Develop Bugs

[Review] Seidio Innocase Rugged

Edit: I've been told by Seidio that the "Active-Like Thing" actually has a name. It's called the Rugged Skin. Also, they assured me that they are "working to make the tabs strong and easier to remove."
Seidio Innocase Rugged Holster Combo
Innocase Rugged Holster Combo For use with HTC EVO 4G
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
The newest case in Seidio's line for the HTC Evo 4G, the Innocase Rugged will not disappointed those who are seeking a case that offers more protection with minimal sacrifice in thickness and weight gain. The best thing about this case is, you choose when you want to add more protection, and when to go for lightweight and style.
If you haven't seen my reviews for the Innocase II Surface and Innocase Active yet, go check them out. I will be referring to them quite a lot, since the Innocase Rugged is at its heart, a combination of the two.
There are 4 separate pieces to the Innocase Rugged, which is an incredible bang for your buck. You are essentially buying a screen protector, a holster, and 2 separate cases for around $50. The pieces are engineered to fit together perfectly, and best of all, it is made by Seidio, a company that is hugely concerned about its consumers. You won't see another company like Seidio who spends a lot of time and effort answering questions on these forums. They've taken advice and criticisms on all their past products, and iterated new generations that fix the most pressing issues. I am truly impressed with their dedication to their consumers.
The Innocase Active was widely considered to be their most successful case (especially the Limited Edition), so lets see how this new case compares.
Full disclosure: I was given a review unit from Seidio. However, you'll find that I strive to be uninfluenced by that, and will be fully honest when it comes to weaknesses.
Raison d'être
The Seidio Innocase Rugged is made for those needs a case with supreme protection, compatibility with a holster, and flexibility. You can choose when to slip the Active-like outer casing over the inner Surface for the times when you want more protection, and don't mind a little extra bulk. When you want to go lightweight, take off the outer layer and you are left with an Innocase II Surface on your Evo. The flexibility, plus the ultimate protection it offers, will no doubt appeal to a lot of people.
Ultimate Screen Guard
The Innocase Rugged comes with Seidio's well-received Ultimate Screen Guard - Crystal Clear. The package contains 1 screen guard, 1 microfiber cloth, and 1 hard application card, which can be bought separately for $9.95. This screen protector is static-cling (not wet-application), has a very hard glass-like surface, no rainbow effects, extremely thin, no orange peel, super scratch-resistant, and does not reduce touch sensitivity. If you'd like to see my full review on the Ultimate Screen Guard, check out this review thread.
Currently I am not using Seidio's Ultimate Screen Guard. I have taken a liking to the Anti-Fingerprint/Anti-Glare variety of screen protectors, and am using SGP's Steinheil Anti-Fingerprint screen protector. It's too bad that Seidio only making Crystal Clear varieties, since I'm sure a lot of people, me included, would love to try out an Anti-Fingerprint version from Seidio. However, like I said in my review for the Ultimate Screen Guard, I found almost no difference between Seidio's Crystal Clear and SGP's Crystal Clear.
Innocase II Surface
This is arguably the most important piece of the Innocase Rugged Combo. This inner piece stays on your phone the whole time, and is exactly the same as a 2nd generation Innocase II Surface. Checkout this great comparison between the 1st and 2nd generation of Innocase II Surface made by htc.EVOlution for more details.
When you do not want the entire bulk of the Innocase Rugged, you take off the other outer layers, and leave this Innocase II Surface on your Evo. It offers enough protection for reasonably high (head height) drops, while only adding 1mm of thickness to the phone. Being the 2nd generation, the inside is coated with rubber, destroying any squeaks and fit issues that the previous generation had. The felt lining on the inside serves as a cushion for sudden impacts, and outer rubberized coating makes the device a joy to hold. For more information on the Innocase II Surface, look at this review.
Rugged Skin
The Rugged Skin is very much like the Innocase Active Limited Edition, yet it's different. What it is, is a slightly larger version of the Active that fits over the Innocase II Surface. Before you ask any questions, yes it is larger, meaning it will not fit over a naked Evo. Also this means the original Innocase Active will not fit inside of the included Hoster without some modding.
By the time you put this Rugged Skin layer on, your Evo will be covered in 2 cases. I feel pretty confident that my Evo will survive if I chuck it across the room, or if it gets thrown off of my desk accidentally. You won't find more protection than this in any cases on the market today.
This Rugged Skin piece comes in 2 parts of its own: The inner rubber silicon layer, and the hard plastic exoskeleton. They've made some adjustments that make this much better than the Innocase Active Limited Edition, but also some adjustments that hurt its viability. Let's talk about the good things first.
There's a camera flap! Even though the old cases indirectly protected the camera by protruding out more than the camera did (kind of like our eye sockets protecting the eye ball), many people were unsatisfied and wanted something more. Seidio then engineered a flap that covers the camera when not in use. It has a little knob at the top which fits into a little hole in the exoskeleton, so that it holds the flap open when you are using the camera. The flap is thin and is only meant to protect against minor bumps and scratches.
No kickstand! I think the reasoning was, since you'd have 2 separate cases on, it would be too difficult to dig out the kickstand if there was an opening. Also, this heavier case might mean that the weight distribution will not be able to be held up by the kickstand.
Redesigned Power and Volume buttons! This was a BIG DEAL to a lot of Innocase Active owners. The power button is now MUCH EASIER to press. The rubber inner silicon layer now has a stub that sticks out of the case, into the Evo's power button, whereas before it had an indent. This makes it so that you have to press it much softer to hit the Power or Volume buttons. Good job listening to your users Seidio!
There are 4 locking tabs located at the corners of the soft inner silicon layer. These tabs hook onto the newly added grooves in the exoskeleton, and prevent the exoskeleton from slipping off. This makes the Rugged Skin much sturdier and more reliable.
There are now covers for the ports. The headphone jack is covered, as well as the bottom ports. The covers are flaps that you lift up when you want to use those ports, and they are designed to keep out dust, dirt, and grime.
Thankfully, the exoskeleton is styled like the Active Limited Edition. I prefer it to the new non-Limited Edition exoskeleton that they've made.
Holster
The holster pretty much weighs the same as the Surface and Active weigh together.
It is a a face-in design, which protects the screen while snapped in. There is felt where it touches the screen, and the rest of the holster is made of hard plastic.
The large back clip is very powerful, and designed so that it won't slip off your belt when someone pulls on it. There is 7 ways to orient/rotate the clip, so you can have the holster be horizontal, vertical, or somewhere in between.
The sprint-loaded top clip has rubber where it touches your phone. It shows very good foresight, and will prevent any scratches that may occur. There is a locking mechanism, so that the top clip does not come loose when you don't want it to. When you have your Evo in the holster, you can be sure that it will stay in there.
The holster will NOT work out of the box with the current Innocase Active. The Rugged is just slightly bigger.
Cons/Criticism
Like I said, I'm going to be very honest with you guys here. Even though the case is awesome, and fixes almost all of the problems people have been having with the Innocase II Surface and Active, it has problems of its own.
Not much to say about the Innocase II Surface. It is what it is. Only thing that might make it better is if there was more felt inside.
The Rugged Skin is missing the kickstand support. That's a big con!
It's much harder to put on and remove the Rugged Skin layer. It has a tighter fit, but takes more effort to add and remove. The exoskeleton is also more difficult to put on and remove, because of the safety tabs that are designed to keep the exoskeleton on. It's always a give-or-take between more versatility and more ruggedness.
The port/camera covers are hard to open. Again, they're designed to keep out dust and offer more protection, so it's no surprise. However, what did surprise me is how flimsy the cover flap connectors are. I feel like over time, it will be inevitable that these port covers will get ripped off accidentally.
Overall, with both the Innocase II Surface and the Rugged Skin on, the device is much bulkier than either the Innocase II Surface or Active by itself. Although that's to be expected, you have to ask yourself what type of protection you need before jumping into the Rugged. Although there is the versatility of being able to use only the Surface when you want to. I imagine that if the Rugged was strictly a heavy weight case, many people will shy away from it. But due to the fact that you can transform it into a lightweight case, many more people should be interested. Right now I have the Innocase Rugged and a dumb phone in my jeans pocket at the same time, and they fit tightly but comfortably. I have to carry around a dumbphone because my AT&T plan isn't up yet, but for those who are worried about pocketability, relax. It slides in and out just fine, the rubber silicon isn't sticky and won't catch on your pockets.
Conclusion
The Innocase Rugged is a great versatile case that I can recommend fully. It offers the highest protection of any cases on the market today, while it can still slim down for when you need it to. The improves the Rugged makes to the Surface and Active far outweigh the cons. You can't go wrong with this case. Everyone asks: Is the thickness/weight/bulk worth it? The answer is YES!
Pictures below.

