Related
So I'm that type of person who has a case for every day of the week. Lol
I have here in order from left to right on the picture
Case logic pouch (For Android/Windows Phones is what it said on the packaging)
Otterbox Defender
Otterbox Commuter
Generic Black TPU Case from ebay
Generic blue hard snap on case.
The leather pouch is awesome! It fits the phone naked or with any of my cases with the exception of the otterbox defender. I had a Seidio spring loaded holster for use with the Captivate+Innocase and it had a very snug fit for the Atrix+any of the other cases aside from the Defender.
The defender is actually really nice on this phone! I had it on the Captivate and it was wayyy to bulky and it made it extremely frustrating whenever you tried to touch the capacitive buttons on the bottom. With the Atrix, it doesn't add too much bulk and I can feel safe whenever I have it on my phone. I usually use this one when I know I'm going somewhere where they'll be potential damage to my phone like the beach.
The commuter is my personal favorite case! It looks real nice with the fancy design on the back. It doesn't add too much bulk, but does add a good ammount of protection. I find it strange that all the Captivate otterbox cases make the phone twice as big, but that's not the same case for the Atrix. It's even stranger that a naked Atrix is bulkier than a naked Captivate.
The generic black TPU is also pretty nice. It doesn't add much bulk at all, but TPU usually offers good protection. Mine specifically has that stupid common Argyle pattern, but it's in the inside so it's not shown on the back of my phone! The only problem I have with this case is the fact that it attracts fingerprints like no tomorrow.
The generic blue snap on case was an impulse buy when I got my phone. I just wanted to make sure it was protected out of the box. I don't really like this case too much as I'm not a big fan of hard cases to begin with.
I'm still waiting on the Candyshell, and other cases to come out. I'll update asap!
If anyone has any detailed questions about any of the cases, let me know!!!
F_L_Abs said:
So I'm that type of person who has a case for every day of the week. Lol
I have here in order from left to right on the picture
Case logic pouch (For Android/Windows Phones is what it said on the packaging)
Otterbox Defender
Otterbox Commuter
Generic Black TPU Case from ebay
Generic blue hard snap on case.
The leather pouch is awesome! It fits the phone naked or with any of my cases with the exception of the otterbox defender. I had a Seidio spring loaded holster for use with the Captivate+Innocase and it had a very snug fit for the Atrix+any of the other cases aside from the Defender.
The defender is actually really nice on this phone! I had it on the Captivate and it was wayyy to bulky and it made it extremely frustrating whenever you tried to touch the capacitive buttons on the bottom. With the Atrix, it doesn't add too much bulk and I can feel safe whenever I have it on my phone. I usually use this one when I know I'm going somewhere where they'll be potential damage to my phone like the beach.
The commuter is my personal favorite case! It looks real nice with the fancy design on the back. It doesn't add too much bulk, but does add a good ammount of protection. I find it strange that all the Captivate otterbox cases make the phone twice as big, but that's not the same case for the Atrix. It's even stranger that a naked Atrix is bulkier than a naked Captivate.
The generic black TPU is also pretty nice. It doesn't add much bulk at all, but TPU usually offers good protection. Mine specifically has that stupid common Argyle pattern, but it's in the inside so it's not shown on the back of my phone! The only problem I have with this case is the fact that it attracts fingerprints like no tomorrow.
The generic blue snap on case was an impulse buy when I got my phone. I just wanted to make sure it was protected out of the box. I don't really like this case too much as I'm not a big fan of hard cases to begin with.
I'm still waiting on the Candyshell, and other cases to come out. I'll update asap!
If anyone has any detailed questions about any of the cases, let me know!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont feel like a loner anymore lol! I've always been obsessed with cases. I have the OBD, OBC, Feather, Bodyglove and the Candyshell. Caint wait for Sedio to release a Active X or Rugged. I'm also hoping for some case-mates soon? Request? http://support.case-mate.com/index.php?pg=request
I'm waiting on the seidio active x with holster! I loved the seidio holster I had for my captivate! It works pretty well still with certain atrix cases, but I ended up giving it away. Lol
Not the biggest case mate fan but ill submit a request and well see ;Db
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
You are not alone I couldn't decide btwn the defender or commuter so I got both to test out in person. I ended up liking.g the commuter mainly BC I had trouble plugging in some headphone jack devices because the defender is slightly bulkier
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
I just ordered the black tpu with the argyle pattern on the inside off Amazon. I have a question for you, the buttons for volume look molded in, how hard is it to push the buttons with the case on?
