A quick search on Google and sample videos on YouTube reveal that the G3 is capable of and should record video with stereo sound, and yet I was disappointed to find out that my new G3 D855 does not record stereo sound in video no matter what I try.
I am also not able to record stereo sound on its own, any app that claims to be able to record stereo sound does not do that. ("Sound & Voice Recorder" by NLL, for example)
I am running official LG firmware (v21a) and I have rooted it in an attempt to modify /etc/media_profiles.xml to fix the problem, to no avail. I have also tried custom camera apps such as XCam LG, but that didn't help either.
Thanks for any help troubleshooting this.
Even thought its capable in my opinion yes it has 2 mics but 1 is for noise cancelling technicly u cant record stereo without 2 mics again in my opinion u need both a left and right channel. It might be stereo quality but tru stereo should need two mics for 2 diffrent reffrence points on sound i may horribly wrong and someone please correct me if im wrong
The mics are placed at two different points - one at the bottom of the phone next to the headphone jack, and the other is on the top of the phone next to the IR blaster. In this video you can see that there are separate L and R channels and you can hear the direction of the sounds that were recorded https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dRrVcgr3Ps8
See everyone every told me that the top mic was only for noise canceling
https://m.reddit.com/r/LGG3/comments/2bvciq/weird_bug_i_found_after_watching_a_video_that_i/
I tried this same thing to so thats the mono sound in videos
I guess this could be a possible solution:
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/732125509/ss07-high-quality-stereo-microphone-for-android
Related
Does anybody know of an external microphone or and adapter that will allow an external microphone to be connected to the USB jack on the Dash? I need to do some recordings of some meetings, and the VITO Audionotes program is ideal for this. However, the internal microphone on the Dash produces fairly tinny sounding recordings. I really need something with a little better quality.
TIA,
dow
have you tried raising the "MIC auto gain" & lowering the "VAS" ???
raising the auto gain and lower the VAS will produced better results !
MIC auto gain --->>> increase microphone sensitivity & makes sound recording louder
VAS --->>> setting level high/low for when recording should start so that you won't have gaps ( avoid silence gaps with VAS "Voice Activation System")
you can also select the recording quality to high for higher bitrates ...
hopes that helps !!
Thanks for the response. Yes, I've tried that, and the voice quality is still tinny. Additionally, it tends to clip louder or sharper sounds. However, I can plug in the headset and record through that mic, and it's much better. What I'd like to find is an external microphone like what's on my headset, but without the earbuds.
Thoughts?
really ??
I find mine is loud enough to spared
hmmm .... ever thought about the jogger volume got accidentally turned down when the recording are being played back ??
... ( I did that once )
for clarity I do agreed with you in getting external mic ... but for loudness ... I find it's quite capable.
another thing is ... voice/music playback tends to be better when listening through headphones anyway ... not the device's regular external speaker ...
UnicornKaz said:
really ??
I find mine is loud enough to spared
hmmm .... ever thought about the jogger volume got accidentally turned down when the recording are being played back ??
... ( I did that once )
for clarity I do agreed with you in getting external mic ... but for loudness ... I find it's quite capable.
another thing is ... voice/music playback tends to be better when listening through headphones anyway ... not the device's regular external speaker ...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh yeah, it's plenty loud, but in this case, clarity is the prime objective. I'll be attending a week-long music workshop next month, and a large part of what I'll be learning has to do with learning by ear, making it necessary to record the classes and sessions. AudioNotes is a great mp3 recording program, and I used it last year with great results on the SDA that I had then. The Dash, however, must have been built with the bargain-basement microphones. Because of this, music recorded live, even in a classroom situation is not acceptable for study use, since the sound quality is so degraded when using the internal mic. After the classes, I'll be transferring the mp3 files to my laptop to be archived for future practice.
Clear as mud?
This might not be as much of an issue for most people as it is for me, but I've noticed that my Mi Max isn't recording stereo audio when filming video or when using audio recording apps.
I've attached screenshots form Sony's Audio Recorder showing the microphone test function. You can see on my old Meizu the levels are different for the top and bottom microphones, whereas on the Xiaomi both microphones are being combined into a mono track (both levels are the same).
If possible, it would be great if someone could confirm that this is the same for their device too. I've attached a link to the Sony Audio Recorder on the Play Store. The mic test function is in the settings menu.
