I am trying to find a SIP client that works on CM10.1 over wifi. I have tried the following:
CSipSimple(latest trunk): whenever I try to make a call it unregisters an re-registers so nothing happens. When I try to receive a call it unregisters and re-registers.
SIPDroid: Try to make an outgoing call and for some reason it goes to the lockscreen while making the call. If the other end picks up I hear nothing and I have to force stop the app to end the call. With an incoming call the same thing happens. Locks the screen, I try to answer and it's dead air on both ends and the only way to end the call is to force stop.
Zoiper: It registers but there is no audio either way on incoming calls. On outgoing calls I can hear the other party but they can't hear me. I have the codecs set correctly.
Has anyone gotten SIP/VOIP to work on this phone with CM10.1?
jfd3220 said:
I am trying to find a SIP client that works on CM10.1 over wifi. I have tried the following:
CSipSimple(latest trunk): whenever I try to make a call it unregisters an re-registers so nothing happens. When I try to receive a call it unregisters and re-registers.
SIPDroid: Try to make an outgoing call and for some reason it goes to the lockscreen while making the call. If the other end picks up I hear nothing and I have to force stop the app to end the call. With an incoming call the same thing happens. Locks the screen, I try to answer and it's dead air on both ends and the only way to end the call is to force stop.
Zoiper: It registers but there is no audio either way on incoming calls. On outgoing calls I can hear the other party but they can't hear me. I have the codecs set correctly.
Has anyone gotten SIP/VOIP to work on this phone with CM10.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same issue here. every sip I throw it in failed. Vonage mobile also failed. The only voip apps that I know works is grooveip.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda premium
I have gotten it to work and use it pretty extensively. I use csipsimple with pbxes.org but I don't use their gateway because I have had the problems you have described with them. Instead I use simontelephonics gateway with pbxes.org. My sets up is kinda complicated though because I have two lines and two gateways that I'm useing
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
What ROM are you using? I'm using the CM 10.1 nightly from a few days ago. I've tried PBXes.org and I get the same issue. When I try to make an outgoing call it unregisters and then registers again a few seconds later but the call is never made.
jfd3220 said:
I am trying to find a SIP client that works on CM10.1 over wifi. I have tried the following:
CSipSimple(latest trunk): whenever I try to make a call it unregisters an re-registers so nothing happens. When I try to receive a call it unregisters and re-registers.
SIPDroid: Try to make an outgoing call and for some reason it goes to the lockscreen while making the call. If the other end picks up I hear nothing and I have to force stop the app to end the call. With an incoming call the same thing happens. Locks the screen, I try to answer and it's dead air on both ends and the only way to end the call is to force stop.
Zoiper: It registers but there is no audio either way on incoming calls. On outgoing calls I can hear the other party but they can't hear me. I have the codecs set correctly.
Has anyone gotten SIP/VOIP to work on this phone with CM10.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
3cx phone works.. Sure wish csipsimple was working though
jfd3220 said:
I am trying to find a SIP client that works on CM10.1 over wifi. I have tried the following:
CSipSimple(latest trunk): whenever I try to make a call it unregisters an re-registers so nothing happens. When I try to receive a call it unregisters and re-registers.
SIPDroid: Try to make an outgoing call and for some reason it goes to the lockscreen while making the call. If the other end picks up I hear nothing and I have to force stop the app to end the call. With an incoming call the same thing happens. Locks the screen, I try to answer and it's dead air on both ends and the only way to end the call is to force stop.
Zoiper: It registers but there is no audio either way on incoming calls. On outgoing calls I can hear the other party but they can't hear me. I have the codecs set correctly.
Has anyone gotten SIP/VOIP to work on this phone with CM10.1?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do a lot of VOIP work and it almost sounds like you don't have the ports open to your phone box. If you're on asterisk TCP/UDP 5060-5080 and UDP 10001-20000 to get audio to work. Just a stab into the dark.
Just found one that works with CM10.1 (I'm on 06/02/2013nightly), MizuDroid. Works great so far and has tons of options!
djxs said:
Just found one that works with CM10.1 (I'm on 06/02/2013nightly), MizuDroid. Works great so far and has tons of options!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice find! Seems to be working for me too!
jfd3220 said:
Nice find! Seems to be working for me too!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As you might already know, you have to change some Sound settings first, especially if you want calls through the ear piece. I believe this is why the built-in SIP client in CM10.1 doesn't work, it's using the wrong audio inputs/outputs.
