5 cases reviewed/compared - LG Nitro HD

*I originally posted this in the thread Cases for Nitro HD and Optimus LTE, but aquariuz23 suggested I just post a thread that would be easier to find for everyone, so here!*
So, I'm a case fiend and have gathered a few in my process of finding the best case for me for how I use my Nitro, and I think I'm finally satisfied! So here's a small summary of the cases I have and tested:
None have the hole in the corner for the antenna that's not there, and all elevate the area around the camera lens just enough so that when set down, the camera glass doesn't touch the surface. Also, all of them have exposed ports for USB and headphone jack, obviously. Finally, they're all quite thin and don't add much bulk to the phone, the thinnest being the Barely-There, and the fattest being the Transparent Snap-On case. But even still, we're talking about plus or minus maybe 1.5 mm variance in added thickness.
Generic black TPU from Ebay (power button covered)-
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Pros:
-Perfect fit
-Grippy in hand, but doesn't cling to inside of jeans, so easy to take in and out of pocket
-Full protection
-Glossy can look nice (if clean)
-Easy to put on and take off
Cons:
-Glossy can look ugly (if dirty, and gets dirty easily)
-Covers volume rocker, which is good for protection, but can make it kinda tricky to find, even though the texture of the case is a little different over the rocker to indicate where it is)
-Hole for camera portion unnecessarily large
Transparent snap-on from Ebay (power button exposed)-
Pros:
-Not as cheap looking as would expect
-Excellent coverage for protection
-Access to volume rocker and power button
-Overall, pretty good fit
Cons:
-Creaky if pressed on certain edges of the case
-Hole for camera portion too large
-A little tricky to take off, though gets easier with practice
-Material feels hard and sharp, and in putting on and taking off the case, I feel nervous about it scratching the screen protector
Rubberized snap-on from Ebay (power button exposed)-
Pros:
-Looks quite good
-Excellent coverage for protection
-Access to volume rocker and power button
-Overall, pretty good fit
-Matte surface hides finger prints
Cons:
-Rubberized texture is surprisingly slick in hand, but tends to grip to inside of jean pocket, making it hard to pull out, but easy to drop
-Creaky if pressed on certain edges of the case
-Hole for camera portion too large
-A little tricky to take off, though gets easier with practice
Barely There from Amazon (power button exposed)-
Pros:
-Looks great, matte surface hides fingerprints
-Solid build
-Perfect Fit
Cons:
-A little slick to hold
-Exposed top and bottom (if dropped, even onto a perfectly flat surface, the top and bottom edge of the front face of the phone will hit the surface, not the case, so not great protection)
-A little hard to take off
Body Glove from Amazon (power button covered)-
Pros:
-Excellent fit
-Great material (kinda like tougher, matte TPU with textured portions for gripping)
-Material is EXCELLENT at repelling fingerprints/particles/hairs
-Good grip in hand but slips right out of pocket easily
-Covers all of the camera but the necessary lens and flash
-Easy to put on and take off
-Complete coverage except for access to volume rocker
Cons:
-Not the best looking case in the world... pattern design is questionable to me...
Personal fav: Body glove! Has full coverage of the phone, is fantastic at staying clean, is a great, tough, firm material, and is easy to pop on and off for those of us that swap out batteries. Shame it's not a prettier design, but for all its pros, I'll set that aside =)

The Body Glove case actually looks nice to me.

I think I'm just a super minimalist when it comes to design, so my immediate impulse is to favor things that are really super simple and uniform, but I think the texture pattern is kinda growing on me =)

I'm starting to look into the body glove too. I'm just trying to judge the thickness from the pictures, as well as the shape. I really like to look of this phone naked, I think it has nice curves and sometimes I feel cases hide the real look, thus why I was leaning towards Barely-There case cuz it very much follows the shape of the phone itself.
Itis (or konrad? lol) do you mind taking a couple or some more shots of the body glove, with better lighting, so I can see how it really looks on the phone?

I, too would appreciate more pics of the Body Glove case with better lighting.

If you guys have an AT&T store nearby you can try the Body Glove case on your phone in store. If not I can see why you want more pictures. It doesn't exactly keep the rounded smoothness of the Nitro. It does, but then it doesn't. I just really like it because it gives texture in all the right places for holding the phone. I wouldn't pay the $30 in store because I'm a cheap-ass. I get accessories half price though so I bought it. I've read that it can be had for pretty cheap on amazon or ebay, so it should be seen as a good purchase.

AllstarE4 said:
If you guys have an AT&T store nearby you can try the Body Glove case on your phone in store. If not I can see why you want more pictures. It doesn't exactly keep the rounded smoothness of the Nitro. It does, but then it doesn't. I just really like it because it gives texture in all the right places for holding the phone. I wouldn't pay the $30 in store because I'm a cheap-ass. I get accessories half price though so I bought it. I've read that it can be had for pretty cheap on amazon or ebay, so it should be seen as a good purchase.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yup it's about 15 with free shipping in ebay. Not sure about amazon.

I'll second the Body Glove after trying the Ballistic HC and SC. HC was too clunky and messed up the screen up with a ****ty screen protector built in, and the SC repels any screen protector by pushing it off on the edges, kind of hard to explain.

Just got myself body glove. Love it. Doesn't add much bulk, the phone still fit in the belt pouch, little snag, but fits. Since I hold it on left side I was afraid the power button that now sticks out would be pressed when in pouch, but it doesn't.
I shall see how it performs in summer in a heat with sweaty hands. Right now it feels less slippery then without the case.
Thanks.

