Related
First of all i think there is a need in common thread about Magisk.
I am on XT1685 with 137-35 ver. and exprerienced some Magisk issues. MagiskSU works well on 12.0, 13 beta and 13.3. But SafetyNet is not. My particular problem is not mountable magisk.img. And there is a suggestion that may be caused by f2fs issue on some Lenovo devices (or something else). In different threads there are a lot of different messages about working/not working SafetyNet so i think we need clarification. Most people don't even bother to point out OS version, stock, custom kernel, model etc. So let try to gather information about issue together.
SafetyNet status: not pass
Model: XT1685
OS: Stock 137-35
Kernel: Stock
Magisk: 13.3
Have you also tried the universal safetynet fix and it still doesn't pass?
That's peculiar, I'm on 13.3 with a 1687 running -35 with extended kernel by @attack11 and pass without universal safety net fix.
Dahenjo said:
Have you also tried the universal safetynet fix and it still doesn't pass?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk modules don't work with stock kernel
For OP, you should try a custom kernel, probably this will fix your safety issue
atrac17 said:
That's peculiar, I'm on 13.3 with a 1687 running -35 with extended kernel by @attack11 and pass without universal safety net fix.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same there. Yesterday flashed attack11 Extended Kernel V4 for NPN25.137-35 then flashed Magisk 13.3. All is green without USNF. Tried V5 but there was broken camera.
CaptPetrenko said:
Same there. Yesterday flashed attack11 Extended Kernel V4 for NPN25.137-35 then flashed Magisk 13.3. All is green without USNF. Tried V5 but there was broken camera.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
V5 is for -67. That's why you had trouble.
atrac17 said:
V5 is for -67. That's why you had trouble.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeap.
Have you faced issue that folder binders or folder mounter not working of any kind. If you got a working then tell me. I am on 35
manjot7798 said:
Have you faced issue that folder binders or folder mounter not working of any kind. If you got a working then tell me. I am on 35
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do you exactly mean? In my case Magisk could not mount magisk.img into /magisk on system start
CaptPetrenko said:
What do you exactly mean? In my case Magisk could not mount magisk.img into /magisk on system start
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean folder mount apps, the app in which you can free space, in which you have to mount the folder or can search it up on play store as folder mount or app2s all in one tool. It didn't seem to work on magisk 13.3 whereas it worked on magisk 11.6
manjot7798 said:
I mean folder mount apps, the app in which you can free space, in which you have to mount the folder or can search it up on play store as folder mount or app2s all in one tool. It didn't seem to work on magisk 13.3 whereas it worked on magisk 11.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can not say something about that. I never mounted folders. Use only Root Explorer for file managing. Do you have problems with SafetyNet? Could you send Magisk log? May be your mounting problem has common roots with stock kernel issue and read-only preferences
XT1687
NPNS25.137-33-5
Security patch level is May 1, 2017
I used this video as my guide: youtube[dot]com/watch?v=zUPTFnzAvSo
Root was successful with Magisk 13.3 (including installation of ElementalX-G5-1.01) but ctsProfile and basicIntegrity are false with Safety Net check. The creator of the video had us flash universal safety net fix v1.zip and updated safety net fix v2.zip which I did, but the SafetyNet check still fails. On his video, both items passed.
Not sure what went wrong for me.
He advised users (in the comments) to flash a different kernel, then flash the two safety net zip files again. Good advice or not? Can someone elaborate?
I can confirm all green via these steps: from stock, install extended kernel v4, install magisk v13.3, and all green. Updated to magisk v14 via Magisk manager, all remains green.
Quote:
Originally Posted by atrac17
That's peculiar, I'm on 13.3 with a 1687 running -35 with extended kernel by @attack11 and pass without universal safety net fix.
