Related
While I do like Swyping, I find that it becomes difficult as one's hands get a tiny bit sweaty or even dirty. You fingers seem to stick to the screen which makes Swyping fairly difficult and almost impossible to be accurate. While I do try to be as clean as possible, sometimes your hands get sweaty for whatever reasons such as if you wear gloves or keep them in your pockets for a while.
I am just wondering if there is a screen protector out there that allows for a totally smooth surface, despite any sweat, dirt or other things that could be on your fingers? I recently got the Realooks and while they are very clear and does a good job resembling the feeling of the bare screen, it has the same issues while Swyping. There may even be a little bit more of a finger resistance with the Realooks on.
I was thinking and thought that maybe a screen protector with a matte finish would be ideal for Swyping. Matte screen protectors are smooth and most are anti-fingerprint which I assume would be very good for Swyping.
Has anyone had any experience with a matte finish screen protector while Swyping?
Any suggestions overall?
i use an anti-glare screen protector from Clarivue (.com) that is matte finish and has a very smooth surface that makes using swype very comfortable and easy. I used clarivue on my N1 as well when i had swype, and i recently got the captivate and i couldnt live without the smooth surface from the screen protector so i had to buy another pack. it is anti scratch and anti smudge, although from what ive seen, it does affect the clarity of the amoled to a certain extent.
I use whatever screen protector that my AT&T store sold - works well with swype.
i have something similar to the invisashield body shield but i cant remember who made mine. i ordered off ebay an in came in an envelope with no branding. like someone with a laser etcher/cutter got a hold of the material and made it in his garage. it has the typical invisishield orange peel look but feels like it has natural oils in it. it is always very slick and doesn't show finger prints. it never feels greasy or sticky or dry. just slightly oily but i have heard that's not typical of the invisishield brand so it might not be the same material. if i come across the add ill post it.
also antiglare protectors are good for that but the ones i bought had bad adhesive on the edges, also i find that anti glare have a good amount of reflection to them and are only better than hard plastic protectors that can be milky, i can read through an invisishield in sunlight better than an anti glare and no screen protector at all is better than that.
Skinomi...I dig it.
kegobeer said:
I use whatever screen protector that my AT&T store sold - works well with swype.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed.
Plus these screen protectors cover the entire front of the phone. Can't even tell it's on there. I've seen others that only cover the display area.
Shovelhead84 said:
Skinomi...I dig it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Dm
Needmorechar
EpicEric said:
Agreed.
Plus these screen protectors cover the entire front of the phone. Can't even tell it's on there. I've seen others that only cover the display area.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
For $10 and you can go buy them locally, it was ideal. Seems to work just as well as without the protector.
Gorilla glass with no screen protector.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
So what do people recommend as the best screen protectors to choose from for the MT4G?
I know everyone has their own opinions on them, but I'm hoping people can post their pros/cons and we can help us all narrow down the choice to a few.
Thanks!
the phantom skinz screen protector! pros: clear, nice feel, covers the whole front. cons: none if installed correctly.
I like the Reallook one. Clear, durable and feels like the glass.
I had the realook and phantom skinz. I settled on phantom skinz. I have the full body matte, plus clear phantom skinz. (Don't install the matte screen protector from PS).
Realook is very good with clear BUT the only thing that sucks is that you get ALOT of oils/fingerprints, etc on it. Easy install and easy clean with soap/water.
Phantom skinz gets oil on the screen too, but not as much. Screen surface is alittle "gummy". (Orange peel is very little to non existant). Watch out as the adhesive backing will attract lint (during installation) and you WILL not be able to get that off. PS also has lifetime warranty = unlimited screen protector replacements. (got the whole kit for $12 during 50% off cyber monday).
Don't bother getting invisible shield, they suck and give you orange peel, and it's thick.
@Jaylito,
Did you notice any kind of cloudiness after you cleaned your screen with alchol/towel? (assuming you've cleaned your screen with alcohol/water) For some reason, mine clouded up on the top.
yeah I have. I guess it's normal tho. goes away if u keep rubbing the screen back & fourth with ur thumb. guess since the material... if it gets wet, it'll cloud a bit cause the moisture seeps thru the inside but it'll dry out bro.
guess I have to do more rubbing then cause it's still cloudy...
oh well....
