Related
Received my TP2 a few days ago, and here are some initial impressions:
GOOD:
- Good form factor; it's thicker than my HD but I find slightly thicker phones more comfortable to hold when talking rather than really thin phones.
- Beautiful screen and very responsive
- immensely improved TouchFlo...HD's touchflo was slow and not very useful, but I've actually been using the TP2's TouchFlo happily...no plans on installing MobileShell, which is something I did not expect!
- Fast...definitely much faster than the HD, and overall usability is way up (having said that, I felt the HD was perfectly usable as well in terms of speed)
- stable; no crashes yet
- web browsing; faster web browsing I've done on a WM device yet
- keyboard; nice and big and quite easy to use (although I suspect it might actually be TOO spacious for people with smaller hands)
- very good speaker and speakerphone
- excellent reception
- Chinese language support; the Hong Kong English version of the TP2 (my unit) now comes pre-loaded with Chinese recognition and input, while keeping the OS in English. I have been hoping to have this functionality for eons...
- overall build quality (minus the poorer tolerance of the screen fit; see below)
BAD:
- Heavy. It has overall larger dimensions so it doesn't feel like a brick like the original TP, but make no mistake this is not a light phone.
- gap, slightly poor tolerance in the flip out mechanism of the screen; when actually popped out and flipped, the hinge feels fine so far. It's when the screen is closed that you can sense the slight gap (as mentioned on the forum). So when I tap on the screen or type, you can sense the slight movement of the screen being pushed down. I actually thought it was the vibration feedback at first, but then realized that is was the screen's give. This could definitely annoy those who insist on excellent fit - but I don't mind so much because the fit of the rest of the unit is great, and I actually kind of like how it's almost like haptic feedback as I tap the screen. Having said that, HTC should've paid more attention to the design as the slight play with the screen really doesn't match with the rest of the phone...which is really an excellent piece of hardware and software.
- no 3.5mm headphone jack. Sure there are ways to get around this, but this should be standard on high-end phones as far as I'm concerned.
- buttons; not really bad, but given that there seems to be some extra real estate at the bottom of the unit, the buttons could have been larger. Feedback on the buttons are very good though, and MUCH better than the touch style buttons on the HD.
- in call volume still not quite as loud as I'd like.
- TouchFlo very memory intensive compared to previous versions. On the HD, the memory usage usually hovered around 43% without any running programs. On the TP2, the memory usage is generally around 63%. I haven't had any issues with slowdowns, but that's a 20% increase, which is a bit surprising. Having said that, it has not impacted the speed or running of programs for me at all so it's just something that's annoying to know, that's all.
Overall, you could probably guess that my impression with the TP2 is extremely positive. I've used so many WM phones in the past, and was ready to give up completely on the OS until the Touch HD (I could not believe how stable and usable it was after pulling half my hair out with previous WM phones including the Omnia). I was planning to play around with it and then give it away, but ended up keeping it. And now the TP2 is even better. As with a few other TP2 owners, my biggest question mark will be how the hinge holds up in the long run...a worry that really shouldn't be there for a TP2 owner given that one of the main features of the unit is the flip out keyboard. I guess time will tell. With interesting WM units on the horizon (such as the just announced Samsung Louvre), I have to say I only trust HTC's implementation - they've done the best job of overall engineering with the OS.
One question that I have for fellow TP2 owners...anyone know how to get AEButton to work with it? Can't seem to figure out which buttons are assigned to which...on the HD, the OK button referred to the back arrow button on the unit, but no so on the TP2. Would really like to get AEButton working.
Overall, TP2 along with the Nokia E71 (and HD to a an extent) has been the most pleasantly surprising phone I've used over the last year or so.
Seems like you are from Hong Kong. So my questions is where did you buy, what carrier and what plan? Just curious, that is all. Cheers!
I picked mine up at Wilson in CWB. No plan or carrier, but it's "official" goods. I traded in my CSL Touch HD...had an unlimited data plan packaged with that.
cocoaju said:
Seems like you are from Hong Kong. So my questions is where did you buy, what carrier and what plan? Just curious, that is all. Cheers!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And the battery? Needs to be charged everyday?
tsaojam said:
BAD:
- no 3.5mm headphone jack. Sure there are ways to get around this, but this should be standard on high-end phones as far as I'm concerned.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's interesting about people's expectations on this. I would have said, if anything, the opposite. Should be a standard on low-end phones. High-end phones should expect high-end solutions for audio, IMHO.
ajbopp said:
It's interesting about people's expectations on this. I would have said, if anything, the opposite. Should be a standard on low-end phones. High-end phones should expect high-end solutions for audio, IMHO.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
true but 3.5mm jack is universal & just an uppgrade in headphones can make all the difference.
I agree, with the 3.5mm being old tech but one thing tho, HTC's earphones don't really fit my ears that well. Keeps on falling off... LOL. If there were more USB earphones, then I am just as happy. I am sorry to say this but the iPod earphones fits me just fine.
I also like the ear bud style earphones or the B&O earphones, they are nice too .
Shame they don't do it with the USB plugs...
tsaojam said:
I picked mine up at Wilson in CWB. No plan or carrier, but it's "official" goods. I traded in my CSL Touch HD...had an unlimited data plan packaged with that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see, I got mine from Voda-Smartone. unlimited internet browsing and 100mb Data. Traded my P3600i in (at last) and only paid $3900 HKD for the phone.
I am keeping my HD which is with CSL.
I thought this phone is gonna come out on CSL but it didn't. Never mind, CSL and Smartone is the same for me, same good receptions.
Did you get an english or chinese version? If you got a english version, do you write chinese? I notice my english version is able to read chinese characters but I can't transcribe chinese words. I hate using the keyboard to write chinese words.
cocoaju said:
I see, I got mine from Voda-Smartone. unlimited internet browsing and 100mb Data. Traded my P3600i in (at last) and only paid $3900 HKD for the phone.
I am keeping my HD which is with CSL.
I thought this phone is gonna come out on CSL but it didn't. Never mind, CSL and Smartone is the same for me, same good receptions.
Did you get an english or chinese version? If you got a english version, do you write chinese? I notice my english version is able to read chinese characters but I can't transcribe chinese words. I hate using the keyboard to write chinese words.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
English version...i never input chinese, so the new English OS is perfect for me as i only need to be able to read chinese characters as well.
tsaojam said:
English version...i never input chinese, so the new English OS is perfect for me as i only need to be able to read chinese characters as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. Same here. I read chinese only most of the time. but it's nice to have. You know what I mean.
What about GPS? What software do you use? Papago or Mapking? Never used it on HD as softwares before weren't compatible with the WVGA screen. Have you installed any?
- gap, slightly poor tolerance in the flip out mechanism of the screen; when actually popped out and flipped, the hinge feels fine so far. It's when the screen is closed that you can sense the slight gap (as mentioned on the forum). So when I tap on the screen or type, you can sense the slight movement of the screen being pushed down. I actually thought it was the vibration feedback at first, but then realized that is was the screen's give. This could definitely annoy those who insist on excellent fit - but I don't mind so much because the fit of the rest of the unit is great, and I actually kind of like how it's almost like haptic feedback as I tap the screen. Having said that, HTC should've paid more attention to the design as the slight play with the screen really doesn't match with the rest of the phone...which is really an excellent piece of hardware and software.
