[Q] "voiding" warranty - Galaxy Note 10.1 (2014 Edition) Q&A, Help & Troubl

All this talk about voiding warranty is interesting. I'm not an expert however I thought that warranty cannot normally just be "voided" in totality - instead manufacturers can deny a warranty claim on the basis that a modification has interfered with the product and they are no longer liable.
So, if we root the device and then have a major software failure (bricked), Samsung can say "denied warranty claim"
On the other hand, if the button stops mechanically working, surely Samsung couldn't claim this was related to the rooting.
thoughts? (or even expert opinion )

boltor said:
thoughts? (or even expert opinion )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In the EU is warranty a legal right which can't be canceled by the seller. In contrast to guarantees the seller made. The problem is that warranty is effective when the problem already exists at the moment of sale. And this is mostly a question of confidence.
I can't speak for Samsung but HTC tries this also and here I know enough cases where the warranty stayed after rooting/unlocking and the device was repaired/replaced free of charge.

I know Asus is not cool about the warranty stuff. I had a 3 month old TF700 that had the touch screen fail and Asus wouldn't fix it under warranty. $280 out of pocket and we all know there is no way CleanROM broke the touchscreen sensor. I just assume Samsung is the same way, but have no idea actually.

snake2332 said:
I know Asus is not cool about the warranty stuff. I had a 3 month old TF700 that had the touch screen fail and Asus wouldn't fix it under warranty. $280 out of pocket and we all know there is no way CleanROM broke the touchscreen sensor. I just assume Samsung is the same way, but have no idea actually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They aren't too bad from my experience. I sent a fully rooted tab 7 to them that had internal memory go bad. I sent it to t hem with ICS on it, though the device was never upgraded beyond gingerbread from OTAs. They fixed it TWICE (it happened again when i received it back) for the same problem without any complaints or questions.

Related

[Q] Rooted S-OFF warranty phone with broken sceen

I have a rooted S-OFF droid incredible with a custom ROM. It also has a completely broken screen. The verizon salesman has told me I can get it covered under warranty and it needs to be sent in. My worry is the S-OFF is going to void this warranty offer when I send it in. Anything to be worried about you think? If there is any doubt, I'd like to turn S-ON, reload stock, and do a factory reset. Anyone able to write up a guide on how to do this pretending I was blind (press down 5 times, wait 5 seconds, etc.)? I did find this guide that gets me part of the way there, but I can't see what I'm doing.
forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=732497
Thanks in advance.
If the screen is busted, they won't be able to see what you ahve done. Also, it is not like you fried the phone due to something you flashed. I don't think you have anything to worry about.
I've sent 3 rooted Droids back to Verizon before I switched to the Incredible, you should have nothing to worry about
I wouldn't worry half as much. The only thing I would worry about is the fact that your gonna send it in and can't do anything to change s-off.. What if they change the screen thinking they can just perform a factory data reset and BAM! they are presented with some custom rom with superuser capability.. And then your account get's hit up with full retail ($529.99US). For some people that can be a large sum of money.
I'll pray with you that is not the case.. I hope you simply receive your replacement phone problem free. I know what it's like to have a cracked screen luckily for me it happened before I jumped the fence into the world of unrevoked forever..
In the future I would check out otterbox(.)com/htc-droid-incredible-cases/htc-droid-incredible-cases,default,sc.html
sorry 4 hijackin'.....
so is it covered under warranty to get a replacement if I dropped the phone and scuffed it up pretty bad?
(It's still operating, but the scuffs make pretty unpleasant to use)
Oh, and is it 9 months for the warranty?
nat4mac said:
sorry 4 hijackin'.....
so is it covered under warranty to get a replacement if I dropped the phone and scuffed it up pretty bad?
(It's still operating, but the scuffs make pretty unpleasant to use)
Oh, and is it 9 months for the warranty?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. What's likely happening is that the VZW rep is referring to an Asurion claim as a warranty even though it's insurance. Warranty only covers manufacturer defects, and does not include cosmetic damage that we inflict ourselves.
najaboy said:
No. What's likely happening is that the VZW rep is referring to an Asurion claim as a warranty even though it's insurance. Warranty only covers manufacturer defects, and does not include cosmetic damage that we inflict ourselves.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
gotcha...thanks
if it's the insurance, does it even matter if it's rooted or not? can't you just pay the deductible and get the new phone. I know they told me i can run mine over with a car and essentially throw it in the river and for $90 i get a new one.

