Stupid question about screen resolution - Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Hey, sorry but this is quite a stupid question I think.
I was just wondering, if the display is 720p then surely watching a 1080p video would look exactly the same as a 720p video? If that is the case, why would you bother watching 1080p videos on the Galaxy Nexus?
Obviously that can't be the case though, can anyone explain why? I'm just curious.

Yep. Same. Realistically you'd have. Hard time telling even 480p video apart from 720p on this small a screen.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk

case0 said:
Hey, sorry but this is quite a stupid question I think.
I was just wondering, if the display is 720p then surely watching a 1080p video would look exactly the same as a 720p video? If that is the case, why would you bother watching 1080p videos on the Galaxy Nexus?
Obviously that can't be the case though, can anyone explain why? I'm just curious.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One point would be if you use the MHL to HDMI adapter, then movies played on your GN would show as 1080p or i on the TV.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk

Herman76 said:
One point would be if you use the MHL to HDMI adapter, then movies played on your GN would show as 1080p or i on the TV.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Confirmed. I have the MHL to HDMI adapter and I can play movies on TV at 1920x1080 from my Galaxy Nexus.

Ah, that would explain why people often ask about the performance of 1080p videos. Cheers!

Related

[Q] Galaxy Nexus and 1080p out.

Hi guys. My GNex only seems to output to 720p when I connect it to the TV or he monitor. Does anyone know if it is possible to get the phone to output in 1080p? Thanks.
Using AOKP build 9 by team Kang
Android 4.0.3
Apex Kernel v4 @ 1.4GHz
Best Wishes!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
DarthPiggie said:
Hi guys. My GNex only seems to output to 720p when I connect it to the TV or he monitor. Does anyone know if it is possible to get the phone to output in 1080p? Thanks.
Using AOKP build 9 by team Kang
Android 4.0.3
Apex Kernel v4 @ 1.4GHz
Best Wishes!
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. Unless ICS can "detect displays", it'll only display 720x1280, that the phone resolution.
Sent from a yakju GSGN
hmmm I see. So why is it that I keep hearing people touting 1080p output . Can the GS2 output 1080i though? I've heard of some people who have. Really bizzare. My Droid X ran at 858x400 and outputted to 720p so something is up.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
So the GNEX and Rezound both record 1080 but both can't output it? I'm confused. I though my GNEX could record it and then play it? I just got two days ago so pardon my absent of knowledge.
I can confirm that when using MHL to my LCD monitor, all video output is 720p. I tried playing some 1080p H.264 video files but the monitor still says 720p.
I'm beginning to think the GN output is always 720p over MHL.
Can anyone confirm this?
Something is amiss here.
With my Droid X, I can also output to my screen using the micro HDMI cable. The droid x also outputs to 720p; however, the resulting output only takes up a portion of the screen; there are black borders on the sides and on the top and bottom .
My Nexus on the other hand takes up the entire screen, which leads me to believe that this is behaving normally and as intended.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus
in this video you can see the switch to 1080p when playing a video file in diceplayer (1:35)... maybe the player has to support it?
No change with Dice player
I tried Dice player with a couple 1080p H.264 videos from Youtube. They all play at 720p in the software player and hardware mode.
I saw in that video above it switches. But my Dell 2408WFP monitor still reports 1280x720 mode.
I know 1080p works fine with this monitor and my PS3 using HDMI.
Maybe when you use this:
http://www.dealextreme.com/p/samsung-micro-usb-to-mhl-hdmi-tv-adapter-for-galaxy-s2-i9100-i9188-i9000-more-black-95031
it works then
I was able to play a 1080p 11gig file on my phone through mhl to my TV and it displayed as 1080p. I was using MX Player and the Samsung mhl adaptor.
I will try this on my non samsung mhl adapter (monoprice verison). I have outputted 720p on my tv but never 1080p.
dug-e-fresh said:
I was able to play a 1080p 11gig file on my phone through mhl to my TV and it displayed as 1080p. I was using MX Player and the Samsung mhl adaptor.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you certain that it was 1080p...?
I shot a test clip with the built in 1080p/24 setting on the camera and it would replay it at 1080p over MHL via the built-in gallery app. I think people run into two type of problems with MHL:
1) Cheap eBay MHL dongles that max out at 720p and won't uprez ever.
2) Non stock playback apps that don't call out to the MHL to up the rez.
Hmmm... I forgot I just got a 1080p plasma. Will have to test tonight.
Sent from my Nexus in Texas.
as far as I'm aware there will only be 1080 p output when playing a 1080 p video file? The rest of the time the display mirrors the phone display at 720 p. Is this the case and are there any games that can take advantage of the larger resolution?
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
Trying to find an answer for this. How do I get 1080p using MHL?
Sent from my wireless telephonic device.
Only when watching 1080p videos to my knowledge.
Swype'ed on my CM10 Galaxy Nexus
I've recorded a video in 1080, but it still plays in 720. MX player and stock player. Google play movies also play in 720.
Can't figure out how to get this to work.
Also strange, the edges of the display are cut.
Sent from my wireless telephonic device.
---------- Post added at 01:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:45 PM ----------
My TV is 3 maybe 4 years old. I bought the previous year's model to save $$
Sent from my wireless telephonic device.
jova33 said:
I've recorded a video in 1080, but it still plays in 720. MX player and stock player. Google play movies also play in 720.
Can't figure out how to get this to work.
Also strange, the edges of the display are cut.
Sent from my wireless telephonic device.
---------- Post added at 01:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:45 PM ----------
My TV is 3 maybe 4 years old. I bought the previous year's model to save $$
Sent from my wireless telephonic device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe you can configure the HDMI settings to cut the (bottom) menus off, my TF300T have it, but I never tried it on my GNEX. I have a (announced as) 1080p MHL=>HDMI cable, tried some 1080p clips but never got my TV to show it above 720p. I'm crazy about it also, I really want to take advantage of FullHD with my Galaxy Nexus.
I'm using MHL Samsung adapter and Samsung 40D7000 tv, and when i play 1080p video through MX Player, TV information shows 1920x1080 resolution.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app

