://goo.im/devs/philz_touch/CWM_Advanced_Edition/t0lteatt/philz_touch_6.19.3-t0lteatt.tar.md5
Does this work?
My wife's Rogers note2 is bone stock running I317MVLUCMK5.
She is paranoid about Knox and possibly killing her phone.
She wants me to get it rooted, but I'm struggling to find a clear cut answer.
Also, it would be better if anyone knows how to (if possible) downgrade to 4.1.2 and start from there... As I know how to do that one like the back of my hand.
Sent from my SGH-I317 using Tapatalk
Stewegg said:
Mine Note II is SGH-I317M with baseband version of I317MVLUCMK5 and KNOX.
I have tried CF-Auto-Root and Root SuperSU but weren't able to root my note II.
I have tried using different version of Odin, reinstalled the USB driver and tried using philz touch and cwm6 root to backup and root.
Nothing worked........Can't even start SuperSU.....
KNOX keep giving me security notice "An attempt to access a secure area on your device without authorisation has been blocked."
I also tried an updated Superuser. Still nothing worked....
Any idea anyone?
Thank you very much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Simple. First get the root. Like the su binary and stuff. once you are rooted get suersu. What I mean by first get root is literally get root through a program or something. After this you will have root but you wont have root access. So get supersu now and launch the app. It will ask to update your su binary. Say yes. then the thing will say something about knox then ask you if you want to try to disable knox. Tap yes and knox should be disabled and your su binary should be updated and working.
I'm exactly in the middle of nowhere .. Try to root with CF method. After the first try and reboot. I got the knox alert "unauthorized, bla, bla" the thing is that I can't get the full root or return to stock. Also when I tried to install knox in order to Uninstaller it, I can't. My phone is not allowed to use knox any more... I already tried to download Su and update it in order to disable knox with no success.... Stupid knox and stupid 4.3:crying:
My phone is I317M Rogers, it run stock 4.3. I followed this guide, http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2618261 rooted success.
Eun-Hjzjined said:
Does this work?
My wife's Rogers note2 is bone stock running I317MVLUCMK5.
She is paranoid about Knox and possibly killing her phone.
She wants me to get it rooted, but I'm struggling to find a clear cut answer.
Also, it would be better if anyone knows how to (if possible) downgrade to 4.1.2 and start from there... As I know how to do that one like the back of my hand.
Sent from my SGH-I317 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ifentanez said:
I'm exactly in the middle of nowhere .. Try to root with CF method. After the first try and reboot. I got the knox alert "unauthorized, bla, bla" the thing is that I can't get the full root or return to stock. Also when I tried to install knox in order to Uninstaller it, I can't. My phone is not allowed to use knox any more... I already tried to download Su and update it in order to disable knox with no success.... Stupid knox and stupid 4.3:crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
koodiifin said:
hey man i have the same phone as you, just found an easy way to root it after struggling. Just updated to Stock 4.3 Bell Firmware using odin, completely fresh phone.
How to root it:
1. Flash philz recovery in odin "philz_touch_6.19.3-t0lteatt.tar.md5" (Download mode= Vol Down + Home + Power)
2. Reboot back into android once
3. Power off phone
4. Boot into recovery (Vol Up + Home + Power)
5. Goto philz settings->Reroot rom (or something to that effect)
6. Recovery will tell you done, and to reboot and install SuperSU from Play Store
7. Reboot download and install SuperSU from Play Store
8. Open SuperSU it will immediately ask if you would like to disable Knox.. say yes
9. Done
......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
koodiifin's way worked perfectly!
Thank you koodiifin!
I'm sorry i had the wrong links and because of this i had miss information. So i formally apologize by updating with the proper links.
this first method doesn't work with the Sph-L710T or the Sph-L710 on NJ2/NJ3
First method: You can root the stock 4.4.2 ND8/NDC:laugh:
1st. Make sure your on 4.4.2 ND8 or NDC
2nd. Download Towel Root
3rd. Place Towel Root in sdcard or internal storage
4th. With any file manager find and install Towel Root
5th. Open Towel Root and well root
6th. Go to play store and download https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=eu.chainfire.supersu&hl=en and also https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=stericson.busybox&hl=en let super user update the binary
7th. Flash any recovery you want {personally i went with PhilZ Touch (this was before PhilZ had a root Option)}
8th. Enjoy your rooted stock 4.4.2 ND8/NDC
Down below is one more way too root Stock ND8/NDC/NJ2/NJ3 or NF4/OA3 (L710T) and basically any other update
(link to the almighty ODIN)
Second Method: mostly recommended
1st. Odin flash TWRP
2nd. In Odin choose PDA, PA or AP then select the TWRP Tar you just downloaded
3rd. Make sure Auto reboot is unchecked (also at this time your s3 should be in download mode)
4th. Hit start and let Odin let it finish!!
