so i always wondered does our camera quality BETTER on STOCK TOUCHWIZ roms than on CM roms?
on me personally
when on TOUCHWIZ i can FOCUS this that are really up close.
but when i was on a CM roms i was not able to FOCUS this that were really up close.
(when i say up close i mean like 3 mm guessing lmao. )
As i see it, TW roms will almost always provide a better camera with more features. They built their firmware specifically for this camera, while cm is more generic and built to cover many devices.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda premium
yeah aosp camera is pretty ****ty compared to touchwiz.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
Related
I'm trying to figure out which to go with, the EVOLTE or the SGSIII. I saw in some discussions that the EVOLTE camera on CM10 was able to get some improve camera source code. How is the camera quality on the SGS3 using CM10? Is it just the standard stock camera, or has it been enhanced to get more of the stock camera quality?
cheers
Idk on cm 10 but the stock touch wiz camera takes pretty good pictures and i would upload one but xda app limits size like crazy
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
I am running cm10 nightlies on my sgs3 and was wondering what app is a good replacement to aosp camera app? It doesn't take as good of photos as the touchwiz camera on stock, the light balance is too dark and flash gives it a weird hue. I love cm10 but need a better camera app and from what I gather, touchwiz camera apk only works with touchwiz ROMs. Suggestions?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
ccole22653 said:
I am running cm10 nightlies on my sgs3 and was wondering what app is a good replacement to aosp camera app? It doesn't take as good of photos as the touchwiz camera on stock, the light balance is too dark and flash gives it a weird hue. I love cm10 but need a better camera app and from what I gather, touchwiz camera apk only works with touchwiz ROMs. Suggestions?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, the AOSP camera sucks big time and the interface is super, extra, ugly and outdated.
you can try lgcamera
eortizr said:
Yes, the AOSP camera sucks big time and the interface is super, extra, ugly and outdated.
you can try lgcamera
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For the majority of people, myself included, the stock Camera is just fine for PointAndShoot. I've even purchased CameraZoom when it was on sale, but prefer the simplicity of the default camera. "Best Shot", "Smile Shot", and the other TouchWiz gimmicks are almost never used.
Well I actually don't use any of the gimmick features of the stock touch with camera app, the thing that I liked about it was how it handled low light situations and getting the true color. I will try LG camera.
* I also purchased camera zoom on sale and am currently trying it out.
Any more suggestions? I don't need gimmicks and I don't need photo editing, I just need a very good basic photo taking ability
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
ccole22653 said:
I am running cm10 nightlies on my sgs3 and was wondering what app is a good replacement to aosp camera app? It doesn't take as good of photos as the touchwiz camera on stock, the light balance is too dark and flash gives it a weird hue. I love cm10 but need a better camera app and from what I gather, touchwiz camera apk only works with touchwiz ROMs. Suggestions?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The best one I've used (and I've tried a bunch!) is the camera app that was included with the Serenity rom....which i think is just the ported Note II app. If you can get your hands on that, try it!
When I was on CM10 I used ProCapture. It lacks HDR which is a big deal for me, but it's pretty good apart from that. The TouchWiz camera is one of the main reasons I switched back.
i have cm10 and i use camera zoom fx it work just fine for me
Yeah...back to touchwiz myself... I am sorry but cyanogen mod just can't equal the picture quality of stock camera... I love aosp...but I have found a good compromise... use a touchwiz rom, use a good aosp launcher and keyboard, and messaging and gallery.... and you get to keep your good camera! Though on another note I am somewhat disappointed with the aosp keyboard now....the Swype is cool but just isn't add accurate as I would like... actual Swype I never have to correct... stock 4.2 keyboard is always getting my words wrong...
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
eortizr said:
Yes, the AOSP camera sucks big time and the interface is super, extra, ugly and outdated.
you can try lgcamera
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
wow.
I find the AOSP camera interface great.
are you suggesting the tw camera app is more modern and less ugly interface, because it doesnt look that way here.
For the past week I had aokp on my phone, I was trying to make it work, and had used the camera a dozen or so times to take photos of the weather. I was pretty happy with it initially.
But then yesterday the camera started crashing and not working, a reboot made it work for exactly one photo so not good enough, so I switched back to neatrom (TW). Now by comparison this camera seems a lot worse in functionality. Is probably 70% configurable options missing, seems slower, so the menu responds slower and the focus is pretty bad in comparison it takes a while to focus and then doesnt stay in focus. On top of this I see can only have limited shortcuts at once meaning all the options are never accessible at same time, have to choose which shortcuts. I think the s3 TW camera app is poor, and am currently looking for AOSP camera to put on TW (but seems noone has bothered except chaos?) but would AOSP camera app still be unstable on a TW rom.
