OEM glass as screen protector (dumb question?) - General Accessories

Has anyone thought about using OEM glass replacement as screen protector? I was thinking perhaps use LOCA glue to lay it down on existing glass. I mean, it's got a perfect fit and strong as the original. But I started wondering how it will affect the touch sensitivity, camera, sensors and case fitment.
I was searching for protector for N8 and came across a product that is basically that but with cutouts for sensors so it got me thinking. The cheapest glass replacement for N8 is currently $30 on Amazon so that's not too bad considering the alternative. As long as the glue can be removed with heat, I don't see why I should spend $15 or more for something worse. And I don't think it will be too difficult to squeeze out the glue to thinnest without introducing bubble since they are perfect fit. Curves are nice but it's PIA to protect it...
What do you guys think?

Related

Which Type Of Case To Protect Digitizer Glass?

Having cracked the screen on my old HD2, I feel a bit paranoid now and want a case for my Note. I haven't ever used a case for any phone in the past as I'm in the mind frame that you pay good money for a phone which is well designed and feels great in the hand, so why go and cover it up? By the time the phone is so scratched and beaten up that it no longer looks pretty, it's time to change it anyway.
So, I don't understand why someone would put a plastic housing around the back of their phone, as surely that area doesn't need anywhere near as much protection as the glass? Happy to hear your views though.
At the same time, the plastic films which cover the screen wouldn't protect the screen from cracking in the eventuality of a fall, would they? So again, I can't see the reason for covering a lovely feeling screen with a film.
I use my phone in the car for navigation, so a flip case might not be practical, which I guess only leaves me with a sock/sleeve case of some sort?
Can anyone recommend something which will offer some level of protection to the glass screen (digitizer) in the event of a fall?
Have you looked at these:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1531858
http://compare.ebay.co.uk/like/170819061955?var=lv&ltyp=AllFixedPriceItemTypes&var=sbar&cbt=y
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SAMSUNG-G...otn=21&pmod=170819061955&ps=54#ht_2421wt_1397
I really like the original flipcase...
Sent from my GT-N7000 using XDA
My only concern with those tempered glass 'covers' is that they only protect the phone's digitizer from scratches. There is no evidence that dropping one's phone will only crack the tempered glass and leave the digitizer in one piece. Or is there?
Use a universal car mount and you can use a flip case.

caseit s3 screen protector

Bough one of these to replace the scree protector that came with my otterbox (which i managed to get a piece of lint under).
5.99 from sainsburys, bought as temporary replacement while I research which is the best replacement for the otterbox one.
Quick review.
Application Comes with a wet, then dry cloth. Cleaned the screen much better than the cleaner that came with the otterbox.
Protector goes on very easily, the plastic cover is just thick enough that when you apply it it keeps the protector straight. No obvious bubbles.
Feeling/sensitivity A little resistance to movement compared to having a naked screen, not as good as the otterbox one. Sensitivity appears relatively unchanged. Does get a littele greasy but easily wiped clean.
VFM At half the price of the cheapest "good brand" I can't complain. Definitely will be replacing it at some point but can't decide with what so at present am quite happy.

Tempered Glass screen protectors; Recommended ones?