5th. Hold power button to turn off your S3, after it turns off about 10 seconds later it will turn back on to the battery charging screen so before that quickly hold Volume+ and Home, to boot into recovery
6th. now your in TWRP
7th. so to root your stock rom with TWRP flash the following file SuperSU.zip by Chain fire (pro tip. Install any other custom recovery the same way I did for TWRP above if it is in .tar format)
and here is Philz recovery for the D2Lte 6.48.4 ( which you must flash in TWRP)
and here is TWRP that was made specifically for the D2Rephersher/triband/L710T TWRP (which you must flash in a recovery)
Third method Most recent.
Hidyman said:
This is in reference to Samsung Galaxy S3 for Boost Mobile SPH-L710.
Just want to let anyone out there that updated their Boost S3 to L710VPUC0J1 know that you can still root and/or ROM your phone.
Use the instructions to (use Odin to) update the recovery to TWRP first (in the second set of instructions). I had trouble trying to go right to PhilZ Recovery (which I believe is based off of ClockWorkMod). I Had to do the TWRP (twrp-2.8.7.0-d2spr.img.tar) first.
It was the only way to get it to actually accept the recovery, not sure why, maybe because the latest Samsung firmware fixed an exploit or two.
This is an older phone, but it is still a viable one.
I hope this helps someone out there.
It took me a while to figure this quandary out.
As always this WILL flag KNOX, but I'm sure this won't be an issue at this date and time (8/2016).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
work on ND8 rom? sprint phone?
Tekone said:
work on ND8 rom? sprint phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i want to say yes but towel root does come with a warning that it might brick your device.....but i want to say yes since most things that can be done to the ND8 can be done to the NDC and also in reverse order.....so try it and report back it will be good to know if it works on both bootloaders
Sprint S3 Android 4.4.2 ND8-It works!
I just used this method to root my Sprint S3 running Android 4.4.2 and ND8, since my USB port is on the fritz, and it worked successfully. I have root, and was able to do a full apps backup with Titanium Backup, and gained root access in ES File Explorer. Next, download and install a custom backup. Thanks, great job, and could not have been made easier to do!
oops
Rooted the phone in one click. Unfortunately, I lost all data (no 3G or 4G connection). Did I goof? I'm looking in the stickies and can't seem to find an answer. I'd appreciate any help I can get.
henhun said:
Rooted the phone in one click. Unfortunately, I lost all data (no 3G or 4G connection). Did I goof? I'm looking in the stickies and can't seem to find an answer. I'd appreciate any help I can get.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ND8 or NDC? have you tried updating your profile/PRL?
6th_Hokage said:
ND8 or NDC? have you tried updating your profile/PRL?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ya know. People keep talking about ND8 and ND___. I have no idea what that means. I know I should be embarrassed.
UPDATE: FIGURED IT OUT, BASEBAND VERSION. GOTCHA. IT IS NDC.
I was JUST coming back to update my post. I DID update the PRL and restarted my phone. That seems to have done the trick. Thank GOD I got my data connection back!! It worked. Even though I found the info somewhere else, thank you so much for the quick reply. PRL update fixes the problem. You're awesome.
I used it before i had a custom recovery. And on reboot i wouldnt have root. After i ran it root checker told me i was rooted then reboot killed. I installed philz and all was ok
Sent from my SPH-L710 using XDA Free mobile app
jbnorton0524 said:
I used it before i had a custom recovery. And on reboot i wouldnt have root. After i ran it root checker told me i was rooted then reboot killed. I installed philz and all was ok
Sent from my SPH-L710 using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
many users of basically the same phone report different things with every root method out there. If it worked for you that's great tell other users what you did for it to work and if it didn't work, then ask for help and you will get help; some people don't have success with any method while others do with all of the methods.....my phone falls under every method.....
Successful Towelroot on VM Galaxy S3 4.4.2.NDC
6th_Hokage said:
you can root the stock 4.4.2
first step make sure your on 4.4.2
second step download Towel Root
third step place Towel Root in sdcard or internal storage
fourth step with any file manager find and install Towel Root
fifth step root
sixth step go to play store and download Superuser (Chainfire) and also Busy Box (Stericson) let super user update the binary
seventh step flash any recovery you want personally i went with Philliz Touch
eighth step if you want flash a custom rom now if not enjoy your rooted stock 4.4.2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Straight forward, fast and easy. I did notice the following:
1) Updating binary reported it did not successfully install. I've seen this before on other devices, but everything worked well. Ext SD and Camera all OK. Everything works fine so far - Titanium, Nandroid, Root Browser, etc.
