I m on my third otterbox defender case (they send them to you by mail if you have problems). With all of them the outer rubber sleeve has stretched so that it no longer stays in the grooves.
So I am looking for a new case. I could use some suggestions.
Thanks.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
I've been using the OtterBox Commuter Series since I got the phone. No issues so far.
Urban Armor Gear. By far the best case for the GS3 if you are looking for protection without adding thickness to the phone. You can find about 1,250 posts regarding this case here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1826668
shaker2k said:
I m on my third otterbox defender case (they send them to you by mail if you have problems). With all of them the outer rubber sleeve has stretched so that it no longer stays in the grooves.
So I am looking for a new case. I could use some suggestions.
Thanks.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on my second defender for the same reason. Commuter is the way to go.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
Seidio ACTIVE with kickstand
This Seidio case is the one I use. I've dropped it several times, and it has a few nicks and scuffs on it. Love it, though, as it is very durable, and seems to maintain its fit very well.
Also, the white/black case looks really nice with my white SGS3. :laugh:
I use an Aduro hardshell case with kickstand, it's awesome. I've dropped it plenty of times and not a scratch on it!
Do you use any cleaners on your Defender? I have run into problems with using plastic cleaners (even good ones like Plexus!) with some phone cases where it allows it to become too soft and stretches it.
TechJunkie14 said:
I've been using the OtterBox Commuter Series since I got the phone. No issues so far.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Me too. I even somehow cracked the shell part and they sent me a new one. I haven't opened it yet.
Stretched out cases are a problem in the materials i think. I've saw it on my Captivate, Inspire, and now S3. But they keep replacing, so I'll keep using. I haven't really saw or heard of a sturdier case, short of the new Armor series.
i've always used case-mate's "tough case" on my galaxy phones. great protection while still remaining slim. also, otterbox has the new reflex case. i would recommend that one as well. slim and tough. you can find both on amazon for around $20. cheers
case-mate tough case: http://www.case-mate.com/Samsung-Galaxy-S-III-Cases/Case-Mate-Samsung-Galaxy-S3-Tough-Cases.asp
otterbox reflex: http://www.otterbox.com/Samsung-Galaxy-S3-Reflex-Series/sam7-galaxy-s3,default,pd.html
Commuter in black, Commuter in white, and Spigen Ultra Thin Air...
Otterbox Defender. Since they replace it once it stretches out with no problems I will continue to use it.
My defender silicon case has stretched out before. I simply placed in boiling water (OFF THE BURNER) for exactly thirty seconds. Remove it with tongs and quickly, yet gently dry it off. Mold it to the plastic case and place it in the fridge to cool.
Perform at your own risk. Your experience may vary.
I use the Urban Armor Gear. It is the best case IMO. I had the Otterbox Commuter, and the CaseMate Pop! Nothing beats the Urban Armor Gear. I love how it makes the phone square and flat and not curved. And idk why, but it makes my screen look bigger. It looks huge and bulky in the product photos but it's really thin.
I'm using a Trident Kraken. I love it more than my Defender.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
im using this http://www.ebay.com/itm/White-TPU-C...261814?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item460c7d7ef6
bought the case alone a while back when it was only 2 dollars
Zoogue black om white gs3 along with seidio holster
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Currently running a black Incipio silicrylic. Yesterday I purchased a black UAG based on the reviews of it and it should be here tomorrow.
I use a Seidio Surface case and love it. It's a hard shell, but not so thick that it can't be used in some docks. Soft-touch coating so it's easy to grip. And it has cutouts around the buttons (I like using the actual buttons on the phone, not the crappy ones that most cases include). The only downside is it's TOUGH to get off if you don't know the trick (apparently, I can't vouch for that since I STILL can't do it easily).
http://www.seidioonline.com/samsung-galaxy-s-iii-surface-case-black-p/csr3ssgs3-bk.htm
I have the defender as well. I also notice the rubber stretching a little bit. Once it gets a little more noticeable I will ask otterbox to replace it. They have great customer service. I experienced this with the galaxy nexus defender case as well. They sent me 3 replacements before I gave up and settled with the commuter for the nexus.
So long as they continue to send replacements, I'll continue to take advantage of it. Personal opinion they should really make the rubber last longer. My defender for my captivate lasted almost two years before I replaced the phone. The case still fits perfect to this day. Something happened within the last few years with otterboxs rubber casing for the defender. Whatever they have changed since the captivate has not worked out very well.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
---------- Post added at 11:09 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:07 AM ----------
In addition, if I were to try a different case, it would be the pure gear dual tek case. I've read good things about it!
