Related
I'm going to buy One X(or One XL) when it released at South Korea.
So I'm searching its specs & informations.
I heard there is frame drop issue when taking 1080p video recording.
First, it took 19fps, and after a firmware update, it takes 23fps at the moment.
Then what about 720p video recording?
Does 720p recording support 30fps perfectly? Or It has same issue?
Are there any news to fix this software problem from HTC?
My 1080p Videos has 19,36 FPS and the 720p has 23,1 FPS.
I use my One X with ARHD 5.1.1 & Bricket-Kernel, still got no OTA to 1.29 so ive got old Radio!
But there are 2 Cam-Mods out there which push the Mbit/s and the Framerates, but aware this are BETA's!
Forsaked said:
My 1080p Videos has 19,36 FPS and the 720p has 23,1 FPS.
I use my One X with ARHD 5.1.1 & Bricket-Kernel, still got no OTA to 1.29 so ive got old Radio!
But there are 2 Cam-Mods out there which push the Mbit/s and the Framerates, but aware this are BETA's!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thx to reply.
So 720p recording also has FPS issue huh?
Don't know why HTC doesn't release patch to fix it.
I heard ONE-S(snapdragon 4th model) doesn't have any FPS issue at all LOL.
It's so weird that ONE-X got video recording problem... This one is way better flagship model
First of all, hardware wise the H1X can do [email protected] You can download Camera ICS from Play Store and see for yourself. However, the stock camera capped fps to 24. Thats really sux.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
Albert Poon said:
First of all, hardware wise the H1X can do [email protected] You can download Camera ICS from Play Store and see for yourself. However, the stock camera capped fps to 24. Thats really sux.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thx for replying
You mean third party camera app can take 1080p recording smoothly, right?
However, stock camera app doesn't support 30fps. So it seems camera application has problem. Am I right?
But Camera ICS app doesn't support Burst shot I guess... hmm.
Neither taking photos while recording.
Anyway, I don't have H1X lol.
First of all, to clear the misconception, I have done A LOT of testing on the video recording capabilities of the HOX. Firstly, ALL camera apps that I have tried have DROPPED frames when recording.
Dropped frames are the sudden jitter and lag during recording. Generally video is recorded at 30fps, but throughout recording and playback, the frames get dropped very often.
Dropped frames and low FPS are NOT the same. Low FPS seems to be constant, during low light it drops to 17fps or so, but well lit areas 30fps MAX. Just go record a short 30 second clip and you will see what I mean. Every few frames you can see the video stutter and then FPS picks back up. Very bad, and very irritating. There doesn't seem to be a fix to it yet.
ArmedandDangerous said:
First of all, to clear the misconception, I have done A LOT of testing on the video recording capabilities of the HOX. Firstly, ALL camera apps that I have tried have DROPPED frames when recording.
Dropped frames are the sudden jitter and lag during recording. Generally video is recorded at 30fps, but throughout recording and playback, the frames get dropped very often.
Dropped frames and low FPS are NOT the same. Low FPS seems to be constant, during low light it drops to 17fps or so, but well lit areas 30fps MAX. Just go record a short 30 second clip and you will see what I mean. Every few frames you can see the video stutter and then FPS picks back up. Very bad, and very irritating. There doesn't seem to be a fix to it yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thx for useful information
Is this fixed in update ?
I'm curious. For a while now my Moto G has had an option available for 720p at 60fps. It looks pretty great, but I haven't seen that option for my Nexus 7. Do any of you guys have 60fps playback on your tablet, or is that like a gradual thing that's rolling out to certain devices?
I believe its server based like the last few YouTube updates, just have to wait for the rollout.
Sent from my Nexus 7 2013 using Tapatalk
Hello, does anyone know if this is implemented in a ROM or if there's a mod available to enable 1080p 60fps recording ? I barely found out about this just before i decided to purchase the 10 and found it odd due to the fact that the M8 can do 1080p @60:rolleyes :roll eyes: . Is there a way a request can be made or something ?