2) At one point, I was directed to install Busy Box. Having done this on other devices, I said "Yes" and installed it.
3) I see that my device now shows Device Status as Custom ( was Normal before, if I remember correctly). Is this due to Busy Box?
4) Is Device Status the only way to know the KNOX Status? I see no yellow triangle as I did on my Galaxy Reverb.
5) I got a Google warning to uninstall Towelroot since it is usafe and a security exploit. I understand that.
I would like to verify the KNOX status and if tripped in the Towelroot process, to let potential users know of that possibility.
Thank You! And thanks to everyone who has continued to work on keeping root free!
Dave
dave260 said:
Straight forward, fast and easy. I did notice the following:
1) Updating binary reported it did not successfully install. I've seen this before on other devices, but everything worked well. Ext SD and Camera all OK. Everything works fine so far - Titanium, Nandroid, Root Browser, etc.
2) At one point, I was directed to install Busy Box. Having done this on other devices, I said "Yes" and installed it.
3) I see that my device now shows Device Status as Custom ( was Normal before, if I remember correctly). Is this due to Busy Box?
4) Is Device Status the only way to know the KNOX Status? I see no yellow triangle as I did on my Galaxy Reverb.
5) I got a Google warning to uninstall Towelroot since it is unsafe and a security exploit. I understand that.
I would like to verify the KNOX status and if tripped in the Towelroot process, to let potential users know of that possibility.
Thank You! And thanks to everyone who has continued to work on keeping root free!
Dave
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Knox only notifies Samsung that your device isn't stock anymore not necessarily rooted like with a custom recovery and then flashed mods and what not but if you Odin the stock rom it resets the counters so Samsung will never know....and that i have noticed TowelRoot doesn't trip that counter.....only the recoveries and when you update the binary (<---completely forgot to fix that) you must hit the option normal not TWRP/CWM
churninern said:
I just used this method to root my Sprint S3 running Android 4.4.2 and ND8, since my USB port is on the fritz, and it worked successfully. I have root, and was able to do a full apps backup with Titanium Backup, and gained root access in ES File Explorer. Next, download and install a custom backup. Thanks, great job, and could not have been made easier to do!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's great news because same boat here. It worked on 4.3 as well.
I had the phone hacked before and something must not be fully stock so the Ota fails.
I downloaded a package and mobile odin should flash it properly and then I can root it with this again and install a nice modified TouchWiz rom.
Darkangels6sic6 said:
That's great news because same boat here. It worked on 4.3 as well.
I had the phone hacked before and something must not be fully stock so the Ota fails.
I downloaded a package and mobile odin should flash it properly and then I can root it with this again and install a nice modified TouchWiz rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
just a quick add on Mobile Odin and stock ND8/NDC don't mix at all
Knox Counter and "Device Status"
6th_Hokage said:
Knox only notifies Samsung that your device isn't stock anymore not necessarily rooted like with a custom recovery and then flashed mods and what not but if you Odin the stock rom it resets the counters so Samsung will never know....and that i have noticed TowelRoot doesn't trip that counter.....only the recoveries and when you update the recovery you must hit the option normal not TWRP/CWM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your response. I may be over thinking these indicators. All I did was Towelroot, successfully. On the phone, the "About Device, Status" now says CUSTOM (was "Official"). The Knox counter according to app "Phone Info" shows Knox Counter at 0x0. As you said, since the counter is not tripped, should be no problem on warranty. So then Device Status CUSTOM is not a problem? I'm not really worried about warranty at this point, but I think I'll hold off further mods for another 6 moths.
Thanks again for your help!
6th_Hokage said:
just a quick add on Mobile Odin and stock ND8/NDC don't mix at all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I tried the md8 and mk3 "mk3 is what it's on". Both just restart and get stuck on splash screen :/.
I have to go to download mode and and restart it that way to boot system back up.
Do you have any other suggestion. I'm not sure what part of the system is altered. It seems like a stock recovery and it's stock firmware "now rooted". Maybe the kernel.
I can't use USB at all.
I'm guessing maybe I should install twrp. Then install a stock zip or try out a 4.3 rom that way. I would like to get to md8 one way or another. Most md8 Roms want you to odin or flash an md8 base.
Darkangels6sic6 said:
Thanks. I tried the ND8 and MK3 "MK3 is what it's on". Both just restart and get stuck on splash screen :/.
I have to go to download mode and and restart it that way to boot system back up.
Do you have any other suggestion. I'm not sure what part of the system is altered. It seems like a stock recovery and it's stock firmware "now rooted". Maybe the kernel.
