Got my Rhino Shield in the mail today and promptly applied it. Here's a short review of my experience with it thus far.
Fit
Coming from a Spigen Ultra Clear, which fit the Nexus 5 screen perfectly, I would say the Rhino Shield is not very accurately cut. It doesn't cover the glass entirely and this makes the application a bit more difficult as you struggle to center the protector on the glass such that hole on the screen protector aligns with the speaker hole. I gave up after a few tries and left the screen protector slightly misaligned to the right.
Furthermore, I noted that the curved edges (top and bottom) of the screen protector does not have the same curvature as the phone. It was slightly less curved than the phone, but doesn't cause any issues as the protector was cut smaller than the screen anyway.
Touch
After applying the Rhino Shield, I kept experiencing touch issues where the screen had issues tracking my swipes and multi-touch. Swipes in the app drawer would accidentally launch applications and trying to zoom in and out in the camera app using pinch zoom often triggered the camera settings circle menu instead.
Not sure if I need to let the protector settle or something as the protector is relatively thicker than normal polymer screen protectors. Will update again if touch responsiveness improves.
Conclusion
All in all, the Rhino Shield was quite a bit of a disappointment for me. The fit was not the level of quality I would expect from such a highly priced polymer/plastic screen protector, especially after having to remove a relatively fresh piece of Spigen Ultra Clear to make way for it.
Also, being tough and offering superb shatter resistance is pretty much meaningless if it causes issues with the touchscreen.
No pictures??
CubicU07 said:
I would say the Rhino Shield is not very accurately cut. It doesn't cover the glass entirely and this makes the application a bit more difficult as you struggle to center the protector on the glass such that hole on the screen protector aligns with the speaker hole. I gave up after a few tries and left the screen protector slightly misaligned to the right.
Furthermore, I noted that the curved edges (top and bottom) of the screen protector does not have the same curvature as the phone. It was slightly less curved than the phone, but doesn't cause any issues as the protector was cut smaller than the screen anyway.
.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw some pictures of the rhino shield on a nexus 5 here: http://m.imgur.com/a/DsSqP
it seems to me like the fit/cut is near perfect. Maybe there is an issue with yours... You should contact them with a picture of your problem.
I would not be surprised if they used a Spigen Glass.t Slim to cut the Rhino Shield because it has the exact same cut. Thankfully Rhino Shield supplies good stickies for removing dust, unlike Spigen. Why, Spigen, why?
The Rhino Shield really shouldn't be compared to the Spigen Ultra Clear which offers minimal protection...and people who are "glass only" must have had some bad experiences with Zagg shields.
Removed the shield. The touch problems made it impossible for me to keep it on. So much for my money.
CubicU07 said:
Removed the shield. The touch problems made it impossible for me to keep it on. So much for my money.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tapped two fingers all around my screen and always got the zoom ui. I suppose there are variations in the manufacturing process.
FloppyDrive said:
I tapped two fingers all around my screen and always got the zoom ui. I suppose there are variations in the manufacturing process.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure... I had some suspicions that it might have been my phone... but once I removed the Rhino Shield and put my Spigen Ultra Clear back on, touch was flawless again.
Wow, this sounds horrible. I ordered one after mentions on XDA about it. I really hope yours is a rarity, sorry about your loss.
Call/Email them, for the money they should make good on their product.
Anyone else having this problem?
I dont know but i have zero of the problems you mention here?
My rhino shield fits perfectly and i have no touch issues.
I love this protector. The surface is like glass and no fingerprints like with the cheap protectors
Gesendet von meinem Nexus 5 mit Tapatalk
Hmmm. Strange how the majority of negative reviews I've seen around here are from accounts that are brand new or have super low post counts. I would definitely take these with a grain of salt. Keep an eye out for reviewers credibility before forming personal opinions.
No.....I dont work for Rhino, lol.
You are making me feel worried... but how could a 0.29mm thick plastic sheet hinder touch, while a 0.4mm thick glass does not?
Plus I've never read that RS has this issue in other phones.
Anyway you should email them for help. From their history they will very likely be sending out replacements if there is indeed an issue.
munsterrr said:
Hmmm. Strange how the majority of negative reviews I've seen around here are from accounts that are brand new or have super low post counts. I would definitely take these with a grain of salt. Keep an eye out for reviewers credibility before forming personal opinions.
