Develop Bugs

What other phone did you consider before choosing the Pixel XL?

1. I'm curious to know what other phone you considered before you got a Pixel XL.
2.. What features made the choice easy in your mind?
I'm struggling with this and am strongly leaning towards an LG V20 for the following reasons:
- Slightly bigger screen
- Removable battery
- as good or a close second (based on a couple of reviews I've seen) camera as on the Pixel
- price
The only two potential cons are (as far as I'm concerned anyway)
- With a Pixel, you'll get the latest Android updates for the next two years.
- The new Google assistant which may not come to the V20 (as it appears that Google want to differentiate their phones from other Android phones). I really want this feature even though the reviews say its really a 1.0 version and needs work.

Im forced to get a new phone so I was definitely looking around.
1) The new Moto lines, LG v20, S7 edge, and possibly the iPhone 7 for the hell of it.
2) I mainly look for a good camera, battery, and speed. The pixel has a great camera, the batter is big enough (XL) and it has one of the latest processing chip. These are enough got me to get the pixel xl. The unlimited storage is also a bonus since I've been using google photos to save my pictures and videos.

Majin101 said:
Im forced to get a new phone so I was definitely looking around.
1) The new Moto lines, LG v20, S7 edge, and possibly the iPhone 7 for the hell of it.
2) I mainly look for a good camera, battery, and speed. The pixel has a great camera, the batter is big enough (XL) and it has one of the latest processing chip. These are enough got me to get the pixel xl. The unlimited storage is also a bonus since I've been using google photos to save my pictures and videos.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Literally my exact opinion, minus the iphone 7. i was kind of debating hoping on the iphone 6+, but after playing with my wifes for a few days that idea was out the door quick.

S7 edge and iPhone 7
Got the iPhone 7, use it for a month...using s7 edge now because I have a feeling the pixel and pixel xl will not be that great of the device because of who's manufacturing it.

Note 7. Only have a Pixel XL because it's the only large screen device that sucks less than the others.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

I still have my S7 Edge Exynos running DBT German unlock firmware. Its difficult because the S7 has a better screen, battery, wireless charging as well as a comperable camera, all for $320 less than the Pixel XL costs (vs what i'd get selling my S7 Edge)

I couldn't find a phone on the market I liked more than my note 7. For me it came down to the iPhone 7 or the pixel xl. I picked the pixel xl and while I do like it. The no ard card, no water resistance and 32gb kills it for me. Sucks cause I really do like the phone but those 3 are big cons for me. Still not sure what I'm going to do. Btw I don't have patience to wait for 128gb

Well I feel the same as everyone else....love my note 7....don't want to be stuck with an already old phone(S7edge) for another 2 years....so I ordered the Pixel XL 128g black.....
Now I'm hearing they may let the ones that got S7edges to upgrade to a S8 or Note 8 free.....ugg
Sent from my SM-N930V using Tapatalk

tttuning said:
Well I feel the same as everyone else....love my note 7....don't want to be stuck with an already old phone(S7edge) for another 2 years....so I ordered the Pixel XML 128g black.....
Now I'm hearing they may let the ones that got S7edges to upgrade to a S8 or Note 8 free.....ugg
Sent from my SM-N930V using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You don't want an S8. You want a Note 8
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

LGV20 but took too long to release on Verizon so I got the Pixel XL

Honestly I didn't consider anything else once the second recall came around. I was more than happy with my Note 7, though

Had the Note 7 and loved it... Now I love this even more! No bugs or issues at all! Got 15hrs off battery and 4.5hrs SOT today in a crappy cell service zone. Pretty good for day 2.

I was considering the V20 as well. But since it didn't come to any carrier in Australia, I figured since I'm buying a phone outright, I'll go with the Pixel XL

Am I the only one who has waited for this since the Nexus 6?

I never could bring myself to get a 6P or Pixel. I feel like I have been waiting all this time, JUST for this phone! I hope it won't disappoint.
What do you all think?