So I've been looking for a tempered glass screen protector for my Moto X, and I'm not sure which to get, the MIME or i-Blason. So I figured that I would ask the community what they recommend.
nachtdraegan said:
So I've been looking for a tempered glass screen protector for my Moto X, and I'm not sure which to get, the MIME or i-Blason. So I figured that I would ask the community what they recommend.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Between the two, i-Blason. It fits much better than the mime
I have the MIME, can't say as I'm super impressed with it. I'm considering switching to the iBlason just because it's thinner. I feel like the MIME is interfering with the touch sensitivity and causing me to have to press harder than I should. Plus it's just ever so slightly too low and the curved edge interferes with the front facing camera causing a slight distortion at the top of the image. I could move it, but that's where it sits centered.
I had MIME, dropped my MotoX couple of times, MIME did it's job and protected the screen. Unfortunately it chipped and then it started to break really quickly. Don't get me wrong I don't complain about this, it's glass it breaks when dropped on concrete, but it's $25 (+ shipping, I live outside US), and spending this kind of money every month is something I would like to avoid, so I bought some cheep Chinese one on eBay for less than $10. And besides that MIME has nice curved edges, I really don't see the difference...
I had the MIME on my X and while I liked it the sensitivity in the Nav bar area wasn't always good if the phone was say laying on a desk. That being said the MIME on my wifes X is perfect. I just removed my MIME and installed the Mocolo glass screen protector, install was as simple as the MIME and I even had to realign it slightly so peeling it off and putting it back on wasn't a problem. I now have No issues at the Nav bar area so I'm very happy with the Mocolo. http://glass4m.com/products/mocolo-premium-tempered-glass-screen-protector-for-moto-x-g
Just to add, the order to shipped to my door process was 6 days from China to NJ, very impressed.
I-Blason is the best fit out of all the available tempered glass screen protectors.
I-BLASON is the best fit size for moto x. But the glass cover Distance Sensor also.
Maybe have below problem:
Take a call, phone will auto screen off and can not make it on until end of this call.
Power key also can not use while calling.
Any one who have Iblason to check it have this problem or not?
FSRBIKER said:
I had the MIME on my X and while I liked it the sensitivity in the Nav bar area wasn't always good if the phone was say laying on a desk. That being said the MIME on my wifes X is perfect. I just removed my MIME and installed the Mocolo glass screen protector, install was as simple as the MIME and I even had to realign it slightly so peeling it off and putting it back on wasn't a problem. I now have No issues at the Nav bar area so I'm very happy with the Mocolo. http://glass4m.com/products/mocolo-premium-tempered-glass-screen-protector-for-moto-x-g
Just to add, the order to shipped to my door process was 6 days from China to NJ, very impressed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm curious what (if any) case you are using.
I'm considering getting one of these, but I'm concerned about the fit inside a hard case. The hard cases are already a VERY tight fit, and I'm wondering if it can even be snapped on with the extra 0.33mm that the Mocolo adds to the thickness.
Can anyone advise?
samwathegreat said:
I'm curious what (if any) case you are using.
I'm considering getting one of these, but I'm concerned about the fit inside a hard case. The hard cases are already a VERY tight fit, and I'm wondering if it can even be snapped on with the extra 0.33mm that the Mocolo adds to the thickness.
Can anyone advise?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a seidio surface case and an i-blason glass screen protector (ordered from amazon). Long story short the case does not overlap with the tempered glass protector that I got. Although mounting the tempered glass protector is best done with the case already on the device.Top to bottom the case and screen protector is a VERY tight fit (but it does barely fit)!
What confuses me though is people above are saying the i-blason protector covers the proximity sensor, mine doesn't, so I am a bit puzzled...
muiriddin said:
I have a seidio surface case and an i-blason glass screen protector (ordered from amazon). Long story short the case does not overlap with the tempered glass protector that I got. Although mounting the tempered glass protector is best done with the case already on the device.Top to bottom the case and screen protector is a VERY tight fit (but it does barely fit)!
What confuses me though is people above are saying the i-blason protector covers the proximity sensor, mine doesn't, so I am a bit puzzled...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I understand, it used to, but they fixed it a long time ago.
I have the i-blason, was very careful with installation, used the "hinge" method, went on fine, been over a month with no issues, I use a minimal case, so no issue with it. I still "baby" it, the protector is more so that in case, I'll say "lucky I had a protector on it"
muiriddin said:
What confuses me though is people above are saying the i-blason protector covers the proximity sensor, mine doesn't, so I am a bit puzzled...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The difference between version 1 and 2.
I have the mime, and coming from the Zagg glass on my Galaxy S5 which was absolutely amazing, it is just as good. The fit is extremely tight though, you need to be spot on for installation. I have only given it a day though so I'll see if it stands the test of time.
speciala106 said:
I have the mime, and coming from the Zagg glass on my Galaxy S5 which was absolutely amazing, it is just as good. The fit is extremely tight though, you need to be spot on for installation. I have only given it a day though so I'll see if it stands the test of time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok so the Ghost Glass only lasted about 2 weeks before it started to chip in the sides from just daily use. Then it shattered when I went to remove it. Customer service responded in less than an hour with a free replacement coupon. So A+ for customer service but the product kindof sucked. Using it was great but as soon as there is one fault the whole thing is junk, something that my Zagg Glass didnt have an issue with. The Zagg cracked but still went on without an issue for 2 months, and even upon removal it stayed in one solid piece.
I will try the replacement for a while and then go to iBlason if there is any issues.
I have the motocolo. The touch screen is good, but the sensivity not realy realy.
Love my iblason, it started getting spiderweb cracks after several months of use, but I was able to transfer the cracked one to my replacement moto x while I work on getting a replacement iblason. No luck emailing them, I have to fill out the warranty form on the site now
Iblason have 2 version? I see many problems with proximity sensor?
Thanks
So any updates on the glass protectors you guys are using?
I've had my MIME for over a year and it's starting to chip and crack after dropping it. I'm not sure if I want to get another one cause I had a lot of difficulty putting it on precisely so as to not have bubble edges.
I have the Mocolo Glass Screen Protector. This Glass fits very nice on the Moto X.
rupro327 said:
I have the Mocolo Glass Screen Protector. This Glass fits very nice on the Moto X.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had motocola but I find the sensitivity of the touch worse so I gave classic screen protector.
I haven't tried all the glass screen protectors, but I bought the monoy and I love it. The best part about it is the edges are curved so your finger just flows over the sides and it feels great.