No.....I dont work for Rhino, lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hate those troller!
My sister has a Rhino Shield on her black Nexus 5, and tells me that touch is definitely affected, although nowhere near as described by CubicU07. Multitouch, swipe still worked flawlessly. I've got the Spigen Glass.t Slim on my white Nexus 5, and did a little comparison. I only had to apply a tad little more force into touches on the Rhino Shield than the Spigen Glass.t Slim. Day to day use is uninhibited in both cases.
Not so smudge free...
After using my rhino shield on my nexus 5 for two weeks, the smudges on the screen are dissapointing, worse than before.
I've not checked the impact protection, fortunately.
Nicks
I've had the rhino shield for almost 3 weeks never dropped the phone and it's the only thing in that pocket, now I have a nick on the screen... which really sucks.
If it's worth anything, I just got mine today and applied it to my phone replacing an iSmooth HD protector (which was very highly rated on Amazon) and was a very decent screen protector.
I would have to say that application was one of the easiest and dust free experiences I've had on a phone (and I've installed tons of screen protectors from various vendors on my different phones).
So far, I don't notice any sort of "fit" issues -- everything lined up nicely. Also, no noticeable loss of touch or sensitivity. In fact, the screen seems a bit smoother than the protector I just replaced.
I don't have any experience with the Glass screen protectors, so I'm not sure how this compares - but in comparison to the the regular screen protectors, this has to be one of the nicest ones available -- plus with the added impact protection make this one a winner.
Pure rubbish. After 6 months of use, completely scratched. No drops, no keys in my pocket. I discourage it.
Related
I purchased this based on some feedback I had read one some other forums. I have tried nearly every major screen protector out there (Spigen, RearthUSA, Incipio, Switcheasy, BodyGuardz, XO Skins, Best Skins Ever, a ton of cheap ones off Amazon, Zagg, etc.). Up until this point, I had always found the Ultra Crystal from Spigen to be the best overall. Not anymore.
Before I get started I want to mention that the Martin Fields Screen protectors are not cheap. One screen protector for the Galaxy Nexus is $16.99 ($34.99 for one iPad protector and $29.99 for one Nexus 7 protector)and it only comes with one screen protector and a set of instructions. That's it.
One issue I've always found to be a huge problem with these dry, crystal clear screen protectors (Again, think Spigen Ultra Crystal) is that they show fingerprints so easily that it really can become a huge nuisance and to my surprise this one doesn't show much at all. I would say it's nearly as good at resisting fingerprints as a matte finish screen protector.
A very innovative feature this screen protector offers is that it is completely removable. They include a Mylar sheet that you can stick it to if you need to take it off. Just apply a small piece of scotch tape at the bottom corner and slowly pull to remove it. This does bring up the biggest problem that I have with this protector though. It is somewhat brittle. It will crease if you aren't careful with it. In fact, if you look in the pictures I have posted, you'll notice a slight crease in the bottom right corner. I've emailed the seller that I purchased it from on Amazon to see if they'll replace it. Not sure if that'll happen and it isn't all that distracting.
Quick Summary:
PROS:
As clear as any I've ever used
Does not pick up oils like most clear, dry application screen protectors generally do
Feels as close to glass as anything I've ever used
Reusable
Covers entire screen
Comes with a Camera Lens cover as well
CONS:
Not cheap. If you purchase directly from MartinFields.com it is $16.99 + $4.99 shipping. Be aware of fakes on Amazon.
Doesn't come with much. Just a simple paper package, a screen protector and a Mylar sheet to apply it to if you decide to take it off and use it later.
Fragile, it will crease if you aren't careful
Almost too big. If you don't line it up absolutely perfect it will not adhere on the sides, bottom. It's almost cut too perfect to a fault.
Anyway, here are some pictures. I had just ran my palm down the screen to show you just how well this does on hand oils.
Martin Field's Link
Well I take it no one found this helpful?
Breezer23 said:
Well I take it no one found this helpful?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I already have one but I will concur with everything you said
Mine creased before I put it on but I was able to bend it back and can't tell you where the crease ever was at this point. Mine is scratched up pretty good at this point but I'm hard on phones so it's not surprising. I've yet to find a screen protector that holds up to my use.
Mind had a crease initially. I contacted their support line in Hong Kong and they had one sent out to me the next day. I ended up buying one for my Nexus 7 and my iPad 3.