Sneak Peeks
Did I just take some pictures of the Innocase Surface, Active Limited Edition, and a holster? Nope, what you're seeing is the newest case to come out of Seidio's labs, the Innocase Rugged.

See what I mean nice clear pictures. Funny thing though....... What is he reaching for in the back ground? pic 5

enragedpaza said:
See what I mean nice clear pictures. Funny thing though....... What is he reaching for in the back ground? pic 5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LOL wow didn't notice that. I guess I told my roommate to step out of the way a bit too late.

pingpongboss said:
LOL wow didn't notice that. I guess I told my roommate to step out of the way a bit too late.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha don't wanna turn the post into a funny comment thread. "Where did you put my phone?" Pong said to friend. Friend says, "Hold on, I will get it."
HAHA
Eidt: the case looks so nice. Might not get the limited active and get this instead

Pingpong...your killing me! I'm about one click away from canceling my order with Amazon
How is the thickness with the case on?

redrazr7791 said:
Pingpong...your killing me! I'm about one click away from canceling my order with Amazon
How is the thickness with the case on?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol are you talking about cancelling the Active? I'll start doing the review when I'm off work at 8ish. Taking, converting, and uploading the video will take another hour or so.
Mm I'd say it's pretty much Surface+Active thickness, which is what you'd expect at around 3-5mm total (2-4mm on each side). That's just me eyeballing it though

pingpongboss said:
lol are you talking about cancelling the Active? I'll start doing the review when I'm off work at 8ish. Taking, converting, and uploading the video will take another hour or so.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I actually have the Rugged case preordered from Amazon. I have been waiting because it is ten dollars less and with my free Amazon Prime membership....I get free 2-day shipping.
Just getting frustrated that it is taking so long for them to get their stock in.

