Samsung Epic 4g Modem Data Performance Comparision. - Epic 4G Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

For testing I will run 2 different speedtest apps for data transfer speed, then I will use the stock web browser to test how long loading a full webpage takes.
Speed will be posted below as measured in mbps. Webpage loads will be measured in seconds.
Modem Ping Download Upload Xbitlabs.com
DK28 125ms 1.8 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 13 seconds
EB13 120ms 1.9 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 13 seconds
EC05 140ms 1.8 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 16 seconds
EE03 116ms 2.0 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 9 seconds
EF02 140ms 1.9 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 9 seconds
EF10 144ms 1.5 Mbps 0.7 Mbps 14 seconds
EG22 130ms 2.0 Mbps 0.6 Mbps 9 seconds
EH06 150ms 1.8 Mbps 0.3 Mbps 12 seconds
EH17 145ms 1.7 Mbps 0.5 Mbps 14 seconds
I performed all of the 3g speedtests using the leaked android 2.34 EH17.
As you can see the results that I was able to achieve are really good.
I am located in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and the 3g speeds over here
are usually horrible, but in this particular area I was able to get great results.
I will be performing another set of data testing near Baker, La.
Over there the 3g speeds are slow and unstable, and although 4g is
available in that area I will be testing as far as possible from the 4g tower to
find out which modem can perform the best with very low 4g signal.

Inspired by HafizNafes, I decided to try a few of these where I live as well, in Raleigh. Sadly, 4G is not available at my house. Using Airave for 3G tests, so included a WiFi to show speeds for comparison.
Epic 4G Stock EC05, Genocide 2.0 Kernel
SpeedTest app, connecting to Greensboro (NC) server
Average 3G Connection tests (to Airave)
EC05: 318ms/P, 1.48Mbps/D, 0.45Mbps/U (5 samples)
EE03: 327ms/P, 1.43Mbps/D, 0.45Mbps/U (4 samples)
EG22: 302ms/P, 1.33Mbps/D, 0.49Mbps/U (4 samples)
EH17: 342ms/P, 1.51Mbps/D, 0.46Mbps/U (5 samples)
WIFI: 68ms/P,22.25Mbps/D, 0.98Mbps/U (3 samples)

Copied over from the thread I started in general (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1328260)
Location: Greenville, SC
Tweaks Tests
Test 1. No reboot, no adds, EC05 Server: Toledo OH
9:55 AM
209,523,528
Test 2. Reboot, no adds, EC05 Server: Toledo OH
10:00 AM
231,381.6,413.2
Test 3. Reboot, no adds, Fresh EC05 odin with EFS Clear Server: Augusta, GA
10:15 AM
184,414.6,533.4
Test 4. Reboot, Supercharger V6 version 8, EC05 Server: Atlanta, GA
10:52 AM
205.8,404.2,605
Test 5. Reboot, SCV6, 3G Turbocharger3 update 11 setting 1 (fast). EC05 Server:Ringgold, GA
11:12
322.4,527,605.6
Test 6 Reboot, SCV6, 3G T3 update 11 setting 3 (fastest) EC05 Server: Atl, GA
11:24
196.8,319,489
Modem Test (abbreviated)
EC05; Retest for control; Time 13:24; Server Augusta, GA
288.4,221.4,456
EH17; Time 13:50; Server Atlanta, GA
272.4,164,342.2
EG22; Time 14:20; Server Bixby, OK
231.6,280.4,437
Gingerbread Tests
Gingerbread EH17 With EH17 Modem Tests
Test 1: No addons, very stock GB, Background Data off. Did 10 runs instead of 5, was getting very inconsistent results. 5 results had DL's less than 100, one as low as 35, and one run DL was 544. Confusing. Upload was relatively consistent.
311,162.6,316.7

Looks to me like you are having serious problems with your data speeds.
Any thing less than 600 kbps on sprint network is not good.
I also have problems where I live but at least I am able to use 4g here in baker louisiana.