Chrismedina72 said:
Hello, does anyone know if this is implemented in a ROM or if there's a mod available to enable 1080p 60fps recording ? I barely found out about this just before i decided to purchase the 10 and found it odd due to the fact that the M8 can do 1080p @60:rolleyes :roll eyes: . Is there a way a request can be made or something ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've looked into it the but HTC added some compilation the configuration for 60fps is the same for The HTC 10 Nexus 6p and 5X have it working on the nexus .
HTC Complications.
In Camera 2 Mode it could be accessed via high speed recording api but for some reason this causes strange green overlay flickering video is in 60fps but unusable so that's out.
Camera 1 mode using Qualcomms video-hfr parameter HTC seems to have substituted this with their own video-mode parameter in theory it should work but they messed with some switch where even if you select 60fps it tries to look for a 90fps stream but that's nothing that can't be fixed in ida.
I tried using video-mode param but didn't seem to take any effect I do not have a HTC 10 to do further tests to make matters worse HTC added log mask code in pretty much all the libs rendering logcat useless.
The logcat mask needs to be disabled somehow once that's done there maybe hope but as it is now no device and no logcat I can't do much about it.
There alternative is to get 60fps working at 4k that does not require video-hfr or high-speed recording it requires time and trial and error to find the correct register values currently the know reg configs give 40fps 1080p and 32-35fps 4k.
Sent from my NX503A using XDA Free mobile app
Was anyone able to achieve [email protected] video recoding with the stock camera app?
I always saw that a lot of phones I had before got some software mods that improved e.g. camera, or any other app, so why is it that HTC 10 cannot get Camera mod to include [email protected]?
Besides, 4k video IS recorded at 60fps, so I doubt it is not possible with 1080p...
Thank you everyone for explanations and answers
CrazyCypher said:
Was anyone able to achieve [email protected] video recoding with the stock camera app?
I always saw that a lot of phones I had before got some software mods that improved e.g. camera, or any other app, so why is it that HTC 10 cannot get Camera mod to include [email protected]?
Besides, 4k video IS recorded at 60fps, so I doubt it is not possible with 1080p...
Thank you everyone for explanations and answers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Anyone figure this out? I'm looking at the Pixel or the HTC 10. The pixel can record at 1080p 120FPS and it has the same CPU as the HTC 10
Is honor 8 pro capable of playing X265 10bit 1080p hevc video?
I've tried samples from jelly fish with stock player, mx player n vlc. None works. Tested the same on friend's op3t phone n it played smoothly with stock player. Even X265 10bit 120mbps 4k video was played without lag on op3t. But this honor 8 pro cant even play 5mbps X265 10bit video?
So is this hardware issue on honor 8 pro?
Any suggestions??
Life_sux said:
Is honor 8 pro capable of playing X265 10bit 1080p hevc video?
I've tried samples from jelly fish with stock player, mx player n vlc. None works. Tested the same on friend's op3t phone n it played smoothly with stock player. Even X265 10bit 120mbps 4k video was played without lag on op3t. But this honor 8 pro cant even play 5mbps X265 10bit video?
So is this hardware issue on honor 8 pro?
Any suggestions??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. It's absolutely capable. I just tried. Make sure you're using the latest vlc 3.0.0
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Yes i m using vlc 3.0 but no help. Any settings to change? Attached is the screen grab. It plays for few secs and then hangs.
https://youtu.be/gvWLlUT0jMs
Pls can anyone suggest what would be the prob??
Life_sux said:
Yes i m using vlc 3.0 but no help. Any settings to change? Attached is the screen grab. It plays for few secs and then hangs.
https://youtu.be/gvWLlUT0jMs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really have no idea.
Try turning the hardware acceleration to Full in Vlc.
Are you on EMUI8?
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Hardware acceleration is to full and m still on emui 5.1, waiting for ota update.
