Develop Bugs

[Q] Best screen protector for me?

I asked in another thread about invisibleSHEILD but Im seeing after different opinions, that there are various others offering the same protection at different prices.
Im going to be using a HTC Desire Z. Its "environment" will most likely be sliding in and out of my pocket and inside of my hoodies' pockets so yes, there will be lint around it. I dont want to use a case as it looks horrible and adds too much thickness to be in my pocket in a comfortable way. The "orange peel effect" is something I believe Im not going to mind. Im going for full body protection so keep that in mind as Ive read some full body protections cover more or less...
Ive pretty much slimmed it down to 5 but I might have missed some so vote Other, say which, and Ill add it to the poll
So which do you think is the best protection for me?
Also, thanks to everyone who is helping out. I truely appreciate it

Can't change the poll? Wanted to add Skinomi.

I am wondering the same thing. I have a Vibrant and want to figure out what a good protective sheild would be. This case is nice but I'd love to carry it without one and not have to worry too much.

caffeinated chris said:
I am wondering the same thing. I have a Vibrant and want to figure out what a good protective sheild would be. This case is nice but I'd love to carry it without one and not have to worry too much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same situation it seems
If you vote, please state why and your expirences if any with others. Thanks once again

So little votes...

Went ahead with the invisibleSHIELD. There was a 50% discount and you just have to take advantage on that
Thanks to all once more for the advice
Now finally, onto the HTC Desire Z (Ill come back problably asking for help on ROM flashing too )

Just recieved and installed the invisibleSHIELD. ZAGG just recieved this email from me:
Totally unacceptable: Last time I’m buying from ZAGG
My purchase for a invisibleSHIELD from you has been horrible since the beginning. First time around, the order button was broken on your webpage and I have to contact you to fix it. I ordered my invisibleSHIELD on 5/5/2011 and it shipped the next day. I sent you guys a email about my order and I’m STILL waiting for a reply. It arrived 5/18/2011; I’ve been shipped things quicker from the United States and Asia but fine. I receive the package (from Germany, why???) and first thing is that the box is semi crushed and not what I would expect from a company. Next thing, the solution bottle you guys send is unscrewed and naturally the solution spilled. I was stuck without a solution and I had to make do (because I’m not reordering paying a dime for you and waiting another 13 days) with soap and water. Next I find that some of the parts are actually already unstuck to the paper so I had to even put MORE effort in installing. I installed the shield today (again after the experience not worth it even if it protects from everything as there are companies that do the same thing).
Basically, no customer care, horrible package protection, and a product that simply is not worth it. Thankfully, I got a discount you were offering and paid half because this product is worth just that and even less.
I’m not recommending this to anyone; I prefer they try other products such as Best Skins Only which actually gives a decent price for the products.

Yea i also want to know which best screen protector i have to use ?

invisibleshield hands down.

From now on, BestSkinsEver; period. They are the only protectors I will use. Cheap, fast shipping, and great protection.

Zaggs are the best u ever feel on those?
Sent from my Arc using XDA premium App

I got an invisibleshield installed in a local store so luckily, I did not have any problem with it. I just did not experience installing it first hand which looks kind of exciting though the pressure.
I have some problems with it though. The small parts that cover the round edges seem to be peeling away and accumulating some dust or cotton, as I reckon from my pocket which annoys me. They said that I could get a new one but I have to ship the whole thing, so does that men I am going to be left with no protector until it gets shipped to my address? Not really an option if you ask me.

try extreme guard,buy in ebay

prizzprizz said:
try extreme guard,buy in ebay
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Becareful of ebay most of the time iz %80 fake

SuperDeform said:
Becareful of ebay most of the time iz %80 fake
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agree, I've bought a a screen protector once which was full of scratches within a month or so.

I use a screen protector from xoskins on a lot of my stuff. They are uv coated so they don't turn yellow, resist finger prints, and do not feel like a rubbery orange peel.