How much bulk does the commuter add? I'm thinking of picking it up but I don't want it to be fat
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
I didn't find it harder to press at all with the tpu case. Then again that might just be me not paying full attention to it. I'm not very picky... lol
The commuter does add a bit of bulk, but I don't think its bad at all especially for the ammount of protection it adds. I do also really dig the design on the back! I heard that it won't fit with any docks though to give you an idea. I was able to dock my phone with the TPU case though.
Sent from my Desire HD using XDA Premium App
bigc_13 said:
How much bulk does the commuter add? I'm thinking of picking it up but I don't want it to be fat
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That was my biggest concern because I didnt really want a case but didn't want a broken phone. So I got the commuter and love that it doesn't make it that much bigger but makes it feel a ton safer.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
I just got the TPU case... dropped it from my lap getting out of the car in a parking garage.. unscathed. great case.. doesnt look as fancy as others but it does the job and its a pretty good price.
yeah, i bought a few of those snap on hard cases just for the sake of protection, however, they are a ***** to get off! And i use my vehicle dock often, so thats a no go. I bought a clear skin (like a zaag), and havent looked back since. It actually makes the back of the phone shinny and the CF weave pattern really POP...looks more like real CF
After checked a cpl of cases for my new Atrix, I found one in HK and its dirt cheap too ($6!!). Dual material PC + TPU with transparent back, flame, scratch resistant, very light and thin, washable too. The fact I disliked about otterbox and similar heavy armed cases (aside of being very bulky) is a lack of heat dissipation.
My suggestion goes for Momax iCasePro:
http://www.momax.net/en/Product_Show.aspx?ID=1415&T=1
Top notch.
F_L_Abs said:
So I'm that type of person who has a case for every day of the week. Lol
I have here in order from left to right on the picture
Case logic pouch (For Android/Windows Phones is what it said on the packaging)
Otterbox Defender
Otterbox Commuter
Generic Black TPU Case from ebay
Generic blue hard snap on case.
The leather pouch is awesome! It fits the phone naked or with any of my cases with the exception of the otterbox defender. I had a Seidio spring loaded holster for use with the Captivate+Innocase and it had a very snug fit for the Atrix+any of the other cases aside from the Defender.
The defender is actually really nice on this phone! I had it on the Captivate and it was wayyy to bulky and it made it extremely frustrating whenever you tried to touch the capacitive buttons on the bottom. With the Atrix, it doesn't add too much bulk and I can feel safe whenever I have it on my phone. I usually use this one when I know I'm going somewhere where they'll be potential damage to my phone like the beach.
The commuter is my personal favorite case! It looks real nice with the fancy design on the back. It doesn't add too much bulk, but does add a good ammount of protection. I find it strange that all the Captivate otterbox cases make the phone twice as big, but that's not the same case for the Atrix. It's even stranger that a naked Atrix is bulkier than a naked Captivate.
The generic black TPU is also pretty nice. It doesn't add much bulk at all, but TPU usually offers good protection. Mine specifically has that stupid common Argyle pattern, but it's in the inside so it's not shown on the back of my phone! The only problem I have with this case is the fact that it attracts fingerprints like no tomorrow.
The generic blue snap on case was an impulse buy when I got my phone. I just wanted to make sure it was protected out of the box. I don't really like this case too much as I'm not a big fan of hard cases to begin with.
I'm still waiting on the Candyshell, and other cases to come out. I'll update asap!
If anyone has any detailed questions about any of the cases, let me know!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do they have those leather cases but sideways????? I'm looking for one that will fit those tpu cases as well.
Yes they do! I bought it at a local supermarket kinda store, but I did see it at Wally World too.