I tried PhantomSkinz and that was a pain to put on (w/ water and soap), Realook was easy and it didn't peel at the edges.
Zagg Invisishield. Lifetime Warranty.
realook, hands down.
pros: crystal clear, feels like the glass itself, easy to clean, easy to apply, easy to reapply.
cons: a little expensive ($10 for 2, but its totally worth it)
MT4G_Slave said:
I tried PhantomSkinz and that was a pain to put on (w/ water and soap), Realook was easy and it didn't peel at the edges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Weird... for me, PS was MUCH EASIER than realook.
PS allows movement up/down/left/right with ease, and then you just squeeze out water.
For realook, it sucked to align the edges cause you can't move the film once you've "stickered" it on. Then you have to peel it back off and realign, causing lint (in my case) to adhere, and then I have to clean it again.
For me the realook was the best by far. I tried a couple of the wet app kind like invisishield and clear freak on the 4 mt4gs that I had and the realook was the best. I agree its a pain to put on, especially if you have animals because of dust and hair, but if you apply it in the bathroom after letting it steam up from the shower, I've found I can get it on without too much dust or hair falling on the screen. Also, get some extra scotch tape and place it on the front of the realook screen to keep your fingers off the adhesive side while applying it. Another nice thing is that each protector comes with two dots to apply to the camera lens in the back.
The only bad thing is that I think the realook attracts fingerprint grease worse than the wet app kind.
I have a zagg on my nexus s mostly because its all that's out right now and will put a realook on as soon as they are available.
Sent from my Nexus S using XDA App
The Boxwave screen protectores look pretty good too, though I've never tried one myself.
Ghost Armor. Just added it today on my 4G n its cut to fit perfectly, including the sensors n camera. FEELS like the real glass n doesn't take away from the display like the ones Tmo sales. Avoid those *****es like the plague.
I used Zagg for my Nexus S.
I get generic ones from a guy named lcd-protectors on ebay, 5 for $3.50. They're the stiff kind with two protective layers that you peel off, one before you apply and one after. I'm too cheap to pay more.
i just ordered a full body cover kit from stealthguards.com
choosing the clear type and none of the colored ones, it was $2.85 (full body protection, just pay shipping)
$2.85 sure beats dishing out $25 for zagg which is the same crap.
What do you need a screen protector for? I haven't used a screen protector since I bought the G1 at launch, and I've never had a screen scratch. Keys in my pockets, etc. Never been a problem. These screens are incredibly scratch resistant.
I love these screen protectors that I bought on Amazon. Perfect on the first try with no bubbles! Check it out here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B004E49TEG/ref=mp_s_a_1?qid=1294786757&sr=8-1:
BoxWare screen protector is well IDK how to rate it as it is just regular. What I did not like about it was it does "NOT" fully cover the screen as you have little gap very small which bugs me as I am neat. The feeling right now is artificial as I can tell it is there maybe cuz its still new as I applied it just 2hours ago. So lets wait and see how it turns out in long run.
I grabbed a Reallook screen protector off of amazon:
Pros: The feel and clarity are great
Cons: The cut. It has a cutout for the FFC and leaves a fair bit of space on all sides (as a result it's easy to get on) but it's really short on all sides in my opinion.
Part Four said:
What do you need a screen protector for? I haven't used a screen protector since I bought the G1 at launch, and I've never had a screen scratch. Keys in my pockets, etc. Never been a problem. These screens are incredibly scratch resistant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tell that to the scratch in my screen that I got the first day of having the phone... yeah, needless to say, I have a screen protector now and its helped a lot.
Sent from my HTC Glacier using XDA App
Full Body Kits:
TOP PICK - SGP (Extremely Thin, Glossy, or Matte, $26 per kit) - Recommended by 3 people
Best Skins Ever ($9 per kit) - Recommended by 3 people
Skinomi ($20 per kit) - Recommended by 1 person
Phantom Skinz (Glossy or Matte, 2 kits for $25) - Recommended by 1 person
Use code "spring20" to get 20% off at phantomskinz.com - Thanks for the tip beazie0885
Ghost Armor ($25 per kit) - Recommended by 1 person
Xtreme Guard ($5 per kit) - Recommended by 1 person
BodyGuardz (Regular or "Dry Apply", 2 kits for $25) - Can anyone recommend BodyGuardz? (Generally Neutral offsite)
ZAGG InvisibleSHIELD (Maximum Coverage and Easy Install, $25 per kit) - Not Recommended by 3 people
Screen Protector Only:
SGP Screen Protectors($14-$16 per kit, Crystal, Fine, and Oleophobic) - Recommended by 1 person
EMPIRE Screen Protector (~$5 for one protector) - Recommended by 1 person
Reviews:
SGP Review by Supish
Well its a dry apply screen protector so it is a little by harder to apply than wet applications. However, it is very smooth, almost no resistance and comparable to the naked screen (almost). Absolutely no yellowing as well and still no scratches so far. Good angle visability and not more of a lint/oil magnet than the naked screen. The one I got was advertised as ultra oleophobic meaning it resists oils, I guess it works.