HafizNafes89 said:
Looks to me like you are having serious problems with your data speeds.
Any thing less than 600 kbps on sprint network is not good.
I also have problems where I live but at least I am able to use 4g here in baker louisiana.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately here in Greenville, SC, those data speeds are a fact of life, best I can tell. I would very much like to see someone else here in Gville post some data results that show different, but I dont know anyone personally here that has a sprint phone. It does not seem to matter what rom, modem, tweaks i use, those are the speeds I get. These test mirror tests I did about 2 months ago as well. Oh, and an added bonus, our sprint stores here are abysmal, staffed by idiots, and I have to pay 10 dollars a month for 4g that it is not available anywhere in the entire state. All this talk about not having a data cap or throttling on the sprint network is irrelevant for me, because without 4g and with 3g speeds like that, I could never reach a cap even if one existed. At least here, Sprint is a massive joke on all fronts, and I wish I had never signed a contract with them.

I think that sprint is broke and they cannot afford to serve reliable high speed data to all of their customers. Next time I complain to them im going to make sure I tell them that.
I dont know why would sprint spend $6 billion to start selling iphones when they could have used that money to go all over the country fixing their 3g. But they keep denying that something is wrong with their 3g and telling customers to make sure that their prl is updated, which means nothing if sprint acually had data towers in our areas.

Any data for the EI22 modem?

In the same area I pulled 2.2 mbps download and 1.0 mbps upload using the new modem.
but it was during the morning at about 8am.

HafizNafes89 said:
I think that sprint is broke and they cannot afford to serve reliable high speed data to all of their customers. Next time I complain to them im going to make sure I tell them that.
I dont know why would sprint spend $6 billion to start selling iphones when they could have used that money to go all over the country fixing their 3g. But they keep denying that something is wrong with their 3g and telling customers to make sure that their prl is updated, which means nothing if sprint acually had data towers in our areas.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is So Ture i live in newton nj and still No 3g but Sprint Still Claims there is 3g in the area..... and with the new "PRL" surveys is Worst then Ever

I have a motorola photon now and 3g speeds in my home area are still less than 150kbps.
sprint should lower are bills until they can get their stuff fixed. Its not fair that we have to pay more than t-mobile users with such horiffic service.

however in downtown my 3g speeds are incredible. the same can be said for 4g.
EI22 modem.
3g: 2.5 Mbps download 1.5 Mbps upload 95ms ping
4g: 9.2 mbps download 1.2 Mbps upload 100ms ping

Related

T-Mobile Network Upgrade

I don't know if anyone else has noticed, but anything related to the internet is about 10 times faster today for me... I thought i had my wi-fi on until I read a post about T-Mobile's 7.2 rollout. I suggest you all check out your speeds.
Speed checked, maybe this had somethign to do with the service outtage the other night LOL
Speed Increase? Not here
I purchased my TP2 in part because T-Mobile's web site indicated full 3G coverage here in Centerville, Ohio. I've had the phone for a week now, and have YET to see the 3G connection on the phone. The E is all I ever see, and that speed has not increased since the outage.
Maybe your local tower was upgraded.
Zylograth said:
Speed checked, maybe this had somethign to do with the service outtage the other night LOL
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was thinking that very thing. Except without the "lol"
Maybe your local tower was upgraded.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Engadget is reporting that none of their tests are showing the new speeds yet, so it does appear to be limited to certain markets at this point.
so how do i increse my network speed if i have a speed of 177 with 3g
T-mobil HSPA roll out
T-mobile has started to roll out HSPA 7.2 mb in all 3G network areas. Go to www.tmonews.com to read up on it. They are trying to get most of the network up by the end of DEC. HSPA is much faster than 3g...about 3x.
Richard
To have 177 you must have a poor RF.
Honestly, I have 5mbps over Wi-Fi and that's more than the TP2 can handle for browsing. It doesn't load pages much faster vs a good 3G signal.
well i got 544 now that i have hspa turned on
Damn, I am in seattle and I range from 500kbps to over 3kbps via mobilespeedtest.com
here in phoenix i can get 3mbps on the handset and up to 9.3mbps thering on my laptop i even started playing call of duty using ics and see little lag. i am debating on canceling my cox subscription. i noticed this the day after the data outage. i can post speed tests if you dont believe me
i shouldnt have spoke so soon i only could get a max of 8.7 just now but im only at 3 bars on h on this side of my house... ill run further tests later...
here is test on speedtest
here is test on bandwithplace
Last Result:
Download Speed: 1988 kbps (248.5 KB/sec transfer rate)
Upload Speed: 355 kbps (44.4 KB/sec transfer rate)
Saturday, November 28, 2009 7:11:36 PM
dsl reports did not work because it said m,y connection was too fast for a mobile speed test
That is very nice, considering T-Mobile had their HSPA network crippled at a 4th of that a few months ago.
Testmyiphone.com works well, but the TP2 never ever registers higher than 2.17mbps over Wi-Fi. There is a limitation or something happening there because my iPhone averages over 4mbps(Wi-Fi) on the same site/same connection. Nevertheless it's accurate - over 3G here I get about 600-700kbps so no upgrades have been put online here.