The Audio recorder should be set to use the mic, not default or auto guess (Voice call, Voice downlink, Voice uplink, Voice communication don't work either). The Audio player to use System sounds (only option that routes the call through the ear piece). Speakerphone player is set to Music playback, and Speakerphone output to Speaker Forced, although Speaker works also.
Groove IP works.
Csipsimple doesnt.
djxs said:
As you might already know, you have to change some Sound settings first, especially if you want calls through the ear piece. I believe this is why the built-in SIP client in CM10.1 doesn't work, it's using the wrong audio inputs/outputs.
The Audio recorder should be set to use the mic, not default or auto guess (Voice call, Voice downlink, Voice uplink, Voice communication don't work either). The Audio player to use System sounds (only option that routes the call through the ear piece). Speakerphone player is set to Music playback, and Speakerphone output to Speaker Forced, although Speaker works also.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your tips proven to be right. the only sip client can be configured like that is mizudroid. Finally I jump into 4.2.2 boat. Thanks.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
I got csipsimple to work by changing the following option:
Settings (Expert) > Media > Audio Troubleshooting > Audio Implementation > change from OpenSL-ES to Java
Apparently CM10's OpenSL-ES doesn't work.
tsuda said:
I got csipsimple to work by changing the following option:
Settings (Expert) > Media > Audio Troubleshooting > Audio Implementation > change from OpenSL-ES to Java
Apparently CM10's OpenSL-ES doesn't work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Another great tips! I am using the latest nightly version on 4.2.2. Sip call seems to be working great
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
Related
Looking to see who else out there is using Groove IP and what settings you have found to work the best. I can't seem to pin down the right combo so I am going to try crowdsourcing.
http://snrblabs.com/snrb/grooveIp.aspx
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.gvoip&hl=en
Are you having issues w/ sound distortion over WiFi?
The default settings work fine on most devices, and the changes I've made are minor.
Using version 1.2.21:
-Allow 3G/4G calling
-Accept calls on answer
-turned off DTMF feedback under Audio/Echo settings
-turned on Keep Screen On and Sync Voice under Troubleshooting
What are your Speaker and Mic gain settings? I am only calling over WiFi
Phillip Fry said:
What are your Speaker and Mic gain settings? I am only calling over WiFi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Speaker vol: 10
Mic gain (bluetooth as well): 0
Echo Cancellation: On, with Auto Detect
I haven't noticed any issues on my end by tweaking these settings, but can also say things worked fairly well on default.
Phillip Fry said:
What are your Speaker and Mic gain settings? I am only calling over WiFi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What kind of issues are you running into? Defaults should be good for the Galaxy Nexus. One thing to watch out for is by default the Galaxy Nexus puts the wifi into a power saving state when the screen turns off. You can change that from the android settings->wifi settings->advanced wifi settings, or enable Keep Screen Alive in GrooVe IP.
I get noticeable lags using Groove IP on my Galaxy Nexus. The extent varies - it's sometimes less than half a second, but often close to two seconds. Happens both incoming and outgoing. I am using the default settings except for the volume. If this matters, the lag is there both on Wi-Fi and 3G.
Phone: Galaxy Nexus (GSM Unlocked)
Carrier: T-Mobile
Region: Seattle
Any advice would be appreciated.
daihard said:
I get noticeable lags using Groove IP on my Galaxy Nexus. The extent varies - it's sometimes less than half a second, but often close to two seconds. Happens both incoming and outgoing. I am using the default settings except for the volume. If this matters, the lag is there both on Wi-Fi and 3G.
Phone: Galaxy Nexus (GSM Unlocked)
Carrier: T-Mobile
Region: Seattle
Any advice would be appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Few things can cause lag. First would be latency on the data connection. Apps running on the device that use cpu or data...or battery manager or task killer apps could also cause problems with calls. We are also working on a new update that should improve the in-app delay for audio. On our Galaxy Nexus it seems to work pretty good so far. I think we'll have a beta for it ready sometime this weekend. We'll likely be posting it on our facebook page when it's ready. Oh, something on the device going into a power saving state would also cause delay. Keep Screen Alive can help with that.
snrb Labs said:
Few things can cause lag. First would be latency on the data connection. Apps running on the device that use cpu or data...or battery manager or task killer apps could also cause problems with calls. We are also working on a new update that should improve the in-app delay for audio. On our Galaxy Nexus it seems to work pretty good so far. I think we'll have a beta for it ready sometime this weekend. We'll likely be posting it on our facebook page when it's ready. Oh, something on the device going into a power saving state would also cause delay. Keep Screen Alive can help with that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the update! I will await the new beta version. I'll keep an eye out on your FB page.
