[REVIEW] Case-Mate Barely There Brushed Aluminum (Signal, GPS Strength, & 4G Tested!)
Here is my review of the highly anticipated Case-Mate Barely There Brushed Aluminum Case.
[UPDATED 10/30 - Added 4G Signal Testing]
[UPDATED 10/31 - Added More 4G Experiences]
Build Quality: The Case's Build quality is excellent. The brushed aluminum has a very nice look and feel, and looks completely real. The edges of the aluminum have a nice cut to them. The rest of the case, made of plastic, is extremely sturdy and strong plastic. The case does not flex more than it should (and doesnt flex at all on the phone). It fits on the phone perfectly and goes on easily.
Protection:It protects the back and both long sides. The top and bottom sides are protected on the back edge, but not so much the front (see pictures to understand). Though if it was dropped on a flat surface from a vertical angle, it would hit the sides of the case that it does protect, and not hurt the middle. The case also "overlaps" the camera, protecting it from scratches when the phone is put down. Taking the case off is a bit trickier, but not too difficult compared to a snap on case. It is most easily taken off by pushing the phone out of the case through the camera hole.
Feel: As the name says, it is supposed to feel Barely There. And for the most part, it's true. The case is pretty thin and light. Though it is thicker than a plastic snap-on case. The phone feels a little thicker, but not very much, adds less bulk than any other case I have used. It keeps the nice looking shape of the phone, that many other cases hide (mostly snap-ons because they cover around the top edge) and this one does not! Though it does make the phone look just a tad wider, which i dont mind at all
The case is somewhat slippery not being rubberized in any way, the aluminum is (understandably) slippery/smooth, but the plastic sides offer a little more grip.
Pictures: Click for Full Size! (If you would like any specifics or comparisons to other phones, just ask!)
Signal Testing
---------------------------
Conclusion: NO DIFFERENCE with case on or off
I have nearly perfect signal in my house. With the case on or off, not touching the phone i get -76db (4/4 Bars) Death Gripping the phone i get -96db (2/4 Bars) with the case on or off. So there is absolutely NO difference!
4G Testing
---------------------------
I am unable to test 4G myself since it is unavailable in my area. Here are quotes from another members about it.
Mixed Experiences - 2/3 people have 4G issues.
banksmi09 said:
[...] This case kills my 4g. As soon as I put the case on, the 4g disconnects and won't connect until I take the case off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
tmacgarris6727 said:
My case kills 4g also
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1lazysheep said:
i'm in san antonio and have no 4G issues with the case installed. i just got my phone last week and once couldn't connect to the network. i rebooted the phone and everything was fine again. i attribute that to the LOS problem people have been reporting.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
GPS Signal Testing
---------------------------
Unfortunetly, Even though cell phone signal is unaffected, GPS signal IS affected by the case.
I compared it also with my old snap-on plastic case. It seems any case affects the GPS signal a bit, but this one a little more than the plastic for signal strength (although sometimes a more accurate lock)
Times to get a lock were the same all around.
Tests: All taken INSIDE.
SIDE NOTE: Obviously, these tests move around alot, and are not static results. Here is what I saw and my own take on it...
Barely There Case: Absolutely see a decrease in strength and accuracy. But not to the point that makes it unusable. strength went up when phone put perpendicular to floor (hard to show in screenshots, but I am sure of it) Keep in mind these tests were also inside.
Plastic Case: Also Affected GPS Signal, did not hurt signal strength as much as Barely There case though. (in some shots the accuracy is shown lower despite higher strength, which I'm not sure why, may be a margin of error.)
No Case: Parallel to Floor...............No Case: Perpendicular To Floor
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
...
Barely There Case: Parallel to Floor..........Barely There Case: Perpendicular to Floor
............
Plastic Snap-On Case: Parallel To Floor......Plastic Case: Perpendicular to Floor
.................
Feel free to ask any questions
I got mine too, was gonna post pictures but you've got plenty of them.
Initial impressions:
It looks nice, but I have a feeling the black version might look nicer (I ordered the black version! But they shipped me the silver one. Emailed their customer service asking about it..)
Compared to my TPU Matte Back Black, the side lips definitely offer less protection, though they are still raised above the level of the screen, just to a lesser extent.
Top and bottom lips are exposed and not very well protected. There are angles at which you could drop your phone and it would definitely get scratched up on top and bottom.
Cutouts are well done, volume rocker is a lot easier to use compared to the TPU case.
It's heavier, but not too bad.. makes the phone feel very solid.
The aluminium and chrome accents are awesome and look sexy.
Camera is very nicely protected with a deep cutout.
The silver clashes with the color of the phone in my opinion.. I hope they send me the right color as I didn't really want silver.
It's slippery but the plastic sides are decently grippy in the hand. Make no mistake though, the phone will slide over anything in this case.
Overall, I'm a little disappointed in the level of protection this case offers. The side, bottom, and top lips all feel too exposed. The TPU case has more protection for less money, but the Barely There definitely has more style and solid feeling to it. Really wish the case went all the way around the top and bottom.. but I'm gonna stick with it and see if it grows on me.
^ Thanks for adding
I agree about the protection on the top and bottom, it would be nice if it went all around, but then it wouldnt be able to bend to put it on/take it off.
Pheno.menon said:
[*]Compared to my TPU Matte Back Black, the side lips definitely offer less protection, though they are still raised above the level of the screen, just to a lesser extent.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How would you compare the thickness to the TPU case?
I have the TPU and love it because it adds almost no bulk to the phone.
spridell said:
How would you compare the thickness to the TPU case?
I have the TPU and love it because it adds almost no bulk to the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not much difference, to be honest. The case really is barely there..
It's a tiny bit wider and heavier, but nothing you would pause to stop and think about. The phone feels very solid with the Case-Mate.
thanks for the review and pics.
i wonder if the decrease in GPS strength would be less if the phone was outside?
hi guys where did you get this case it looks nice
Everyone's results will be a little different, but my GPS test results were identical with the case on and off, both inside and outside.
Just found this...http://www.ebay.com/itm/Case-mate-B...ccessories&hash=item1e67c75072#ht_1678wt_1141 How much did everyone else pay for their case?
coldblooded79 said:
Just found this...http://www.ebay.com/itm/Case-mate-B...ccessories&hash=item1e67c75072#ht_1678wt_1141 How much did everyone else pay for their case?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same price and seller.
This is their regular site though: http://www.mobilecityonline.com/wireless/store/productdetail.asp?productid=28553
Pheno.menon said:
Not much difference, to be honest. The case really is barely there..
It's a tiny bit wider and heavier, but nothing you would pause to stop and think about. The phone feels very solid with the Case-Mate.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the response and the pics
I got mine today and I like the case. I think the TPU had a better feel and slightly less bulk, but I have to say the CaseMate looks much better. I think either one is quite adequate.
My pix for comparison...
Hey, could you possible do a video review of the case? Like, zoom in on it, the flex, tap it to see what noise it makes, etc? I know it's asking a lot lol, but I would appreciate it.
---------- Post added at 09:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:04 PM ----------
mrpickem said:
I got mine today and I like the case. I think the TPU had a better feel and slightly less bulk, but I have to say the CaseMate looks much better. I think either one is quite adequate.
My pix for comparison...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That looks like ICS....is it?
galaxytabevo said:
That looks like ICS....is it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No lol, that's Go Launcher.
ahl395 said:
Signal Testing
---------------------------
Conclusion: NO DIFFERENCE with case on or off
I have nearly perfect signal in my house. With the case on or off, not touching the phone i get -76db (4/4 Bars) Death Gripping the phone i get -96db (2/4 Bars) with the case on or off. So there is absolutely NO difference!
GPS Signal Testing
---------------------------
Unfortunetly, Even though cell phone signal is unaffected, GPS signal IS affected by the case.
I compared it also with my old snap-on plastic case. It seems any case affects the GPS signal a bit, but this one a little more than the plastic for signal strength (although sometimes a more accurate lock)
Times to get a lock were the same all around.
Tests: All taken INSIDE.
SIDE NOTE: Obviously, these tests move around alot, and are not static results. Here is what I saw and my own take on it...
Barely There Case: Absolutely see a decrease in strength and accuracy. But not to the point that makes it unusable. strength went up when phone put perpendicular to floor (hard to show in screenshots, but I am sure of it) Keep in mind these tests were also inside.
Plastic Case: Also Affected GPS Signal, did not hurt signal strength as much as Barely There case though. (in some shots the accuracy is shown lower despite higher strength, which I'm not sure why, may be a margin of error.)
No Case: Parallel to Floor...............No Case: Perpendicular To Floor
...
Barely There Case: Parallel to Floor..........Barely There Case: Perpendicular to Floor
............
Plastic Snap-On Case: Parallel To Floor......Plastic Case: Perpendicular to Floor
.................