T-Mobile 3G Users Welcome to HSPA 7.2 Mbps

So anybody who gets T-Mobile 3G now is able to take advantage of The new upgraded HSPA 7.2Mbps 3.5G network. Phone that are able to take advantage of this are the HTC G1, HTC MyTouch, HTC Dash 3G, HTC Touch Pro 2, Samsung Behold 2,and I believe the Blackberry 9700.
Check your speed using you phone browser at www.mobilespeedtest.com
Here is my speed in Miami, Fl.
Must not be in every market. 3g In phoenix seems to top out around 250kbps...at least right now.
Should in all 3G markets. It might be rolling out to different cities throughout the day.
http://www.tmonews.com/2010/01/t-mobile-officially-upgrades-to-hspa-7-2mbps/
Also try doing the 1Mb or larger test.
Yeah you're probably right. I'll just keep checking through the day. These speeds will nearly make the fee for 3g worth it.
Mine is 541kps, is that good? lol Have no idea about phone speeds.
The way ISPs advertise speeds is in bits. When we download is its bytes. So 7.2MBPS should be equilvalent to 7200 / 8 = 900 Kbytes a sec. So 900kbps should be max on our phones which is in between dsl and cable modem speeds. This is of course on the Tmobile Network. The fastest I got on my Tmobile TP2 was 800kbps full 3G bars.
I'm in the Tampa Bay area with full 3g bars. I did the 1MB test and got 717kb's per second. Not sure how to tell if I improved from before tmobile "upgraded" to hspa
mpicart said:
I'm in the Tampa Bay area with full 3g bars. I did the 1MB test and got 717kb's per second. Not sure how to tell if I improved from before tmobile "upgraded" to hspa
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sound just about right for 7.2MBPS.
WOW!!!! 6283 kbps here in PA
i have 727.273 with about 2 bars..is that good?
michealmyers said:
i have 727.273 with about 2 bars..is that good?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Me too, just about the same, which is an upgrade at least 50% from before. I can't wait to try it out at work tomorrow with a full signal!!!
1774kbps in phoenix right now...pretty decent...
I have always used :
http://www.dslreports.com/mspeed?jisok=1&more=1
However the site posted here gives me much better results, so I think I prefer it. Bit odd though.
Ok guys. When you test it out it gives yous the small download test. You need to retest at 2Mb or higher to see the real speed. I used the 7Mb test to test my connection and was consistently getting 6500Kbps - 7000Kbps
I noticed quite a difference between Opera and Opera 10 Beta. What's the most accurate browser to use?
To get a "true" test I use Internet Explorer
Too bad all this speed won't mean **** because our CPU is slow. You will only take advantage of these speeds when you tether to your computer.
Not sure the test is reliable, got so many reading on my end. 700+kps, sometimes 25kps (huh????) sometime 650++, etc.
I've tried 3 times using dslreports simple mobile test. 1MB and got
~700kb
~800kb
~900kb
thaddyusmaximus said:
I've tried 3 times using dslreports simple mobile test. 1MB and got
~700kb
~800kb
~900kb
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I'm now getting all over this range.
I am unable to test with PIE for some reason though. Just hangs at "running test"