I suggest you to change another one. I've tried several TP2 in shop and some of them have a larger gap than the others. Finally, I picked up a TP2 with a small gap only and didn't notice any (slight) movement when I push the screen/hardware buttons.
I have been thinking about a "fix" to tighten up the phone when closed. The plastic strips on the sides of the keyboard could be a little thicker, and this would tighten up the structure?
Then how much extra have you paid? I'm thinking getting one to replace my X01HT though still in very good condition after two years service. Thanks.
tsaojam said:
I picked mine up at Wilson in CWB. No plan or carrier, but it's "official" goods. I traded in my CSL Touch HD...had an unlimited data plan packaged with that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
desman said:
- gap, slightly poor tolerance in the flip out mechanism of the screen; when actually popped out and flipped, the hinge feels fine so far. It's when the screen is closed that you can sense the slight gap (as mentioned on the forum). So when I tap on the screen or type, you can sense the slight movement of the screen being pushed down. I actually thought it was the vibration feedback at first, but then realized that is was the screen's give. This could definitely annoy those who insist on excellent fit - but I don't mind so much because the fit of the rest of the unit is great, and I actually kind of like how it's almost like haptic feedback as I tap the screen. Having said that, HTC should've paid more attention to the design as the slight play with the screen really doesn't match with the rest of the phone...which is really an excellent piece of hardware and software.
I suggest you to change another one. I've tried several TP2 in shop and some of them have a larger gap than the others. Finally, I picked up a TP2 with a small gap only and didn't notice any (slight) movement when I push the screen/hardware buttons.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the suggestion, i know what you mean that some units have more of a gap than other models.
Having said that, I'm embarassed to say the gap on my machine isn't that bad...the movement I felt really WAS the haptic feedback...apparently even if you turn it off from TouchFlo, the vibra feedback still applies when I'm using Opera. Not sure if it's a glitch, but that's actually what it happening.
skyplay said:
Then how much extra have you paid? I'm thinking getting one to replace my X01HT though still in very good condition after two years service. Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The price is standard at Wilson, how much you can get for trade in will depend on the condition of your trade-in unit.
cocoaju said:
I see. Same here. I read chinese only most of the time. but it's nice to have. You know what I mean.
What about GPS? What software do you use? Papago or Mapking? Never used it on HD as softwares before weren't compatible with the WVGA screen. Have you installed any?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah, i know what you mean...i have tons of programs on my TP2 that I never use but it's nice to have...
I've only been using Google Maps. I don't think Mapking is compatiible still...have yet to find a good GPS solution that I like.
I don't think I could trade in my X01HT. I just want to know the trade-in difference between HD and TP2. Thanks.
tsaojam said:
The price is standard at Wilson, how much you can get for trade in will depend on the condition of your trade-in unit.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tsaojam said:
yeah, i know what you mean...i have tons of programs on my TP2 that I never use but it's nice to have...
I've only been using Google Maps. I don't think Mapking is compatiible still...have yet to find a good GPS solution that I like.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been using google maps as well, but shame there is no voice directions. I have read some users have installed MapKing R12 and it works on the HD. But just looks weird as the images get stretched.
Papago is meant to be good but haven't seen it in action before. Users on uwant.com said it works ok as well. I might check it out later.
I just tested the video capabilities and I am just amazed. I bought an 8GB Class 6 Transcend today at Wilson for under $190 HKD. Went home, inserted the card, transfered my Transformer movie xvid rip, dvd resolution. Played it on Coreplayer 1.3.2. WOW! No dropped frames, sharp pictures and all this without needing to re-encoding.
This upgrade is WELL WORTH IT from the HD. Although I still have the HD with me.
cocoaju said:
I have been using google maps as well, but shame there is no voice directions. I have read some users have installed MapKing R12 and it works on the HD. But just looks weird as the images get stretched.
Papago is meant to be good but haven't seen it in action before. Users on uwant.com said it works ok as well. I might check it out later.
I just tested the video capabilities and I am just amazed. I bought an 8GB Class 6 Transcend today at Wilson for under $190 HKD. Went home, inserted the card, transfered my Transformer movie xvid rip, dvd resolution. Played it on Coreplayer 1.3.2. WOW! No dropped frames, sharp pictures and all this without needing to re-encoding.
This upgrade is WELL WORTH IT from the HD. Although I still have the HD with me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can it play .mkv's ....720p ??
vardig said:
Can it play .mkv's ....720p ??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CorePlayer Mobile can play mkv, but not TP2 cannot play 720p files properly. Further, it is all a function of the bitrate of the movie.
You'd be well off to watch Lasse's video review on this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uONMuEeTo7A
Practical optimum resolution and bitrate for playback with CorePlayer 1.3 is 640x288 @ 1.6Mb/s for H.264 without major frame dropping. For DivX 720x322 @ 2.0Mb/s.
I really miss a few features on my HTC Hero. Sadly it seems like the Hero was much more userfriendly when it comes to hardware design choices.
1. PenTile Matrix Display freaks me out. I can see the rough edges very easily. Makes my eyes having problems with focusing because the edges seem blurry. I have read a lot about this problem prior to getting an Desire so i shouldn't complain. Still it's much more visible than some people try to make it sound. Especially in white text/ black background.
2. Hardware Buttons: Call Buttons...yeah everybody can see that the Desire doesn't have those, and that's not my main gripe. My MAIN problem is that i can't wake this damn screen with ANY other button than the POWER Button, which happens to be positioned at the most uncomfortable position available. It was so much more user friendly on the Hero where i can wake and unlock the screen by two hardware buttons at the bottom.
3. Android Market is SLOW: Why is the Android market like 500 times slower to start a download than my old hero?
4. trackpad: the trackwheel for the hero was more precise.
5. color saturation. welcome to the candy land! Reds and orange colors burn into your eyes. some people like that.
6. it killed my microsd card...well ok i don't know if this is the desires fault but still: suddenly my sd card was shown as faulty. On the PC is works without any problems, but i had to format it in order to use it with the desire.
Of course there are some good things too, like the speed. The desire is really fast, but not THAT much faster than the Milestone. And the overall built quality is great.
Everything you mention is why I LOVE my Desire - vibrant colours, awesome screen, optical pad instead of ball which only ends up breaking/getting clogged with dust...can't fault it IMO (except the Market, it is a bit slow but meh)
according to your point nr 6. did you always safety remove it after plugging in to the PC ?
well i'm sort of used with the "power button to wake the device" since i had a winmo device before the desire, so i don't really see it as a bad thing
cez10 said:
according to your point nr 6. did you always safety remove it after plugging in to the PC ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i'm using windows 7 64bit and never did that, my sd card was show as faulty once so i powered off the phone took out the card, putted in my pc and saw that everything was working fine, putted it again in the phone and never had a problem again.
EddyOS said:
Everything you mention is why I LOVE my Desire - vibrant colours, awesome screen, optical pad instead of ball which only ends up breaking/getting clogged with dust...can't fault it IMO (except the Market, it is a bit slow but meh)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
awesome screen? Have you seen the Motorola Droid live?
About the colors, they are not reproduced correctly as many tests have proven. But i already said that this is also a personal preference.
But the bad resolution quality (comapred to the droid) of the PenTile Matrix display is not a matter of preference, because nobody would prefer the PenTile concept compared to the usual RGB per Pixel approach.
cez10 said:
according to your point nr 6. did you always safety remove it after plugging in to the PC ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no, and actually i believe this was the problem. I only unmounted the sd card using the desire/hero, but never ejected the card on windows prior to that. Just recently i found out that i have to eject the card via windows before unmounting it.
