There's an ongoing discussion on which brand of tempered glass screen protectors are the best value, but I'm curious which ones have been most prone to chips and bubbles. I've had this problem with the Spigen GLAS.t and am looking to replace it. I'm not willing to sink $30+ for something that will just chip within several weeks. I'm very careful with my N5 and I have 6 chips that have magically appeared over the past couple months.
Your votes are appreciated =) If you haven't encountered any issues, details like which screen protector you have and for how long (this is important) would be helpful. Cheer!
EDIT: To help get more definitive information, please try to post details that reveal the following:
BRAND (Spigen, etc.)
MODEL (GLAS.tR, etc.)
PROBLEM(S) (# of chips or bubbles, none, etc.)
HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN USING IT
EDIT2: Here's a list of the tempered glass screen protectors and their thickness, please let me know if I need to correct or add anything:
SPIGEN
GLAS.t Nano - 0.15mm
GLAS.tR Nano - 0.23mm
MIME
Feather - 0.15mm
Ghost - 0.3mm
NILLKIN
H+ Nanometer Anti-Explosion - 0.3mm
GLASS-M
Slim - 0.33mm
Nano Slim - 0.2mm (note: you can select the Slim and Ultra Slim from the drop down)
Ultra Slim - 0.15mm
AMZER
Kristal - 0.4mm
CRUZERLITE
TRUGLASS - 0.25mm
SEIDIO
VITREO - 0.55mm
iLOOME
Premium - 0.26-0.4mm
Flex - 0.12mm
ANKER
Premium - 0.38mm
nilkin anti explosion is 9h, 0.3mm and KICKS ASS
love it
cheap
strong
ships world wide
You could ask for experiences of those who've owned and used the product for a month or two. It's common to see people on within a week singing praises but things don't always go so well with cheap glass over time.
I got the Spigen Glas.Tr and it had a chip in it on day 1. Ended up cracking across the screen.
I emailed their customer service 11 days ago and still haven't gotten a response.
Pretty upset.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
bblzd said:
You could ask for experiences of those who've owned and used the product for a month or two. It's common to see people on within a week singing praises but things don't always go so well with cheap glass over time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah this is my thinking too. The first few weeks I had mine I LOVED it, but ask me today and I wouldn't recommend it. If anyone who hasn't had any problems with their screen protector mention how long they've used it for, that would be helpful =)
eyeisdasteve said:
I got the Spigen Glas.Tr and it had a chip in it on day 1. Ended up cracking across the screen.
I emailed their customer service 11 days ago and still haven't gotten a response.
Pretty upset.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My GLAS.t is cracked across the screen too, twice! Sad to hear the tR has issues as well since Spigen claims the rounded corners help a lot more with chipping.
Using the mime feather with a Ballistic case and the right top and bottom corners started cracking for some reason. I also have a crack from left to right in the center of the screen that doesn't even touch the corner cracks. Not very happy. This is my first slim-design glass protector and first time using MIME, but I never had any problems with my Spigen.
I've had the mime ghost with a spigen neo hybrid for over a month now. No cracks at all. Tiny bubbles only when case is on. The case is very tight fitting, so the corners rise up a little. No problems with the screen protector itself.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
i'm on my second mime ghost glass and it's paired up with the spigen slim. both were chipped and the second one has a scratch on it as well.
Spigen glas.tr here.I haven't had any issues yet... I've been lucky, but I baby the **** out of my phone.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
can the people stating the have cracking issue also say how thick the glass is? maybe if you can edit that question into the main thread, we'll find a trend =?
Well those people who got their screen protector chipped or bubbled...can they share some pics of it....and mention the particular cause that how it was happened...???
As I use this Tempered glass Screen protector for my N5 and believe me its such a nice product that it never make me feel as if I have put something on my screen..the touch is pretty smooth and flawless...n I just love it...and couple of times it has saved the screen from my car keys too.....I just love this product..very pleasant experience....
Thanks
Hey guys, I updated the first post with a list of tempered glass sp's for the N5 along with their thickness and link. Let me know if I'm missing anything!
Mime Ghost
I have been using MIME Ghost for over a month now. It is good. No bubbles/cracks. I have read may posts that say that the mime feather cracks easily after a week or two. Ghost is a bit thicker and a better option in my opinion.
Jimmy2u said:
Well those people who got their screen protector chipped or bubbled...can they share some pics of it....and mention the particular cause that how it was happened...???
As I use this Tempered glass Screen protector for my N5 and believe me its such a nice product that it never make me feel as if I have put something on my screen..the touch is pretty smooth and flawless...n I just love it...and couple of times it has saved the screen from my car keys too.....I just love this product..very pleasant experience....
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have 6 chips around my Spigen GLAS.t and I honestly have NO idea how I got any of them. I treat my phone with care and always leave it in its own pocket so it doesn't get scratched or anything, albeit I don't have a case on it. But a good quality screen protector should be able to withstand day-to-day use without a case, in my opinion.
Interestingly this is the first I've heard of the Amzer Kristal (which I'll add to the list in the first post) and it's the thickest of all its competitors. How long have you been using it, and do you have a case with it?
b.spec said:
I have 6 chips around my Spigen GLAS.t and I honestly have NO idea how I got any of them. I treat my phone with care and always leave it in its own pocket so it doesn't get scratched or anything, albeit I don't have a case on it. But a good quality screen protector should be able to withstand day-to-day use without a case, in my opinion.
