On the recent nightlies of CM10, people who called me said they were hearing an echo of themselves as they spoke. I reverted back to CM 10 form 08/15/12 and it has gone away. I was using CM 10 nightly from 08/24/12. Has any one else experienced this? I did also turn off the voice suppression but it still continued creating the echo. Do someone have a solution to this?
This is a universal issue. I'm on Verizon and there is lots of talk about this going on.. No fix yet. Seems to affect the builds after the first couple. Some have it some don't. Mine.. Comes and goes.. Annoys the mess out of my wife when I call her. Cyanogen stated back on 8/20 that he had a patch coming, but at this point nothing yet..
Some people are stating that the echo is probably a result of a defective phone. I really don't think so. If I flash cm 10 08/15 there is no echo, any latter rom gives me echo. I think it is some software glitch. someone needs to check what changed from cm 10 08/15 to the next update, which was cm10 08/18.
The 8/31 nightly has a fix. The S3 has an audio canceling chip it uses to detect yourself and cancel out so the echo isn't heard. It is currently not supported but they added support in the 8/31 build which should fix this issue.
I see that on the cm10-log. I can't wait till 08/31!:laugh::laugh::laugh:
I'm on stock rooted. It happens once in awhile. It has to do with cdma...not the phone. People on verizon will attest to this.
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda premium
I can confirm this was fixed in nightly 31.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Restola said:
I can confirm this was fixed in nightly 31.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Problem still present on my tmobile s3 even with factor reset and 8/31 flash stock kernel :/
i too can confirmed this was fixed in 8/31 nightly. also, OP, why didn't you just search the cm10 thread for "echo" instead of starting a new thread about something that's already discussed in detail in the cm10 thread?
cnstarz said:
i too can confirmed this was fixed in 8/31 nightly. also, OP, why didn't you just search the cm10 thread for "echo" instead of starting a new thread about something that's already discussed in detail in the cm10 thread?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did search for one but did not find one so I decided to just create one. Apologies if I stepped on anybody's toes.
This is not just on the S3. The S2 have this issue too. And not just the European version but all of em. Is the way Samsuck ****s with their phones.
Related
FOR AT&T LEAK BASED ROMS ONLY. NOT FOR CM9 or gingerbread!!!
Hi all,
No more call echo
This fix uses the proper T989 audio parameters so noise suppression actually works like it should (car dock should work too in theory). On top of that is Samsung Diamond Voice Engine which really makes calls sound great.
It fixes the issue at the core, within the audio libraries. The audio paramaters and noise cancelling routines now work as they should.
UPDATED
I think I finally fixed this f$cking issue once and for all. For real this time. Try out the newest update I have attached to this post (Diamonds.zip)
This patch is a breed of libraries from the Galaxy Note and the Galaxy Blaze. It took me a very long time to put it together. But with a lot of work and hex digging I found the perfect combination.
I don't even think T-Mobile's ROM is going to sound this good
You might still have to turn down your volume a notch if you have a troublesome case, but I am going to make a bold statement and say that this should fix the problem for a 90% portion of you
Also--by its nature--this newest patch should fix the car dock audio problems. I can't test it to confirm. Please let me know if it does.
Report back with results!
Devs you are free to use. Credit is all I ask I spent lots of time on this and not enough time working on a project due tomorrow >_<
To the kind folks that donated to me in the past few days. thank you and I will thank you personally and address my PMs too. Been on and off the grid because of finals.
Cheers
Yaldak
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727-IcyS using xda premium
Dear sweet baby jesus yes!! DLing, gunna see what happens! ur the effin man, seriously.
I've made two phone calls yaldak and asked if they here an echo. They both said no..
1st call was w/ case
2nd call was w/o case
Before it was hit and miss for me some ppl would complain if echoing bothers were not..
So far so good brother
Edit 1 : have not had an oppurtunity to test compass.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda premium
Good to hear. Compass is still broken in this version
Did 4 test calls myself. All reported no echo.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727-IcyS using xda premium
great work my friend!.. i love your rom. and your fixes.. rotation, facebook font, now echo ! great!
I think TDJ already fixed this issue you should ask him for help if he'd be willing to share.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
unlvmike said:
I think TDJ already fixed this issue you should ask him for help if he'd be willing to share.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know people keep saying he fixed it, but if he did. I would expect he would have released it. Unless he is doing the community a disservice and trying to squander the fix for him self only for glory or what ever other reasoning.
Also to the OP. What do the display firmware in /etc have to do with the audio echo? and i understand you're trying to fix the compass so is that why the sensors lib is in there?
Based on his new ROM being a beta I think TDJ is testing a fix same as Yaldak.
Hopefully they both work.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda premium
Seems legit, my wife won't hate talking to me! Do you drink? If so, what's your drink of choice? If not, I'll buy you a burger.
