Develop Bugs

[Q] I have superuser installed on android 4.0.4 but I still can't get root access?

I rooted my phone at 4.0.2, then applied the update up to 4.0.4 and am still able to flash new versions of clockwork mod through rom manager... However, all my other apps won't be granted root access. In the superuser application, I'm running superuser v3.0.7(41) and my Su binary is at v3.0.3, for which there is an update available. However, when I try to apply the update, it tries to ask for root privileges and gets denied access... I tried reflashing su.zip through clockwork mod touch but I guess I may be flashing an outdated su.zip? Any insight into the matter would be greatly appreciated!

Same here
Same exact scenario, I went from 4.0.2 to 4.0.4, and even after a factory restore I cant seem to get root access for any app. I checked the bootloader, and I still am rooted.
Help appreciated for us both!

try this zip...flash in recovery
http://www.box.com/s/jvcf196j7x8f8vrc9cyt
this worked for me....
if it doesn't clear superuser data first then try it again.

ezcats said:
try this zip...flash in recovery
http://www.box.com/s/jvcf196j7x8f8vrc9cyt
this worked for me....
if it doesn't clear superuser data first then try it again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CWM Recovery is not working for me, and I cant flash it due to no permission for elevated commands although its rooted.

Clockwork recovery does not require root if it is already installed. If not, fastboot clockwork recovery.

I had the same issue and all you have to do is reroot the phone and all will be well then download and install ota rootkeeper for the future. The update breaks root but doesn't block it

evanextreme said:
CWM Recovery is not working for me, and I cant flash it due to no permission for elevated commands although its rooted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Flash from recovery, not an app.....
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium

jerseyh22accord said:
I had the same issue and all you have to do is reroot the phone and all will be well then download and install ota rootkeeper for the future. The update breaks root but doesn't block it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This did the trick!
Had this same problem earlier

I need help
I am having the same problem. I am a noob and it sucks cause I can't figure it out. I can't even go into recovery since I installed 4.0.4 someone please dumb it down so i can understand

Install busybox free, then install titanium backup free. Open busybox and click inatall. Then run
Titanium backup, it will ask you do you want it to configure root, accept this. please note After completing busybox steps reboot. Then after titanium backup steps reboot again
Did this help?
If not pm me and il see if i can help

I can't use any of my root apps. My SU isn't working. I'm pretty sure that's causing the problem. I tried updating the binary (I read that somewhere) but the process fails. Is there a way I can do it manually?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA

brightsideme said:
I can't use any of my root apps. My SU isn't working. I'm pretty sure that's causing the problem. I tried updating the binary (I read that somewhere) but the process fails. Is there a way I can do it manually?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try flashing this:
http://goo.im/superuser/Superuser-3.0.7-efghi-signed.zip

Can you please explain how to flash? I don't want to mess it up lol
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA

brightsideme said:
Can you please explain how to flash? I don't want to mess it up lol
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have CWM installed yet?
If not...
I'd recommend simply starting from the top and using my guide.
But if you have CWM:
Just navigate to "Install Zip From SD Card"
"Choose Zip"
And find it.
Yes to install.

I tried going to clockworkmod recovery but I just get that error. Last night I went into recovery using the cmd on my computer. I tried flashing that same file but it just failed.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA

brightsideme said:
I tried going to clockworkmod recovery but I just get that error. Last night I went into recovery using the cmd on my computer. I tried flashing that same file but it just failed.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
boot to clockworkmod manually, than flash the superuser zip from here http://www.box.com/s/jvcf196j7x8f8vrc9cyt (this does not require busybox, that why the other su zip was failing)

I can't go to recovery from my phone. When I try I just get the Droid with a red exclamation point. I'll have to do it from a computer. Only problem is that I'm at work. I'll see if I can get to one ASAP
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA

brightsideme said:
I can't go to recovery from my phone. When I try I just get the Droid with a red exclamation point. I'll have to do it from a computer. Only problem is that I'm at work. I'll see if I can get to one ASAP
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is the stock recovery that you're getting to.
Use my guide.
And navigate to the part about flashing a custom (CWM) recovery and flashing SU.
The SU in my post is updated to work for all users...the one you're using won't work on 4.0.4.