Interestingly this is the first I've heard of the Amzer Kristal (which I'll add to the list in the first post) and it's the thickest of all its competitors. How long have you been using it, and do you have a case with it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any piece of glass with sharp corners will chip easier, even with large window panes. If you have the glas.t and are not using a case, it will definitely chip as the edges are most vulnerable and more chips/cracks will propagate from there. I don't know why Spigen doesn't put the message for the glas.t on all of the glas.t products, but this is from the iPhone 5 glas.t page:
*As this is a glass product, please note that the edges of the glass are the most vulnerable areas. We highly recommend that you use a case along with your GLAS.t SLIM to avoid chipping or cracking the edges of your GLAS.t SLIM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Myself, I have had the glas.tr since early December and have no issues with or without a case. I switch between the Neo Hybrid/Ultra Fit and no case about half the time and have had no chips or bubbles.
TL;DR: If you get a glass protector without rounded edges, it will most likely chip unless you have a case to protect the edges of the glass.
tysj said:
Any piece of glass with sharp corners will chip easier, even with large window panes. If you have the glas.t and are not using a case, it will definitely chip as the edges are most vulnerable and more chips/cracks will propagate from there. I don't know why Spigen doesn't put the message for the glas.t on all of the glas.t products, but this is from the iPhone 5 glas.t page:
Myself, I have had the glas.tr since early December and have no issues with or without a case. I switch between the Neo Hybrid/Ultra Fit and no case about half the time and have had no chips or bubbles.
TL;DR: If you get a glass protector without rounded edges, it will most likely chip unless you have a case to protect the edges of the glass.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this. I was going back and forth between the t and tR, but figured I was careful enough with my phone that it should be fine. I assumed the disclaimer was for people who had the tendency of being a little more hard on their phones. I'm really thankful mine was in the first batch that was recalled, so I essential got a trial run at the glas.t. Good to hear the tR is more durable as they advertise. I'm curious to know which of the other brands have curved edges as well, which is definitely a must if I'm not using a case.
Added the Cruzerlite TRUGLASS to the first post as well. Seems like there isn't one brand that is clearly more durable than the rest.
nillken
H+ 9h
used static tape, dirt removing tape, and installed in bathroom with hot shower on to make sure no dust was floating but
produced spiderweb like bubble on bottom of screen which i could not get rid of, took it off after an hour and returned it.
halojinx said:
nillken
H+ 9h
used static tape, dirt removing tape, and installed in bathroom with hot shower on to make sure no dust was floating but
produced spiderweb like bubble on bottom of screen which i could not get rid of, took it off after an hour and returned it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had the same thing but just used a binder clip with some microfiber cloths to protect the phone to apply pressue on that point of the protector for a few hours and untile the bubbles went away and they did and havent com back since and its been a few days.
Nocturnal86 said:
Had the same thing but just used a binder clip with some microfiber cloths to protect the phone to apply pressue on that point of the protector for a few hours and untile the bubbles went away and they did and havent com back since and its been a few days.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will try that next time, thanks.:good:
Related
Has anyone bought this screen protector for the N5? I'm considering it since I want a fingerprint-resistant screen protector, but I don't know whether the cut outs will be faulty as their clear screen protector...
If not any other recommendations for a fingerprint-resistant screen protector for N5?
Link to it
http://www.spigen.com/nexus-5-screen-protector-glas-t-slim-premium-tempered-glass.html
I'm a huge spigen fan, considering the GLAS.tR SLIM as they say the t non-rounded chips more easily?
Has anyone used these?
My TR screen should be coming in today. First time using a glass screen, high expectations.
garyHal said:
My TR screen should be coming in today. First time using a glass screen, high expectations.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been using one on my iphone and love it. Never going back to normal screen protectors.
Rattles said:
I have been using one on my iphone and love it. Never going back to normal screen protectors.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
2nd that. Have used one on an S4 and loved it. Ordered one for the N5. Should be in this week - can't wait.
garyHal said:
My TR screen should be coming in today. First time using a glass screen, high expectations.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
please post some pics i've bought the tR last week and i'm waiting it too
There's been high praise for the Spigen glass protectors so I ordered the GLAS.t SLIM. I think the cheaper of the two should provide enough protection as I generally take care of my phones pretty well. The lower profile of the GLAS.t seemed better for me although the rounded corners of the GLAS.tR would have been nice.
I've used cheaper anti-glare film screen protectors in the past, and they worked but didn't last long due to normal wear and tear, so I'm hoping this glass screen protector goes the distance. I hate applying new screen protectors =/
Edit: As for the recommendations, I would NOT advise Clarivue anti-glare. It works well initially but diminishes screen quality and the anti-glare coating wears out quickly in higher-use areas like where the keyboard is. Went through three in the past year.
If you're in Canada, they are now fulfilled by amazon.ca, that means free shipping! http://www.amazon.ca/SPIGEN-Protect...id=1383316041&sr=1-12&keywords=spigen+nexus+5
I'm really interested in getting the glass.t or glass.tr protectors. However, one thing that has always worried me about tempered glass protectors is the possible space between the screen and the protector.
Since glass protectors are not flexible, but the protector and actual screen must be perfectly flat or there will be bubbles due to points of non-contact between the two. Does anyone have experience applying one, and do they fit well together or are there problems?
EDIT: Also, would these protectors work with the Spigen cases or would the extra thickness cause a problem?
Anyone got theirs yet? I'm thinking of getting the GLAS.t Slim since I'd prefer the thinner one.