It's weird, the Ultra Crystal's and many other dry application protectors leave blue smears when you try to wipe away fingerprints. These don't. They are there but they don't leave that annoying blue greasy smudge.
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
TheBeardedAx said:
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Mime feather is my first experience with extremely thin glass protectors. My experience at first was great, but it is starting to fall apart and I'm regretting my purchase. It started with the corners for some reason even though I have the heavy duty ballistic case on the phone. Now I'm getting whole cracks from one side to the other... Not even originating from the corners where it started. I am clueless as to how it happens because I have never dropped my phone.
If you're going to get a glass protector I strongly encourage you to get the non-thin versions. It's not a whole lot thicker and it is less likely to be brittle. I have used several normal thickness glass protectors in the past (Spigen) and was never disappointed in those. So far my experience with MIME is poor, but Spigen has been excellent and that includes their cases.
Thanks. I was tempted buy Iloome's flex glass cause it's on sale right now for $17 but I was thinking the thicker protector might be the way to go.
TheBeardedAx said:
I just got my Nexus 5, my first Nexus phone, and I'm pretty excited about it. Naturally I want to add some protection to it especially since I will likely be going sans-case (at least for use, though I've ordered a leather/wool felt sleeve for it to take refuge in while not in the protection of my hands, which will work well with my Pebble as I don't need to constantly check the phone for notifications). A friend of mine that I talked into impulse buying the N5 ordered the Mime Feather Glass protector after his research. Looking through the threads I could find it looks like a lot of people have had issues with chipping edges on that model, and it sounds like a slew of other issues from other manufacturers like Spigen, and I don't like the extra cutouts on the Nillkin protector (just seems like an extra space for dust to collect and takes away from the sleekness a bit IMO). Anyway it looked like most of those posts originated closer to the launch time of the N5 so I'm wondering if any glass protectors have stood out for quality above the rest over the past couple months?
I know the tempered glass protectors are more expensive, but the feel, look, scratch resistance, and apparently debatable shatter protection of the underlying screen seem to be the best option. I saw the post about the Rhino Shield but the much lower scratch resistance and similar price coupled with the article claiming a ziploc bag offered similar protection deterred me slightly :silly:
tl:dr- looking for a sweet tempered glass screen protector to use without a case, what's the best option (overall/value)
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using MIME Ghost glass protector. It is excellent. I am using my N5 without a case.
psy_spy said:
I am using MIME Ghost glass protector. It is excellent. I am using my N5 without a case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How long have you been using the Ghost? Any issues with peeling/chipping/bubbles?
I enjoy the spigen glastr nano slim. I haven't had any issues since i put it on week ago. I wrote a thread about it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
TheBeardedAx said:
How long have you been using the Ghost? Any issues with peeling/chipping/bubbles?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have been using it for 2 weeks. No peeling/chipping issues since it is a bit thicker compared to feather. When I applied it on the phone, I got a very small bubble near the upper left corner. It disappeared after a day. Please read reviews from other mime ghost owners to get a fair idea. I remember seeing a separate thread for mime in the n5 forum.
I've got the spigen glass nano.tr slim (the one with rounded corners) coming the mail. Any tips on applying it? I REALLY get OCD (ADHD) if there's ANY dust or bubbles under the screen, so I have to do it perfectly, since it costs nearly £30.
Any advice on how to do it flawlessly?
I read somewhere about running the shower on hot for 30 mins, then doing it in the bathroom, because the hot air causes the dust to all fall to the ground and isn't flying around - but won't that cause condensation etc to build up on the screen in the seconds before you apply the protector?
Any tips would be greatly appreciated.
paradoxiumwind said:
I've got the spigen glass nano.tr slim (the one with rounded corners) coming the mail. Any tips on applying it? I REALLY get OCD (ADHD) if there's ANY dust or bubbles under the screen, so I have to do it perfectly, since it costs nearly £30.
Any advice on how to do it flawlessly?
I read somewhere about running the shower on hot for 30 mins, then doing it in the bathroom, because the hot air causes the dust to all fall to the ground and isn't flying around - but won't that cause condensation etc to build up on the screen in the seconds before you apply the protector?