Jubakuba said:
That is the stock recovery that you're getting to.
Use my guide.
And navigate to the part about flashing a custom (CWM) recovery and flashing SU.
The SU in my post is updated to work for all users...the one you're using won't work on 4.0.4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
but i think the su zip in ur post, only work if there is busybox installed...and the stock rom doesn't have it...
this the updater-script of ur su.zip: run_program("/sbin/busybox"...
that work only on custom roms, that usually have busybox preinstalled
check the different syntax in the other su zip posted above, it doesn't require busybox

andQlimax said:
but i think the su zip in ur post, only work if there is busybox installed...and the stock rom doesn't have it...
this the updater-script of ur su.zip: run_program("/sbin/busybox"...
that work only on custom roms, that usually have busybox preinstalled
check the different syntax in the other su zip posted above, it doesn't require busybox
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nope, he was getting a permissions error because rom manager didn't have root access, that was the issue there.
edit: re-read the post, yes, you might be right about busybox in stock recovery, although i believe cwm has a set of minimal busybox tools.
if manually booting into recovery by shutting down the phone, pressing power+vol up until Google screen appears, doesn't take him to cwm but to stock recovery, he doesn't even have cwm installed, which could very well be the case, since stock rom default behaviour overrides any existing recovery when flashing.

Root Lost

Im currently on Android 4.3 and have been since a couple days after it was pushed to AOSP, no problems until recently, I got a message to update SuperSU Binary's, the install flailed so I tried flashing it through TWRP, but I cant boot into recovery either so im not sure what the problem is but I think I might have lost root although i still have SuperSU on my device. Included some screenshots below:

Dunno what went wrong but you can't go wrong with reflashing your recovery via fastboot and then flashing su or reflashing your ROM
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 4

Thank you
Thank you, it worked

[Q] Missing custom recovery

I took the OTA on my Rooted N7 2013 with TWRP installed. I originally rooted with Wugs Nexus Toolkit and installed recovery with Recovery Toolkit. I knew I would lose root by updating but assumed I could just flash a new SuperSU.zip file with TWRP, however, the OTA took me back to stock recovery.
This has happened before with my 2012 N7, so I am either missing a step or was asleep in class that day on how to bring back the custom recovery without going back to the computer. Anyway to fix this from the device, and how to avoid in the future?
Thanks in advance.

Ota files sometimes flashes stock recovery. You will need a computer to get it back
prshosting.org

I kept root because I bought SuperSu pro. Then I reinstalled TWRP using GooManager. No pc needed.

purple lady said:
I kept root because I bought SuperSu pro. Then I reinstalled TWRP using GooManager. No pc needed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, just upgraded to SuperSU Pro and will see if that works on the next update.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

[Q] Now that we have S-Off, CWM or TWRP? Opinions?

The subject pretty much says it all. Now that we have S-Off again (yay, way to go developers) which would you use and why, CWM or TWRP? Pros? Cons?

twolostminds said:
The subject pretty much says it all. Now that we have S-Off again (yay, way to go developers) which would you use and why, CWM or TWRP? Pros? Cons?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've used both CWM and TWRP pretty extensively over the last few years but I have settled on TWRP just because I like the layout and ease of use. So far I haven't ran into anything that didn't play nice with either one, so for me its an aesthetic choice.

I've only used TWRP once. A lot of people are using it these days because of the theming options and it being faster than CWM but I've read too many reports about various flashes not working properly with it. Stability trumps coolness for me so I'm sticking with CWM.

I've used TWRP since I got my rezound way back when and have used it since then there where some issues fliashing kitkat when it first came out. Philz is a nice recovery too.
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

Santods twrp is the best.