SGP Oleophobic Screen Protector Review by cheetah2k
I've just received the SGP Oleophobic screen protector. It took me a whole 2 minutes to install and is totally bubble free. You get 2 protectors in each packet, plus bubble removal card, cleaning cloth and 4 dust removal stickers.
Definitely the most complete screen protector on the market.
And it works!!! Awesome i give it 10/10
Skinomi Review by djkinetic:
i use the skinomi screen protectors and they are great in my experience, at the time i ordered it it was the only one available, it is a wet apply, put it on align it, and let it dry and its nearly invisible no bubbles, the material is polyurethane, and supposedly has a uv coating to prevent yellowing, it feels smooth when using the touch screen even tho the texture seems rubbery, its weird cuz u can definately tell its a different texture but ur finger still glides over the touch screen like nothin is there. Only downside is that if u knick the protector it doesnt self repair, for example if u press hard on the film with a fingernail it will leave an imprint that doesnt go away. However they do offer lifetime replacements, overall id recommend it.
Ghost Armor Review by cegna09
Used them on my Aria, and now my Atrix. They are awesome if only for the warranty alone. Great coverage of the phone, great protection, awesome at hiding finger grease on the screen. And if you ever need it replaced they send a new one no questions asked, just mail the old one back to them. Had it on my Aria for 6 months without problems, then switched phones.
EMPIRE Screen Protector Review by vin791
bought the empire screen protector from amazon for $4 (free 2 day shipping w/ amazon student) and it rocks. there's a ~.5mm border on the sides and ~1mm border on the top, doesn't both me though and its super clear. i got it perfectly aligned on the 2nd lay down with no bubbles or dust (make sure you wipe it down really good with the cloth they send). its easier when you start from the top of the phone instead of the bottom. i oull the whole sticky side protector off, align the top and kind of guide it straight towards the bottom. the card they send removes any bubbles that are there at first. no worries. as long as you cleaned the surface well and theres no dust, you shouldn't have bubbles when you're done. great and inexpensive product (compared to competitors)
InvisibleSHIELD Maximum Coverage Review by kmiller8:
Immediately after I applied the skin, I could tell instantly I would love it, mainly because of the texture/feel of the plastic "skin" applied to the phone. It added a nice rubbery feel to it while at the same time not making it any harder (maybe even a little easier) to use the OSK and Swype. You can see in the album on pics 2 and 5 where I had a bit of trouble applying, but those could have been easily avoided, had I taken just a few more minutes to make the skin more even throughout the phone. However the edges of the cover are a HUGE lint magnet especially in pockets but I think (hope) that this is just because it was recently applied. Also, it still fits perfectly in the Standard and Car Dock In the pictures it appears as if there are little bubbles throughout the skin, this is not visible under normal lighting, but the flash of the camera seems to have over exaggerated it.
EDIT: After a few weeks with the protector, I ended up removing the part covering the glass, The atrix just looks SOOO much better without a skin protector on the front, but I did keep the ones on the side and back because it adds a much needed grip to the back of the phone.
Fin
I hope this helps someone decide whether or not to get one of these skins, and personally I like the fact that it appears as if it is just the bare phone, but there is a nice layer of protection throughout the phone, however others will equally enjoy a nice OtterBox Defender or Incipio Feather case (two previous options).
If anyone has any questions feel free to ask, or if you have any suggestions to be added to the first post (kit recommendations, personal reviews) reply below!