MHL to HDMI connector

Hi guys
i just bought mhl to hdmi convertor off ebay and it supports 1080p resolution. However when i connect it with my Gnex it only outputs 640x480 resolution ...is there any fix for this??
mohsin125 said:
Hi guys
i just bought mhl to hdmi convertor off ebay and it supports 1080p resolution. However when i connect it with my Gnex it only outputs 640x480 resolution ...is there any fix for this??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are you trying to output? Home screen?movie?game?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
everything i have tried is displaying at 640x480 resolution...even movies games
seems like you got a funky MHL my friend.
mohsin125 said:
everything i have tried is displaying at 640x480 resolution...even movies games
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
did you sort this as ive got the same but im using a hdmi to dvi adaptor to try on a monitor, it says 1280 x 720 support on the box...
cheers
I'm experiencing some sort of overscan when using the adapter, but I'm not sure if it is the phone, my av-receiver or the TV.
Oh well. It was dirt cheap on dealextreme.com. Not like I lost a lot of money
I haven't got one yet but have been researching like crazy. What I have found so far is that cheap ones are cheap. They do what yours is doing, the connections need to be wiggled to keep it connected etc. Spring for a good quality one if you're actually going to be using it. The folks at MHL have a good one I think, just haven't been able to find it.
No 1080p when using DVI
What a pity! Back in time, when we had ICS there we at least got the possibility to use 1280x720 (as far as I remember) when using a monitor via mhl->hdmi->dvi chain, now we are only getting 640x480, Even when watching movies.
You will only get full HD whenn you connect directly usb-.hdmi->TV
So no desktop mode any more.
mohsin125 said:
Hi guys
i just bought mhl to hdmi convertor off ebay and it supports 1080p resolution. However when i connect it with my Gnex it only outputs 640x480 resolution ...is there any fix for this??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know how helpful this is, but Samsung actually makes an HDMI media dock for the GNex that works really well. I'm not sure how much it costs, however, as mine came with my phone.
The only issue I've had with it is that I have to take the case off my phone to use it.
The real good question...
The real question here is: "Can the Galaxy Nexus output 1080p playback, given his native resolution IS NOT 1080p?"
I mean, I know that OSs can adapt second displays and all that, Linux does that, but can Android do that? Treat the HDMI output as a second and independent display? I hope it can. I have a MHL=>HDMI cable (that also needs the power adapter to be plugged in) and I can only get 720p out of it, and the GNex can actually play 1080p movies, so... That would be awesome to play 1080p movies on my TV screen.

[Q] 1080p output from HDMI?

Hey guys I have been using the GN with 720p for a while and it's fine an all but I want to try and get 1080p output, is this possible?
I have been using the Samsung G2 MHL cables.
Thanks in advance.
Only if you play movies in 1080p i think. Not the homescreen itself.
Where do you guys get movies in 1080p for phones? Legally of course
Sent from my iPad 3G using Tapatalk
Depending on where you live, you could use something like MakeMKV to rip your BluRays (in sane parts of the world that would fall under fair use, in other parts the MPAA would track you down and beat you with your own entrails for causing millions of dollars in losses by watching a movie you bought on a device for which it was not intended).
However, since the MHL adapter mirrors the screen I highly doubt you'll get anything more or less than 720p without going through an upscaler which would kind of defeat the purpose.
big samm said:
Where do you guys get movies in 1080p for phones? Legally of course
Sent from my iPad 3G using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you just want a short for testing or demonstration, download a few official Angry Birds shorts off youtube with some extra programs . They are available in 1080p MP4 versions. I have a few of them on my phone.
Shooting off on a tangent here, anyone tried those MHL dongles off ebay?

