Good Day!.
I create this thread not only for me
but for all P350 users.
Because of too many Custom Roms
made by Diff. Developers.
Some of the users really confused.
they always ask, what is the best rom?
Thats why i created this thread to help
others to choose their rom
and get some information to
the others who have experience their roms.
you can vote using poll or
you can rply on this thread.
and answer this question.
"-What is the best rom for you? Why?"
SORRY FOR MY BAD ENGLISH
This thread and poll have been closed
While many of you believe a poll like this might be useful, I do not want things like this to become a popularity contest for ROMs. All ROMs are different and people want different things in their ROMs. While I believe it's useful to compare and contrast the good and bad in all the different ROMs, polls like this are not. Please encourage all developers to pursue their projects and support them if you like their work. Don't let things like this discourage their efforts because they didn't get as many votes as other developers.
If you have any thoughts and concerns about this moderating decision, feel free to send me a PM.
Related
DON'T POST!¡ THREAD IS NOW UNDER CONSTRUCTION!
This thread is about discussing ROMs, mostly reviewing, giving opinions and else. ~~~~~~~~~~~
IF YOU DON'T WANT TO BE BOTHERED BY READING ALL TEXT BELOW, GO TO 2nd POST!
TO SIMPLY UNDERSTAND AND COMPREHEND THIS THREAD
SO YOU MAY BECOME IMPORTANT PART OF THIS DISCUSSION BY GIVING REVIEWS AND OPINIONS!
Hello Guys,
Many people using Android handset confused about making decision on which ROM they will be using for daily activities...
Before flashing they may take a look at others' reviews. The opinions about the ROM are usually posted under ROMs thread, so users can make better judgement before install it depending on what they want it to be. But on some cases, the reviews may not be perfectly honest sometimes on new developed ROMs which have a lot of bugs to at least appreciate the developers, and someone who've tested would rather say honestly in PMs. It's obliously pretty difficult for us to decide whether it's good enough or not. But sometimes, even new, they are good. Happens when the testers make complete review in posts of the ROM's thread.
Hail Open Source, Android lovers!
That is normal, so the users would trust the developers capability. If the bugs are clearly said in the thread, we still can assume that we need opinions. Because every person might say different about something. Nice screenshots aren't enough. In regular ROM thread, we have to search for opinions. No way every posts contained opinions.
Summary, most of the issues which have been said above just happened if the ROMs are still in development. Of course we could undoubtedly trust the proven ones. Issues that have been said above are mostly about newly developed ROMs.
So, to simplify searching and observing the ROMs (mostly the new-developed), we are making this thread. That's what we want to find here and discuss.
You are INVITED here to make reviews about ROM you are using with guides about what to flash and install or with another third party support to make it perfect enough.
Before Starting. . .
There are some points you should know about this thread: ~~~~~~~~~~~
~This thread is made for sharing about ROMs so people could know how and what to do to get a stable, smooth, and suitable ROMs for specific needs of every person. (Customized, Performance-boosted, etc)
~ YOU ARE INVITED to post your experience about specific ROMs in the compilation, and things that might boost performance which added, like Kernels, Fixes or maybe Scripts. But you may suggest unlisted ROM to be published. The post mainly talks about ROMs and the added things like boost are just for supporting the ROMs' capability. YOUR POSTS will be posted below the compilation of ROMs listed (if attractive and important enough, may contained information guides, etc.) The compilation may be limited (it will not be as much as regular compilation of ROMs because it just is including ROMs of Most Users. No kernels. Nothing other than ROMs.) Opinions could be helping. Explanation required. Posted updated at a period of time.
~Before posting, you are expected to read the rules and understand it. Then implement when posting. We expect your obedience for the neatness of the thread.
Here are the rules:
Here are the basic rules, additions will be added if necessary:
»»» The post should obey the Xda Forum Rules. «««
»»» The post shouldn't be offense others, you can say disagree for others' opinions but please make sure the words are good enough to be read and fulfill the politeness. «««
»»» Please post facts, so people will not confuse whether it's real or not. «««
»»» The discussion is expected to be according to the topic. «««
»»» Opinions are the major main problem expected by many people, so don't hesitate yourself by not saying it. It won't be considered spamming at all, we need THIS to be stickied! «««
That settle the problems!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Our object of discussion is. . . Gio!