I can't use USB at all
I'm guessing maybe I should install TWRP. Then install a stock zip or try out a 4.3 rom that way. I would like to get to md8 one way or another. Most ND8 Roms want you to Odin or flash an md8 base.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
cause they need the ND8 base to work as intended...my suggestion would be to get the usb port on your phone fixed but i don't know how expensive that will be
6th_Hokage said:
just a quick add on Mobile Odin and stock ND8/NDC don't mix at all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
6th_Hokage said:
cause they need the ND8 base to work as intended...my suggestion would be to get the usb port on your phone fixed but i don't know how expensive that will be
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was afraid you would say that.
Holy crap. May I say, I am quite impressed. I never planned on rooting my S3 (I like it that much!) but this just looked so damn easy to do and it was!
For the curious! I have a Virgin Mobile S3, and I'm on Kitkat 4.4.2, baseband NDC. Verified root with Root Checker Basic. No problems with mobile data.
Many thank yous, 6th_Hokage!
strangelady said:
Holy crap. May I say, I am quite impressed. I never planned on rooting my S3 (I like it that much!) but this just looked so damn easy to do and it was!
For the curious! I have a Virgin Mobile S3, and I'm on Kitkat 4.4.2, baseband NDC. Verified root with Root Checker Basic. No problems with mobile data.
Many thank yous, 6th_Hokage!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
your welcome strangelady and if you want check out the links in my signature area for other cool stuff
added two more t=root methods
Trying to purchase Galaxy S4 Mini (GT-I9195) I received S4 Mini Plus (GT-I9195I) from online retailer. After some consideration I decided to treat this as a challenge and not to return the purchase. Here is what I learned so far about hacking this tiny piece of electronics:
Getting Root
I was not able to get root on the firmware installed on the phone (I9195IXXU1AOB1). The way I fixed that was to download another firmware from SamMobile and flashed it with Kies. The highest version I was able to flash without issues was I9195IXXU1AOD2, and it immediately updated to I9195IXXU1AOG1. For both versions latest KingRoot worked just fine. SuperSu Me fixed all the damage KingRoot did, replacing it with proper SuperSu. This did not trip Knox device status, BTW.
Flashing Custom Recovery
I downloaded official TWRP recovery from teamw.in and decided to go the hard way and install the recovery doing dd fom command line (ConnectBot) - I was hoping this will help me to keep the warranty. Worked just fine, but tripped Knox bit nevertheless. NB: avoid extra hassles and just use Odin to install recovery.
Installing Xposed
Xposed install sent my device into boot loop. Fixing permissions from recovery allowed me to boot, but gapps was having permanent ANRs. Upon investigation it looks like Xposed for KK is not designed to take selinux enforcing mode into account. Specifically it installed app_process with wrong security context making device unbootable. The fix is very simple:
1. Install Xposed Installer and ES File Explorer.
2. Open Xposed Installer, go to Framework menu, select "Recovery (write zip to SD card, flash manually)" Installation mode, press "Install/Update".
3. Open ES File, navigate to /sdcard/Andriod/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/files. There are two files there: Xposed-Installer-Recovery.zip and Xposed-Disabler-Recovery.zip
4. Now comes the fun part: in both archives you need to modify META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary: comment or delete all "chmod", "chown" and "restorecon" commands and replace "cp XXX/app_process[.orig] XXX/app_process" with "cat XXX/app_process[.orig] > XXX/app_process". This will keep both permissions and security context of the file. Unpack, edit, repack.
5. Reboot into recovery, install Xposed-Installer-Recovery.zip, enjoy.
I will send patch to Xposed maintainer later this week. But we have not seen new releases of Xposed fo KK for over a year now, so I am not sure it will get released any time soon.
I will update the post as my adventures continue - my plan is to have CyanogenMod on this device some day. Stay tuned.
Alte.78 said:
I will update the post as my adventures continue - my plan is to have CyanogenMod on this device some day. Stay tuned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want you can PM me or join Freenode IRC and PM droidlambda. I've already started making CyanogenMod for the device, although I haven't come that far yet (even though the TWRP recovery you installed was ported by me). I could give you some advice (of my experiences with this phone and porting) and my basic config (which builds recovery successfully) if you want.
Does it have to go through all that trouble for Xposed? Or only if you want to install it via recovery (not classic / APK)?
Because recovery will trigger Knox (bye warranty).
Anyone installed Xposed the classic way on i9195i?
Alte.78 said:
Getting Root
For both versions latest KingRoot worked just fine. SuperSu Me fixed all the damage KingRoot did, replacing it with proper SuperSu.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If we install TWRP, can't we just flash SuperSU zip from recovery to avoid the KingRoot removal hassle?