Added the full review + youtube video to the OP.

Edit: I've been told by Seidio that the "Active-Like Thing" actually has a name. It's called the Rugged Skin. Also, they assured me that they are "working to make the tabs strong and easier to remove."

UPDATE
Just got my email from Amazon that my preordered Rugged Case has shipped. So, for those who did the same...check your email

so i had a close look at my case today... the tab that covers the usb/hdmi ports is already about to tear off...
this is a MAJOR disappointment, i really like this case but i haven't even got a full week of use out of it yet before the tabs start tearing
ill be contacting Seidio about this tonight, hopefully they will atleast try to make this right, as im sure i will not be the only person to have this problem

dmc971989 said:
so i had a close look at my case today... the tab that covers the usb/hdmi ports is already about to tear off...
this is a MAJOR disappointment, i really like this case but i haven't even got a full week of use out of it yet before the tabs start tearing
ill be contacting Seidio about this tonight, hopefully they will atleast try to make this right, as im sure i will not be the only person to have this problem
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're not the only one. I mentioned this problem in my review, and Seidio assured me that they are working on making them stronger.

dmc971989 said:
so i had a close look at my case today... the tab that covers the usb/hdmi ports is already about to tear off...
this is a MAJOR disappointment, i really like this case but i haven't even got a full week of use out of it yet before the tabs start tearing
ill be contacting Seidio about this tonight, hopefully they will atleast try to make this right, as im sure i will not be the only person to have this problem
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is crazy, I need to contact them when they finally have a new batch. Seems like you can't order from Seidio when they first release a product.

Ok, so I just got mine earlier and guess what...the freaking tab that covers the charging dock ripped off
Contacted Amazon and got my RMA information. Major letdown after waiting this long. The whole case/combo IMHO is good, but the silicone skin is way to thin and rips way to easy!

although i knew what i was buying, i was hoping seidio's rugged would be like otterbox's defender for iphone. the case only covers the back and sides, exposing the screen fully. why couldnt they put a plastic screen like the before mentioned defender case on iphone. the screen protector's nice, but i would feel more secured with one built into the case. lets just hope if and when i drop my phone, it lands on its bback
i was pretty much forced to get this case. i work offshore/ and on boats, before i bought this case, all i had was the seidio spring clip holster. although i never dropped my phone/had it intentionally/accidentally popped out, i needed more coverage. now with seidio i have 200 percent coverage on the back and 6 percent on the front.

i have the active now.. its ok but i may get this one too.... im not too worried about the tabs ripping off.. i was thinking about cuting them off anyways.. make the hole for the usb bigger and taking off what cover the camera...

Mayonesa said:
i have the active now.. its ok but i may get this one too.... im not too worried about the tabs ripping off.. i was thinking about cuting them off anyways.. make the hole for the usb bigger and taking off what cover the camera...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Come to think about it, the USB cut out for the RUGGED was actually misaligned. I had to manually move the cut out just to get the cable to plug-in. Maybe it was just a bad batch, but the case itself was not what I expected.

I have the rugged case without the holster used for 2 days. I didn't like it. If anyone wants to buy it from me let me know. I have the original box with it as well.

I just received mine and it looks and feels great. I will post update if I see any tab problems. The screen protector was a bit difficult for me to get on...bubbles and stuff. Otherwise it's just what I was looking for.

Best Protector Case for a captivate

Hi, i was wondering about which case buy and want to see your opinions about the best case for the cappy.
I've been watching the Trident Clyclops: http://www.cyclopscase.com/products/Trident-Cyclops-Protective-Case-for-Samsung-Captivate--Red.html
And also the otterbox http://www.otterbox.com/samsung-captivate-cases/samsung-captivate-cases,default,sc.html.
Seidio http://www.seidioonline.com/product-p/csk3sscap-rd.htm?
Body Glove http://www.bodyglovemobile.com/produ...and,219,19.htm

Otterbox Defender is amaxing
Sent from my Darky's ROM 10.2 EE Captivate using XDA App

I had issues getting to the four buttons with the Otterbox Defender. Nevertheless, in terms of protection, I trust them wholeheartedly.

Anyone has tested the Trident?

In addition to otterbox and cyclops look at the seidio active x.

this one http://www.seidioonline.com/product-p/csk3sscap-rd.htm? i like the desing

I just had my second Otterbox holster break. They replaced the first one without batting an eye. I haven't had a chance to call about #2, but frankly I'm not sure if I want to risk it. Fortunately the phone fell out while I was driving my car, not my motorcycle, but I'm not sure I want to risk it again.
So far it's the only case I've tried.

I hate to buck the trend, but I really like the cheap TPU eBay cases. I know, I know, some of us think you need to spend a lot to pamper your Cappy, but I do have my reasons.
They are cheap. I'm big on spending less than $5 for things.
TPU is a great blend of rigidity and pliability. I think silicone is a touch too soft to disperse impact energy, and hard plastic transmits the energy to the phone and often breaks in the process.
They are slick, but easy to hold. I carry my phone in my pocket. I think holsters look kinda dumb. TPU is generally very smooth and slides in and out of a pocket very nicely.
They are thin. Many of the hard molded cases turn your sexy-thin Captivate into a non-sexy blob, cool molded patterns notwithstanding. Lots of the silicone cases have kind of a shapeless look that I don't like.
I've been using a plain black TPU case for a while now, and I get lots of comments on how thin my phone is. I've also dropped it several times with no ill effect, except a less shiny spot on one corner of the cover. No complaints, and I really have a hard time imagining how the expensive ones are better.