If its of any help, attached is the screen grab from stock player.
Playback is smooth but with distorted colors.
https://youtu.be/YDyZ4vTSJuM
Life_sux said:
If its of any help, attached is the screen grab from stock player.
Playback is smooth but with distorted colors.
https://youtu.be/YDyZ4vTSJuM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I too had this problem on EMUI 5.1
Wait for the update. It may solve the problem because I didn't encounter this problem on EMUI 8.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Thanks for your help!! Will update once i get oreo update..
So my phone has been updated to emui 8.0 and phone has been factory reset post update but this issue of non playing X265 10bit videos is still there.
Any advise?
1080p hevc mkv videos cannot be played with inbuilt player (due to colour distortion, though videos are played). With MX player, HW decoder is not supported; video automatically starts playing with SW decoder. With VLC full Hardware decoding is supported without color distortion (but still playback is not that smooth, sometimes even videos got stuck).
Overall video playback on honor 8 pro is poor. So don't expect much.
Lakadbaggha said:
1080p hevc mkv videos cannot be played with inbuilt player (due to colour distortion, though videos are played).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct
Lakadbaggha said:
With MX player, HW decoder is not supported; video automatically starts playing with SW decoder.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct
Lakadbaggha said:
With VLC full Hardware decoding is supported without color distortion (but still playback is not that smooth, sometimes even videos got stuck).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
correct
M facing same issues that u highlighted above. Earlier in my posts I was told that this device is capable of running hevc 10bit videos so I thought its my device specific issue.
Lakadbaggha said:
Overall video playback on honor 8 pro is poor. So don't expect much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK, so any solutions to play hevc vdo or should I stick to x264 only?
Life_sux said:
correct
correct
correct
M facing same issues that u highlighted above. Earlier in my posts I was told that this device is capable of running hevc 10bit videos so I thought its my device specific issue.
OK, so any solutions to play hevc vdo or should I stick to x264 only?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The chipset is surely capable but I don't know why this happens.
Vlc does play the video but if the video is skipped, it gets stuck on that frame.
Maybe because the kirin chipset isn't widely used and thus, there are optimisation issues with many apps. I get dropped frame rates almost in all games and this baffles me because the chipset is fairly powerful.
I am not buying device with kirin chipset again. Lots of optimization issues with 3rd party apps.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
K.khiladi said:
The chipset is surely capable but I don't know why this happens.
Vlc does play the video but if the video is skipped, it gets stuck on that frame.
Maybe because the kirin chipset isn't widely used and thus, there are optimisation issues with many apps. I get dropped frame rates almost in all games and this baffles me because the chipset is fairly powerful.
I am not buying device with kirin chipset again. Lots of optimization issues with 3rd party apps.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it would be really sad. u've contributed a lot to this community. to say this means we won't see you in the honor/ huawei section that often since they usually stick to their own processor.
but yes, it does seem sad that there's really not much optimisation... though for the GPU, it is still MALI, which is also on Exynos.
i can only hope things will be better and Huawei/ honor can really work with more developers.
mydragoon said:
it would be really sad. u've contributed a lot to this community. to say this means we won't see you in the honor/ huawei section that often since they usually stick to their own processor.
but yes, it does seem sad that there's really not much optimisation... though for the GPU, it is still MALI, which is also on Exynos.
i can only hope things will be better and Huawei/ honor can really work with more developers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can't really say if that first line was sarcasm or not.
This device can't play any game without skipping frame rates. It lags pathetically on playing temple run 2.
There are clearly optimisation issues for 3rd party apps because they have optimised it exceptionally well for their own apps and the whole software. This ruins the overall experience because as the OP stated that a device with SD821 plays 1080p 10 bit x265 videos smoothly while this doesn't.
Exynos devices may not be relying from this same problem because Samsung sells those devices in a lot more number than Kirin devices.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
K.khiladi said:
I can't really say if that first line was sarcasm or not.