I like camera JB+... It does have a similar UI to the aosp camera though (I think I'm one of the few people who love the aosp camera UI).
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
Been using TouchWiz since I got my phone (FreeGS3), now switched to LiquidSmooth (4.2.1), and it's awesome...
BUT, the photo quality on TW was MUCH better. So much that I think I'll switch back.
UNLESS anyone knows ... is there a camera app for AOSP that can match the quality of the TW camera?
Has anyone else noticed the inferior photos? Blurrier, less colorful, no HDR ...
And most idiotic of all, the whole "viewfinder" rotates from landscape to portrait ... which makes NO sense.
On a side note ... I wish someone would create a camera app like the HTC Evo 4G LTE where there are TWO buttons on the screen, one for photos, and one for video ... so that you don't have to switch apps!
Samsung's tw camera is the best...I have downloaded camera zoom fx and still the two camera is better by far...I wish there was an apk for the the tw camera on my aosp...all other cameras are slow
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
Porting the TW camera to AOSP is possible. The TW dependencies just have to be removed. I remember an old friend of mine posted a how to in the OG Epic forums... Might take a look and see if it's something I can poke into
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
Ceelos09 said:
Porting the TW camera to AOSP is possible. The TW dependencies just have to be removed. I remember an old friend of mine posted a how to in the OG Epic forums... Might take a look and see if it's something I can poke into
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That would be freaking awesome.
Like, donation awesome
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2
Ceelos09 said:
Porting the TW camera to AOSP is possible. The TW dependencies just have to be removed. I remember an old friend of mine posted a how to in the OG Epic forums... Might take a look and see if it's something I can poke into
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes please!
Sent from my Galaxy S3. Long live the original Galaxy S
Same here if you can find tw camera which will work on aosp that will be great.
Didnt google tried to improve camera in 4.2.2 ??
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app
That's what I thought as well.... However it doesn't appear that way.
sent from my liquidsmooth gs3
This app is AOSP based and has two buttons for stills and video.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.marginz.snaptrial
Sent from my SPH-L710
Didn't want to make another thread but... I am running Liquid Smooth (Stable) and I was wondering if there was a mod to get Photosphere?? I have tried many times and it never works lol... just wondering if there is a working Photosphere mod? Thanks!
Joe0113 said:
Didn't want to make another thread but... I am running Liquid Smooth (Stable) and I was wondering if there was a mod to get Photosphere?? I have tried many times and it never works lol... just wondering if there is a working Photosphere mod? Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe photosphere only works on 4.1.x AOSP based ROMs and not 4.2.x AOSP ROMs...
kwheaties said:
I believe photosphere only works on 4.1.x AOSP based ROMs and not 4.2.x AOSP ROMs...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have it working on my phone running LiquidSmooth. I have the zip that I used but cannot find the xda thread that I got it from. I'm a little hesitant on posting it, because it's not my work, but I also want to help.
Here is a link to the file: 4CamNex2.zip
This is the stock camera for the Nexus. All you have to do is flash it in your Recovery (I used TWRP). It has a working photosphere, but is very limited in the settings you can change. For instance, I cannot choose the storage location or HDR or any of the fancy stuff that comes with the LiquidSmooth Rom. You can see my screenshots I just took to see what it looks like.
What I have done to mitigate these limitations is that I kept the LiquidSmooth camera. When I want to use Photosphere (which isn't too often), I use the Nexus Camera, and all other pictures are taken with the Stock LiquidSmooth camera. When I do things like set wallpaper, I have to choose my gallery (two cameras = two galleries), but it's not too much of an issue for me.
Hope this helps, and if anyone can find the original thread with this camera, let me know and I'll link it (and remove my dropbox link). I want to give props to whoever created it.
So are the pics quality better with this camera mod compared to whats in liquid smooth ??
Hello. I was wondering if the quality of the camera is any different(not as good) on aosp then stock samsung software? When i had my galaxy s2 there was a noticeable diffrrence in the focusing area. Thanks
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
xamadeix said:
Hello. I was wondering if the quality of the camera is any different(not as good) on aosp then stock samsung software? When i had my galaxy s2 there was a noticeable diffrrence in the focusing area. Thanks
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i am running aokp 4.1.2 with a flashed port of the 4.2 camera. i installed the 4.2 camera simply because the camera app itself on the 4.1.2 rom was very bland and almost outdated. havent had any issues with the new camera and enjoy how well it works. zoom, focus, shutter speed, etc.
i say all this to let you know that there are other options once you've gone aosp-based. cheers
Imo the Samsung camera is better, I have stuck with touch wiz roms for that reason and simply installed the aosp camera and gallery as well, for sphere (the aosp gallery is better for viewing sphere) you will have two camera and gallery, no issues, give it a try:thumbup:
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Both take pictures at the same resolution. If you look on a computer, the pictures look the same, no difference between TW and ASOP. The only difference that I can see is that photos are presented clearer on the phone with TW more than on ASOP. However, after the picture is taken, you wouldn't be able to tell which rom it came from.