Besides the Keep Screen Alive option, are there other options that may help reduce the lag? I see things like Synchronize Voice and Mic Buffer. For instance, will it reduce delay if I change the Mic Buffer size from medium (default) to small?
Thanks again!
daihard said:
Thanks for the update! I will await the new beta version. I'll keep an eye out on your FB page.
Besides the Keep Screen Alive option, are there other options that may help reduce the lag? I see things like Synchronize Voice and Mic Buffer. For instance, will it reduce delay if I change the Mic Buffer size from medium (default) to small?
Thanks again!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Synchronize Voice can help, I don't really use it on the Nexus. Changing the mic buffer to small should also help, that's one of the things we're changing. Small seems still too large. So we're going to be adjusting small to be smaller and make it the default.
snrb Labs said:
Synchronize Voice can help, I don't really use it on the Nexus. Changing the mic buffer to small should also help, that's one of the things we're changing. Small seems still too large. So we're going to be adjusting small to be smaller and make it the default.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks! I will make adjustments to those settings to see how it goes.
I wonder if there is plan to support more than one google voice login in Grooveip soon? Something that we can switch from one to another quickly?
testrider said:
I wonder if there is plan to support more than one google voice login in Grooveip soon? Something that we can switch from one to another quickly?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Might not be soon but it is something we're working on. Right now you can switch users pretty quickly by going into the menu and pressing change user. But that's not the same as supporting multiple accounts. Battery life is also an issue with multiple sign ins, still working on it.
Hey is this beta or new version addressing the latency available yet? I have an Epic Touch 4G & have tried everything (spoken to support repeatedly over email - thanks!) & still get 1-2 second delay. Difficult to have a normal conversation as we keep cutting each other off as we think we're done speaking.
snrb Labs said:
Might not be soon but it is something we're working on. Right now you can switch users pretty quickly by going into the menu and pressing change user. But that's not the same as supporting multiple accounts. Battery life is also an issue with multiple sign ins, still working on it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
elcidroyale said:
Hey is this beta or new version addressing the latency available yet? I have an Epic Touch 4G & have tried everything (spoken to support repeatedly over email - thanks!) & still get 1-2 second delay. Difficult to have a normal conversation as we keep cutting each other off as we think we're done speaking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The latest version on the market has all our improvements for latency. There will still be latency from your network or from the device. Stopping apps running in the background can improve the device latency.
Well I downloaded that version and most of that lag seems to be gone. Yippee!
elcidroyale said:
Well I downloaded that version and most of that lag seems to be gone. Yippee!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Glad that improved things. Thanks for the update.
I just purchased this after months of debate. Are there any settings to reduce the static on the other caller's end? I did some test calls with a friend's phone, except I was holding both devices in each hand. It doesn't matter who initiates the call, but they'll hear a static noise that doesn't happen if the call is made via mobile network. Could very well be Google Voice itself because people have mentioned it to me before before I purchased Groove IP, but I just want to be sure.
Also, sending and receiving bluetooth calls do work through my car stereo. But if I'm receiving a call, something is missing to tell the radio to pause/mute the music and start the ringer. The phone itself still rings and vibrates, but it's easy to miss a call if the music is loud enough. Is there an additional setting I'm missing? The function works properly if I'm using the regular phone app.
binglejellsx2 said:
I just purchased this after months of debate. Are there any settings to reduce the static on the other caller's end? I did some test calls with a friend's phone, except I was holding both devices in each hand. It doesn't matter who initiates the call, but they'll hear a static noise that doesn't happen if the call is made via mobile network. Could very well be Google Voice itself because people have mentioned it to me before before I purchased Groove IP, but I just want to be sure.
Also, sending and receiving bluetooth calls do work through my car stereo. But if I'm receiving a call, something is missing to tell the radio to pause/mute the music and start the ringer. The phone itself still rings and vibrates, but it's easy to miss a call if the music is loud enough. Is there an additional setting I'm missing? The function works properly if I'm using the regular phone app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The static could be because both phones were in close proximity to each other. Have you tried it with normal calls?