Alte.78 said:
Installing Xposed
Xposed install sent my device into boot loop. Fixing permissions from recovery allowed me to boot, but gapps was having permanent ANRs. Upon investigation it looks like Xposed for KK is not designed to take selinux enforcing mode into account. Specifically it installed app_process with wrong security context making device unbootable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was this boot loop after classical (write to /system), or recovery install?
I installed Xposed classical on i9195 (not i) KK (it also has selinux enforcing) without problems. Is there a difference that I'm not aware of?
Thanks.
Alte.78 said:
Trying to purchase Galaxy S4 Mini (GT-I9195) I received S4 Mini Plus (GT-I9195I) from online retailer. After some consideration I decided to treat this as a challenge and not to return the purchase. Here is what I learned so far about hacking this tiny piece of electronics:
Getting Root
I was not able to get root on the firmware installed on the phone (I9195IXXU1AOB1). The way I fixed that was to download another firmware from SamMobile and flashed it with Kies. The highest version I was able to flash without issues was I9195IXXU1AOD2, and it immediately updated to I9195IXXU1AOG1. For both versions latest KingRoot worked just fine. SuperSu Me fixed all the damage KingRoot did, replacing it with proper SuperSu. This did not trip Knox device status, BTW.
Flashing Custom Recovery
I downloaded official TWRP recovery from teamw.in and decided to go the hard way and install the recovery doing dd fom command line (ConnectBot) - I was hoping this will help me to keep the warranty. Worked just fine, but tripped Knox bit nevertheless. NB: avoid extra hassles and just use Odin to install recovery.
Installing Xposed
Xposed install sent my device into boot loop. Fixing permissions from recovery allowed me to boot, but gapps was having permanent ANRs. Upon investigation it looks like Xposed for KK is not designed to take selinux enforcing mode into account. Specifically it installed app_process with wrong security context making device unbootable. The fix is very simple:
1. Install Xposed Installer and ES File Explorer.
2. Open Xposed Installer, go to Framework menu, select "Recovery (write zip to SD card, flash manually)" Installation mode, press "Install/Update".
3. Open ES File, navigate to /sdcard/Andriod/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/files. There are two files there: Xposed-Installer-Recovery.zip and Xposed-Disabler-Recovery.zip
4. Now comes the fun part: in both archives you need to modify META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary: comment or delete all "chmod", "chown" and "restorecon" commands and replace "cp XXX/app_process[.orig] XXX/app_process" with "cat XXX/app_process[.orig] > XXX/app_process". This will keep both permissions and security context of the file. Unpack, edit, repack.
5. Reboot into recovery, install Xposed-Installer-Recovery.zip, enjoy.
I will send patch to Xposed maintainer later this week. But we have not seen new releases of Xposed fo KK for over a year now, so I am not sure it will get released any time soon.
I will update the post as my adventures continue - my plan is to have CyanogenMod on this device some day. Stay tuned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the Xposed trick!
I managed to root according to your instructions (King root the supersu me), then install xposed through flashfire.
No need to flash custom recovery!
So knox is still 0x0!!
Great!
nick_white said:
Does it have to go through all that trouble for Xposed? Or only if you want to install it via recovery (not classic / APK)?
Because recovery will trigger Knox (bye warranty).
Anyone installed Xposed the classic way on i9195i?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you have. Normal install (Write to /system) will send your phone into bootloop and you will have to re-flash your rom. I've tried that.
Karboush said:
Thanks for the Xposed trick!
I managed to root according to your instructions (King root the supersu me), then install xposed through flashfire.
No need to flash custom recovery!
So knox is still 0x0!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats absolutely cool! I want to have custom recovery anyway, but your discovery will surely help a lot of people. :good:
nick_white said:
Was this boot loop after classical (write to /system), or recovery install?
I installed Xposed classical on i9195 (not i) KK (it also has selinux enforcing) without problems. Is there a difference that I'm not aware of?.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For me it failed both ways wiping out security context of app_process. Maybe your better luck has something to do with a different rom or Xposed version you are using?
Getting Root
I was not able to get root on the firmware installed on the phone (I9195IXXU1AOB1). The way I fixed that was to download another firmware from SamMobile and flashed it with Kies. The highest version I was able to flash without issues was I9195IXXU1AOD2, and it immediately updated to I9195IXXU1AOG1. For both versions latest KingRoot worked just fine. SuperSu Me fixed all the damage KingRoot did, replacing it with proper SuperSu. This did not trip Knox device status, BTW.