hdmi adapter UK

Hi,
Can anyone recommend a good (cheap) hdmi adapter?
Cheers...
MJ-12
After over a week now, i will take that as a no?
Cheers...
MJ-12
Sorry, do you want a good one or a cheap one?
Both together is nearly impossible, but you are lucky!
We have a priceworthy and good MHL-adaptare (which i think yopu need): http://goo.gl/aD8T7
Shipping to UK is 4€ extra btw.
I got the samsung one from amazon at 13 euros. Decent enough but no HD video. Not with the somesung one or any other adapter i tried. Just keeps the Phones resolution. Fun to play games and maybe a movie though
hdmi adapter uk
http://www.mobilefun.co.uk/bizlink-mhl-adapter-microusb-to-hdmi-tv-out-black-p29839.htm
£12.95 inc of vat
this also works with no problems
http://www.play.com/Mobiles/Mobile/4-/20189616/-/Product.html
that's for £15 and claimed to be official. Took almost a week to deliver but worked without fault. Going by few reviews of "cheap" adapters, it seemed hit n miss thingy. Thought price is in middle for something genuine.
I can't vouch for the quality of this as I'm waiting for mine to be delivered (only ordered it this morning), but for a tenner I'm not complaining...
http://goo.gl/8BwsJ
starfarer said:
that's for £15 and claimed to be official. Took almost a week to deliver but worked without fault. Going by few reviews of "cheap" adapters, it seemed hit n miss thingy. Thought price is in middle for something genuine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is the price for the genuine. post resolution when you try it pls.
---------- Post added at 05:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:01 PM ----------
Just got ICS on my phone and tried the HDMI adapter. It seems that it has better quality with ICS. Don't know if it upscales the resolution but it seems clearer.
edit: So the output is 1080p but the upscaling isn't always the best. especially in games where the downloades files are for 800x480. In movies and photos it works great though.
starfarer said:
http://www.play.com/Mobiles/Mobile/4-/20189616/-/Product.html
that's for £15 and claimed to be official. Took almost a week to deliver but worked without fault. Going by few reviews of "cheap" adapters, it seemed hit n miss thingy. Thought price is in middle for something genuine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Argh hope it doesn't take a week to arrive, only ordered mine today
Decided at that price it just wasn't worth saving a couple of quid to get one that might work but likely have worse build quality.
Also ordered a HDMI to DVI cable from there for a stupidly low price of £2..
What's the actual conclusion on the SGS2s HDMI out? I've seen scattered reports of some people getting full 1080p out, others can't get any higher than the native 480x800. Then there's the Video Player app designed specifically for HD playback.
I'm getting 1080 with ICS but only on Videoplayback.
Tried several apps to resize the density for "office use" - everytime i had to reflash...
Sent from my ARCHOS 80G9 using XDA Premium HD app
Hollow.Droid said:
What's the actual conclusion on the SGS2s HDMI out? I've seen scattered reports of some people getting full 1080p out, others can't get any higher than the native 480x800. Then there's the Video Player app designed specifically for HD playback.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Used to be 480p but in ICS works like a charm. BUT the app you are running has to be in HD or the phone upscales it a bit but not an actual HD quality. In movies it rocks.
cyberfux said:
I'm getting 1080 with ICS but only on Videoplayback.
Tried several apps to resize the density for "office use" - everytime i had to reflash...
Sent from my ARCHOS 80G9 using XDA Premium HD app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To me MX player works perfect, no problems with the stock samsung player.
Anyway even while the phone upscales the picture if you are at a big screen from the right distance you do not see bad quality. It is actually more than good. In photo gallery the quality is great, same on videos with any player. Only problem? Games. cause the downloaded files are for 800x480 which is low resolution if plagged on a 1080p tv.
Hollow.Droid said:
What's the actual conclusion on the SGS2s HDMI out? I've seen scattered reports of some people getting full 1080p out, others can't get any higher than the native 480x800. Then there's the Video Player app designed specifically for HD playback.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Video resolution is independent of the phones native screen resolution. If the phone is 480*800 and the video is 1920*1080, then provided the media player can output 1080, and the tv being outputted to can display 1080, then the video will be 1080.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA
euklidis said:
Used to be 480p but in ICS works like a charm. BUT the app you are running has to be in HD or the phone upscales it a bit but not an actual HD quality. In movies it rocks.
To me MX player works perfect, no problems with the stock samsung player.
Anyway even while the phone upscales the picture if you are at a big screen from the right distance you do not see bad quality. It is actually more than good. In photo gallery the quality is great, same on videos with any player. Only problem? Games. cause the downloaded files are for 800x480 which is low resolution if plagged on a 1080p tv.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Photo gallery is played on 1080p? are you sure? on GB only videos were 1080
Not 1080p as far as I'm aware it is 1080i isn't it?
I got mines from fleebay, 19 pounds and that included a docking station and a spare battery.
You could always check Dealextreme... they always have good stocks of decent enough products
Wezi said:
Video resolution is independent of the phones native screen resolution. If the phone is 480*800 and the video is 1920*1080, then provided the media player can output 1080, and the tv being outputted to can display 1080, then the video will be 1080.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What if say the video is 720p and your screen only goes up to 720p
My 22" monitor can't do 1080i so I appear to be stuck at 720x480
I got this one from Amazon for £6.99 and a HDMI cable for £2.25, I've only tried it with my TV (which can only do up to 1080i) and I get 1080i on it, no problems at all.
I haven't tried it with my monitor yet (I got it mainly to watch films on my TV without having to burn any disks/buy a NAS or anything) but I can try it to see the 1080p output if requested.
From what I understood it doesn't support 1080p