I just tried the body glove case in the ATT store. I didn't really like how flush it is with the screen. If you dropped it it seemed like the screen could easily be damaged. I wish the rubber/plastic extended up past the screen a tiny bit more. I'm gonna keep looking .
I have 3 kids... so I think I need something a bit more rugged perhaps. I just HATE adding bulk to the phone. Its so sad.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App

acanaday said:
I just tried the body glove case in the ATT store. I didn't really like how flush it is with the screen. If you dropped it it seemed like the screen could easily be damaged. I wish the rubber/plastic extended up past the screen a tiny bit more. I'm gonna keep looking .
I have 3 kids... so I think I need something a bit more rugged perhaps. I just HATE adding bulk to the phone. Its so sad.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, if you really want ultimate protection ballistic is the way to go..
http://www.goballisticcase.com/collections/lg-nitro-hd

Nice review!
I usually go for the cheap silicone ones off ebay but the body glove one seems nice.

Anyone know waterproof cases that would fit Nitro?

Anyone know if the lg p930 will get an otter box ? As I was at a bell store and there was a guy who said there was one but I'm yet to find it on the internet or otter box website.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App

There is no otterbox for the Nitro. They have one listed for the Optimus, but it's not ours.

So I bought a ballistic case last night and think I'm going to take it back. The screen protector puts a terrible looking noise over the screen (maybe they all do that, I'm not used to screen protectors) but more annoyingly, the thick plastic bezel comes right up to the top edge of the screen and it makes it hard to pull down the notification shade. I fail at pulling it down about 40% of the time and it's driving me crazy.
Thought I would share.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App

acanaday said:
So I bought a ballistic case last night and think I'm going to take it back. The screen protector puts a terrible looking noise over the screen (maybe they all do that, I'm not used to screen protectors) but more annoyingly, the thick plastic bezel comes right up to the top edge of the screen and it makes it hard to pull down the notification shade. I fail at pulling it down about 40% of the time and it's driving me crazy.
Thought I would share.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is there $50 dollar one, correct?
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App

I'm a fan of slim cases so I got the casemate barely there from newegg. Great fitment, great feel, great quality.

acanaday said:
So I bought a ballistic case last night and think I'm going to take it back. The screen protector puts a terrible looking noise over the screen (maybe they all do that, I'm not used to screen protectors) but more annoyingly, the thick plastic bezel comes right up to the top edge of the screen and it makes it hard to pull down the notification shade. I fail at pulling it down about 40% of the time and it's driving me crazy.
Thought I would share.
Sent from my LG-P930 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That noise is the main reason I returned it. It absolutely killed the phone for me. And no, it doesn't happen for any screen protectors except that one. I can't even tell I'm using a screen protector with my Moshi one, and that isn't even the best one. It's just the easiest to apply and the only one AT&T had for the Nitro. Do yourself a favor and skip getting the Ballistic SG and just go for the Body Glove.

Sorry for the off topic, but what do you guys do to the phone to scratch the gorilla glass? I mean seriously why do you need a screen protector?
Even if you keep your phone in a pocket with change or keys (well, doh, it already NOT smart), gorilla glass supposedly unscratchable by soft metals as keys or coins.