Could you point me as to where did you find the firmware for the phone. I'm tempted to try rooting it. Is xposed necessary for the root to take full effect or no ? Cause it sounds a bit tricky and risky.
CostasV23 said:
Could you point me as to where did you find the firmware for the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try this link: http://www.sammobile.com/firmwares/database/GT-I9195I/
soo
Alte.78 said:
Trying to purchase Galaxy S4 Mini (GT-I9195) I received S4 Mini Plus (GT-I9195I) from online retailer. After some consideration I decided to treat this as a challenge and not to return the purchase. Here is what I learned so far about hacking this tiny piece of electronics:
Getting Root
I was not able to get root on the firmware installed on the phone (I9195IXXU1AOB1). The way I fixed that was to download another firmware from SamMobile and flashed it with Kies. The highest version I was able to flash without issues was I9195IXXU1AOD2, and it immediately updated to I9195IXXU1AOG1. For both versions latest KingRoot worked just fine. SuperSu Me fixed all the damage KingRoot did, replacing it with proper SuperSu. This did not trip Knox device status, BTW.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So my phone has the AOD1 firmware can i root it like AOD2? Im in greece
Alte.78 said:
For me it failed both ways wiping out security context of app_process. Maybe your better luck has something to do with a different rom or Xposed version you are using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you tell me if these will work for sure I have the aob1 firmware
Ok, so I have mine updated to I9195IXXU1AOG1. How do I get SuperSU on it without changing Knox to 0x1?
Which version of Xposed is everyone using? On the S4 Mini Plus?
xposed?
Is xposed necessary for the rooting process? or can i just skip it to avoid all the fuzz?
Alte.78 said:
Yes you have. Normal install (Write to /system) will send your phone into bootloop and you will have to re-flash your rom. I've tried that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I upgraded my firmware to:
PDA: I9195IXXU1APA1
CSC: I9195IPHN1APA1
which is also (one of) the latest version, and has the Stagefright vulnerabilities fixed.
Then rooted with latest KingRoot (4.80) + Super Sume Pro.
Then installed Xposed 2.6.1 (stable) and installed "classical" (write to /system). It worked, no bootloops. Maybe you tried a different Xposed version?
Hi! anyone have a baseband I9195LUBUCNJ2?
Synomenon said:
Which version of Xposed is everyone using? On the S4 Mini Plus?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im using the app_process 58 and
xposedBridge.jar 54 which i think is the latest stable edition as of 13/07/2016
Xposed installer version 2.61 with auto flash in recovery method no problems 5 months that i have it
Full debloat stock ROM on Samsung S4 mini Plus (GT-i9195i)
For more than a year, after I upgraded my firmware to:
PDA: I9195IXXU1APF1
CSC: I9195IYUX1APG1
which was the latest version from https://www.sammobile.com/firmwares/database/GT-I9195I/
I am using a debloat version of Galaxy S4 mini Plus (serranoveltexx). Inspired by @btnetro I made a script and tested a full debloat stock ROM on Samsung S4 mini Plus (GT-i9195i). All this time my device has worked very well and even now I am very pleased with him. For those who want to keep stock OS like me, I decided to share with you this flashable zip.
First flash via Odin, a custom recovery on your device( installation instructions here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/galaxy-s4-mini/development/recovery-cwm-twrp-philz-t3182207 ), restart your device and copy attached files in the root of your ext. SD card. Reboot your device in recovery mode and flash “Full_debloat_i9195i.zip”. For those who want to keep weather widget flash this file “weather2014_A3.zip” too (first debloat). Wipe /cache and reboot your device.
OK, i've a weird issue.
I tried all the available recoveries (Philz touch 6.59.0, twrp 2.8.4.0 & 2.8.7.1 etc, and all flashed with odin method) but none of them recognize my external SD.
I tried other sd cards as well, known to be good as they're used in other phones, but end up with th same.
Funny part is that inside os (stock KK 4.4.4) i can see all the files in SD card...
Any suggestion?
hey...been here a while...did a quick search, but probably didnt look kard enough...ive always gotten good help here, so thanks in advance. just got a new note 4 through insurance and its on 5.1.1 and i was previously on, well not 5.1.1...so i need to root it. is it hard and could i get a good link? ...and sorry , but thanks again always gottwn good help here
There's actually 3 methods commonly used here with SuperSU superuser. Which applies to you?