The description specifically sais "for Windows and Android Phones"
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Helpful post, I got the commuter, it's pretty good
never really saw the need for a case it makes a good phone look ugly and doesnt really protect i prefer invisible shields
Until it slips out of your hands and hits the ground and ends up looking worse than with a case..... I like the look of the commuter otter box case
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Question for anyone that does not mind answering. I currently have the otterbox defender which I have to say I enjoy having it while I am out running around etc. Like that feeling of safety with the "hefty" case since I have large hands does not bother me to much. BUT, I was thinking of getting another case to use just around the house and thinking about the feather case or something small and minimal. I tend to set my phone face down most of the time. Any suggestions? also to expound upon that if anyone else has tried or done this before if I did that i would look into getting a adhesive screen protector. If I did that would it work with the otterbox defender and its built in screen protector would I maybe have to cut that out? Which I am not totally opposed to just seems almost like a waste. I know gorilla glass is tough stuff I am just the meticulous kind of person that if i saw the scratch on my screen I would not be able to let it go and it would drive me crazy.
Ryan,
I would suggest either the otterbox commuter (still kinda bulky, but not as bad as the defender), or the body glove mirage (nice and thin).
As far as the screen protector, I've used the matte/anti glare from att with the defender. I do kinda notice its not as responsive when I'm typing and etc, but thar might just be a mental thing.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA Premium App
So, I've been using Innocases for awhile. On my iPhone 3g and Samsung Vibrant.
I've constantly been tempted to purchase an Otterbox for the protection purposes and some of them seem to have nice styling as well, but I love the texture and feel of the Seido cases.
I was just wanting to get some opinions on both cases. I know it always comes down to personal preference, but wanted to hear the thoughts of others before dropping $25 on one or the other.
I love my Commuter. I like it even more than the Commuters on my iPad & Captivate. The 'X' design on the back sets it off.
I prefer the Commuter case as well. It really is the best case for money, style, and protection.
What is the case texture like? I only ask because I always keep my phone in my pocket and don't care for rubber cases that cling too much.
Sent from my Vibrant using my fingers.
Seido Surface without a doubt. Offers amazing protection, doesn't add bulk, stays tight, and even has a nice feel and look to it.
I love my commuter case I just got today. It tends to catch a little lint but I can already see that getting less and less. very happy with my purchase.
zyrinx said:
What is the case texture like? I only ask because I always keep my phone in my pocket and don't care for rubber cases that cling too much.
Sent from my Vibrant using my fingers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the Commuter case will NEVER cling to your pocket insides because the back has that hardshell along with some on the side too so the silicone won't ever cause contact problems with pockets, satchels, pouches, etc.
I certainly appreciate all of the input. Definitely a Commuter case supporting group. I'll have to see if I can find one somewhere to check it out since I know how much I like the Seidio already.
I'm going to get a Galaxy Nexus soon, and I need a case. I was thinking of getting the defender because of the build in screen protector, but i read a couple of posts that say that the case can scratch your phone. Is this true?
I have also read somewhere that it can scratch the phone. It's probably not the case that scratches the phone but a foreign body (sand, grit, dust) getting trapped inside the case. I think regular cleaning of the inside should fix that. I think i could anyway live with a few minor scratches considering the peace of mind the case otherwise gives you.
I bought one and had it on for a few months, it not only scratched the outer edges of the phone, it gouged it. I agree it likely had to do with contaminants getting into the case, which did happen. I had to pull the phone out of the case every second day because of things getting into it.
While I love defender cases, I was disappointed in the one for our phones.
Thanks for the info guys. I will stay away from this case.
Try the otterbox commuter. It wont scratch the device as the inner layer is silicon and not plastic.
Have a commuter and although I rarely use it, the case is sufficient. Only complaint is that it's a huge lint collector.
I have the trident kraken. It's thick, but still fits easily into my pocket. Another good option is the Seidio Active.
I had the Defender and quickly returned it as it doesn't fit properly with my GSM Galaxy Nexus.
I ended up getting the Trident Kraken and Otterbox Commuter. Both are great cases that provide enough protection for the type of work I do.
The Kraken may be too bulky for most, so I would recommend getting the Commuter instead.