[Q] Slow DATA speeds!!! Post your speed test results

NY Queens Speedtest results to nearest NY server 15miles away.
3g
94ms ping
.14Mbps Down
.30Mbps Up
Roam Control roaming
1x
803ms ping
.11Mbps Down
.18Mbps Up
WiFi Speedtest
63ms ping
6.46Mbps Down
.38Mbps Up
srf 1.2 EB13 modem Twilight zone v1.1.1 kernel
I believe i should get better speed any advice greatly appreciated.
Upgrade your modem
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA Premium App
I tried them all eb13 seems a bit faster. What speeds do you get
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
What speed test are you using? I was using. Speedtest from ookla. It worked fine the 1st day but seemed to have. A loss in data after that. I normally got to speakeasy.net/speedtest with my pc. And I was getting around 18 mb dl. And 2mb ul. But my phone on wifi would barly get 1mb dl. I went to the website with my phone and boom it showed me real results. On 3g. At home I get 2.03 mb dl. .44 mb ul. And wifi. I get 12.8 mb dl and 2.08 mb ul. I am currently on stock with no tweaks. So. Try a different speed test unless u notice the lack of speed
Edit: I just changed the server for the speedtest by ookla to chicago. My closest server is kalamazoo, mi. But I changed to chicago and my results were a lot closer to the websites. So try changing he server to a different one
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA Premium App
lucifermoh said:
I tried them all eb13 seems a bit faster. What speeds do you get
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
on eg22 modem, for 3g i get about 1.4mbps upload about 700-800kbps
4g i get 5-8mbps, and upload is 1.4mbps
Test Date: Aug 12, 2011 5:34:59 pm
Connection Type: EvdoA
Server: El Paso, TX
Download: 0.05 Mbps
Upload: 0.10 Mbps
Ping: 450 ms
External IP: 174.18.152.6
Internal IP: 174.18.152.6
Latitude: 31.79275
Longitude: -106.27708
I wish I could get 4g this is my 3g its horrible and I'm on the EG22 modem which was the fastest for me
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
On EG22 I get between 1500-1700 kBs download and 700 up on an Airave.
Running SyndicateROM Frozen 1.2, Genocide kernel 2.0, EG22 modem
Inside my house:
Down: 169kbps
Up: 22kbps
Ping: 440ms
Bars: 1/4
Outside my house:
Down: 367kbps
Up: 290kbps
Ping: 369ms
Bars: 3/4
I live in a one story woodframe home and I lose 2 bars by just going inside.
Fastes 4G result:
1952kbps
1224kbps
351 kbps
Send from my SPH-D700 (Samsung Epic 4G)
kwazytazz said:
Upgrade your modem
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not anyones modem. It's Sprint! My gf and I both have different phones and for the past two weeks both phones data speeds have been complete garbage.
Server Los Angeles
Down 871 kbps
Up 318 kbps
Server Phoenix
Down 847 kbps
Up 88 kbps
LMFAO! Unacceptable
Sprint is definately capping the WiMax through the Realm and possibly a 2nd place. I used to get 7MBps regularly on my downloads. Now I get in the 3 to 5 range. People that use Clear directly don't have this happen. I did some testing with my Clear mac address on my Epic and the download speeds were regularly much higher.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Oh, forgot my screenie. In between L.A. and Orange County...SoCal
Sent from my SPH-D700 using Tapatalk
Speedtest.net always lists closest server in Kansas (and South-West). I'm in NYC. FCC works OK for me.
3g New York server
0.90 down
0.75 up
90 ping
Tested with FCC Test (by Ookla)
SRF 1.2 Genocide 2
EG22 modem
MikeyLee said:
It's not anyones modem. It's Sprint!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. Sprint has acknowledged that there are data speed and reception issues in NYC area. My brother recently called to nag them about it several times and got 1 month credited to his account and will probably get a 2nd month if they don't do something about it soon.
Sent from my SPH-D700 using XDA App
With 4G on:
1.83 Mbps Down
0.73 Up
Same exact spot with 4G off:
0.10 Mbps Down