1) Stock with Chainfire Auto Root for Note 4 (CFAR) has recently been updated to support Android 5.1 and possibly 6.0 It offers possibility to full un-root and take next OTA update but limits system and recovery to stock using systemless root. It's experimental, patches stock kernel and sort of fragile unless you avoid recovery flashes and mounting system. Custom recovery or mounting system may break the ability to return to OTA for update with full un-root but also, flashing custom recovery may trick you into applying system based SuperSU which would break root by loss of the stock kernel boot and root patch causing boot loop. Even flashing a SuperSU zip package may not help unless also flashing a custom kernel (kernel first). CFAR is not the method to use if wanting custom kernel, flash system mods, unofficial Xposed or custom ROM. You've rooted before so you most likely have your Samsung driver from Samsung mobile support for Note 4 SM-N910P and know to enable USB debugging in Developer mode.
Latest Odin
CFAR-follow OP in thread for instructions if this is best root method.
2) Rooting stock Odex by way of custom recovery and using modified custom kernel with SuperSU for root. It allows for some Odex modifications but not recommended Xposed due to the system .odex extensions making addition of system applications extra work. Have to remove the Wanam unofficial Xposed framework (the one required to use for stock) to install system application mods and reinstall unofficial Xposed. You could still use Odex ROM and Xposed, just use the unofficial Xposed as a finishing touch to your ROM. You could also backup before applying Xposed to restore later if you decide to make a system application change.
TWRP recovery
Beastmode patched kernel
SuperSU 2.52 beta
3) Flashing custom ROMs, usually deodexed which are more friendly with modifications, including Xposed only requires the custom recovery flashed in Odin with latest Odin with auto reboot option unchecked, USB and battery pull 30 seconds after success 0 fail message, and booting into recovery to flash the custom ROM per OP instructions. Watch these stock ROMs for systemless root (SuperSU version greater than 2.52 beta); you may have to swap kernel and SuperSU (together, in that order) if making a change to either.
Knowing what you want to use root for would help but the above may get you started or direct your next question.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk
i just want to get started with root, so i can get titanium back-up installed and get my apps back,... from there just install an ad blocker and from there that would probably be it
tammyjustin said:
i just want to get started with root, so i can get titanium back-up installed and get my apps back,... from there just install an ad blocker and from there that would probably be it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The ad blocker, depending on choice may indicate you should go with method 2 or 3.
Adguard from XDA forum would work with method 1 but only works with the browser in free mode. I know that Adaway webserver wouldn't stay enabled with method 1, systemless root.
You may also consider using FolderMount from Google Play to enable write to sdcard if you keep your titanium backup folders on extSdCard. The app patches /system/bin/sdcard and /system/etc/permissions/platform.xml That app would also suggest method 2 or 3 for root.
Mostly stock your preference? Go with method 2. Only real limitation methods 2 and 3 yield us having to update with Odin or try the return to stock for OTA. In theory, return to stock with method 1 and full un-root may actually fix OTA update if attempt to return to stock and OTA update fails for dm-verity or unauthorized modification. No guarantees though. Rooting means we accept the possibility that we may have to wait for a stock tar to update. Best to wait for confirmation that root is possible and what is required first, anyway.
Edit: the minimum links to root with are end of method 2. The instructions for TWRP flash are actually in method 3. Flash the kernel and SuperSU zip in recovery once TWRP is booted.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk
yea, i mostly just want toot and stock.. so u suggest method 2...thanks...i hope the instructions are clear cut cayse its been a while since ive rooted, dont want toscrrw up
i use the beast mode kernal?
tammyjustin said:
i use the beast mode kernal?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can choose other kernels for root but Beastmode is closer to stock and easy on battery, IMO.
But yes, starting in Android 5.1.1 for our phone, kernel with root exploit became necessary for root. Flash the kernel then SuperSU zips in TWRP recovery together and boot. Rooted stock.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk
so i odin... flash twrp, kernal then SU?
tammyjustin said:
so i odin... flash twrp, kernal then SU?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct. You did mean Odin the TWRP recovery and then in TWRP, flash kernel and SuperSU zips, right?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk
correct
samep said:
There's actually 3 methods commonly used here with SuperSU superuser. Which applies to you?
1) Stock with Chainfire Auto Root for Note 4 (CFAR) has recently been updated to support Android 5.1 and possibly 6.0 It offers possibility to full un-root and take next OTA update but limits system and recovery to stock using systemless root. It's experimental, patches stock kernel and sort of fragile unless you avoid recovery flashes and mounting system. Custom recovery or mounting system may break the ability to return to OTA for update with full un-root but also, flashing custom recovery may trick you into applying system based SuperSU which would break root by loss of the stock kernel boot and root patch causing boot loop. Even flashing a SuperSU zip package may not help unless also flashing a custom kernel (kernel first). CFAR is not the method to use if wanting custom kernel, flash system mods, unofficial Xposed or custom ROM. You've rooted before so you most likely have your Samsung driver from Samsung mobile support for Note 4 SM-N910P and know to enable USB debugging in Developer mode.