Any tips would be greatly appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
See my thread. Use the hinge method. I didn't do it in a steamy room, but it went on near flawless. (No dust, but only very slightly off center)
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I got the xgear glass for nexus 4 and it was great. It save me phone, I drop it on is screen and nothing happens only the tempered glass was broken.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
KTT16 said:
See my thread. Use the hinge method. I didn't do it in a steamy room, but it went on near flawless. (No dust, but only very slightly off center)
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Regarding the hinge method, make sure when you close the hinge it falls smack dab center. No having to pull it to slightly center it, etc. The tape itself has some bit of tension so it will pull the screen protector back. I'm like 0.2mm off center and I'm very annoyed. So maybe when you tape the screen protector down, start slightly to the left (assuming you tape the right).
Also if you have access to a clean room, do it there. I regret doing it at home and not staying late at work to use the CDA and cleanroom to properly dust off my screen. A stupid eyelash fell off in the middle of the procedure and I have a freaking eyelash underneath my screen protector. LOL. Good thing it's at the bezel though.
The most effective method imo is the steamed washroom method which gives you lots of chances to get it right and you'll never get any dust or any other particles on your screen.
The cruzerlite glass screen protector is amazing. I need to write up a review on it now and take some pics as I've had it over a week. It honestly feels better than the real n5 screen.
>^.^< Sent From Meow nexus 5
I have the Mime Feather Glass and it works great. I did have to shave the corners of my Ringke case to prevent the screen protector from peeling up on the edges. See post #30 here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2540471
On a side note., the screen protector did crack, from something I did, and Mime sent me a coupon for 50% off a new one.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
I have a Nillkin protector, looks and feels great. Just wondering how a tempered glass protector fares against drops compared to those shatter proof polyurethane (non glass) screen protectors like Rhino Shield and Zagg Extreme. I know Tempered glass protectors can shatter but those others won't, I’m not worried about that, I’m more concerned about the level of protection they offer. Are glass protectors as good as those other ones at dispersing and dampening impact forces? I've seen a couple of videos on Rhino Shield and they look amazing.
I received the first gen of Spigen's SLIM.t screen protectors in mid-November and have been using it since. Initially, the product was great albeit it still attracted fingerprints. I was highly satisfied and the tempered glass looked and felt amazing (plus I managed to avoid any of the bubbles the majority of early buyers experienced).
But a month after normal use (I don't use a case either, but I'm very careful with my phone) it started chipping on the edges. I never dropped my phone or do anything that would cause damage, but magically out of no where the screen protector started chipping.
Currently today, I have 6 chips around my screen protector (2 at the top, 1 on the right, 3 on the left), and two clear cracks across my phone as well (both stemming from separate chips on the side). I'm not sure how the SPIM.tR Nano performs, but I can tell you that paying over $30 for a screen protector that chips this easily is not a worthwhile investment. Something to be aware of.
Zagg HD shield has no problems
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
KTT16 said:
I enjoy the spigen glastr nano slim. I haven't had any issues since i put it on week ago. I wrote a thread about it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This. Best screen protector I've ever had, a little pricey but I'm glad I bought it.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Hello Folks,
I know there are loads of screen protector threads out there but none of them are recent for the MotoX.
I have had an XtremeGuard Protector on my X for a few months, but the gummyness, orange peel and lack of screen sensitivity is killing me.
What are some good current options that are $15 or under ?
Thanks,
Pete
I'm currently using the SUPCASE Screen protector that came with my case: has everything I need to get it on once and only once(even comes with a lint remover film). Looks and feel great. I don't know what you mean by 'gummyness though, the only screen protector I would describe that has a gummy-like feel(especially when I pinch with my fingernail is the Skinomi brands.
pasta1234 said:
Hello Folks,
I know there are loads of screen protector threads out there but none of them are recent for the MotoX.
I have had an XtremeGuard Protector on my X for a few months, but the gummyness, orange peel and lack of screen sensitivity is killing me.
What are some good current options that are $15 or under ?
Thanks,
Pete
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using this: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00EVWX5VO/ref=oh_details_o01_s01_i01?ie=UTF8&psc=1
and like it. If you get it - start applying from the bottom of the phone (near USB connector) because the cutout for microphone is small and more precision is required there than on top.
Thank you for the suggestions folks
What about the glass ones i hear people talking about, what are there advantages ?