Sorry you've had such a bad experience with Zagg. I've never had an issue with them myself. The screen protectors have worked very well for me and I've put them on something like eight devices. I'd still recommend them to anyone.

Best buy screen protectors
I hate paying the price at Best Buy, but their sales rep(s) are really good at applying the protector.

steven300 said:
Yea i also want to know which best screen protector i have to use ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would stay away from invisibleSHIELD unless you have the patience to install it or pay someone else to install it. My bro used it on his Evo 4G and for the price it was not all that good. I have been using ReaLook for my Epic 4G and it is very good and offers great protection

I use invisibleSHIELD protects good and installation was simple.Like other poster said it's peeling on corners and edges but I change my case a lot so that contributes.

Screen Protectors - The good and the not so good

If you have purchased Screen Protectors off Ebay (or anywhere), post a link, a pic, and whether you like them or not.
I bought:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=280665594632
-They are ok, I've had better.
-They have the three step approach (take 1 cover off, stick it down, take 2nd cover off.)
-The holes for speaker and sensor don't line up properly. I'll take a pic at some point

After a few hours use I can safely say the above screen protectors are terrible. you just have to run your fingernail across them and they scratch. I will be asking for a refund for sure.

The Savvies Screen protectors (ebay - 180660459805) are also terrible. The cuts for the home button, speaker and front camera dont match up.

i go one of these http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/6-x-LCD-SCREEN-PROTECTOR-SAMSUNG-I9100-GALAXY-S-II-/270726135062?pt=UK_MobilePhones_MobilePhonesCasesPouches&hash=item3f0888fd16
Seems pritty good apart from the camera hole is slightly off. Waxed it as well as it wasnt very slippy. No scratches and you can hardly tell its there apart from the 1 bubble

Stay away from the savvy one. It's a ****ty screen protector ! does not fit at all !

The Vikuiti ones (both the ADQC27 & DQC160) ordered from DISAGU via Amazon, do not fit properly I'm afraid.
The ones I purchased were just a fraction too long and so would have to overlap the bezel slightly, which would be unsightly (air pocket) and not make for a particularly secure fit.
Here's hoping SGP decide to make their Oleophobic ones for the i9100...

jenkinson6a said:
i go one of these http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/6-x-LCD-SCREE..._MobilePhonesCasesPouches&hash=item3f0888fd16
Seems pritty good apart from the camera hole is slightly off. Waxed it as well as it wasnt very slippy. No scratches and you can hardly tell its there apart from the 1 bubble
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got the same and can confirm the front camera hole is off but seems to be fine for a cheap protector until something better comes out.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App

anyone tried the xtremeguard screen protectors? Ive got one coming hopefully soon.

I have a Brando Ultra Clear here, but still waiting for my phone
Looks like the holes are in the proper place do, but can't judge exactly.

I bought this:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=110676862121&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT
bad fit on FFC, means the protector has to be angled to line up with the home button... even if it was straight, theres a good 1-2mm gap around the protector and tbh i don't think i'd bother unless the protector was flush to the end or at least 0.5mm or less gap...
I had a HTC branded protector on my Hero and it was a perfect fit... anyone know if Samsung do the same? or did for the SGS etc??
Dickie

dickie2007 said:
I bought this:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=110676862121&ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT
bad fit on FFC, means the protector has to be angled to line up with the home button... even if it was straight, theres a good 1-2mm gap around the protector and tbh i don't think i'd bother unless the protector was flush to the end or at least 0.5mm or less gap...
I had a HTC branded protector on my Hero and it was a perfect fit... anyone know if Samsung do the same? or did for the SGS etc??
Dickie
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just tried these: http://www.amazon.com/5-Pack-EZGuardZ©-Samsung-Protectors-Packaging/dp/B004UBXH1E/ref=pd_rhf_p_t_1 and they didn't work well at all.
I left my review -- stay away and save your $1.99 for a cup of coffee!