I'm with you. Upgrading from my N6 too. Was going to get the Pixel XL last year but couldn't pull the trigger at that price with those bezels, no waterproofing, etc.

me too (i spend all my saving for this year )
i order my pixel 2 xl 64 black
to replace my n6 64g
running Oreo (crDroid V4)

no, i did that also

I had fun with the Nexus6p and Pixel XL between the Nexus6 and the Pixel XL 2...

Same here... Upgrading my Nexus 6 to the Pixel 2 XL. Never got a 6P or Pixel.

HankStorm said:
I'm with you. Upgrading from my N6 too. Was going to get the Pixel XL last year but couldn't pull the trigger at that price with those bezels, no waterproofing, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here, for all the same reasons. N6 is starting to slow down and battery isn't as good as it once was. It lasted longer than any other phone I've ever had though

I'm upgrading from Nexus 6.
I am getting Pixel XL 2 128 GB and I plan on using it up to the last security update (3 years)
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk

I'm getting a P2XL, but I feel like I'm still waiting for the perfect phone. If I didnt have to get stuck with TouchWiz I would say the S8+ would be it.

Went from galaxy nexus to nexus 5 to nexus 6 then to 6P then skipped the first pixel. So i also has high hopes for this year
But I learned with my 6P that 128gb of storage isnt quite going to cut it so very disappointed the XL 2 doesnt have a 256gb option.
But other than that it ticks all the boxes and then some for me....in still debating it lol.
sent from my Note FE

force70 said:
Went from galaxy nexus to nexus 5 to nexus 6 then to 6P then skipped the first pixel. So i also has high hopes for this year
But I learned with my 6P that 128gb of storage isnt quite going to cut it so very disappointed the XL 2 doesnt have a 256gb option.
But other than that it ticks all the boxes and then some for me....in still debating it lol.
sent from my Note FE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'll probably get it knowing your track record!

Currently have the Nexus 6 and upgrading to the Pixel 2 xl. It was between that or the v30. Want a phone with good development don't know if the v30 will have an unlockable bootloader maybe only the unlocked version. The nexus 6 has been so good to me that haven't had a reason to upgrade. Its still kind of difficult to let it go since the phone works perfect. Maybe the battery has a little less capacity. Other than that, Shamu will be missed.

galaxys said:
You'll probably get it knowing your track record!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol....yeah i have a hard time saying no.
sent from my Note FE

I went from Nexus 5 to The original Pixel xl. Was looking hard at the Nexus 6P. Now the new Pixel 2 XL.

I just put my Nexus 6 up for sale. It was my daily driver for 2+ years. It had every ROM known to man at one time. I got an XL nut the screen was not big enough for me. The N6 spoiled me.
I'm daily driving a Note 8 right now but I'm looking forward to the 2 XL.

Hehe.. yeah i had the orig xl verizon version.. depixled when i got it...bit had to rma.. received 7.1.1 on replacement.. put it on swappa same day.. went back to my tried and true N6... I just hope the 2 xl stacks up to this phone on quality and dev support
Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk

I tried the pixel and had charging problems so I returned it like the phone though. Just ordered the xl2. If there are any kind of problems with this phone illl return it and go back to a iphone. As frustrating as iPhones are to use I'll at least have something that works properly

I'm coming from a N6 too... Though not because I didn't wanna upgrade sooner!

Yes, I'm upgrading from a Nexus 6 to a Pixel 2 XL. Haven't decided which color to get thought.

Great to see a lot of Nexus6 and Nexus6p owners onboard for this exciting Pixel XL 2! Rock on

Is pixel xl still worth?