Gio, as middle devices, has gotten upgrade from Froyo to Gingerbread, and the ported developed ICS rom still seems pretty difficult to be used for daily activities because the problems of camera, and else...
Example, the Cyan9.0, people who want to install it may not know if the camera is not working if they miss the detailed bugs. And because of reading reviews the may know it well. Even though after knowing they might install without any hesitation. But overall, the ROM is perfect enough in stability and everyone has been using it.
And still, this device has many ways in order to make good performance for various user needs.
So? So? So? !?
Let's share all things to make the handset stable and smooth!
REVIEWS AND OPINIONS
Basically we're helping each other to build better ROM.
Because even a genius needs others' helps. . .
So why don't we help if we could.
So let's get started by the compilation.
Here are what the most users would have:
reserved 3
reserved 4
I am not a pro user of these forums, but I would like someone, especially the Mods to make a thread about most popular roms of DHD and let people vote.. It would give one an idea of what rom is trending and what is the most widely used.. Sure would help ignite the competition too ..
If any such thread already exists on this forum, please tell me...
You can do it yourself...and you might be the first one to do so (i havent searched to see if there is one out there already...)
It is not done do the fact we are all tired of hearing the same question over and over again what's the best rom what's a solid stable rom and they all get closed. Each rom works different for everyone. What's good to one is utter crap to another and your topic will only start a flaming war hence the reason why such threads are closed. Only you can tell what's good for you by trying a few out or reading comments on the devs threads. Hmm I think I hear zels footsteps.
Sent from my Ice Cold Inspire 4G
Reinaldo33897 said:
It is not done do the fact we are all tired of hearing the same question over and over again what's the best rom what's a solid stable rom and they all get closed. Each rom works different for everyone. What's good to one is utter crap to another and your topic will only start a flaming war hence the reason why such threads are closed. Only you can tell what's good for you by trying a few out or reading comments on the devs threads. Hmm I think I hear zels footsteps.
Sent from my Ice Cold Inspire 4G
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Might be nice to centralize it though. No comments, just a pure poll. (Not sure if there's a way to do that.) It might cut down on the one-post immediately-closed "which is the best ROM" threads.
A poll with no comments may work.
Sent from my Ice Cold Inspire 4G
Well there is something similar. Its not a poll.. but it gives a pretty decent breakdown on the roms currently available broken down into categories Jellybean, ICS, GB etc. It might help out?
>>> Development List <<<
fallenkirmit said:
Well there is something similar. Its not a poll.. but it gives a pretty decent breakdown on the roms currently available broken down into categories Jellybean, ICS, GB etc. It might help out?
>>> Development List <<<
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I know about that, but I see a lot of threads opened that basically ask "I'm new, what is the most popular/best/favorite ROM?" The index gives a good list of available ROMs, but it doesn't shed a lot of light on how many people use each one, which seems to be what newbies would like to know (to help them decide which to install). Maybe a poll would cut down on such threads. I've PMed a mod to see if such a poll would be well-received.
salman1497 said:
I am not a pro user of these forums, but I would like someone, especially the Mods to make a thread about most popular roms of DHD and let people vote.. It would give one an idea of what rom is trending and what is the most widely used.. Sure would help ignite the competition too ..
If any such thread already exists on this forum, please tell me...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I completely disagree, bcoz u can't compare all the efforts of devs. Every single piece of their work is truly admirable. Whatever they have done is absolutely priceless.
Sent from my HTC Desire HD
I didn't mean that devs work isn't priceless, of course that is commendable!! And its not strict comparing either.. I just meant that one should have idea about new trending romS and also how many people are using which rom.... I know one rom may be excellent for someone and crap for another, have probably flashed more than 100 roms myself. I am just taking about the current trend of roms
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using xda app-developers app
I agree with a poll with no comments, just a simple poll with rom names allowing members to state what they are using, we don't need to know their reasons why.
One thing I don't always understand is people read threads, see what features the rom has but still want other people to tell them.... Just install it and have a look yourself! Most common case I've seen is in the Sabsa Prime thread as it's what I use, people ask for updates and then when one comes along, they ask people to try it out and report back if it's worth updating. Grrrrr!! It's your phone, you want the updates so try it out and see if it suits YOU. Simples.