#1
You say I shouldn't complain... then don't I don't have any problems with my eyes.
#2
Why would you need call buttons? My screen turns on as soon as I pull it from my ear (proximity sensor) quite easy to touch the big red bar then isn't it?
#3
My market doesn't appear to be any slower, and download is only improved, I have a 20 mbit connection and with my hero on wifi I would max get 500kb/s
The desire reaches full connection speed @ 1500kb/s so download from market is a lot faster.
#4
More precise but it got dirty very quick, mine even changed color from white to yellowish (maybe I should stop smoking) but not only nicotine sticks to it. Everything sticks to it.
Shahpur.Azizpour said:
awesome screen? Have you seen the Motorola Droid live?
About the colors, they are not reproduced correctly as many tests have proven. But i already said that this is also a personal preference.
But the bad resolution quality (comapred to the droid) of the PenTile Matrix display is not a matter of preference, because nobody would prefer the PenTile concept compared to the usual RGB per Pixel approach.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've not seen the Droid, nor do I want to. Motorola phones are some of the WORST I've ever had the pleasure (or not) to use. I've no issues with the Desire's screen and bar the slight pink issue I can't fault it.
As said, this is all personal opinion but putting a thread about why you hate a device in the forum where people who love it frequent is asking to get flamed!!
EddyOS said:
I've not seen the Droid, nor do I want to. Motorola phones are some of the WORST I've ever had the pleasure (or not) to use. I've no issues with the Desire's screen and bar the slight pink issue I can't fault it.
As said, this is all personal opinion but putting a thread about why you hate a device in the forum where people who love it frequent is asking to get flamed!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He only hates a few parts of it, not the whole thing, what's wrong with that?
I agree on most points, though this is my first android phone. The first thing I noticed when I turned it on was the jagged line thing because of the pentile display, its no way near as nice looking as a display should be with that ppi. It kind of defeats the point of a hi res screen.
But other than that and the fact that sense sucks compared to stock ui, I love this phone
I must either not have this jagged line or not noticed it but I have no idea what you're on about!
EddyOS said:
I must either not have this jagged line or not noticed it but I have no idea what you're on about!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol you will have it as it's impossible to not. Its easiest to notice on the edge of each key on the keyboard. You can quite clearly see the individual pixels, which you shouldn't really see on a high res screen
EddyOS said:
I must either not have this jagged line or not noticed it but I have no idea what you're on about!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
your eyes probably don't notice it, which is actually very good in this case.
Sadly my eagle eyes can see it very clearly. I just have to wait a few year, then i won't see the problems either.
But believe me the Motorola Milestone Display is just better by a huge margin. I had a testdevice for my blog for about 2 months, and the display is fantastic.
samac92 is completely right, when he says that the pentile technology defeats the point of having a (pseudo) WVGA resolution. If you ever have the chance to compare the Motorola droid vs. Desire display, do it. The difference is huge, because the droid has real WVGA resolution as every pixel has RGB color informations, while pentile pixel only have two color informations per pixel.
I've got perfect 20/20 vision, I just probably haven't looked close enough tbh - a slightly jagged keyboard really doesn't bother me. Coming from the HD2 with it's huge (but washed out) screen this is a god send and easily the best phone I've had...and I've had a lot!!
No doubt something else will come out in future but for now I honestly have no issues with the Desire. If I did I'd be rid of it
Plus, the Milestone is a HORRID looking phone...nothing new there, eh Moto??
#1: i was hoping that the pentile problem wasn't as bad. But sadly it is quite bad indeed.
#2 i don't need call buttons at any cost, i need hardware buttons at the bottom of the device (don't care if its a call button or any other button) which can wake up the screen, and put it so sleep mode. I don't want to reach out to the power button every time, as this is not a natural movement when holding the device with one hand.
Also redialing using the "start call" button was very comfortable as you would directly open the dialer app. It's quicker than having to use a shortcut app on the homescreen imho.
#3 not the download itself is slower. but the time that passes until the download starts. There are time where i have to wait for 3-4 minutes until the download starts. Having a good downstream is great, but on my hero i have the app installed before the download starts on the desire on some occasions.
Stafflover said:
#1
You say I shouldn't complain... then don't I don't have any problems with my eyes.
#2
Why would you need call buttons? My screen turns on as soon as I pull it from my ear (proximity sensor) quite easy to touch the big red bar then isn't it?
#3
My market doesn't appear to be any slower, and download is only improved, I have a 20 mbit connection and with my hero on wifi I would max get 500kb/s
The desire reaches full connection speed @ 1500kb/s so download from market is a lot faster.
#4
More precise but it got dirty very quick, mine even changed color from white to yellowish (maybe I should stop smoking) but not only nicotine sticks to it. Everything sticks to it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
EddyOS said:
I've got perfect 20/20 vision, I just probably haven't looked close enough tbh - a slightly jagged keyboard really doesn't bother me. Coming from the HD2 with it's huge (but washed out) screen this is a god send and easily the best phone I've had...and I've had a lot!!
No doubt something else will come out in future but for now I honestly have no issues with the Desire. If I did I'd be rid of it
Plus, the Milestone is a HORRID looking phone...nothing new there, eh Moto??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you are right, the HD2 was somehow blurry and washed out.
The sad thing is that i don't have to look close to see the rough edges on the desire display. i can see it very easily.
But you really miss out on the milestone display, you don't have to wait for future devices to blow out the desires display out of the water. After seeing that milestone magic, the desire display is just no contest anymore. I would have opted for the milestone, but other than the display the desire just has much better hardware specs like RAM and CPU. i also like sense.
And the milestone doesn't have the new launcher style of the N1 after the 2.1 update, but still the plain old boring android 1.x launcher.
I wouldn't be caught dead with the Milestone - every review I've read has said it's crap and a screen just isn't enough to have a phone I'm afraid...
Desire FTW!!
EddyOS said:
I wouldn't be caught dead with the Milestone - every review I've read has said it's crap and a screen just isn't enough to have a phone I'm afraid...
Desire FTW!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hmm very interesting as nearly all known media like engadget and gizmodo as well as all big media in germany really praised this device.
I praised it on my blog review too. And i'm definetly not preferring motorola usually. I'm a HTC fan starting from MDA Compact (HTC Magician) days a decade ago.
The Milestone was the first real killer Android device which sold some impressing numbers. Of course the HTC Hero wasn't bad either, but it didn't have the impact that the droid/milestine had.
Well I've just looked long and hard at the keyboard and I can't see any individual pixels.
But I am 40, so that might be another benefit of getting older.
It was the very first thing I noticed on the Desire, even though it took me a while to find what it was. I don't think good or bad eyesight has anything to do with us noticing or not noticing the PenTile issue. I also see issues on HD tv's and expensive HD Projectors, that no one else sees. And no, my vision is far from perfect. I don't wear glasses, but other than that, my sight is average at the most. So I guess it has to do with how your brain process the visual input. Oh, and I am over 40 too
3. Android Market is SLOW: Why is the Android market like 500 times slower to start a download than my old hero?
Download appbrain from the market then you can use the appbrain.com site for apps then sync to your phone from your pc.