Samsung warranty repair - too good to be true?

I just finished a conversation with a Samsung support person, regarding my hard bricked T989. It seems that either there was some major misunderstanding between the two of us, or Samsung's policy is unexpectedely too firendly.
The bottom line was this: if you hard brick your phone due to firmware update - they will fix it and the repair is under warranty. Huh? Does anyone have a personal experience with getting a phone to be unbricked by manufacturer?
Here are some quotes.
Q: The phone had a firmware update which went wrong and now the phone is 100% inoperable. But there is no mechanical or any other damage whatsoever - only the firmware updated wrong.
Answ.: We can repair the phone, if it is still under warranty and has not been physically damaged. [...] Provided there is no physical damage to the phone and the failure is not due to any type of liquid damage, the phone will be repaired under warranty.
I think I was clear describing the bricking, and the answer was just as clear. Did I miss something?
BTW, the chat was exactly to clarify the question. Originally I emailed them asking a question on a different topic. The reply suggested that the phone could be covered by warranty. Surprise.
Yes Samsung can unbrick it. But they will take like 3 weeks. My friend he bricked his 7 inch galaxy tab and he sent it to Samsung and they unbricked it and sent it back.
Sent from my SGH-T989 using XDA App
Well, having the phone back working 3 weeks late late is better than never. I am aboroad, bought the phone from a tiny retailer, and returning to it to T-Mo wasn't an option. After figuring out that unbicking is not an option either - no one offers the service, because they dont know how to unbrick it yet, - I was thinking that either the phone will go to Adam or will spend a six months in the desk, loosing its value to something like $50. Three weeks is soon.
But the point was slightly different: normally the warranty is void as soon as a product used not as intended. Bricking, I think, is mainly caused by reckless flashing, no paying attention, not reading the instuctions, etc. I expected that if one admits that it is him who made his own phone inoperable, then... well - it's his loss.