Yeah. Ive noticed differences in the detail area. And how well the camera focuses with touchwiz roms vs aosp. Its very weird.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
zubrug said:
Imo the Samsung camera is better, I have stuck with touch wiz roms for that reason and simply installed the aosp camera and gallery as well, for sphere (the aosp gallery is better for viewing sphere) you will have two camera and gallery, no issues, give it a try:thumbup:
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
which rom are you using? i tried many different roms, CM, aokp, and one TW rom but not happy with camera. S3 camera is pretty decent but i'm not quite happy with ANY rom yet, in terms of camera performance. very slow to zoom, blurry display, unnecessary flash focus, slow to take shots... just went back to stock rom for now.. until i i find a good rom with good cam support.
on the stock rom, shots are real quick. good display.
From everything i have ever seen and read... Samsung's camera is closed source. Anything AOSP/AOKP is never going to be AS good, unless Samsung makes their drivers open source. Touchwiz ROMs utilize the Samsung closed source camera libs.
Either way, I don't really see much of a difference, and I really have no idea as to what the big differences are. There don't really appear to be any huge differences. FWIW I'm on Task650's AOKP ROM.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
One thing you should be aware of is that video recording on aosp rom will have very low volume
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
TW vs AOSP GS3 Camera Image Quality
xamadeix said:
Hello. I was wondering if the quality of the camera is any different(not as good) on aosp then stock samsung software? When i had my galaxy s2 there was a noticeable diffrrence in the focusing area. Thanks
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I noticed coming from Stock TW GS3 that the AOKP 4.22 camera was .... grainy. I did some research and it turns out that the Samsung software takes better advantage of the camera hardware that AOSP cannot by design replicated.
I LOVED AOKP 4.22, but I have a baby and good pics are important, so I flash HyperDrive RS14 because it offers BOTH cameras.
AOSP with photosphere AND the stock TW camera. The "stock" TW camera is largely the same but has been modified. Nevertheless, the TW camera provides MUCH better quality.
Here are two pics, each take at the same time and place with the FLASH on . Both set to 8 mp.
The darker one is the HyperDrive RS14 ROM TW cam.
The pics actually were taken farther out, this is just a screenshot of zoomed in to show clarity.
TW hyperdrive rom cam
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B1CyR6ybaCzPemh3SUptTkt1Skk/edit?usp=sharing
AOSP hyperdrive rom (same as AOKP quality)
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B1CyR6ybaCzPb1MyQ205WjVGTFE/edit?usp=sharing
Current: HyperDrive RS14
Recent AOKP 4.22
Stock
garvus said:
I noticed coming from Stock TW GS3 that the AOKP 4.22 camera was .... grainy. I did some research and it turns out that the Samsung software takes better advantage of the camera hardware that AOSP cannot by design replicated.
I LOVED AOKP 4.22, but I have a baby and good pics are important, so I flash HyperDrive RS14 because it offers BOTH cameras.
AOSP with photosphere AND the stock TW camera. The "stock" TW camera is largely the same but has been modified. Nevertheless, the TW camera provides MUCH better quality.
Here are two pics, each take at the same time and place with the FLASH on . Both set to 8 mp.
The darker one is the HyperDrive RS14 ROM TW cam.
The pics actually were taken farther out, this is just a screenshot of zoomed in to show clarity.
TW hyperdrive rom cam
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B1CyR6ybaCzPemh3SUptTkt1Skk/edit?usp=sharing
AOSP hyperdrive rom (same as AOKP quality)
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B1CyR6ybaCzPb1MyQ205WjVGTFE/edit?usp=sharing
Current: HyperDrive RS14
Recent AOKP 4.22
Stock
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The differences in those photos is far more than camera apps... the one that is claimed AOSP is out of focus and blown out, it looks as if exposure was set as high as it would go... the Sammy photo looks like it is properly exposed and focused... there is more going on in this comparison than just TW vs. AOSP...
If I switch to stock android, will the picture and video quality be the same as it would be in touchwiz? I want to make the switch to stock android, but a fully functioning camera is important to me. I need the best video and picture quality thats possible on this hardware.
I actually like the aosp camera app more as far as photo quality/accuracy. The colors look way more accurate with the aosp camera. As far as functionality everything works great. I'm on slim ROM 2.2
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
I like the touchwiz camera better, I always experienced better quality and overall picture once you set it to the right settings.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk