I have tried everything mentioned. I can get the middle button to work but the the top and bottom does not seem to register at all. I tried the headset droid app. It had a test function for buttons. The middle was recognized but the other two nothing. If I look at the socket when putting the headphones in it does not seat all the way leaving one of the black ring out and not connected. The way the plug hole is angled could be causing this issue. This is probably not the issue however since the provided earphone stick out and show the black ring as well.
I moved from my iPhone 4 and this is the only issue that I can't solve. After spending $350 for these headphones. I would love to get them working fully with my HOX.
Any new approaches that somebody has tried?
Thanks
AFIAK most headphones/earphones are made for iphone/ipods. I had this issue with beats solo hds before, I think it was because the controls were made specifically to work with iphones/ipods and the volume buttons wont be working, on android it's different most earphones/headphones with remote has skipping buttons instead of volume buttons, I got beats solo with my htc one x in a premium pack and the control works perfectly I connected it to someone else's iPhone and only the middle button worked. So whatever earphone/headphone is made for iphones/ipods then the volume buttons wont work with android, but whatever earphones/headphones that does NOT say it is made for iphones/ipods and has skipping buttons instead of volume buttons, it will work for android but not for iphones/ipods. I hope this makes sense to you
You see...you got the x10i...the i10a woulda worked perfect
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2
KLUVJ said:
You see...you got the x10i...the i10a woulda worked perfect
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
X10a's. Can't seem to find them on the Klipsch site. I bought the 10i because over a year ago it was the updated version go the X10.
Do you have a web address for the X10a?
Thanks
Ed
EdwardLotz said:
X10a's. Can't seem to find them on the Klipsch site. I bought the 10i because over a year ago it was the updated version go the X10.
Do you have a web address for the X10a?
Thanks
Ed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol, seems to me they didnt make an android ones yet, all i know is that for their s4s, they named s4i for iphone and s4a for android
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2
When you said the DROID app, was that the klipsh android app? That activated all the functions except volume (which will never work) on my s4i
Chluz said:
When you said the DROID app, was that the klipsh android app? That activated all the functions except volume (which will never work) on my s4i
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found the Klipdch app and have seen that the middle button does work now. It would be nice with all of them. Also iTunes control was better in this regard. This is the first Downside to android phones.
I had some Ultimate Ears Super Fi 5 ear phones. I used the headset button app on the play store. It has loads configuration options to work with most earphones. Try the free version.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
It would seem the headsets use different resistor values, someone modified a iphone headset to work with android.
http://www.instructables.com/id/Galaxy-Nexus-and-others-headset-remote-with-medi/?ALLSTEPS
Related
Hello everyone,
I just received my epic touch last saturday.I can't use the control button with the repic touch. When I click the middle button, there is no action. I know that the volumn control doesn't work with android. However, the middle button can play, pause and answer call. I use my headset with my old HTC evo and it work fine. Does anyone have the same problem with me? I don't know if it's a bug or I got a defective phone. Thank you very much guys.
Does anyone use this phone with headset? Does your headset control work fine? I looked for this problem on google and found out that the Klipsch s4i work fine with the international galaxy S2 version.
Same thing happening to me...center button does not work with my s4i headset.
I tried a few headset control apps from the market, but still will not work.
Ditto here with both Skullcandy and Koss earbuds. Control button does squat except launch the stupid voice control app after holding for a few seconds. Headset Droid doesn't even detect button presses.
weirdon said:
Hello everyone,
I just received my epic touch last saturday.I can't use the control button with the repic touch. When I click the middle button, there is no action. I know that the volumn control doesn't work with android. However, the middle button can play, pause and answer call. I use my headset with my old HTC evo and it work fine. Does anyone have the same problem with me? I don't know if it's a bug or I got a defective phone. Thank you very much guys.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The i in s4i stands for ipod. You want the s4a, not sure if it is for sale yet, but it has been announced.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk
kingsway8605 said:
The i in s4i stands for ipod. You want the s4a, not sure if it is for sale yet, but it has been announced.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you everyone for your reply. I just afraid that I got a defective GS2. I know the S4i is designed for ipod. However, the middle control button work fine for most of the android. I also bought the headset droid control on the market and I could do a lot of things with the control except for the volumn. SO this is a bug for GS2. Hope samsung will fix it soon.