I'm wondering if the upper lip on the Spigen cases will actually cover the edges of the protector or if there will be a gap. Since I'm planning to use it in combination with a case, if the case covers the edges of the protector I can't see any advantage of the GLAS.tR Slim.
I've also read some other glass protectors have a grid of dots on them. I think this would really annoy me. Do the Spigen protectors have this?
Do they affect viewing angles at all?
Finally, is a cracked or shatter glass protector likely to scratch up the screen? They are of similar hardness...
Thanks.
I turst Spigen
I have not tried the tempered glass on Nexus 5, but I would trust Spigen products all time, they are getting very positive review on Amazon as well, so I would say go for it and I believe they have the money back guarantee, so why to worry
Xodus22 said:
I'm really interested in getting the glass.t or glass.tr protectors. However, one thing that has always worried me about tempered glass protectors is the possible space between the screen and the protector.
Since glass protectors are not flexible, but the protector and actual screen must be perfectly flat or there will be bubbles due to points of non-contact between the two. Does anyone have experience applying one, and do they fit well together or are there problems?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the Sir Lancelot Armor-Holy Grail for my N4. I have tried them all. First off stay away from Clarivue and Maru, both are just not good.
Haven't tried any others since SLA and ILoome(which have GREAT customer service!) on my N4, so I hope the Spigen can play well with the hybrid case!
The Spigen site recommends using a case along with their GLAS products, so I'm going to assume they fit cases (or at least Spigen cases) just fine.
b.spec said:
The Spigen site recommends using a case along with their GLAS products, so I'm going to assume they fit cases (or at least Spigen cases) just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I remember using a SGP screen protector three years ago. I had tried two. The adhesive was bad and it curled off my phone.
FloppyDrive said:
I remember using a SGP screen protector three years ago. I had tried two. The adhesive was bad and it curled off my phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've heard this from some people as well. I personally will keep my phone without a case or a bumper at the most, so I can't speak from experience. If it's a wet application screen protector, it's probably much more likely that it will curl off since those tend to extend to the edges of the screen.
Here's what is on the Spigen site:
As this is a glass product, please note that the edges of the glass are the most vulnerable areas. We highly recommend that you use a case along with your GLAS.t SLIM to avoid chipping or cracking the edges of your GLAS.t SLIM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tmagritte said:
Since I'm planning to use it in combination with a case, if the case covers the edges of the protector I can't see any advantage of the GLAS.tR Slim.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe the point of the tR is precisely to be used without a case (the tR product page doesn't have the paragraph about using it with a case to protect the edges). So if you're going to use a case, get the t, if not you should get the tR.
I used the glas TR with my work iphone, and they're fantastic. Very durable and they almost feel better than the naked screen. I have one on order for the N5, but not sure if ill put it on right away. You can't go wrong with one of these though, well worth the money if you are looking for long lasting screen protection.
From Spigen's website:
GLAS.T - Our first and original GLAS.t screen protector. Made of real tempered glass and premium silicone adhesive. It is about 0.4mm thick.
GLAS.tR - The "R" stands for rounded. This glass protector has beveled edges to to help prevent chipping on the edges of the glass. Recommended for users that are not using a case or a minimal case design. About 0.55mm thick.
GLAS.T Slim - We've made our popular GLAS.t even slimmer. Same concept and material as our GLAS.t, but it ranges from 0.23-0.26mm depending on the product.
GLAS.tR Slim - Also the rounded version of the GLAS.t Slim. The thickness is about 0.4mm
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm having some trouble with the GLAS.tR. I just installed it, and the bottom left corner is not sticking, and there is a spot that's not sticking on the right side of the headset speaker. I'm trying to leave some weight on top of it and see if that will fix it.
wormbaby11 said:
I'm having some trouble with the GLAS.tR. I just installed it, and the bottom left corner is not sticking, and there is a spot that's not sticking on the right side of the headset speaker. I'm trying to leave some weight on top of it and see if that will fix it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
same here! I have three rather large "bubbles" (though thankfully none are on the screen), one of which is in the bottom left corner. When I apply pressure, it reduces to a tiny bubble, but after about a minute, it will have expanded again. I tried putting a textbook on top overnight, but this morning when i lifted the book, it just grew back in a minute.
If it doesn't fix itself in another 24 hour, I'm going to call Spigen.
Hey guys, so I got my Nexus 5 recently and pretty happy with it (even got the official Gray bumper today and well, kinda nice) but I really don't wanna end up having a plastic screen protectors like with all the other phones I had, I hate sooooo much when fingerprints show on the PET film and they always do so I thought of just getting a nice tempered glass protector - expensive but $ well-spent. After a little googling I found out that spigen are the best ones out there, that the N5's glas.tr had a design flaw, and that they are replacing it with the glas.tr NANO Slim. Now, couple questions:
Is there a really big difference between the Glas.T and the glas.TR NANO Slim? Or just the rounded edges on the TR version?
I'd really like to know also when Spigen is gonna sell these things. I wanna order one of these tomorrow so I've checked Amazon.co.uk and they are both in stock, but on amazon.com glas.t will be in stock on 30th nov and glas.tr on fifth december. But why are these in stock at amazon.co.uk? Am I missing something? (I'd like to order the protector from amazon.co.uk because UK is more near than US to Italy of course, but first I wanna know if it actually is in stock)
Last but not least, do you think these protectors will cause any issue with the official bumper? Because I really don't wanna flush 40 bucks down the toilet.