Here's something to show my gratitude - 0LC82576P94652635.
unlvmike said:
I think TDJ already fixed this issue you should ask him for help if he'd be willing to share.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The approach used in the Darkside ROM is different. I did a library comparison to verify it.
While the approach should work because it appears to reverse the noise redcution switch (hence why the TDJ says to keep it on), this approach fixes the problem at its core--audio library side. Noise reduction will work exactly as it did in Gingerbread. Some people in that thread are still reporting the call echo issue because the audio paramters are off in all of the Skyrocket-based roms.
A LOT of work and experimenting was done to narrow it down to this one stupid file.
-Mr. X- said:
I know people keep saying he fixed it, but if he did. I would expect he would have released it. Unless he is doing the community a disservice and trying to squander the fix for him self only for glory or what ever other reasoning.
Also to the OP. What do the display firmware in /etc have to do with the audio echo? and i understand you're trying to fix the compass so is that why the sensors lib is in there?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is no display firmware. That's sensor firmware. This is preliminary work toward fixing the compass, as such it is a work in progress. It's not a beautified patch just yet
Seems legit, my wife won't hate talking to me! Do you drink? If so, what's your drink of choice? If not, I'll buy you a burger.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A beer will do my friend
I had echo before and using NexusMod.
Made calls to a POTS, VOIP, and another cell phone.
These people had complained about the echo before and report these calls sounded fine.
Thanks and great work.
Hey Yaldak,
I'll test this out on RomChicago tonight, which is based on your base.
As far as the compass goes, I didn't even realize there was an issue with it until now. I'll check the parts bin to see what works.
This is why I use your bases, because you da man.
Sent from my SGH-T989 Lawyerphone
What ICS ROMs is this patch compatible with?
Thanks for the patch. When I flashed it.in CWM its says auto rotation fix lol. Just forgot to rename it? Did I download the wrong one. Thanks!
deathknellx said:
What ICS ROMs is this patch compatible with?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Should work with all of them.
Thanks for the patch. When I flashed it.in CWM its says auto rotation fix lol. Just forgot to rename it? Did I download the wrong one. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I didn't rename it, this is still "beta"
So would this work on megamix 1.31 ROM?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
HoustonsBirdman said:
So would this work on megamix 1.31 ROM?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't see why not.
test it with the new darkside ics rom before and after and people reported to me the they had an echo..
not only that when im back to gingerbread people says that they dont hear an echo but they hear my voice like im coming from out of space
gypsy214 said:
test it with the new darkside ics rom before and after and people reported to me the they had an echo..
not only that when im back to gingerbread people says that they dont hear an echo but they hear my voice like im coming from out of space
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Darkside's ROM has another approach to this issue....so that is probably why.
It is also likely that--since you had the issue with gingerbread--your phone might be defective. My GB audio was crystal clear.
I'm up to 8 phone calls (2 incoming 6 out) in which the recipients reported no issue.
Is it difficult to apply this? Just asking cuz I never applied a patch. Switching roms, navigating thru root explorer, etc no problem.. but I don't want anyone wasting time explaining it if its something you believe is too complicated to do so. I'd just love to have call echo fixed so people stop telling me about something I already know. Never had call echo on GB. (I have tried the search but with how many posts there are with 'how to' and 'patch' in them its quite difficult and easier to ask)
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using Tapatalk 2
I have Verizon GN rooted with latest CM9
set my google voice mail instead of carrier voice mail to play it from call log. Everything was working very well for couple months. However, few days ago stops working. It will show that I have a new voice mail in the call log, and it will show me from whom, but when i open it and hit play it will kick me out back to call log and wont play it!!!!
I was thinking maybe a bug from CM9!!! Can anyone check that for me on his device and confirm it?
I was searching for that problem before I decided to post this, but all what I find is about Sprint and I know it is something different from this one.
Regards,
Bassil
Its either only me, or no one uses google voice for the voice mail from call log except me
I'm having the same problem all of a sudden. I wonder if it's a new bug introduced in CM9 because it works on my old builds on my Nexus One but doesn't work on the Galaxy Nexus or my HTC One X running CM9.
My Google-fu indicates that it might be a codec error, but I don't see any recent changes that would account for this.
sassafras
It looks like it is crashing trying to load the variablespeed playback lib.
Still don't see any change in the CM9 repos that would cause this problem.
sassafras
sassafras_ said:
It looks like it is crashing trying to load the variablespeed playback
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly, this what is happening to me!!! It wasn't like this with the older versions of CM9. I guess either from the new builds or from Verizon disabled it!!!