Latest Odin
CFAR-follow OP in thread for instructions if this is best root method.
2) Rooting stock Odex by way of custom recovery and using modified custom kernel with SuperSU for root. It allows for some Odex modifications but not recommended Xposed due to the system .odex extensions making addition of system applications extra work. Have to remove the Wanam unofficial Xposed framework (the one required to use for stock) to install system application mods and reinstall unofficial Xposed. You could still use Odex ROM and Xposed, just use the unofficial Xposed as a finishing touch to your ROM. You could also backup before applying Xposed to restore later if you decide to make a system application change.
TWRP recovery
Beastmode patched kernel
SuperSU 2.52 beta
3) Flashing custom ROMs, usually deodexed which are more friendly with modifications, including Xposed only requires the custom recovery flashed in Odin with latest Odin with auto reboot option unchecked, USB and battery pull 30 seconds after success 0 fail message, and booting into recovery to flash the custom ROM per OP instructions. Watch these stock ROMs for systemless root (SuperSU version greater than 2.52 beta); you may have to swap kernel and SuperSU (together, in that order) if making a change to either.
Knowing what you want to use root for would help but the above may get you started or direct your next question.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am in kind of an odd position here. For some reason, I can't root my Note 4. I've tried both methods 1 and 2 you listed, but neither works. I am running 5.1.1, bone stock. I've been running the stock ROM for about a month since I got this phone used, upgrading from my old Note 3. This is really odd, considering I've been rooting/flashing ROMS since my first Android phone (HTC Hero) in 2010, and have had Samsung phones the last 4 years and never run into this issue. Currently, my phone shows that the beastmode kernel has been flashed, but SuperSU is not showing up and Root Checker is telling me I am not in fact rooted.
I really just want to root so I can WiFi tether, I don't mind running the stock Touchwiz ROM. It runs smoothly and I've had zero issues. Is my best bet just to Odin a stock .tar and start over? I'm trying to bypass having to backup a bunch of files. Normally CFAR would do the trick. Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!
HarrisY said:
I am in kind of an odd position here. For some reason, I can't root my Note 4. I've tried both methods 1 and 2 you listed, but neither works. I am running 5.1.1, bone stock. I've been running the stock ROM for about a month since I got this phone used, upgrading from my old Note 3. This is really odd, considering I've been rooting/flashing ROMS since my first Android phone (HTC Hero) in 2010, and have had Samsung phones the last 4 years and never run into this issue. Currently, my phone shows that the beastmode kernel has been flashed, but SuperSU is not showing up and Root Checker is telling me I am not in fact rooted.
I really just want to root so I can WiFi tether, I don't mind running the stock Touchwiz ROM. It runs smoothly and I've had zero issues. Is my best bet just to Odin a stock .tar and start over? I'm trying to bypass having to backup a bunch of files. Normally CFAR would do the trick. Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Basically, attempting method 2 after method 1 breaks root. If you want method 1, you'd have to start over with Odin.
There are a couple of solutions to get method 2 to work if you're not interested in method 3. Method 3 would be the easier fix though.
Are you interested in some fixes for methods 2?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk
samep said:
Basically, attempting method 2 after method 1 breaks root. If you want method 1, you'd have to start over with Odin.
There are a couple of solutions to get method 2 to work if you're not interested in method 3. Method 3 would be the easier fix though.
Are you interested in some fixes for methods 2?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did it the other way around. I tried method 2 before method 1. I am definitely open to some fixes. However, if it requires a full wipe, I'd rather just backup and go with Odin/method 1 since I am already familiar with that method. Either way, I appreciate the help.
HarrisY said:
I did it the other way around. I tried method 2 before method 1. I am definitely open to some fixes. However, if it requires a full wipe, I'd rather just backup and go with Odin/method 1 since I am already familiar with that method. Either way, I appreciate the help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, they're not really that interchangeable as you've discovered. That is why I tried to differentiate the methods to choose a direction and stay the course.
Starting over with method 1 will possibly restore the OTA for update with full un-root. But no guarantee from me. But that's the only way to restore it with that possibility. Using the ##3282# method to get hotspot may break that. I'm not sure but I think flashing the zip in recovery would break that option for two reasons: flashing custom recovery and modifying system. It wouldn't break root, just nullify the reasons to use systemless root when the traditional method is more stable and you have to use Odin to update anyway.
I guess I omitted the hotspot only suggestion should most likely choose method 2? And updated CFAR isn't the traditional system based root we had in KitKat. It's strictly systemless root and experimental as far as Samsung Lollipop is concerned.
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk