Develop Bugs

[GUIDE] Root T999 (variants) on android 4.3 AND remove knox

WARNING: Following any of these instructions WILL void your warranty,
and could possibly cause irreparable harm to your device (i.e. bricked)
If you do Not understand these risks, stop here and do Not proceed.
If you do Not know how to use Odin, stop here and do Not proceed.
This guide is ONLY for SGH-T999 variants that are ALREADY RUNNING android 4.3
If you do Not have a SGH-T999 variant, stop here and do Not proceed.
If you are Not currently running android 4.3, stop here and do Not proceed.
I am not responsible for anything that happens to your device. YOU chose to follow this guide.
I have the SGH-T999V (samsung galaxy S3, canada, Videotron)
I flashed the full 4.3 firmware from samsung-updates.com as soon as it became available ... and then I tried to root it the usual ways
However knox prevented the superSu app from running, and it closed immediately, and obviously root was Not available to any app
This method will obtain ROOT and REMOVE the knox garbage
note ... altho it is optional to remove knox, I have Not tested without removing knox and do Not know if root will work using this method (guide) with knox still installed !
I did NOT create this method ... I simply found it, read thru user comments, and used it
FULL CREDIT goes to
@upndwn4par for the method ... the thread is here
@Kaito95 for the Knox Removal script ... the thread is here
@Dees_Troy for the TWRP recovery
@Chainfire for SuperSu
as you can see, this method was for the AT&T, Rogers, Bell, Telus Samsung Galaxy S3 ... I747 variants, I believe
So here is how I achieved a successful root on 4.3 using the above method, with adjustments for our T999 variant
Using Method #2
1. Download required files
a) download Odin 3.07 to your PC​
b) download the latest TWRP recovery for your device, in TAR format, to your PC
click on your device here
scroll down on your device page to the section called Download - Odin Flashable Tar
below that, click on the Select the latest .tar file from here link
scroll to the bottom of the files and click on the latest TAR version
note to d2tmo users ... thanks to @Perseus71 it has been noted that 2.6 versions may have issues on your device, and it is recommended that you choose the 2.5.0.0 TAR version
example: Mine looks like this: openrecovery-twrp-2.6.3.0-d2can.tar
note to T999V users ... both d2can and d2tmo work for our device ... I personally use d2can​
c) download SuperSu 1.65 zip to your DEVICE​
c) download Knox Removal zip to your DEVICE​
2. Reboot into Download mode ... VolumeDOWN + Power + Home
Run Odin
make sure that re-partition is NOT checked!
click the PDA button and point to the TWRP recovery TAR file that you downloaded above
connect your device to the computer ... wait briefly
the COMM port in top left box should turn blue
click Start
when it is done, PASSED, and phone has rebooted, disconnect device
3. Reboot into Recovery mode ... VolumeUP + Power + Home
Flash (install) the Knox Remover zip
Flash (install) the SuperSu zip ... it is version 1.65, current is 1.80, so it will prompt us to update later :good:
Reboot System
4. Update SuperSu from the Play Store
5. Open SuperSu
it should prompt that it needs to update the binary
accept and let it update the binary the Normal way
6. Reboot
7. Enjoy rooted 4.3, knox-free :laugh: :good:
​
thanks again to @Perseus71 for noting that it is possible that the default Enforcing mode of SElinux may cause issues with the ability and/or performance of some root apps despite being granted root permission
if you are experiencing similar issues, he recommends that you check out the SELINUX Status Changer app.
[I have Not personally tested this app]

reserved
in case

You may also wish to mention the SELINUX Status Changer. Here's the Thread.
With it enabled, root won't be stable.
Ahem. First ?
EDIT - TWRP 2.6.x.x has trouble remounting and formatting /Data. You may wish to reccomend version 2.5.0.0

Perseus71 said:
You may also wish to mention the SELINUX Status Changer. Here's the Thread.
With it enabled, root won't be stable.
Ahem. First ?
EDIT - TWRP 2.6.x.x has trouble remounting and formatting /Data. You may wish to reccomend version 2.5.0.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi and thanks for your input
I just looked at that SELINUX Status Changer thread and will keep an eye on it ... but for now I won't add it cuz:
the dev says it is pre-alpha version
Mine is Enforcing and root seems stable and hasn't had any problems, yet ... 4 days so far
SElinux is here to stay, and there's a big difference between proper (Google) implementation and samching implementation ... root blocked by samching, but not by standard android enforcing #BAM
congrats on being first, lol
what kind of things are you referring to when you say that root won't be stable?
what is your device d2 id?
I haven't had any problems with twrp 2.6.3 for d2can
THAT is something I WILL add, for your specific device
any particular reason you're recommending all the way back to 2.5 instead of just earlier 2.6 version?

cLogic said:
what kind of things are you referring to when you say that root won't be stable?
what is your device d2 id?
I haven't had any problems with twrp 2.6.3 for d2can
THAT is something I WILL add, for your specific device
any particular reason you're recommending all the way back to 2.5 instead of just earlier 2.6 version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have D2TMO AKA SGH-T999. Yes this is specific to my variant. I tested all the 2.6.x versions to establish that the /Data Problem exists in all these versions.
As to Root, well, Certain apps such as Nandroid Manager, and other apps have difficulty performing Root operation despite SuperSU granting it. @Aerowinder has a lot of stories. May I suggest you please visit the D2TMO Leaked 4.3 Rom thread in development for more details ?

Perseus71 said:
I have D2TMO AKA SGH-T999. Yes this is specific to my variant. I tested all the 2.6.x versions to establish that the /Data Problem exists in all these versions.
As to Root, well, Certain apps such as Nandroid Manager, and other apps have difficulty performing Root operation despite SuperSU granting it. @Aerowinder has a lot of stories. May I suggest you please visit the D2TMO Leaked 4.3 Rom thread in development for more details ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
fair enough ... thanks again for your input ... OP updated

Did this to the letter and soft bricked as soon as I flashed the mod zip in twrp. Stuck on pulsing samsung logo.
Had to reflash. Tried twice just to be sure.
(T999) (root, 4.3 stock)

trepoman said:
Did this to the letter and soft bricked as soon as I flashed the mod zip in twrp. Stuck on pulsing samsung logo.
Had to reflash. Tried twice just to be sure.
(T999) (root, 4.3 stock)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what do you mean ... bricked as soon as you flashed mod zip? you mean the knox removal script?
not sure how that's even possible
if you see the pulsing logo, then you rebooted
your T999 is rooted?
meaning it was before, or everything was fine after you did it twice?

cLogic said:
what do you mean ... bricked as soon as you flashed mod zip? you mean the knox removal script?
not sure how that's even possible
if you see the pulsing logo, then you rebooted
your T999 is rooted?
meaning it was before, or everything was fine after you did it twice?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The native tether mod. Knox remover worked fine.
Phone is rooted, stock 4.3.
Flashed tether mod in twrp recovery, which succeed but phone would not boot past the pulsing Samsung afterwards (10 minutes of pulsing, never booted past that) nor would it boot to recovery. I could get to boot loader luckily. I pulled the battery and tried again, same thing. Flashed stock 4.3 in Odin to get phone alive, tried flashing tether mod again, exact same result and same solution. HTH.
So close to clicking buy now on a nexus 5...

trepoman said:
The native tether mod. Knox remover worked fine.
Phone is rooted, stock 4.3.
Flashed tether mod in twrp recovery, which succeed but phone would not boot past the pulsing Samsung afterwards (10 minutes of pulsing, never booted past that) nor would it boot to recovery. I could get to boot loader luckily. I pulled the battery and tried again, same thing. Flashed stock 4.3 in Odin to get phone alive, tried flashing tether mod again, exact same result and same solution. HTH.
So close to clicking buy now on a nexus 5...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ummm .. not sure what this tether mod is that you are talking about, but it's not part of this guide, lol
this guide simply flashes the knox removal script (to delete knox files) and superSu (to root)

cLogic said:
ummm .. not sure what this tether mod is that you are talking about, but it's not part of this guide, lol
this guide simply flashes the knox removal script (to delete knox files) and superSu (to root)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Confounded facts. Always kicking my ass.
This is what happens when I stay up too late and try to do too many things. Linked from another thread and had too many tabs open.
Delete.

Thanks for the post. Sadly, no dice for me. I was directed to this post after creating my own. I've really held off asking for help, but only conclusion I can come to is I got one of those phones that just flat out won't root. Tried everything I can think of. Samsung Galaxy s3, SGH-T999v, 4.3, Wind (Canada). The Odin steps worked, when I boot into recovery, just get the stock android recover menu (original issue I've been having). Nothing seems to work in the slightest.

So I followed this to the letter and it all went well. Except, while the device seems to be rooted, SuperSU seems to be granting permissions to apps, Root Check Pro reports the device is rooted... I still can't use any apps that require root access. GameCIH doesn't work. ROM Manager doesn't work. Nothing wants to work.
Why is this happening? Because every step seemed to go flawlessly. Also, I have no idea how to put it back to stock if I wanted to try and start over lol.
[EDIT]
Oh yeah. Pertinent information. Samsung Galaxy S3 T999V through Mobilicity (Canada) running 4.3.
Used the 2.5 tar rather than the 2.6.
Also set SElinux to permissive.