Sent from my SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
Otterbox commuter with a brand new one at work still in box. My 2 year old child has chucked my phone over and over without any damage. Otterbox for life!
Related
Ok I like how the commuter case is somewhat slim and it maintains the original form factor of the phone giving it a lower profile but giving it great protection. I also like how the Aegis has more options for color although it looks a little thicker. Which one should i go for?
I like the defender personally
I have a commuter case I'm selling if your interested? Pm me for details
Sent from my ADR6350 using xda premium
I have had the commuter for a couple of months and it is a great case. I've dropped my inc2 a couple of times with no ill effects. The only complaint I might have is that the headphone jack is a little recessed, so a 90 degree plug doesn't work too well, but a 45 and a straight plug work just fine. Pretty minor complaint.
I like that the seal of the case is enough that I don't get crap built up around the edge of the screen and in the ports like tends to happen with cheap cases.
I use an invisible shield brand screen protector (the only kind I will use - lifetime warranty and no bubbles! Harder to put on...).
If you look on Amazon, you can get the case for about 1/2 price or less, and the shield for the same amount. Including shipping, it came to less than 40 for my setup.
I use the commuter. Without any screen protector. I just love the feeling of the screen. Nothing getting in the way ya know? It is gorilla glass, but take your chances of your own accord.
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA App
seventystangfan said:
I use the commuter. Without any screen protector. I just love the feeling of the screen. Nothing getting in the way ya know? It is gorilla glass, but take your chances of your own accord.
Sent from my ADR6350 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here
Sent from my Incredible 2 using XDA App
the aegis looks and feels great!
I had a blue Aegis case I loved it at first then crap would always get behind the screen protector that the case has and then the corners started breaking and not clipping together anymore, I am back to zagg and cheap hybrid case this case I can't complain about http://www.ebay.com/itm/HTC-6350-IN...ccessories&hash=item1c1bcbd6b4#ht_1789wt_1037 I have mine in red is all. I just ordered a otterbox commuter though so I have high expectations for the otterbox. if not ill go back to my ebay hybrid case. it isn't rubbery it is hard inside but soft to touch on outside so it can slide on not snap together.
coley909 said:
I had a blue Aegis case I loved it at first then crap would always get behind the screen protector that the case has and then the corners started breaking and not clipping together anymore, I am back to zagg and cheap hybrid case this case I can't complain about http://www.ebay.com/itm/HTC-6350-IN...ccessories&hash=item1c1bcbd6b4#ht_1789wt_1037 I have mine in red is all. I just ordered a otterbox commuter though so I have high expectations for the otterbox. if not ill go back to my ebay hybrid case. it isn't rubbery it is hard inside but soft to touch on outside so it can slide on not snap together.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use a different screen protector...the case itself is pretty darn good.
Sent from my Incredible 2 using xda premium
I am also tied between the Commuter and the Trident Aegis since my Incipio SILICRYLIC case broke..by looking at the Aegis pictures, it looks like it covers up the Notification LED for sure, and it looks close to the front-facing camera..Is this a problem for any of the owners?
rjason09 said:
I am also tied between the Commuter and the Trident Aegis since my Incipio SILICRYLIC case broke..by looking at the Aegis pictures, it looks like it covers up the Notification LED for sure, and it looks close to the front-facing camera..Is this a problem for any of the owners?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does cover up the LED but the front facing camera is not covered at all. Hope that helps
Sent from my Incredible 2 using xda premium
Commuter
I bought the Otterbox Commuter from Newegg, and so far I like it. It slips out of your pocket really easily because the back is slippery, more slippery than the back of the phone in my opinion. I wish the silicon was tighter on the phone, but it is still tighter and a better case than my old incipio.
I wouldn't get the trident I just took mine off and threw it in the trash after busting 3 of the belt holsters and having to constantly put the thing back together. I ordered a seido off of amazon.
The Commuter felt too slippery for me. I always felt like my phone was going to slip out of my hands unless I used two hands.
I have had the Otterbox defender on since day one. And it protects great. Today i took it off to swap my battery and remembered how great this phone looks without it. But I'm not one to go unprotected.
I'm looking for suggestions on other cases. Something that protects but necessarily the bulk of the Otterbox. I work a office job so rugged case isn't too necessary.
Must be compatible with the extended battery.
I was looking at the SGP Neo hybrid cases but they say coming soon on the website.