Same here
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus
I don't think it's carrier side. I think it's a bug new since a recent build of CM9
I think it's from the Android build 4.0.4, not from cm9 because I changed from cm9 to another rom with same android 4.0.4 and having same problem.
bassil2022 said:
I think it's from the Android build 4.0.4, not from cm9 because I changed from cm9 to another rom with same android 4.0.4 and having same problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which ROM? Are you sure it doesn't use the CM9 codebase?
sassafras
I've been told that Google voice replay from the dialer will fail on any linaro build. I think, but could be wrong, that the latest CM9 and AOKP both are now linaro. I'm using stock 4.0.4 and it works fine.
I experienced the same exact issue, also some m3 files wouldn't play.
I was running latest BlackIce which is cm9 based. Just flashed it Monday, reverted back to my nandroid and everything started working correctly. It must be something with the latest updates made on CM9.
Sent from a phone...
sassafras_ said:
Which ROM? Are you sure it doesn't use the CM9 codebase?
sassafras
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOKP
I switched to an old build by CM9, and now its working
I was already backed up. So I just restored. It was bulid 5/20
Pretty safe to say it's a CM9 bug, but still no idea what is actually causing it.
sassafras
sassafras_ said:
Pretty safe to say it's a CM9 bug, but still no idea what is actually causing it.
sassafras
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's pretty well established that it's a linaro issue.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
The latest cm9 nightly (July 9) seems to have fixed this. It works for me now at least.
T-mobile gs2
Hey Guys,
I've been reading of a forum to this problem I've been having with any Cyannogenmod after 10.1-20130226. There seems to be this problem where when I make or receive a call, I can't hear anything but the other party can hear me talking. I've kept updating to newer and newer versions only to figure out all of them have this problem, and that the last working one is the 10.1-20130226 version. Is there something the devs messed up on?
This is of course for the SGH II T989.
And here's the link with other people with the same problem:
This is on the forum for cyannogen mod. copy and paste it into the forums.
topic/69560-101-20130302-nightly-phone-calling-is-broken/
If anyone knows a solution to this, that will be great, otherwise I have to stick with this version till the newest update fixes that problem.
mikloish said:
Hey Guys,
I've been reading of a forum to this problem I've been having with any Cyannogenmod after 10.1-20130226. There seems to be this problem where when I make or receive a call, I can't hear anything but the other party can hear me talking. I've kept updating to newer and newer versions only to figure out all of them have this problem, and that the last working one is the 10.1-20130226 version. Is there something the devs messed up on?
This is of course for the SGH II T989.
And here's the link with other people with the same problem:
This is on the forum for cyannogen mod. copy and paste it into the forums.
topic/69560-101-20130302-nightly-phone-calling-is-broken/
If anyone knows a solution to this, that will be great, otherwise I have to stick with this version till the newest update fixes that problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's also about 10 threads here too. Same fix for everyone. Flash a different kernel, or a different ROM. Cerux kernel fixed it for me. It's in the development forum.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
I'm not able to post directly to the developer thread, and I thought that would be the appropriate course of action considering how narrow this problem is, but I guess it isn't? I'm not sure of the etiquette here, so I apologise for being awkward.
I've installed the latest nightly (2013/10/02) for Shawn157's AOKP build because apparently AOKP just isn't going to develop for my phone despite it being really dang new still. Everything is working on par with everyone else except for one odd thing; my phone won't receive or transmit audio during a phone call. I get or make a phone call and there's no sound coming out, and the person on the other end can't hear me either.
I'd be happy to dump/log/paste whatever you need. Thanks in advance for the help!
Usually you should try troubleshooting the issue yourself, if you still can't figure it out, then ask.
Have you tried a different 4.3 ROM?
Have you tried flashing a 4.2.2 ROM?
Have you tried flashing a 4.1.2 touchwiz ROM?
Have you tried returning to stock?
If yes to all and your still experiencing the issue, then its a hardware issue and you'll either have to fix it yourself or send it in for repair.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Da Kine said:
Usually you should try troubleshooting the issue yourself, if you still can't figure it out, then ask.
Have you tried a different 4.3 ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup. CM10.1 works, the last released official AOKP (Android 4.2.2) works, PACMAN works; it's really just this rom.
Have you tried flashing a 4.2.2 ROM?
Have you tried flashing a 4.1.2 touchwiz ROM?
Have you tried returning to stock?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not since flashing this one particular ROM, but I was hoping to not have to wipe my user data for the bajillionth time as I'm getting quite sick of having to reset all of my ribbons and re-log into every bloody social media app I use.
lindarthebard said:
Not since flashing this one particular ROM, but I was hoping to not have to wipe my user data for the bajillionth time as I'm getting quite sick of having to reset all of my ribbons and re-log into every bloody social media app I use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOKP team tweeted that there were some issues on the d2 devices (Galaxy S 3) which prevent them from building 4.3 nightlies. Shawn's build is also pulled directly from AOKP source so issues that AOKP team hasn't fixed will still be there. Anyway, I'm still rocking 4.2.2 build until AOKP fixes those issues. When playing around with new ROM, I do not reinstall all apps until I use the new ROM for a little while to see if there are critical issues. Saves me time of restoring all apps.