ksec said:
Thanks for the post. Sadly, no dice for me. I was directed to this post after creating my own. I've really held off asking for help, but only conclusion I can come to is I got one of those phones that just flat out won't root. Tried everything I can think of. Samsung Galaxy s3, SGH-T999v, 4.3, Wind (Canada). The Odin steps worked, when I boot into recovery, just get the stock android recover menu (original issue I've been having). Nothing seems to work in the slightest.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
are you sure you're running stock 4.3 ? baseband MK5 ?
re-do the Odin steps, except uncheck the auto reboot option .. so that it stops after successfully pushing the recovery tar
unplug the phone from the pc .. it should still be in download mode
pull the battery
then put it back in
boot into recovery immediately
if you see the TWRP recovery, great!, complete the guide and you'll be knox free and rooted
if that worked then there are two files that you seem to still have that are putting stock recovery back on normal boot .. post results here and I'll find them for you

Ergonyx said:
So I followed this to the letter and it all went well. Except, while the device seems to be rooted, SuperSU seems to be granting permissions to apps, Root Check Pro reports the device is rooted... I still can't use any apps that require root access. GameCIH doesn't work. ROM Manager doesn't work. Nothing wants to work.
Why is this happening? Because every step seemed to go flawlessly. Also, I have no idea how to put it back to stock if I wanted to try and start over lol.
[EDIT]
Oh yeah. Pertinent information. Samsung Galaxy S3 T999V through Mobilicity (Canada) running 4.3.
Used the 2.5 tar rather than the 2.6.
Also set SElinux to permissive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
did you go into superSu and update it's binary?
what do you mean, exactly, by apps won't work ?
do they run? you said they are being granted permission.
how were they installed?
we're they restored using Titanium?
the 2.5 TWRP was recommended for tmobile users.. we are T999V, can use d2can 2.6.3.0 or d2tmo 2.6.3.1

cLogic said:
did you go into superSu and update it's binary?
what do you mean, exactly, by apps won't work ?
do they run? you said they are being granted permission.
how were they installed?
we're they restored using Titanium?
the 2.5 TWRP was recommended for tmobile users.. we are T999V, can use d2can 2.6.3.0 or d2tmo 2.6.3.1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I updated the the SuperSU binary.
The apps will open but when it attempts to do anything requiring root access it is denied or fails.
SuperSU and Knox were installed through the TWRP recovery boot thing as the guide specified. Other things were either installed from the app store or downloaded APK files. I didn't have Titanium at the time I attempted rooting my phone. Wasn't mentioned in the guide so I never got it. I have the basic version now from the play store now. As I'm sure you can tell, I've never rooted my device before. Always had a friend do it for me.
Should I just restore to a stock install (not sure how to do this) and then try again? Especially now that I know the 2.5 warning was specifically for T-Mobile users? Or can I just put the 2.6X version on my phone and try again? lol

it's working
@ cLogic
Thanks a lot man, thanks to you I successfully root my sgh-t999v (stock android 4.3)

I've managed to use GooManager from the Google Play store to install latest TWRP and to flash the 4.3 mod.

Having issues when trying this. I followed all the steps and received no errors. But when the SuperSu ap tries to open on my phone it crashes, the ap only phone is stable.
I have Tomo G3 4.3 Stock rom
Flashed the TW 2.5.0.0 version
Rebooted into the touch recovery
Ran Knox removal
Ran SuperSu
Booted
Knox is not in my list off apps
SuperSu does show
Cant not open supersu, updating binarys does not work since the app crashes.
(Edit)--> Redid the whole process but did not let the phone reboot during the TW flash and the Zip installs. Seemed to of fixed the issue. (Edit)
Thanks added

I flashed Stock 4.3 via Odin before coming across this guide and now my device seems to be stuck at the boot screen. My question is, if I haven't completely booted, can I reflash using the modified version of 4.3 (root, deodexed, knox removed)? Do I have any other options right now?

[Q] Proper Way to Flash SuperSU.zip/Root N7 - Fresh Tablet 4.4.2??

Long story short, I was a victim of the bricked/unrecoverable OTA update situation that seems to be plaguing everyone lately. ASUS did repair my tablet, so it got back to me last week and it a fresh, untouched 4.4.2 as far as I can tell.
I am trying to get a better handle on the "proper", manual non-toolkit way of doing everything. I am up to the unlocked bootloader and have TWRP 2.8.4.0 flashed for recovery - now to root and updating.
My confusion with with flashing the SuperSU zip - should you just always us the most updated version (and where is the "proper" source everyone uses) or are there certain versions of SuperSU that pair correctly with different OS numbers (4.4.2, 4.4.4, 5.0.2, etc)? Is it always as simple as flashing the SuperSU.zip through TWRP after updating via factory image flash to a different OS version #? (Say from 4.4.2 now and flashing to 4.4.4 or 5.0.2)?
When I exited TWRP the first time after flashing it, it said I did not have superSU installed and did I want to - will that process auto-flash the zip and root the N7 with the correct superSU version (it is the latest TWRP release 2.8.4.0) or do I need to download the proper superSU.zip for TWRP to then find on my internal storage when that prompt comes up?
Thanks,