That site is faster to use than the market place
With all the bad press, reviews an bug reports on here latley i rekon it has put a lot of people off getting this awesome peice of kit so just to clear the air when all is said and done would you still get the One X again i would for sure
Mod or Die
snowwhite007 said:
With all the bad press, reviews an bug reports on here latley i rekon it has put a lot of people off getting this awesome peice of kit so just to clear the air when all is said and done would you still get the One X again i would for sure
Mod or Die
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not always that simple. There are three types of issues:
1) S/W which is correctable over time. HTC's future rests on the success of the One line so I have confidence the X will be updated as frequently as necessary. A lot of the issues reported seem (to me) to be s/w related.
2) H/W issues which fall in to two categories. The first being random production defects which don’t affect every device equally. The second category is consistent failings that affect every device (like the black One S's coating chipping off). The majority of h/w issues I've seen posted seem to fall in to the first category.
3) Design flaws. The Sensation antenna-gate issue is an example of this. So far the One X doesn't seem to have any of these.
Even with all that's been posted I ordered one that's due to arrive tomorrow. If it performs well, it stays. If it's flaky (beyond what's reasonable for a new device), it goes back.
Everyone's expectations are different and both the happy and unhappy need to be respected.
I like the phone and it will not be going back. There isn't a single phone on the market in my opinion that matches it when it comes to its combination of looks and specifications and shear wow factor. Its taken me almost 8 months to pick a phone that met all of my requirements after coming from the original Desire.
I am not a hard core phone gamer (But i can be if i want to be now), I am not someone that needs endless memory cards for tonnes of music and video (I have a PC for this, transfer rates are super fast, so it really isn't a hard ship, plus there is dropbox), I do not need a replaceable battery as I have a technet 7000mah portable which is great, its also just as portable as a spare battery anyway (Not that I have had any cause to use it yet).
I also have the white version, so shouldn't have any paint issues.
Yes it has Sense 4.0 which tends to hang every now and then, yes the video camera isn't as good as it will be, all of which are software, and WILL be fixed. Yes it has a rattle when you shake it like an idiot next to your ear, but I will never need to do that unless there is a Maraca app!
Its a mass produced product, as is the case with EVERYTHING mass produced there are batches that have faults and experience issues. Look at the mighty Apple I-Phone! Slight rant over
Yes of course ure correct thats why i feel people need a better idea of those who have the device are they happy knowing and waiting for fixes or would they have choosing different. My reason for post is that theres a lit of people went down the one S route due to all the posts here. Of course there is reason to complain just wanted people to no that im sure there are others like me happy knowing that the fixes will come an the device is great
Mod or Die
The difference in price between the S and X isn't that far apart. I think I would get a sense of buyers remorse 6 months down the line if I went for the S.
jaspabt said:
Yes it has a rattle when you shake it like an idiot next to your ear, but I will never need to do that unless there is a Maraca app!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
best post so far i seen here on these forums
but on a serious note i love my phone and i would recommend it to people no matter what. i know i had a few problems with my phones but it is due to me being picky..but overall it is a beautiful phone to have and would recommend it to many more people..and i exchanging my white version for the grey...saw my mates one and it looks more damn sexier than the white
Don't know what people are whinging about.
IT IS THE BEST SMARTPHONE ON THE MARKET
There, I've said it.
NoobTerminator said:
best post so far i seen here on these forums
but on a serious note i love my phone and i would recommend it to people no matter what. i know i had a few problems with my phones but it is due to me being picky..but overall it is a beautiful phone to have and would recommend it to many more people..and i exchanging my white version for the grey...saw my mates one and it looks more damn sexier than the white
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was going to order white, then I changed my order for grey. Then I was having second thoughts so I went to look at them both in a shop before my order arrived. So glad I went for grey now
DaveDesire said:
Don't know what people are whinging about.
IT IS THE BEST SMARTPHONE ON THE MARKET
There, I've said it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
forget it just saw the actual post now why you quoted me
Good thread. I was surprised to find so many negative comments about the One X on here. It's cutting edge, possibly even bleeding... I bought mine in the knowledge that there may be some teething problems, but I'm more likely to still have something "current" in 18 months as the 2 year contract nears it's end. There are't many phone's that is true of.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
OneXuser said:
Good thread. I was surprised to find so many negative comments about the One X on here. It's cutting edge, possibly even bleeding... I bought mine in the knowledge that there may be some teething problems, but I'm more likely to still have something "current" in 18 months as the 2 year contract nears it's end. There are't many phone's that is true of.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly it will be long while before theres are more powerful phone around and i cant wait to see what devs are cooking
Mod or Die
I came to the One X from a Desire. This is my 3rd HTC mobile and I've loved all of them. I have really enjoyed having the Desire and it's been superb for build quality, reliability and always looked great. Having dozens of lovely roms to play with once it was rooted made all the difference after I became bored with Sense.
So, it was a no brainer for me to choose the One X. Quad core, Tegra 3, that lovely huge, curved screen and ICS were too good to pass up. The phone is stunning and I was most surprised at the looks when I put it beside my Desire. There really is no comparison at all.
It's incredibly fast. I've never used a phone so quick before. The new minimalist Sense is a joy to use and ICS is a great improvement for Android. The screen feels like silk to touch and hasn't attracted much in the way of fingerprints at all. It's lovely to use, very responsive, accurate and image quality is mind blowingly good. Although I don't have the official headphones, Beats Audio does sound fab through a pair of Sennheisers. It ramps up the bass, which is the weakest part of the closed back headphones I have. And so on and on. This mobile is amazing in many ways.
That's the pro's. The con's are:
1. Screen and case don't match up properly. There's a minute gap between the screen and the case along the top and down the left side of mine. This is not normal and classed as a fault by HTC (I asked them). After only 1wk, there's a tiny white strand of cloth under my screen. It can't be seen until the screen is black and it's in the corner. But, as I said to T-Mobile and HTC on the phone today; if it's collected something under the screen after 1wk, what is it going to look like after a few months? HTC said it's a definite fault and should be returned for a replacement. I will be doing so next week.
2. Gripes with the Tegra 3 performance. I know others have seen this on a few games, but for my Desire to easily outperform this phone when playing Stair Dismount is a real disappointment. Secret Exit Ltd answered my request for help earlier very quickly, so I'm really chuffed that a dev is prepared to at least try. I'm not sure whether this is something to do with the game or the phone, so will wait and see. Still a pain though. Interestingly, Stair Dismount also plays very well on my ASUS Transformer, which has Tegra 2.
3. Slight worry about the power button. As the Desire had other hardware buttons, I could assign one of those to wake the phone to take the strain off the power button being used so much. Not possible with this phone. I'm hoping it will be ok.
4. The camera lens cover. If it were Gorilla glass, I'd be happy. If it were recessed enough to not be threatened with being scratched every time I put down my phone, it wouldn't be a problem. So, it begs the question: why the hell did they make the lens cover out of simple glass and the rest of the case out of materials seemingly unbreakable in normal use? Very bad design decision.
5. Lack of external memory could become an issue. Yes, 32Gb is pretty huge. But, so are many of the new games, with 200Mb becoming more common. Not to mention the capability of the phone to play HD content. I also rip music for mobile playing as flac or at least 320k mp3. This makes an album anything up to 800+Mb in size. The internal memory won't take much to fill. None of these are really that big a deal for me, so I'm just being picky with this one!