Related

Case Mate Tough Review

Hey Guys,
I managed to pick up a case mate tough in black today.
First impressions, with the case on it makes the phone a much nicer size to hold and the rubber backing on it gives it a very sturdy grip.
Most screen protectors out there which are dry tends to leave a gap around the edges of the phone, with the case mate tough on this fills the gap up while giving it the lay on the table design.
The case also gives easier access to the power and volume buttons, however i am finding it too easy to accidently press as it feels quite sensitive.
There are 2 nicely cut outs for the noise cancelling and microphone, the rest of the cutouts i must say are perfect.
The home button however is slightly difficult to get to, you have to press it more direct from the top rather than from the bottom up, other than that its pretty must perfect and it protects from drops!
I've attached some photos below, feel free to ask any questions though and i will try my best to answer them.
Hope this helps you guys when purchasing a case!
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Nice review! I didn't buy that one, but I was consindering brush aluminum case from case mate.
And, I guess u need this, as well.
Haha thanks! I actually forgot to wipe the screen down! First review so I'll learn to do it next time.
I looked at the case mate aluminium as well; however it doesn't cover the top or bottom completely so that's something to keep in mind.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
blue-bear said:
Haha thanks! I actually forgot to wipe the screen down! First review so I'll learn to do it next time.
I looked at the case mate aluminium as well; however it doesn't cover the top or bottom completely so that's something to keep in mind.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No worries! i was just joking around. I wanted to review some cases, but my device is still coming.. :/
Haha I know mate! Reviews are helpful so I thought I'd give back to the xda community
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Not trying to thread jack, But I figured I'd add my little review to give another view point!
Here is a review of the case-mate tough case. If you owned the tough case for your galaxy S II, you'll love this one. They have made the rubber inside case much thicker around the edges of the phone for added protection. The buttons are extremely easy to press and you can even hear them click in as if there was no rubber covering them at all.
After having the tough-case on for about a year the thin layers of the around the headphone jack and USB port started tearing up. Those areas are much thicker this time around. I can throw this thing around like it's a rock and it has no issues. Great protection and well worth the money. If you plan on buying it from case-mate directly make sure you use the CMPeople20 discount code to get 20% off your order. I cost me $33.50 with expedited shipping. Would have been $27 with the free shipping they are offering right now.
Please PM me if you have any specific questions about the case.
Cheers!
how does the case make the home button hard to press? it doesnt look like its covering touching it
imsuperjp said:
how does the case make the home button hard to press? it doesnt look like its covering touching it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can see it being tough, the home button is pretty close to the bottom of the screen
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using XDA
The home button is quite close to the edge of the case making it slightly difficult to press unless you are direct with the button
Sent from smy GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Looks tough. Mind dropping it a couple of times to see how well it protects your phone?
Speaking of dropping it, i dropped it accidentally today and it survived!
Don't mean to be negative but I got the case today and it feels great except I'll be returning it. Why? Because the top front and bottom front of the case don't have hard plastic holding down the rubber lips, so they get caught and stretch in the pocket when retrieving. This over time may cause the rubber to tear or stretch too much cause it's very elastic and thin.
Whereas the Otterbox Commuter has the plastic sides cover top, bottom and both sides so that no rubber is loose, but held down tight. A much better product from my experience in the past and looking forward to having it when it arrives in the next week or so. This review will cover what I was talking about. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21Dxcyfm3Vg
UPDATE: See my review on both cases here. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=27997216#post27997216
i also ordered a otterbox commuter as well, should be getting it soon
I ordered the ToughCase for my S3 after having it on my vibrant for the past 2yrs. I've dropped that thing on concrete multiple times and various other surfaces and never had an issue. It wasn't until the past month that the outer plastic starting cracking in the corners which was to be expected at this point.
Also, in my experience the rubber doesn't permanently stretch or rip and I've pulled the phone out of my pocket by the rubber piece many times.
I had the tough case for my GS2. It was ok. Good protection but the silicone was mighty flimsy and pulled when I removed the phone from my pocket.
I also felt that the plastic outside needed to be a little tacky. It was hard plastic and had good texture for grip but was a bit too hard and therefore just a little too smooth on the hand. Now where it was smooth (almost slick) in the hand I felt it was also too rough coming out of the pocket as the texture gripped to my clothing a little to well.
I feel my experience with the GS2 case will keep me from buying it for my GS3. They may have changed those problems though.
I loved the body glove case (the Mirage i believe) I had for my GS1. It had alternating stripes of smooth/tacky and textured lines. It slid in and out of the pocket perfectly and had great grip in the hand. Perfect combination IMO.
When you say your buttons are extremely easy to press is that going to be a problem. I had the seidio active case. Are the buttons as easy to press as that case because I don't like buttons that are too easy to press. Also will it slide easily in and out of your pocket??
Nice review! Have u ever used the incipio silicrylic? seems very much comparable to the Case-Mate Tough and I dont know which one to choose.. Heres a link http://www.amazon.com/Incipio-SA-302-Silicrylic-Silicone-Samsung/dp/B0085VAP38/ref=sr_1_2?s=wireless&ie=UTF8&qid=1353870767&sr=1-2&keywords=incipio+s3
i was about to order this case but the back hard plastic had me kinda iffy.. ive had cases that the rubberized coating starts to wear out and fall off. Does the back part have the rubberized coating or is it full rubber
1slow4G said:
i was about to order this case but the back hard plastic had me kinda iffy.. ive had cases that the rubberized coating starts to wear out and fall off. Does the back part have the rubberized coating or is it full rubber
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I second this question, does the polycarbonate back have a rubberized or is it just slick?
Another way to ask, if I lay it on a slanted surface back side down, will it slide right off or have a little grip?
rocket321 said:
I second this question, does the polycarbonate back have a rubberized or is it just slick?
Another way to ask, if I lay it on a slanted surface back side down, will it slide right off or have a little grip?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Little bit of grip I think.
Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

Incipio Silicrylic Review (Blue)