Feel free to ask any questions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have this case, albeit for the AT&T Galaxy S2 and am curious about what app you used to test the GPS strength? Even though your results does indeed show loss of accuracy, for the purposes that we all use GPS for, does it really matter?
I agree with most people's take on this case...it best feature has to be its looks! I
The Brushed Aluminum Barely There is a great product - what do you guys say to Black, White and Pink?
If you would like, we can setup something with XDA members and a group buy?
Why isnt this product on the official case mate site under E4GT?
Soxtron said:
The Brushed Aluminum Barely There is a great product - what do you guys say to Black, White and Pink?
If you would like, we can setup something with XDA members and a group buy?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Perhaps I am mistaken, but the Aluminum is only available in black, red, and silver???
Is the black available yet or only still shipping the grey?
tboooe said:
I have this case, albeit for the AT&T Galaxy S2 and am curious about what app you used to test the GPS strength? Even though your results does indeed show loss of accuracy, for the purposes that we all use GPS for, does it really matter?
I agree with most people's take on this case...it best feature has to be its looks! I
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
GPS Test
boolboo said:
Why isnt this product on the official case mate site under E4GT?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I believe its not officially released yet.
spridell said:
Is the black available yet or only still shipping the grey?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only grey. MobileCityOnline sent me the following emails:
Code:
Thank you for your email. We apologize for you receiving the wrong colored case in error. At this time the color description of the case was advertised incorrectly and we do not have this case available in the color black. We do have a couple of options; If you like we can honor free shipping on the order you received or email you a prepaid return mailer to send the product back and once received provide a full refund on the account. Let us know what will work out best and we apologize for any inconvenience in this matter. Let me know if you have any other questions or concerns.
I asked: "Will you be getting the black color in stock at any time in the future? Or not at all?"
Reply:
Code:
Thank you for your email. It looks like we will only be carrying the silver color at this time. Let me know if you have any other questions.
Related
Hopefully this information would be helpful for anyone who's in search for perfect case.
Yesterday I bought this case for about 20 $.
http://www.mobili.lt/lt/aksesuarai/samsung/811263.html
It seems that the case is almost perfect for me. I was searching for very slim profile case, but with the protection for the whole bezel. Previously I had been using Seidio Surface, but it's still too bulky compared to Samsung's.
The good about Samsung Protective Cover+:
- Very slim profile
- Looks like phone without the case
- Plastic on back, TPU on sides
- Same plastic as original Samsung backplate
- Fits perfectly with 3D curved screen protectors (I use Realook 3D curved film)
The bad:
- Gets greasy very easily
- Attracts dust very easily
Here some pictures (had been taking with my SGS1):
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
(I have ruined left corner of SP when I was applying it)
zmagas1 said:
Hopefully this information would be helpful for anyone who's in search for perfect case.
Yesterday I bought this case for about 20 $.
http://www.mobili.lt/lt/aksesuarai/samsung/811263.html
It seems that the case is almost perfect for me. I was searching for very slim profile case, but with the protection for the whole bezel. Previously I had been using Seidio Surface, but it's still too bulky compared to Samsung's.
The good about Samsung Protective Cover+:
- Very slim profile
- Looks like phone without the case
- Plastic on back, TPU on sides
- Same plastic as original Samsung backplate
- Fits perfectly with 3D curved screen protectors (I use Realook 3D curved film)
The bad:
- Gets greasy very easily
- Attracts dust very easily
Here some pictures (had been taking with my SGS1):
(I have ruined left corner of SP when I was applying it)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
im assuming this cannot fit the oem samsung extended battery?
I wish I could find this in America.
Natureboy72 said:
I wish I could find this in America.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Found it here but not worth the $23 worth of shipping to the us
http://www.spendwisor.com/samsung_galaxy_s3_protective_back_cover_black-p-9281.html
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Natureboy72 said:
I wish I could find this in America.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's sold on Amazon, but currently out of stock.
Yup I'll be monitoring this one. I definitely want it!
Here's a link for the white one:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009UQ2TZ4?ie=UTF8&force-full-site=1&ref_=aw_bottom_links
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Hello there. Thanks for your review. Been thinking about changing my case from the acase supperlegera pro to this one. Do you think it will give me similar protection? This one is much more good looking
Badelhas said:
Hello there. Thanks for your review. Been thinking about changing my case from the acase supperlegera pro to this one. Do you think it will give me similar protection? This one is much more good looking
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey, as I seen on pictures, Acase gives good protection as it is dual layer case.
This original Samsung cover+ visualy could be compared to UAG case (except that military pattern on back). It's back are very hard plastic, corners made from hard tpu material. Overall I think it should provide good protection.
My only concern is the screen, but for this I ordered Glasszone tempered glass screen protector.
Hopefully this would be my last money spend on my S3
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
I own a brown S3 and it was difficult to find the cover in that colour (impossible in Belgium) actualy found on Amazon UK.
Good cover but no protection on the sides, not cheap but samsung quality and it fit without any problem with my Oso dashmount.
Found nothing better if you like to protect the screen and not bulky.
blokart said:
Good cover but no protection on the sides, not cheap but samsung quality and it fit without any problem with my Oso dashmount.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It actally has a hard TPU matetial that is covering phone's corners and sides.
Sent from my GT-P7300 using xda premium
The White is back in stock at the Samsung Accessories US site.
Remember to create a Samsung account and register your device and they will send you a 50% off coupon.
$14.99 plus $3.95 shipping after coupon.
or
Anything over $49.99 has free shipping.
I placed an order last week and it came in 4 days from UPS. It was over the $49.99
ricktat said:
The White is back in stock at the Samsung Accessories US site.
Remember to create a Samsung account and register your device and they will send you a 50% off coupon.
$14.99 plus $3.95 shipping after coupon.
or
Anything over $49.99 has free shipping.
I placed an order last week and it came in 4 days from UPS. It was over the $49.99
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the heads up, just ordered one!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Guys, please give us your feedback on the case when it gets there.
Anybody ordered the new samsung original protective Cover plus in dark blue? Does the color really match the pebble blue phone?
Just received my white one, and aesthetically speaking, this is the best case available for the white GS3. It is very striking. I'll do a very brief, early review for now:
The case is a combination of hard plastic for the white back and matted TPU for the gray sides. What's hard to see from the pictures is the texturized plastic on the back. This gives it more grippiness and makes it less likely to slip from your hands. The matted TPU on the sides is the slippiest part of the case, which holds minor concern. My old diztronic had glossy, easily gripped sides with a slippery matte back, almost the direct opposite of this official Samsung cover. In time I'll be able to determine which company had the right idea.
This case is absolutely beautiful and stays true to the design of the GS3. If someone saw me using this, they might think I'm not using a case at all. It is very low profile but still provides ample protection. The lip of the case does protrude on the front, making it safe to set screen-down on surfaces. The lip protrusion differs per side; it seems to protrude more on the top and bottom than it does on the left/right sides. It is important to note that the protrusion on the left/right sides does seem rather shallow, but this lends to the case's low profile. This case stretches ever-so-slightly near the power button and volume rocker, barely exposing the shiny trim on the phone where its not otherwise present. This isn't a huge issue, but may be for some perfectionists.
One major area of concern is the power button. It is extremely easy to activate with this case on and I would not be surprised if it activated in my pocket. Even pressing in the lip part of the case near the power button will trigger it. However, I feel this problem isn't as bad as a stiff/hard to press power button. I suspect after minor modification the button can perform as expected.
There are too many good things about this case for me not to be recommending it. I have been searching for a case to go with my white GS3 ever since it came out and I now feel that search is over. After some time of using it I'll update my review or start a new thread. I'll post some pictures here in a bit.
Pros:
- Best looking case I've seen for a white GS3
- Offers good protection around the entire device along with a front lip
- Texturized back makes it easier to grip
Cons:
- Power button is too easily activated
- Front lip may be to shallow for some
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Div033 said:
Just received my white one, and aesthetically speaking, this is the best case available for the white GS3. It is very striking. I'll do a very brief, early review for now:
The case is a combination of hard plastic for the white back and matted TPU for the gray sides. What's hard to see from the pictures is the texturized plastic on the back. This gives it more grippiness and makes it less likely to slip from your hands. The matted TPU on the sides is the slippiest part of the case, which holds minor concern. My old diztronic had glossy, easily gripped sides with a slippery matte back, almost the direct opposite of this official Samsung cover. In time I'll be able to determine which company had the right idea.
This case is absolutely beautiful and stays true to the design of the GS3. If someone saw me using this, they might think I'm not using a case at all. It is very low profile but still provides ample protection. The lip of the case does protrude on the front, making it safe to set screen-down on surfaces. The lip protrusion differs per side; it seems to protrude more on the top and bottom than it does on the left/right sides. It is important to note that the protrusion on the left/right sides does seem rather shallow, but this lends to the case's low profile. This case stretches ever-so-slightly near the power button and volume rocker, barely exposing the shiny trim on the phone where its not otherwise present. This isn't a huge issue, but may be for some perfectionists.