Pete
JoeSchmoe007 said:
I am using this: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00EVWX5VO/ref=oh_details_o01_s01_i01?ie=UTF8&psc=1
and like it. If you get it - start applying from the bottom of the phone (near USB connector) because the cutout for microphone is small and more precision is required there than on top.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll second these. I had the ArmorSuit and it was terrible. These are cheap, durable and don't negatively affect the screen.I've been using one for over 2 months and it still looks fine.
The screen protectors from Motorola are very good.
pasta1234 said:
Thank you for the suggestions folks
What about the glass ones i hear people talking about, what are there advantages ?
Pete
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought a couple of the Mimeusa.com glass screen protectors, one for my wife and another for myself. Installed mine first, its a little different installing such a stiff protector, luckily i was able to lift it back up easily a couple times to adjust the positioning.
The wifes I installed a couple hours after, and it felt like it gave me more problems. didn't want to get positioned right, but eventually I got it lined up well.
The next day it fell off in her car while she was driving and got covered in dirt and dust on the adhesive side.
Mine is still on, after 2 weeks of use;
The texture is awesome! i hate most screen protectors, but this is glass and feels so good to the touch. you hardly notice its there.
It hasn't taken and scratches, and it does feel like fingerprints are less noticeable than on the bare screen.
I don't have a case of my X yet, ordered a bumper from amazon, but its not here yet.
I feel that the protector gathers small fibers easily at the edge. there are a couple of very small fibers that have worked there way just under the edge of the glass. They are hardly noticeable, especially when the screen is on.
I have not seen any new accumulation since the first few days, so maybe its more prone to catching the fibers in the hours / day after installation. I would advise avoiding pockets for 24 hours after installing this product if you can.
I will probably use this screen protector until it chips/breaks/gets too scratched up, and then go naked screen for the rest of the phones life.
If you are intending to spend $15 for a screen protector, might as well get a tempered glass one. I'm using this one: http://www.amazon.com/i-Blason-Motorola-Ultra-Thin-Tempered-Protector/dp/B00E0CUP18/
If you installed it correctly the first time, it should stay stuck and without any bubbles.
pasta1234 said:
Thank you for the suggestions folks
What about the glass ones i hear people talking about, what are there advantages ?
Pete
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you Google?
eksasol said:
If you are intending to spend $15 for a screen protector, might as well get a tempered glass one. I'm using this one: http://www.amazon.com/i-Blason-Motorola-Ultra-Thin-Tempered-Protector/dp/B00E0CUP18/
If you installed it correctly the first time, it should stay stuck and without any bubbles.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's very expansible for me i think...
I appreciate everyone help...
For those who have the glass protectors, do u feel they are worth the extra money compared to a good clear protector like the halo ? Do they cause interference with cases ?
What do u mean expansible sumonmolla ?
Pete
pasta1234 said:
Hello Folks,
I know there are loads of screen protector threads out there but none of them are recent for the MotoX.
I have had an XtremeGuard Protector on my X for a few months, but the gummyness, orange peel and lack of screen sensitivity is killing me.
What are some good current options that are $15 or under ?
Thanks,
Pete
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would just like to throw out my support for Liquid Armor. I use it on all of my touchscreen devices, and have never had a scratch on a screen since, and it feels just like glass, without anything on it. The best part is that the one bottle can be used for several screens. Though if you don't use it in a couple months, the stuff will harden in the nozzle of the bottle, making it more difficult to use.
Edit: figured Id throw in a link. http://www.amazon.com/Dynaflo-LIQUID-ARMOR-Universal-Microfiber-DYN-LA100SP/dp/B007EZ3EM0
Wingdom said:
I would just like to throw out my support for Liquid Armor. I use it on all of my touchscreen devices, and have never had a scratch on a screen since, and it feels just like glass, without anything on it. The best part is that the one bottle can be used for several screens. Though if you don't use it in a couple months, the stuff will harden in the nozzle of the bottle, making it more difficult to use.
Edit: figured Id throw in a link. http://www.amazon.com/Dynaflo-LIQUID-ARMOR-Universal-Microfiber-DYN-LA100SP/dp/B007EZ3EM0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1 on this stuff. Been using it on my last 5 phones in the family. Especially great since the wife and I usually are yearly on replacement devices
Sent from my XT1053 using Tapatalk
Disclaimer: I posted this in a couple other threads, but I wanted to try and post it where I know we've been discussing tempered glass screen protectors.