http://www.incipio.com/Samsung-Galaxy-S-III-Cases/Samsung-Galaxy-S-III-Cases.asp
Contents:
1. Phone Case
-Silicone rubber
-Acrylic
2. Screen cleaning clothe
3. Dry screen protector
Where purchased: T-Mobile Store.
Price: $29.99 + TAX
Review: I bought this case to hold out for maybe a Speck, Otterbox or Body Glove. But man I was impressed with the design. It feels very sturdy and tight on the phone, yet it is quite slim and easy to take off the case. With the acrylic, it slides in and out of pockets. But with the rubber on the sides it grips firmly in your hand.
Compared to Speck, like I said it's easy to take out. When I had a Speck candyshell on my HTC One X, I felt like I was going to break the One X anytime I needed to remove the case. This is essential as we have removable batteries and SD cards, so accessing the back is required.
Compared to Otterbox, it's thinner. The depth of this case is .49" measured with calipers.
I highly recommend this case. It looks very nice, feels great, thin and slides in and out of pockets. plus it comes with goodies like the screen protector and cleaning clothe. Along with the acrylic background, I plan on creating a Captain America Shield decal and using the blue area as the center of the decal.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Cons: Top and bottom parts of rubber are a little flimsy. But it makes it easy to hit the home button if you have big thumbs.
If anything goes wrong, I will update the OP.
EDIT: With the plastic backing, it's perfect to put a decal on.
Thanks for the pics...That's the best looking case I've seen so far on Pebble blue. Love how the grey blends with the front.
vw671 said:
Thanks for the pics...That's the best looking case I've seen so far on Pebble blue. Love how the grey blends with the front.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem. The great thing is that they're out now. Should be in best buys, T-Mobile stores, etc.
This blue one might be a T-Mobile exclusive since I could not find it anywhere else.
Do you have any pictures with the case on the actual phone? The pic you posted shows the camera not centered in the cut out, so I'm not sure if that's a real phone in the case or just a piece of cardboard .
NA 521" said:
Do you have any pictures with the case on the actual phone? The pic you posted shows the camera not centered in the cut out, so I'm not sure if that's a real phone in the case or just a piece of cardboard .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's just the cut out, but I posted the site and they have it around the phone. I can't take photos because well.... I'm taking the photos with my phone lol, unless if I do front cam in mirror.
Looks good! I might get Incipio Feather
http://www.incipio.com/Samsung-Gala...-S-III-feather-Ultralight-Hard-Shell-Case.asp
So I went and compared this case with the Speck candy shell one. I'm sticking to Incipio.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
Do you feel the screen is protected from the accidental falls? Thanks
SlimJ87D said:
So I went and compared this case with the Speck candy shell one. I'm sticking to Incipio.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you elaborate? Was there something you disliked about the Candy Shell.
KevTN said:
Do you feel the screen is protected from the accidental falls? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From falls, acrylic is known to break. Speck Candyshell should be much stronger with the plastic material they are using. But it will protect for phone and get the job done. Plus there are some add on bonuses like the screen protector and clothe.
I chose it mainly because it looks the best, slides in and out of my pocket, and feels studry enough for my lifestyle. I work in a cubicle, not construction, trucking, etc.
vw671 said:
Can you elaborate? Was there something you disliked about the Candy Shell.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Candyshell is very VERY hard to get on and off of the phone. Try and watch a video on how it attaches itself, the hard rubber and plastic are almost molded in together where is the incipio are two separate pieces.
So if you ever wanted to get your ext SD card out to transfer files, access your battery for battery pulls if you get a soft brick during flashing, the Speck will make it extremely difficult. I meant extremely. It feels like you are going to break your phone in half to get it off.
Thanks for the review.
I hope someone can do a side by side comparison/review of of the otterbox commuter and this.
After all that i've seen so far, i am down to choosing between the two for my needs.
Can't to seem to find the case with the colour in your photo on the website.. Hmm...
I thought I'd add to this thread since I have used the Incipio Silicrylic Dual Protection case on my new S3 over a busy weekend. After three days of use, these are my impressions:
PROS
Slim styling adds minimal bulk, while the two-piece design adds protection while adding sophisticated styling details
Excellent side-button covers give an accurate tactile feel to the on/off and volume toggle switches on the side of device - I can feel the case itself click with the button!
Smart, well-centered cutouts for all ports, camera lenses, etc. with no exposed plastic edges (all rubber or rubber-lined)
Nice - almost "rubberized" - feel to the plastic outer case with an almost aluminum look - so it feels AND looks sharp
The blue teal color is unique - Incipio doesn't offer it on their website, so it's probably a T-Mo exclusive (I picked mine up in a T-Mo store). And, uncannily, it just happens to be a perfect match for my VAIO EB "Iridescent Blue" notebook PC - not intended but a pleasant surprise that likely no one without an iridescent blue VAIO will likely care about.