My skullcandy button does nothing either. Oh well. I like to use the phone right now cause everyone asks "ooh what's that?"
The s4i used to work flawlessly with my evo. I was able to change volume, pause, play, and slip tracks. Now I can't do any of the above. ButI noticed that if you hold the middle button it'll bring out the voice command.
mine either
i just dont think they work with this phone
kingsway8605 said:
The i in s4i stands for ipod. You want the s4a, not sure if it is for sale yet, but it has been announced.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 . Its not a bug, these buttons send code, code meant for an iDevice. Looking forward to the S4a.
Scaplet said:
+1 . Its not a bug, these buttons send code, code meant for an iDevice. Looking forward to the S4a.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why does the S4i work fine with the International Samsung Galaxy S2?
Hmm my s4i's have worked with my previous android phones although I rarely play music from my phone...ill check it out later today and maybe try some apps on the market...fyi only the play pause button worked..apple and their patents :-(
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
same goes for shure remote
I think shure only makes one remote for all. This has worked fine for me with iphone, ipad, blackberry, webos, and 2 HTC android phones.
Sucks that Samsung went this route for a crappy feature like video out on headphone jack. I knew this device was too good to be true and now I may have to swap it out for another.
As a note: the button won't answer the phone, but the mic does work in-call.
?????
Sent from my R800i using Tapatalk 2
Depends, which Beats? ControlTalk won't work, but with the Solos you get 2 cables. One works.
Look in the forum, as far as I remember this has been posted before but I can't find the post.
Now, to answer you, the short answer is not. And to clarify here's why:
SonyEricsson phones use a (jack) standard called OMTP (also does Nokia), while Sony phones (Xperia P, S, U, etc), Apple and almost every other company uses CTIA.
This obviously means that the headphones won't work, but...
The only difference between those two are the connection layout:
CTIA:
T-Left Audio
R1-Right Audio
R2-Ground
S-Mic
OMTP:
T-Audio Left
R1-Audio Right
R2-Mic
S-Ground
So to make them work you can buy or make an adapter that swaps R2 and S, or one that short-circuits both; the first kind will let you use the mic, volume control etc, while the other kind (a simple extension would do) won't.
Now, if you don't want to use ANY kind of adapter, not even a simple extension there's a way you can make them work:
It is supposed that once you push the central button on a headset (OMTP or CTIA, doesn't matter) what it internally does is short circuit R2 and S, so, if you manage to hold all the time the central button on your beats they should work, nevertheless the mic and so won't work either as their data goes through the S ring.
Being all that said here's an issue, even with the adapter they won't work, I'm not quite sure why, you can see my post about that issue, there I try to make work a headset like the beats on my Xperia.
I hope I helped you
I bought studio. It works.
Sent from my R800i using Tapatalk 2
jhonyrod said:
Look in the forum, as far as I remember this has been posted before but I can't find the post.
Now, to answer you, the short answer is not. And to clarify here's why:
SonyEricsson phones use a (jack) standard called OMTP (also does Nokia), while Sony phones (Xperia P, S, U, etc), Apple and almost every other company uses CTIA.
This obviously means that the headphones won't work, but...
The only difference between those two are the connection layout:
CTIA:
T-Left Audio
R1-Right Audio
R2-Ground
S-Mic
OMTP:
T-Audio Left
R1-Audio Right
R2-Mic
S-Ground
So to make them work you can buy or make an adapter that swaps R2 and S, or one that short-circuits both; the first kind will let you use the mic, volume control etc, while the other kind (a simple extension would do) won't.