Please share your suggestions. Thanks guys.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
Hey, i have the commuter case on for a few days now and i love it. It adds just enough bulk and size to the phone to make is sit and feel perfect in my hand. But everyones hands are different so not all will think its great. I did however order the Neo Hybrid case in Reventon yellow and should have it tomorrow or saturday and ill let you know how it is and feels along with some pics, and possibly a small review.
But so far i LOVE the commuter case. should take a look at it. i wrote up a review but i have to do a few more posts before xda lets me post it lol
I have the Otterbox Defender as well and am surprised at how much I like it... Typically like nothing on my phones but gotta have protection on this beauty...
Just got an Incipio Silicrylic in the mail to try... Definitely less bulk than the Otterbox... You can actually see some of the sexy lines of the Nexus with this case.... The Incipio provides some protection, as it does have at least some hard plastic to it, but not anything close to the Otterbox.. Not sure that my GNex would survive a fall on a hard surface in the Incipio....
Problem with the Incipio is that it will not fit in the Otterbox holster or the Verizon holster that I already have, so probably will go back to the OB Defender...
Anybody interested in making me an offer on a brand new Incipio or Verizon Case & Holder I will listen....
One reason for my Otterbox purchase was the holster. But i have never used it. It's too big to have clipped on my side.
I know no case will protect like the defender but im good with my phones to get a scaled down case. I thought about the commuter but not sure how much size difference there is.
What price you looking at for your incipio?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
highflyin128 said:
One reason for my Otterbox purchase was the holster. But i have never used it. It's too big to have clipped on my side.
I know no case will protect like the defender but im good with my phones to get a scaled down case. I thought about the commuter but not sure how much size difference there is.
What price you looking at for your incipio?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's a link to one on Amazon...
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00634HFEQ/ref=oh_o00_s00_i00_details
I ordered mine last weekend and recieved today... Paid $24....now available for $13 so probably your best bet if interested...
StingRay_ said:
Here's a link to one on Amazon...
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00634HFEQ/ref=oh_o00_s00_i00_details
I ordered mine last weekend and recieved today... Paid $24....now available for $13 so probably your best bet if interested...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I watched a review and it said with the extended battery the plastic outer shell just fit tightly against the silicone as it does at the top. Did you notice this?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA App
Fit tight w/extended battery in, but not a problem in my opinion... I would bet it might even loosen up a bit over time...
I like the Incipio's look and feel... Much smaller size than OB, but have to have a holster to carry my GNex..
It doesn't have quite the amount of protection (ie not waterproof) like the defender but soon Ballistic will release their case for the Galaxy Nexus. I have a Galaxy Nexus on the way and will be giving my Nexus S to my wife. My wife is like a phone's worst nightmare. She seems to always be dropping them and my two kids are both under 3 and the oldest loves to snatch our phones. I got the Ballistic case for the Nexus S for her and after putting it on yesterday I'm a believer. I already have it covered completely by Ghost Armor skin, and with the Ballistic case it's just very well protected. The bumpers on the corners are amazing and so is the fit and finish. Makes the phone pretty bulky (not as much as the defender) but it makes the phone much nicer to hold and type on. I would recommend it for the Galaxy Nexus. I have a TPU case on order but will pick up the Galaxy Nexus version Ballistic case too once it is released.
k20igor said:
Hey, i have the commuter case on for a few days now and i love it. It adds just enough bulk and size to the phone to make is sit and feel perfect in my hand. But everyones hands are different so not all will think its great. I did however order the Neo Hybrid case in Reventon yellow and should have it tomorrow or saturday and ill let you know how it is and feels along with some pics, and possibly a small review.
But so far i LOVE the commuter case. should take a look at it. i wrote up a review but i have to do a few more posts before xda lets me post it lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have any quick impressions/pics of the Neo Hybrid? It'll be interesting to see how well it fits the LTE GNex since it was designed for the GSM non-extended battery GNex.
I have the Incipio Silicrylic (aka Double Cover, VZW repackaged). It's a nice case and it fits well on the phone. It doesn't add too much bulk. I like that the hard cover goes around the corners, unlike the Otterbox Commuter. Cutouts for the phone are nice. No need to mess around with clumsy flaps. And the buttons work well under the silicone cover. Great case for less. I got mine at the Verizon store for $20 +tax after a discount. I don't use a holster, but I am looking into getting an XO Skin.