Sent from my iPhone 5s HD Galaxy Maxx with Bionic Retina using Tapatalk
i need help deciding on a rugged case. i've read mixed reviews on all. my main concern is drop protection.
the lifeproof seems nice and slim, but i'm worried it wont provide enough drop protection
i currently have a otterbox defender on my razr maxx, and it is my favorite case. however, i've never dropped it, so i can't comment on the drop protection. i thought for sure it would be my go-to case for the s3, but i've read many people say that otterbox dropped the ball on the defender for the s3. stating that drops cause the screen to break and the screen protector is lifted too far from the screen. i'm aware that the silicone stretches out over time, and i'm ok with that. since otterbox has terrific customer service. is the defender really that bad of a case for the s3?
i also have a trident kraken for my maxx. it is a nice stylish case, but i never use it because it is very slippery and hard to hold. the s3 seems to have a different design that might not be so slippery. but i also haven't read as many reviews for it as some of the others.
i've always seen the griffin survivor cases in stores, but only for iphones. they look very nice and rugged, but i dont have any experience with one. it would seem to offer the same protection as the defender. one concern i have is the port covers seem loose. like they would come open every time you pulled the phone out of your pocket.
the ballistic hardcore seems to be the same design as the defender and survivor.
the otterbox armor seems like it would be a great case. but many drop tests on youtube show the case constantly coming open upon impact. and many reviews complain about sound quality.
i will probably also get a UAG case for weekends, but for now, i'm more concerned on more rugged cases.
music_man185 said:
i need help deciding on a rugged case. i've read mixed reviews on all. my main concern is drop protection.
the lifeproof seems nice and slim, but i'm worried it wont provide enough drop protection
i currently have a otterbox defender on my razr maxx, and it is my favorite case. however, i've never dropped it, so i can't comment on the drop protection. i thought for sure it would be my go-to case for the s3, but i've read many people say that otterbox dropped the ball on the defender for the s3. stating that drops cause the screen to break and the screen protector is lifted too far from the screen. i'm aware that the silicone stretches out over time, and i'm ok with that. since otterbox has terrific customer service. is the defender really that bad of a case for the s3?
i also have a trident kraken for my maxx. it is a nice stylish case, but i never use it because it is very slippery and hard to hold. the s3 seems to have a different design that might not be so slippery. but i also haven't read as many reviews for it as some of the others.
i've always seen the griffin survivor cases in stores, but only for iphones. they look very nice and rugged, but i dont have any experience with one. it would seem to offer the same protection as the defender. one concern i have is the port covers seem loose. like they would come open every time you pulled the phone out of your pocket.
the ballistic hardcore seems to be the same design as the defender and survivor.
the otterbox armor seems like it would be a great case. but many drop tests on youtube show the case constantly coming open upon impact. and many reviews complain about sound quality.
i will probably also get a UAG case for weekends, but for now, i'm more concerned on more rugged cases.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Otterbox Armor gets my vote, it's a beast of a case. I've had the Griffin survivor and trident Kraken. Both great cases, but the trident case the plastic eventually broke on a drop, and the kickstand rattled like crazy. The Griffin survivor was a great case, but i got tired of opening a flap to take pictures.
As far as the Defender case it never impressed me and it's not dust proof.
In the end no case can protect your phone from every single drop. It comes down to luck.
Sent from Under water
Do you have problems with the sound quality with the armor? And how does the survivor compare to the defender? Since they use the same technology. The silicone looks a little beefier on the survivor.
Sent from my Motorola RAZR MAXX using Tapatalk 2
Sound quality for me is good enough for me, you can tell a difference but i either got use to it or it went away.
The survivor and defender are no where near the same imo. The survivor's exterior has a lot more grip to it. And as i said before the defender is not dust/dirt proof, the survivor is.
The survivor is also water resistant, meaning it could take a light rain, but not a submerging.
My armor case saved my phone from a 1 story drop onto rocks, I've taken it swimming multiple times. Also it has to be the easiest case to take on and off when needed.
But every drop is different, the only thing a case will do is provide a extra barrier. If dropped just at the right angle anything can break.
People put a lot of false hope in cases and then try to blame the manufacturer when the phone breaks.
Sent from Under water
none of the above. If i needed serious drop protection again, i would go with bodyglove toughsuit case. even the slimmer version has great protection, called the shocksuit. Ive had them both
Armor case for me as well.
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2
any experience with the other cases mentioned? or is the armor the only one you've tried? comparisons would be nice.