One major area of concern is the power button. It is extremely easy to activate with this case on and I would not be surprised if it activated in my pocket. Even pressing in the lip part of the case near the power button will trigger it. However, I feel this problem isn't as bad as a stiff/hard to press power button. I suspect after minor modification the button can perform as expected.
There are too many good things about this case for me not to be recommending it. I have been searching for a case to go with my white GS3 ever since it came out and I now feel that search is over. After some time of using it I'll update my review or start a new thread. I'll post some pictures here in a bit.
Pros:
- Best looking case I've seen for a white GS3
- Offers good protection around the entire device along with a front lip
- Texturized back makes it easier to grip
Cons:
- Power button is too easily activated
- Front lip may be to shallow for some
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the also detailed review. I just ordered the dark blue one, I hope it matches the pebble blue phone. I have a black acase supperlegera pro case, with dual layer, and while providing much protection, it doesn't look to match the phone.
Can you please post some pictures?
Badelhas said:
Thanks for the also detailed review. I just ordered the dark blue one, I hope it matches the pebble blue phone. I have a black acase supperlegera pro case, with dual layer, and while providing much protection, it doesn't look to match the phone.
Can you please post some pictures?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got mine today also. Same comments as above.
If you like a TPU case then you will really like this. I have plenty of thick cases and wanted a thin one that looked great. It's defintely a case that will help scratches and not drops. All thin cases are the same in this area. This one just looks the best.
ricktat said:
I got mine today also. Same comments as above.
If you like a TPU case then you will really like this. I have plenty of thick cases and wanted a thin one that looked great. It's defintely a case that will help scratches and not drops. All thin cases are the same in this area. This one just looks the best.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I used a TPU case for quite some time and I felt it helped immensely when dropped. I even casually tossed my device onto concrete to show my friend that a TPU case is plenty for drop protection.
I feel like this case integrates better with the device but has slightly less impact absorption and drop protection. Its a trade-off for sure, but I find this is the best balance between protection and aesthetics. Samsung also makes an ultra thin case which is what I like to call a 'condom-case' which will only protect against scratches without any impact absorption. This case does offer substantially more drop protection than those, but still slightly less than a diztronic TPU case.
Also, I suck at taking pictures. I'm still trying to get some good shots to upload!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Div033 said:
I used a TPU case for quite some time and I felt it helped immensely when dropped. I even casually tossed my device onto concrete to show my friend that a TPU case is plenty for drop protection.
I feel like this case integrates better with the device but has slightly less impact absorption and drop protection. Its a trade-off for sure, but I find this is the best balance between protection and aesthetics. Samsung also makes an ultra thin case which is what I like to call a 'condom-case' which will only protect against scratches without any impact absorption. This case does offer substantially more drop protection than those, but still slightly less than a diztronic TPU case.
Also, I suck at taking pictures. I'm still trying to get some good shots to upload!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have 4 "condom cases" (great name and accurate, BTW) and they do offer a tad bit of impact protection. I've got out of my car multiple times forgetting my phone on my lap. It bounces off a black top driveway. Also dropped it from about 5 feet high onto concrete. Scratches the hell out of the case (looks like a dog chew toy) but phone is perfect.
I'm buying this in white been eyeing it for awhile. Didn't realize the back was plastic until this thread.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Div033 said:
I used a TPU case for quite some time and I felt it helped immensely when dropped. I even casually tossed my device onto concrete to show my friend that a TPU case is plenty for drop protection.
I feel like this case integrates better with the device but has slightly less impact absorption and drop protection. Its a trade-off for sure, but I find this is the best balance between protection and aesthetics. Samsung also makes an ultra thin case which is what I like to call a 'condom-case' which will only protect against scratches without any impact absorption. This case does offer substantially more drop protection than those, but still slightly less than a diztronic TPU case.
Also, I suck at taking pictures. I'm still trying to get some good shots to upload!
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a TPU case, the boxwave duosuit, along with the acase supperlegera pro that I am using now but I prefer the acase dual layer one, it does add much more bulk but I believe I am much more protected in case of a fall (wwhich happened once, with no damage done). I ordered this one because it's blue, much more good looking. Let's hope I still feel protected.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
ZooGue S3 Case Review
Introduction
I have owned this case for several months, and have only sparingly used it. But recently, I have fallen in love with a few of it's very specific attributes and I cannot ignore the ZooGue any longer. Being passionate about my smart phone accessories, and being a real stickler for good design and maximum efficiency, this cheap (if not free) case really won me over. Therefor you may find this review slightly biased.
Dimensions
13.8mm Length 5.5 inches
7.4mm Width 2+15/16 inches
11mm Thick 7/16 inch
Weight
Not sure...very light though. Probably as light as it gets for this type of full case.
(Following 3 photos slightly enhanced to show closer to true colour which is BLACK or CHARCOAL GRAY, the darkest of the set in the photo above.)
ZooGue vs the competition
I recently bought a UAG case (the Blue one, AERO) and I think the workmanship is outstanding, to the eye of the beholder...it's beautiful looking, and it really has a super solid precision fit which will surely offer edge to edge protection. (not direct face plants on jagged rocks) BUT....I am contemplating staying with the ridiculously cheaper Zoogue (not really in the same class) for a number of reasons. It's a give and take, but I am trying to pick my battles so to speak, and decide what is at the TOP of my LIST for a case to protect my beloved S3.
My top 3 wants: in a case
1] SLIM: as possible while offering good fall protection.
Some cases fall off the phone when they drop but I don't think this one will. Some, like UAG/Outerbox etc., offer shock protection at the expense of moderate to high bulk. Also, very important to me, is one handed operation.
2] GRIP: easy to hold non slippery yet easy to pull out of pocket.
It seems that so many cases are either slippery or sticky, both of which can increase the rate of dropping your S3!
3] Esthetics: I prefer it to compliment the style quality of the S3 itself or actually improve upon it.
The Zoogue Advantages
- Price: got it for free + shipping = $7cad (I've seen 99cents advertised too) But that's not why I bought it. I bought it because I had an inkling that it was good simple case design.
- Slim: as thin as should be for the protection offered. As low pro as it gets really.
- GRIP: ***ribbed edges*** this is one of the best feeling side grips ever. So simple. Rear side is neither sticky nor slippery. In stiffness, the material feels like somewhere between a rigid soft plastic and stiffer than TPU. It hugs like much firmer than any silicon case I've seen, but still flexible if you pull on the edges with your finger. It's a strange composition.
- Contouring: curved edges, forming to the curves of the S3 and allowing maximum secured one handed reach. Also there is a low profile semi rigid lip that hugs around to the front edges of the display, allowing you to place the S3 face down without damaging the screen. (that obviously also keeps the S3 from popping out)
- Menu Button: the lip of the case near the menu button is slightly beveled out to allow your finger more room. Subtle Genius!!
- Colour: many to choose from. I have the Black one on a BLUE S3.
- Logo: decent logo on the back in beveled gloss black (not cheesy looking)
- Buttons: Stiffer covered power and volume buttons which I prefer. I mostly power my S3 on with the MENU button and power off with a gesture. Still, they are not stuck or broken...just more rigid.
- Docks: uniform edge dimension ensures one handed sliding compatibility with charging docks like CraigsDocks. Also, this case should fit most desk docks that are designed to hold S3 with slim cases.
- Lint and Finger Prints: so far not bad at all. Hardly any lint whatsoever...and definitely no finger prints. I wonder if the Zoogue will get a bit less powdery feeling over time. (my TV remote was like that and went smoother, nicer over time)
UPDATE: that powdery almost SANDY feeling is starting to dissipate nicely just a few days later.
- Weight: not much at all.
- Fire Proof: really? no. Just seeing if you are paying attention.
If I could snap my fingers
...and make the Zoogue better for my liking, I would:
- Sticky Back: add a pattern to the back of the case to allow more grip when laying flat on a table. It's not bad, but perhaps a strategic smoothened out strip or logo would help there. (the UAG has feet for this) I plan on testing it with a strip of Egrips that I ordered from the internet. Stay tuned.
- Colour: it's a matte black, and the deepness of the black is not near as rich as my Nillken slim minimalistic case.
- Holes: the cutouts for all the holes are not bad, but definitely not nearly as precise as the UAG. There are workarounds for this if need be.
- Shield: I don't use a screen protector, but from what I hear, it may be a hit or miss whether it will work in harmony with this case. Customizing the shield usually works too.
Dream Case
I would love to see a case like this that was part of a hybrid design.
So lets say I was going fishing, I would slip on an outer hard shell shell specifically made for this slim softer shell case and have perhaps water resistant properties.