I have the GLAS.tR and have no problems with it. Most people had like one whole corner of the glass lifting up.. I had 2 air bubbles (decent size), the first one went away, the second one is almost gone now. I guess it's just how you install it. I do know that anyone that bought the GLAS.t/tR from spigen and requested a replacement will be getting the nano slim as soon as it is released. They didn't specify a release date, though:
"We will be releasing the New GLAS.t and GLAS.tR Nano tempered glass screen protectors within the next few weeks and we would like to send these as a replacement for your GLAS.t or GLAS.tR Slim when the New Nano Slims are available"
So... whats the news with the nano.tR protectors... are they any good...
My glas.tR slim was stuck for a few days eventually it gave up on one of the corners, and that part is lifted up now...
glas.t and glas.tr are total failures... if at all the nano's only work...
G
The NANO fixes that issue even Spigen has recognized. But I want to know from you guys: does it protect the WHOLE glass surface of the phone or leave a little space at the edges? I wanna know because I don't want to get issues with the Google bumper.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Bytecode said:
The NANO fixes that issue even Spigen has recognized. But I want to know from you guys: does it protect the WHOLE glass surface of the phone or leave a little space at the edges? I wanna know because I don't want to get issues with the Google bumper.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the GLAS.tR, which also lifted in the top right corner. The fit of the glass has a small space around all edges of roughly 1mm. (Which for me, makes it harder to line up as you need to make spacing even on all sides - I would prefer an exact fit).
theickleone said:
I have the GLAS.tR, which also lifted in the top right corner. The fit of the glass has a small space around all edges of roughly 1mm. (Which for me, makes it harder to line up as you need to make spacing even on all sides - I would prefer an exact fit).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Everyone'd love an exact fit but that'd make it incompatible with any case.
On a different but not unrelated topic, is there really a big difference between glas.t and glas.tr? Just the rounded edges? Glas.t go in stock earlier so I'll have to wait less and maybe can get it for around Xmas. If I wait for december fifth I'll most likely get it after Christmas cause you know, in that time of the year every shipping gets jammed and stuff.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Bytecode said:
Everyone'd love an exact fit but that'd make it incompatible with any case.
On a different but not unrelated topic, is there really a big difference between glas.t and glas.tr? Just the rounded edges? Glas.t go in stock earlier so I'll have to wait less and maybe can get it for around Xmas. If I wait for december fifth I'll most likely get it after Christmas cause you know, in that time of the year every shipping gets jammed and stuff.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I personally only have experience with the glas.tr, but the rounded edge is really the main difference. I do know that the glas.t is thinner, but I feel that the "bulk/extra thickness" difference between the two are pretty minimal.
I went for the glass.tr because I swipe from the edge of the screen with quite a lot of my apps.
theickleone said:
I personally only have experience with the glas.tr, but the rounded edge is really the main difference. I do know that the glas.t is thinner, but I feel that the "bulk/extra thickness" difference between the two are pretty minimal.
I went for the glass.tr because I swipe from the edge of the screen with quite a lot of my apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will the rounded edge thingy make a big deal if I'm using a case? If not imma go for glas.t.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I have the glas.t because of the lower profile and it was cheaper. I do NOT have a case with it, however, and I prefer it that way. Unlike a lot of others, I actually had no problem applying the glas.t without bubbles (I used clips to hold it in place for several hours to achieve this).
The screen protector covers basically the entire screen, leaving a minor 1-1.5 mm bezel around the edges. I'm not sure about the rounded edges of the tR, but I've had my screen protector for about 2 weeks and there are zero blemishes. Nothing cracked, nothing scratched. But you should note that while it's tempered glass, it's not fingerprint proof. My hands do get oily at times, and it WILL show fingerprints.
That being said, I really really like this product (when it works obviously). The glass feels amazing to use on a daily basis. It's quite durable (as I said before, I keep my phone without a case and just carry it in my pocket). Screen clarity is great and touch sensitivity is still consistent across the entire screen. With the Nano version improving on the regular glas.t/tR, I would definitely recommend picking one up. The tR's are meant for use without a case (hence the rounded edges), so I would probably get the t.
b.spec said:
I have the glas.t because of the lower profile and it was cheaper. I do NOT have a case with it, however, and I prefer it that way. Unlike a lot of others, I actually had no problem applying the glas.t without bubbles (I used clips to hold it in place for several hours to achieve this).
The screen protector covers basically the entire screen, leaving a minor 1-1.5 mm bezel around the edges. I'm not sure about the rounded edges of the tR, but I've had my screen protector for about 2 weeks and there are zero blemishes. Nothing cracked, nothing scratched. But you should note that while it's tempered glass, it's not fingerprint proof. My hands do get oily at times, and it WILL show fingerprints.
That being said, I really really like this product (when it works obviously). The glass feels amazing to use on a daily basis. It's quite durable (as I said before, I keep my phone without a case and just carry it in my pocket). Screen clarity is great and touch sensitivity is still consistent across the entire screen. With the Nano version improving on the regular glas.t/tR, I would definitely recommend picking one up. The tR's are meant for use without a case (hence the rounded edges), so I would probably get the t.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So, the glas.tr are for people who don't use cases eh? I'm gonna buy the glas.t then (I always use a bumper). One question: does it show fingerprints and dirt as the normal gorilla glass 3 or a little more? And what about it compared to a PET screen protector?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Bytecode said:
So, the glas.tr are for people who don't use cases eh? I'm gonna buy the glas.t then (I always use a bumper). One question: does it show fingerprints and dirt as the normal gorilla glass 3 or a little more? And what about it compared to a PET screen protector?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To my experience, it seems to be the same amount for fingerprints on the screen and the glass protector. But a quick wipe solves the problem.