0.15 Up
There's an issue with 3G right now, as I've tested it with all of the store's demo phones, and other employees are also seeing the same results in 3G. I haven't seen any official word on what is going on, but it's been a couple weeks since I noticed the speed decrease. Hope something gets fixed soon because I don't have 4G at home, and would like to use my Tab and phone when I am not at work.
Starting to wonder if the latest PRL did something?
There is sporadic 3G service currently in NYC, not sure about other places. I have tested for 3g service in queens, manhattan and brooklyn today and it was all 1X speeds. 4G is working fine but slower than usual, I usually get about 7mpbs on average but today my max is 2mbps. Seems like everyone has switched to 4g until they fix the 3g.
By the way, if your in NYC (or in the northeast), the best and most reliable servers to test with are Newark, NJ and Portland, ME on the ookla speedtest.net app.
MikeyLee said:
It's not anyones modem. It's Sprint! My gf and I both have different phones and for the past two weeks both phones data speeds have been complete garbage.
Server Los Angeles
Down 871 kbps
Up 318 kbps
Server Phoenix
Down 847 kbps
Up 88 kbps
LMFAO! Unacceptable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same hear :-(
Sent from the Drivers Seat of my Suby txting and Driving doing 100MPH+ in a school zone! Ha.
Here's my 4G/3G speeds in my bedroom:
Here are some of the differences between 3G and 4G (in the one area oh Phoenix that it's up)
Where I live is NOT where 4G is available but it's very close.
In my house I downloaded a game that's 2mb in size from the market and it took about a minute and a half to download and install. hen tried to download the 102 mb data pkg that comes with the game and after 15 minutes it froze and stopped about 30 mb into the download. I uninstalled the app and I went down the street to the area that has 4G and the app downloaded and installed in less than 2 seconds. Then downloaded the data pkg in about 4 minutes total. I think Sprint owes me a serious service credit, especially since I pay their stupid $10 premium data charge every month.
Here some pretty good speeds
MikeyLee said:
Here are some of the differences between 3G and 4G (in the one area oh Phoenix that it's up)
Where I live is NOT where 4G is available but it's very close.
In my house I downloaded a game that's 2mb in size from the market and it took about a minute and a half to download and install. hen tried to download the 102 mb data pkg that comes with the game and after 15 minutes it froze and stopped about 30 mb into the download. I uninstalled the app and I went down the street to the area that has 4G and the app downloaded and installed in less than 2 seconds. Then downloaded the data pkg in about 4 minutes total. I think Sprint owes me a serious service credit, especially since I pay their stupid $10 premium data charge every month.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Some thing is going on with sprint even up in WI near Milwaukee. I started complaning to them about 3G after that sprint news letter add thingy came out in june or July because it said "we are working to improve the network in "my towns name hear". Well they asked me for speed test data and what speeds I was talking about. I email data to them and over the 2 to 3 weeks of emailing guess what happend to 3G..... yep it got slower :-( I can't even watch youtube on my phone in low def with out it buffering many times over and over. Its getting to the point where I want to chuck the phone! I/WE pay for a nice SAMOLED screen and we can't ever watch youtube. WTF SPRINT!
I just get so sick of there fbs if my market in my town is not going to be upgraded cuz there are working on one of your citys (yes u guys reading) then they should man the F up and just say it not going to happen.
Sent from the Drivers Seat of my Suby txting and Driving doing 100MPH+ in a school zone! Ha.