CONS
Poor implementation of clear acetate screen protector - first, only one is included. Although the surface of the S3 is only subtly convex, it is enough for the edges of the screen protector to separate and float above the corners of the device. Additionally, the edges of the rubber shell will overlap some of the acetate screen saver, further "nudging" it off the screen.
Extra screen protectors are surprisingly unavailable from Incipio as a separate purchase
Minor point - extra outer or inner shells unavailable, so mixing colors is not an option (I'd think that would be a revenue generator for Incipio since the two-piece stylish design lends itself to some fun mix-and-matches)
CONCLUSION
In all, this is the best case I've had for a smart phone yet. Since the S3 - like the other Samsung S-series smart phones - uses Gorilla Glass, the value of the screen protector is questionable, but my Samsung S (Vibrant) was showing microscratches after 20 months of in-and-out-of-pocket use despite Corning's claims. If anyone has figured out how to use the screen protector, I'd like to know about it. Perhaps a slightly larger screen protector from another manufacturer (a true edge-to-edge) would work better with the Incipio shell.
shiro836 said:
Can't to seem to find the case with the colour in your photo on the website.. Hmm...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's an exclusive to tmobile right now I think.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
KevTN said:
Do you feel the screen is protected from the accidental falls? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. It is thin. I sent mine back because it was so slippery in the hand, I felt I was at a greater chance to drop the device WITH the case on rather than without it. It felt like it was covered in baby powder or talc or something.
yeahmon said:
... it was so slippery in the hand, I felt I was at a greater chance to drop the device WITH the case on rather than without it. It felt like it was covered in baby powder or talc or something.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow - that is definitely not my experience. I have the Silicrylic DualPro but not the DualPro Shine - in case that makes a difference..
Looks a great case
I went and bought this case earlier. i will upload a few pics when the camera is charged. My case isn't as blue as the op's case though but it has the same sku on the back. I think it may be the lighting as mine's more of a teal color. Still a cool color though.
is the rubber part flexible easily on the sides once the hard case is on?
that was a problem with other incipio silicrylic cases. the rubber would move in your pocket cause it was too lose and lint/dust would get trapped between the case and the rubber.
i hope the response is that "it's nice and tight"
im really looking into buying this case.
micromania said:
is the rubber part flexible easily on the sides once the hard case is on?
that was a problem with other incipio silicrylic cases. the rubber would move in your pocket cause it was too lose and lint/dust would get trapped between the case and the rubber.
i hope the response is that "it's nice and tight"
im really looking into buying this case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not sloppy loose but it's not as tight as say the "body glove dimensions" case either. But then again, it's a different material. While the body glove it really tuff, this is really smooth. I like this one better.
Incipio SILICRYLIC in blue exclusively for T-Mobile USA.
The case is very, very nice. The soft material is very comfortable and a joy to grip. The plastic is also a great "soft" feeling material. I've jumped through 4 premium cases so far and this is by far the best one for what I want in a case. The only thing that stopped me from buying this in the 1st place, was the colors available on the Incipio site. The color of this one is more of a metallic teal than the blue that it looks in the pictures. I'd rather have the blue, but the teal is very attractive in person.
The case is $30 at T-Mobile (I snagged it for like $23). I would've payed the $30 though no problem. Cause I feel the case is way better than some that are priced higher.
The main thing about this case - It's easy to take off so I can swap batteries. This is a must for me as I've tried it with the speck case, the body glove dimensions and the case-mate barely there and this is by far the easiest to take off.
When it comes to protection, this is number 1 from the ones I've tried. And that includes the speck candy shell. The reason this beats the speck? Cause you seriously run a risk of cracking the gs3 screen while trying to remove it from the speck. And there should be no reason that a case, can make you risk breaking your phone while trying to do a simple task like removing it.
Some say "use a tool to remove the speck". Nah, I'll pass. If the 10 tools that I use daily for other jobs (fingers), can't remove the case, then the case is a p.o.s.
If the phone falls in this case, it has just as much of a survival rate as that of the candy shell, if not more... I have dropped phones from waist high with a Incipio feather on it and it didn't have a mark on it (gs2). I'm pretty sure that this case can do better. The candy shell, though it has a hard and soft material, is a lot less shock absorbing than this. The reason is the specks "soft material", isn't nearly as soft as this Incipio case. And for that reason alone, I feel there's a risk of less shock absorption with it than this case.. Drop a rock and a sponge and tell me which one does better...
Here's the pics.