Now, if you don't want to use ANY kind of adapter, not even a simple extension there's a way you can make them work:
It is supposed that once you push the central button on a headset (OMTP or CTIA, doesn't matter) what it internally does is short circuit R2 and S, so, if you manage to hold all the time the central button on your beats they should work, nevertheless the mic and so won't work either as their data goes through the S ring.
Being all that said here's an issue, even with the adapter they won't work, I'm not quite sure why, you can see my post about that issue, there I try to make work a headset like the beats on my Xperia.
I hope I helped you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro thanks for this suggestions but I didnt do anything but Studio works with no problem...
Sent from my R800i using Tapatalk 2
Oh, I see... sorry for my rant, I thought that you were talking about the ControlTalk enabled ones , since every 3.5 standard TRS headphone works with almost every phone .
Would a OMTP to CTIA concerter therefore double as a CTIA to OMTP adapter, following circuit logic, making OMTP work on my iPod Nano as well as CTIA on my PLAY?
Sent from my R800at using xda premium
I think all headphones work with cm9
Sent from my R800i using Tapatalk 2
af230 said:
I think all headphones work with cm9
Sent from my R800i using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah mate! The hardware restrictions will not allow you, no matter what kinda software you use.
CTIA & OMTP are two different hardware standards!
kloud_ said:
Nah mate! The hardware restrictions will not allow you, no matter what kinda software you use.
CTIA & OMTP are two different hardware standards!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Beats seemed to work on my phone when I had cm9 but not on gingerbread. Although I might have fake beats: I'm not too sure.
Has anyone tried these headphones? I wanna known how they sound and if they're worth the purchase.
http://www.iskin.com/eartones/
omgitsmoosh said:
Has anyone tried these headphones? I wanna known how they sound and if they're worth the purchase.
http://www.iskin.com/eartones/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
great sound all three buttons work on gs3 and they have an app
http://www.nocs.se/blogs/latest_news/6108414-ns200-android-samsung-galaxy-s-iii
I ordered them......will let u know when they arrive
omgitsmoosh said:
Has anyone tried these headphones? I wanna known how they sound and if they're worth the purchase.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I placed an order for the eartones this am.......I will let you know when they arrive whether they work or not. I emailed iskin and asked if they worked and the rep said they work 100% for mic, volume, everything......same as headset we get with phone.......so heres hoping he wasn't wrong!!
UPDATE..........
So I got the eartones today and they do work great for an apple earbud replacement! HOWEVER, there is NO volume control........they are not even capable of it so not sure why the rep at iskin told me on two occasions that volume control works???? They sound far better than apple earbuds and the mic works great on the S3 as well as answering and declining calls, playing and pausing music. That was my beef with the apple ones as the mic didn't work on the GS3.
If its made for iPhone then most likely no
thelastred said:
If its made for iPhone then most likely no
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah thats exactly what I thought too, but then it said it supports the S3 on the site and so I decided to inquire about it working and they claim it does......at any rate I should know is I just wasted my money in a few days.
Do u have a link or model number for the earphones
Yeah so I went to the home page then clicked on shop. Then clicked on vibe under Samsung on the left side. This brought up a page that has the GS3 cases (vibe and aura) as well as it stating the eartones are compatible with the phone too. So yeah the weird thing is there is only one type......not a model for the iPhone and galaxy........so don't worry, I, like u are quite skeptical. But I guess we will see. I still have the email from them stating they work exactly like the Samsung set we get with the phone so I guess I should have no problem returning them if they don't work.
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
Here is his response to me asking if they in fact work for every function.......if they don't, mark will be getting a call! Lol
I am really crossing my fingers cause I hate in ear headsets......they never fit me no matter how many tips I try.
"Hello Garret,
Thank you for your question.
The eartones absolutely work with the samsung galaxy s3 in regards to the functionality you require.
Playing music...answering and ending calls and the volume buttons are all fully functional.
Hope to see your order soon!
Thanks!