I've used invisibleshield on other phones and the lint at the edges problem only got worse...
nomisunrider said:
I've used invisibleshield on other phones and the lint at the edges problem only got worse...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
do you know of any ways to reduce the lint problem? i was thinking of trying to do something along the edges to remove some of the adhesive
Man, i like invisibleshield but i HATE the yellowing that is guaranteed to happen, and even the peeling of the corners that happens VERY often. makes me rage
Yellowing, corner adhesion, edge lint, and texture = no way Invisibleshield is going on my phone. I used it on my Fuze and it was awful.
Is there any other kind of "full body" clear protector that is better?
Phantomskinz.com is the best imo
No joke. And I think its cheaper too
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
beazie0885 said:
Phantomskinz.com is the best imo
No joke. And I think its cheaper too
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Whats the texture of the phantomskin? like is it smooth like the regular phone or more "rubbery" like the Zagg shields.
Also, they're the same price $25 before shipping, but i do like how phantomskinz has a matte version avialable
EDIT: nevermind, apparently you get two kits for $25. i might just try out a set.
EDIT 2: heavily modified first part of first post to provide links to both Zagg and Phantom Skinz. and other places
Didn't see the Best Skins Ever shield on here. I used their product on my iPhone and its held up good.
Here's the link for their Atrix product http://www.bestskinsever.com/motorola-atrix-4g-skin
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
i have the best skins ever full body on my atrix and i love it. the pieces are cut perfectly and install fairly easily. i love that it adds some much needed grip to an otherwise super slippery device
projekt1 said:
Didn't see the Best Skins Ever shield on here. I used their product on my iPhone and its held up good.
Here's the link for their Atrix product http://www.bestskinsever.com/motorola-atrix-4g-skin
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hondaguy said:
i have the best skins ever full body on my atrix and i love it. the pieces are cut perfectly and install fairly easily. i love that it adds some much needed grip to an otherwise super slippery device
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Added to first post.
Looking at total body skin photos on their website.
Does the body cover wrap around and prevent one from pulling the back cover off?
Sort of looks like it does...
i use the skinomi screen protectors and they are great in my experience, at the time i ordered it it was the only one available, it is a wet apply, put it on align it, and let it dry and its nearly invisible no bubbles, the material is polyurethane, and supposedly has a uv coating to prevent yellowing, it feels smooth when using the touch screen even tho the texture seems rubbery, its weird cuz u can definately tell its a different texture but ur finger still glides over the touch screen like nothin is there. Only downside is that if u knick the protector it doesnt self repair, for example if u press hard on the film with a fingernail it will leave an imprint that doesnt go away. However they do offer lifetime replacements, overall id recommend it.
kmiller8 said:
Whats the texture of the phantomskin? like is it smooth like the regular phone or more "rubbery" like the Zagg shields.
Also, they're the same price $25 before shipping, but i do like how phantomskinz has a matte version avialable
EDIT: nevermind, apparently you get two kits for $25. i might just try out a...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its like glass on the screen, ive only used the chromatics on the back of my cappy, but I prefer a tpu case anyways. I did like the chromatics though.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
djkinetic said:
i use the skinomi screen protectors and they are great in my experience, at the time i ordered it it was the only one available, it is a wet apply, put it on align it, and let it dry and its nearly invisible no bubbles, the material is polyurethane, and supposedly has a uv coating to prevent yellowing, it feels smooth when using the touch screen even tho the texture seems rubbery, its weird cuz u can definately tell its a different texture but ur finger still glides over the touch screen like nothin is there. Only downside is that if u knick the protector it doesnt self repair, for example if u press hard on the film with a fingernail it will leave an imprint that doesnt go away. However they do offer lifetime replacements, overall id recommend it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea I have the skinomi screen protector on the atrix as well, and the first day I nicked it with my fingertip and its still there. Also my buddy tried to use the hard end of a capacitive stylus on it and messed it all up... I just ordered a protector from phantom skinz because I only had one on my captivate the whole time Ive had it (since launch) and it still looks brand new. Feels just like skinomi but repairs itself, and you get two for $9.99...