Conclusion
It's a cheapo Charlie case guys. Nothing fancy. But sometimes that's what hits the mark better than complicated designs. There are many simple cases out there that probably share similar dimensions and thickness etc., but many are shiny lint, dirt and finger print magnets. The simplistic yet strategic design of the Zoogue may just satisfy my need for a non bulky, light weight, protective, easy to hold and use, decent looking case for my S3. My reasons for liking it may be different than your reasons for liking a case.
All in all, I give this would be 5/10 case...a more deserving 8.5/10. It works for me. So now the moment of truth. Will I be able to keep this case on for 30days without feeling the need to go back to my UAG? Stay tuned...
UPDATE Feb 4 2013:
I ordered another one tonight. The website says $9.99 but I inserted a free shipping coupon and a 20% off coupon and it was $7.99cad total. That's only about a dollar more than I paid for the first one months ago. I couldn't resist. Here is the coupon page. (I used a hot solder iron to melt a bigger headphone jack area since I have several headphones that have fat plugs. I wanna try to do a better job with the next case. Also, I ever so slightly increased the mic holes. I also want to try to put a dab of nail polish or paint on the buttons for feel. (the braille effect) And Lastly, when my Egrips come in, I am going to try putting a thin strip on the back.
themadproducer said:
ZooGue S3 Case Review
Introduction
I have owned this case for several months, and have only sparingly used it. But recently, I have fallen in love with a few of it's very specific attributes and I cannot ignore the ZooGue any longer. Being passionate about my smart phone accessories, and being a real stickler for good design and maximum efficiency, this cheap (if not free) case really one me over. Therefor you may find this review slightly biased.
(pictures in action...to come soon)
ZooGue vs the competition
I recently bought a UAG case (the Blue one, AERO) and I think the workmanship is outstanding, to the eye of the beholder...it's beautiful looking, and it really has a super solid precision fit which will surely offer edge to edge protection. (not direct face plants on jagged rocks) BUT....I am contemplating staying with the ridiculously cheaper Zoogue (not really in the same class) for a number of reasons. It's a give and take, but I am trying to pick my battles so to speak, and decide what is at the TOP of my LIST for a case to protect my beloved S3.
My top 3 wants: in a case
1] SLIM: as possible while offering good fall protection.
Some cases fall off the phone when they drop but I don't think this one will. Some, like UAG/Outerbox etc., offer shock protection at the expense of moderate to high bulk. Also, very important to me, is one handed operation.
2] GRIP: easy to hold non slippery yet easy to pull out of pocket.
It seems that so many cases are either slippery or sticky, both of which can increase the rate of dropping your S3!
3] Esthetics: I prefer it to compliment the style quality of the S3 itself or actually improve upon it.
The Zoogue Advantages
- Price: got it for free + shipping = $7cad (I've seen 99cents advertised too) But that's not why I bought it. I bought it because I had an inkling that it was good simple case design.
- Slim: as thin as should be for the protection offered. As low pro as it gets really.
- GRIP: ***ribbed edges*** this is one of the best feeling side grips ever. So simple. Rear side is neither sticky nor slippery. In stiffness, the material feels like somewhere between a rigid soft plastic and stiffer than TPU. It hugs like much firmer than any silicon case I've seen, but still flexible if you pull on the edges with your finger. It's a strange composition.
- Contouring: curved edges, forming to the curves of the S3 and allowing maximum secured one handed reach. Also there is a low profile semi rigid lip that hugs around to the front edges of the display, allowing you to place the S3 face down without damaging the screen. (that obviously also keeps the S3 from popping out)
- Menu Button: the lip of the case near the menu button is slightly beveled out to allow your finger more room. Subtle Genius!!
- Colour: many to choose from. I have the Black one on a BLUE S3.
- Logo: decent logo on the back in beveled gloss black (not cheesy looking)
- Buttons: Stiffer covered power and volume buttons which I prefer. I mostly power my S3 on with the MENU button and power off with a gesture. Still, they are not stuck or broken...just more rigid.
- Docks: uniform edge dimension ensures one handed sliding compatability with charging docks like CraigsDocks. Also, this case should fit most desk docks that are designed to hold S3 with slim cases.
- Lint and Finger Prints: so far not bad at all. Hardly any lint whatsoever...and definitely no finger prints. I wonder if the Zoogue will get a bit less powdery feeling over time. (my TV remote was like that and went smoother, nicer over time)
- Weight: not much at all.
- Fire Proof: really? no. Just seeing if you are paying attention.
If I could snap my fingers
...and make the Zoogue better for my liking, I would:
- Sticky Back: add a pattern to the back of the case to allow more grip when laying flat on a table. It's not bad, but perhaps a strategic smoothened out strip or logo would help there. (the UAG has feet for this) I plan on testing it with a strip of Egrips that I ordered from the internet. Stay tuned.
- Colour: it's a matte black, and the deepness of the black is not near as rich as my Nillken slim minimalistic case.
- Holes: the cutouts for all the holes are not bad, but definitely not nearly as precise as the UAG. There are workarounds for this if need be.
- Shield: I don't use a screen protector, but from what I hear, it may be a hit or miss whether it will work in harmony with this case. Customizing the shield usually works too.
Dream Case
I would love to see a case like this that was part of a hybrid design.
So lets say I was going fishing, I would slip on an outer hard shell shell specifically made for this slim softer shell case and have perhaps water resistant properties.
Conclusion
It's a cheapo Charlie case guys. Nothing fancy. But sometimes that's what hits the mark better than complicated designs. There are many simple cases out there that probably share similar dimensions and thickness etc., but many are shiny lint, dirt and finger print magnets. The simplistic yet strategic design of the Zoogue may just satisfy my need for a non bulky, light weight, protective, easy to hold and use, decent looking case for my S3. My reasons for liking it may be different than your reasons for liking a case.
All in all, I give this would be 5/10 case...a more deserving 8.5/10. It works for me. So now the moment of truth. Will I be able to keep this case on for 30days without feeling the need to go back to my UAG? Stay tuned...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
where are these available sir?
I have 3 different cases. The Acase Superleggra, a cheap hard shell with kickstand and 2 of these ZooGue cases. The ZooGue is by far my favourite case. I also got them cheap (2 for $9 delivered) which makes it even better. I bought one black and one grey although I wish they had a dark blue one to match my blue S3. The material and grooved edges are perfect for grippiness and sliding in and out of my pocket which is usually a problem with other cases.
Overall it's awesome and I'd recommend them to anyone who prefer a slim case over a max protection type of case.
http://www.zoogue.com/galaxy-siii-social-case/
Awesome review! I'm reeeally considering getting one (or more) of these cases... anybody have pics on a Pebble Blue phone?
grillheadxl said:
Awesome review! I'm reeeally considering getting one (or more) of these cases... anybody have pics on a Pebble Blue phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will post some day light taken pics later tomorrow with my Pebble Blue S3 and the Black Zoogue.
Re: ZooGue Review - full yet Slim Case for S3
Ive been rocking black zoogue on my white s3. Im in love with this case. Was a huge fan of uag myself but after this i cant stand ths slick back of the uag cases. This zoogue is by far the best tpu case out there. Hands down. Ive had quite a few cases now, rearth ringke, seidio surface, seidio active, uag, ballistics, otterbox, you name it.. I wont use the others anymore for numerous reasons on each. I rock this along with the seidio holster. Perfect combination for me. Here are some pics with the holster in action. As you can see my ports line up perfectly. The only thing i disliked was that it doesnt play friendly with my full screen protector. Had to remove it and install a dry application one. But i can live with it no biggie.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
I re-uploaded the Pebble Blue + Zoogue case photos.
Bump for the best tpu case
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Ordered one in gray. Can't wait to get it!
grillheadxl said:
Ordered one in gray. Can't wait to get it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice! Post pics if u can when u get it. Want to see the gray actual color.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
1slow4G said:
Nice! Post pics if u can when u get it. Want to see the gray actual color.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's a pic of the grey on a Pebble Blue S3. Pic was taken in a bright sun-filled room. In regular light, the grey cover is a bit darker than it appears in the pic. In my opinion, the grey has a slight tinge of blue in it, so it complements the Pebble Blue very well (but will also look nice on a white handset as well).
I ordered another one tonight. The website says $9.99 but I inserted a free shipping coupon and a 20% off coupon and it was $7.99cad total. That's only about a dollar more than I paid for the first one months ago. I couldn't resist. Here is the coupon page.
JSCinSK said:
Here's a pic of the grey on a Pebble Blue S3. Pic was taken in a bright sun-filled room. In regular light, the grey cover is a bit darker than it appears in the pic. In my opinion, the grey has a slight tinge of blue in it, so it complements the Pebble Blue very well (but will also look nice on a white handset as well).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thinking about ordering the grey one. I have the white s3 not sure how well it would look.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
1slow4G said:
Thinking about ordering the grey one. I have the white s3 not sure how well it would look.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should note that the grey cover is definitely NOT as light as it appears in the OP's first post. If you wind up ordering it, expect to see a darker shade of grey.