I've heard various mentions of the battery life being poor on the One X. Considering what this phone does, I'm reasonably happy with having comparable performance as I had with the HTC Desire. Generally, with moderate-heavy use, I'm beginning to think about charging late evening after taking it off charge when I get up in the morning. That's fine by me. I carry a Veho Pebble in my car, so can always put the mobile on charge when I'm out anyway.
I think that's it
leaston said:
I came to the One X from a Desire. This is my 3rd HTC mobile and I've loved all of them. I have really enjoyed having the Desire and it's been superb for build quality, reliability and always looked great. Having dozens of lovely roms to play with once it was rooted made all the difference after I became bored with Sense.
So, it was a no brainer for me to choose the One X. Quad core, Tegra 3, that lovely huge, curved screen and ICS were too good to pass up. The phone is stunning and I was most surprised at the looks when I put it beside my Desire. There really is no comparison at all.
It's incredibly fast. I've never used a phone so quick before. The new minimalist Sense is a joy to use and ICS is a great improvement for Android. The screen feels like silk to touch and hasn't attracted much in the way of fingerprints at all. It's lovely to use, very responsive, accurate and image quality is mind blowingly good. Although I don't have the official headphones, Beats Audio does sound fab through a pair of Sennheisers. It ramps up the bass, which is the weakest part of the closed back headphones I have. And so on and on. This mobile is amazing in many ways.
That's the pro's. The con's are:
1. Screen and case don't match up properly. There's a minute gap between the screen and the case along the top and down the left side of mine. This is not normal and classed as a fault by HTC (I asked them). After only 1wk, there's a tiny white strand of cloth under my screen. It can't be seen until the screen is black and it's in the corner. But, as I said to T-Mobile and HTC on the phone today; if it's collected something under the screen after 1wk, what is it going to look like after a few months? HTC said it's a definite fault and should be returned for a replacement. I will be doing so next week.
2. Gripes with the Tegra 3 performance. I know others have seen this on a few games, but for my Desire to easily outperform this phone when playing Stair Dismount is a real disappointment. Secret Exit Ltd answered my request for help earlier very quickly, so I'm really chuffed that a dev is prepared to at least try. I'm not sure whether this is something to do with the game or the phone, so will wait and see. Still a pain though. Interestingly, Stair Dismount also plays very well on my ASUS Transformer, which has Tegra 2.
3. Slight worry about the power button. As the Desire had other hardware buttons, I could assign one of those to wake the phone to take the strain off the power button being used so much. Not possible with this phone. I'm hoping it will be ok.
4. The camera lens cover. If it were Gorilla glass, I'd be happy. If it were recessed enough to not be threatened with being scratched every time I put down my phone, it wouldn't be a problem. So, it begs the question: why the hell did they make the lens cover out of simple glass and the rest of the case out of materials seemingly unbreakable in normal use? Very bad design decision.
5. Lack of external memory could become an issue. Yes, 32Gb is pretty huge. But, so are many of the new games, with 200Mb becoming more common. Not to mention the capability of the phone to play HD content. I also rip music for mobile playing as flac or at least 320k mp3. This makes an album anything up to 800+Mb in size. The internal memory won't take much to fill. None of these are really that big a deal for me, so I'm just being picky with this one!
I've heard various mentions of the battery life being poor on the One X. Considering what this phone does, I'm reasonably happy with having comparable performance as I had with the HTC Desire. Generally, with moderate-heavy use, I'm beginning to think about charging late evening after taking it off charge when I get up in the morning. That's fine by me. I carry a Veho Pebble in my car, so can always put the mobile on charge when I'm out anyway.
I think that's it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you have it spot on. Luckily I have no issues with my screen and no dust collected anywhere. Using a pouch to keep it nice and safe and it survived a small drop. I don't understand the decision not to make lens from gorilla glass unless its something to do with picture quality. Ordered a flip case as a good work around. I am just debating if I should sell desire or keep as a backup phone
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
BarryH_GEG said:
It's not always that simple. There are three types of issues:
1) S/W which is correctable over time. HTC's future rests on the success of the One line so I have confidence the X will be updated as frequently as necessary. A lot of the issues reported seem (to me) to be s/w related.
2) H/W issues which fall in to two categories. The first being random production defects which don’t affect every device equally. The second category is consistent failings that affect every device (like the black One S's coating chipping off). The majority of h/w issues I've seen posted seem to fall in to the first category.
3) Design flaws. The Sensation antenna-gate issue is an example of this. So far the One X doesn't seem to have any of these.
Even with all that's been posted I ordered one that's due to arrive tomorrow. If it performs well, it stays. If it's flaky (beyond what's reasonable for a new device), it goes back.
Everyone's expectations are different and both the happy and unhappy need to be respected.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Search for HTC One X Antenna Reception Test at Youtube. I have tried it myself and indeed the signal did dropped. Does that count as design flaw?
wcypierre said:
I have tried it myself and indeed the signal did dropped. Does that count as design flaw?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seriously? A 10% dBm drop is, in your mind, a "design flaw?" If you're looking for something to be concerned about the YouTube poster's best performance at 89 dBm is pretty atrocious. Two floors away from my router I get better results on my SGS2. The weaker the signal the more any device will be impacted by obstructions (like bone). You'll see drops and gains like that simply by changing the phone's orientation to the router. As devices get thinner with more and more stuffed in to them antenna placement gets more complicated to avoid interference. That video doesn't concern me a bit (unless 89 dBm is typical Wi-Fi performance).
Had mine for 8 days now, it has no rattle that i've noticed, the screen glitches occasinally in browser, it sense restarts fairly often, battery life imo is decent my stats are typical of others. I had a single occasion where died/crashed, no power button or at least not the usual one press so held it and a small dialogue came up after a while saying 'hold for 2 more seconds to restart' which i did and the fone restarted fine, oh and i've had a single overheat whilst streaming a movie.
I had an early release hero which had some serious bugs which improved dramatically and an early desire s which i found pretty much ironed out from the start.
I'm very happy with my one x overall as any issues it has are teething problems which can be sorted.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
UPDATE:
I've got my HTC ONE X yesterday. It's been on full brightness. I've done everything I could to test it. I see no flickering and any other glitches I mentioned in OP.
Hope it stays that way.
--------
Hi all HOX owners. I hope you all are enjoying your new phone as it's a great phone to have. I've been reading the HOX problems on the internet and have been very keen to know the solutions. Here are my few findings.
Update: Flickering is no more a problem now as people are reporting the latest OTA solves the issue. HTC says it can take upto 14 days but it'd do the job.
PROBLEMS:
> Flickering of the screen.
> Yellow/Orange colour dots.
> Jumping of screen especially near the dock.
> Different colour bands appearing on edges in Camera App. (That don't affect the picture anyway)
> Creaking Sound near the edges of the phone.
> Rainbow like effect while pressing the edges or display for some longer time.
> Gap between the screen and polycarbonate body.
> Sensors not working.
> GPS problems.
>Sense Crashing and sudden reboots.
> Bad reception (fails to catch the signals)
> capacitive buttons stopped working for few.
> Phone constantly being in portrait/landscape mode.
> Phone was perfect at first and then started flickering after a week of use.
> Hear sound of something when vibrating the phone near the ear.
> Phone screen going black and blank.
> Dead Pixel.
> Camera not processing pictures.