Dear sirs....!
I'm here to ask if you would recommend me this device, and if you can, I would like to have some questions answered
First: does it feel old in your hand? How is it? Good?
Is it fast enough for everything? Any issue?
I'm coming from an htc 10, I want to switch to an oled display, how is it? Is ambient display good/worth?
Do Google camera mods give better camera performance than stock? Like pixel 2 software ports or s#!t
Would you give it a go or get a u11 / mi mix 2 / pixel 2
I'm interested mainly in camera, display and no lag experience
Thank you very much for your attention sirs

yes

if you have the cash, I'd pick the Pixel 2 Xl over the Pixel XL.

Nope, feature support for devices ends this year as it only has 24 months feature updates. Go for the Pixel 2 or 2 XL.

Based on what you are looking for...
Camera is excellent, though the pixel 2 apparently is even better.
Screen is excellent, big bezels but better than the LG panel on the pixel 2xl. Reportedly. I don't own the p2xl.
Speed is fine.
Sent from my Pixel C using Tapatalk

pkelly517 said:
Based on what you are looking for...
Camera is excellent, though the pixel 2 apparently is even better.
Screen is excellent, big bezels but better than the LG panel on the pixel 2xl. Reportedly. I don't own the p2xl.
Speed is fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I thought Pixel 2 has an LG display, but the 2XL has a Samsung display.
Do I have that backwards?
ETA, Pixel 2 made by HTC. Pixel 2 XL made by LG.
Apologies

Yup.
Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

I tell you, I am not impressed with the display.
I'm not much of a photog, so Canberra does not really matter to me.
I recently bought a used Pixel XL, to root and rom, because my daily driver (Moto Z2 Play) does not have much development.
My recent phones, in reverse order were Nexus 6P and Moto X Pure Edition.
All of those poses better displays than this XL. It is not very bright or vibrant. There is no setting to change.
I sure hope the 2 XL has a better screen, because I think that's my next.

I just picked up an XL and I would say it depends on what you get it for and how long do you want to keep it? My moto phone (big mistake, I'll never again buy a Moto) died on me after less then a year and I just need something to keep me going until the Pixel 3 comes out (I unusually wait a few months after release to see how the reviews pan out). So for me it doesn't have to be perfect. I like the screen.
I will mention that this is fairly subjective. I had the Moto 2 Play for a bit and ended up returning it. The display was fuzzier and not as sharp (what you would expect from a 5.5" 1080p display), side by side the Pixel XL (IMHO) has the much better screen.

I come from OnePlus 5 to Pixel XL and no regrets. I received mine yesterday. So far so good!

Dilemma| Pixel 2xl 128gb for 640$ vs OP6 for 560$

I have a 6p 32gb for now, thought about upgrading and I don't want to wait for the Pixel 3, so I have 2 options and I want your opinions.
In terms of storage, I don't really need 128gb, 64 is just enough, though the Pixel offer is only for 128

Pixel has better camera, faster updates, water resistant, and dual speakers. Oneplus is cheaper, has a bigger screen with notch ?, newer processor, and better battery life, also 3.5mm jack. So it depends on what you want out of your phone.

Pixel 2 XL. It's going to be updated for 3 years.

For me, the continued updates are very important.

If OP6 supported Verizon, I would move back to them in a second. The devs and support are as good as anybody, and they support bootloader unlocking. They've had some issues with customer support at times, like the cc fraud problem, otherwise, they are posed to continue good success. Camera isn't that big of a deal to me personally if the Pixel is slightly better. The case, near edge less top bottoms and sides make it more comfortable and better looking as well. Loved my 5t.

Would recommend pixel 2 XL.
I was in same dilemma too few weeks back. After looking at colleagues op6 and pixel 2 xl, went with pixel 2 xl. A very hard choice for me as choosing a single sim pixel 2 xl vs dual sim op6 (always favored dual sim before).
For me, I liked the pixel 2 xl display, sound and camera much better than op6. I also got info from colleagues that battery life us better in pixel 2 xl than op6.
I am happy with pixel 2 xl now.