Edit: Use code "spring20" to get 20% off at phantomskinz.com
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
djkinetic said:
i use the skinomi screen protectors and they are great in my experience, at the time i ordered it it was the only one available, it is a wet apply, put it on align it, and let it dry and its nearly invisible no bubbles, the material is polyurethane, and supposedly has a uv coating to prevent yellowing, it feels smooth when using the touch screen even tho the texture seems rubbery, its weird cuz u can definately tell its a different texture but ur finger still glides over the touch screen like nothin is there. Only downside is that if u knick the protector it doesnt self repair, for example if u press hard on the film with a fingernail it will leave an imprint that doesnt go away. However they do offer lifetime replacements, overall id recommend it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
beazie0885 said:
Edit: Use code "spring20" to get 20% off at phantomskinz.com
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you both for you contributions to the thread, both added to first post!
Get a sgp steinheil screen protector. Now that's a screen protector you can't tell that's on
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Supish said:
Get a sgp steinheil screen protector. Now that's a screen protector you can't tell that's on
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you elaboate? Like yellowing? Lint magnent? Angle viewability? Scratch resistant etc etc.
So from this thread and other similar to it:
I should go with either Best skin ever or Phantom Skinz. Question for those that are using the Phantom Skin, did you get the clear or matt finish? What's the difference?
-Roze- said:
Can you elaboate? Like yellowing? Lint magnent? Angle viewability? Scratch resistant etc etc.
So from this thread and other similar to it:
I should go with either Best skin ever or Phantom Skinz. Question for those that are using the Phantom Skin, did you get the clear or matt finish? What's the difference?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well its a dry apply screen protector so it is a little by harder to apply than wet applications. However, it is very smooth, almost no resistance and comparable to the naked screen (almost). Absolutely no yellowing as well and still no scratches so far. Good angle visability and not more of a lint/oil magnet than the naked screen. The one I got was advertised as ultra oleophobic meaning it resists oils, I guess it works.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Supish said:
Well its a dry apply screen protector so it is a little by harder to apply than wet applications. However, it is very smooth, almost no resistance and comparable to the naked screen (almost). Absolutely no yellowing as well and still no scratches so far. Good angle visability and not more of a lint/oil magnet than the naked screen. The one I got was advertised as ultra oleophobic meaning it resists oils, I guess it works.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Updated first post with your review. Thank you for that.
I was going to try a Phantom Skinz, but ended up sticking with no screen protector whatsoever
I have tried about 3 protectors so far, and always end up taking them off and feeling happier. Seems like they all either feel too weird on my finger, peel too easily, or in one case it was good for a little but over time had too much indents and the look of small warping in spots. As soon as I take one off, screen looks better, and feels better. I know gorilla glass can be scratched but I really wonder if a screen protector is truly necessary. If I never bring the phone in contact with sand or diamonds is there anything else I need to worry about? Also, will a screen protector help prevent the screen from cracking if the phone is dropped?
sfetaz said:
I have tried about 3 protectors so far, and always end up taking them off and feeling happier. Seems like they all either feel too weird on my finger, peel too easily, or in one case it was good for a little but over time had too much indents and the look of small warping in spots. As soon as I take one off, screen looks better, and feels better. I know gorilla glass can be scratched but I really wonder if a screen protector is truly necessary. If I never bring the phone in contact with sand or diamonds is there anything else I need to worry about? Also, will a screen protector help prevent the screen from cracking if the phone is dropped?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. I have a Zagg screen protector on my S3, and recently bought an Incipio case (which I love), however, the screen protector is peeling off in the corners, which makes it look ugly. Probably going to rip it off soon.
Agreed.
So far I've tried:
1. Skinomi -- Wet protectors suck. They produce a "rainbow glitter" effect on the screen, you notice it especially when its white.
2. Diztronic/cheapo -- The outward curved screen causes cheapo protectors not to lay flat.
3. SGP Nano 3pack -- Doesn't offer much protection. I screwed up the 1st one putting it on, and the 2nd one I managed to put scratches in it with their damn PLASTIC air bubble removal tool!
Oh well, 90% of the scratches on my Galaxy S1 were from me being lazy and putting the phone on surfaces screen-down. Having a case with a large lip around the edges will prevent a majority of the scratches (I already keep one pocket dedicated for phone-only).