> Font size set to 'small' in SMS app will go back to 'medium' after a while on it's own.
> Phone giving a burning smell while it's being charged. (Phone getting hot is normal.)
> Dust under the screen out of box.
> Badly finished metal rim around the screen.
CONCLUSION:
Since it's a flagship phone of HTC I'm really disappointed how the phone has taken the start. It should have broken the records but here we find it simply the opposite. With SGSIII launch around the corner I really see HTC in a big trouble. (Won't go away from HTC anyway; Hate Samsung and it's Touch Wiz UI).
Since this is a flagship phone of HTC I don't really think HTC would let it go easily. We've seen a firmware upgrade recently and hopefully all bugs would be removed within a short time.
----> Please mention in your comments if you've any other issue than these and also the solution, if you have any.
IF YOU HAVE A PERFECT DEVICE OR SWAPPED A FAULTY WITH NEWER AND PERFECT DEVICE THEN:
Please mention your serial number of the phone. (Few initial figures like HT23, HT24)
If you find anything helpful for correcting any bug I'll welcome.
*Hit Thanks button if you think I've posted something useful that'd help people know their devices.*
Sent from my HTC Desire
mohsinraza said:
Hi all HOX owners. I hope you all are enjoying your new phone as it's a great phone to have. I've been reading the HOX problems on the internet and have been very keen to know the solutions. Here are my few findings.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for putting together such an exhaustive list. I'm sure it'll help quite a few people in their troubleshooting.
Since it's a flagship phone of HTC I'm really disappointed how the phone has taken the start. It should have broken the records but here we find it simply the opposite.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't you think you're being a bit extreme? Without question there are some devices that probably shouldn't have passed QC but clearly not every device has every (or any) of the list of issues you outlined. I've only seen two HOX's and both were fine with the exception of one having a warmer display.
With SGSIII launch around the corner I really see HTC in a big trouble.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This statement assumes the SGS3 will launch without any h/w or s/w issues. Based on the GN launch that's a pretty big leap of faith. Samsung's launch of ICS on the SGS2 has also been fraught with issues. More complex s/w and h/w = more issues that escape in to the wild. Don't get me wrong, I appreciate Samsung products and came from a SGS2 and own a 3G Tab, but they are no more or less exempt from problems than HTC. With the HOX having been out for less than two weeks I think it’s a bit premature to say the sky is falling.
Please mention in your comments if you've any other issue than these and also the solution, if you have any. IF YOU HAVE A PERFECT DEVICE OR SWAPPED A FAULTY WITH NEWER AND PERFECT DEVICE THEN: Please mention your serial number of the phone. (Few initial figures like HT23, HT24)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mine's defect free. Gray HT23 from the UK.
Wow that's quite a list.
We only share one thing in common with sense crash and random reboot but mine is flawless otherwise. Not one creak,blemish or screen issue.
Sh23 Made in China
Sent from my HTC One X using xda premium
Just going to point out some flaws in your list...
mohsinraza said:
PROBLEMS:
> Flickering of the screen.
> Yellow/Orange colour dots. --- iPhone 4S / iPhone 4 had these issues, they subside after using the screen for a while.
> Jumping of screen especially near the dock. fixed in 1.28
> Different colour bands appearing on edges in Camera App. (That don't affect the picture anyway)
> Creaking Sound near the edges of the phone.
> Rainbow like effect while pressing the edges or display for some longer time. -- You have to REALLLY squeeze the edges of the phone to even make this occur - if you pushed down on any LCD screen on a weaker part you'll get these deformation of the liquid crystals.
> Gap between the screen and polycarbonate body.
> Sensors not working.
> GPS problems.
>Sense Crashing and sudden reboots. -- Fixed in 1.28
> Bad reception (fails to catch the signals) -- None of the several HOX's I have encountered (in the UK) have had this issue.
> capacitive buttons stopped working for few.
> Phone constantly being in portrait/landscape mode.
> Phone was perfect at first and then started flickering after a week of use.
> Hear sound of something when vibrating the phone near the ear. -- Small amounts of haptic feedback will cause a short movement that sounds like something is loose. This was also true with the Nexus One and the HTC Sensation (Only phones I have had access to recently)
> Phone screen going black and blank.
> Dead Pixel. -- Common with most phones / screens, but the number of dead pixels are quite low. Simply ask to view the phone before you buy it... Reason you hear about these often are because people are more likely to complain about a dead pixel than a perfect screen!
> Camera not processing pictures. -- Camera only takes a while to process pictures if you take 40+ of the quick shots. This isn't a problem, I mean, you show me something that can take 40 shots in the space of 10 seconds, and then not pause for a while to process all the images and write them to memory!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have only commented on the ones that I believe I have some knowledge on!
And, please do point out if I am speaking nonsense with any of my points... My experience is from being an owner of an unbranded White HOX running 1.28 and also from research too!
EDIT: Oh, and my phone is fault-free. Writing from another room that my phone is in, so will post again tomorrow with my s/n. ^^
Yeah not every device is faulty but there's a healthy percentage of users who have issues. I'm not saying I want defect free device on the very first day. I know tgere are issues and are settled down with time but there are some very OBVIOUS bugs are errors that should have been noticed.
I may have gone bit too harsh but I really love this device. Wanna get one soon so not happy the start it has taken.
Hopefully the mixture of these HW & SW bugs are fixed with time.
Sent from my HTC Desire
Rzrr said:
Just going to point out some flaws in your list...
I have only commented on the ones that I believe I have some knowledge on!
And, please do point out if I am speaking nonsense with any of my points... My experience is from being an owner of an unbranded White HOX running 1.28 and also from research too!
EDIT: Oh, and my phone is fault-free. Writing from another room that my phone is in, so will post again tomorrow with my s/n. ^^
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hope it all goes well in near future.
Thanks for correctinge me btw.
Sent from my HTC Desire
You say a healthy percentage - lots of people will stumble across a forum such as this when their device has an issue. They will then post about their issue, making it sound more 'common' than those without any issues at all - I mean, why bother posting saying "MY DEVICE IS PERFECT!"?
I imagine there has been some sort of QA undertaken by both HTC and the manufacturers, so the %age of defective products per batch is probably really low. My only "beef" as such with the release of the HOX was the apparently rushed Software release, of which most of my "issues" have been dispelled with the release of 1.28.
Rzrr said:
I imagine there has been some sort of QA undertaken by both HTC and the manufacturers, so the %age of defective products per batch is probably really low.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah this will lower with time. And hopfully all faulty phones are wiped off the markets within a short time.
As the hardware is excellent this phone will be a real beast once the bugs are removed.
EDIT: And if there's an issue it has to be written down and put infront of people. No matter how many of them are common. The point is they exist and someone can face them anytime.
Sent from my HTC Desire
mohsinraza said:
a healthy percentage of users who have issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For that statement to be true you'd have to know how many were sold and somehow extrapolate XDA's users experiences against it. The s/w issues shouldn't be surprising with ICS, Teg3, and Sense 4 being used together for the first time. Of the h/w issues the only one that really seems to impact a lot of people (based on XDA alone) is the display. Specifically defects, color temperature, and how well it's installed in the metal shell.
All of this sucks but doesn't strike me as anything HTC can't address via ongoing s/w updates, improved manufacturing, and better QC. If all the issues were truly that widespread you'd think that at least some of the reviewers test samples would have been affected. It doesn't appear they were.
I got my SGS2 out of the first batch released in the UK last May. The front page of the SGS2 forum was riddled with h/w issues too (USB ports dislodging, light showing through the screen surround, banding and yellow tint on some displays, finger prints on the inside of the display, faulty cameras, dead head phone jacks, just to name a few. They were all resolved over time.
If the front page of the forum still looks the way it does today in May then I'd say HTC has a significant problem. For now it looks pretty much like that of every other high-end product launched in the past six months (that I've tracked).
well well
BarryH_GEG said:
Don't you think you're being a bit extreme? Without question there are some devices that probably shouldn't have passed QC but clearly not every device has every (or any) of the list of issues you outlined.
Mine's defect free. Gray HT23 from the UK.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmmm..lmao You should've said this in Prime forums now you know how it feels when you own the device, which works great, and people lump all devices as having the issues listed by others. Sounds like Deja vu here.
Best of luck though to HTC and Nvidia squaring away any possible issues with this phone. IMO, the HTC One X is bada$$. I heard its coming to at&t now. Yes, the international version, HTC One X is said to be coming to America now and At&t will have it. Sounds like this might be the phone I use my upgrade discount on.
Edit: just realized at&t is actually getting the HTC One XL. Which has the S4 snapdragon. I'd rather have a tegra3 in it
---------- Post added at 10:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:56 PM ----------
[/COLOR]
BarryH_GEG said:
For that statement to be true you'd have to know how many were sold and somehow extrapolate XDA's users experiences against it. The s/w issues shouldn't be surprising with ICS, Teg3, and Sense 4 being used together for the first time. Of the h/w issues the only one that really seems to impact a lot of people (based on XDA alone) is the display. Specifically defects, color temperature, and how well it's installed in the metal shell.
All of this sucks but doesn't strike me as anything HTC can't address via ongoing s/w updates, improved manufacturing, and better QC. If all the issues were truly that widespread you'd think that at least some of the reviewers test samples would have been affected. It doesn't appear they were.
I got my SGS2 out of the first batch released in the UK last May. The front page of the SGS2 forum was riddled with h/w issues too (USB ports dislodging, light showing through the screen surround, banding and yellow tint on some displays, finger prints on the inside of the display, faulty cameras, dead head phone jacks, just to name a few. They were all resolved over time.
If the front page of the forum still looks the way it does today in May then I'd say HTC has a significant problem. For now it looks pretty much like that of every other high-end product launched in the past six months (that I've tracked).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Shoe is on the other foot now..lol. its cool. I'm sure you're being humbled with this experience and now see what I had to go thru.
demandarin said:
Shoe is on the other foot now..lol. its cool. I'm sure you're being humbled with this experience and now see what I had to go thru.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're funny. In a way it's exactly like the Prime's launch. There's a bunch of issues and everyone's trying to figure what's little, what's big, and how many people are affected. Most everything discussed here though is QC and assembly not design and function which were the Prime's biggest issues. Now if HTC announced the One X Infinity next week there would be a lot more in common. The HOX really is an amazing device though (even though the front page may not reflect it).
Please add:
When SMS font size is set to small, after some time, it will go back to medium.
Sent from my HTC One X using xda premium
> Flickering of the screen.
>>no
> Yellow/Orange colour dots.
>>no
> Jumping of screen especially near the dock.
>>no
> Different colour bands appearing on edges in Camera App. (That don't affect the picture anyway)
>>absolutely not..
> Creaking Sound near the edges of the phone.
>>uhh no..
> Rainbow like effect while pressing the edges or display for some longer time.
>>nope
> Gap between the screen and polycarbonate body.
>>not noticeable
> Sensors not working.
>>uhm yeah they do..
> GPS problems.
>>no problems whatsoever
>Sense Crashing and sudden reboots.
>>don't use sense, can't help ya there..
> Bad reception (fails to catch the signals)
>>you just happen to live in an area where the reception simply sucks
> capacitive buttons stopped working for few.
>>they always work, at least for me..
> Phone constantly being in portrait/landscape mode.
>>nah
> Phone was perfect at first and then started flickering after a week of use.
>> 5 days, still nothing..
> Hear sound of something when vibrating the phone near the ear.
>>not really
> Phone screen going black and blank.
>>no
> Dead Pixel.
>>none
> Camera not processing pictures.
are you serious?
hint: flash a custom rom..
hello00 said:
flash a custom rom..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I won't root the phone btw. I'll use it with stock. Btw I'm yet to own the device. All bugs and issues I posted I've read people shouting out about these.
Update: OP UPDATED with 2 new bugs
Sent from my HTC Desire
BarryH_GEG said:
For that statement to be true you'd have to know how many were sold and somehow extrapolate XDA's users experiences against it. The s/w issues shouldn't be surprising with ICS, Teg3, and Sense 4 being used together for the first time. Of the h/w issues the only one that really seems to impact a lot of people (based on XDA alone) is the display. Specifically defects, color temperature, and how well it's installed in the metal shell.
All of this sucks but doesn't strike me as anything HTC can't address via ongoing s/w updates, improved manufacturing, and better QC. If all the issues were truly that widespread you'd think that at least some of the reviewers test samples would have been affected. It doesn't appear they were.
I got my SGS2 out of the first batch released in the UK last May. The front page of the SGS2 forum was riddled with h/w issues too (USB ports dislodging, light showing through the screen surround, banding and yellow tint on some displays, finger prints on the inside of the display, faulty cameras, dead head phone jacks, just to name a few. They were all resolved over time.
If the front page of the forum still looks the way it does today in May then I'd say HTC has a significant problem. For now it looks pretty much like that of every other high-end product launched in the past six months (that I've tracked).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hope I'm wrong about the words "A healthy percentage..."
This is all what I experienced in last 15 days. But yup you're right on a point.
Why would one say one's device is perfect? Only people with issues will post here and there.
Hopefully every issue is wiped off in near future.
Sent from my HTC Desire
Ive gone through two before getting a refund. I suggest everyone check for dead pixels at http://jasonfarrell.com/misc/deadpixeltest.php . Use the black background and set brightness to max. Do this test in a low lit room and take some time to scan properly for them. They are quite small !!!
PROBLEMS:
> Flickering of the screen.
First handset didn't have this, my second did.
> Yellow/Orange colour dots.
First handset had this, second didn't
> Different colour bands appearing on edges in Camera App. (That don't affect the picture anyway)
> Creaking Sound near the edges of the phone.
Second handset had this.
> Rainbow like effect while pressing the edges or display for some longer time.
> Gap between the screen and polycarbonate body.
again my second handset had this.
> Sensors not working.
> GPS problems.
>Sense Crashing and sudden reboots.
> Bad reception (fails to catch the signals)
> capacitive buttons stopped working for few.
> Phone constantly being in portrait/landscape mode.
> Phone was perfect at first and then started flickering after a week of use.
> Hear sound of something when vibrating the phone near the ear.
> Phone screen going black and blank.
> Dead Pixel.
Both handsets had this, my first had 3 and my second had 2.
> Camera not processing pictures.
> Font size set so 'small' in SMS app will go back to 'medium' after a while on it's own.
> Phone giving a burning smell while it's being charged. (Phone getting hot is normal.)
I think the people think the people that are experiencing all those problems are less that 1%
Probably 99% of the people have experience maybe 1 of the things on the list but most of the time just ONCE and if it repeats they change their units.