How tight is the case. Cause I have a ghost amror screen protector will it cause that to come up?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda app-developers app
JSCinSK said:
You should note that the grey cover is definitely NOT as light as it appears in the OP's first post. If you wind up ordering it, expect to see a darker shade of grey.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah all the colors are different in person. I have the red and its more of a light red and pinkish lol. Not using it for that reason
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
1slow4G said:
Yeah all the colors are different in person. I have the red and its more of a light red and pinkish lol. Not using it for that reason
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's why I always tend to stick with black. Boring, but predictable.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
1slow4G said:
... I rock this along with the seidio holster. Perfect combination for me. Here are some pics with the holster in action. As you can see my ports line up perfectly. ...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you know what exact Seidio holster you have? I ordered one from Amazon, based on your reply. However, when it came it seems too small and that I got the wrong one.
Thanks in advance.
ticojpunk said:
That's why I always tend to stick with black. Boring, but predictable.
Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep same here
haxx said:
Do you know what exact Seidio holster you have? I ordered one from Amazon, based on your reply. However, when it came it seems too small and that I got the wrong one.
Thanks in advance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the seidio surface holster. U might of ordered the holster that requires no casr, just the s3 naked.
Sent from my Galaxy S3 using neighbors wifi
themadproducer said:
ZooGue S3 Case Review
Introduction
I have owned this case for several months, and have only sparingly used it. But recently, I have fallen in love with a few of it's very specific attributes and I cannot ignore the ZooGue any longer. Being passionate about my smart phone accessories, and being a real stickler for good design and maximum efficiency, this cheap (if not free) case really won me over. Therefor you may find this review slightly biased.
Dimensions
13.8mm Length 5.5 inches
7.4mm Width 2+15/16 inches
11mm Thick 7/16 inch
(Following 3 photos slightly enhanced to show closer to true colour.)
ZooGue vs the competition
I recently bought a UAG case (the Blue one, AERO) and I think the workmanship is outstanding, to the eye of the beholder...it's beautiful looking, and it really has a super solid precision fit which will surely offer edge to edge protection. (not direct face plants on jagged rocks) BUT....I am contemplating staying with the ridiculously cheaper Zoogue (not really in the same class) for a number of reasons. It's a give and take, but I am trying to pick my battles so to speak, and decide what is at the TOP of my LIST for a case to protect my beloved S3.
My top 3 wants: in a case
1] SLIM: as possible while offering good fall protection.
Some cases fall off the phone when they drop but I don't think this one will. Some, like UAG/Outerbox etc., offer shock protection at the expense of moderate to high bulk. Also, very important to me, is one handed operation.
2] GRIP: easy to hold non slippery yet easy to pull out of pocket.
It seems that so many cases are either slippery or sticky, both of which can increase the rate of dropping your S3!
3] Esthetics: I prefer it to compliment the style quality of the S3 itself or actually improve upon it.
The Zoogue Advantages
- Price: got it for free + shipping = $7cad (I've seen 99cents advertised too) But that's not why I bought it. I bought it because I had an inkling that it was good simple case design.
- Slim: as thin as should be for the protection offered. As low pro as it gets really.
- GRIP: ***ribbed edges*** this is one of the best feeling side grips ever. So simple. Rear side is neither sticky nor slippery. In stiffness, the material feels like somewhere between a rigid soft plastic and stiffer than TPU. It hugs like much firmer than any silicon case I've seen, but still flexible if you pull on the edges with your finger. It's a strange composition.
- Contouring: curved edges, forming to the curves of the S3 and allowing maximum secured one handed reach. Also there is a low profile semi rigid lip that hugs around to the front edges of the display, allowing you to place the S3 face down without damaging the screen. (that obviously also keeps the S3 from popping out)
- Menu Button: the lip of the case near the menu button is slightly beveled out to allow your finger more room. Subtle Genius!!
- Colour: many to choose from. I have the Black one on a BLUE S3.
- Logo: decent logo on the back in beveled gloss black (not cheesy looking)
- Buttons: Stiffer covered power and volume buttons which I prefer. I mostly power my S3 on with the MENU button and power off with a gesture. Still, they are not stuck or broken...just more rigid.
- Docks: uniform edge dimension ensures one handed sliding compatibility with charging docks like CraigsDocks. Also, this case should fit most desk docks that are designed to hold S3 with slim cases.
- Lint and Finger Prints: so far not bad at all. Hardly any lint whatsoever...and definitely no finger prints. I wonder if the Zoogue will get a bit less powdery feeling over time. (my TV remote was like that and went smoother, nicer over time)
UPDATE: that powdery almost SANDY feeling is starting to dissipate nicely just a few days later.
- Weight: not much at all.
- Fire Proof: really? no. Just seeing if you are paying attention.
If I could snap my fingers
...and make the Zoogue better for my liking, I would:
- Sticky Back: add a pattern to the back of the case to allow more grip when laying flat on a table. It's not bad, but perhaps a strategic smoothened out strip or logo would help there. (the UAG has feet for this) I plan on testing it with a strip of Egrips that I ordered from the internet. Stay tuned.
- Colour: it's a matte black, and the deepness of the black is not near as rich as my Nillken slim minimalistic case.
- Holes: the cutouts for all the holes are not bad, but definitely not nearly as precise as the UAG. There are workarounds for this if need be.
- Shield: I don't use a screen protector, but from what I hear, it may be a hit or miss whether it will work in harmony with this case. Customizing the shield usually works too.
Dream Case
I would love to see a case like this that was part of a hybrid design.
So lets say I was going fishing, I would slip on an outer hard shell shell specifically made for this slim softer shell case and have perhaps water resistant properties.
Conclusion
It's a cheapo Charlie case guys. Nothing fancy. But sometimes that's what hits the mark better than complicated designs. There are many simple cases out there that probably share similar dimensions and thickness etc., but many are shiny lint, dirt and finger print magnets. The simplistic yet strategic design of the Zoogue may just satisfy my need for a non bulky, light weight, protective, easy to hold and use, decent looking case for my S3. My reasons for liking it may be different than your reasons for liking a case.
All in all, I give this would be 5/10 case...a more deserving 8.5/10. It works for me. So now the moment of truth. Will I be able to keep this case on for 30days without feeling the need to go back to my UAG? Stay tuned...
UPDATE Feb 4 2013:
I ordered another one tonight. The website says $9.99 but I inserted a free shipping coupon and a 20% off coupon and it was $7.99cad total. That's only about a dollar more than I paid for the first one months ago. I couldn't resist. Here is the coupon page. (I used a hot solder iron to melt a bigger headphone jack area since I have several headphones that have fat plugs. I wanna try to do a better job with the next case. Also, I ever so slightly increased the mic holes. I also want to try to put a dab of nail polish or paint on the buttons for feel. (the braille effect) And Lastly, when my Egrips come in, I am going to try putting a thin strip on the back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yoobao Cases and extended battery review
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=ejLR1Z-tV-M
www.kevikev.com 10% off coupon code 10offxda or flossy
I know we already have a huge thread about UAG, but those are 65+ pages of people waiting/speculating/complaining and maybe 3-4 good reviews with pictures. So, I figured maybe to start an official review thread for UAG Note 2 case http://www.urbanarmorgear.com/collections/galaxy-note-ii
Since I don't own iPhone or S3, my experience with previous UAG cases was based on reading only reviews from others, and it seems those cases were quite popular with a huge fan base. Note 2 case introduced a new design, and that generated a mixed reviews. I'm personally looking at the case as is without comparing it to previous models.
The case came in a nice packaging box, nothing too fancy but with a clear display and highlights of the features. In addition to the case, UAG included a screen protector, a small screen cloth and a squeeze for sp installation. I can't comment on sp since I already have one installed, but I have a feeling its a basic one. I can comment it had a good cut, although didn't feel as thick as some other 3H film screen protectors.
Also, as part of new "vent" design, it came with 2 inserts in orange and black. Those are interchangeable and you can use either one. There has been a lot of discussion about quality of material used on these inserts and perhaps some people had higher expectations. These inserts are cardboard cut outs with diamond textured design and some thin laminating layer on color side. Each insert is colored on one side, while white on another side. In theory you can make your own inserts. Those have two side cut outs that align with guiding small pins inside of the case. Once you put down the insert, you better keep the case horizontal while inserting the phone, otherwise the insert will move. When phone is inserted into the case - inserts stay dead on, although if you shake the phone you will hear it move a little bit. Don't get me wrong, it looks cool as hell, and could be easily fixed with a little piece of scotch tape holding it down. The vent itself should keep air circulating which is a good idea while charging the battery.