Unlocking through htcdev.com and warranty repair - my story

I have bought through clove.co.uk my HTC ONE X.
I have successfully unlocked it through htcdev.com
Now I have a yellowish spot on the lower left corner - a hardware fault, clearly.
I have sent it back to clove.co.uk
They told me that HTC has some doubts about free of charge repairing.
I will keep you posted.
ninja.rogue said:
I have bought through clove.co.uk my HTC ONE X.
I have successfully unlocked it through htcdev.com
Now I have a yellowish spot on the lower left corner - a hardware fault, clearly.
I have sent it back to clove.co.uk
They told me that HTC has some doubts about free of charge repairing.
I will keep you posted.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
please do..as your story seems quite interesting now. hopefully they will replace it for you but kinda makes you think twice before unlocking it now kinda makes me sad hearing that..i really do hope there is an S-OFF exploit cause if there is not i maybe just maybe might end up selling this and going back to either s2 or buy the s3 when that comes out and hopefully that bootloader will be unlocked...i am really loving my phone but things on this side seem so complicated compare to the s2 one
The htcdev unlock shouldn't affect your hardware warranty but it is worded so that in theory anything could be blamed on you altering the firmware. It would be daft if they do end up refusing to fix your phone for free as it is obviously nothing to do with the unlock.
NoobTerminator said:
please do..as your story seems quite interesting now. hopefully they will replace it for you but kinda makes you think twice before unlocking it now kinda makes me sad hearing that..i really do hope there is an S-OFF exploit cause if there is not i maybe just maybe might end up selling this and going back to either s2 or buy the s3 when that comes out and hopefully that bootloader will be unlocked...i am really loving my phone but things on this side seem so complicated compare to the s2 one
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea if you want an easy to root/mod phone Samsung ones are generally better.
Sent from my HTC One X using XDA
I also have informed Clove that I have posted here.
Let's wait and see whether all the hype about HTC opening the bootloader is just marketing or has some sense. After all, I didn't alter anything hardware so if - say - some button or screen ceases to function or doesn't do it properly, why shouldn't warranty be valid??
The thing with the yellow point is well known. At least in Germany. Had a One X that had the same yellow spot on the left bottom of the display too.
Brought it back to the shop (Saturn) and get a complete new one.
Hopefully you get a new one, too!
Forget to mention that I've didn't unlock it.
ninja.rogue said:
After all, I didn't alter anything hardware so if - say - some button or screen ceases to function or doesn't do it properly, why shouldn't warranty be valid??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The way HTC word it on htcdev is that because you're not using official validated firmware then you might have had faulty firmware which damaged hardware e.g. it was overheating but the firmware somehow managed to ignore it and continue.
It depends on what is faulty I guess. If the micro USB socket breaks then it is obviously nothing that could be caused by firmware.
The yellowish spot is probably the glue they used to stick the LCD to the touchscreen. There are quite a few mentions of similar spots on this forum. Was it there when you first got the phone?
Yes it was there but it went unnoticed due to excess of enthusiasm in going through each and every menu and too much work to take care of small details. but then, with time, I got aware of the yellow spot.
Clove also noticed it and sent the phone to HTC.
I avoided unlocking at HTCDev as I'd like to keep my warranty, so I will be waiting for Revolutionary
Sent from my HTC One X using xda premium
same story here, i'm about to send it to htc, i'll await your results, too.
So no rooting without potential warranty issues?
patp said:
So no rooting without potential warranty issues?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HTC is entitled to some form of protection. If you overclock and fry your CPU they shouldn't have to eat the cost. Friends who unlocked international phones have gotten h/w (display, build issues, etc.) related warranty service from HTC with no hassle.
Here's their policy:
It is our responsibility to caution you that not all claims resulting or caused by or from the unlocking of the bootloader may be covered under warranty.
Unlocking the bootloader means that you now have the ability to customize software on your device. Please note that changing your bootloader can cause significant issues with your device and once you have unlocked your device, you have agreed to the disclaimer that states a change in warranty status such that in the event you render your device unusable, you are responsible for the recovery of your device, whether by repair or by other means.
It seems fairly reasonable. Asus has Prime owners completely waive their warranty rights, even for non-related issues, when they unlock their bootloaders. So it could be worse.
You know the old saying - "you play, you pay."
BarryH_GEG said:
HTC is entitled to some form of protection. If you overclock and fry your CPU they shouldn't have to eat the cost. Friends who unlocked international phones have gotten h/w (display, build issues, etc.) related warranty service from HTC with no hassle.
Here's their policy:
It is our responsibility to caution you that not all claims resulting or caused by or from the unlocking of the bootloader may be covered under warranty.
Unlocking the bootloader means that you now have the ability to customize software on your device. Please note that changing your bootloader can cause significant issues with your device and once you have unlocked your device, you have agreed to the disclaimer that states a change in warranty status such that in the event you render your device unusable, you are responsible for the recovery of your device, whether by repair or by other means.
It seems fairly reasonable. Asus has Prime owners completely waive their warranty rights, even for non-related issues, when they unlock their bootloaders. So it could be worse.
You know the old saying - "you play, you pay."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One one side - an entirely software based brick: user should pay. On the other side, failed hardware: manufacturer should pay. In between there may be differences of opinion!
patp said:
So no rooting without potential warranty issues?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have also sent my phone in for a yellow spot. Phone was rooted on HTC dev. Right now the status is "In Repair". So we will see what they say. I did flash back to stock before sending it in.
i rooted my HOX also. after 2 weeks i noticed the wifi fault AND a yellow spot. relocked it and send it in for repair. returned the phone a few weeks later. Still had a wifi issue, but now i don't get warranty for their faulty repair the first time because they saw is was *relocked*
after a few angry phone calls i decided to fix it my self
Lazy-eye said:
i rooted my HOX also. after 2 weeks i noticed the wifi fault AND a yellow spot. relocked it and send it in for repair. returned the phone a few weeks later. Still had a wifi issue, but now i don't get warranty for their faulty repair the first time because they saw is was *relocked*
after a few angry phone calls i decided to fix it my self
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My status just changed to "REPAIR COMPLETE". So i think i am in the clear.
I think due to a bad install of a rom on my part the phone would not charge.I had used Htcdev to unlock but reset to facory settings before sending it back to HTC for repair.I have been told its been repaired and on its way back to me.
Flyinace2000 said:
My status just changed to "REPAIR COMPLETE". So i think i am in the clear.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Strange now i am back to "In Repair"
Flyinace2000 said:
Strange now i am back to "In Repair"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And now it is back to awaiting device....very strange.
Flyinace2000 said:
And now it is back to awaiting device....very strange.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And now it shows the phone is being returned. So looks like they didn't care/check that my phone was "relocked".
UPS is set to drop it off tonight, but i am away on business so won't be able to report back on the quality until this weekend.
-Will

Warranty when screen broke?