Should you require further assistance, please reply to this email or give us a call at the number below. Please include all previous correspondence in your response. Our business hours are Monday-Friday 9-5 EST.
Best regards,
Mark Lakhan Client Relations Representative
2225 Sheppard Ave. East, Suite 1203 | Toronto, Ontario | Canada | M2J 5C2 416-924-9607
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
It's a one button remote most likely why it works on both
Bah!!! Brutal you are right! So obviously there will be no volume control.......lame. well Mark definitely got his info messed up that he gave me.......said there is volume control. Yeah maybe with an app!!! Hmmmmmm need to decide quickly if I should cancel my order.
Hey thanks for pointing that out tho!!!
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
My goodness is it too much to ask for a decent set of ear buds with working mic, volume control!?!?! I just need something that doesn't block out all noise around me.......since I use them for work. As much as the apple buds sucked, they suited my needs exactly! I was very disappointed that they didn't work in the GS3. Any other bud style suggestions?
Thanks xda members!!
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
yama0ha said:
My goodness is it too much to ask for a decent set of ear buds with working mic, volume control!?!?! I just need something that doesn't block out all noise around me.......since I use them for work. As much as the apple buds sucked, they suited my needs exactly! I was very disappointed that they didn't work in the GS3. Any other bud style suggestions?
Thanks xda members!!
Sent from my SGH-I747M using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My point exactly. Not everyone likes or can use the in ear headphones, so it would be nice if companies did develop some nice headphones for the rest of us!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
omgitsmoosh said:
My point exactly. Not everyone likes or can use the in ear headphones, so it would be nice if companies did develop some nice headphones for the rest of us!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try http://item.mobileweb.ebay.com/viewitem?itemId=261030664855&index=5&nav=SEARCH&nid=36939919832
Do those have volume control? Probably not as it seems that is always the kicker. Thanks for the suggestion......they are less than $10 so I will likely buy a pair just to try out.
The link I give for black earphone have volume control for asking galaxy s3
Guys, I thought I would post this here as well so you can get my review for the eartones........
Hey fellow xda members I just wanted to share my take on the iSkin Eartones that I just received today. These are great for anyone who doesn't like in-ear headsets. The fit in your ear is very similar to the apple earbuds which for me was a huge plus because I use my headset mostly for business calls etc while I drive (which in-ear were too unsafe as they block out all outside sound). The sound quality is actually very good for an earbud. There is good lows and highs and there is an included set of foam covers to put over the tips which would give you better sealing of the ear to further enhance the sound for the music junkies out there.
They have some flex in the earbud part which allows it to fit very well in different ear shapes.
The sound quality on the other end of a phone conversation is extremely good according to my business partners.
The only downside for me is that there is no volume control. This is a letdown since the rep I spoke with at iSkin prior to ordering these said to me on two occasions that they had volume control and that it worked flawlessly with the GS3.......not sure where he was pulling that info from but he is wrong.
They are $39.99 for www.iSkin.com
Also, the shipping was super fast. I am in Calgary AB and they shipped form Toronto to me in less than a day!
Feel free to ask me any questions you may have!
---------- Post added at 01:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:47 PM ----------
thelastred said:
The link I give for black earphone have volume control for asking galaxy s3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually just ordered a pair of these as well so we will see if they have volume control!!!! The eartones work really good though........just would love to have volume control!
They only non inear earbuds I can think of is htc earbuds with remote and mic. All three buttons work on galaxys2 &3
The skip buttons work as volume and center is play ,pause ,pick up and end call
http://item.mobileweb.ebay.com/viewitem?itemId=261030664855&index=6&nav=SEARCH&nid=16390308358
thelastred said:
They only non inear earbuds I can think of is htc earbuds with remote and mic. All three buttons work on galaxys2 &3
The skip buttons work as volume and center is play ,pause ,pick up and end call
http://item.mobileweb.ebay.com/viewitem?itemId=261030664855&index=6&nav=SEARCH&nid=16390308358
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep........I ordered a pair of those........so we will see how they work and sound. The guys at iSkin said they would fully refund my shipping and price for the Eartones if I didn't like them since they misinformed me about the volume control. I will likely keep them though as they do sound pretty good. But I have my fingers crossed the HTC ones will work for everything and not sound like crap.