Here's some pictures of the redesigned i-Blason protector. As you can see, there is now a cutout for the proximity sensor. The corners also fit the Moto X perfectly (their old design fit perfectly too). Very happy I finally have a protector that FITS and where the proximity sensor won't be blocked! I liked the i-Blason until I had started having proximity sensor issues because I had dropped it several times, and it never once cracked, unlike the MIME, which cracked the very first time I dropped it.
pasta1234 said:
I appreciate everyone help...
For those who have the glass protectors, do u feel they are worth the extra money compared to a good clear protector like the halo ? Do they cause interference with cases ?
What do u mean expansible sumonmolla ?
Pete
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have tempered glass on my moto X ( mimeusa.com/product/moto-x-ghost-glass-screen-protector/ ) since january.
it was very easy to install and the feel is wonderful. my only complaint is that when you drop your phone, it can crack. better a crack on the protector than a scratch on the device, right? my phone has been pretty suicidal lately, what w/ jumping off tables, so it has accumulated many cracks on the protector. i am replacing it (with same ghost glass) and also buying a bumper case ... that may make a difference in the life span of the protector.
this is my first glass protector and yes i like it. on previous devices i used zagg screen protectors and was VERY HAPPY with them, but when i ordered their protector for the moto X, i found that they must have screwed up on the device specs, as the film didn't even cover the entire viewing screen. UNACCEPTABLE! i will not go back to their products.
I had the MIMEUSA and was very happy with the feel of the MIMEUSA, but it didn't fit properly. The corners were too squared and extended over the screen. The edges were also suppose to be beveled to prevent chipping but mine seemed like they were beveled out, leaving a lip on the glass. This all led to the edges chipping and eventually a larger break.
I ordered the i-Blason to try it and am very happy. The fit is perfect, its quite a bit thinner than the MIMEUSA, and it feels just as slick and smooth as the MIMEUSA and the glass screen. I would recommend the i-Blason over the MIMEUSA. And the i-Blason is only $17 on Amazon making it about the same price as the high quality plastic protectors.
James4.0 said:
The screen protectors from Motorola are very good.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1. The Power Support protectors are very good. Their 15% off right now as well, till March 21st.
Has anyone been able to put their Rhino Shields to the test? Any near-death OnePlus One experiences where the Rhino Shield has saved you? Drops? Throws? Scratches? Etc..?
More or less the only impact where the Rhino shield will protect your device is if
a) your phone falls flat onto a piece/rock on the floor
b) you hip-bump your pocket+phone into the table
Most impacts will be sideways and the Rhino will not be able to rescue your phone. Only a good case might.
I do have a Rhino but rather sceptical about it's real-world benefits in most cases.
I realize this doesn't answer you question, however, I had one on my OnePlus One and it severely hindered touch screen responsiveness. Peeled it off after a week because I couldn't stand having to touch the screen multiple times for it to notice a touch... Scrolling through pages was even worse. Won't ever buy another Rhino Shield.
Kyle C said:
I realize this doesn't answer you question, however, I had one on my OnePlus One and it severely hindered touch screen responsiveness. Peeled it off after a week because I couldn't stand having to touch the screen multiple times for it to notice a touch... Scrolling through pages was even worse. Won't ever buy another Rhino Shield.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. Expensive and won't buy again, but since I have it on I am leaving it because I want a screen protector. Are the other tempered glass ones any better/do they actually protect? (I am skeptical of rhino's claims, but it's better than nothing or an unknown)
mikelebz said:
I agree. Expensive and won't buy again, but since I have it on I am leaving it because I want a screen protector. Are the other tempered glass ones any better/do they actually protect? (I am skeptical of rhino's claims, but it's better than nothing or an unknown)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rhino Shield is better from direct impact. You could literally hit it with a hammer and I'm sure it wouldn't crack. But for side impacts or anything less severe, a tempered glass protector will be just as good. Plus you won't lose that glass feel.