TPU is nice and much, much better than silicone. I wish otter/seidio/trident would use TPU. I have a thin TPU case (body glove) and like it alot. Its just sometimes I want the thicker, two layered plastic and rubber case which is why I also have the seidio active.
The first case I bought was the pdair aluminum which would be a nice case but it kills the cellular signal so I can't recommend anyone buy it. Wifi works fine so if I ever travel somewhere I won't have service I plan on using it.

I like my Bodyglove case just fine. I've used it since the launch of the cappy and couldn't be happier. It's more rigid than silicone and less bulky than the otterbox. I've dropped my cappy numerous times on pavement, and as long as a jutting edge doesn't hit the screen it won't break. There is a slight lip on the front of the body glove that makes it so the screen doesn't hit when dropped on a flat surface.

asrrin29 said:
I like my Bodyglove case just fine. I've used it since the launch of the cappy and couldn't be happier. It's more rigid than silicone and less bulky than the otterbox. I've dropped my cappy numerous times on pavement, and as long as a jutting edge doesn't hit the screen it won't break. There is a slight lip on the front of the body glove that makes it so the screen doesn't hit when dropped on a flat surface.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This right? http://www.bodyglovemobile.com/prod...-glove-snap-on-case-with-clipstand,219,19.htm
Is like the otterbox impact, i guess.

I just bought today the body glove, found a great offer in ebay. I will post my opinion after test it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using Tapatalk

I have the Otterbox Defender and I love it

I have an Otterbox Defender for my Captivate, but my Galaxy S 2 is naked. Need to find one for it.

I love my body glove, the phone is slim and easy to handle. I never droped yet but it feels really solid.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using Tapatalk

I have a generic silicone protector on my cappy, and fits so good on it, looks so pro.

NightHawk877 said:
I have an Otterbox Defender for my Captivate, but my Galaxy S 2 is naked. Need to find one for it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Last I checked, Otterbox only has the Commuter for the S2, ATM.

Body Glove
I have bought like 5 cases for my cappy, the Otterbox, Body Glove, a slim hard plastic snap on case and a full hard snap on case.
In the end my 2 favorites are the Body Glove and the Slim snap on that snaps only on the back.
The otterbox case is nice, it is just too bulky. I use the Body Glove daily because it protects from impact, is not bulky and slides in and out of the pocket easy.
Moving forward I am all about the TPU cases.

I use this case http://www.seidioonline.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=BD2-HK3SSCAP-BK
Look on ebay, I've seen these for $35. Dropped the phone twice and there's no damage on the phone at all.

I use the otterbox commuter with an invisible shield screen protector. I work with concrete and often get my phone cpvered with dust and grime. The case gets really dirty but when I remove it the phone is still perfect. I would take this case over the bulky defender version.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA Premium App

Ballistic Shell (SG) vs Otterbox Commuter vs UAG vs Element Eclipse [Final Review]