This device can't play any game without skipping frame rates. It lags pathetically on playing temple run 2.
There are clearly optimisation issues for 3rd party apps because they have optimised it exceptionally well for their own apps and the whole software. This ruins the overall experience because as the OP stated that a device with SD821 plays 1080p 10 bit x265 videos smoothly while this doesn't.
Exynos devices may not be relying from this same problem because Samsung sells those devices in a lot more number than Kirin devices.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
why do you think it's sarcasm??
as for Exynos devices... they also use MALI GPU, though it's a diff variant of the chip. still, if they can get it optimised... i guess we can hope it's the same for Huawei/ honor. after all, Huawei/ honor is also one of the top manufacturers in the world right now.
mydragoon said:
why do you think it's sarcasm??
as for Exynos devices... they also use MALI GPU, though it's a diff variant of the chip. still, if they can get it optimised... i guess we can hope it's the same for Huawei/ honor. after all, Huawei/ honor is also one of the top manufacturers in the world right now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I felt it was sarcasm because I don't think I have done anything major for the community here. I am not a dev [emoji12]
I haven't used an Exynos device. So, I am just guessing. Yup, I know they both use the same GPU but with lesser number of cores though. Maybe that's the root cause of this or it's just pure optimisation problems, don't know because reviews didn't show any such issues with this device. I am really confused.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
K.khiladi said:
I felt it was sarcasm because I don't think I have done anything major for the community here. I am not a dev [emoji12]
I haven't used an Exynos device. So, I am just guessing. Yup, I know they both use the same GPU but with lesser number of cores though. Maybe that's the root cause of this or it's just pure optimisation problems, don't know because reviews didn't show any such issues with this device. I am really confused.
Sent from my DUK-L09 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes even i am also confused as reviews shows no such issues but it can be possible that not many ppl really tested these specific vidoes on this device. Hence I posted screen recordings of my phone. Need some more testers to see if I m the unlucky one.
Stock player plays video smoothly but with lot of color distortion. VLC just hangs after 1sec and MX player plays through SW decoder with lot of stuttering. XPlayer from Google play plays video much better but still stutter a lot. Overall you can't play x265 10bit HEVC videos with higher bitrate n framerate and of higher file size on our H8Pro. What a disappointment. I tested the Jellyfish sample video which was around ~33mb and main10
Not only in hevc, x264 video playback also have a bug. The 'blacks' are not shown properly in HW decoding of MX player or inbuilt player or VLCs full Hardware decoding or any app using internal codecs including video playback in YouTube app. There is a permanent 'tint' over video (only video screen) when played in these ways. The tint is absent in SW decoding mode of MX player which means the fault is in internal decoding.
To check this pause a black scene of widescreen video (so that there are top and bottom black bars). The black bars are distinctly visible in inbuilt player (and other playbacks that use internal decoding); But screen is full black (black of screen becomes same as that of bars and so can not be distinguished) when SW decoding of MX player or VLC (No harware acceleration) is used.
Not only blacks become greenish black but all colors become slightly dull compared to actual.
This most probably wasn't before oreo update.
Also there is one more magic to it. I tried to attach screenshot, but the screenshots are clear (tint is absent), even when screen recording is on tint dissapears and reappears as soon as screen recording is turned off.
I had to take shot from another phones camera. Pics in attachment is of same black scene (video paused). Screenshot is completely black while photograph shows how it actually appears (distinct top and bottom stripes).
Eye comfort or display color settings has nothing to do with it.
I already reported this issue to honor customer care but I don't think it would do anything.
Anyways, there is NO way to fully enjoy videos in our honor 8 pro. We have to just accept this. To avoid frustrations: stop downloading x265 video, stop comparing with other phones and simply accept what we have.
Wanted to kick off the conversation about enabling high frame rate video recording on the Pixel 3. I just found out the Pixel 3 supports 1080p 120 FPS rear camera video recording. It's even advertised in their camera specs.