For incoming calls were you using the native music app or another app like pandora? We broadcast that a call is being made or received, the native music app should detect that, but an app like pandora may not since the app isn't the same as the native phone system.
snrb Labs said:
The static could be because both phones were in close proximity to each other. Have you tried it with normal calls?
For incoming calls were you using the native music app or another app like pandora? We broadcast that a call is being made or received, the native music app should detect that, but an app like pandora may not since the app isn't the same as the native phone system.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean to a landline? I haven't. I did try with another person a few hundred feet away with the same results. I also talked to someone else for a few seconds, but the only thing they asked was if I was whispering. After I had posted on here, I changed my settings to the ones recommended from the "other" forum: http://rootzwiki.com/topic/32464-voip-apps/page__st__10#entry902020. My voice was probably just low due to the low mic gain setting, but I'll leave things the way they are until I get more comments from people's calls.
As for the bluetooth issue, I'm not using my phone to play music. The music is through the radio, which utilizes bluetooth to make phone calls. Normal operation of incoming calls cuts the audio and rings through the car speakers until I pick up. With Groove IP calls enabled, only the phone is ringing and the music/car audio is still playing (which is usually louder than the phone's ringer). Hope that clears things up a little.
Happy Holidays!
While on a call, particularly speaker, is there no way to disable the keypress sound only during a call without doing it via the sound toggle or manually doing it in the settings? Doesn't seem to make any sense that certain sounds wouldn't automatically turn off so the caller wouldn't hear them. My previous HTC Hero did this automatically.
[Sent from my cellular telephone via wireless transmission]
I have found this to be annoying as well. I have noticed that I have have my phone set on Vibrate (no sounds normally produced) and if I am on a call and an email or SMS comes in I get a notification sound. For some reason the sounds that are silenced when I am not on a call are produced when I am in a call.
I wish I knew of a solution to this issue.
m20120 said:
I have found this to be annoying as well. I have noticed that I have have my phone set on Vibrate (no sounds normally produced) and if I am on a call and an email or SMS comes in I get a notification sound. For some reason the sounds that are silenced when I am not on a call are produced when I am in a call.
I wish I knew of a solution to this issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This might work for you:
Phone>Call Settings>Call alert>Uncheck "Alerts on call"
Now help me fix my problem and we're even.
Since I ported my number into Google Voice, I have been using Hangouts Dialer as my go-to voice service on my S3. My calls will usually connect after a 3-5 second pause. I can then hear the other person crystal clear, but they can only hear my voice garbled and extremely low volume. It doesn't matter if I'm on WiFi or mobile data. It doesn't matter if I make the call or receive the call. I am currently using PAC-man ROM 4.4.4.RC-3. Does anyone else have this issue or know how to solve it? Is there anyone who has been using Hangouts Dialer regularly that does not have this issue that can maybe help? Thank you!
OK, so after further testing I have discovered that Hangouts is using the wrong microphone for audio. It seems to be using the speakerphone microphone (at the top of the phone) instead of the handset microphone at the bottom. Is there any way to switch the microphone that is being used for just this application?
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nll.acr&hl=en
Confirmed to work perfectly with the S6 Edge on T-mobile. Can't speak if it works on other carriers, I don't see why it wouldn't. Auto records both sides clearly with no root access needed.
LIVEFRMNYC said:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nll.acr&hl=en
Confirmed to work perfectly with the S6 Edge on T-mobile. Can't speak if it works on other carriers, I don't see why it wouldn't. Auto records both sides clearly with no root access needed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It doesn't record wifi calls however.
btothec said:
It doesn't record wifi calls however.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just tested wifi calling. It recorded just fine. Both parties are clearly audible using wifi calling.
I made about 5 short calls. The only difference I noticed was my voice was noticeable lower(but still very audible) than the person on the other end when I played it back. When I turn off wifi calling, volume from both sides are equal when played back.
LIVEFRMNYC said:
Just tested wifi calling. It recorded just fine. Both parties are clearly audible using wifi calling.
I made about 5 short calls. The only difference I noticed was my voice was noticeable lower(but still very audible) than the person on the other end when I played it back. When I turn off wifi calling, volume from both sides are equal when played back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well that is great news. He must have updated the app. I tested all of the known working apps when I first got this phone and none of them worked with wifi calling. I will test it out again. Thanks for the update!