HeroPlane said:
I have a 6p 32gb for now, thought about upgrading and I don't want to wait for the Pixel 3, so I have 2 options and I want your opinions.
In terms of storage, I don't really need 128gb, 64 is just enough, though the Pixel offer is only for 128
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using both and think the Pixel 2 XL is a better daily user. Everyone's opinion is different - depends on hand feel, usability, screen, speed, etc.
The Pixel does it ALL....

Thank you guys
2xl it is

HeroPlane said:
Thank you guys
2xl it is
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You probably are going to get anwer as Pixel 2 XL as you are in Pixel device forum

ram4ufriends said:
You probably are going to get anwer as Pixel 2 XL as you are in Pixel device forum
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Partly agree with your thought process.
Another thought process is high cost mobile may always outperform low cost mobiles overall. So pixel 2 xl will come out better overall anyway than OP 6 right.
Check out the review of OP 6 whose UI fluidity is worse than pixel 2 xl surprisingly even for me (expected better UI fluidity in OP 6 due to less resolution screen and better processor than pixel 2 XL). Other areas of speed tests do resulted in good in op6 though.
https://www.xda-developers.com/oneplus-6-speed-gaming-review/

sri4xda said:
Would recommend pixel 2 XL.
I was in same dilemma too few weeks back. After looking at colleagues op6 and pixel 2 xl, went with pixel 2 xl. A very hard choice for me as choosing a single sim pixel 2 xl vs dual sim op6 (always favored dual sim before).
For me, I liked the pixel 2 xl display, sound and camera much better than op6. I also got info from colleagues that battery life us better in pixel 2 xl than op6.
I am happy with pixel 2 xl now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You liked the display no offence the pixel has a inferior display.
Camera smashes the op6 out of the park

sutty86 said:
You liked the display no offence the pixel has a inferior display.
Camera smashes the op6 out of the park
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
<sarcasm>Oh my, chime in on the horrid blue shift and terrible colors of the Pixel 2 XL.</sarcasm>
Better yet, don't. Both issues are totally overrated. If you really think the FHD display of the OP6 with notch is superior to the QHD screen of the P2XL without notch then whatever drugs you are on must be really good.

sutty86 said:
You liked the display no offence the pixel has a inferior display.
Camera smashes the op6 out of the park
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmmm, not sure about inferior or superior spec. But I like the display of pixel 2 xl more than op6 one (not sure it is due to resolution may be, people say 1080p is sufficient but my eyes are demanding more) My s9+ display on other hand feels good than pixel 2 xl though.

I think that Pixel's display is superior to OP6's, Google did a lot lately to improve the colors and reduce the blue tint. I had S8+ and when comparing those two, the amount of blue tint was the same on both. It was visible on Pixel a couple of degrees earlier, but that was pretty much it.
Maybe I am just lucky with my Panda 128GB...

Get the pixel 2 xl coz when the 3 comes out you can trade in the 2 for up to 500$ you'd only be losing a 100$ or so. That's what did i picked a 128 panda used pixel 2 xl in mint conditions off swappa for 570$.

I own both. I'm selling the op6. I told myself I'd never try another option device but bought one anyway. Every opportunity device I've owned has had some odd hardware issue and none of them were the same. Also the UI had some odd behaviour even though it looks stock.

pieman13 said:
I own both. I'm selling the op6. I told myself I'd never try another option device but bought one anyway. Every opportunity device I've owned has had some odd hardware issue and none of them were the same. Also the UI had some odd behaviour even though it looks stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am not sure why everobody (I mean all the reviewers) calls OnePlus software stock..I feel it's far from stock...their settings page design is still struck at Android 7 days...

ram4ufriends said:
I am not sure why everobody (I mean all the reviewers) calls OnePlus software stock..I feel it's far from stock...their settings page design is still struck at Android 7 days...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed completely.