The Google Camera APK currently only supports 30fps or "Auto", which is god awful as it fluctuates FPS and doesn't even reach ~55 FPS in bright settings. Aside from enabling a constant 60 FPS option (like the Pixel 2), is there a way to enable the 120 FPS setting as well? Would this require a custom ROM that changes the Pixel 3 source code, or is the only thing necessary a patched APK of Google Camera? I'm wondering if it's also possible to do this through a Magisk module.
Happy to hear any ideas on how we all could enable 60/120 FPS as the hardware clearly supports it. Furthermore, the Snapdragon 845 supports 4K 60 FPS recording. This makes me believe that it may be even possible to enable 4k 60 FPS which would be amazing. It's really unfortunate we have to revert to an awful 30 FPS for 1080p recording after the Pixel 2 had a 60 FPS option. Thanks in advance.
this doesn't belong here
you should ask this to be moved to general
arh2o said:
Wanted to kick off the conversation about enabling high frame rate video recording on the Pixel 3. I just found out the Pixel 3 supports 1080p 120 FPS rear camera video recording. It's even advertised in their camera specs.
The Google Camera APK currently only supports 30fps or "Auto", which is god awful as it fluctuates FPS and doesn't even reach ~55 FPS in bright settings. Aside from enabling a constant 60 FPS option (like the Pixel 2), is there a way to enable the 120 FPS setting as well? Would this require a custom ROM that changes the Pixel 3 source code, or is the only thing necessary a patched APK of Google Camera? I'm wondering if it's also possible to do this through a Magisk module.
Happy to hear any ideas on how we all could enable 60/120 FPS as the hardware clearly supports it. Furthermore, the Snapdragon 845 supports 4K 60 FPS recording. This makes me believe that it may be even possible to enable 4k 60 FPS which would be amazing. It's really unfortunate we have to revert to an awful 30 FPS for 1080p recording after the Pixel 2 had a 60 FPS option. Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also think its possible. The Hardware is definitely ready for this.
On my old Nexus 5X there were some guys that enabled 1080p/60fps through some edits of the camera lib's. Maybe this will happen too on the P3XL.
Also the Snapdragon 845 is listed with up to 2.8GHz but Google decided to ship the P3 with
2.5GHz but that is another point.
Maybe im wrong
Gesendet von meinem Pixel 3 XL mit Tapatalk
Komodoketavaran said:
I also think its possible. The Hardware is definitely ready for this.
On my old Nexus 5X there were some guys that enabled 1080p/60fps through some edits of the camera lib's. Maybe this will happen too on the P3XL.
Also the Snapdragon 845 is listed with up to 2.8GHz but Google decided to ship the P3 with
2.5GHz but that is another point.
Maybe im wrong
Gesendet von meinem Pixel 3 XL mit Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is correct the 845 goes up to 2.8 ghz and Google under clocked it to 2.5 but a custom kernel can easily fix that. I upped mine back to 2.8 and still have great battery life.
hope Google will fix it
Guys google isn't going to do this.
So who'll build that Mod?
collindubya said:
Guys google isn't going to do this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea I was hoping Google would include the 60 FPS video recording option on the Pixel 3 with their monthly updates but so far nothing. After this sparse January 2019 Pixel 3 update (only audio fixes) I've lost some hope that Google will ever add these high frame rate options. It's a real shame that the Pixel 2 can record at a constant 60 FPS, while the Pixel 3 cannot.
where is camera mod enabling this for stock?
Make the P3xl Camera Great Again
I'm also in support of this mod. Anyone aware of a dev working on this that I can track/follow?
Maybe we could motivate the dev of the Mod for the Pocophone to give it a try? ?
There is even a new magisk module for Samsung exynos devices to activate [email protected] So I would be surprised if it were impossible for our Pixel.
I tried to edit some xml lol but it doesn't let me save the changes
Gesendet von meinem Pixel 3 XL mit Tapatalk
Sadly I'm miles away from being a dev