Hi guys,
I've had a Galaxy Nexus for a very long time now and have been very happy with it. These days however, a very annoying charging problem appeared on my Galaxy Nexus. Basically, the device doesn't 'recognize' if it's charging or not. You can read more about the problem here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1427539
Now I want to fix my Galaxy Nexus under warranty, because that's the safest way and I don't want to invest any money in it anymore since I plan on buying the new Nexus when it comes out. Problem is, my Galaxy Nexus' screen broke a few weeks ago (For the people who are wondering how; phone fell on the ground and then a biker rode over it...) and I'm not sure if Samsung will fix my phone under warranty since I'm 99% sure it's a hardware issue and it COULD have been from the drop which broke my screen (which I'm 100% sure it's not, because I had the same problem some months ago, but it promptly disappeared and just a few days ago, which means it was a few weeks after the drop, the problem came back.)
Anyone here can tell me what Samsung's and my rights are and if they will fix it? I'm currently visiting family in China, so if I'm not sure if Samsung's going to fix it, I can probably let it fix in China for cheaper, but that's not my preferred option, since it will officially break my warranty (and still costs money of course ).
Anyone? There must be someone who has some experience in warranties... ?
Is the glass cracked?
Warranties cover problems/defects from normal use. If they see the broken glass they will tell you that the problem was caused by an accident or drop which is not their fault.
you may get lucky and they could replace it, but its their decision.
gab2012 said:
Is the glass cracked?
Warranties cover problems/defects from normal use. If they see the broken glass they will tell you that the problem was caused by an accident or drop which is not their fault.
you may get lucky and they could replace it, but its their decision.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, the glass is broken. So basically, you'd recommend me to let it repair for cheap in China? Thanks for your answer by the way!
Screen replacements aren't cheap either..$100-$150 at least
BroodjeBami said:
Yes, the glass is broken. So basically, you'd recommend me to let it repair for cheap in China? Thanks for your answer by the way!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should get quotes from a few places before repairing, If someone offers to replace it WAY cheap than the others it may be a poor quality screen they're using. The most expensive one will be samsung though. ( I supposed since its OEM)
I know screen replacements aren't cheap, I've done my research. The problem is that the glass is linked to the whole screen which means you've basically got to replace half of your phone just for the glass. The cheapest I've found for a repair is about 190 euro.
But that's NOT what I meant. Because it's so expensive I've decided to not repair the screen and wait for the new Nexus phone. I can live a few months with a broken screen. I can't live with this charging issue however so I just want to fix the mini USB port. I got my contacts in China, so bad quality isn't a problem.
So basically I got two options:
1. Let the USB port fix in China for cheap
2. Let the USB port fix by Samsung in Europe (where I live) under warranty, but have a chance to be denied thanks to the broken screen.
And you guys recommend me to do the first one right?
Someone that can help me for the last time?
Warranty
BroodjeBami said:
Someone that can help me for the last time?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know how comfortable you feel about getting it repaired in China, but if you really trust your contacts, then get both of them done there. Since you said that you are going to get the new Nexus when it comes out, you really don't have anything to lose.
I do have trusts in my contacts in China. Just wasn't sure if I should do it because I will probably lose my warranty and it costs money. But I've decided: I'm hoping to let it repair in China, thank you! (Only the USB port btw, not screen).
They will likely deny your claim for a warranty replacement and tell you that it was probably just damaged when it fell. Unless you can actually prove to a rep that the issue happened before the drop. Even so, cracked glass generally voids your warranty as user inflicted abuse. Factory warranty generally only covers problems cause by the makers of the device. Anything else and the warranty is voided and the claim dismissed.
Source: I dropped my last Samsung phone. Cracked glass, bad radio. Was going to be warranty replaced, until I dropped it. They had on file my claim for the bad radio, but since the screen cracked after the fact they told me that voided the warranty and they absolutely would not honor the replacement. I had to pay an insurance deductible and get it replaced for $99USD.
Sent from my Paranoid JellyBean
This was the answer I was looking for. Thanks!

Bootloader relocked, can I claim warranty?