Kyle C said:
I realize this doesn't answer you question, however, I had one on my OnePlus One and it severely hindered touch screen responsiveness. Peeled it off after a week because I couldn't stand having to touch the screen multiple times for it to notice a touch... Scrolling through pages was even worse. Won't ever buy another Rhino Shield.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really? That's extremely weird. I had one on my iPhone and I currently have on my OnePlus One and I have absolutely zero touch issues. The reason I made this post was just to see if anyone has tested the actual durability of the protector.
mikelebz said:
I agree. Expensive and won't buy again, but since I have it on I am leaving it because I want a screen protector. Are the other tempered glass ones any better/do they actually protect? (I am skeptical of rhino's claims, but it's better than nothing or an unknown)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can't comment on how well they protect compared to any other screen protector. I always buy screen protectors for scratch protection and nothing else.
My buddy has a tempered glass protector, brand unknown to me, on his G3 and its awesome. Perfectly clear, does not interfere with sensitivity at all, and the best part, IMO, it doesn't feel like theres anything there being that it's glass.
jetstream131 said:
Really? That's extremely weird. I had one on my iPhone and I currently have on my OnePlus One and I have absolutely zero touch issues. The reason I made this post was just to see if anyone has tested the actual durability of the protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd like to think I had one from a bad batch or something. Ill leave it at that. If I were to guess, I wouldn't expect it to save the screen from a common drop. They appear to be more designed to withstand a direct impact from something above. Like if you were drop something on top of it. I doubt it would save a screen if it landed on its corner.
If you're in the market for a tempered glass screen protector for the One, look into Orzly. I have one and have had no touch screen sensitivity issues whatsoever. The glass is crystal clear, and is oleophobic so it will do its best to resist oils and water that you may get on it, and anything that you do get on it along the lines of oil, etc. can be easily wiped off with a rag, shirt, etc.
This is my first tempered glass screen protector, and having used it for about 3 weeks now I can safely say that I'll never go back to anything else.
Kawaisa said:
Rhino Shield is better from direct impact. You could literally hit it with a hammer and I'm sure it wouldn't crack. But for side impacts or anything less severe, a tempered glass protector will be just as good. Plus you won't lose that glass feel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have to disagree, I don't believe their marketing claim that it will withstand a direct blow from a hammer, sure the screen wont break but the energy goes somewhere. My issue with rhinoshield is its ability to get scratched up and look horrible. In that respect tempered glass or gorilla glass options outshine it immensely.
jetstream131 said:
Has anyone been able to put their Rhino Shields to the test? Any near-death OnePlus One experiences where the Rhino Shield has saved you? Drops? Throws? Scratches? Etc..?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have my 4-th OPO since it arrived on market, and i have Rhino Shields on my last one. Rhino Shield is the best screen protector i ever had on any of my phones! really !
I recommend it to everyone !
Okay. Here it is. We can start the debate soon about which screen protectors actually work on this phone without Halo and bubble issues. It is always an issue with these curved glass screens but there are always 1 or 2 screen protectors that people can get to actually work. Please post which ones you have purchased and how well they worked.
Posting without pictures is not helpful to anyone.
Ordered the ones through Amazon from Mr. Shields and the case/protector from HanhuaTech. The Mr. Shields order gave me 3 and all 3 were nothing but bubbles. Never used their stuff before and highly disappointed. The latter was a nice case, but the screen protector has a black ring around the edges and is impossible to line-up so it doesn't cover the edges of the display area. No bubbles though. Just cut off part of my screen. Still looking. The Otterbox Defender does not include a screen protector.
I tried those Mr shield protectors with my v30 and they were garbage.
The supershieldz worked well with my v30 but the v40 version has that stupid black border which means it only has adhesive at the edges and will have the rainbow effect
Guess we're all screwed for a bit. For what this thing costs, I refuse not to have the tempered glass protector, but they all have the black ring or bubbles. Early adopter blues I guess.
Curved screens, like the V40 (and pretty much every flagship phone) have tend to have poor tempered glass adhesion, in my experience. It seems they all utilize only adhesive along the outer edge, leading them to come unstuck extremely quickly and easily. All of the reviewed models on Amazon, likewise, have this problem. Hopefully a good one will come out for this phone at some point reasonably soon.
I know that T-Mobile tried to sell me an overpriced one when I purchased my phone, though I'm not certain they had any in stock yet. If no models come out that stay stuck pretty well, I will take purchase one of theirs, as they will replace it every time I come in the store.
Be patient and wait for IQ Shield LiQuidSkin, best on the market for curved screens. Available mid Nov.