Norcalz71 said:
Long story short, I was a victim of the bricked/unrecoverable OTA update situation that seems to be plaguing everyone lately. ASUS did repair my tablet, so it got back to me last week and it a fresh, untouched 4.4.2 as far as I can tell.
I am trying to get a better handle on the "proper", manual non-toolkit way of doing everything. I am up to the unlocked bootloader and have TWRP 2.8.4.0 flashed for recovery - now to root and updating.
My confusion with with flashing the SuperSU zip - should you just always us the most updated version (and where is the "proper" source everyone uses) or are there certain versions of SuperSU that pair correctly with different OS numbers (4.4.2, 4.4.4, 5.0.2, etc)? Is it always as simple as flashing the SuperSU.zip through TWRP after updating via factory image flash to a different OS version #? (Say from 4.4.2 now and flashing to 4.4.4 or 5.0.2)?
When I exited TWRP the first time after flashing it, it said I did not have superSU installed and did I want to - will that process auto-flash the zip and root the N7 with the correct superSU version (it is the latest TWRP release 2.8.4.0) or do I need to download the proper superSU.zip for TWRP to then find on my internal storage when that prompt comes up?
Thanks,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You got it, flash recovery and select yes when it asks you if you want to install SU binary. If you plan on sticking with KitKat (that's what I'm doing, I hate Lollipop), then I recommend flashing the 4.4.4 system image via fastboot first, then flash recovery again, and then let TWRP install SU. I actually just did this yesterday. I dusted off my N7 after a year of not using it and it was still on 4.4.2 so yesterday I updated it to 4.4.4 by flashing a system image. Wanted a clean start.
I'm pretty sure it works the same for lollipop now too. Originally you needed to flash a special kernel, but I think now you can root it the same way as Kit Kat, ie. via recovery. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think I am.

_MetalHead_ said:
You got it, flash recovery and select yes when it asks you if you want to install SU binary. If you plan on sticking with KitKat (that's what I'm doing, I hate Lollipop), then I recommend flashing the 4.4.4 system image via fastboot first, then flash recovery again, and then TWRP install SU. I did this yesterday. I dusted off my N7 after a year of not using it and it was still on 4.4.2 so yesterday I updated it to 4.4.4 by flashing a system image. Wanted a clean start.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
10-4, thanks. So the 2.8.4.0 version of TWRP should already have that SU binary ready to roll (could either choose to flash it now and be rooted on 4.4.2, or fastboot flash the factory 4.4.4 and then reflash TWRP and flash the su zip?) No further superSU.zip/binary downloads, essentially?
I also think I will go with 4.4.4 for now, the 5.0.1 bricking my tablet left a bad aftertaste, it was OTA though. Perhaps fastboot factory image would have no issues.

Norcalz71 said:
10-4, thanks. So the 2.8.4.0 version of TWRP should already have that SU binary ready to roll (could either choose to flash it now and be rooted on 4.4.2, or fastboot flash the factory 4.4.4 and then reflash TWRP and flash the su zip?) No further superSU.zip/binary downloads, essentially?
I also think I will go with 4.4.4 for now, the 5.0.1 bricking my tablet left a bad aftertaste, it was OTA though. Perhaps fastboot factory image would have no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It'll install the SU binary but then once you boot into the OS it prompts you to download SuperSU from the play store. Once you download it and open it, it'll prompt you to update the SU binary. Just hit yes and it'll do it for you, and then you reboot and you're done.

_MetalHead_ said:
It'll install the SU binary but then once you boot into the OS it prompts you to download SuperSU from the play store. Once you download it and open it, it'll prompt you to update the SU binary. Just hit yes and it'll do it for you, and then you reboot and you're done.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome, thanks man. From all the various threads about how to root, it makes it seem WAY more involved than that.

Norcalz71 said:
Awesome, thanks man. From all the various threads about how to root, it makes it seem WAY more involved than that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No prob bud. One of the big benefits of Nexus devices is that they are super simple to root. Heck, they are super simple to do pretty much anything on. That's the only reason why I decided to start from scratch yesterday, because it's like nothing to do. The longest part was re-downloading all my apps, but still the whole process took about 30 min start to finish. If you're not downloading a ton of apps, it'll take you 5 minutes.

How to remove Root from Galaxy Tab S?