I have the spg Nano on and it does get scratched easily. On the other hand I have a friend with the same phone so we split a pack and did rock paper scissors for the 3rd screen protector.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
Can't stand some screen protectors. The Zagg and those expensive ones have the orange peel effect and can get indents which is ugly. The wet apply ones have the rainbow affect and the cheap ones come off easy and don't protect lol. I've said screw it. So far I have no scratches and my case keeps the screen from surface contact. Whatever.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
I'm using the one provided with Otter box and aside from it smearing easily and having to wipe it off quite a bit, its not too shabby considering I usually liken screen protectors to raincoats. BTW if you're looking into a case, an otter box is pretty good. A bit pricy ($35 from Fry's), but so far solid. Not to mention it raises the edges making it difficult to irritate the protector/start peeling
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
jnadke said:
Agreed.
So far I've tried:
1. Skinomi -- Wet protectors suck. They produce a "rainbow glitter" effect on the screen, you notice it especially when its white.
2. Diztronic/cheapo -- The outward curved screen causes cheapo protectors not to lay flat.
3. SGP Nano 3pack -- Doesn't offer much protection. I screwed up the 1st one putting it on, and the 2nd one I managed to put scratches in it with their damn PLASTIC air bubble removal tool!
Oh well, 90% of the scratches on my Galaxy S1 were from me being lazy and putting the phone on surfaces screen-down. Having a case with a large lip around the edges will prevent a majority of the scratches (I already keep one pocket dedicated for phone-only).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha that's funny, because I do the exact same for my pocket as well! I'm using diztronic protector and it sucks major balls!
When I get my now replacement white s3. My phone will be naked
Sent from my SGH-T999 using xda app-developers app
I'm not sure about the rest of you, but for now it seems like we can't get a good screen protector for the S3. All the flexible film based protectors dent too easy. This includes protectors like the SGP Curved Crystal. This review below clearly shows what I mean about easily denting. It also has issues with tight fitting cases.
Then if we go for a screen protector that doesn't dent so easy, they end up not covering enough of the screen. The SPG Ultra Clear nano and Ultra Crystal (2nd version) both don't dent like the Curved Crystal, but they don't cover enough of the screen. Especially the sides. So swiping near the edges you can easily feel the ridge. Ruins the smooth experience of the S3. Would be nice if Spiegen does a revision of the Curved Crystal like they did with the Ultra Crystal and made it so it didn't dent so easily. I definitely don't want to go with tempered glass as its just too thick. I am currently using a Realook Flex Film, and it covers the whole screen nicely, but has orange peal and dents easy just like the other flexible films out there. Realook now has a "3D forming crystal clear" protector. It covers the whole screen and uses their PET material for the main part of the screen, which should prevent the denting effect. I'll give this one a try, if it's not that great, I may just use no protector and go with a flip case. Anyone else have any suggestions.
Here's a pic of what I mean with not covering the whole screen for the Spigen SGP screen protectors.
This is what I just bought.. not sure when it's going to arrive but it should fit your criteria better?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/261072327014?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649
Ignore that link. I just recieved it and it doesn't cover the whole screen completely.
Search for the threads. There has been plenty of this
Sent from my SGH-T999
Xcor3 said:
Search for the threads. There has been plenty of this
Sent from my SGH-T999
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To be honest, I've searched far and wide through the threads and Spigen seems to be the protector of choice. But once I look at reviews of those protectors elsewhere (like the YouTube video I posted) I end up seeing that they're not that great. I'm beginning to think that we have to go with either the flip cover protector or go with a hard film protector that doesn't cover the whole screen in order to get that glass like experience. All the soft film based protectors just dent to easy or have some orange peel effect. It just ruins the beautiful display of the S3.
Tempott said:
I'm not sure about the rest of you, but for now it seems like we can't get a good screen protector for the S3. All the flexible film based protectors dent too easy. This includes protectors like the SGP Curved Crystal. This review below clearly shows what I mean about easily denting. It also has issues with tight fitting cases.
Then if we go for a screen protector that doesn't dent so easy, they end up not covering enough of the screen. The SPG Ultra Clear nano and Ultra Crystal (2nd version) both don't dent like the Curved Crystal, but they don't cover enough of the screen. Especially the sides. So swiping near the edges you can easily feel the ridge. Ruins the smooth experience of the S3. Would be nice if Spiegen does a revision of the Curved Crystal like they did with the Ultra Crystal and made it so it didn't dent so easily. I definitely don't want to go with tempered glass as its just too thick. I am currently using a Realook Flex Film, and it covers the whole screen nicely, but has orange peal and dents easy just like the other flexible films out there. Realook now has a "3D forming crystal clear" protector. It covers the whole screen and uses their PET material for the main part of the screen, which should prevent the denting effect. I'll give this one a try, if it's not that great, I may just use no protector and go with a flip case. Anyone else have any suggestions.