blsrbl said:
Get the pixel 2 xl coz when the 3 comes out you can trade in the 2 for up to 500$ you'd only be losing a 100$ or so. That's what did i picked a 128 panda used pixel 2 xl in mint conditions off swappa for 570$.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am not from the us as you can probably see

who thinks pixel 3 xl is a worthy upgrade from p2 xl

Hi chaps, anyone who upgraded from 2xl to 3xl ..is it worth it? For the screen alone and better haptic feedback? Do u feel like camera is far better factor too?

misiokicio said:
Hi chaps, anyone who upgraded from 2xl to 3xl ..is it worth it? For the screen alone and better haptic feedback? Do u feel like camera is far better factor too?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You may get better responses posting your question in the P3XL Q & A section. :good:

Badger50 said:
You may get better responses posting your question in the P3XL Q & A section. :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
U probably right xd

Not that much of a upgrade for me. Maybe OnePlus 6T or Note 9. But Pixel 2XL is my DD!

The screen is nicer, the camera is a little bit better and more responsive, the phone is a little bit lighter and feels better in the hand not as Big And Chunky but I don't know if it is a reasonable $900 upgrade. I guess like going from an S8 to an S9. The phone is definitely cool though but I did return mine and I'm using my pixel 2 XL because it is not a big difference. I use that money to buy a 4K OLED TV 65 in

The Pixel 3 is more like a Pixel 2.1 imho

Just coming back from picking up a used 128gb pixel 2 xl and will be boxing up the Pixel 3 xl to return tomorrow. After a lot of faffing around I ultimately decided the "upgrade" wasn't really worth it. I had the 2XL, went to Huawei mate 20 pro, returned due to screen issues, then tried the Pixel 3 xl. Decision to return to the 2XL swayed of course by the distortion of the lower speaker of the 3XL....
Ultimately I'm gonna be happy to wait and see what Pixel 4 XL looks like

cd993 said:
Just coming back from picking up a used 128gb pixel 2 xl and will be boxing up the Pixel 3 xl to return tomorrow. After a lot of faffing around I ultimately decided the "upgrade" wasn't really worth it. I had the 2XL, went to Huawei mate 20 pro, returned due to screen issues, then tried the Pixel 3 xl. Decision to return to the 2XL swayed of course by the distortion of the lower speaker of the 3XL....
Ultimately I'm gonna be happy to wait and see what Pixel 4 XL looks like
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You chose wisely young Obiwan! Thanks for the insight for the other devices as well. I've thought about trying out the P3XL and OP6t, however, after reading many reviews on both, I just don't see the need. My P2XL is just fine as can be. We'll see what next year brings I reckon

Badger50 said:
You chose wisely young Obiwan! Thanks for the insight for the other devices as well. I've thought about trying out the P3XL and OP6t, however, after reading many reviews on both, I just don't see the need. My P2XL is just fine as can be. We'll see what next year brings I reckon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey hey! Thanks matey, good to be back home

Upgrade? Nah. The days of 'upgrading' (more like replacing) my phone every year is over. Why would I need another phone that is just as capable as the phone I already have? People use PCs for 5+ years without a single upgrade because it's not really needed (This coming from a Gamer)... It's time we started treating phones the same. There's nothing newer phones can do that a phone from 2-3 years ago can't. Save your money and spend it on something that is actually worth it... And honestly, no one cares what phone you have. Don't treat it as some kind of status symbol... You'd be better off buying some clothes or shoes if that's your goal. And yes, I understand that not everyone views their phones as such, but many do.