Well, I guess my One X isn't perfect.
When I first got it, I didn't look for the flaws, I just checked that the Wi-Fi is ok and there was no ripples, so I unlocked it and flashed ARHD. But, after few days of usage I was shocked after I pressed the screen a bit harder (not VERY hard, just a bit harder because I stumbled upon some HOX screen creaking issue videos) and it started creaking in the upper corners and you can push the screen further into the casing (upper side) like it's on some kind of springs. Note: It was in a case since day 1, never fell because I treat it like a baby, I've had it for around a week. Now, I relocked bootloader and got everything back to stock. I never flashed custom kernels nor tried to overclock it/undervolt it. Plus, it NEVER got hot, after playing some more intensive (THD) games it got SLIGHTLY warm, you could barely feel it. So it is deffinitely assembly issue. My question is, can I claim warranty? Because I bought this phone in Germany (1&1) and I'm from Croatia, so I would have to ship it to Germany first. Or should I take it to repair shop so they fix the screen because it's perfect in every other way? It's model SH26.
Thanks very much.
Regards.
Well, I would say that it depends on the engineer who examine your phones. However, they always knew that you are unlocked and they have the right to void your warranty if they detemine it was caused by mis-used of custom ROM/kernels or else. Since, this is a assembly issue which was not consequences of unlocking. I can said that you are safe from this.
I adviced you get to HTC directly instead of a repair shops and query to HTC croatia asking wether they accept your device or not. For you interest, I heard that international warranty was apply my One X from a local retailer while my device is brought from neighbour country.
Either its hardware fault or not if ur device is unlocked they can refuse the repair under warranty. i have asked the same thing and they told me that if you unlocked it u cant use ur warranty.i said all the stuff about its not my fault or unlocking and its by manufacture but no luck. so i guess it depends ur rights that ur country provides .In Uk you can claim hardware fault in court.
Sounds like a shoddy products.
Yup, had to admitted the warranty may go as per country basis refering local laws. I don't think many asian countries deserves the rights for requesting changes/rejecting a device in 7 days without giving any reason as in UK. Thus, this may be why there are more strict on this unlocking issue in UK.
I sent my HOX (unlocked) for repair directly to HTC due to faulty earpiece jack.
They returned it to me fixed, and with a new and better battery.
HTC didn't charge me a cent.
Ive installed ARHD recently and a few hours after i noticed my screen making creaking and popping noises when pressed. Not sure what i should do about it, it doesnt bother me that much but if my screen falls out ill be slightly annoyed ;p. Surely they have to replace/fix the phone because this is a hardware issue?
Guess I was extremely lucky. Having heard of many defective devices, I began to worry about mine, and, to my surprise, there was no problems i could detect.
That's because generally people only shout about things that don't work. The happy folks with good phones are much quieter.
Rusty! said:
That's because generally people only shout about things that don't work. The happy folks with good phones are much quieter.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True,i haven't had a single problem with my HOX.When it was first released many people complained about the flickering screen,after that with the memory loss problem,now with the new 2.17 update alot of people are having problems with the wifi,and even so,i don't have any problem with the phone.
ON Topic:In my country if you unlock your bootloader the waranty is completly void,a friend of mine had problems with the phone microphone and they denied his waranty,had to pay to repair the HOX.
This may not be the greatest tip to give, but if you know that they will reject warranty claims (If you are in the UK, etc...) on the basis of bootloader unlock, it might be possible to bypass the issue by just bricking the phone to the point that you cannot get to the bootloader, because it seems they determine warranty status by going to the bootloader and looking at the screen.
Hence, no bootloader screen to check, no evidence that warranty was broken.
Of course this is quite shady and if you have the means you should pay for the warranty repairs.
...or realise (UK, etc.) that your statutory rights are not affected. Which is why they are "statutory".
It's hard to tell, some users reporting that they've been charged for a new motherboard prior to fixing any issues. Until then they won't touch the device. It varies from country to country and individual on the other end.
If you got it from a carrier maybe try sending it to them and bypassing HTC.
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2
Im in the uk, does anyone know if they will or wont fix my phone? Also do they fix the phone or replace it?
MadCatz900 said:
Im in the uk, does anyone know if they will or wont fix my phone? Also do they fix the phone or replace it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Depends on the problem, but usually a fix is possible/cheaper for them.
On the UK, your statutary rights stand with the retailer. If you're unlocked (relock it) take it to them.
Great news, my One X is back and It's fixed. Big ups for HTC Germany!
Sent from my HTC One X using xda app-developers app

Categories

Resources