I bought a second hand Samsung Galaxy Tab S a few months ago and it has been working fine.
However, when I looked at version of Android then seems a bit old (5.0.2) and when I did a check for updates it said that it couldn't update because "The operating system on your device has been modified in an unauthorised way". When I checked then it seems that the device has been rooted.
A quick search suggested I should run SuperSU to remove the root. So, I had to download and install this, but, when I run it says "The SU binary needs to be updated. Continue?" - if I do then I get another message "If you have a custom recovery like TWRP or CWM that can be used to (try to) install the SU binary" and gives me a choice of Normal or TWRP/CWM. I am struggling to know how to proceed.
So, should it be possible to remove the root and still preserve all my data, apps, settings, etc?
If so, is SuperSu the way to go or are there other tools I should look at, such as Kingo Android Root?
Or, am I faced with rebuilding with a stock ROM?
Thanks

There is no update. 5.0.2 is the latest.

ashyx said:
There is no update. 5.0.2 is the latest.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, thanks for info.
However, I would still like to remove Root and would appreciate advice on this, please!

MysteryMan1 said:
OK, thanks for info.
However, I would still like to remove Root and would appreciate advice on this, please!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If your root manager is supersu then it has the option to unroot in it's settings.
Sent from my SM-T800 using XDA Premium HD app

3DSammy said:
If your root manager is supersu then it has the option to unroot in it's settings.
Sent from my SM-T800 using XDA Premium HD app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried to fire up SuperSU, but, run into problems, as described in my initial post, and this is what I need to resolve.
Any ideas?

MysteryMan1 said:
... A quick search suggested I should run SuperSU to remove the root. So, I had to download and install this, but, when I run it says "The SU binary needs to be updated. Continue?" - if I do then I get another message "If you have a custom recovery like TWRP or CWM that can be used to (try to) install the SU binary" and gives me a choice of Normal or TWRP/CWM. I am struggling to know how to proceed.
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm having a bit of trouble understanding the end goal. As stated Android v5.0.2 is the latest non-custom firmware available. As a previous owner has unlocked the bootloader and seems to have flashed a SuperSu version that modification is blocking any OTA update to v5.0.2. It is also clear your trying to avoid loosing user data.
Would it be acceptable to be rooted and use a different method to apply the latest Samsung stock firmware for your region? If the answer is yes install a TWRP recovery for your device model but you'll loose your warranty by tripping KNOX (you may already be in that state). Follow the instructions in the TabS TWRP thread.
Then finish the SuperSU install (where your stuck today). Then install Flashfire. With Flashfire and the downloaded latest Samsung firmware package you can flash the boot and system images to update your install then use ODIN to update the Bootloader image from that download firmware. You could also flash the recovery image but that would overwrite TWRP and in your case I don't see the point. Flashfire needs the whole Samsung firmware file to be available on the device itself unlike when using ODIN to flash the Bootloader image.
As I'm rooted but retained my warranty I use FlashFire and ODIN to update to the latest stock firmware and never loose user data. Unfortunately to root and not trip KNOX I did wipe my user data that first time so it does not seem to be an option for you.
Hope that gives you some ideas. In your current state it maybe as simple as completing the SuperSU install (assuming a custom recovery (TWRP/CM) is already installed) then using Flashfire and ODIN as described.
Good luck

3DSammy said:
I'm having a bit of trouble understanding the end goal. As stated Android v5.0.2 is the latest non-custom firmware available. As a previous owner has unlocked the bootloader and seems to have flashed a SuperSu version that modification is blocking any OTA update to v5.0.2. It is also clear your trying to avoid loosing user data.
Would it be acceptable to be rooted and use a different method to apply the latest Samsung stock firmware for your region? If the answer is yes install a TWRP recovery for your device model but you'll loose your warranty by tripping KNOX (you may already be in that state). Follow the instructions in the TabS TWRP thread.
Then finish the SuperSU install (where your stuck today). Then install Flashfire. With Flashfire and the downloaded latest Samsung firmware package you can flash the boot and system images to update your install then use ODIN to update the Bootloader image from that download firmware. You could also flash the recovery image but that would overwrite TWRP and in your case I don't see the point. Flashfire needs the whole Samsung firmware file to be available on the device itself unlike when using ODIN to flash the Bootloader image.
As I'm rooted but retained my warranty I use FlashFire and ODIN to update to the latest stock firmware and never loose user data. Unfortunately to root and not trip KNOX I did wipe my user data that first time so it does not seem to be an option for you.
Hope that gives you some ideas. In your current state it maybe as simple as completing the SuperSU install (assuming a custom recovery (TWRP/CM) is already installed) then using Flashfire and ODIN as described.
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for your very helpful and comprehensive reply. I can't profess to understanding all of it, but, I am sure I will get there eventually!
I shall follow your suggestion of trying to get get SuperSU installed first.
:good:

If you want to go back to stock just flash the latest firmware with odin.