[Review] Seidio Surface case

{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Seidio-Sams...ccessories&hash=item564b61dbc4#ht_3764wt_1396
Packaging:
Nothing special, plastic box shipped inside a plastic bagvelope (bag/envelope) The box it comes in is much easier to open from the bottom than the top, learn from my mistake. No fancy packaging here, the case slides around inside the box a bit. Nothing inside the box but the case...no screen protector, no cleaning cloth, no fancy color brochure showing other products the company makes, nothing. In my opinion, $30 is a steep price to pay for a case so to see the case flopping around in it's box and no extras at all included with the case was kind of a let down.
Fit and finish:
When I first grabbed the case out of the box my very first thought was "oh boy, feels kinda slippery." I got the Garnet Red version, planned on getting the limited edition Gloss White when it becomes available...more on that later. The case is lined with a black felt material on the inside part of the back wall to protect the battery cover from getting scratched during installation/removal, might even add a little shock protection as well. Sliding the case on to the phone one thing I noticed is that the front edges do infact put a little pressure on the sides of the face of the phone, this is notable because those of you who have a wet application screen protector or other full face protection like the Moshi iVisor or any one of the curved full face protectors may have a little problem getting this care to play nicely with it. I think a wet application would be fine so long as it's fully cured before you go putting this case on and as long as you are careful when installing it...making sure it's not pulling up the protector as you go. The case slides on and locks in place to itself thanks to a little tab built in on it's inner wall on the back. Getting it off can be tricky, especially if you have an aftermarket, non-stock battery cover on like I found out. I highly advise not using the case with anything other than the stock battery cover. I had my white carbon fiber cover on which seemingly added no extra bulk but apparently the tiny little bit it did add made it next to impossible to remove the case. I ended up using brute strength to get it apart and luckily avoided causing any damage to it or it's locking mechanism. Putting the stock battery cover on made things much easier. Helpful hint, when trying to remove it, press down on the raised part in the back when squeezing the top part of the case on the sides.
With the case installed I noticed that the fit was so snug that there was no daylight at all between the face of the phone and the edge of the case, a good thing. The cutouts are all spot on but the bottom mic opening wasn't quite centered. There are no overlays over the buttons so they are easily accessible and engaged. Those openings are beveled/tapered to allow unobstructed access to the buttons...no need to tactically attempt to press the buttons, you just press them as you would normally as the case does not get in the way. The color I chose, Garnet Red, has a metallic sheen to it and is very easy on the eyes however it lacks grip. Holding the phone, it's not as bulky as I thought it would be, but it's not as easy to hold on to either. The finish is very slippery so make sure you have a firm grip on it. This is the first case I've had on this phone that requires you to stick your pinky out while you're holding the phone to ensure it doesn't slide down. Very disappointed. The design of the case does provide a front side lip, allowing you to set the phone face down with no worry of causing damage to the screen.
Final thought:
While the case looks nice, fits like a glove and allows easy access to all ports and buttons, it is very slippery to hold and can be a problem depending on what type of screen protector you're using. The locking mechanism is a nice touch but be aware if using an aftermarket, non-stock battery cover as it can make the case nearly impossible to remove. Am I going to order the limited edition Gloss White when it comes out? It'll surely have better grip but i'm not that in love with this case to say for sure.
I have the Seidio surface in blue and I do not find the case to be slippery it has a lot more grip than the stock battery door. The finish is a soft touch finish that does not show fingerprints.
Here are some photos and I have a full review up to.
from my AOKP galaxy s3
Grip is not a strong point of this case by any stretch of the imagination. It's coming off as soon as my TPU bumper arrives. The finish on this case is pretty much identical to that on the Incipio Silicrylic Dual Pro, the difference being the silicone sleeve which gives you the good grip. I like everything about this case except for the lack of grip and how it limits what screen protectors you can use with it.
via Galaxy S III
Gadgetz said:
Grip is not a strong point of this case by any stretch of the imagination. It's coming off as soon as my TPU bumper arrives. The finish on this case is pretty much identical to that on the Incipio Silicrylic Dual Pro, the difference being the silicone sleeve which gives you the good grip. I like everything about this case except for the lack of grip and how it limits what screen protectors you can use with it.
via Galaxy S III
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You've amassed quite the S3 case collection. Post a pic of it later.
zmore said:
You've amassed quite the S3 case collection. Post a pic of it later.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just trying to find "the one". The SGP Neo Hybrid is on my radar. Not really sure there's any others I really want to try out right now.
I have the platinum series which is pretty much this case with the holster. I have had it for my past three phones but am on the by bubble with this one. I have to agree that this case is more slippery then I remember my past cases to be. Because of that (and the fact that I dropped my OG Evo with his case on and the Efren shattered ) I am looking for another case. Thinking of getting an otterbox. Need something with good screen protection and a holster.
Does nfc work?
elosogrande7076 said:
I have the platinum series which is pretty much this case with the holster. I have had it for my past three phones but am on the bubble with this one. I have to agree that this case is more slippery then I remember my past cases to be. Because of that (and the fact that I dropped my OG Evo with his case on and the Efren shattered ) I am looking for another case. Thinking of getting an otterbox. Need something with good screen protection and a holster.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was pretty disappointed with how slippery this thing is but i'm leaving it on until my TPU bumper and igadgitz clear tpu case show up...only other case I could see myself buying after this is the SGP Neo Hybrid.
GNja said:
Does nfc work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes sir
Alright guys, today was my first day out in the wild with this case and I have discovered something......moist hands = good grip with this case! Normally my hands are dry, no sweaty palms for me....but its pretty warm out today and I wear nitrile gloves alot during the day which cause my hands to sweat badly. So after removing my gloves and patting them dry I picked up my phone to take a few pics and I noticed it wasnt sliding in my hand. Figuring it was the moist hand I was holding it with I turned on the AC to dry my hand completely and sure enough, the slipperyness was back.
So those of you with sweaty palms, this is your case!
via Galaxy S III