Retrox89 said:
The Savvies Screen protectors (ebay - 180660459805) are also terrible. The cuts for the home button, speaker and front camera dont match up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i agree mate is crap and cant take off this bubbles lol

I'm going to order a SGP one maybe from Korea or when out internationally they are highly regarded. The one that is oil resistant these cheap ones get too oily.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App

nikzDHD said:
I'm going to order a SGP one maybe from Korea or when out internationally they are highly regarded. The one that is oil resistant these cheap ones get too oily.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fit is usually excellent with the SGP ones and then inclusion of a Camera lens protector is a nice addition.
However the Oleophobic qualities aren't especially obvious.
Another thing to note though --an email reply from SGP a couple of days ago indicated that they hadn't yet decided whether to offer an SGS2 accessories yet.
Assuming they do, given the popularity of this model, we may be in for a bit of a wait.

nightic said:
Fit is usually excellent with the SGP ones and then inclusion of a Camera lens protector is a nice addition.
However the Oleophobic qualities aren't especially obvious.
Another thing to note though --an email reply from SGP a couple of days ago indicated that they hadn't yet decided whether to offer an SGS2 accessories yet.
Assuming they do, given the popularity of this model, we may be in for a bit of a wait.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This site has SGP screen protectors for the Galaxy S 2. There are 3 to choose from, ultra crystal, ultra optic anti-fingerprints and oleophobic anti-fingerprints.
http://www.exportprive.com/samsung-screen-protectors-c-1164_1224_1232.html
Anyone had experience with any of these?

MaelstromXC said:
This site has SGP screen protectors for the Galaxy S 2. There are 3 to choose from, ultra crystal, ultra optic anti-fingerprints and oleophobic anti-fingerprints.
http://www.exportprive.com/samsung-screen-protectors-c-1164_1224_1232.html
Anyone had experience with any of these?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Google seems to suggest they are a legit site! Will try and order one let's see what happens!

nikzDHD said:
Google seems to suggest they are a legit site! Will try and order one let's see what happens!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Very odd, as I receive the following from the SGPstore a few days ago.
I guess SGP and the SGPstore aren't joined at the hip.
"Thank you for contacting SGPstore.com Customer Service Department.
Hi, my name is Lynn from SGPstore.com.
We are still deciding whether we are going to have products for Samsung Galaxy S II.
Please stay tuned with us and check our website."
ExportPrive are a legit site, in so far as they will send out the goods.
However, I had a bad experience with them a few months ago where they sent me the incorrect leather SGS1 case.
3 months later, despite promises, they still hadn't refunded.
I had to contact my CC provider to claim the funds back in the end.

nightic said:
Very odd, as I receive the following from the SGPstore a few days ago.
I gues SGP and the SGPstore aren't joined at the hip.
"Thank you for contacting SGPstore.com Customer Service Department.
Hi, my name is Lynn from SGPstore.com.
We are still deciding whether we are going to have products for Samsung Galaxy S II.
Please stay tuned with us and check our website."
ExportPrive are a legit site, in so far as they will send out the goods.
However, I had a bad experience with them a few months ago where they sent me the incorrect leather SGS1 case.
3 months later, despite promises, they still hadn't refunded.
I had to contact my CC provider to claim the funds back in the end.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They will probably have it soon, it's available on SGP Market (Korean SGP site).

99p protectors on ebay are a no go, they are absolutely bubbletastic!

nightic said:
Very odd, as I receive the following from the SGPstore a few days ago.
I guess SGP and the SGPstore aren't joined at the hip.
"Thank you for contacting SGPstore.com Customer Service Department.
Hi, my name is Lynn from SGPstore.com.
We are still deciding whether we are going to have products for Samsung Galaxy S II.
Please stay tuned with us and check our website."
ExportPrive are a legit site, in so far as they will send out the goods.
However, I had a bad experience with them a few months ago where they sent me the incorrect leather SGS1 case.
3 months later, despite promises, they still hadn't refunded.
I had to contact my CC provider to claim the funds back in the end.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I've bought my SGS1 case + screen protector before from them. They did deliver the goods. So, unless the products I got are fakes, otherwise, they are legit.

Anti-Glare/Fingerprint Screen Cover by Sir Lancelot's Armor

Has anyone tried these screen protectors yet? They have 8 reviews, all of which are 5 stars. Surprised nobody has mentioned these yet. I went ahead and ordered one to see how it looks. I know it's going to be the matte finish but I'm wondering how the fit is because nobody mentions the fit in a negative manner in any of those reviews.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B006ZNVWO4/ref=oh_o00_s00_i00_details

Looking forward to hearing about the "clear" version.
Thanks for the heads-up.

Would love to hear how you like this as well. Any time there is a random product with all five stars I get suspicious, so be sure to give us a review!

Yeah, they do have the ultra-clear version too (http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galax..._17?s=wireless&ie=UTF8&qid=1332858648&sr=1-17) but it's unavailable so wasn't able to order that one. Really just want to see how the fit is...if it's a hybrid of the full size plus SGP's size then I think it will be perfect!

I think its safe to say just about every single one of those reviews are fabricated... some guy commenting even pointed out that one of the reviewers had written a review on multiple products of the same company in the same day.
But alas, try it out, I do like Anti-glare protectors, and report back here, I'll be awaiting a quick (real) review!

al2x said:
I think its safe to say just about every single one of those reviews are fabricated... some guy commenting even pointed out that one of the reviewers had written a review on multiple products of the same company in the same day.
But alas, try it out, I do like Anti-glare protectors, and report back here, I'll be awaiting a quick (real) review!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Damn, I didn't see that last review comment. I feel like I kind of got ripped off now. Oh well we will see, if it sucks too badly then I'll just return it. Amazon customer service FTW.

I'd love to know as well, I stumbled upon that same exact screen protector this morning, and a quick Google search led me here (was also skeptical of the reviews after reading the last comment).
I LOVE matte screen protector's, but I haven't been able to find one the does not 'rainbow' on the Galaxy Nexus. Need something to stop my sweaty fingers from smudging up the screen! I will be waiting for your review as well, and possibly a close up camera pic to show possible 'rainbowing'?

tw15egan said:
I'd love to know as well, I stumbled upon that same exact screen protector this morning, and a quick Google search led me here (was also skeptical of the reviews after reading the last comment).
I LOVE matte screen protector's, but I haven't been able to find one the does not 'rainbow' on the Galaxy Nexus. Need something to stop my sweaty fingers from smudging up the screen! I will be waiting for your review as well, and possibly a close up camera pic to show possible 'rainbowing'?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As a recommendation, I'm using the anti-glare "Basal Guard" from Amazon. The fit is very good, only problem is that it does lip on the edges, if you have a case that covers the edges though you wouldn't be able to tell. As far as rainbowing goes, I don't see any, and it has the standard matte feeling to it.
The antiglare effect is very heavy on the protector, some will hate it, some will appreciate it, I personally do think it detracts from the beautiful screen, but I love the matte feeling so I kept it on.

So I just got it in today and after using it for the day I've decided to take it off already. This is a very heavily matted type screen cover so the rainbow looking pixels are very noticeable on anything white which bugs the living hell out of me. HOWEVER, the fit is near perfect. I think they hit the perfect size from the edge so it doesn't lift up so I will definitely be ordering their ultra-clear one when the come back in stock. I will put up a picture as soon as I get my hands on my girlfriend's camera to show you guys.

From their Facebook site:
Sir Lancelot's Armor Amazon houses all of our inventory. Our sales have been much better then expected. We are hoping to have them back in stock by the first weekend of April. 10 days give or take.
6 hours ago · Like
Sir Lancelot's Armor Also, when they are back in stock we will be running a promotion pricing them at $9.95.

tabii said:
From their Facebook site:
Sir Lancelot's Armor Amazon houses all of our inventory. Our sales have been much better then expected. We are hoping to have them back in stock by the first weekend of April. 10 days give or take.
6 hours ago · Like
Sir Lancelot's Armor Also, when they are back in stock we will be running a promotion pricing them at $9.95.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol, the comment that they replied to was from me if you didn't notice.