Clayco [Hera Series] Full-body Rugged Case with Built-in Screen Protector

The screen protector on this is really good, and the case provides all around protection for your device. It provides a better grip on your phone and offers premium protection without feeling bulky. It even has little covers for the headphone jack and charger port to keep dust out. I've dropped it a few times and it's paid for itself. For $20 you can't go wrong with this case.
It bought it here on Amazon.
Is this bulky?
Is it a cheaper version of an otterbox?
Does it need an extender to use both the USB charging port and the headphone port?
sanjsrik said:
Is this bulky?
Is it a cheaper version of an otterbox?
Does it need an extender to use both the USB charging port and the headphone port?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No this is not as big as an OtterBox you won't be disappointed and you don't need extenders
---------- Post added at 05:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:17 PM ----------
I would recommend this case to anyone it's a good value with great all around protection
I have this case and it is very good with a cheap price
sanjsrik said:
Is this bulky?
Is it a cheaper version of an otterbox?
Does it need an extender to use both the USB charging port and the headphone port?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not bulky at all, though it does make the phone feel slightly larger, but with a better grip. It feels sturdy, too, so you know it'll protect it well even if you drop it.
It is similar to an Otterbox, yes, though it is much cheaper compared to $80+ for Otterbox cases.
No, you don't need an extender. It works fine with the headphones and charger that come with it. I did need to buy one for my radio transmitter (my car is old and doesn't have Bluetooth yet). I'd take pictures of it but my old Nexus 6 was stolen, so I don't have another camera at the moment.
how is the shockproof?
jinshanghaiaraol said:
how is the shockproof?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pretty good. I've dropped it a few times with no issues.
GuyInDogSuit said:
It's not bulky at all, though it does make the phone feel slightly larger, but with a better grip. It feels sturdy, too, so you know it'll protect it well even if you drop it.
It is similar to an Otterbox, yes, though it is much cheaper compared to $80+ for Otterbox cases.
No, you don't need an extender. It works fine with the headphones and charger that come with it. I did need to buy one for my radio transmitter (my car is old and doesn't have Bluetooth yet). I'd take pictures of it but my old Nexus 6 was stolen, so I don't have another camera at the moment.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As a case, it's probably one of of the best on the market. However, as a screen protector it's just ok. Screen protector scratches easily and eventually, it will require a replacement. However, there is no option to buy screen protector separately.
im using lifeproof nuud and its pretty slim and all around protection.
ocujos said:
As a case, it's probably one of of the best on the market. However, as a screen protector it's just ok. Screen protector scratches easily and eventually, it will require a replacement. However, there is no option to buy screen protector separately.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well I disagree with your assertion that there is no seperate option for screen protector, the official Samsung soft screen protectors for the s8 work perfect, it is just that they are not glass. Apparently there still is not a good option for glass so I may stick with that
distantneighbor said:
well I disagree with your assertion that there is no seperate option for screen protector, the official Samsung soft screen protectors for the s8 work perfect, it is just that they are not glass. Apparently there still is not a good option for glass so I may stick with that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're arguing semantics. Ocujos is correct in saying there is there is "no option to buy screen protector separately."
The Clayco Hera case consists of 2 pieces: the frame that attaches to the top of the phone and to which a hard plastic screen protector is glued, and a 2nd frame that attaches to the back of the phone. The 2 frames lock together to provide complete 360 degree coverage. When the hard plastic screen wears out from scratches, you cannot purchase a new top frame piece containing the plastic screen protector separately from Clayco, so ocujos is absolutely right.
The choices are to buy a complete new case (not a bad option considering they're so cheap), or cut out the old old plastic screen from the frame and use a separate glass or film screen protector, but I can assure you film is probably the least functional alternative.
I have the Hera case on my LG V30. I wore out the plastic screen, ended up removing the old plastic screen from the frame, and applied a film protector. However, when removing the top frame from my phone to clean it often resulted in peeling the edges of the film. I had the same issues using tempered glass with adhesive only on the edges.
IMO, the best replacement for a worn plastic screen on the Hera and all other i-Blaison cases with screen protectors is to use tempered glass with LOCA adhesive. The glue will prevent the glass from lifting when popping the top frame off the phone.
After about 9 months my Clayco Hera screen protector has started "peeling" (see attached photo). At first, it was a small patch. Now it's covering almost the whole screen. I've kept my phone indoors and in my pocket most of the time.
Has anyone else had this issue?
I think mine is starting to do that, as well. It's very light and barely there, but I think that's what is happening.
GuyInDogSuit said:
I think mine is starting to do that, as well. It's very light and barely there, but I think that's what is happening.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Expect a rapid deterioration from this moment on. Within a week of two from first noticing the issue , it spread across the whole screen. I've contacted i-Blason support and am waiting for a response.
My wife's S8 plus screen cracked when using this case but the built in screen protector in the case didn't crack... Weird.
ajsmsg78 said:
My wife's S8 plus screen cracked when using this case but the built in screen protector in the case didn't crack... Weird.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Plastic screen protectors are only good to stop scratching glass. For a complete protection you need a *real* hardened glass screen protector like WhiteStone Dome.
ocujos said:
Plastic screen protectors are only good to stop scratching glass. For a complete protection you need a *real* hardened glass screen protector like WhiteStone Dome.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The case has a built in tempered glass screen protector.
ajsmsg78 said:
The case has a built in tempered glass screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My Samsung S8 Plus is protected by a Clayco (i-blason) Hera case. The built-in screen protector is made of *plastic*!
Plastic is not as strong as e.g. 9H hardened glass. Where glass screen protector will absorb the impact, plastic would just pass it onto the screen.