Sent from my HTC Desire HD using xda premium
I see a lot of talk, but no one stepping in to start a poll? You guys do realize anyone can start poll as a part of the thread!!
ai6908 said:
I see a lot of talk, but no one stepping in to start a poll? You guys do realize anyone can start poll as a part of the thread!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have PMed the mods (since they would need to lock comments) a couple times. No response yet.
The mods say that locking a thread while leaving the poll open is not possible.
bananagranola said:
The mods say that locking a thread while leaving the poll open is not possible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw your PM yesterday and had been giving it some thought. It looks like my co-moderator has contacted you already and let you know that the system will lock the poll as part of closing thread. Even if it was possible to separate the two, I'd be inclined to close down polls like the one you suggest. While some of you might think a poll like this a good idea, it smells a bit too much like a popularity contest.
Some of you may already know that many moderators in other forums have a wholesale ban on "Best ROM" threads. This is because a lot of these threads tend to be a breeding ground for rivalries and disrespecting others' work that can degenerate into infighting and other nastiness. I don't want to be heavy-handed on this topic because I see some benefit to discussions that compare/contrast ROMs and kernels IF they are done objectively and with respect for others. The last part of this is the most important here.
You might have already seen comments that say, "there is no best, try it and see what you like" and that's true. We all have different needs and likes, so there can be no best, but some sharing of knowledge and experiences with various ROMs can be helpful to others. Again, all of this needs to be done objectively and with respect for others. There's already a thread in General with many opinions and nobody's been really causing any trouble there, so I suggest all of you continue those discussions there. Please... no "best" polls.
I'm sorry to threadjack this from the OP, but since the idea has been shot down, I welcome your thoughts on the matter. If you don't want to air it out publicly, my PM box is always open.
kinfauns said:
...(edited for brevity)...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for explaining. I just thought that a more centralized and easy-to-read format would help newbies who are confused when they first see that (seemingly endless) list of ROM threads that is so appealing to those of us who've been around a little longer. But I respect your position and it makes sense. Also, without the comment-locked-forum option, I agree that these types of threads do tend to degenerate.
Is it possible for someone to make a thread about ROM and Kernel benchmarking and comparisons, and make that thread sticky?
A lot of threads like this has come and gone, but I think something revolving around this idea should be kept open and accessible for improvement purposes.
Here are a couple of my ideas:
1. There should be a poll in the thread, which is updated and contains all active ROMs and Kernels
2. All poll stats and old reply posts should be wiped every 2 weeks/ 1 month
3. All voters are expected to leave SMART comments about their vote choice and have actually tried and tested a LOT of ROMs already
4. All developers for ROMs and Kernels should provide a link to this thread, and ask their patronizers to vote and leave comments about their ROMs there.
5. Mods should regularly check the thread for spam posts and delete them.
6. If possible there should be a ROM+Kernel combination which will be awarded "ROM and Kernel" of the week/month.
This is a serious suggestion!
Some positive outcomes of this are:
1. Since its' basically come down to a competition, developers will be ever more diligent in updating their work, making it possible for them to be encouraged to make better ROMs.
2. Many newcomers may come in and "try" to join in on the "competition". (More new devs, and not the poser-kind)
3. Galaxy Younger's can easily have a benchmark on which ROM is currently top notch, especially with the monthly/weekly award.
4. xda's SGY community might possibly increase in population.
5. There is a possibility that some ROM critics might be born out of the process, taking android development into a whole new tier.
This thread that I suggested isnt easy to manage, so someone who has a lot of free time and technical know-how should handle it. It also might be biased for just anybody to make it, so preferably it has to be an admin or moderator. I know this could be asking for a lot, but it may make SGY one of the best sections on xda.
Thanks for writing this up and I too agree with you!
Such a thread coupled with brief user reviews as comments will help a lot of people decide which rom suits them!
Btw y don't you start the thread we can ask captain to make it sticky if thats okay!
great idea but unfortunately only mods have the ability to wipe posts, modify polls and move / edit stuffs,
so it would cause xda a high upkeep
U need some supportes..
I am here...
sent from galaxy next to earth
+1 from me too
Good suggestion
May Allah Bless U All...
Dikirim Ti GT-S6102 Kuring Nganggo Tapatalk2
I find it useful hearing people combo's and results i know it can be redeemed 'as hard to the teams'
but end of the day there full grown men there not going to lose sleep over it it will just make them work harder right?