I used a Spigen PET (ultra clear, front and back) screen protector on my Nexus 4, which seemed to be collecting oil. It would be difficult to remove even when wiping. (Should be called Spigen oil slick).
But generally, even though it does get a smudge it cleans a lot easier compared to the PET screen protector. :good:
theickleone said:
To my experience, it seems to be the same amount for fingerprints on the screen and the glass protector. But a quick wipe solves the problem.
I used a Spigen PET (ultra clear, front and back) screen protector on my Nexus 4, which seemed to be collecting oil. It would be difficult to remove even when wiping. (Should be called Spigen oil slick).
But generally, even though it does get a smudge it cleans a lot easier compared to the PET screen protector. :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is exactly what I was going to say. The glas.t feels just like the gorilla glass 3 since both have the oleophobic properties. As mentioned above, while it still shows fingerprints I think a big advantage is how easily those are to get off the screen. Typically film screen protectors, no matter how clear they are, will smudge fingerprints around until it's like "meh, good enough".
Also, you might want to check Glass-M and Nillkin for tempered glass screen protectors. Way cheaper and people seem to be happy about them. The Nillkin you can buy for like 9 €... That's one hell of a price difference.
I bought the Glass-M for about 20 € (including shipment to Europe). It's about half the price of the Spigen one and I doubt there is much difference.+
http://theglass-m.com/collections/f...red-glass-screen-protector-for-google-nexus-5
Thanks for the replies guys. About the glass-m thanks, but I'd rather have the best in its class (spigen).
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
TheBeardedAx said:
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Mime feather is my first experience with extremely thin glass protectors. My experience at first was great, but it is starting to fall apart and I'm regretting my purchase. It started with the corners for some reason even though I have the heavy duty ballistic case on the phone. Now I'm getting whole cracks from one side to the other... Not even originating from the corners where it started. I am clueless as to how it happens because I have never dropped my phone.
If you're going to get a glass protector I strongly encourage you to get the non-thin versions. It's not a whole lot thicker and it is less likely to be brittle. I have used several normal thickness glass protectors in the past (Spigen) and was never disappointed in those. So far my experience with MIME is poor, but Spigen has been excellent and that includes their cases.
Thanks. I was tempted buy Iloome's flex glass cause it's on sale right now for $17 but I was thinking the thicker protector might be the way to go.
TheBeardedAx said:
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using MIME Ghost glass protector. It is excellent. I am using my N5 without a case.
psy_spy said:
I am using MIME Ghost glass protector. It is excellent. I am using my N5 without a case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How long have you been using the Ghost? Any issues with peeling/chipping/bubbles?
I enjoy the spigen glastr nano slim. I haven't had any issues since i put it on week ago. I wrote a thread about it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
TheBeardedAx said:
How long have you been using the Ghost? Any issues with peeling/chipping/bubbles?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been using it for 2 weeks. No peeling/chipping issues since it is a bit thicker compared to feather. When I applied it on the phone, I got a very small bubble near the upper left corner. It disappeared after a day. Please read reviews from other mime ghost owners to get a fair idea. I remember seeing a separate thread for mime in the n5 forum.
I've got the spigen glass nano.tr slim (the one with rounded corners) coming the mail. Any tips on applying it? I REALLY get OCD (ADHD) if there's ANY dust or bubbles under the screen, so I have to do it perfectly, since it costs nearly £30.
Any advice on how to do it flawlessly?
I read somewhere about running the shower on hot for 30 mins, then doing it in the bathroom, because the hot air causes the dust to all fall to the ground and isn't flying around - but won't that cause condensation etc to build up on the screen in the seconds before you apply the protector?
Any tips would be greatly appreciated.
paradoxiumwind said:
I've got the spigen glass nano.tr slim (the one with rounded corners) coming the mail. Any tips on applying it? I REALLY get OCD (ADHD) if there's ANY dust or bubbles under the screen, so I have to do it perfectly, since it costs nearly £30.
Any advice on how to do it flawlessly?
I read somewhere about running the shower on hot for 30 mins, then doing it in the bathroom, because the hot air causes the dust to all fall to the ground and isn't flying around - but won't that cause condensation etc to build up on the screen in the seconds before you apply the protector?
Any tips would be greatly appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See my thread. Use the hinge method. I didn't do it in a steamy room, but it went on near flawless. (No dust, but only very slightly off center)
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I got the xgear glass for nexus 4 and it was great. It save me phone, I drop it on is screen and nothing happens only the tempered glass was broken.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
KTT16 said:
See my thread. Use the hinge method. I didn't do it in a steamy room, but it went on near flawless. (No dust, but only very slightly off center)
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Regarding the hinge method, make sure when you close the hinge it falls smack dab center. No having to pull it to slightly center it, etc. The tape itself has some bit of tension so it will pull the screen protector back. I'm like 0.2mm off center and I'm very annoyed. So maybe when you tape the screen protector down, start slightly to the left (assuming you tape the right).
Also if you have access to a clean room, do it there. I regret doing it at home and not staying late at work to use the CDA and cleanroom to properly dust off my screen. A stupid eyelash fell off in the middle of the procedure and I have a freaking eyelash underneath my screen protector. LOL. Good thing it's at the bezel though.
The most effective method imo is the steamed washroom method which gives you lots of chances to get it right and you'll never get any dust or any other particles on your screen.