I have had the defender, commuter, ballistic SG MAXX, and Lifeproof as of now. Ballistic and defender did their job well but did not care for the silicone stretching. Commuter works well considering. Lifeproof has been great this far. No major tumbles so I cannot vouch for how well it stands up to concrete or asphalt in major drops but it is waterproof and sound quality is good.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747
To throw in one more choice for ya ... Pure gear PX260 or PX360 ,. I have a 360 and it is a BEAST. Not waterproof but built like a tank and has a place for a snap hook and is held on with screws ..
http://www.pure-gear.com/shop-by-de...stem-for-samsung-galaxy-s-iii-collection.html
or
http://www.pure-gear.com/shop-by-de...stem-for-samsung-galaxy-s-iii-collection.html
I purchased the Seidio and Ballistic cases and they finally came in the mail. I'm probably done with buying cases as I think I've settled on the one I want to use most often. The others I might keep for occasional use or eventually sell the phone off and bundle it.
Along with the neo hybrid I first bought here's a mini review .
Ballistic SG vs Seidio vs Neo Hybrid.
Ballistiic SG
pros- Build quality is top notch. Ports are well accessible. Can take punishment
Cons- bulky
Seidio Dilex
Pros- decent built quality for moderate use. Kick stand is a plus. easy installation. Looks (subjective)
Cons- the polymer or rubber insert that you put the phone in first can pull/stretch so it may expose the phone if you're not careful.
Neo Hybrid-
Pros- slick looking. many compliments thinking its part of the phone. Case really hugs the phone
cons- difficult to take case off and on if you like to switch out cases. The back of case is very slippery. Overall case seems to make you want to handle it with care still. Like the Seidio, I believe it can take a few bumps and drops here and there. Can't access ear phone jack
Overall, for my preferences. I prefer the Ballisitc SG. Has a nice solid feel. It is bulky but I feel it can take some abuse and with my 2 kids wanting to occasionally use the phone, I'm pretty confident it'll survive.
Neo Hybrid comes second. I'll use it for a nice night out or to a wedding, etc.
Seidio -I'll use it the least. Probably just to change it up for the sake of it or use the kickstand when I know the kids would want to watch something as we're out and about.
If moderator can post this in the nexus 5 accessories! My bad.
I agree with your review 100%, even though I don't own a Ballistic, but out of the three, overall, I'd pick the Ballistic as well. And the Seidio, I would use that when going on a trip on a plane or something where you can use the kickstand and you or/and your kids can look at it without holding the phone. And the Spigen is the slick version of the three. Very sporty and slim, like a Corvette, compared to the Ballistic which is like a Caddy Escolade, where the Seidio equates to a F150 where you can also use it and abuse it without much thought. :laugh:
I have the Ballistics case. I love it. The hard screen is a little different and what I would consider the biggest con but you could take it off and use a regular screen protector.
Sounds like you have the Ballistic SG MAXX which offers even more protection with a hard screen overlay. I've got a screen protector (Spigen version) on mine for minimal protection. None of the cases interfere with the screen protector.
Only concern is how hot the phone may get in the summer heat with these cases. The Spigen offers vented grooves in their tpu case so let's see...
boothbrave said:
Sounds like you have the Ballistic SG MAXX which offers even more protection with a hard screen overlay. I've got a screen protector (Spigen version) on mine for minimal protection. None of the cases interfere with the screen protector.
Only concern is how hot the phone may get in the summer heat with these cases. The Spigen offers vented grooves in their tpu case so let's see...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Correct, The Hard Plastic is kind of overkill, but it's fine while I what for my Xtreme Guard protector to come in. I've also noticed the hard screen does settle a little nicer over the screen after some use.
Ordered my SG MAXX the other day on amazon. Hopefully it is going to come- I haven't gotten a tracking number. If anyone is trying to buy the SG MAXX, note that it appears Ballistic has renamed their cases- and what is now the "Tough Jacket Maxx" appears to be exactly the same as the sg.
Just want to mention my Ballistic case saved my phone in an accidental drop on the pavement.
Good weather meant less pockets to store my phone and more chances for a drop.
The SG hit the ground and the thick corner bumper took it like a champ. No scratches and no damage to the phone. Makes me wonder regarding my other two cases I picked up cause Ballistic is the only website to show you details in case protection.