Here's a pic of what I mean with not covering the whole screen for the Spigen SGP screen protectors.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are correct, the Ultra nano does not cover the entire screen. Really though, it makes it perfect for use with a case. The amount no covered is so minimal when using most cases that it's not concern, for me anyway.
I use the screen protector that came with my otterbox case and it has served me well so far. It doesn't cover the whole screen but then again, if it did it would come off when I used a case.
werked said:
You are correct, the Ultra nano does not cover the entire screen. Really though, it makes it perfect for use with a case. The amount no covered is so minimal when using most cases that it's not concern, for me anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use the genuine Samsung Super Slim case which I feel gives the scratch protection I need for the back and sides of the phone, while adding practically no bulk to the phone. So an edge to edge screen protector would have no issues for me. If only Spigen would use the same material they use for the Ultra Nano or Ultra Crystal in their Curved Crystal protector it would be perfect. It's really too bad the Curved Crystal dents/creases so easily as shows in the above video.
I like what zagg did for the iPhone. They make a case friendly screen protector. I like having that option. If you plan to use a case then it's a perfect choice. If going to use no case or a snap on case then a regular screen protector suits just fine. It would be nice for companies to show android some love in this respect of options.
werked said:
You are correct, the Ultra nano does not cover the entire screen. Really though, it makes it perfect for use with a case. The amount no covered is so minimal when using most cases that it's not concern, for me anyway.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you can pick up the SGP Flex HD. They cover the entire screen, and is hard to see that it is actually there. It feels smooth as well. Also it doesn't leave much finger prints on there
It seems you haven't looked hard enough, I have a thread on a skinplayer 3D mask film, 99.5% full coverage and has a self healing surface, flexible PET screen protector.
I use the zagg invisishield. Best one I've used yet. I also use it on my tablet. It's more expensive, but worth it. Of course I got mine from best buy the second day the phone was out. So there were only two to choose from ,and I didn't want to wait for one to be shipped to me.
It's designed to fill itself in for minor dents and scratches (I possibly butchered that explanation, but I think you understand). Also, it can be removed and reapplied.
The best part though, is that it's so clear it doesn't detract from the screen. In the past when I would use a screen protector it would always look like a filter was on my screen. Hated it. They've come a long ways in that aspect.
Sent from my SPH-L710 using xda app-developers app
I noticed nobody mentioned Wrapsol. Their ultra line is pretty tough. It comes with a back protector too.
adamdavidson said:
I noticed nobody mentioned Wrapsol. Their ultra line is pretty tough. It comes with a back protector too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not 100% coverage, but excellent quality.
I hate when people ask about screen protectors because that means they obviously don't know about the best one out there. It is called clear-coat. Google it. Ive had it on all my phones. It is perfect. It doesn't come off unless you peel it off and leaves no residue behind. Most malls have a station that sells it and puts it on for you. If you watch videos of it you will see a guy scratching his iphone against rock and then peeling it off and no marks on the screen. Best way to go by far. It is also covered by a lifetime guarantee.
Skinomi - - - - very nice!
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app
Seidio
Sent from my HTC EVO 4G ELTE using Tapatalk 2
Can't believe no one said real look screen protectors.
Sent from my JellyBean Galaxys3
Vikuiti!
I'm currently using Vikuiti screen protectors, and they're working out pretty well. It attracts fingerprints a bit, but nothing a quick wipe doesn't get rid of~
I'm not really so sure why everyone is so worried about the very edges of the screen that the Ultra Nano doesn't cover. It's a great protector that you can barely even tell is there, and it covers all of the important and useful parts of the screen just fine. I've been using it for 2 months and it still looks great, plus I've had no issues at all with scratches on the edges that aren't covered. Using it with a Diztronic TPU case. Put a case on your phone and the combination seems perfect to me.
I've been using vikuiti ( a less mentioned brand for screen protectors I think) and it's been working perfectly fine with the genuine galaxy s3 clear TPU case. No scratches on the phone or screen protector, I never really understood how people had to cycle through so many screen protectors. Best of luck to you finding your preferred sp!