I received a pair of Beats by Dr. Dre headphones for my birthday (Solo HD) and have paired them with my S3. Wth the Controltalk cable I have most functionality except for volume up/volume down. Was wondering if this was a software issue and has anyone found a suitable wor arou d for them.
I don't think they're compatible, check the market and you might find an app that'll help you out.
A check of the Play store using the search terms Monster Controltalk yields nothing. I am hoping that someone has developed an app outside of the store.
I just sold my ibeats with control talk.
I bought a set of Jays a-Jays One+ but dont really like them... I might just have to get a set of Monster UrBeats
madchild1 said:
I just sold my ibeats with control talk.
I bought a set of Jays a-Jays One+ but dont really like them... I might just have to get a set of Monster UrBeats
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And this helps me with my problem because...
???
banistersmind said:
And this helps me with my problem because...
???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because the UrBeats are the ones you should have gotten. Those Beats are made for iphones, not really androids. No need to be a ****
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
banistersmind said:
And this helps me with my problem because...
???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because, without being a **** and saying "Use the search" I offered two different options for you. Both headsets work with the SGS3, and both are made for android.
On another note, I decided on the Klipsch S4A instead of buying UrBeats off ebay....
(*hint* also headphones built for Android....)
madchild1 said:
Because, without being a **** and saying "Use the search" I offered two different options for you. Both headsets work with the SGS3, and both are made for android.
On another note, I decided on the Klipsch S4A instead of buying UrBeats off ebay....
(*hint* also headphones built for Android....)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you read the OP, I received the headphones as a birthday present.
banistersmind said:
If you read the OP, I received the headphones as a birthday present.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you'd use the search function, you'd know there's already a solution. Theres a cable that you buy. You hook it to your phone from one end n the other end is connected to your headphones n control talk works. Now use the search function to find it *hint its already in a topic about this subject*
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
hmmm, I actually did use the search function and search term was controltalk and I couldn't find this cable. Can you please link me either the post of what cable I need to get? Have my Beats Studio and S3 for about a month, and all I can do is play pause and skip on music. Can't even call with it let along control volume.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1695717
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
sheesh...so much tension in this topic...but you should do a better search...so to save you the trouble...here it is...
Are the Beats by dre executives compatible with the GS3? Meaning if the incline mic works with the phone to answer calls control volume and play music?
you should at least do a little search.
it is on the first or second page, a list of compatible headsets.
good luck on finding it. it won't be hard.
nonyhaha said:
you should at least do a little search.
it is on the first or second page, a list of compatible headsets.
good luck on finding it. it won't be hard.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I looked at all of them but there is nothing on beats by dre. I read that the powerbeats and Studios don't work. But I was thinking since the executives are fairly new that they might work. I just want conformation on that.
DaKid1 said:
I looked at all of them but there is nothing on beats by dre. I read that the powerbeats and Studios don't work. But I was thinking since the executives are fairly new that they might work. I just want conformation on that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are all for iphone. Find something else
Sent from my GT-I9300 using XDA Premium HD app
Actually I believe the issue lies in the control talk cable itself. I bought a pair of mixr and had the same issues as everyone else with an Android phone. Apple devices the wiring is done backwards inside the cable. So I got to thinking about reversing but my soldering skills aren't the same. So I thought maybe a new cable, so I found one on ebay, obviously a 3rd party beats knockoff, where it has 2 black rings on the plug and 3 rings where it gets plugged into the phone. And viola they work perfect all features Inc volume.. See the picture I uploaded and u see what I mean
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
I personally wouldn't buy any beats by dres unless u get a large discount. Like almost half. Otherwise you're being ripped off. But I don't believe any control talk headphones work fully
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2