The cruzerlite glass screen protector is amazing. I need to write up a review on it now and take some pics as I've had it over a week. It honestly feels better than the real n5 screen.
>^.^< Sent From Meow nexus 5
I have the Mime Feather Glass and it works great. I did have to shave the corners of my Ringke case to prevent the screen protector from peeling up on the edges. See post #30 here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2540471
On a side note., the screen protector did crack, from something I did, and Mime sent me a coupon for 50% off a new one.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I have a Nillkin protector, looks and feels great. Just wondering how a tempered glass protector fares against drops compared to those shatter proof polyurethane (non glass) screen protectors like Rhino Shield and Zagg Extreme. I know Tempered glass protectors can shatter but those others won't, I’m not worried about that, I’m more concerned about the level of protection they offer. Are glass protectors as good as those other ones at dispersing and dampening impact forces? I've seen a couple of videos on Rhino Shield and they look amazing.
I received the first gen of Spigen's SLIM.t screen protectors in mid-November and have been using it since. Initially, the product was great albeit it still attracted fingerprints. I was highly satisfied and the tempered glass looked and felt amazing (plus I managed to avoid any of the bubbles the majority of early buyers experienced).
But a month after normal use (I don't use a case either, but I'm very careful with my phone) it started chipping on the edges. I never dropped my phone or do anything that would cause damage, but magically out of no where the screen protector started chipping.
Currently today, I have 6 chips around my screen protector (2 at the top, 1 on the right, 3 on the left), and two clear cracks across my phone as well (both stemming from separate chips on the side). I'm not sure how the SPIM.tR Nano performs, but I can tell you that paying over $30 for a screen protector that chips this easily is not a worthwhile investment. Something to be aware of.
Zagg HD shield has no problems
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
KTT16 said:
I enjoy the spigen glastr nano slim. I haven't had any issues since i put it on week ago. I wrote a thread about it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This. Best screen protector I've ever had, a little pricey but I'm glad I bought it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Anyone found a tempered glass screen protector for the HTC One (that works). Only one I can find is this Tempered glass screen protector.
Are all the tempered glass screen protectors the same?
mp119519 said:
Anyone found a tempered glass screen protector for the HTC One (that works). Only one I can find is this Tempered glass screen protector.
Are all the tempered glass screen protectors the same?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought one off ebay not too long ago. Anyway, its a quality tempered glass screen protector. Scratch free and no touch issues whatsoever. Long story short, for the most part they are most likely all the same.
Here's the one I purchased :
http://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Premium...l_Phone_Screen_Protectors&hash=item565ffcf158
Did yours match the size of the screen exactly? I bought one off ebay a few months ago, and it works fine but it's about 1mm shorter than the black area. I've sent mine in for the pink camera noise issue, and if I get it back with a bare screen I'd like to replace it with one that fits.
size
It's normal, that the protector is slightly smaller than the acutal screen. If they were spot on the same size, it would be almost impossible to put the protector on, without any air bubbles underneath it.
Brando Rounded Tempered Glass protector
I've had this... http://shop.brando.com/Brando-Works...Rounded-Edition-HTC-One-_p09083c1531d008.html on my phone for about 9 months. Not a mark on it and fits perfectly.
Bit more expensive than some, but it's 9H glass (Diamond is 10H!) & just watch the videos... They have a go at it with knives & a drill! (I've tried a knife myself ... Not a scratch!)
Worth a bit extra cash in my opinion.
DonKaio said:
It's normal, that the protector is slightly smaller than the acutal screen. If they were spot on the same size, it would be almost impossible to put the protector on, without any air bubbles underneath it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The one I purchased fits the screen perfectly. Maybe a extremely small gap at the top but literally unnoticeable
I have the MIME ghost glass protector and love it! Does not have that sticky feel that PET protectors have, I'd never go back to plastic again.
http://mimeusa.com/product/htc-one-ghost-glass-tempered-glass-screen-protector/
Well, my One is back and the screen is nakies so it's time for a new screen protector. They must have replaced the screen, since it had a tiny hairline scratch when I sent it in and it's gone so I can't complain too much. Hopefully the new screen protector fits better than the last.
Mime Feather on mine and I love it.
Covers the screen perfectly and I had no trouble installing it. The only way you know it's there is because it's slightly raised above the phone (0.15mm, they say).
The iloome Flex is pretty good, I have one myself. It's easy to install, because it's flexible unlike other glass screen protectors and they also give you some tape if you want to use the hinge method. It's pretty hard (8H) and thin too.
revised review, now very negative about Mime
Mike02z said:
I have the MIME ghost glass protector and love it! Does not have that sticky feel that PET protectors have, I'd never go back to plastic again.
http://mimeusa.com/product/htc-one-ghost-glass-tempered-glass-screen-protector/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have to revise my opinion of Mime and their products after having gone through 3 of them on the same phone.
1. The first one felt great initially. But it scratched much too easily for it to be 9H, so I am going to have to call BS on their hardness claim.
Mime offered to send me a new one and did after about a month.
2. The second one did not stick correctly, even though I installed it in exactly the same manner as the first one.
Mime offered to send me a new one, but they were out of stock in both Ghost Glass and Feather for this phone (M7). After several weeks, the Feather was finally available again but the discount code they sent did not work and there was a further delay while Mime sorted that out. Also the Feather model cost more so I had to pay an extra $3 US plus the coupon.