[REVIEW] Incipio Feather SHINE Case

My Incipio Feather SHINE case came in and I've been using it for a couple of days and decided to write up a full review. Let me know if you have any questions about it.
First thing is first, if the case doesn’t at least match the beauty and aesthetics of the device its protecting, you won’t get my approval. Thankfully for the Incipio Feather SHINE it is a minimalistic case with a sophisticated finish which certainly accentuates the HTC One’s design cues.
The shell case features an extremely thin and light profile with a brushed aluminum reflective finish on the back. The sides are transparent to show off the machined polymer on the HTC One and the cut outs fit perfectly around the camera, rear microphone and volume rocker. Small groves are in place for comfortable use of the 3.5mm headphone jack as well as the power button which doubles as an IR blaster.
There is a tiny lip which I would barely consider a lay on the table design but it may be enough for you if you plan on always laying your phone face down on a smooth flat surface, otherwise you better consider getting a screen protector. Overall the design of the Incipio Feather SHINE case is clean, fresh and form fitting. The brushed aluminum finish on the back provides a premium look and feel and enough of the phone remains covered while still showing off the magnificent design of the HTC One.
The build quality of the case is exactly what we’ve come to expect from such a recognized brand and Incipio certainly pays attention to detail when delivering products that shouldn’t just look good but offer protection from any unfortunate damage. As previously mentioned, the cut outs are done very well and no rigid plastic is left poking out that may damage your device. Every surface is sleek, smooth and wraps around your HTC One like a glove.
The Feather line won’t offer the best drop protection as it boasts a thickness of just 1.27 mm but its more than enough for protecting the phone from scratches on its aluminum frame. It is composed of sleek polycarbonate material which tends to attract some pretty nasty fingerprints on the finish that aren’t the easiest to wipe off so make sure to keep a microfiber cloth handy.
At a measly half ounce the case itself holds true to its Feather name and is by far one of the easiest to slip in and out of your pocket as well.
Its hard not to like the Incipio Feather SHINE if you’re in the market for a slim style case. It feels great in the hand and clings tight to your HTC One so there’s no danger of it popping out. The brushed aluminum finish gives off a modern and sophisticated feel which is great if you’re needing to protect your new investment while wanting to display a premium look. The case is available for $29.99 direct from Incipio’s website or you can find great deals on Amazon which is where I purchased mine from.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
this case look good but it doesn't cover top and bottom of phone
True but it shows off the build quality so it's not necessarily a negative depending on how you look at it.
I ordered this yesterday. One of the best looking cases with low protection. When I need more protection, I use Incipio Dualpro -series.
Only drawback was high Ups cost. Normal was 7.9$ and express 17.9$.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using XDA Premium HD app
Ouch! I got free shipping through Amazon for bundling it with a Spigen screen protector, they delivered it in 4 days.
I'm using the one with the soft finish instead of aluminum. It's pretty impressive and the feel is quite nice. Perfect fit too.
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
To be honest I intended to order the soft touch version but made a mistake. When I got the SHINE in the mail I was so impressed that I didn't bother sending it back lol
Just a heads up, I'll be dropping reviews of the rest of Incipios line up for the HTC One soon and will post links on this thread as well.
I have this case and its really nice however the silver paint on the back is already starting to peel and scratch off. Have only had it and the phone for about a week now so a little disappointed with it overall. I have not dropped it at all so I guess the scratches are just from dirt on a desk or table. I guess it is better than scratches in the phone though.
Sent from my Nexus 10 using XDA Premium HD app
ebratter said:
I have this case and its really nice however the silver paint on the back is already starting to peel and scratch off. Have only had it and the phone for about a week now so a little disappointed with it overall. I have not dropped it at all so I guess the scratches are just from dirt on a desk or table. I guess it is better than scratches in the phone though.
Sent from my Nexus 10 using XDA Premium HD app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is what I was worried about, so I opted for the soft finish version instead.
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
It is a gorgeous case, but I have also had a problem with the finish coming off. I received mine from Amazon yesterday afternoon and it's already on it's way to Incipio for a warranty replacement
Hopefully the next one will hold up better. If not, I'll just have to go for the soft touch. The feather is a great fit, and definately matches the phone in it's good looks.
SouthernGal said:
It is a gorgeous case, but I have also had a problem with the finish coming off. I received mine from Amazon yesterday afternoon and it's already on it's way to Incipio for a warranty replacement
Hopefully the next one will hold up better. If not, I'll just have to go for the soft touch. The feather is a great fit, and definately matches the phone in it's good looks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How well is your replacement holding up? Was the first one you got just a bad batch?
ChrisM0678 said:
How well is your replacement holding up? Was the first one you got just a bad batch?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just received the replacement Friday, and there is already a small chip in the aluminum finish. I do love this case, but I just don't see a way to avoid the chipping. Even as careful as I am about setting it down, what I set it down on, and easily placing it in my purse or back pocket. If it looks horrible in a few weeks I will go with the soft finish case. Incipio is a great company and gave me absolutely no problem exchanging the case.
TaiTrang said:
this case look good but it doesn't cover top and bottom of phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
from the mega info thread:
http://images.anandtech.com/doci/6747/Screen Shot 2013-03-07 at 9.31.13 PM.png
http://www.anandtech.com/show/6747/htc-one-review
I'm thinking that the open top and bottom is best for transmission and reception.
That's crazy, who would of thought...
I ordered my incipio feather shine. . If I get the peeling chipping effect ill have it replaced with a softtouch one. Incipio has an excellent warranty.
I wish there was a case like the feather that had a low profile kickstand
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
clninja said:
I ordered my incipio feather shine. . If I get the peeling chipping effect ill have it replaced with a softtouch one. Incipio has an excellent warranty.
I wish there was a case like the feather that had a low profile kickstand
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I ordered mine a few months ago at launch. Came in the mail from amazon and looked awful out of the gate. Peeling, chipping, the finish feels cheap and your fingers/keys will dig into right away.
HOWEVER.
Rather than return it I simply peeled all of the gray finish off. Wow does this case look way better. It actually has a metal/aluminum look that makes it seem way way nicer than it ever did.
Did they ever notch out the charger port area on this case. I had one at launch, but there is no cutout like there is on the regular feather case for the charger. Forcing it to go in at an angle, and will likely lead to breakage, or very loose fitting cables in no time.
I sent it back and went with the regular feather instead. I prefer the feel of the regular one much more, and its about half as thick.