After updating to v. 14.0 ctsProfile error occured. I rolled back to 13.3 version but there was the same error. I flashed the latetst beta of universal fix and ctsProfile check went through. Don't know would it work with 14.0 ver.
brandonsisco said:
I can confirm all green via these steps: from stock, install extended kernel v4, install magisk v13.3, and all green. Updated to magisk v14 via Magisk manager, all remains green.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CaptPetrenko said:
After updating to v. 14.0 ctsProfile error occured.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Most of the work regarding the cts check can be done with a custom kernel.
And one relevant factor is remove the parameters "androidboot.verifiedbootstate" and "androidboot.veritymode" from the command-line (patching the "/proc/cmdline" file).
See this post: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=73712158&postcount=471
If you like to pass the SafetyNet, then first use a patched kernel or request to developers to include this patch!
Don't waste your time with other complex solutions!
Hi,
If you like to pass SafetyNet in stock and have full support for Magisk then install this kernel:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=73783900&postcount=483
Regards.
Lineage OS 14.1 & LOS kernel with Magisk 14 does not pass.
brandonsisco said:
I can confirm all green via these steps: from stock, install extended kernel v4, install magisk v13.3, and all green. Updated to magisk v14 via Magisk manager, all remains green.
Quote:
Originally Posted by atrac17
That's peculiar, I'm on 13.3 with a 1687 running -35 with extended kernel by @attack11 and pass without universal safety net fix.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I changed to the v4 extended kernel, Magisk V14.0, and also getting all green on the SafetyCheck with the 35 rom. BUT MagiskHide does not work: when I look at the logs I see
fopen:/magisk/.core/hidelist failed with 2: No such file or directory
Does MagiskHide work for you?
Yes working for me I suspect you have mounting error above that in log?
---------- Post added at 08:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:39 PM ----------
I suggest install stock then extended kernel then magick fresh
snaggletooth1 said:
XT1687
NPNS25.137-33-5
Security patch level is May 1, 2017
I used this video as my guide: youtube[dot]com/watch?v=zUPTFnzAvSo
Root was successful with Magisk 13.3 (including installation of ElementalX-G5-1.01) but ctsProfile and basicIntegrity are false with Safety Net check. The creator of the video had us flash universal safety net fix v1.zip and updated safety net fix v2.zip which I did, but the SafetyNet check still fails. On his video, both items passed.
Not sure what went wrong for me.
He advised users (in the comments) to flash a different kernel, then flash the two safety net zip files again. Good advice or not? Can someone elaborate?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, I came from the same video and I did all the steps he put in there. I did the root process with Magisk 13 then I updated to 14 version (a days ago) and everything is working ok.
cannot pass safety net on miui 10 global beta .
i installed root using magisk 16.
everything works fine ( Gcam, viper4droid etc)
but my safetynet is broken.
cts profile mismatch is true.
i m unable to find any solution.
tried universal safety net fix through twrp it says no magisk installed but root is working properly.
can anyone fix it?
wirex13 said:
cannot pass safety net on miui 10 global beta .
i installed root using magisk 16.
everything works fine ( Gcam, viper4droid etc)
but my safetynet is broken.
cts profile mismatch is true.
i m unable to find any solution.
tried universal safety net fix through twrp it says no magisk installed but root is working properly.
can anyone fix it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install the fix through magisk directly. Not twrp.
change your device fingerprint in build. prop file.. and then reboot ..voila!
you can replace fingerprint with stable rom v9. 5.13
Can anyone share the stable rom's fingerprint from their device?? It will be very helpful.
Edit :-I have found a fix and stable rom's fingerprint in this thread.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/module-magiskhide-props-config-t3789228
And its working very well. Hope that helps you. Ask me if you need any help about enabling this module because its a bit different than others.
otonieru said:
Install the fix through magisk directly. Not twrp.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
its says
Copying zip to temp directory - Installing ... Failed! !
wirex13 said:
its says
Copying zip to temp directory - Installing ... Failed! !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If that so, theres chance your magisk installation was derp. Try reinstalling magisk first. Or use the safetynet prop fix module, not the universal one.