After I had been used Samsung Galaxy S3 i9300 for a year, I would like to make ultimate review of these 4 premium cases in the market. I just got my Element Eclipse case last week so I would like to add in to this thread. This thread was to provide useful information about S3 casing for those who still wish to buy Galaxy S3 this year 2013. I think that Galaxy S3 still a worth gadget to own especially the i9305 model which with LTE support and 2GB RAM because the price of S3 in my country already decreased to $400. Below was the final comparison of the 4 premium and protective cases in the market :
First : Ballistic Shell (SG) series case in black colour.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Oh yeah, I would like to say that, Ballistic case was just a perfect case and it make you feel that your phone was wearing a bulletproof shirt. It protect the phone from every single drop EXCEPT angle drop. The cutting was just nice, every hole (microUSB, music jack, camera, flash, speaker, microphone) were fit perfectly. The power button was easy to press on. The only Cons for this case was it's not so pocket friendly due to the case had 4 big angle to protect the phone. :victory:
Second : Otterbox Commuter (Night Sky)
What I can say was the case was awesome. The night sky colour was perfect combo with my Pebble blue SIII. The commuter offer the same protection level with Ballistic or maybe higher as the inner silicone was harder compare with Ballistic (but this had cause the power n volume button harder to press on) The cutting for commuter was as perfect as Ballistic. The back side was a bit slippery compare with Ballistic but It's make the case more pocket friendly just bsc of that. The case was a bit harder to put in and take it out as it was VEEERY TIGHT FIT n you can really feel that the phone locked in the case. The case also offer cover for microUSB and music jack to avoid dust. :laugh:
Third : UAG AERO
I had received my UAG Aero case 3 months ago and it was awesome case. This is one of the best case for Galaxy S3 with the unique & great design, moderate protection and moderate price(Amazon.com : $22++). The Aero case match with my Pebble Blue S3 perfectly. It was a modded case with 1 piece of hard silicone and 1 piece polycarbonate. The quality of the hard silicone was the best I ever seen in the S3 casing market. It was hard enough to protection your phone from drop. The case was much more thinner compare with Otterbox and Ballistic. Your phone will be tightly fits inside the casing. The matte finished on the back of the case was great but a little bit slippery. The volume and power button was very easy to press(same as Ballistic SG). The cutting was very nice and perfect fit with the audio jack, mic, microUSB, camera, flash and speaker. The 4 angles of the case give your phone a great protection while retain the beauty of the phone. (Ballistic SG had 4 big angles offer much more protection but bulky). You will feel better when you holding you S3 due to it's "square" shape design if compare with Commuter. Overall, the case was thin and very pocket friendly. It's just like a case that combine of all the Pro of the Commuter and Ballistic SG.
Fourth : ELEMENT ECLIPSE
I just received my Element Eclipse case last month and what I would said was, this case was awesome. The design of this case was sleek and nice. The case was separate into 2 part, the aluminium bezel and the back carbon fiber. Your phone will be "clip" inside the case. The main selling point of this case was the SBS (Sound Boost System) which I can said was Awesome and it's work pretty well. But the downside of this case was the kickstand. It was very thin and easily to get broke but it's work well; just you have to be careful while using it. The case was slim and thinner compare with UAG and the other case. I would said the thinnest among 4 of these cases. The case was about $65 which you may able to buy 2 to 3 UAG or Otterbox case from the market for that price. For drop protection, I think this case may not handle it well as the aluminium bezel might break your screen glass when it drop to the floor.
Conclusion
I giving 5 star for three of these premium cases as three cases also satisfy my needs. But I highly recommend to buy UAG as it's unique design and using good quality material to build the case. Just some small advices, for those wish to buy a case with Ultimate protection, easy-to-press buttons and with acceptable bulkiness; then grap a Ballistic SG. For those who plan to get a case with Ultimate protection with port's cover, acceptable bulkiness, and pocket friendly but the button is harder to press and the case was slippery, then you able recommend to go with the Otterbox Commuter. If you want to get a case with great design, offer great protection while able to retain the beauty of your phone, then grab a UAG case. Besides that, for those who got frustrated about the S3 audio issue when playing games and want your S3 to have a premium look + kickstand function while you are willing to pay for the price, then Element Eclipse will be your choice.
Below are the ebay links that I bought the cases from :
Amazon.com UAG Case for S3
Amazon.com Ballistic SG for S3
Amazon.com Otterbox Commuter for S3
Ebay.com Element Eclipse for S3
Please press the "Thank" button and RATE my thread if you feel this was help.

bump

Ok, I have the Blue Commuter too, I like it but I'm thinking about getting the Ballistic SG(blue or black). Which one you prefer of these two??? Are the back and menu buttons too hard to press on the SG??

keltsi95 said:
Ok, I have the Blue Commuter too, I like it but I'm thinking about getting the Ballistic SG(blue or black). Which one you prefer of these two??? Are the back and menu buttons too hard to press on the SG??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I more prefer the Blue commuter as it's more pocket friendly. For the button issue, the difference was very big for Commuter and Ballistic SG,. Ballistic SG was much much MORE easier to press on Bro, if you think the commuter case satisfy you then just save the money and keep using it. As I spend about 100 bucks for cases and feel regret now...

I'm new to the S3. Thanks for the review. I will be getting the black commuter
Sent from my Galaxy S3

id need to have details on the gum part thicness of the ballistic.
im willing to cut the first layer in order to find the room for an extended battery (anker or hyperion) and later cover it with the second layer.
like something it has been done on the kraken here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1826376

Thanks for spending the time to write this review and sharing your finds :thumbup:
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

Does anyone know if the Commuter will fit in the Siedio holster. I've been researching so long and read so much that I don't remember what's what anymore! Thanks.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app

OnceAMatrixMan said:
Does anyone know if the Commuter will fit in the Siedio holster. I've been researching so long and read so much that I don't remember what's what anymore! Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I remember seeing this brought up earlier. Got buried down a ways. Here's the thread with pictures of the mating. Hope it helps.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1780383
Sent from a 3rd Galaxy in the middle of the Pacific.

mexiking713 said:
I'm new to the S3. Thanks for the review. I will be getting the black commuter
Sent from my Galaxy S3
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go for it and you will not regret. Just some advice for you, the button is stiff and you should aware of this before you make buy decision. :fingers-crossed:

OnceAMatrixMan said:
Does anyone know if the Commuter will fit in the Siedio holster. I've been researching so long and read so much that I don't remember what's what anymore! Thanks.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro, it should fit perfect with Siedio holster but why not you grab a Defender series so that everything is in perfect combo..^^ You can take out the temp glass of the defender series anytime if you feel tht it's too bulky..

marcogtt said:
id need to have details on the gum part thicness of the ballistic.
im willing to cut the first layer in order to find the room for an extended battery (anker or hyperion) and later cover it with the second layer.
like something it has been done on the kraken here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1826376
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bro, if you cut the gum part of the ballistic then you will definitely spoil your 20 bucks away as it's take off the beauty of the case. And I very certain that it will decrease the level of protection. Why not you get a Battery Bank instead of install a ugly and fat battery behind your phone? :silly:

mikeyj1973 said:
Thanks for spending the time to write this review and sharing your finds :thumbup:
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are welcome bro! Sharing is caring... Just feel curious that nobody compare this 2 premium case side by side. And I sure that both case is above the Trident Aegis series. :good:

bump

lvoonjian8888 said:
Bro, it should fit perfect with Siedio holster but why not you grab a Defender series so that everything is in perfect combo..^^ You can take out the temp glass of the defender series anytime if you feel tht it's too bulky..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I have been leaning towards the Defender over the Ballistic SG Maxx because if the corners on the Maxx. But I liked that you could take the screen protector off of the Maxx without losing the integrity of the case. Are you saying you can take the screen protector off with the Defender and it's still a tight fit? If so I am sold!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app

I love the fact that these photos were taken from an iphone which I can see in the reflection, :good:

I think Ballistic SG Case look much better!

I have both cases and am returning the Defender. Both great cases I just prefer the Ballistic over the Otterbox. I like the look better and the buttons are much easier to push on the Ballistic. BTW I am using the Zagg HD with the Ballistic , not the one provided. I have an Urban Armor on order a also. I know it's a sickness ordering all of these accessories. . Also have the 4500 extended battery from accessory swamp on order and a case for it. Lol.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda premium

OnceAMatrixMan said:
Thanks. I have been leaning towards the Defender over the Ballistic SG Maxx because if the corners on the Maxx. But I liked that you could take the screen protector off of the Maxx without losing the integrity of the case. Are you saying you can take the screen protector off with the Defender and it's still a tight fit? If so I am sold!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I shouldnt say it tight fit but there are other members used this method..^^ :cyclops:

al3b3d3v said:
I love the fact that these photos were taken from an iphone which I can see in the reflection, :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha, just use my brother's phone to take the photo. He using Apple and I am using Android. Arh!! Fighting always happen..:victory:

Case-mate Pop! case review with lots of pictures

After using Case-Mate Tough case, you can read my full detailed review here (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=37884573&postcount=105), I decided to check out its sibling - Case-Mate Pop! What got my interest was a kick stand and a molded single piece design. Here is a link to Pop! case website - http://www.case-mate.com//samsung-galaxy-note-2-cases/case-mate-samsung-galaxy-note-2-pop-cases.asp
Being already impressed with a level of details and high quality of Tough design, I can tell you that Pop! is on the same level. Pop! is very slim with similar dimensions in comparison to Tough. What sets them apart is that Pop! has a molded single piece design with outer plastic shell and inner rubber lining. Outer side is very shiny and smooth, and plastic feels very sturdy. Being shiny and black with a color I got makes it somewhat a fingerprint magnet, but it wipes off very easy. I also think that with time you might see some scratches, but it will not be too bad because the case has a brilliantly designed rubber handles that extend to the back thus lifting a phone off the surface when placed back down. It's one of those great engineered details that a lot of other manufactures don't account for since everybody always concerned with a lip on the front of the phone to keep the screen off the surface, rather than back. So in addition to giving a great side grip, these side handles keep the phone off the surface, make sure the phone will not slide on the surface, and make it very sturdy to keep the phone on it's back without wobbling.
Also, the kickstand is completely recessed in the back of the case without any need for through cutout (another great design detail). The kick stand itself has a rubber tip to keep it from sliding when extended. Due to the slim design, I wouldn't consider this kick stand to be the sturdiest and I have to point out - the rubber tip/flap doesn't have longevity in it's attachment. Since you do need to use a nail to lift it up (and its not that bad actually), its easy to tear off. But even without this rubber tip/flap - kickstand functionality is not compromised and it should work regardless.
Inner rubber part of the shell is nicely textured. I think its one of the Case-Mate signatures to have some funky inner design. That works well by reducing the weight of the case and gives a better cushion if you drop it on the back. The rubber material is softer than one in Tough (where in case of Tough they used just a bumper which is hard tpu-like rubber). The lip height is the same as on Tough, gives you enough clearance when you put the phone down on its screen. Cutouts are perfectly aligned with adequate room. I always have to note that micro-usb opening is wide enough for aftermarket connectors, mic openings generous not to cause any echo or sound obstruction, s-pen will go in/out without a problem. I also want to mention that because rubber material is softer than Tough case, the volume/power buttons are easier to push - those work perfectly!
The fitment with a phone is like a glove, a very tight one! Once you insert the phone, it almost becomes like a tight skin around it. As a matter of fact, to take the phone out I had to push slightly on a camera lens. Typically this will wear off after a few fitments, but its a very good indicator how well the case will stay with a phone if you drop it. In terms of protection, I feel Tough and Pop! will protect it on the same level, maybe with some advantage to Tough design since the rubber bumper is harder. But overall these are both very slim and light cases that should protect your phone in style during everyday use.
Below you will find a number of pictures, including a few with comparison between Pop! and Tough.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}

Thanks for the nice review and pics. I have the Blue Tough case and I can say it is the best case I have ever used so far. I have tried the Utterbox commuter which is utter garbage in that it is very thick and very slippery (even when dry). I also have a hybrid ebay case which also is good but as thick as the otterbox. I also have the original Samsung TPU case which is great, but does not offer much protection on the sides/corners just like the very thin ebay cases. I also have a few bumper cases, which went straight to the bin after a few hours of use.
Can you cipher what is written on the inside of the POP ?
It's Show Time !!!!!
edit:
I really love the Tough case, I ordered another one in black.....

Scratch easy
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda premium

Uh, you are right. Inside of POP! its written "It's Show Time", and inside of Tough "Tough Love" Another freaking awesome design detail.
Yeah, Tough case is at the top if you are looking for slimmest case with decent protection. Pop! has it's own benefits, and so does UAG. I'm right now using Tough and UAG. Don't need any other case, unless if Case-Mate will release Tough Xtreme for Note 2 That would put Defender to shame!!!

vectron said:
Uh, you are right. Inside of POP! its written "It's Show Time", and inside of Tough "Tough Love" Another freaking awesome design detail.
Yeah, Tough case is at the top if you are looking for slimmest case with decent protection. Pop! has it's own benefits, and so does UAG. I'm right now using Tough and UAG. Don't need any other case, unless if Case-Mate will release Tough Xtreme for Note 2 That would put Defender to shame!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you mind posting side by side pics of the tough and UAG please. I might get a UAG because it looks good. But is it slippery ?
Many thanks in advance

nm8 said:
Do you mind posting side by side pics of the tough and UAG please. I might get a UAG because it looks good. But is it slippery ?
Many thanks in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The back of UAG is a little bit slippery but I have been told it wears off after a short time. Plus due to its little rubber feet it will grip with a surface (unlike Commuter slip'n'slide). Plus, the front bumper/lip helps with a grip. Just look up my UAG review post with comments. Regarding side-by-side pictures, here you go, I had those taken all together but didn't post in original review above since I wanted to keep it in case-mate family. But nevertheless, check it out:

Hey man, Nice job on the review. I really appreciate the pics and the write up. Thanks Bro:thumbup:
Cheers :beer:
Sent from my iPhone smokin' Samsung Galaxy Note II SGH-I317

@vectron
Thank you very much for those pics... I'm still undecided for now if I will get a UAG case.....

nm8 said:
@vectron
Thank you very much for those pics... I'm still undecided for now if I will get a UAG case.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know, usually its an easy decision when dealing with cheap ebay cases where you can get a bunch and then decide later. These are pricier quality cases, each one with it's own feel, function, fit, and level of protection - and often you just need to hold and to feel it in our hand and stick it in your pocket rather than look at the pictures. And as you know what might work for one person might not work for you.

nice review man, and great pictures!
I like my case mate tough a lot, and decided to get a trident aegis; 20 bucks on ebay.
I have had a few trident cases, so I know they are sweet..
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Trident-Aeg.../230900703643?ssPageName=ADME:X:BOCOS:US:1123
That UAG case is just way overpriced for what you get...

i had the epic touch version of this. the rubber on the kickstand will eventually wear away and slip out automatically after a few months of use.

enter260 said:
i had the epic touch version of this. the rubber on the kickstand will eventually wear away and slip out automatically after a few months of use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But then kickstand should still work without that rubber tip? Plus, you get 1yr warranty if anything.

I so wish the Pop was not so glossy on the back (in both white and black). Totally love the cover other than that. I currently have the the Seidio Surface in blue and it's pretty badass as well. Love the kickstand for this screen size.. Makes media consumption so much easier, especially when you're flying or sitting anywhere with a surface to keep the fone on. The one thing I did not like as much bout the Seidio was that the cover is comprised of two piece (top and bottom) and it tends to pop open sometimes.. Which is why I was so excited to see this CaseMate Pop. But not too sure bout the glossy back... would be a total fingerprint magnet I assume...

KT said:
I so wish the Pop was not so glossy on the back (in both white and black). Totally love the cover other than that. I currently have the the Seidio Surface in blue and it's pretty badass as well. Love the kickstand for this screen size.. Makes media consumption so much easier, especially when you're flying or sitting anywhere with a surface to keep the fone on. The one thing I did not like as much bout the Seidio was that the cover is comprised of two piece (top and bottom) and it tends to pop open sometimes.. Which is why I was so excited to see this CaseMate Pop. But not too sure bout the glossy back... would be a total fingerprint magnet I assume...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why not look into Case-Mate Tough? That one is slimmer than Pop!, and although 2-piece design - feels like a slim one piece. I reviewed it HERE. It has a textured design that feels very nice in your hand and not slippery at all, although no kickstand. Right now Case-Mate is running 1-day only 30% sale with coupon code FLASH13
Regarding Seidio Surface, you know you can add CONVERT kit on top of it to turn into a super protection brick? It will add bulk, but external CONVERT layer will keep Surface from popping open and adds extra drop protection with a new bigger holster. I'm getting CONVERT Value Pack for review soon, and will post it in the forum once I have it. Now, Note 2 users have a lot of choices

vectron said:
Why not look into Case-Mate Tough? That one is slimmer than Pop!, and although 2-piece design - feels like a slim one piece. I reviewed it HERE. It has a textured design that feels very nice in your hand and not slippery at all, although no kickstand. Right now Case-Mate is running 1-day only 30% sale with coupon code FLASH13
Regarding Seidio Surface, you know you can add CONVERT kit on top of it to turn into a super protection brick? It will add bulk, but external CONVERT layer will keep Surface from popping open and adds extra drop protection with a new bigger holster. I'm getting CONVERT Value Pack for review soon, and will post it in the forum once I have it. Now, Note 2 users have a lot of choices
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks so much for the code and the advice. Appreciate it!
To answer your question, I wasn't considering the Tough case for that very reason; no kickstand. But with this 30% discount coupon, I think I might just pull the trigger. Always good to have multiple cases

I had white pop case then switched to the defender just bc i work in construction. I feel the pop would of protected my phone about in about 90% of the enviroments i work in but if my phone was to fall out my pocket while in an attic, rafters or just really high in general i dont think the pop would have protected my phone from the drop. I will say the pop was WAYYYY more comftorable in my hand then the defender. It slides on and off the phone very easily and i really liked the kickstand.
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda app-developers app

Hmm... on second thoughts, I'll wait for something with the tactile feel of the Tough case and a kickstand. A 30% discount on a $40 case is $28 but I just checked and Amazon is selling the same case for $22 - http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galax...922617&sr=8-1&keywords=case+mate+tough+note+2

KT said:
Hmm... on second thoughts, I'll wait for something with the tactile feel of the Tough case and a kickstand. A 30% discount on a $40 case is $28 but I just checked and Amazon is selling the same case for $22 - http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galax...922617&sr=8-1&keywords=case+mate+tough+note+2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want the blue w/grey, you can get the Note 2 Tough case for $19 shipped... figured I'd give it a shot... placed order couple hrs ago.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0..._m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=03J0GX7Z7VA8E71BBESC

Wow, those are great values for 1/2 off. I remember they had FRIENDS50 coupon for 50% off from the website. On Amazon, you don't even need a coupon, and typically returns are hassle free (although this one is not fulfilled by Amazon). One thing to keep in mind as a main difference between Tough and Pop. Tough will be slimmer and lighter, no kickstand, 2 piece design, and nice textured back. Pop has a shiny smooth back that will collect more fingerprints and scratches, it's a bit thicker with a better grip side handles, single piece design that grips the phone very tightly, and a kickstand that practical only in landscape mode, and push buttons that are easier to press because its a softer rubber material versus Tough tpu-like bumpter. Quality of both is superb, design details are very unique, and they both will offer equal level of drop protection, although as bmoreboy02 pointed out - I wouldn't trust it in places where you are around construction or outdoor activities.

DoctorQMM said:
If you want the blue w/grey, you can get the Note 2 Tough case for $19 shipped... figured I'd give it a shot... placed order couple hrs ago.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0..._m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=03J0GX7Z7VA8E71BBESC
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the link. Found a black one too for $18 and change
http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galax...TF8&colid=1SHP6WWX3MOTO&coliid=I3TOL9ZZGAAH56

Best Case for Durability?

Hey all,
I've owned the Ballistic SG case for my One X for 16 months now, and I love it. It's insanely rugged and I love how it bounces when dropped instead of all of the impact being absorbed into the phone.
Now I'm moving onto the HTC One and I'm stuck - do I stay with Ballistic? Or do I move on to a new brand?
DURABILITY is definitely the most important feature to me as I'm ridiculously paranoid after having broken several screens - specifically having a big lip on the front side of the case makes me feel a lot better about my phone's safety. I don't care about holsters, and looks don't really matter all that much to me but it wouldn't hurt for the case to also look badass (like the UAG cases...super sexy).
Help a dude out. I'm in the realm of deciding between the Otterbox Defender vs. Ballistic SG, but if you think a case like the UAG Navigator (or your favorite case) will withstand drops from 5 feet please let me know.
THANKS

Dude, I have the Ballistic on my One and it's really great! I'd recommend it.

Otterbox defender man

No doubt, Otterbox Defender!

If you need absolute full coverage, then you need something like the Otterbox Defender. However, I have a few cases, one of them being the Speck CandyShell Grip - I dropped my phone from about four feet high on to granite tile, it literally bounced up about 6-7 inches, did a couple of rotations, then landed face down after another small bounce. Picked it up, not a scratch - not even on the case! Speck makes an excellent product. Check it out. I have the white one
http://www.speckproducts.com/candyshell-grip-for-htc-one.html

UAG definitely!

I use seidio for all my devices very durable cases they have many to choose from depending on your needs the down side there expensive
http://www.seidioonline.com/seidio-HTC-One-s/8798.htm
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk 2

Ballistic Max and Mime glass is my protection for the ONE. Feel pretty confident that the combo will handle most mishaps while looking a lot better than the Defender.

For durability and ruggedness I would say for peace of mind something like a dual layer Incipio Dual Pro, Trident Kraken or Aegis and even an Otterbox Commuter or Defender. Now if you are completely content with the UAG case durability and protection in which you should be because I swear by them also then get UAG because they have great cosmetics alongside being the best IMO for ruggedness and durability for a one piece snap on
Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk 4

ingenious247 said:
If you need absolute full coverage, then you need something like the Otterbox Defender. However, I have a few cases, one of them being the Speck CandyShell Grip - I dropped my phone from about four feet high on to granite tile, it literally bounced up about 6-7 inches, did a couple of rotations, then landed face down after another small bounce. Picked it up, not a scratch - not even on the case! Speck makes an excellent product. Check it out. I have the white one
http://www.speckproducts.com/candyshell-grip-for-htc-one.html
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This, and unlike the UAG the Candyshell fits so tight very little to no dust can get in under the edge and grind away at your anodized finish!

cpufrost said:
This, and unlike the UAG the Candyshell fits so tight very little to no dust can get in under the edge and grind away at your anodized finish!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i was put off by the high price otherwise have read good reviews