Question Which front glass screen Which front glass screen protector

From experience of using front screen glass protectors for the fold 3, which would you recommend for the fold 4?
Yes won't purchase from whitestone due to bad support they gave when trying to get support on screen protector and how rude they were. Even though I used to recommend them a lot before. But when needed. They failed. But that was my experience. Should be decent but haven't used them for more than a year since it happened. With the note 20 ultra release.
Spigen looks decent but haven't used their screen protectors as used AMfilm. But they don't seem to have for the fold. So still seeing on what to use. As well.
But seeing both would be about same warranty just depends on who handles it better.
The Spigen comes with guide to install it but whitestone comes with 2 at a cheaper price.
The good thing of these is not as the note series that they are $30 to $45 per pack.
The Spigen is so easy to install, plus I don't see the point of installing or replace the inner screen protector. We can get Samsung to do it for free? or cheaply after a year.
I went with the non liquid adhesive whitestone simply because i have it on my fold 3 and it works well. Plus the kit came with a film hinge protector as well.
this one. it involve soap water while applying. i dont know if we can apply the inside protector over and bove the stock one on inside screen
https://www.amazon.in/gp/product/B0B9YQF2LF/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Installed the Whitestone last night with no issues. This one is not as easy as the Spigen since there is no lineup template but I like that I received 2 front screen protectors, a camera protector and an edge guard.
can we apply screen procetor above the factory one inside? last year the inside screen protector oleophobic coating got weared off and it was so hard to scroll. this time thinking of applying another one, so that i can change it every 5months or so
I applied the Spigen EZFit on my Fold4 today, came out perfect. They make a great product, been buying their stuff for years.
Recieved my fold 4 today
Immediately i put on spigen glass Tr
The front tempered glass is good
And doesn’t interfere with the case lips
But the hinge protector is not working as advertised.
The hinge protector from spigen is very thin already but after installing it, everytime i open or close the screen it will get caught up and peeled off on edges
Maybe the gap between the hinge and the screen is slimmer this time
So I don’t think we can put any protector on the hinge without interfering with the mechanism.
On my old flip 1 it was ok
I tried the Whitestone and it is smaller than the front screen?!?!?!? I should send it back!
Flame Red said:
I tried the Whitestone and it is smaller than the front screen?!?!?!? I should send it back!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You kinda want a smaller screen protector because the case will take up the rest of the screen
Flame Red said:
I tried the Whitestone and it is smaller than the front screen?!?!?!? I should send it back!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah they all are, so cases don't lift it. I've put a Samsung one on now, not glass one.
10-Dee-Q said:
Recieved my fold 4 today
Immediately i put on spigen glass Tr
The front tempered glass is good
And doesn’t interfere with the case lips
But the hinge protector is not working as advertised.
The hinge protector from spigen is very thin already but after installing it, everytime i open or close the screen it will get caught up and peeled off on edges
Maybe the gap between the hinge and the screen is slimmer this time
So I don’t think we can put any protector on the hinge without interfering with the mechanism.
On my old flip 1 it was ok
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah had the exact same thing, took it off, ordered full body skin instead
I also got the whitestone. I must say it perfectly covers the actual LCD part with about 2mm extra glass borders. The camera lense cutout is quite perfect as well, with the face unlock light ring lining up perfectly. I would certainly have preferred the glass to be taller and wider, but that's to prevent case interference as we know. Sometimes later in the cycle certain companies release their "edge to edge" screen protects, would want to see if any of them come up.
The included camera cover also fits quite perfectly, no have issues with the official Samsung case cutout.
The included hinge protector film I didn't try, not sure if it would mess with the mechanism to keep dust/grime out.
Overall for the price, I think it's pretty good.
Waiting for my Whitestone EZ glass screen protector to arrive. In the meantime, I already have a fairly deep scratch in the front glass. Ive babied this phone and have zero clue where it came from.

Categories

Resources