RockStar8 said:
Can anyone share the stable rom's fingerprint from their device?? It will be very helpful.
Edit :-I have found a fix and stable rom's fingerprint in this thread.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/magisk/module-magiskhide-props-config-t3789228
And its working very well. Hope that helps you. Ask me if you need any help about enabling this module because its a bit different than others.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i used above steps but in terminal it says
"the settings boot script does not appeared to run during boot"
this means the module doesn't work.
dipak9477 said:
change your device fingerprint in build. prop file.. and then reboot ..voila!
you can replace fingerprint with stable rom v9. 5.13
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can u provide ro fingerprint
ro.build.fingerprint =
wirex13 said:
i used above steps but in terminal it says
"the settings boot script does not appeared to run during boot"
this means the module doesn't work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The module itself has Redmi Note 5 Pro Oreo MIUI 9.5 Stable signature added in its database. You just need to download and flash the module from magisk and reboot. Then open terminal and run command su then allow root access then run command props choose change device signature then choose Redmi Note 5 Pro then Confirm and Reboot. Just remember to reboot after installing the module and then use terminal commands.
dipak9477 said:
change your device fingerprint in build. prop file.. and then reboot ..voila!
you can replace fingerprint with stable rom v9. 5.13
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
just replace miui version in ro. build. fingerprint with V9.5.13.0.OEIMIFA
After flashing universal safetynet, when i open magisk manager it shows magisk is not install but in case i have installed it. The safety net succes with ctsProfile and basicIntegrity.
Please help me out of it.
It happens in my Moto G5s(montana)
Thanks in advance it will be big help for me.
sumirandahal76 said:
After flashing universal safetynet, when i open magisk manager it shows magisk is not install but in case i have installed it. The safety net succes with ctsProfile and basicIntegrity.
Please help me out of it.
It happens in my Moto G5s(montana)
Thanks in advance it will be big help for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Universal SafetyNet is long discontinued. You're better off with @Didgeridoohan's Magisk Hide Props Config module.
Sent from my Moto G5S using XDA Labs
Not only is it discontinued, while it was still being actively developed it was already replacing Magisk internals with it's own stuff (a rather stupid move causing all kinds of problems). Now, even though it's dead, it's zombie corpse is still moving about the internet, eating the brains of Magisk and messing up users devices.
Please tell me how can I fix this issue ?
Please
This zip is there after flashing safety net ?
MagiskHidePropsConfig what i should do ?
Please help me ??
I can't find anything on this so does anyone know of a working EdXposed version for our 7T that doesn't bootloop?
I would also like to know if somebody managed to get EdExposed working?
I tried Canary versions 0.4.6.3 (4552), both SandHook and YAHFA without success. I didn't get bootloop but only the notice about EdExposed Framework being installed but not active.
avalx said:
I would also like to know if somebody managed to get EdExposed working?
I tried Canary versions 0.4.6.3 (4552), both SandHook and YAHFA without success. I didn't get bootloop but only the notice about EdExposed Framework being installed but not active.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Working fine for me.
I'm using the stable magisk version 20400. The edexposed is sandhook , 4510 stable.
ashimiyy said:
Working fine for me.
I'm using the stable magisk version 20400. The edexposed is sandhook , 4510 stable.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'll try that version also.
Working fine for me as well, for a while. Just know that installing edxposed seems to kill any chance on safety net passing. At least lately.
Not sure if it's the same thing you are running into, but I was getting something like a SystemUI restart loop after updating OOS. It was only when using Gravitybox with the Master switch in Clock settings set to On.
My issue: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=82828629&postcount=833
What resolved it for me: https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=82858097&postcount=839
I got it working using Magisk, but it caused my SafetyNet to fail
Hey guys, has anyone gotten Gpay to work on lineage 19.1? I have done the following and have had very odd results. Firstly, I am passing safteynet and my device is registered as play certified in Google play store. I'm seeing where sometimes gpay won't open at all and when it does it says it is unable to load my payment methods.