Another alternative that I was initially looking at was the Seidio Surface Combo. It's a hard soft-touch case with a holster, if you need the holster. They also sell it without.
Hey guys,
I had bad luck with my Rezound (5 replacements), so I talked to Verizon and they're sending me a certified Galaxy S3 instead (exchanged phones). I read up on the GS3 though and have heard that the glass is really brittle and will crack/break if you drop it. Well lucky me, I have dropped my previous phones more times than I can count. Despite all the problems I have had with my Rezound, the screen was surprisingly resilient. I have gotten nothing more than scratches to the screen and dent marks where the side of the phone hit the road.
Most of my past drops have been either falling out of my pocket when I'm walking, getting out of my car, or slipping out of my hands when I take it out of my pocket. So now I'm definitely worried about my GS3. I've been looking at many different cases, and I think my top choice so far are the DBA cases:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009ANI712
They seem to be raved about over in the DBA thread, and it looks quite protective, yet slim. They remind me a lot of the commuter series from Otterbox, only that the inside layer is TPU instead of silicone. The only thing that worries me is that if I drop it, the front of the case doesn't raise the screen as high as it does on the Otterbox.
I like a protective case, but after the Commuter, (on my fat Rezound) I really didn't want to add to the thickness. Can you guys recommend me a slimmer case that will protect me from 3-5 ft drops?
Thanks!
Theres a few out there, Urban Armor Gear, Ballistic SG, Ballistic Life Style, I have the seidio surface right now but I wouldnt rely on it for multiple hi drops. Ive dropped it a couple times from bed height without a scratch on it tho.
PS, i ordered the new release for ballistic, called the every1 case, ill get back at u with info next week.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
I recommend the Body glove Rugged in black. Its amazing!! I have it and when I first put it on it felt so thin from my previous case. Its really thin, yet has a lip and great edge drop protection . Sometimes I throw it for fun , lol
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app
1slow4G said:
Theres a few out there, Urban Armor Gear, Ballistic SG, Ballistic Life Style, I have the seidio surface right now but I wouldnt rely on it for multiple hi drops. Ive dropped it a couple times from bed height without a scratch on it tho.
PS, i ordered the new release for ballistic, called the every1 case, ill get back at u with info next week.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm really liking the Urban Armor Gear. What would be more protective, the Urban Armor Gear or the DBA case? Basically both are the same, TPU inner layer with a hard shell covering it, except the UAG is a hybrid (1 piece) while the DBA case has two pieces. They look the same in bulkiness too but what's to be determined is their protection.
What do you guys think?
Honestly the urban armor case would be the wise decision. But i like to clean my phone once and awhike the case was a bit a pain to take off because of it concave shape, so i got myself the rokform case. I like it because i dropped it several times at different speeds and it survive so far. Plus having the magnet works for me and the sbeam does work without fail. And having that built in socket for mounts and ect. Saves me money on car mounts , and using it at a dock in my room. Rokform is my decision im glad i chose.
Asian Powaa!?!?!?!?!?
From sprint gs3
I have 2 uag cases and love them. The new versions have a more flexible tpu which they are easier to install or remove
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
I think you should seriously consider the seidio surface case. I beleive its what youre looking for and it is also very handsome. There is a review of a blue one somewhere on this forum
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
Try taking a look at the Tech21 D3O Impact Mesh case. It's pretty thin and unobtrusive yet provides a nice protection. Here's a link to the one I use. I've been through a bunch of expensive cases and like this one the best by far.
http://www.tech21.uk.com/Product/impact_mesh_samsung_galaxy_siii_Smokey
I use it at work. I work on roof tops and have already dropped my phone off of a one story house and my phone was fully protected. Here's a little advertisement on YouTube.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPEciw3cBss
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Hi guys,
I bought the galaxy nexus.
since i'm in the millitary I want to protect the phone perfectly and I though about the otterbox defender.
BUT I've seen on youtube a video that shows how the case scratchs the top of the device,the bottom and around the front camera.
I wanted to know if there is someone here has the case and could recommend me buying this or not.
thanks
Because the defender's inner frame is hard plastic, debris like sand and dust can become lodged between the frame and the device, causing scratches.
The otter box commuter has a silicon inner layer, and won't have this issue.
If you want a case LIKE the defender, maybe the trident krakken case will work? Its very similar to the defender.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
jordanishere said:
Because the defender's inner frame is hard plastic, debris like sand and dust can become lodged between the frame and the device, causing scratches.
The otter box commuter has a silicon inner layer, and won't have this issue.