5.1.1 root

hey...been here a while...did a quick search, but probably didnt look kard enough...ive always gotten good help here, so thanks in advance. just got a new note 4 through insurance and its on 5.1.1 and i was previously on, well not 5.1.1...so i need to root it. is it hard and could i get a good link? ...and sorry , but thanks again always gottwn good help here

There's actually 3 methods commonly used here with SuperSU superuser. Which applies to you?
1) Stock with Chainfire Auto Root for Note 4 (CFAR) has recently been updated to support Android 5.1 and possibly 6.0 It offers possibility to full un-root and take next OTA update but limits system and recovery to stock using systemless root. It's experimental, patches stock kernel and sort of fragile unless you avoid recovery flashes and mounting system. Custom recovery or mounting system may break the ability to return to OTA for update with full un-root but also, flashing custom recovery may trick you into applying system based SuperSU which would break root by loss of the stock kernel boot and root patch causing boot loop. Even flashing a SuperSU zip package may not help unless also flashing a custom kernel (kernel first). CFAR is not the method to use if wanting custom kernel, flash system mods, unofficial Xposed or custom ROM. You've rooted before so you most likely have your Samsung driver from Samsung mobile support for Note 4 SM-N910P and know to enable USB debugging in Developer mode.
Latest Odin
CFAR-follow OP in thread for instructions if this is best root method.
2) Rooting stock Odex by way of custom recovery and using modified custom kernel with SuperSU for root. It allows for some Odex modifications but not recommended Xposed due to the system .odex extensions making addition of system applications extra work. Have to remove the Wanam unofficial Xposed framework (the one required to use for stock) to install system application mods and reinstall unofficial Xposed. You could still use Odex ROM and Xposed, just use the unofficial Xposed as a finishing touch to your ROM. You could also backup before applying Xposed to restore later if you decide to make a system application change.
TWRP recovery
Beastmode patched kernel
SuperSU 2.52 beta
3) Flashing custom ROMs, usually deodexed which are more friendly with modifications, including Xposed only requires the custom recovery flashed in Odin with latest Odin with auto reboot option unchecked, USB and battery pull 30 seconds after success 0 fail message, and booting into recovery to flash the custom ROM per OP instructions. Watch these stock ROMs for systemless root (SuperSU version greater than 2.52 beta); you may have to swap kernel and SuperSU (together, in that order) if making a change to either.
Knowing what you want to use root for would help but the above may get you started or direct your next question.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk

i just want to get started with root, so i can get titanium back-up installed and get my apps back,... from there just install an ad blocker and from there that would probably be it

tammyjustin said:
i just want to get started with root, so i can get titanium back-up installed and get my apps back,... from there just install an ad blocker and from there that would probably be it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The ad blocker, depending on choice may indicate you should go with method 2 or 3.
Adguard from XDA forum would work with method 1 but only works with the browser in free mode. I know that Adaway webserver wouldn't stay enabled with method 1, systemless root.
You may also consider using FolderMount from Google Play to enable write to sdcard if you keep your titanium backup folders on extSdCard. The app patches /system/bin/sdcard and /system/etc/permissions/platform.xml That app would also suggest method 2 or 3 for root.
Mostly stock your preference? Go with method 2. Only real limitation methods 2 and 3 yield us having to update with Odin or try the return to stock for OTA. In theory, return to stock with method 1 and full un-root may actually fix OTA update if attempt to return to stock and OTA update fails for dm-verity or unauthorized modification. No guarantees though. Rooting means we accept the possibility that we may have to wait for a stock tar to update. Best to wait for confirmation that root is possible and what is required first, anyway.
Edit: the minimum links to root with are end of method 2. The instructions for TWRP flash are actually in method 3. Flash the kernel and SuperSU zip in recovery once TWRP is booted.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk

yea, i mostly just want toot and stock.. so u suggest method 2...thanks...i hope the instructions are clear cut cayse its been a while since ive rooted, dont want toscrrw up

i use the beast mode kernal?

tammyjustin said:
i use the beast mode kernal?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can choose other kernels for root but Beastmode is closer to stock and easy on battery, IMO.
But yes, starting in Android 5.1.1 for our phone, kernel with root exploit became necessary for root. Flash the kernel then SuperSU zips in TWRP recovery together and boot. Rooted stock.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk

so i odin... flash twrp, kernal then SU?

tammyjustin said:
so i odin... flash twrp, kernal then SU?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct. You did mean Odin the TWRP recovery and then in TWRP, flash kernel and SuperSU zips, right?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