Beamed from my GS III via Tapatalk
Are there any known 4.3 or 4.4 ROMs with working phone mic?
I've used CM 10.2 Stable (4.3) and Carbon Rom (4.4.2). Both work great, the only issue is that the headset is not usable for calls (low mic output). My solution for now is using the earbud/mic, but I'm curious to know if anyone has made progress on this. Aside from this, the various ROMs are near perfect for my needs.
I'm not very knowledgeable on the details of writing ROMs, but would any type of source code release from LG help developers solve this? Curious to know what the main hurdles are for the devs and what tools they need.
Thanks.
Wish I could tell ya but I don't have a headset with a mic. I'd say give AICP a try since it uses AOKP sources instead of CM. Might give ya a better outcome.
Sent from my AICP 4.4 LG-E980
Neroga said:
Wish I could tell ya but I don't have a headset with a mic. I'd say give AICP a try since it uses AOKP sources instead of CM. Might give ya a better outcome.
Sent from my AICP 4.4 LG-E980
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the suggestion, downloading now.
Do phone calls work fine on yours?
markusrussell225 said:
Thanks for the suggestion, downloading now.
Do phone calls work fine on yours?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Still no luck on a solid working phone microphone (low volume on other end). And the search continues.
Now that mid March has come around, has anyone had any good luck with a working in call microphone?
I was previously using several 4.4.2 Builds however, the need for a working phone mic was too critical for daily usage.
I'm using a 4.3 build (Slim Bean) which I believe is the only one with a working phone. The build is an unofficial beta and the only real issues are lack of microSD function, FC on Google Drive, and a few freezes here and there. Overall it's usable for my needs but would like to get back onto 4.4.2 granted the phone mic works.
Any suggestions/advice would be great. Thanks!
markusrussell225 said:
Now that mid March has come around, has anyone had any good luck with a working in call microphone?
I was previously using several 4.4.2 Builds however, the need for a working phone mic was too critical for daily usage.
I'm using a 4.3 build (Slim Bean) which I believe is the only one with a working phone. The build is an unofficial beta and the only real issues are lack of microSD function, FC on Google Drive, and a few freezes here and there. Overall it's usable for my needs but would like to get back onto 4.4.2 granted the phone mic works.
Any suggestions/advice would be great. Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know much, plus i am still on stock but i will suggest you to ask your query and issues on particular custom ROM posts. i have seen people getting response faster and if in case there is a bug, high chances that developer of that particular ROM can fix it :thumbup:
Sent from my LG-E988 using xda app-developers app
ja.andro said:
I don't know much, plus i am still on stock but i will suggest you to ask your query and issues on particular custom ROM posts. i have seen people getting response faster and if in case there is a bug, high chances that developer of that particular ROM can fix it :thumbup:
Sent from my LG-E988 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I ask because this is a problem has existed on all known roms since 4.3.1 for the E980 on ATT. Never been able to get a straight answer anywhere so I figure I would generically post it. I have reached out to some devs but not luck.
Any success on your searching?
thureos said:
Any success on your searching?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
---
Here is a manual fix for the in call mic from JustinNL on XDA:
Step 1:
download a "build.prop editor app", I used: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jrummy.apps.build.prop.editor
Step 2:
Modify these 2 specs in the build prop editor
persist.audio.handset.mic.type=digital --> replace digital with analog
persist.audio.dualmic.config=endfire -- replace endfire with false
Since i changed it i haven't had any complaints so far but flashing to new nightly makes it revert again, keep that in mind."
Been working great for myself and others.
markusrussell225 said:
---
Here is a manual fix for the in call mic from JustinNL on XDA:
Step 1:
download a "build.prop editor app", I used: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jrummy.apps.build.prop.editor
Step 2:
Modify these 2 specs in the build prop editor
persist.audio.handset.mic.type=digital --> replace digital with analog
persist.audio.dualmic.config=endfire -- replace endfire with false
Since i changed it i haven't had any complaints so far but flashing to new nightly makes it revert again, keep that in mind."
Been working great for myself and others.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw that solution but I went back to rooted and debloated stock, I am very pleased with speed and stability.
Thanks
i've made the edits suggested on that post and still get the same issue...i dont remember having this issue before but i thnk youre right and the previous roms werent 4.4...oh well i live on the phone for work so back to stock for me. for now i guess...wanting a new phone anyways, hope we get the g pro 2 or g3 soon