I quite enjoy the bodyguardz one I got. It's aluminosilicate like gorilla glass and does have the black border, however I've seen 0 rainbowing. Also comes with lifetime replacements which I will probably thoroughly abuse.
I just ordered a set right from their website. It didn't list that it wasn't in stock and ready to ship, so we'll see!
Don't rush! The earlier you get it, the bigger the risk it's not properly tested yet (especially when it comes to curved screens). This early after release, you're the guinea pig...
While I'm waiting for "IQ Shield LiQuidSkin" I ordered "PULEN Screen Protector"... I'll keep you updated!
I ordered the Poetic tempered glass screen protector. Works like a charm. 3 Days and still sticking no problem. No halo, rainbow effect, etc. Absolutely loving it. Fit is amazing and the feel is as good as the original glass, if not slicker. I'm using it with a Ringke Fusion-X case and they work perfectly together. The screen protector is case friendly and the gap between the glass and case is very minimal.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07HNNBJLC/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
nyttliv7 said:
While I'm waiting for "IQ Shield LiQuidSkin" I ordered "PULEN Screen Protector"... I'll keep you updated!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know PULEN hasn't got very good reviews, but for now, while waiting for LiQuidSkin, it's all good, fits almost perfect. Nothing I recommend though. The black frame covers a faction of the visibility of the screen (left and right side)
But totally OK. Let's see if it falls off before I get my LiQuidSkin?
tveith said:
I ordered the Poetic tempered glass screen protector. Works like a charm. 3 Days and still sticking no problem. No halo, rainbow effect, etc. Absolutely loving it. Fit is amazing and the feel is as good as the original glass, if not slicker. I'm using it with a Ringke Fusion-X case and they work perfectly together. The screen protector is case friendly and the gap between the glass and case is very minimal.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07HNNBJLC/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was just looking at the poetic glass on Amazon and can't seem to find a good enough review that specifies it the tempered glass fully seals to the device or only seals around the edges of the glass?
Just heard from Whitestone email support that they do not currently plan on producing Dome Glass for the V40... real shame. Maybe some other V40 owners can chime in to pique their interest?
I was also just looking at the Poetic before I came over here, and also wonder if it is in fact full-adhesive. Anyone?
justinkerng said:
Just heard from Whitestone email support that they do not currently plan on producing Dome Glass for the V40... real shame. Maybe some other V40 owners can chime in to pique their interest?
I was also just looking at the Poetic before I came over here, and also wonder if it is in fact full-adhesive. Anyone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've been looking at that but but I'm in high doubts it's full adhesive
I just installed the Poetic tempered glass from Amazon and it has a massive rainbow effect. There clearly isn't any adhesive in the middle. Until someone makes a decent one it will have to do.
Blown 89 said:
I just installed the Poetic tempered glass from Amazon and it has a massive rainbow effect. There clearly isn't any adhesive in the middle. Until someone makes a decent one it will have to do.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dang, it seems so difficult to find good tempered glass screen protectors. Poetic seemed promising but glad you confirmed it is not full adhesive, since so many brands don't specify.
nyttliv7 said:
I know PULEN hasn't got very good reviews, but for now, while waiting for LiQuidSkin, it's all good, fits almost perfect. Nothing I recommend though. The black frame covers a faction of the visibility of the screen (left and right side)
But totally OK. Let's see if it falls off before I get my LiQuidSkin?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Update!
Amid medium level reviews on Amazon, I have to say I'm surprised this pulen sp is working so well. Some kind of drier than normal glue, covers the whole sp, and if you place it perfectly, it's actually a very nice sp. The black frame slightly covers (1/10 of a mm) of left and right sides, but it really doesn't take away anything, not even the screen off blue notification around the frame. I'm not sure about the physical strength though. I'm a very careful person, never really drop my phone. No rainbow! No dust stuck around the borders. Right now I'm not sure I will order the liQuidSkin? I'm happy with this one
Folks, whitestone dome for LG V40 available for sale @ Amazon :
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07JQT17Q4/ref=cm_sw_r_em_apa_gAR5BbVS4BYDV
I'm using Key liquid glass screen protector. I can't stand the film protectors so decided to use this. It's a wipe on application, scratch resistant, 9H superior hardness rating, water proof and anti bacterial. Just clean the screen with the included cleaning wipe than apply the liquid screen protector via the included wipe. Let sit for about 5 minutes and you're set.