Best cases I've found (without battery button cutouts!)

I've been on the hunt for a decent case for this phone since I got it on its release date and it's been greuling. It's almost as if this phone doesn't exist, in the Americas anyway, a lot of cases I've come across are nameless and generic, worst of all, poorly designed with a big theme being the inclusion of the battery door button cutout.
Here's a few companies and cases I've found to be actually designing a case for this phone:
VRS Design, some simple designs that work, nothing too fancy but that's just what some of us want:
https://vrsdesign.com/collections/lg-v20
Noreve, these are some impressive wallet style cases and the quality seems unprecedented, great for a gift or for those of us who want a nice leather flip case, definitely not within most budgets with certain customization options but worth keeping in mind:
http://www.noreve.com/en/1303-v20
J&D Slim Case, a simple case from Amazon for cheap, does the job but features the aforementioned battery button cutout and a less precise design than the rest on this list, I found it to be the more acceptable of the budget cases I've come across because of its simple design, small form factor, and the 4 color options:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01KNQ4SH6/ref=cm_sw_r_other_apa_ONQGybGDMFMHS
Seidio, skeptical at first but glad this is a case I bought, a random brand that popped up in my search a few times. They seem to have one of the few 2 layer cases that don't have a battery button cut out and that also doesn't add much heft to the phone, all with adding a kickstand as well. Another great thing I love about the case is that it's inner layer can function as a standalone super slim rubber case, the fit is perfect and there are no quality issues as far as the precision and design is concerned (will post pics eventually):
https://www.seidioonline.com/product/lg-v20-surface-case/
Incipio, a popular brand making decent cases for more than just Samsung and Apple phones? WHAT?! I was surprised to see the selection Incipio has for the V20 and they look very promising. Starting from $20 you can get a case that fits well, looks nice, is from a trustworthy brand and best of all, doesn't have a battery button cutout! I took a liking to the Dualpro, NGP, and Octane models, they seem to provide good protection without adding a ton of bulk and offer some options for color:
https://www.incipio.com/cases/smart...lg-v20-cases/incipio-dualpro-lg-v20-case.html
https://www.incipio.com/cases/smart...0-cases/incipio-ngp-advanced-lg-v20-case.html
https://www.incipio.com/cases/smart.../lg-v20-cases/incipio-octane-lg-v20-case.html
I hope this helps some people out there hunting for cases, I was sure in need of this research and thought I'd share.
these are some cool cases. Thanks.
I have the High Pro Shield VRS (also had it on Note 7). Fit and feel is perfect,however.... The kickstand pivot seems to be positioned a hair too low. The phone tends to wanna fall over at the slightest bump. The Note 7 didn't suffer from this (same model case). Its like the center of gravity is a lil higher, still a great case and is not a deal breaker.
Oh hey, I've wanted Incipio to make cases for this phone. It's my lucky day. Now to convince myself 19.99 is worth it...
Have you actually tried them all? If not which one did you end up going with? I may go with the Incipio for $19.99. It's definitely worth it because I don't have phone protection. You think I'd learn my lesson after dropping a Nexus 6P and cracking the screen. Nope. I'll try to be careful.
UAG
It's a bit bulky and the cam is recessed (good).
However, when you insert the case, make sure the button (left) side inserted first.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Slickwrap and under a poetic atmosphere case....I see no other case/skin setup I rather have. Feels good and I love the way it looks (get compliments all the time on it). Not the best picture (looks better in person)
Spigen Rugged Armor black is very nice, thin, fits prefectly, improves grip and audio jack cutout is large enough to use Professional Headphoes such as DT990 or HD500 and such... and it also is very very light
axaman943 said:
Spigen Rugged Armor black is very nice, thin, fits prefectly, improves grip and audio jack cutout is large enough to use Professional Headphoes such as DT990 or HD500 and such... and it also is very very light
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly the problem I have with the Obliq. Nice case but the Sennheiser hd650 cable struggles to make the fit.
Sent from my LG-H918 using Tapatalk
axaman943 said:
Spigen Rugged Armor black is very nice, thin, fits prefectly, improves grip and audio jack cutout is large enough to use Professional Headphoes such as DT990 or HD500 and such... and it also is very very light
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
By far my favorite case so far. I have 3 other cases and I haven't used any of them since I picked up the Spigen. Can't say enough good things about it.
mingkee said:
UAG
It's a bit bulky and the cam is recessed (good).
However, when you insert the case, make sure the button (left) side inserted first.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
2nded.
My big thing has been keeping screen recessed since my Evo 4g took a 2 ft fall getting out of a car & hit perfectly on a rock to shatter the screen.
I always used OtterBox defender after that. But phones kept getting larger. When I got Note 7, tried UAG and loved it when I switched to V20 got UAG again. Much less bulk, but feels just as safe. Phone has dropped multiple times with zero issues.
I bought this one in navy for 11$ on Ebay sale. Gorgeous looks with solid quality, great feel in hand (not slippery at all), not bulky and totally protected with Spigen tgsp! #stronglyrecommend https://www.incipio.com/cases/smartphone-cases/lg-smartphone-cases/lg-v20-cases/incipio-ngp-advanced-lg-v20-case.html
How good are the Ghostek cases? They look pretty cool.
https://www.amazon.com/Ghostek-Premium-Protective-Explosion-Proof-Protector/dp/B01N52ENP5/
But mostly i'll be going for the UAG case. Sucks that its not available here in India. Have to wait for someone to drop by from the USA
Currently rocking this one , the only case minimal enough with a good grip and a very classy back
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01LZ7W06J/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1
i found the poetic revolution to be the best case . My phone has fell so much in the street and also i accidentally threw it to a wall. LOL everything looking good so far. I have had it since november. It has flaps for dust proofing and whole for every mic and the IR . It has a screen protector that if it gets scratched or you dont like it, well, you can always remove it and use your temper glass.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/For-LG-V20-...hash=item1c734fc168:m:mPdtEZsVXyX2QYszMOeYMbw
jinkerz9430 said:
i found the poetic revolution to be the best case . My phone has fell so much in the street and also i accidentally threw it to a wall. LOL everything looking good so far. I have had it since november. It has flaps for dust proofing and whole for every mic and the IR . It has a screen protector that if it gets scratched or you dont like it, well, you can always remove it and use your temper glass.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/For-LG-V20-...hash=item1c734fc168:m:mPdtEZsVXyX2QYszMOeYMbw
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How well does it slide in and out of your pocket? My biggest beef is when a case is too "rubbery" and gets hung up.
Also how is the built in screen protector? I've been thru a ton of glass protectors now, none seem to suit me.
bond32 said:
How well does it slide in and out of your pocket? My biggest beef is when a case is too "rubbery" and gets hung up.
Also how is the built in screen protector? I've been thru a ton of glass protectors now, none seem to suit me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It slides very nice in and out of pocket. Lol
The built om screen protector is quite good. I didnt remove the one that came with the and yet it adhered very well to it. Up until now it has just one small scratch on it.
Over the time, the cover start getting some external sign of use that looks like sctatch but is more caused by all the time thr phone has felt on the street and other places. Lol nevertheless it still feels as if thr cover were brand new.
The only downside is that if you put it in a diagonal surface, it will slide easily. Unless you put it upside down
Picked up the Poetic Revolution case but removed the screen protector. In hindsight, that might not have been the best idea because of the double-sided take they use on the top and bottom of the front piece that holds the protector.
Let's just say I'm almost worried about removing the front now as I can see the adhesive trying to stick to the phone. ....... (Wait, Devhux! You mean to say you didn't think of that BEFORE putting on the front piece????? Hahahahaha!)
Sent from my LG-H990 using Tapatalk
Been using Ringke Onyx, it is well made although a bit slippery. Good price as well.
I bought this as I needed one in a hurry. Works great though
Caseology Parallex
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B01N4MB2VY/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Nice texture. Just enough grip

Categories

Resources