correct

samep said:
There's actually 3 methods commonly used here with SuperSU superuser. Which applies to you?
1) Stock with Chainfire Auto Root for Note 4 (CFAR) has recently been updated to support Android 5.1 and possibly 6.0 It offers possibility to full un-root and take next OTA update but limits system and recovery to stock using systemless root. It's experimental, patches stock kernel and sort of fragile unless you avoid recovery flashes and mounting system. Custom recovery or mounting system may break the ability to return to OTA for update with full un-root but also, flashing custom recovery may trick you into applying system based SuperSU which would break root by loss of the stock kernel boot and root patch causing boot loop. Even flashing a SuperSU zip package may not help unless also flashing a custom kernel (kernel first). CFAR is not the method to use if wanting custom kernel, flash system mods, unofficial Xposed or custom ROM. You've rooted before so you most likely have your Samsung driver from Samsung mobile support for Note 4 SM-N910P and know to enable USB debugging in Developer mode.
Latest Odin
CFAR-follow OP in thread for instructions if this is best root method.
2) Rooting stock Odex by way of custom recovery and using modified custom kernel with SuperSU for root. It allows for some Odex modifications but not recommended Xposed due to the system .odex extensions making addition of system applications extra work. Have to remove the Wanam unofficial Xposed framework (the one required to use for stock) to install system application mods and reinstall unofficial Xposed. You could still use Odex ROM and Xposed, just use the unofficial Xposed as a finishing touch to your ROM. You could also backup before applying Xposed to restore later if you decide to make a system application change.
TWRP recovery
Beastmode patched kernel
SuperSU 2.52 beta
3) Flashing custom ROMs, usually deodexed which are more friendly with modifications, including Xposed only requires the custom recovery flashed in Odin with latest Odin with auto reboot option unchecked, USB and battery pull 30 seconds after success 0 fail message, and booting into recovery to flash the custom ROM per OP instructions. Watch these stock ROMs for systemless root (SuperSU version greater than 2.52 beta); you may have to swap kernel and SuperSU (together, in that order) if making a change to either.
Knowing what you want to use root for would help but the above may get you started or direct your next question.
Sent from my SM-N920P Note 4 via Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am in kind of an odd position here. For some reason, I can't root my Note 4. I've tried both methods 1 and 2 you listed, but neither works. I am running 5.1.1, bone stock. I've been running the stock ROM for about a month since I got this phone used, upgrading from my old Note 3. This is really odd, considering I've been rooting/flashing ROMS since my first Android phone (HTC Hero) in 2010, and have had Samsung phones the last 4 years and never run into this issue. Currently, my phone shows that the beastmode kernel has been flashed, but SuperSU is not showing up and Root Checker is telling me I am not in fact rooted.
I really just want to root so I can WiFi tether, I don't mind running the stock Touchwiz ROM. It runs smoothly and I've had zero issues. Is my best bet just to Odin a stock .tar and start over? I'm trying to bypass having to backup a bunch of files. Normally CFAR would do the trick. Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!

HarrisY said:
I am in kind of an odd position here. For some reason, I can't root my Note 4. I've tried both methods 1 and 2 you listed, but neither works. I am running 5.1.1, bone stock. I've been running the stock ROM for about a month since I got this phone used, upgrading from my old Note 3. This is really odd, considering I've been rooting/flashing ROMS since my first Android phone (HTC Hero) in 2010, and have had Samsung phones the last 4 years and never run into this issue. Currently, my phone shows that the beastmode kernel has been flashed, but SuperSU is not showing up and Root Checker is telling me I am not in fact rooted.
I really just want to root so I can WiFi tether, I don't mind running the stock Touchwiz ROM. It runs smoothly and I've had zero issues. Is my best bet just to Odin a stock .tar and start over? I'm trying to bypass having to backup a bunch of files. Normally CFAR would do the trick. Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Basically, attempting method 2 after method 1 breaks root. If you want method 1, you'd have to start over with Odin.
There are a couple of solutions to get method 2 to work if you're not interested in method 3. Method 3 would be the easier fix though.
Are you interested in some fixes for methods 2?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

samep said:
Basically, attempting method 2 after method 1 breaks root. If you want method 1, you'd have to start over with Odin.
There are a couple of solutions to get method 2 to work if you're not interested in method 3. Method 3 would be the easier fix though.
Are you interested in some fixes for methods 2?
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did it the other way around. I tried method 2 before method 1. I am definitely open to some fixes. However, if it requires a full wipe, I'd rather just backup and go with Odin/method 1 since I am already familiar with that method. Either way, I appreciate the help.

HarrisY said:
I did it the other way around. I tried method 2 before method 1. I am definitely open to some fixes. However, if it requires a full wipe, I'd rather just backup and go with Odin/method 1 since I am already familiar with that method. Either way, I appreciate the help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, they're not really that interchangeable as you've discovered. That is why I tried to differentiate the methods to choose a direction and stay the course.
Starting over with method 1 will possibly restore the OTA for update with full un-root. But no guarantee from me. But that's the only way to restore it with that possibility. Using the ##3282# method to get hotspot may break that. I'm not sure but I think flashing the zip in recovery would break that option for two reasons: flashing custom recovery and modifying system. It wouldn't break root, just nullify the reasons to use systemless root when the traditional method is more stable and you have to use Odin to update anyway.
I guess I omitted the hotspot only suggestion should most likely choose method 2? And updated CFAR isn't the traditional system based root we had in KitKat. It's strictly systemless root and experimental as far as Samsung Lollipop is concerned.
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

recovery is not seandroid enforcing

I keep having this problem. I just tried both KINGROOT and CF-AUTO ROOT.
After doing this whole process through ODIN. I then try to flash the latest TWRP from their website : dl.twrp.me/jfltetmo/twrp-3.2.0-0-jfltetmo.img.tar.html
Then after that finishes, I try to boot into recovery and it gives me the message: recovery is not seandroid enforcing and just sits there.
I have a tmobile s4.
and I also checked if I am indeed rooted by using an app from the play store to check root and it shows Im rooted.
Any help would be great.