3. The unit I received after ordering the Feather did not appear to be glass. It was flexible and felt, looked and scratched just like a cheap plastic screen protector. I patiently waited because I assumed this was an interim unit to hold me over until the glass ones became available again. But when I contacted Mime they assured me that was the Feather and that Mime does not stock any plastic at all to fit the M7. So apparently the Feather is no better than plastic, but costs $30 US apiece shipped.
So I asked for a refund. Mime asked me to ship it back, which I did.
Mime received it 2 weeks ago and I have not heard from them despite multiple emails.
Terribly slow customer service all around, the products are ridiculously overpriced, I definitely would not buy again.
I apologize to anyone that bought Mime products after reading my review because my opinion of Mime and their products has certainly changed since then.
Initial quality felt good, but they do not last long enough to warrant the high price and the after sale support is also not worth the price.
I could have bought 6 of the Chinese cheapie tempered glass screen protectors + shipping and still had 5 left as I am still on the 1st one vs 3 Mime duds. This is what I have done on my S5 and it was better quality than the Mime for $4.
Don't waste your money on Mime.
initial observation is below:
I also use the Mime Ghost Glass and I really like it.
It measures .32mm. You can tell it's there if you are looking for it, but so far everyone I hand my phone to has not noticed it.
Mime also makes the Feather model, as mentioned by someone else, which measures .15mm thickness. I would have probably bought that if I had seen it before I bought the Ghost Glass. They are both rated at 9H hardness, but theoretically the thicker one should offer more protection.
jthatch12 said:
The one I purchased fits the screen perfectly. Maybe a extremely small gap at the top but literally unnoticeable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just ordered the one you suggested for $6.85. It's my first ever glass screen protector, hoping it will be a fun experience. From reviews on amazon, and I belive the one on ebay that the seller is selling, is the one made by PThink, judging from the same photos. The only complaint on the cheaper ones are that sometimes the edges don't seal down the the screen, and can cause bubbles. Still, I am excited.
Here is the link once again to buy, and at time of purchase is only $6.85 with free shipping.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Premium...l_Phone_Screen_Protectors&hash=item565ffcf158
Here are the reviews believed to have been the same glass protector. http://www.amazon.com/PThink-Ultra-...Q62/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?showViewpoints=1
nohamSam said:
I also use the Mime Ghost Glass and I really like it.
It measures .32mm. You can tell it's there if you are looking for it, but so far everyone I hand my phone to has not noticed it.
Mime also makes the Feather model, as mentioned by someone else, which measures .15mm thickness. I would have probably bought that if I had seen it before I bought the Ghost Glass. They are both rated at 9H hardness, but theoretically the thicker one should offer more protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using Mime Feather model, very happy with it, and they have excellent customer service. Word of caution though, if you're planning to use it with HTC's Double Down case it won't work, that case presses on the edges of Mime glass and causes it to rise along the edges.
I bought this when my phone was new, and its is perfect!
Opius90 said:
I bought this when my phone was new, and its is perfect!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it feel sharp edges when sliding finger from speakers to screen area? how long have you been using it? I got chineese one from ebay, was good for 3 months but now glass has adhesive problems, small bubbles appeared near edges ;D
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk
oxyg3n89 said:
Does it feel sharp edges when sliding finger from speakers to screen area? how long have you been using it? I got chineese one from ebay, was good for 3 months but now glass has adhesive problems, small bubbles appeared near edges ;D
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, it does actually feel sharp, but i have never tought of it as a problem, in fact, i havent noticed untill now. Its been on my phone for 3 months now as well, but no scratches or bubbles what so ever.
Anyone use a tempered glass with the UAG case?
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using xda app-developers app
stricklerjosh said:
Anyone use a tempered glass with the UAG case?
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use the Mime Ghost glass screen with a UAG case. No issues with it at all. That combo works great.
is there one that can fit with the HTC Double Dip Hardshell? I'm looking for screen protector that can fit in that thing.
stricklerjosh said:
Anyone use a tempered glass with the UAG case?
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've got UAG + Mime feather. Works great though a couple of days ago I actually chipped the edge of the feather glass and my phone. But that's because I'm an idiot and keep my keys+keyring-multitool and phone in the same pocket (hence why I have a case and protector)
...my naked N5 slipped from my cold, numb fingers and landed flat but face down on a NYC sidewalk a couple days ago. At first it looked like a "soft landing" but no such luck and now I'm looking at a screen replacement (screen itself OK, but glass cracked all to hell).
So now I'm wondering if this could have been prevented simply by a case and not necessarily a screen protector as well. I've used cases such as an Otterbox Commuter in the past but never dropped any of those phones to the extent this one went down. It seems to me that any case with a slight lip on the front -- as most of them must have -- would be enough since the screen itself would not hit the ground.
From research on this forum and web sites I'm currently favoring the Spigen Thin Armor case but am wondering if a high-quality screen protector would also be worth it. My screen at the time it was damaged really had no scratches at all, so the Gorilla Glass was doing its job. Would one of those tempered glass protectors also provide shatter protection? Or would a decent case by itself be sufficient?
FWIW, I've used thin-film protectors in the past but always found them annoying due to bubbles, making the screen less readable, and/or affecting the touch response.
Even with a case on, if there was a small rock or a jagged edge on the ground that nicks the screen, it would have still been toast anyway. This is regardless of if there was a lip protecting it or not. It all depends on what's on the ground by chance.
A tempered glass protector probably could have saved the screen though, since you said it landed flat on its face. Tempered glass protectors are perfect for impacts that land face down, not so much on edges or sides. You will see most demonstrations of tempered glass done with nails, hammers, drop tests, etc. with the phone being impacted directly on the face. If it impacts from the side, there is a good chance the screen could still break as tempered glass isn't really designed to protect from those types of impacts.