The case is VERY light - amazing considering the high level of protection it offers at a minimum added bulk. Of course, just like any case it adds some bulk, but when you compare to other case with equivalent level of protection - this is feather-light! The construction is composite where inner protection bumper and outer shell are molded together. Yes, I would consider the inner rubber (hard TPU material) to be a bumper since it doesn't wrap around the back of the phone. The outer shell made of a very high quality impact plastic material, definitely not some cheap brittle stuff. The inner side of the plastic shell has honeycomb pattern, while the outer side is smooth and has sort of sandblasted finish. I do have to note, plastic does feel a little slippery in your hands. I have heard this will go away with time, but I still have to point it out. But since they have vent cut out in the back and also hard rubber bumper around the edges of the screen, you still get an acceptable grip when holding it in your hand. The rubber bumper doesn't pull away and fits around the edge of the phone very snugly. The only place where it pulls a little bit is at the bottom in the aread of micro-usb connector, but very slightly. It also offers a very nice lip to protect the screen of the phone when faced down, and a VERY good corner protection with some extra material while still keeping it slim and not exaggerated around corners like some other designs do. Furthermore, the back of the phone has 4 subtle stands in a shape of a torx screw head. Those are of course not real screws but rather rubber bumps, but functionally it's brilliant since you can put your phone down on the back and it will keep it from sliding!!! This little design detail is so subtle yet brilliantly functional and adds to "urban" style of the phone.
Port openings are very generous; mic openings big enough for a clear sound, micro-usb opening is wide enough to accommodate after market connectors, headphone jack should accept a connector up to 3/8". S-pen opening deserves a special mentioning. It's not your typical rectangular opening, and narrows down while still giving enough room for a nail to grab the edge of s-pen when pulling it out. Just a very nice detail. Speaker grill has a cross line which makes speaker design with a battery cover of the phone to look partitioned and cool next to the grill design. Camera and led flash openings are partitioned - a very clever idea for glare-free flash photos! Volume and power buttons have a very unique design to make them look like a separate external buttons. These buttons have a separate slit opening along one side to make them push easier. I very clever idea! I have documented all these details in my pictures.
Another comment I would like to bring up is the color of the case itself. Since I choose Navigator to compliment my white GN2, I want to mention that white of the case is a few shades brighter than white of the phone - not a big issue since those two colors don't come in contact. I do want to mention also, there is a little flex when you push down on the vents. I assume that was always part of the design even with solid back on iPhone/S3 cases. With vents cut outs, it's more visible now. I would say it could be looked as positive and negative point. Positive since it absorbs some shock if case falls down flat on its back, and negative since you are opening back door to lint and dust getting under the vent.
Overall, its a very unique design that offers both a visual eye candy and a decent level of protection to the phone. I tried to be fair in my review and describe all the positive and negative points I found, IMHO. But in my personal opinion - I highly recommend it!
As usual, I will leave the rest to the pictures. Please keep in mind due to case being white, my camera had a hard time focusing.
I'm sure some will share my opinion, others might disagree or want to add comments. If you can, please don't reply with all the pictures in the post to duplicate it.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
I guess you can consider this as the first mod. Actually someone else done it before, but I'm elaborating on details with more pictures!
Yes, you can have GN2 in OEM Flip case going right into UAG case and it works! Of course, there are some limitations. You can flip the cover all the way around, unless you modify UAG case by cutting it's side (which nobody in their right mind going to do). And, because the left side is covered by flip case, UAG volume buttons will not be pushing directly on phone's volume, which makes it a lot harder to work BUT it WORKS!!! So here you go, an alternative to add flip cover to your UAG case:
Good idea and nice pics...I'd like to add my review from yesterday here so if it helps anyone good stuff.. I'd like to add day 2 and the feel is better IMO less slippery and fit seems to have settled in nicely..Keeper ..
What up peeps..Just wanted to give a small overview of the case I received today. I will test drive it for a few days(week) and let y'all know how it flows for me..Haha
Excuse my noobness to the video making world..
Part 1: Case without phone..
https://www.dropbox.com/s/sfwqpcw278kob47/UAG_reviewPart1.mp4
Part 2: Case with phone...
https://www.dropbox.com/s/yf62xa2oimqstb8/UAG_reviewPart2.mp4
bkdodger said:
Good idea and nice pics...I'd like to add my review from yesterday here so if it helps anyone good stuff.. I'd like to add day 2 and the feel is better IMO less slippery and fit seems to have settled in nicely..Keeper ..
What up peeps..Just wanted to give a small overview of the case I received today. I will test drive it for a few days(week) and let y'all know how it flows for me..Haha
Excuse my noobness to the video making world..
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good job, videos are great! I'm actually thinking now about getting Scout/black for my white GN2 as well.
Just a quick question.
Ive owned a few white and clear cases and all of them started yellowing/browning.. Do you think this will happen to this one also?
vectron said:
Good job, videos are great! I'm actually thinking now about getting Scout/black for my white GN2 as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha.. Your pics make me want the white..
《Take Note2 BK's here..》
Double0EK said:
Just a quick question.
Ive owned a few white and clear cases and all of them started yellowing/browning.. Do you think this will happen to this one also?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good question, but considering their make Navigator/white for iPhone 4 and S3 and I haven't read anybody complaining about those (since people been using it for awhile now), I assume it won't be an issue. I had a cheap clear case before, from ebay for a few bucks, after 3 days in my jeans pocket it got a shade of blue. I will give this case a benefit of a doubt that hard plastic material they use won't change the color. I guess time will tell, but like I said - this is an exactly the same material as older iPhone 4 and S3 cases and there is no complains about it. UAG for S3 has almost 980 reviews on Amazon with an average of 4.75 stars. I will take that as a positive sign
Thanks. Never even thought to read the reviews on Amazon..
Really liked your idea of adding the flip cover. After I colored the back of the orange back panel red, I threw the flip cover on and the new UAG case, and am lovin the results. Oh, I also used an exacto blade to remove the silver UAG lettering. Thanks for the great idea!
Hey just ordered mines thanks to your good review
Sent from my SPH-L900 using xda app-developers app
vectron said:
The case is VERY light - amazing considering the high level of protection it offers at a minimum added bulk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I started analyzing the case first hand and I'm beginning to appreciate UAG's design more and more. Some people complain about not getting their previous design you see on the S3, but I understand why UAG did this. It is all about trying to chip off as much excess weight from the case as possible without compromising protection and style. Throughout the case you will see that besides the vents, the insert is not a full piece but just covers the vents nicely (more weight off there), there are grooves, and the inside TPU back is also honey-combed, to reduce the overall weight as much as possible. With a big phone like Note 2, I think this is a very wise decision by them. If they used the old design, the case would probably be a bit heavier than what we have now.
Overall I think it is a great case. Possibly the best case out there that scores in every category in style, protection & functionality in my humble opinion. 9.5/10
@vectron, i appreciate your review. its basically the same thing i would have said i f i did a review on this case. at the end of the day this case is a great investment. functionallity, quality & great design are all incorporated into this and you will not be let down. i couldnt be happier with it.
Anyone try to use it with the Smart Dock?
IamPro said:
Anyone try to use it with the Smart Dock?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Didn't work with smart dock. It would fit in if you force it but doesn't go in far enough to make any connection. Also will not work in the battery charger. Here it fits in but falls forward. Price you pay for protection I guess. No big deal to me, I will just take case off when I put in dock. Now if I was using dock every day for charging, it may be a bigger deal.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2
Can any comment on the comparisonf of this UAG case with the likes of OTterbox Commuter and Ballistic SG series in terms of weight, protection, ease of use and slippery feel, etc?
garyart1 said:
Didn't work with smart dock. It would fit in if you force it but doesn't go in far enough to make any connection. Also will not work in the battery charger. Here it fits in but falls forward. Price you pay for protection I guess. No big deal to me, I will just take case off when I put in dock. Now if I was using dock every day for charging, it may be a bigger deal.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you talking about the spare battery charger dock?
Sent from my SGH-I317M using Tapatalk 2
My fondness of the UAG Navigator is starting to waver a bit. I am realizing it makes the phone quite a bit more wide, almost to the point I don't like the way it feels in my hand. As odd as this sounds, I might go back to the hyperion extended battery and case (newer style) as that feel is about as solid as I have found when it comes to cases on the Note 2. Plus, for about one milimeter difference, I am packing a 6200mAh battery, and the phone is quite a bit less wide in my hand. The attached photo shows the height difference between the hyperion and the UAG.
mdt73 said:
Really liked your idea of adding the flip cover. After I colored the back of the orange back panel red, I threw the flip cover on and the new UAG case, and am lovin the results. Oh, I also used an exacto blade to remove the silver UAG lettering. Thanks for the great idea!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How are you guys adding the flip cover on this case?
Sent from my SGH-T889V using xda app-developers app
sofia-captivate said:
How are you guys adding the flip cover on this case?
Sent from my SGH-T889V using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It fits perfectly. The only problem is the cover itself doesn't have a lot of room to move, so it won't open all the way, making typing with your left hand sort of cumbersome. Just install the flip cover, then the UAG case.