I wanted to chime in here: I've used both on my HTC one for Verizon and I seem to have a problem with both. After using JCase's root app and successfully getting s-off, I'm not able to get either recoveries to flash the superuser apk so that I can sustain root access. This is preventing me from flashing any rom. I know that a bunch of other people on this forum were able to get their roms flashed on so I was wondering if it's something I've done wrong, or just incompatibility with these 2 recoveries?
Steps I took:
1) installed JCase's weaksauce app, rebooted
2) obtained root, downloaded SU from market
3) proceeded with firewater to obtain s-off (successful)
4) installed clockwork recovery via fastboot.
5) proceeded to install superuser, unsuccessful.
6) rebooted phone, uninstalled SU (from 1st installation prior to s-off)
7) attempted to reinstall SU from Clockwork - fail.
8) flashed TWRP recovery, attempted to install SU, failed.
Not sure if there are other recoveries that I should be trying?
Thanks for the help!

Bobert360 said:
I wanted to chime in here: I've used both on my HTC one for Verizon and I seem to have a problem with both. After using JCase's root app and successfully getting s-off, I'm not able to get either recoveries to flash the superuser apk so that I can sustain root access. This is preventing me from flashing any rom. I know that a bunch of other people on this forum were able to get their roms flashed on so I was wondering if it's something I've done wrong, or just incompatibility with these 2 recoveries?
Steps I took:
1) installed JCase's weaksauce app, rebooted
2) obtained root, downloaded SU from market
3) proceeded with firewater to obtain s-off (successful)
4) installed clockwork recovery via fastboot.
5) proceeded to install superuser, unsuccessful.
6) rebooted phone, uninstalled SU (from 1st installation prior to s-off)
7) attempted to reinstall SU from Clockwork - fail.
8) flashed TWRP recovery, attempted to install SU, failed.
Not sure if there are other recoveries that I should be trying?
Thanks for the help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you sure you obtained S-Off? One S-Off is complete, uninstall weaksauce, and flash recovery via fastboot (makes sure your using the latest cwm or TWP. I used this one http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2416431
Boot into recovery and flash SU. Worked like a champ for me.

dcorrea said:
Are you sure you obtained S-Off? One S-Off is complete, uninstall weaksauce, and flash recovery via fastboot (makes sure your using the latest cwm or TWP. I used this one http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2416431
Boot into recovery and flash SU. Worked like a champ for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much for your response. Yup, when I hold down the power and volume down button, my hboot says Unlocked at the top (which I believe to be the status of my bootloader) and S-Off.
I flashed recovery via fastboot, and tried what I believe to be the latest versions of both Clockwork and TWRP. I'll check out the link you sent again and will post results.
Question for you, after you uninstalled the weaksauce app, you left SU installed, correct? So the process would be uninstall weaksauce, reboot to fastboot mode, flash recovery, flash rom?
Thanks again!

Bobert360 said:
Thank you so much for your response. Yup, when I hold down the power and volume down button, my hboot says Unlocked at the top (which I believe to be the status of my bootloader) and S-Off.
I flashed recovery via fastboot, and tried what I believe to be the latest versions of both Clockwork and TWRP. I'll check out the link you sent again and will post results.
Question for you, after you uninstalled the weaksauce app, you left SU installed, correct? So the process would be uninstall weaksauce, reboot to fastboot mode, flash recovery, flash rom?
Thanks again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep that's what I did. I flashed superuser before flashing the rom though. What error do you get when you try to flash superuser?
Oh wait, I just read your initial post. Youre not trying to flash an .apk through recovery right? You should be flashing a .zip file in recovery.

You don't have to flash super user to flash a Rom either bro as long as you have custom recovery you can flash wahat ever Rom you want ?
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

coachcrey said:
You don't have to flash super user to flash a Rom either bro as long as you have custom recovery you can flash wahat ever Rom you want ?
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, just to clarify I originally flashed superuser because I kept the stock rom, but I quickly went to the debloated rom the next day. But Coach is right, you don't need superuser to flash the rom.