Root isn't needed to flash a twrp.
Tried flashing the latest stock rom and twrp without rooting the phone?

audit13 said:
Root isn't needed to flash a twrp.
Tried flashing the latest stock rom and twrp without rooting the phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup didn't work after trying it all the only thing that did work was SkipSoft Unified Android Toolkit and it was the easiest thing I ever used.

Krappa420 said:
Yup didn't work after trying it all the only thing that did work was SkipSoft Unified Android Toolkit and it was the easiest thing I ever used.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the exact problem, can you kindly explain in details how you went about it? I already downloaded SkipSoft.

Same issues here, buddy.
I tried to work on solving it out for approximately 8 hours and still no sign of success. Tried to reflash stock OS back on the phone via ODIN and it went successful. Tried CF-Auto-root file and it went through successful. But when it only came to the TWRP file, it went successful onto flashing on ODIN's side, but now something is interfering with the boot up process onto TWRP now. Hopefully there's a alternative towards this issue, since i've been wanting to reflash a Nougat OS onto the device.
Edit: I give credit to @Krappa420 for the mention of "SkipSoft Unified Android Toolkit" because i just installed the program on my laptop now and it went successful. But since i already had other materials pre-installed, some others with ODIN and ADB installed can just download this TWRP version here: https://dl.twrp.me/jfltexx/twrp-2.7.0.0-jfltexx.img.html
Edit #2: Seems that the TWRP version is too old to flash some of the newer OS's, such as nougat itself. Will find a way to update TWRP without breaking the boot up process, like the past attempts
Edit #3: After fiddling with TWRP versions 2.7.0.0 and up, i managed to get it capped up to 3.1.1 any future versions will most likely not work, so you're capped at 3.1.1 Here's the link for flashing it with ODIN: https://dl.twrp.me/jfltexx/twrp-3.1.1-0-jfltexx.img.tar.html

So you twrp 3.1.1 and it will work right
I having the same issue
Thank you

so do i need to install cf-auto root first or the twrp 3.11
what are the steps to install
Thank you for helping a disabled veteran

timj3371 said:
so do i need to install cf-auto root first or the twrp 3.11
what are the steps to install
Thank you for helping a disabled veteran
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It wouldn't really matter what order you're using.
You can use CF-Auto-Root to root it for you while you have stock recovery still, and after you can flash to TWRP and use a custom recovery afterwards
Or you can flash TWRP first and flash a SuperSU zip file afterwards and it'll give you root while maintaining to have TWRP installed.
But to sum it up, it wouldn't matter what order you choose. Help yourself

Trwp
What version of twrp I need to use
Thank you

timj3371 said:
What version of twrp I need to use
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TWRP version 3.1.1

Thank you for the help I have lineage installed. Wow so fast. How ever when trying to root it I get a error says binary occupied. If I uninstall I get no root available. How do I install root ? Thank you so much
A disabled veteran

timj3371 said:
Thank you for the help I have lineage installed. Wow so fast. How ever when trying to root it I get a error says binary occupied. If I uninstall I get no root available. How do I install root ? Thank you so much
A disabled veteran
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Before anything, try to install the SuperSU app over on the play store, if it says you're not rooted, you may have to restart the whole process within TWRP and reflash the SuperSU Zip file.

Thank you
Says the binary is occupied in su
Where do I find su zip
Should I use the chain fire auto zip
Thanks

timj3371 said:
Says the binary is occupied in su
Where do I find su zip
Should I use the chain fire auto zip
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try this one: https://download.chainfire.eu/696/supersu/
If it keeps on persisting, I'll have to find another way

I tried that file and it just sits in booting. I left it be then reinstated the ROM. Still no root its OK tight not to have root
Thank you

timj3371 said:
I tried that file and it just sits in booting. I left it be then reinstated the ROM. Still no root its OK tight not to have root
Thank you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah try to re-flash the ROM again but this time flash magisk through TWRP since SuperSU is being trippy on your S4

Thank you for the help
Dummy me I found out from reading other forums you have to go in to tools and enable root after going in to recovery and flash the root file in the extra section.
Every thing works
Thank you so much
Disabled veteran