Yep, Note 2 with flip cover fits right into the UAG case. Take a look at my Post#2 in this thread, you can see from the pictures it fits right in, although with a few limitations like can flip the cover all the way back and volume buttons need to be pushed harder since you pushing on them through the flexible side of flip case.
This is going to be a long post, so I figured I would just make a new thread. I welcome anyone else to add their reviews, opinions, and pictures here as well (or if you disagree with me, let me know). The other thread was getting quite long anyway, so a new one full of reviews from people who have it would be nice.
So, does it live up to the hype? How sexy is that Nexus logo? I know some of you already have it, but here’s my take on it.
Maple Syrup:
White:http://www.puremobile.ca/lg-aaa75187802-hardshell-nexus-5-white
Black: http://www.puremobile.ca/lg-aaa75187801-hardshell-nexus-5-black
Football:
White: http://www.puremobile.com/lg-aaa75187802-hardshell-nexus-5-white
Black: http://www.puremobile.com/lg-aaa75187801-hardshell-nexus-5-black
Cup-o-Tea:
White: http://www.mobilefun.co.uk/lg-official-nexus-5-bumper-white-p42340.htm
Black: http://www.mobilefun.co.uk/lg-official-nexus-5-bumper-black-p42351.htm
Red: http://www.mobilefun.co.uk/lg-official-nexus-5-shell-case-red-p42344.htm
I was lucky enough to pick it up when it was $14.99, then got a 10% discount on top of it before they caught on and bumped the price/killed the discount. So all in, came to $14.16 CAD. Not bad for an OEM case. It’s currently listed as $17.99 in Canada/US, and £24.99 in UK. For Canada and US that’s still a pretty good price, but UK I think is getting the shaft here.
Now you probably already know I love my quicksand hardcases. To me nothing is going to beat those $0.99 lovelies. The look, feel, and texture of the quicksand cases can’t be beat in my eyes. But, sometimes a guy just wants that NEXUS logo showing proud. It’s an amazing phone, and deserves attention every now and then.
That’s where this case was supposed to come in. I have a lot of hardcases already (10+); the prospect of an OEM hardcase with NEXUS printed down the centre was too hard to pass up. It was enough to consider occasionally pulling me away from my quicksands. Pearly white, tri-side coverage, sleek and thin, stormtrooper/panda look, and the NEXUS logo down the middle. It could have been perfect. But alas, unicorns don’t exist and puremobile lied to me as well…
When I asked them, they confirmed to me the Nexus logo was there. I said I would cancel my order if it wasn’t, as that was the only reason I ordered it. They said yes… but it really wasn’t…
Anyway, enough of my wallowing in self-pity… Is this case still good despite the logo being absent? I know my main reason for ordering it is gone, but if it’s still a great case, those of you who don’t care about the logo might be in for a treat. So let’s get to reviewing.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Construction:
The material is standard issue polycarbonate hard plastic. I have the white case, so can’t comment on black. It is a matte finish similar (if not the same) as my white Ringke Slim. It has a nice feel, albeit a bit slippery if you have dry hands. Also, when I say feel, I mean it’s almost nonexistent. This case adds next to no bulk. I would consider this more of a skin (a hard skin) than an actual case.
This case is thin. I mean super thin. When Ringke Slim and Spigen Ultra Fit say they’re thin, this case takes a gander at them and tells them they’ve been eating too much cake! That is good and bad. For me, I’m a minimalist, I want a case that’s there, but isn’t there. Scuff and scratch protection is all I want, and this case literally follows ONLY that, anyone expecting this to give you any protection beyond scratch only is dreaming. Take this into consideration, my quicksand cases seem like otterboxes in comparison to this.
With how thin this case is, you should realize that it will offer ZERO impact protection. I can’t emphasize that enough. Since there is next to no bulk, there is next to no case. It is very thin, so dropping your phone with this case on, is like dropping your phone naked (which is why I said the case is more like a hard skin). So for those of you who may drop your phones, don’t buy it. For minimalists, you may like it.
Honestly, this case reminds me of the 0.3mm TPU cases that were available on ebay. Only this is a better plastic and higher quality mold. If I didn’t know any better, I would seriously say those 0.3mm cases were the “beta test” design for this case. (If you saw my opinion on those 0.3mm cases, I hated them…) The different type of plastic used and the slightly more rigid feel, make it substantially better than the 0.3mm TPU cases.
You can see here, the striking similarities between the LG Hardshell and the 0.3mm TPU ebay cases:
Fit on the Phone:
This hardcase has tri-side coverage. Most hardcases as you know stick to covering the sides, the back, and some of the corners. And they snap into place with a lip that hooks over the sides/face of the phone. This also creates that “face down” gap that lifts the screen off when you place your phone screen down (don’t know why people would do that though…).
The LG hardshell gets rid of the lip and hook method of securing the case to the phone and adds top coverage in its place. This fundamentally changes how the case attaches to the phone. It is not hooked on and snapped in place. It follows the contours of the phone and hugs the sides tightly. Since the phone is wider in the back and narrower in the front (Dat Azz), the case follows those dimensions and holds itself in place just by shape alone. By hugging the sides instead of snapping in place, the LG hardcase does not create the face down gap. So, if you have this case, don’t put your phone screen down.
You can see the design difference and lack of lip the LG hardcase has vs. one of my quicksand cases.
The fact that this case does not snap on also means it will be less likely to scratch the corners of your phone. This case does not attach in the same way as a normal hardcase (it attaches by hugging the sides only) (remember Dat Azz). There is no lip to catch on the corners, so you can slide it on and off without worrying as much about scratches.
The downside of course, is the lack of the ability to place your phone face down. If you’re the type of person who likes to put your phone down like that, be aware. Again, this case is more of a skin than an actual case. For pure minimalists, this case is fantastic (I just want the damn NEXUS logo….)
Here you can see that face down, the case is actually lifted off of the table. That’s full on screen contact there.
The volume and power buttons I also find to be a bit odd to press. There is no problem pressing them, but the narrow cutouts make the feel a bit weird. It’s hard to explain, but I prefer the cutouts to be a little bigger, like standard hardcases where the cutout goes behind the back a bit.
Build Quality:
Okay, this is a bit tricky. In terms of design, button cutouts, and everything lining up perfectly, it does the job very well. The camera and flash cutouts are perfect, the volume and power button cutouts are centred nicely, and the headphone jack cutout lines up perfect as well. Don’t worry about not fitting fatter headphone jacks on with this case attached. The case is so thin that it doesn’t even matter. In terms of cutouts and fit, this case did very well.
Now the tricky part, since this case is so thin, the actual case itself is quite flimsy. There is only so much strength you can get out of a ridiculously thin piece of plastic (remember, think hard skin vs. case). It bends very easily, and honestly, I think if you bent it a little too much it would crack easily, make a crease in the plastic, or even tear. Add in cold weather, and I think it could crack with a gentle bump if the plastic got cold enough. If you were to compare this case vs. a quicksand in terms of strength, feel, and durability; the quicksand case easily takes it no question. If you were to compare this case vs. a Ringke Slim or Spigen Ultra fit, this case takes it in terms of fit/finish/detail, but both the Ringke Slim and Spigen Ultra Fit are more durable cases.
So in terms of build quality, this is a mixed bag.
Will I keep it?:
I was contemplating whether or not I would keep this case. If it impressed me enough despite not having the NEXUS logo on it, I would keep it. Honestly, after testing it out for a while, it’s going back. I like the minimalism and look, but the actual feel in hand for me was a turn off. It reminded me too much of the 0.3mm TPU cases, and this is what I thought of those when I posted it here. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=49827734&postcount=44
The slipperiness, narrow power and volume cutouts, and it being a bit too flimsy for my liking really sealed the deal of the trip back. The surprising thing for me is, I would probably still send it back even if it did have the NEXUS logo on it. For some reason, I just don’t like the way it feels in the hand. It might be my love for the quicksand cases clouding my judgment, but it just doesn’t feel as nice in my hand. And that’s a big factor in a case for me. Looks are one thing, but feel is definitely important as well.
Surprisingly, this case, after the [email protected]#$ of information and wondering if it would ever come out, turned out to be a bit of a disappointment for me. Maybe I overhyped myself, or was just expecting too much, but I’m just not that impressed.
I think it all boils down to just feeling a bit too cheap and flimsy for my liking. For an OEM case, it just doesn’t hold up. I still think my $0.99 Quicksand cases have this beat hands down.