This phone is the best phone I have owned in a long time and I have experienced a few of those issues but maybe once or twice but thats it.
Im sure ALOT of other brands experience very similar issues, especially in the beginning of the launch of a new product.
Image this phone in 6 months from now, im sure the software will have matured alot and become more awesome than it already is.
And when it comes to specs it seems this phone is a pretty good competitor with the SGIII.
Also HTC has an OFFICIAL webpage for you to unlock your device for full customer satisfaction, i think thats pretty awesome, and many people forget that you does NOT void you HARDWARE warranty only software (unless your phone is branded) or if it is software related issue that you have casued and if you don't know the slightest bit about flashing roms and overclocking then you should not even be there in the first place.
I think the phone is full of potential and will get better and better
So... Any updates? The users who swapped their phones got something to cheer about or it's just that there is gonna be another replacement?
Sent from my HTC Desire
mmm my first handset was perfect except had a tiny scratch under the gorilla glass and two imperfections to the polycarbonate shell, china, singapore region
second handset was flexing on the left+gap+lcd ripple+slightly less bright screen (yellowness/spots went away in one week) and more edge light bleed than usual, made me realize the gorilla glass isn't laminated well so had to go, taiwan HT242, south african region / euro firmware
my cousin has taiwan HT23 made for france region / euro firmware, perfect brightest screen like described in the review, just slight creak on the top right corner of the glass but its fit perfectly
another one sold to his friend the same code/region/build as my cousin's didn't even make a noise on shake, perfect in every way
they all heat depending on your usage and firmware, on 1.26 used to heat bad on heavy wifi use plus charger, they all have glitches
im hunting a perfect one for me all the others we sold to people who didnt care about this stuff
dont blame us guys for complaining this way more defects/imperfections rate than the usual, been buying HTC since the diamond
HTC stopped producing the Legend too soon if you all remember, lets hope it won't happen here...
I feel sorry to all that are experiencing problems with their device. I feel you. To those potential buyers and future owners of the One X, DONT feel discouraged about these issues.
Id say 99% of these devices are fine, a very mall minority have these issues. And its the same with any other device out there.
Mine's an early batch (i think). Preordered it and got it April 4th. Am i lucky that i got a problem free One X? NO. Because that's how the phone should be (and any other device for that matter).
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2
Hi Guys,
Recently reverted back to Android from iOS. I have had low end and mid range Android devices for development purposes as well as a Windows Phone devices all the way through.
Since taking up the HTC M8 as my day to day device, I have been noticing issues (teeth grindingly frustrating issues) regarding touch screen accuracy and responsiveness.
A prime example of this is when using a browser (Any browser, on both GPE and Sense editions). When making a pinch to zoom gestures, my fingers can move almost half an inch apart before the actual zoom process begins. I have tested this on a Samsung GS4 and found this not to be the case on that device. I believe the root cause of this problem is also behind the poor accuracy when typing on *any* keyboard (i find myself re-writing words again and again despite the larger screen size, you'd expect larger on screen keys would equal less frequent miss stokes...). Again this is not the case on the GS4.
I have used a multitouch testing tool to gauge some measure of response time and touch latency. I have found when moving points at any rate of velocity they begin to lag quite substantially behind my finger. I don't know if this is part of the same problem.
I am wondering if anyone could shed light on whether this is an issue with display touch sensitivity settings, something which could be changed at the kernel level or a limitation with the hardware itself,
Is it also possible that the same algorithm used to detect and handle touch for devices with smaller screen real estate is still being used and that the distances and tolerances for touch and gesture recognition are acting proportionally to the screen size.
Hopefully this is something we can fix, it makes the device tiresome to type with and feel clunky and unresponsive.
The screen on this phone has a higher touch response then the iPhone
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk
Go in a store and check out another phone. If yours turns out to be defective (which should be the case), you should get it replaced
Sent from my iPod touch using Tapatalk
No issues with mine.it's better than iPhone5s I had. Which had some issues sensing touch on corners of display
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using xda app-developers app
sabianadmin said:
Hi Guys,
Recently reverted back to Android from iOS. I have had low end and mid range Android devices for development purposes as well as a Windows Phone devices all the way through.
Since taking up the HTC M8 as my day to day device, I have been noticing issues (teeth grindingly frustrating issues) regarding touch screen accuracy and responsiveness.
A prime example of this is when using a browser (Any browser, on both GPE and Sense editions). When making a pinch to zoom gestures, my fingers can move almost half an inch apart before the actual zoom process begins. I have tested this on a Samsung GS4 and found this not to be the case on that device. I believe the root cause of this problem is also behind the poor accuracy when typing on *any* keyboard (i find myself re-writing words again and again despite the larger screen size, you'd expect larger on screen keys would equal less frequent miss stokes...). Again this is not the case on the GS4.
I have used a multitouch testing tool to gauge some measure of response time and touch latency. I have found when moving points at any rate of velocity they begin to lag quite substantially behind my finger. I don't know if this is part of the same problem.
I am wondering if anyone could shed light on whether this is an issue with display touch sensitivity settings, something which could be changed at the kernel level or a limitation with the hardware itself,
Is it also possible that the same algorithm used to detect to handle touch for devices with smaller screen real estate is still being used and that the distances and tolerances for touch and gesture recognition are acting proportionally to the screen size.
Hopefully this is something we can fix, it makes the device tiresome to type with and feel clunky and unresponsive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you have just moved from the iPhone, then this is a slight orientation problem ... and actually the M8 is the nearest you can get in terms of responsiveness to an iPhone, thanks to the fastest screen response time on the market ... for keyboard, you need to deliberately slow your finger speed down for few days and then you get used to it ... Screen/phone size also play a part in your typing because your mind can remember sub-consciously how much finger movement to do for typing ..
All the above is assuming you were an avid typist for long time on an iPhone
v-b-n said:
If you have just moved from the iPhone, then this is a slight orientation problem ... and actually the M8 is the nearest you can get in terms of responsiveness to an iPhone, thanks to the fastest screen response time on the market ... for keyboard, you need to deliberately slow your finger speed down for few days and then you get used to it ... Screen/phone size also play a part in your typing because your mind can remember sub-consciously how much finger movement to do for typing ..
All the above is assuming you were an avid typist for long time on an iPhone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for all the replies, it is likely that its a transitional issue alright. But before i write it off as such, can anyone verify the issues regarding pinch to zoom? Just trying to figure out if it is a faulty device i have on my hands or not
I get the exactly the same issues. I really thought it was me .
However I had the HTC One M7 and had no issue whatsoever.
LG G2 also same no issues .But since getting
HTC One M8, the touch accuracy is well absolutely useless. I am forever correcting what I type.
I don't think its the hardware but something to do with the Algorithm..No matter what keyboard you use or calibration you do. doesn't make any difference
I am hoping that lollipop cures this problem..
My touch accuracy has always been great. I'd say that if yours isn't it's a hardware problem.
Lostatsea23 said:
The screen on this phone has a higher touch response then the iPhone
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried the m8 and iphone 6 instore and compared them. The m8 screen is very sensitive, requiring minimal touch to be activated. This may be why tests are showing that the m8 has a faster touch response. However, when dragging your finger along the screen, such as swiping launcher screens, the iphone is more responsive.
I then tested "show touches" on the m8, the touch lags behind my finger.