Specs:
OS - linageOS 19.1 (latest build as of this post)
GAPPS - Mindthegapps (latest build as of this post)
Steps taken:
Installed magisk, enabled zygisk and rebooted
Installed magisk hide props module then rebooted
Installed shamiko module then rebooted
Installed universal safteynet fix (zygisk) then rebooted
Configured denylist in magisk checking GPS (all), and Gpay (all) rebooted
Changed device fingerprint with magisk hide props module to a certified one then rebooted
Additional steps taken:
I cleared data from GPS, play store and Gpay and rebooted
I tried a different device fingerprint and rebooted (clearing data like above afterwards and rebooting again)
I have done a complete fresh install of my OS and tried again from scratch.
I also tried seeing is renaming magisk would help at all, it didn't
It appears I'm getting nowhere with this. If anyone has gotten it to work and has some insight it's be greatly appreciated!
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
deathblade said:
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey deathblade!
Thanks for helping me out on the other thread.
Just wanted to check in, did you use the official build or the unofficial one with the Pixel Goodies? I'm intending/hoping to have full functionalities of Google Pay using the unofficial build, but from your post it seems that I can't have the Pixel experience if I want the ROM to work with Google Pay?
HW898 said:
Hey deathblade!
Thanks for helping me out on the other thread.
Just wanted to check in, did you use the official build or the unofficial one with the Pixel Goodies? I'm intending/hoping to have full functionalities of Google Pay using the unofficial build, but from your post it seems that I can't have the Pixel experience if I want the ROM to work with Google Pay?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using the official build. I think the unofficial has everything needed to use Gpay and have some pixel things baked in. So might be worth a look in your case
deathblade said:
I'm using the official build. I think the unofficial has everything needed to use Gpay and have some pixel things baked in. So might be worth a look in your case
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aite, I will try out the unofficial one and see if GPay works there too. Thanks for the headsup!
HW898 said:
Aite, I will try out the unofficial one and see if GPay works there too. Thanks for the headsup!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just remembered, the unofficial is setup to pass safteynet out the box, but more maybe needed for Gpay to work. Once you flash it try it out, if you run into issues I can provide what I did to get Gpay working
deathblade said:
Nevermind, looks like it was an issue from having the pixelify module installed as well. After I removed it it started working just fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi there, trying out the official build after experiencing some problems on the unofficial one. Any alternatives to pixiel-ing the ROM?
HW898 said:
Hi there, trying out the official build after experiencing some problems on the unofficial one. Any alternatives to pixiel-ing the ROM?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not that I've found, however I did notice if you install the pixelify module then uninstall it, it does seem to leave some stuff behind. Like I still have the option to use Hold for me and direct my call. So it might work out where you can install it to get the things you want then remove it to get Gpay working
deathblade said:
Not that I've found, however I did notice if you install the pixelify module then uninstall it, it does seem to leave some stuff behind. Like I still have the option to use Hold for me and direct my call. So it might work out where you can install it to get the things you want then remove it to get Gpay working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see... So these also means stuff like Now playing etc. will be gone too right?
Also, did you experience the problems I've faced in the unofficial build? sounds cannot change etc. as posted in main thread
HW898 said:
I see... So these also means stuff like Now playing etc. will be gone too right?
Also, did you experience the problems I've faced in the unofficial build? sounds cannot change etc. as posted in main thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope now playing is still there. I really only used it the module to force call screening to show up. But I have pretty much everything I remember from stock plus a few phone related goodies. I never tried the unofficial build but on the official I do not have that issue
deathblade said:
Nope now playing is still there. I really only used it the module to force call screening to show up. But I have pretty much everything I remember from stock plus a few phone related goodies. I never tried the unofficial build but on the official I do not have that issue
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see... I will try installing the official one without magisk as I won't want to meddle with rooting stuff for now, will get back with results asap!
deathblade said:
Hey guys, has anyone gotten Gpay to work on lineage 19.1? I have done the following and have had very odd results. Firstly, I am passing safteynet and my device is registered as play certified in Google play store. I'm seeing where sometimes gpay won't open at all and when it does it says it is unable to load my payment methods.