Anyone just my opinion whole point in this is to see others opionon
I'm so confused right now.....
I remember there was a thread in Galaxy S2 section named "Whats your best combo for S2" . It was highly participated and even mods didn't removed it .
maxpower7 said:
I'm so confused right now.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No idea whats happening here
Why do people have to be so cryptic? This makes absolutely no sense to me either.
what ban?
this thread should be removed.
I think OP is referring to the forum rule that we can't have a thread dedicated to discussing which are the best kernels.
Whelan189 said:
I find it useful hearing people combo's and results i know it can be redeemed 'as hard to the teams'
but end of the day there full grown men there not going to lose sleep over it it will just make them work harder right?
Anyone just my opinion whole point in this is to see others opionon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If this confusing mass of words is asking why "best rom/best kernel" threads aren't allowed, it's because it's a highly subjective topic without a right or wrong answer. Your mileage may vary, as they say. Also, by allowing this type of thread, the moderators could be seen as favoring one developer over another. This is a place where development is encouraged and devs would not be happy with someone else's work being promoted above theirs. Because of the subjective nature of the topic (and the fact that there are undoubtedly thousands or even millions of possible setups), it doesn't add anything to the community to ask for people to spoonfeed you what works best for them. Do some flashing and figure out what works best for YOU, not someone else.
It is only logical to have that ban. If the ban would be lifted, users will continuosly praise one or few developers, and discouraging users from trying other kernels. Without users, devs would not be motivated to contribute. Less contributions = less inovations and in the end-effect stagnation of development. Devs respect and cooperate with each other.
Read the development threads, try the kernels your self, and decide what is best for you.
not to mention that all that will happen is you will just get a listing of all the kernels and roms, since people will list what they use. and on top of that, everyone thinks that the rom and kernel that they are using is the best rom/kernel. eventually people start arguing, and the thread will get closed anyways. there is no best kernel or rom. we all have differing needs, and they all react differently on our differing devices.
maxpower7 said:
If this confusing mass of words is asking why "best rom/best kernel" threads aren't allowed, it's because it's a highly subjective topic without a right or wrong answer. Your mileage may vary, as they say. Also, by allowing this type of thread, the moderators could be seen as favoring one developer over another. This is a place where development is encouraged and devs would not be happy with someone else's work being promoted above theirs. Because of the subjective nature of the topic (and the fact that there are undoubtedly thousands or even millions of possible setups), it doesn't add anything to the community to ask for people to spoonfeed you what works best for them. Do some flashing and figure out what works best for YOU, not someone else.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
^^^This is really a very solid answer to why we do not allow them on xda^^^.
If you want the short answer.
Trying out ROMs yourself is part of what XDA Developers is about. If you're too lazy to do this and would like others to do it for you, this website might not be for you.
So this really is not open for debate and no poll or petition is going change our stance on this.
Thread Closed
Happy New Year guys.
Recently there have been such threads about best ROM popping up again:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2593315
I would like to remind you that such threads are NOT ALLOWED[\b] here on XDA because:
- Each user will want a different Android experience. Therefore every user will have a different opinion on what ROM they will use.
- The phone belongs to the user. It is your phone and you yourself will determine which ROM suits you best. It's not up to me or any other dev to tell you what is best for you.
- Don't be lazy. Instead of having one hundred users tell you about a certain ROM, trying it out yourself will let you decide if it suits you or not. If you install a ROM based on what other users say, you may not like the ROM because it lacks a certain function or does not meet up to your expectations. Also, reading up on relevant material can help you decide if you want to use the ROM. So, head down to the Development section, pick a few ROMs and read up on the relevant content before making a decision.
- Discrediting other dev's work. A lot of you will agree that LX and Jader make good ROMs, but what happens to the other devs? Some of them put in effort to compile a ROM. Although there are not as many users of that ROM, the dev still did it in his free time and without pay. Telling one user that this ROM is better than the other is disrespectful to the dev because he put in effort for his work, only for someone to tell him that it cannot compare to another ROM.
Please take your time to read this. I would also like to thank the guys who have read it already and to help spread the word to the other users.
Cheers, 日焼け。一郎
僕のLT18iから送られてきた