LIVEFRMNYC said:
Just tested wifi calling. It recorded just fine. Both parties are clearly audible using wifi calling.
I made about 5 short calls. The only difference I noticed was my voice was noticeable lower(but still very audible) than the person on the other end when I played it back. When I turn off wifi calling, volume from both sides are equal when played back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well just like before this doesn't work. When trying to make a wifi call it will randomly stop the call as soon as it begins, or it will simply not record it. Did you do anything to get this to work?
btothec said:
Well just like before this doesn't work. When trying to make a wifi call it will randomly stop the call as soon as it begins, or it will simply not record it. Did you do anything to get this to work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, Left everything as it is. Works fine. Do you have another record call app installed?
LIVEFRMNYC said:
Nope, Left everything as it is. Works fine. Do you have another record call app installed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have call recorder installed, but I disabled recording on it when I tested this. It does the same thing that callrecorder does when trying to record wifi calls.
So just to clarify, you have a t-mobile galaxy s6 edge, and you are connected to wifi and calling over wifi with the built in wifi calling feature correct?
btothec said:
I have call recorder installed, but I disabled recording on it when I tested this. It does the same thing that callrecorder does when trying to record wifi calls.
So just to clarify, you have a t-mobile galaxy s6 edge, and you are connected to wifi and calling over wifi with the built in wifi calling feature correct?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct, tmobile s6 edge, and I have the wifi calling settings set to "Wi-Fi Preferred". I'm connected to my own wifi router. I'm recording in 3GP audio format. Record on Bluetooth is set to on. Everything else is pretty much stock settings.
I just tried WiFi calling and it didn't record. Not a big issue with me anyways.
My problem is with the speakerphone. No matter which app I use, and no matter that I am rooted, when I record a call in speakerphone mode, my own voice is hardly audible when the recording is played. The other voice is quite clear in all recordings, but mine is barely audible. On non-speakerphone mode, all works well. But, speakerphone, forget about it.
Anyone else have this problem?
FunbunzSF said:
I just tried WiFi calling and it didn't record. Not a big issue with me anyways.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe it has something to do with network speed? I'm going to try wifi calling on different networks and see the results.
[email protected] said:
My problem is with the speakerphone. No matter which app I use, and no matter that I am rooted, when I record a call in speakerphone mode, my own voice is hardly audible when the recording is played. The other voice is quite clear in all recordings, but mine is barely audible. On non-speakerphone mode, all works well. But, speakerphone, forget about it.
Anyone else have this problem?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, same thing here. My voice when using speaker phone is also barely audible, the other side is loud and clear. If you go to the settings within the app and select a different recording format, some formats allow you to adjust the audio gain. The default recording format of 3GP doesn't. But the OGG, WAV, FLAC, and other formats allow adjusting the gain. Although, other formats will take up more space. You should give that a try.
.
Call Recorder ACR work fine for me..
Well I spent hours on this and I cannot get it to work. In addition to not recording calls it seems to not allow me to make a wifi call at all simply dropping the call right when I make it 90% of the time.
Never have been able to record a WiFi call with this and I've been using it for years. Sent dev an email asking if it will support WiFi call recording soon? If not, I'm going to have to find something else.
I noticed what could be a bug regarding bluetooth and voice dialing. When the screen is locked and I use voice dial it would always route the call to the speaker phone instead of the Bluetooth. After doing some digging I noticed this happens when I have media unchecked. When I have media check it wouldn't route my calls to the speaker phone. This is very annoying and I don't know what to do to fix it. I don't always want to have media checked because I don't like having notifications playing in my ear all the time.
Kingaries79 said:
I noticed what could be a bug regarding bluetooth and voice dialing. When the screen is locked and I use voice dial it would always route the call to the speaker phone instead of the Bluetooth. After doing some digging I noticed this happens when I have media unchecked. When I have media check it wouldn't route my calls to the speaker phone. This is very annoying and I don't know what to do to fix it. I don't always want to have media checked because I don't like having notifications playing in my ear all the time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have same issue with the same headset. It does not do it all the time.
It's very annoying
Kingaries79 said:
It's very annoying
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
why do you want it to go threw speaker phone if your using your bluetooth.
wouldn't you want the calls to go threw the bluetooth?