Specs:
OS - linageOS 19.1 (latest build as of this post)
GAPPS - Mindthegapps (latest build as of this post)
Steps taken:
Installed magisk, enabled zygisk and rebooted
Installed magisk hide props module then rebooted
Installed shamiko module then rebooted
Installed universal safteynet fix (zygisk) then rebooted
Configured denylist in magisk checking GPS (all), and Gpay (all) rebooted
Changed device fingerprint with magisk hide props module to a certified one then rebooted
Additional steps taken:
I cleared data from GPS, play store and Gpay and rebooted
I tried a different device fingerprint and rebooted (clearing data like above afterwards and rebooting again)
I have done a complete fresh install of my OS and tried again from scratch.
I also tried seeing is renaming magisk would help at all, it didn't
It appears I'm getting nowhere with this. If anyone has gotten it to work and has some insight it's be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just also wanted to clarify in the case I decide to install magisk, which module do you install exactly? All of them? Zygisk/hide props module/shamiko/universal safetynet fix?
HW898 said:
Just also wanted to clarify in the case I decide to install magisk, which module do you install exactly? All of them? Zygisk/hide props module/shamiko/universal safetynet fix?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
deathblade said:
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aite thanks for the help mate! just installed but apparently, i couldn't find gapps despite sideloading it.. might have to reinstall again
Hmm safetynet fix seems to fail, can't pass cts profile.. any step by step guides by any chance?
deathblade said:
Ok so here is the breakdown:
Zygisk is not a module, but an implementation method used by modules. Magiskhide props is used to change the device fingerprint to a valid one that registers as protected by google play. Shamiko is for hiding root from Google play services, and Gpay (and whatever other apps may need it). Universal safteynet fix is used to help pass google safteynet checks (security). Not listed is the pixelify module used to add pixel exclusive features but of course with it install it cause havoc on Gpay and other apps so once installed it should be uninstalled.
TLDR
Yes all of them
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HW898 said:
Hmm safetynet fix seems to fail, can't pass cts profile.. any step by step guides by any chance?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's where magisk hide props comes in. I don't have a full guide that I know of but I could do a quick wtite up tomorrow for you
deathblade said:
That's where magisk hide props comes in. I don't have a full guide that I know of but I could do a quick wtite up tomorrow for you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got it working after following a guide~
Unfortunately features like now playing isn't working. the rest is pretty much okay tho
HW898 said:
I got it working after following a guide~
Unfortunately features like now playing isn't working. the rest is pretty much okay tho
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You install the pixelify module? Also can you explain how it's not working?
deathblade said:
You install the pixelify module? Also can you explain how it's not working?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, I didn't. Other than the modules to hide from banking apps as mentioned above, I installed a pixel launch module here to make it for pixel-like: https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/app-mod-pixel-launcher.4442077/
Other than that nothing else.
It doesn't;t work in the sense that it does not pick up music, even popular ones. The settings are there though, I can see them. It just doesn't identify any songs
HW898 said:
Nope, I didn't. Other than the modules to hide from banking apps as mentioned above, I installed a pixel launch module here to make it for pixel-like: https://forum.xda-developers.com/t/app-mod-pixel-launcher.4442077/
Other than that nothing else.
It doesn't;t work in the sense that it does not pick up music, even popular ones. The settings are there though, I can see them. It just doesn't identify any songs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is the pixelify module I installed then removed, you can give it a try.
GitHub - Kingsman44/Pixelify: Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui
Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui - GitHub - Kingsman44/Pixelify: Magisk module to enables pixel exclusive features and ui
github.com