I'm using a Hydrogen 32GB/3GB with the latest unrooted/unmodified global ROM. 8.1.6.0
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.sonymobile.androidapp.audiorecorder
Yep same. It has a mono speaker so it's normal that it has a mono recorder.
RedFox12 said:
Yep same. It has a mono speaker so it's normal that it has a mono recorder.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi RedFox. Thanks for confirming that. It's true that the handset has a mono speaker, but the phone has two microphones, one at the top and one at the bottom.
Like most modern handsets it uses both microphones to record audio when filming video. When the phone is held in landscape one microphone (usually the top) records on the left and the other (usually the bottom) on the right. The issue is that it mixes both left and right channels into one mono track. That is actually pretty uncommon, as most handsets keep the stereo separation to give you a more immersive experience when watching on a laptop or listening on headphones.
Maybe it's an issue they'll fix with a future update. Who knows! Thanks again for checking it out! :good:
MikusP said:
Hi RedFox. Thanks for confirming that. It's true that the handset has a mono speaker, but the phone has two microphones, one at the top and one at the bottom.
Like most modern handsets it uses both microphones to record audio when filming video. When the phone is held in landscape one microphone (usually the top) records on the left and the other (usually the bottom) on the right. The issue is that it mixes both left and right channels into one mono track. That is actually pretty uncommon, as most handsets keep the stereo separation to give you a more immersive experience when watching on a laptop or listening on headphones.
Maybe it's an issue they'll fix with a future update. Who knows! Thanks again for checking it out! :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this! Hope that lineage os will fix this eventually
hi MikusP, my mi max also having this issue, not only the mi max series device, most of the all Mi mobiles are in the same problem, because this is not a mobile hardware problem, its depends on the (OS) software, by the software only we could rectify this problem, these process has to rectify done through only mi xiome manufacture, the manufacture also know this problem, most of the people didn't like stereo recording, even though many people they dont know about this problem we could not modify this problem. and also one more problem is FM radio not play in stereo mode, i checked in most of the mi series, these also can modified only by (OS).
Simple question, does it record audio videos in Stereo or Mono??
No one has the phone yet, so its hard to say right now. However, the store page for the device says it has 3 microphones, so there is a chance it does.
It is not likely that it has dual-mics for recording. The extra mics on a phone are typically only used for noise cancellation while the primary mic will change depending on usage. For example, the mic on the face is primary for normal phone calls, the mic on the bottom is primary during speaker phone useage and the one on the rear is primary for video.
According to this video: https://youtu.be/0Mp5Y3UTWH8?t=704
...it only records in mono.
Hello. Does anyone know how to defeat the problem with stereo? I record video but stereo is not felt. In the media info writes 2 channels of stereo but there is no sound on it. Tried to close the microphone one at a time, so the top one writes a bit silly, and the bottom one is normal but there is no stereo. How to be? Firmware 9.2.2.0
I understand the stereo does not work for us?
Hi, I don't know if you have noticed, but the Xiaomi Mi 6 with the original sound recorder app has an outstanding stereo sound quality (set on music and high bitrate), like an ASMR microphone. The problem is that it looks like this can be achieved only with that app; I've tried many other recorder apps but there's no stereo recording and no such a high-quality sound. I also think this is the most underrated characteristic of this flagship. Just to clarify, I put the headphones on my phone, matching the left and right channels with the respective microphones (one on the bottom, near the Type C and one on the top, near the infrared IF), I played a song and in the meanwhile I recorded it. This is the result:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1dSQfl0mGc_9p7goNMr2-_srRJ5jXi6yi
And this is the original one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsv5-RO04Ds
(I hope not to have problems with copyrights or something; in that case, let me know about it)
Anyway, is there any way to have the same sound quality with a different ROM? I found the MIUI recorded .apk but for some reasons, it doesn't want to install. It would be a real shame if I lost this function.
Have you tried Sony's audio recorder? https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.sonymobile.androidapp.audiorecorder
I'm using it on Pixel Experience 9, I set the quality to the highest, and it has great sound quality.
Yes, I tried it but the sound quality is way lower than the original app; also, if you select "stereo recording" there's not really a stereo sound because it will record the sound only using the microphone on the bottom of the phone.