Are we not all entitled to our opinions?

removed! (10char)

Is this screen protector any good?

Is this anygood? and the mirror one will the screen still look good?
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/150817739...X:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1952.l2649#ht_1385wt_1199

You are buying a flagship phone for £600-700 and ask if £0.99 screen protector is good when the good ones cost like £10-15????

Allways used cheap ones for the sg2 been fine for me.

So why do you ask? There are also threads discussing about screen protectors with many links to what others recommend

camspy said:
You are buying a flagship phone for £600-700 and ask if £0.99 screen protector is good when the good ones cost like £10-15????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What rubbish. The cheap ones are perfectly fine. You pay £10-15 for a screen protector you are being ripped off.

Such statement, if we use it for smartphones too, would say that you are being ripped off for SGS3 too. Better buy some cheap chinese replicas.

Its rubbish because they work perfectly well and usually go on easier than the expensive ones. I have never bought such rubbish as things like the invisible shield stuff. Total junk.
I have a cheap £1 one on my Galaxy Tab 8.9 right now, you cant even tell its on there, it fits perfectly.

Same i always buy £2 ones and they are awesome my HTC Desire has a mirror protector on it i bought 2 years ago still brilliant. It was just £2..
So yes it is good..

is a screen-protector still needed/suggested?
i came across a discussions about this, but there was no real conclusion about this =/

Umpfi81 said:
is a screen-protector still needed/suggested?
i came across a discussions about this, but there was no real conclusion about this =/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well,even if keys and coins don't scratch your screen fine sand and such will, say the phone takes a plunge and go skidding down the pavement screen side down you wont be so happy. a 1$ screen protector works greate.

Absolutely, i have scratched gorilla glass before. Having said that my S2 has been fine so far with no protector, but it has always been in a soft pouch.

rovex said:
What rubbish. The cheap ones are perfectly fine. You pay £10-15 for a screen protector you are being ripped off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is not true, i had a cheap screen protector for my SGSII and it was rubbish so i splashed out and purchased a SGP Ultra Olephobic screen protector for about €13 and i still have it on my phone it has never failed me once.

Well its true for me, you had bad luck. For the sake of £1 each or even less its worth the risk.

I was more asking will the mirror affect make the screen less visible?
And i have always used cheap ones and never had a problem. I paid for a £9 once and was rubbish had a rainbow affect and made things blurred.

These guys generally get good reviews, a little pricey but apparently good...
http://mediadevil.com/index.php/browse-by-device/samsung/galaxy-s-iii.html

Cheap ones arent that good tbh. They are good the first weeks but it gets torn and dirty very easily. I bought a few when i was studying abroad in China for my iPad. It is cheap, sure but not worth it. Bought a flex HD one from SGP.

This one is good

Skinomi Screen Protector for a buck!

The Skinomi screen protector is really cheap on Amazon right now:
http://www.amazon.com/Skinomi-TechS...International/dp/B0084F4HY8?tag=5336653508-20
It says normally it's $11.95. Right now it's $0.99

kingwp1 said:
The Skinomi screen protector is really cheap on Amazon right now:
http://www.amazon.com/Skinomi-TechSk...axy+s3+skinomi
It says normally it's $11.95. Right now it's $0.99
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just grabbed this thanks!

kingwp1 said:
The Skinomi screen protector is really cheap on Amazon right now:
http://www.amazon.com/Skinomi-TechSk...axy+s3+skinomi
It says normally it's $11.95. Right now it's $0.99
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WORKING SKINOMI LINK -- and it's $.99 + $2.95 shipping, but still not bad, and it beats the $16 + $2.95 for the others with the back skin if you don't need it.
Just ordered one as well, since I'll have my phone before SGP has their new SGP Ultra Nano in stock and shipped

Thanks.. Just picked one up. Even with the $2.95 shipping... its a bargain!
kingwp1 said:
The Skinomi screen protector is really cheap on Amazon right now:
It says normally it's $11.95. Right now it's $0.99
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

zmore said:
WORKING SKINOMI LINK -- and it's $.99 + $2.95 shipping, but still not bad, and it beats the $16 + $2.95 for the others with the back skin if you don't need it.
Just ordered one as well, since I'll have my phone before SGP has their new SGP Ultra Nano in stock and shipped
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for pointing that out. I guess I failed at copy/paste
OP is updated

Thanks op for this deal. Was about to order one from the regular site but you saved me around 6 or 7 bucks.

I wonder if they're blowing it out because of the curved screen and they fubar'd their first attempt at making a screen protector.

CZ Eddie said:
I wonder if they're blowing it out because of the curved screen and they fubar'd their first attempt at making a screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Me too, they did the 99 cent thing for the HTC One X early on and people gobbled them up. Overwhelming majority of reviews were negative and some concluded that the batch was defective which explained the price slash.

pdubcramp said:
Me too, they did the 99 cent thing for the HTC One X early on and people gobbled them up. Overwhelming majority of reviews were negative and some concluded that the batch was defective which explained the price slash.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Interesting. Well I guess there's 3-4 of us who will know for sure. I'd be happy to come back in here and let yall know if it's a screw up when mine comes in the mail.

I have this screen protector in my s3 and it sticks pretty well to the screen. My only complain is the orange peel effect

I ordered one of these. Hopefully the orange peel isn't too bad. I currently have the realook one installed but when I put my cruzerlite case on the edges start to come up.

I've always wondered if these types of protectors provide more protection than the hard/dry protectors

pdubcramp said:
Me too, they did the 99 cent thing for the HTC One X early on and people gobbled them up. Overwhelming majority of reviews were negative and some concluded that the batch was defective which explained the price slash.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seems like you guys maybe right. I just got mine in today and the film was kind of stuck to the plastic bag it was in which resulted in some weird bubble imprints on the top of the screen protector. I'll try to get a picture up tomorrow. I'm letting it sit overnight to see if the weird markings on it come out.

I just applied mine last night and after a nights dry, it seems a bit on the tacky side. Its not as smooth as I would like, kinda hard to swipe. But I will give this a day or 2 more to fully dry and judge from there.

Wond3r said:
I've always wondered if these types of protectors provide more protection than the hard/dry protectors
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They don't provide more or less, they seem to be on par.
The real differences are how long they last. Skimomi type repair themselves, can take hits that would usually damage the dry hard type, doesn't usually peel off if applied correctly. That's why most have a lifetime warranty. And the reason they come singular or in a two pack (mostly if you mess up installation, you have that spare), but not 3-5 packs, because you're gonna have to put another one on in a few weeks...
This has been my experience..

clockcycle said:
They don't provide more or less, they seem to be on par.
The real differences are how long they last. Skimomi type repair themselves, can take hits that would usually damage the dry hard type, doesn't usually peel off if applied correctly. That's why most have a lifetime warranty. And the reason they come singular or in a two pack (mostly if you mess up installation, you have that spare), but not 3-5 packs, because you're gonna have to put another one on in a few weeks...
This has been my experience..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
does the skinomi come in pairs?

mariotme said:
does the skinomi come in pairs?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just one. Wet application, though, so, hard to screw up.

Deal dead? Coming up as 6.95 in my browser now.

minister of etc said:
Deal dead? Coming up as 6.95 in my browser now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes we missed it :banghead:
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

Just put mine on, the orange peal is much smoother than the original Zagg on my inspire, however the holes don't fit perfectly, they fit, just not as well as i would like.
Immediately after install any white on the screen looks very pixelated with a rainbow of colors, anyone else get this? Does it go away? Please tell me it goes away, if not i am going to rip it off right now.