mhl to hdmi adapter

Just bought 2 from Mertiline... i'm new here and cannot post link so here's product code #0005278. Price is 9.99 but if you buy 2 you'll get at 8.50 each. They're working good, i've just watch 720p video that i took with my T989D and quality is very nice.
That's cool. Im thinking of getting one too. Didn't know they were so reasonable.
Sent from my SGH-T989D using xda app-developers app
Im using the samsung one..really great quality. was $20.00 @ frys i think?..read somewhere that some third party MHL adapters messed the phone up so i decided to use the factory recommended one:good:
i remember seeing the mertiline deal...was about to jump on it, until i realize it doesn't allow me to plug in the charger. I think I'll be ordering one from monoprince that adds an inline USB charging port. But good to see the video quality is good via the converter.
Quality
How is the quality? I want to use mine to watch youtube and downloaded videos on my TV. Is the quality comparable to connecting my laptop to my tv via hdmi.
Thanks
smartypants0 said:
How is the quality? I want to use mine to watch youtube and downloaded videos on my TV. Is the quality comparable to connecting my laptop to my tv via hdmi.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry for the delay, i could not say is comparable to HDMI with your laptop but it's still very nice to watch. I tried youtube videos, WMV, AVI, and 720P MKV Videos without problem,...You can notice some small blur when there.s a lot of movements in the videos. Maybe the Original Samsung Adapter is better than this one, i don't know i don't have one in my hand to compare...
Tornade69 said:
Sorry for the delay, i could not say is comparable to HDMI with your laptop but it's still very nice to watch. I tried youtube videos, WMV, AVI, and 720P MKV Videos without problem,...You can notice some small blur when there.s a lot of movements in the videos. Maybe the Original Samsung Adapter is better than this one, i don't know i don't have one in my hand to compare...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you turn your cell phone screen off while using the adapter?
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
elesbb said:
Can you turn your cell phone screen off while using the adapter?
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No you can't, sleep button is disabled when watching videos!!
Tornade69 said:
Sorry for the delay, i could not say is comparable to HDMI with your laptop but it's still very nice to watch. I tried youtube videos, WMV, AVI, and 720P MKV Videos without problem,...You can notice some small blur when there.s a lot of movements in the videos. Maybe the Original Samsung Adapter is better than this one, i don't know i don't have one in my hand to compare...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
as far as having blurring the samsung one shows none of that..the quality is really great...HD youtube vids and movies play pefectly.:good:
elesbb said:
Can you turn your cell phone screen off while using the adapter?
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you have root check out root-dim. Pretty much the same effect. Dim to 0...
I ordered an mhl adapter off eBay with inline charger ... but it doesn't seem to work... it charges my phone but I get nothing on my television... :/ I have it on proper input .... is there something I am missing?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
I've read other threads saying the ones from e-bay it's a hit and miss... some works some don't!!!
Did you try to reboot while it is plugged ?
I bought the cheapest one I could find for like $5 and it works great. The adapter doesn't seem to work with any of the JellyBean roms, just ICS and lower if that helps.
whenever i use my sgs2 with a MHL adapter the phone goes into 'auto rotation out of control mode' when i switch inputs on the target device. i'm sure it has something to do with it losing HDMI sync, but i've never seen a fix for it which is so damn annoying.
other than that it's pretty nifty.

Categories

Resources