Badger50 said:
You chose wisely young Obiwan! Thanks for the insight for the other devices as well. I've thought about trying out the P3XL and OP6t, however, after reading many reviews on both, I just don't see the need. My P2XL is just fine as can be. We'll see what next year brings I reckon
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well me and Craig both tried mate 20 pro?.. and same both went back, but i've pre ordered op6t to give it honest chance... Will post back here in few days otherwise px2 xl stayin in my hands for longer

tkoreaper said:
Upgrade? Nah. The days of 'upgrading' (more like replacing) my phone every year is over. Why would I need another phone that is just as capable as the phone I already have? People use PCs for 5+ years without a single upgrade because it's not really needed (This coming from a Gamer)... It's time we started treating phones the same. There's nothing newer phones can do that a phone from 2-3 years ago can't. Save your money and spend it on something that is actually worth it... And honestly, no one cares what phone you have. Don't treat it as some kind of status symbol... You'd be better off buying some clothes or shoes if that's your goal. And yes, I understand that not everyone views their phones as such, but many do.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ur totally right... But its the urge of gettin something new xd

misiokicio said:
Well me and Craig both tried mate 20 pro?.. and same both went back, but i've pre ordered op6t to give it honest chance... Will post back here in few days otherwise px2 xl stayin in my hands for longer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got my Pixel 2 XL almost all setup and feels sooooo nice to have it back I have Pixel Dust rom installed, with Sultan kernel and the performance script - running like a dream! After seeing the grass isn't greener on the other side, I'm happy to be here for another year

cd993 said:
Just coming back from picking up a used 128gb pixel 2 xl and will be boxing up the Pixel 3 xl to return tomorrow. After a lot of faffing around I ultimately decided the "upgrade" wasn't really worth it. I had the 2XL, went to Huawei mate 20 pro, returned due to screen issues, then tried the Pixel 3 xl. Decision to return to the 2XL swayed of course by the distortion of the lower speaker of the 3XL....
Ultimately I'm gonna be happy to wait and see what Pixel 4 XL looks like
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I went from pixel 2 XL, to note 9, to op6, back to note 9, to mate 20 pro and now I’m back with pixel 2 XL.
It was a very exhausting exercise! I’m now content with the pixel 2 XL, offers great value for money used compared to the competitors and is a no brainer.
I was tempted to try the op6t but remember from the op6 that the speaker was very tinny. Once you go dual speakers it’s hard to go back to single.
So for everyone thinking of moving, don’t do it, wait till pixel 4 XL and see what that brings.

I'm actually going from pixel 3 to pixel 2 xl
Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

I haven't purchased the 3 XL but I already know it won't be a good upgrade for me.
For one, the price for the 128GB 3XL is roughly $1400 CAD. :silly:
Two, that notch.
Three, the upgrades seem minor.
And finally, I had to RMA my 2 XL for screen burn-in and I got lucky with a brand new 2 XL! Fresh battery, got to experience the whole unboxing for the first time since my original 2 XL was purchased second hand.
Looks like I'll definitely be staying with this until the Pixel 4 XL, hopefully the notch size is significantly reduced, or better yet, completely gone by then!

bigup7 said:
I went from pixel 2 XL, to note 9, to op6, back to note 9, to mate 20 pro and now I’m back with pixel 2 XL.
It was a very exhausting exercise! I’m now content with the pixel 2 XL, offers great value for money used compared to the competitors and is a no brainer.
I was tempted to try the op6t but remember from the op6 that the speaker was very tinny. Once you go dual speakers it’s hard to go back to single.
So for everyone thinking of moving, don’t do it, wait till pixel 4 XL and see what that brings.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did u find the cam on op6? Comparable or ****? I've ordered op6t just for fun of tryin it out

misiokicio said:
How did u find the cam on op6? Comparable or ****? I've ordered op6t just for fun of tryin it out
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It’s was ok, not better than pixel 2 XL in my opinion

bigup7 said:
It’s was ok, not better than pixel 2 XL in my opinion
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Definitely not expecting it to be better in this case.. but would u say bearable? Could the op6 satisfy ur needs in camera department as a pixie user? Mine aint coming till wed i think,

misiokicio said:
Definitely not expecting it to be better in this case.. but would u say bearable? Could the op6 satisfy ur needs in camera department as a pixie user? Mine aint coming till wed i think,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I could not move to op6 due to the camera.
But it may be ok for you, for me decent camera is a must (family)