That is where the case with a lip comes in. Those are meant to protect from side and edge impacts. Most drops generally don't land flat like yours, they tend to bounce around on corners first, so the case would absorb most of the impact and not the phone directly.
Your best bet is to both have a tempered glass screen protector (for flat impacts), and a bumper frame or TPU case (for the rest).
I use a Nillkin H+ Tempered Glass screen protector and a bumper frame (back not covered as I put a skin on the back) and I'm pretty much covered for most brain lapse moments.
rochrunner said:
FWIW, I've used thin-film protectors in the past but always found them annoying due to bubbles, making the screen less readable, and/or affecting the touch response.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Once you learn the hinge method for putting on screen protectors, you won't have air bubbles or dust underneath. You can't even tell my phone has a screen protector on it. Youtube has several videos on how to do it properly.
I refuse to pay big $$$ for glass protectors because you only get one of them, and you either do it right, or throw it away. With plastic protectors, you get several for a few dollars.
wolfen69 said:
I refuse to pay big $$$ for glass protectors because you only get one of them, and you either do it right, or throw it away. With plastic protectors, you get several for a few dollars.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not true. I applied and removed my Nillkin more then 10 times during the application to get rid of the dust I missed trapped underneath because I suck at applying screen protectors. It reapplied the same every time. All you have to do is make sure you don't firmly press it down and you're fine. This is even after you see the adhesion process occur. It will still peel up. The adhesive takes a few hours to a day (depending on brand) to fully stick/cure.
If a person like me can apply one glass screen protector, anyone else will do it better. One is all you need.
Plastic will only give basic scratch protection and leave a greasy screen after a while. If it takes the same fall his did, the screen would still be done for.
mmmmBACON said:
I use a Nillkin H+ Tempered Glass screen protector and a bumper frame (back not covered as I put a skin on the back) and I'm pretty much covered for most brain lapse moments.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What bumper frame do you use? I've been looking for one myself for a while now...
Cases protect the actual body of the phone, and maybe the screen if it happens to land flat. But if a rock of some other elevated object hits the screen then it will be done for. And a plastic screen protector will do nothing, that protects against scratches like from sand. A glass one would be the best bet for shatter protection. I've seen a person take a hammer to a screen with a glass screen protector on. The protector was rekt but the phone screen was fine.
Awesomepie85 said:
What bumper frame do you use? I've been looking for one myself for a while now...
Cases protect the actual body of the phone, and maybe the screen if it happens to land flat. But if a rock of some other elevated object hits the screen then it will be done for. And a plastic screen protector will do nothing, that protects against scratches like from sand. A glass one would be the best bet for shatter protection. I've seen a person take a hammer to a screen with a glass screen protector on. The protector was rekt but the phone screen was fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are 2 that I would probably recommend. I'm currently using a transparent bumper case off of ebay. I did a review here http://forum.xda-developers.com/google-nexus-5/accessories/lucency-transparent-bumper-case-review-t2690108. It is $2.88 shipped. If you do choose this one, I would stick to black. After using them for a while now, the various colours tend to stain easily, but the black doesn't. It is just for light drop protection, but since the main body is a harder plastic, it won't absorb a higher drop like a softer bumper frame, or a TPU case would. I personally like it because it is transparent and you can still see the sides of the phone and the skin through it.
The other is the replica Nexus 4 bumper, for the Nexus 5. Mine is still in the mail so I haven't tried it out yet, but others have bought it and it seems to have gotten pretty good reviews overall. http://forum.xda-developers.com/google-nexus-5/accessories/replica-official-nexus-4-bumper-nexus-5-t2698422. It's a little bit pricier at $12.99 off Amazon, or around $8 - $10 off Aliexpress.
rochrunner said:
...my naked N5 slipped from my cold, numb fingers and landed flat but face down on a NYC sidewalk a couple days ago. At first it looked like a "soft landing" but no such luck and now I'm looking at a screen replacement (screen itself OK, but glass cracked all to hell).
So now I'm wondering if this could have been prevented simply by a case and not necessarily a screen protector as well. I've used cases such as an Otterbox Commuter in the past but never dropped any of those phones to the extent this one went down. It seems to me that any case with a slight lip on the front -- as most of them must have -- would be enough since the screen itself would not hit the ground.
From research on this forum and web sites I'm currently favoring the Spigen Thin Armor case but am wondering if a high-quality screen protector would also be worth it. My screen at the time it was damaged really had no scratches at all, so the Gorilla Glass was doing its job. Would one of those tempered glass protectors also provide shatter protection? Or would a decent case by itself be sufficient?
FWIW, I've used thin-film protectors in the past but always found them annoying due to bubbles, making the screen less readable, and/or affecting the touch response.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are many choices for thicker protection cases. Properly applied screen protectors don't have any bubbles.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Hey! There's a kickstarter project for someone: A case with airbags that deploy when the phone finds itself in free-fall .
Claghorn said:
Hey! There's a kickstarter project for someone: A case with airbags that deploy when the phone finds itself in free-fall .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Those sly people at Honda have already done it.
Claghorn said:
Hey! There's a kickstarter project for someone: A case with airbags that deploy when the phone finds itself in free-fall .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think I'd feel comfortable having that in my side pocket close to my family jewels or especially not in my back pocket.
BCSC said:
Those sly people at Honda have already done it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk