Develop Bugs

Galaxy S III or Galaxy Note II?

I currently have the Galaxy S III on Sprint that I got the day it was released. However, I am switching to AT&T next week, and I don't know if I want to get the AT&T Galaxy S III or the Galaxy Note II. I love my Galaxy S III, with my one wish being that it had a quad-core processor. With the Note II, I love everything, except it seems like it might be too big. However, I have big hands, and I don't use my Galaxy S III one handed anyways. I also do a lot of texting/emailing.
What do you think? Is the Galaxy Note II worth the extra $100 or so? Does it run really fast, smooth, and speedy compared to the Galaxy S III? Also, can you use third-party keyboards using the one-handed setting like you can with the stock keyboard?
Also, is it likely that both AT&T and Samsung will keep updating the Galaxy Note II over the course of the next 18 months?

The note 2 kills the s3. I went to the att store and played with both. If you're afraid it might be too big, go to att and check it out.
Sent from my SGH-I317 using xda premium

Its a personal preference. I use my phone for lot of reading so for me Note's big 5.5" screen and 310mAh battery are plus. Thats why I traded my S3 for galaxy note 2. But remember this phone is huge to carry.

P1 Wookie said:
The note 2 kills the s3. I went to the att store and played with both. If you're afraid it might be too big, go to att and check it out.
Sent from my SGH-I317 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree. The note II is bigger, faster, and has at least twice the battery life. I don't have huge hands and have no problems with it.

lathamc said:
I currently have the Galaxy S III on Sprint that I got the day it was released. However, I am switching to AT&T next week, and I don't know if I want to get the AT&T Galaxy S III or the Galaxy Note II. I love my Galaxy S III, with my one wish being that it had a quad-core processor. With the Note II, I love everything, except it seems like it might be too big. However, I have big hands, and I don't use my Galaxy S III one handed anyways.
What do you think? Is the Galaxy Note II worth the extra $100 or so? Does it run really fast, smooth, and speedy compared to the Galaxy S III? Also, can you use third-party keyboards using the one-handed setting like you can with the stock keyboard?
Also, is it likely that both AT&T and Samsung will keep updating the Galaxy Note II over the course of the next 18 months?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pick up GN2 , use for a week & if your not digging it swap to GS3.
I'm betting that you will keep the GN2

Go for the Note 2. If you've got big hands you'll get used to it. (yes, that's what she said too)
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using xda premium

I had a gs3 and iphone 5 and ik here lol sold them both and here ill be for a while
you wont regret note 2
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 2

Did the same thing as OP, even made a thread here about the same question. Sprung for the note 2, never looked back.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using xda app-developers app

Same advice. Go for the Note 2. I had the first Note, but it was the international model on ATT and didn't have LTE, so I ended up getting the S3 when it came out, but I missed the Note so much. Almost went to ATT and got their version of the Note, but held out and waited for the 2, and now, its the great size, and the LTE....and its the happiest I've been with a phone in a while!

malinois16 said:
I agree. The note II is bigger, faster, and has at least twice the battery life. I don't have huge hands and have no problems with it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1

Try them both out at the store - I have a Note 2 and my wife has an S3. I love my note 2 but every once in a while I pick up the s3 and it really feels like the perfect size for a phone... both are great devices imo.
lathamc said:
I currently have the Galaxy S III on Sprint that I got the day it was released. However, I am switching to AT&T next week, and I don't know if I want to get the AT&T Galaxy S III or the Galaxy Note II. I love my Galaxy S III, with my one wish being that it had a quad-core processor. With the Note II, I love everything, except it seems like it might be too big. However, I have big hands, and I don't use my Galaxy S III one handed anyways. I also do a lot of texting/emailing.
What do you think? Is the Galaxy Note II worth the extra $100 or so? Does it run really fast, smooth, and speedy compared to the Galaxy S III? Also, can you use third-party keyboards using the one-handed setting like you can with the stock keyboard?
Also, is it likely that both AT&T and Samsung will keep updating the Galaxy Note II over the course of the next 18 months?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Having had both phones I must say that if the S3 had the battery to last a day I probably wouldn't have made the switch. I'm glad it didn't and I switched. I was toying around with the idea I was going to get a tablet but was hung up on carrying around two devices. Then my girlfriend got the N2 and I started playing around and found that is the best of both worlds. The extra screen real estate and battery life is awesome. It really doesn't feel funny or big after a couple days plus I can still use it one handed and I'm not a big guy. I would suggest the N2 to anyone.

Made the switch
I just made the switch from the SGS3 to the GN2. I would agree with a previous poster that if the SGS3 had a longer battery life, I probably would not have switched. But alas, it does and I made the switch and am glad I have done so. The phone is very responsive and the battery life is fantastic. I love the S-Pen and camera.
Both are great phones. Don't forget some carriers have a 14-day return policy (at least here in CA) so you can try it out but you might be subject to a restocking fee ($35 for AT&T).

Note 2 on 4.1.2 international firmware.
Sent from my GT-N7105 using xda premium

I owned an SIII for about 4-5 months and I just sold it for a Note 2. It's better in EVERY way. It's so good that it's the first Android phone I probably won't bother rooting to install a custom rom. Get it and live happily ever after knowing that you own the best phone in the world. :victory:

bryanhayn said:
I owned an SIII for about 4-5 months and I just sold it for a Note 2. It's better in EVERY way. It's so good that it's the first Android phone I probably won't bother rooting to install a custom rom. Get it and live happily ever after knowing that you own the best phone in the world. :victory:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd agree...the stock ROM was surprisingly good. I keep considering going back to it...

Sg3 over note 2?

I posted this over on the note 2 section and someone thought I should put this on here too. Sg3 with jelly bean for $99 or note 2 for $289. It's an upgradable line. Difference of 190 bucks. Opinions are welcomed.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using xda app-developers app
--FROM THE MODERATOR--
Double posting not allowed and there is already a thread for phone comparisons
...........THREAD CLOSED..........

Its personal preference right. Its your decision
sent from the dark side of the universe....

Sanfo12 said:
I posted this over on the note 2 section and someone thought I should put this on here too. Sg3 with jelly bean for $99 or note 2 for $289. It's an upgradable line. Difference of 190 bucks. Opinions are welcomed.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Note 2 is a beast. Yea they're very similar but using both, I can definitely feel the quad core performance advantage on the Note 2. Side by side I could also tell a distinct difference in the brightness and saturation of the screen. And probably the biggest difference is the battery. You can literally go days on one charge with heavy use. The GS3, not so much. If you're into phablets, def go with the Note 2.

I had Note 2 to play around with for a couple of weeks and I've owned SGS3 since July. I thought the Note 2 was solid but it was just too darn big for my liking. That was pretty much the only issue I had with the Note 2. I love how big the Note 2 screen is and all but I hated walking around with it in my pants pocket.

greystealth said:
The Note 2 is a beast. Yea they're very similar but using both, I can definitely feel the quad core performance advantage on the Note 2. Side by side I could also tell a distinct difference in the brightness and saturation of the screen. And probably the biggest difference is the battery. You can literally go days on one charge with heavy use. The GS3, not so much. If you're into phablets, def go with the Note 2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
X_Fact0r said:
I had Note 2 to play around with for a couple of weeks and I've owned SGS3 since July. I thought the Note 2 was solid but it was just too darn big for my liking. That was pretty much the only issue I had with the Note 2. I love how big the Note 2 screen is and all but I hated walking around with it in my pants pocket.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
These two posts hit my experience with the Note 2 right on the head.
Like X_Fact0r, I've had the S3 since July. I decided to give the Note 2 a try and while it's a GREAT phone, I just couldn't get past the size. If someone has already had the S3, it feels like the Note 2 is just a S3 on steroids. For me, it wasn't worth the nearly $700 off-contract price to feel like I was just getting a bigger screen and I returned it. I also didn't think I'd use the S-Pen very much, although if I'd kept it for good, I may have found that it was really useful.
Add to that how good the development is for the S3, and I just decided to stick with it. But I'm not bashing the Note 2 at all. It worked flawlessly and if you don't mind having a small tablet in your pocket, it's a great choice. But I LOVE my S3, so I stuck with it.

Very interesting to see how the S3 people feel about this as opposed to the Note II users.
Mainly it looks like it's just a size issue here. And for the Note II guys, they thought the same until they put it to good use; multi-tasking and such.
I'd like to hear from more people.. For the sake of knowing.
& thanks OP for posting over here as well.

I played with one at best buy and it honestly I say gs3. Not to get all Apple but it was difficult to use one handed which is nice about the gs3 is that it is perfect size just pushing the boundaries of comfort. Also the price tag IMO is inexcusable. The note II might be a better phone but with the gs3 I feel you are getting your monies worth for what we pay. The note II did seem more durable than the sgs3 issue solved with a d30 case though
sent from my Samsung Gangster S III on the T-Mobile network
---------- Post added at 11:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:10 PM ----------
Brad.S. said:
Very interesting to see how the S3 people feel about this as opposed to the Note II users.
Mainly it looks like it's just a size issue here. And for the Note II guys, they thought the same until they put it to good use; multi-tasking and such.
I'd like to hear from more people.. For the sake of knowing.
& thanks OP for posting over here as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am sure had I owned one I would change my opinion and adapted to the size...still I say gs3
sent from my Samsung Gangster S III on the T-Mobile network

To me the Note 2 is a better phone. Size, pen, battery life and quad core are awesome!
For the money an S3 for 99 is a great deal. For instance if a Note 2 user would offer me their Note 2 if I gave them my S3 and $200 I would keep the S3.
Pretty much that is why I still have the S3 today
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app

Brad.S. said:
Mainly it looks like it's just a size issue here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's exactly what it was for me. I'd gotten into the "bigger is better" mentality, but I found it was just too big for my tastes.
The odd thing, and this was just my experience, was that I expected with the quad core hype it would be the smoothest phone I could find. I actually ended up having some unexpected lag. This was just with the stock launcher, but it was still there. It must have just been an aberration, though.
My S3 is smooth as silk.

I'll take the s3 over n2 any day.

I have the GS III, my wife has the Note II. For me the size of the GS III is perfect, just on that edge of being too big. The note 2 however is just too big for my tastes, but then again my wife drops hers in her purse, so carrying it is not an issue. If I want a bigger screen I bust out my transformer tablet, or even worse my toshiba laptop.
But I do like both devices for what they are and what they are capable of doing. Now if your a BIT of an artist always looking for a canvas, then the note 2 is more for you. Just not for me. I love my GS III, that is until the next shiny thing that comes along...oh look a penny....

I have both, S3 from July and Note 2 from Nov. I like note 2 better.

I played with the note recently and I honestly don't think I could get over the size of that thing. I put it to my ear and it was like I literally had a book to my ear.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app

MasterDecker said:
I love my GS III, that is until the next shiny thing that comes along...oh look a penny....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is so totally me. I love my S3...until the S4 is announced and I start obsessing over it!

Honestly I bought the S3 coming from an iPhone 5 and I really want a Note 2 LOL

why Is that Reid?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using xda app-developers app

I've had my S3 since July, and now I wish I had waited for the Note 2 before signing up for a contract. I wonder if I can sell my S3 for $300 and pay the difference for a Note 2 at retail price. I don't mind the size. If anything is worth doing or achieving for you, then there's no reason to be embarrassed.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda app-developers app

my GF has the GS3 and I have the note 2... I literally have spotify streaming music for 10 hrs per day on average... surf ebay and craigslist apps constantly at the same time... play videos and use the multiview ability all the time... sounds silly but its useful with whatsapp! I never turn anything off! I have wifi, BT, NFC, all motion, all samsung, no power saving, basically zero concern for battery draw and after 18 hours of constant use... I end my days with around 20% battery remaining! The GS3 is nothing close. Plus the raw power and freakish speed of the GN2 is unreal! I can scroll any list no matter the length at maximum speed and never induce even one shutter... wicked fast! So yeah... I'm sticking with the Note2.

I have a s3, 2 note 2s. s3 is a better bang for your buck but note 2 destroy s3 in
Everything IMO..
Sent from outside our window

[Q] Note 2 or S4

Hi All
At the moment I am using HTC Sensation but am due for upgrade (3UK) Dont like HTc at the moment had lots of problems so thought I would give Samsung a try.
I have never had a Samsung phone so am undecided about which to go for. I like the screen size on the Note 2 and from what I have heard the battery is great (HTC Crap) I use it for internet a lot and email ,when i have my Tablet I would use it to tether if this is possible with the note. Watch some video nd use word documents.
I can get either the Note 2 or S4 as free upgrade so any advice would be appreciated as to which is best. My main requirement is battery, the HTC I had to carry two batteries to last the day...
Thanks all.

Battery - undoubtedly go for Note II. No second thoughts there. Hands down has the best battery life of all phones except Droid Razr (which lacks quite a few features of N2).
If you like the screen size, and battery life is your priority, it's a no brainer IMO.

tuxonhtc said:
Battery - undoubtedly go for Note II. No second thoughts there. Hands down has the best battery life of all phones except Droid Razr (which lacks quite a few features of N2).
If you like the screen size, and battery life is your priority, it's a no brainer IMO.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app

I've just had to make the sane decision as you. I'm also in 3 and I decided on the note 2 for screen and battery and after a week I made the right choice. After it being off charge since 7am this morning it's now 8 at night and I have 52% left.

I just made this decision, went with N2. It's already ready to go development wise and you don't have to worry about new phone hiccups or wait a long time for a proper portfolio of accessories. Plus the bigger screen, s pen, and most likely better battery make it worth it to me.
But if you're a stock ROM guy, really want 1080p res, or want the new CPU architecture, then S4's the way to go.

Buy a note 2...no contest here. Its got nice screen, big screen, big battery, s pen and just about all s4 software features are coming.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

kjt57 said:
Hi All
At the moment I am using HTC Sensation but am due for upgrade (3UK) Dont like HTc at the moment had lots of problems so thought I would give Samsung a try.
I have never had a Samsung phone so am undecided about which to go for. I like the screen size on the Note 2 and from what I have heard the battery is great (HTC Crap) I use it for internet a lot and email ,when i have my Tablet I would use it to tether if this is possible with the note. Watch some video nd use word documents.
I can get either the Note 2 or S4 as free upgrade so any advice would be appreciated as to which is best. My main requirement is battery, the HTC I had to carry two batteries to last the day...
Thanks all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you miss my thread? The note 2 is all you need for 2013 and beyond till the note 3
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app

I was also a HTC addict. But was really disappointed with their take on battery and storage. I was tempted by the s3, no s4 in January, but I wanted the big screen. Believe me every day I'm so glad I got the note 2. If I had to choose today between the s4 and the note 2 is still choose the note.
As long as you are happy with size pick the note.
Enjoy.

skyelm said:
Buy a note 2...no contest here. Its got nice screen, big screen, big battery, s pen and just about all s4 software features are coming.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I quote all

3vo3d said:
I was also a HTC addict. But was really disappointed with their take on battery and storage. I was tempted by the s3, no s4 in January, but I wanted the big screen. Believe me every day I'm so glad I got the note 2. If I had to choose today between the s4 and the note 2 is still choose the note.
As long as you are happy with size pick the note.
Enjoy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My words exactly!

3 UK have now discontinued the Note 2 on their website........

I've had this same question roaming around my mind for a bit now. Since T-Mo is ending contrancts if you want to end and go on your own. My wife and I are eleigible for an upgrade in June.... not free but if we get a new phone T-Mo is making changes where we would be paying about $20 a month to pay off whatever phone we choose, and that will actually still be cheaper then our plan now. I was thinking about waiting it out for the note 3 but I honestly don't have the patience for that. Went in a T-Mo store yesterday and dude told me it won't be until November most likely until the Note 3 get dropped. I can't wait that long..... I'm getting the Note 2 over S4 and probably sell it in September or October and use that money to get the Note 3.
Notes are big, almost too big but from what I have read peeps love them. Probably take some time to get used to them but I'll learn

Yeah, the size was initially scaring me too, but I got used to it real quick and now would definately miss the screen estate on a smaller device.
Actually the S4 felt like a small toy when I tried it in a shop (also due to low weight).

I admit that it's slightly (again, slightly - and I've not got the biggest of hands either) awkward to hold at times, but the positives by far outweigh the cons for me. I'm a big time reader (mostly comics ) and watch movies on my device. My hands get tired like hell while using tablets and my eyes hurt while using the tiny sized devices - Note II hits the sweet spot for me And I don't have to camp near a recharge socket either.

Bought a s4 for my wife yesterday and played with for 30 min.
Just 1 thing: note2 is better believe me BUT s4 has a good camera tbh xD
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda premium

WTF?!
These kinds of thread just won't die

Note 3.
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda app-developers app

I do not love intermediate solutions, so I have the Note II to be complete everytime, but I need a small phone in my pocket, to be available, it is not possible with S4, S4 and Note II, so I have the Acer Liquid Gallant, not expensive and with acceptable performances for me...
Two is better than one, Note II, waiting for Note 3...

Note 2 no doubt.
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2

Galaxy s4 or note 2???

People who have said theres no difference between the s4 and the s3 or note are TRIPPIN have yall held the device? Feels great in my hand went with my mom to get hers for mothers day. And holy cow. The features it has are one untop of another all hidden too. The screen is farrrr better. The way it feels. So Smooth. The besel on the side of the phone makes it look nice and feel great. Even if the note 2 gets the 4.2 update with some features of the s4. The s4 will still have the best unique features. I love my note 2. But as soon as I held. N played around with the s4. Man I might just buy me mine cash next month. Figured the s4 is the perfect size fits perfectly in my hand. The note 2 still to big . What do you guys think?
Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk 2

Well the main thing, if you feel its to big you will never be completely happy with it, and will be itching to move on..on the other hand waiting on development is always my issue when deciding what to do

Unfortunately, I agree. I like my wife's S4 more than my Note 2. It kills me on benchmarks with the better processor. The GPU is a billion times better. It can get 37FPS when I can only get 9. It goes through battery a bit quickly and it seems that a few apps aren't quite formatted for 1080 resolution yet, but that will change soon. If I were to put a kernel on her phone and UV I'd prolly get pretty good battery life too. I like the fit in my hand, for sure. Any smaller would be too small but it fits in one hand nicely. On the GN2 I have to use a nilken case that has a knurled finish on the back so that it stays in my hand. The camera is nice and the camera features are pretty cool. I do like my S-Pen but I've gone to AOSP for themeing, control, and speed so I've lost S-note already. I miss S-note (looks much nicer than Papyrus) but I don't think that makes the note worth having over the S4. I'm not going to drop coin on it though, going to stick with the Note.

I just got my 4 today I also have the S3 and Note 2. They are all so different its crazy. I gave my note 2 to my kid and I thought I would keep it until I started playing with my S4 and realized I dont miss it one bit lol or the S3. If you have a S3 it is worth the upgrade if you have the Note2 and are thinking of upgrading yes itsbway worth it but that is a personal opinion. The S4 takes the cake I am amazed at how smooth compared to the Note2 and s3 it is expecially the nore because its quad core.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

[Q] anyone switch from note 2 to s4?

I am in the middle of making a decision any go from note 2 to s4 if so how was your experience?

Well, I'd say don't. There isn't a big difference tho, Note 2 is almost the same. But if u dont really like such a big screen as Note2 then u can switch. But if I was u, then I wouldnt really waste extra money for it, but if u didnt have the Note2 then going for a S4 isnt bad either

I have the note 2 and got the s4 thinking, I thought 5in screen would be a good compromise because once in awhile I find the note 2 too big...The biggest adjustment I had to make was size, its funny but the s4 actually feels too small vs the note 2 now where I find it more the note 2 more comfortable to use then the s4. Texting is another adjustment I had to make, I got used to typing on a bigger screen to now the s4 feels cramped.
Besides that the .5in makes a pretty big difference I find my self still preferring to use the note over the s4 so I'll end up returning the s4 and keeping the note.
If you think the Note 2 is too big then get the s4, also battery life is another small adjustment I had to make although the s4 battery life is really good it the note 2 is still better. Oh yeah the screen pixel density isnt that big of a jump although 1080 is nice the jump is not as drastic as from a non 720p phone to a 720p phone.

jawang26 said:
I have the note 2 and got the s4 thinking, I thought 5in screen would be a good compromise because once in awhile I find the note 2 too big...The biggest adjustment I had to make was size, its funny but the s4 actually feels too small vs the note 2 now where I find it more the note 2 more comfortable to use then the s4. Texting is another adjustment I had to make, I got used to typing on a bigger screen to now the s4 feels cramped.
Besides that the .5in makes a pretty big difference I find my self still preferring to use the note over the s4 so I'll end up returning the s4 and keeping the note.
If you think the Note 2 is too big then get the s4, also battery life is another small adjustment I had to make although the s4 battery life is really good it the note 2 is still better. Oh yeah the screen pixel density isnt that big of a jump although 1080 is nice the jump is not as drastic as from a non 720p phone to a 720p phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seems like note 2 owners are not liking the s4 switch.

I switched and im loving it. Obvisouly the battery still isnt that good but im hoping for more kernels to be relwased by devs that provides optimsl battery life. Regardless I still get all day battery life with both phones.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using Tapatalk 2

I did, I even had the ascend mate, change in screen size is immediate. Once you find a buddy with a note 2,you will realize how big it was.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app

coachb97 said:
Seems like note 2 owners are not liking the s4 switch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It really just depends on your own personal preference, there both really good phones but I'm paying full price , prob 250-300 after I sell my note 2...to me the jump is not worth the extra $$$ but if I we're to change to a smaller phone it'd be the s4

witeboy07 said:
I did, I even had the ascend mate, change in screen size is immediate. Once you find a buddy with a note 2,you will realize how big it was.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are u happy with the size change

I'm using both daily and I'm surprised how typing is actually easier for me on the note 2 now that I get to play with both.
The perfect phone for me would be the note 2 with the thinner bezels of the s4 and the features of the s4 such as air view without the pen, and mostly the 1080p screen. That screen just looks quite a bit better for me as I'm near sighted and tend to read very small text on Web pages and such, it just makes it more convenient to have the full Web page on the screen and still be able to read the text on it.
To sum up, I still have a preference for my note 2 due to battery life and screen size. However, if the note 3's body ends up bigger than the note 2's, I won't be going for that. I'm probably going to use the s4 for a little while longer and then sell it.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using Tapatalk 2