Data Speeds

So I have a T-Mobile G2 and the 4g plan. I was wondering what type of data speeds everyone is getting. I've been averaging around 2-3 mbps (highest was 6mbps down).
I'm concerned because this is not 4g speeds (they should be 14 mpbs+ easily). My friend has a Verizon 4G LTE phone and he consistently averages 20+ mbps in the same area.
Also, I am using MIUI rom which may not support 4g so this could cause problems if my results are indeed low and others are getting higher data speeds.
all depends on the area your in. in riverside county, ca i average about 13 mbps
I'm living near UCLA/Westwood in Los Angeles and so far I am averaging around 2-3 mbps which seems to be low.
In phone status, it says I am connected to HSDPA network. I'm going to try walking around campus and see if I am ever connected to HSPA+ network and test my speed there.
I'm concerned that either I am not getting 4g speeds (which I am paying for) or my MIUI rom / CM7 kernel is somehow interfering (even though it shouldn't since my speeds should depend on the radio I have which is the newest one).
Also, is the G2 incapable of exceeding 14.4 mbps downlink? I ask because that is what I believe it was originally advertised for.
Any qualcomm smartphone doesn't have the ability to download faster than 14.4 Mbps. And LTE is just a better (in speed anyway, not battery life) technology.
Sent from my G2 running Cyanogenmod 7.
Correct, the G2 only has a 14.4 max based on the chip. Additionally, that is best case scenario. Depending on where I am at in the city, and the time of day (population shift during work hours), I will get 2-3 down, and in some areas as high as 8-9.
If I recall, anything nowadays still isn't true 4G as the standard for 4G is supposed to be 100+ Mbit. I don't see the need (for me anyways) to be pulling 10-15 down at any given time. I don't do major downloads via my phone (don't want to hit data cap) and it uses additional battery. I know some people require the higher speeds, but I really think a large majority of regular users just think "that has a higher number, it must be better". And before people may get mad with that comment, I don't necessarily lump XDA members as regular users.
Yes, I do realize we are no where near what 4G speeds should be, hence the reason why the technology is called LTE.
Ok, so I wanted to confirm that we are hard capped at 14.4 mbps because of the chip. Thanks guys!
Yeah I get anywhere from 3-5Mbps with good signal. After that when the cap hits data is practically useless. Can't even use the market or any kind of video streaming. Gay should be atleast 2G but its nowhere close to that speed. The cap is crippling me.
Sent from my HTC Vision using XDA App
I would actually suggest downloading the 3G script from here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=15948434#post15948434
it seems like hokus pokus, but I swear, my 3G DL speeds were averaging maybe 2 mbps before, now it's up to 6! Not sure which will work best for you so you're going to have to try them all and use maybe the speedtext.net app

Data Speeds

Using the Galaxy Note II in Manhattan, we remained firmly rooted to Sprint's 3G network, with predictably slow results. On Speedtest.net, the Note II achieved an average download speed of only 0.40 MBps and an equally sluggish upload speed of 0.35 MBps. On AT&T's 4G LTE network, by contrast, we noted average download and upload speeds of 22.5 and 12.9 MBps, respectively. Not surprisingly, websites loaded agonizingly slowly over 3G. The mobile version of CNN.com, for instance, loaded in 20 seconds (compared to 2.1 seconds on AT&T's network), while the mobile version of NYTimes.com loaded in 21 seconds (versus 2.7 seconds on AT&T). What are the best options to get switched to a faster data speed?
My speeds were fast for over a year like verizon but sprint did something to the towers by my house and it's horrible 3g at best speeds . It says 4glte but there's no way close to that there's no fix all this change prl or modem stuff to change anything I tried all of them with same results. The apps that say they will boost your signal are full of **** until sprint fix towers we are stuck with b.s service hope this save you time trying to fix something that can't be fixed by us.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

Categories

Resources