Philz touch is by far the most user friendly. Lots of customization options. Its based on cwm but is much better.
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

I had cwm corrupt all my backups I had. Since then I ran twrp. As far as Rom issues people seems to have outdated twrp version or something about the Rom. When I had a Rom fail to flash while in recovery I would reboot recovery and would then flash just fine
Sent from my HTC6525LVW using Tapatalk

Twrp all the way. Its faster at backup and restore, and themeable.

I had really good luck with TWRP 2.6.3.4 but when I upgraded to 2.7.0.1 suddenly backups failed. Never got an answer back on why that was happening, so I switched to Phiz and haven't had a problem with it yet so I'm gonna stick with it for now.

Philz Touch Advanced CWM is the best recovery, hands down. Try it. You will see.

ccarr313 said:
Philz Touch Advanced CWM is the best recovery, hands down. Try it. You will see.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried it and wasn't impressed. Every process seemed to take forever to do. With latest twrp I can do a backup in under a min.
Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

Going with TWRP. It's always just worked for me.
Sent from my HTCM8

No Root No Recovery

The other day I flashed velocity ROM on my flo and it failed on twrp so I flashed clockwork mod and it did the trick but I had forgotten to flash super su so when I pressed reboot it gave me "root lost do you wanna fix sys xbin su?" And of course I clicked yes but after that it told me that the ROM wanted to flash stock recovery and I clicked no so when I booted up I tried using trickster mod and it wouldn't open because I didn't have root so I figured no biggy ill just flash the latest su zip I had and I tried rebooting into cwm but there was no recovery just an android with a red triangle so now I have no root and no recovery which isn't a huge deal but I would really like to fix this. I was thinking of using the wugfresh toolkit I used to first root my flo but I wasent sure if that would work any suggestions?

OsSkates1996 said:
The other day I flashed velocity ROM on my flo and it failed on twrp so I flashed clockwork mod and it did the trick but I had forgotten to flash super su so when I pressed reboot it gave me "root lost do you wanna fix sys xbin su?" And of course I clicked yes but after that it told me that the ROM wanted to flash stock recovery and I clicked no so when I booted up I tried using trickster mod and it wouldn't open because I didn't have root so I figured no biggy ill just flash the latest su zip I had and I tried rebooting into cwm but there was no recovery just an android with a red triangle so now I have no root and no recovery which isn't a huge deal but I would really like to fix this. I was thinking of using the wugfresh toolkit I used to first root my flo but I wasent sure if that would work any suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have any experience using toolkits but I do hear of people using wug's quite a bit. I've only ever used adb/fastboot with the complete sdk installed but a lot of people have problems getting it setup. You can use the toolkit but I would recommend using adb/fastboot because you will get a better working knowledge of what you are actually doing. I installed ADB Installer v1.2 on my brother's laptop and it was ridiculously easy to setup. There are a ton of guides/tutorials out there. Piece of cake!
[GUIDE][30/10/2013]New To Adb And Fastboot Guide
How To: Restore Your 2013 Nexus 7 Back To Stock Using A Full Factory Image And Root It

OsSkates1996 said:
The other day I flashed velocity ROM on my flo and it failed on twrp so I flashed clockwork mod and it did the trick but I had forgotten to flash super su so when I pressed reboot it gave me "root lost do you wanna fix sys xbin su?" And of course I clicked yes but after that it told me that the ROM wanted to flash stock recovery and I clicked no so when I booted up I tried using trickster mod and it wouldn't open because I didn't have root so I figured no biggy ill just flash the latest su zip I had and I tried rebooting into cwm but there was no recovery just an android with a red triangle so now I have no root and no recovery which isn't a huge deal but I would really like to fix this. I was thinking of using the wugfresh toolkit I used to first root my flo but I wasent sure if that would work any suggestions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FWIW, the Android with the red triangle is recovery, stock recovery, just flash a custom recovery again.