If you want a case LIKE the defender, maybe the trident krakken case will work? Its very similar to the defender.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
but the commuter doesnt protect the screen..:/
I bought a OtterBox Defender based on my good experiences with OtterBoxes for iPhone.2 weeks into owning the case,I decided to remove it and found that a lot of dust got accumulated in the the case and the phone was scratched at the top.Not only that,I found out that the plastic frame of the screenguard had broken on one side.I'd advise you to not buy the Defender,instead something like the Trident Kraken.
maschiosoosai said:
I bought a OtterBox Defender based on my good experiences with OtterBoxes for iPhone.2 weeks into owning the case,I decided to remove it and found that a lot of dust got accumulated in the the case and the phone was scratched at the top.Not only that,I found out that the plastic frame of the screenguard had broken on one side.I'd advise you to not buy the Defender,instead something like the Trident Kraken.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you say about ballistic shell gel? Its kinda hard to get this trident in my country.
And thanks for your comment
Eliav said:
What do you say about ballistic shell gel? Its kinda hard to get this trident in my country.
And thanks for your comment
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That ballistic shell case looks pretty good.The Seidio Active is another great case( http://www.seidioonline.com/samsung-galaxy-nexus-active-case-black-p/csk3ssgnlk-bk.htm).I haven't used it though.
Thanks for this thread. I was going to buy one as I do for all of my phones. Bet I've owned six defender cases.
After reading this and the reviews on otterbox.com I think I'll buy a trident case.
I had a ballistic on the infuse I had. Was a nice case.
Eliav said:
What do you say about ballistic shell gel? Its kinda hard to get this trident in my country.
And thanks for your comment
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used the ballistic sg case on my gs2, and my Galaxy Nexus. I was happy with the case. I decided to slim down, so I went with a tpu case.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Balistic cases dont have the port covers, which is a must for me.
The Defender was my first case, I was told in the VZW store that it might scratch the phone due to trapped dust, but it was better than nothing on day 1. I liked it alright but after a few months the clips started breaking, I bought the Kraken as a replacement.
The Kraken is an alright case, a little bulkier than the defender. I liked that it offered the same protection as the Defender, I disliked how the front LED was half covered. In the end - it was too bulky for me to keep it on forever, I would still use it if I wanted some super extra duty protection.
So I got the Commuter, I have had Commuters for my Captivate and Atrix so I am familiar with their design and function. The gnex Commuter is the same as past Commuters, if you've had one before you know how it works. (This is not true for the Defender) I've had the Commuter on for the past 6-8 months and will not be switching again. It DOES protect the screen to an extent, I have dropped my phone allot and there are no blemishes on the phone or screen or Commuter. I do have a Zagg applied, not the protector that comes with the OB. If I had it to do over I would have bought the commuter first and it would have been the only case I needed. It offers plenty of protection with minimal bulk.
Hi, i wanna buy a case for the s3,
i'm Debating between 3 case,
1.speck candy shell
2.otterbox
3.Case Mate Tough
I'd like to hear the Advantages and Disadvantages of each
tnx!
I have owned the otterbox defender and the commuter series. I am much happier with the commuter. It has a dual layer and the exposed layer is hard which I like better because the defender series had a soft shell that streched out and looked bad. Plus the commuter series is much smaller. It feels less bulky and mire high end.
Sent from my SGH-I747 using Tapatalk 2
No for otterbox defender, it streches pretty easily
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
so what yes?
some one told me not for the otterbox becuse it's scrath,the other one told me that is good case.
someone else wrote not for the speck candy i'm Confused more than before
I am assuming you have already looked at the UAG case. If not, definitely check it out. I have a few friends that switched from Otterbox to the UAG and they love it. Good luck
no, i didn't hear about UGA
but he looks a very "massive" case and uncomfortable to carry the s3, put hin in the pocket etc
Not the case at all.
Not nearly as bulky as you'd think, and slides easily in and out of your pocket.
Great protection as well.
Does it have to be drop protection case?
Ive had quite a few. My fav as of now is the zoogue tpu, seidio surface, podera transformer case
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Check out the Case Mate Phantom. It's a bit sleeker than the Otterbox but just as protective.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
Griffin Survivor for drop protection and true dust protection. Mine stays on my hip crawling in basements, crawlspaces and attics everyday. Take the case off and still looks brand new.
Or wait for the Otterbox Armor series... Said to be "this spring", I ain't holding my breath for it though.
Sent from a planet far far away.