Feel free to add in your own reviews, as I’m sure there are a lot of people who will disagree with me
Pros:
- Perfectly centred cutouts
- Thinness (double edged sword here)
- Minimalism taken to the extreme
Cons:
- Narrow volume / power cutouts
- Flimsy/cheap feeling (due to the thinness... which is quite the conundrum)
- No face down lip (if you place your phone face down)
- No NEXUS logo
Awesomely done review! Thanks for taking the time to do this review even though you're not keeping the case. Very good read
Good review. I don't really see the point in such a thin case. Adds bulk, decreases the feel of the device, and adds zero protection.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
_jordan_ said:
Good review. I don't really see the point in such a thin case. Adds bulk, decreases the feel of the device, and adds zero protection.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thin cases such as these are meant for protection against scratches and small bumps. Personally, I don't like using a case any thicker than these thin hard shells
mine came in today, and even sans the nexus logo this is by far the best case for me. I don't drop my phone and want it for scratch protection only so I want as close to nothing as possible. this fits like a glove. even the spigen ultra fit was too big for me, but this is definitely thinner. the black feels similar to the black nexus, but is slightly more slick. it reminds me of the bear motion super slim, with just a bit more grip. I'm very disappointed there is no nexus logo, it's the only thing that is holding this back from being truly perfect, but I'll be keeping this and stop looking for other cases
I like how it makes the black Nexus look like the white version. I'll probably keep mine once I get it. How's the material with picking up stains or smudges? I hate how all whites cases I've owned get dirty after a week.
On a side note, do you happen to know which eBay listing has a Quicksand case in red, not watermelon color. Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
I was just about to write an in-depth review, but you beat me to it.
For me, this is the perfect case. The fit is precise and covers what can be covered, it's extremely thin (by far the slimmest case I've used), and it has the very same soft touch finish as a naked Nexus 5. However, if you're the adventurous sort, this case probably isn't for you; it has no lip (the case sits a hair lower than the front face), it's not made of sturdy plastic, and the jury is out on whether or not the white will stain over time. It's clearly not meant to protect your phone from a fall, but it will protect it from normal day-to-day use for most. But other than that, this is about as near naked as you could hope for if you're in the market for a minimal case.
Hopefully Bacon doesn't mind, but I've attached a few more macro shots for good measure...
Ngo93 said:
Awesomely done review! Thanks for taking the time to do this review even though you're not keeping the case. Very good read
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, and no problem.
Atticustrd said:
I like how it makes the black Nexus look like the white version. I'll probably keep mine once I get it. How's the material with picking up stains or smudges? I hate how all whites cases I've owned get dirty after a week.
On a side note, do you happen to know which eBay listing has a Quicksand case in red, not watermelon color. Thanks.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I didn't use it terribly long (I am returning it, so it's wiped clean and repackaged haha) and I wanted to keep it in new shape. But from the time I used it smudges were not visible. It's a matte finish, so it won't show smudges clearly. As for stains, I couldn't tell you. It just came out so most people haven't even had it for more than a couple of days.
As for the quicksand cases, the original ones I bought don't have it in red (only watermelon/orange/pink, or whatever colour that is supposed to be). There is this one (I've ordered white and red, they haven't arrived yet) but it isn't the exact same design, and some other xda members who have it say it isn't as high of quality as the one's I've posted about before. I had to get it though because I just wanted white and red quicksand cases to go along with the rest I've got.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Ultra-Thin-Quicksand-Matte-Frosted-Case-Cover-Hard-for-Google-Nexus-5-/380788789723?pt=US_Cell_Phone_PDA_Cases&var=&hash=item58a8c7d1db
Jason_MCG said:
I was just about to write an in-depth review, but you beat me to it.
For me, this is the perfect case. The fit is precise and covers what can be covered, it's extremely thin (by far the slimmest case I've used), and it has the very same soft touch finish as a naked Nexus 5. However, if you're the adventurous sort, this case probably isn't for you; it has no lip (the case sits a hair lower than the front face), it's not made of sturdy plastic, and the jury is out on whether or not the white will stain over time. It's clearly not meant to protect your phone from a fall, but it will protect it from normal day-to-day use for most. But other than that, this is about as near naked as you could hope for if you're in the market for a minimal case.
Hopefully Bacon doesn't mind, but I've attached a few more macro shots for good measure...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry about that. I didn't see one up and I got a request to do a review when I received it. Also I welcome the pictures! The more the better. And other reviews as well (I did put an "s" in the thread title). I know my opinion isn't going to match everyone else.
I was seriously surprised that I didn't like this case. I'm a minimalist and I thought this would be exactly what I was looking for. But for some reason, just a bunch of little things compounded into my not liking it.
mmmmBACON said:
Sorry about that. I didn't see one up and I got a request to do a review when I received it. Also I welcome the pictures! The more the better. And other reviews as well (I did put an "s" in the thread title). I know my opinion isn't going to match everyone else.
I was seriously surprised that I didn't like this case. I'm a minimalist and I thought this would be exactly what I was looking for. But for some reason, just a bunch of little things compounded into my not liking it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't apologize - it's a great review! I just didn't want you to think I was trying to hijack or anything.
I briefly entertained the thought of returning it because it is so thin and it's like you said: it's not going to really protect the phone. I'm not a clumsy person, but falls do happen...I just don't want my love of minimal to be an Achilles heel.
I was looking at those Quicksand case couple days ago, let me know how those two cases turn-out. White and red are the exact color I'm looking to get next. I Pre-ordered the Spigen ultra fit case in red.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Poetic quicksand is really nice for about 4 bucks. Shipping is faster than the 2.99 generic quicksand. Both are extremely sleek and nicer than the lg case
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Jason_MCG said:
Don't apologize - it's a great review! I just didn't want you to think I was trying to hijack or anything.
I briefly entertained the thought of returning it because it is so thin and it's like you said: it's not going to really protect the phone. I'm not a clumsy person, but falls do happen...I just don't want my love of minimal to be an Achilles heel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No worries.
Yeah, that was one of the main things I was thinking about. I love minimalism, and I don't need drop protection as I baby all of my devices, but if a drop did ever happen, this isn't protecting anything. With the (white) case on I feel I would be more likely to drop it compared to the (black) phone naked. It's quite slippery unless your hands have some moisture to them.
Atticustrd said:
I was looking at those Quicksand case couple days ago, let me know how those two cases turn-out. White and red are the exact color I'm looking to get next. I Pre-ordered the Spigen ultra fit case in red.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will do.
If you check out the mobilefun site (UK) there is the listing for Red as well as black and white - this has only appeared today.
No pictures as yet but im guessing this matches the red nexus 5 in colour.
How about scratches when you try to take off the case? Because the Ringke case had scratch all the corners of my phone
Tapatalked with my Nexus5(AKA The Hammerhead)
Great review. I have to say it's infinitely superior to the 99p 0.3mm case I received (which had sharp edges and was rough to the touch, nothing like this OEM case). It's very similar to the OEM HTC One hard shell in that it doesn't have a lip but I much prefer that. My phone is always face up so it's a non-issues for me.
Yes, it's expensive foe us UK early adopters but I'm sure it'll end up cheaper once it's on eBay a bit more but I don't care
EDIT: @mmmmBACON - does it work with a wireless charger? I'd imagine so but just checking
It should be noted that the black version has the same soft touch feel as the black nexus and is not slippery at all. Great minimalist case.
dsmpampis said:
How about scratches when you try to take off the case? Because the Ringke case had scratch all the corners of my phone
Tapatalked with my Nexus5(AKA The Hammerhead)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you read the OP I talked about this case and any issues with scratched corners. I also have a Ringke Slim and have never had scratched corners. I made some videos on how to remove hardcases without scratching your phone.
Take a look here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2601790
EddyOS said:
Great review. I have to say it's infinitely superior to the 99p 0.3mm case I received (which had sharp edges and was rough to the touch, nothing like this OEM case). It's very similar to the OEM HTC One hard shell in that it doesn't have a lip but I much prefer that. My phone is always face up so it's a non-issues for me.
Yes, it's expensive foe us UK early adopters but I'm sure it'll end up cheaper once it's on eBay a bit more but I don't care
EDIT: @mmmmBACON - does it work with a wireless charger? I'd imagine so but just checking
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, it is definitely better quality than those 0.3mm TPU cases, but the feel in hand to me was too similar. Not the type of material and texture, but the shape, contours, and button layout. I think maybe if I had never bought those 0.3mm cases I might have liked this case more, but those were such crap, and this one was just similar enough in feel to remind me of them.
And there are no problems with wireless charging with this case on.
pemz82 said:
If you check out the mobilefun site (UK) there is the listing for Red as well as black and white - this has only appeared today.
No pictures as yet but im guessing this matches the red nexus 5 in colour.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Updated the OP with a link to the Red case as well.
mmmmBACON said:
If you read the OP I talked about this case and any issues with scratched corners. I also have a Ringke Slim and have never had scratched corners. I made some videos on how to remove hardcases without scratching your phone.
Take a look here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2601790
.
And there are no problems with wireless charging with this case on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The second time I took off the case, I tried your way from the video but I scratched the 2 left corners.....maybe I made something wrong.....
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
dsmpampis said:
The second time I took off the case, I tried your way from the video but I scratched the 2 left corners.....
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you try the card method (video #2), that works for EVERY hardcase I own and I still don't have any scratched corners. I don't know what to tell you otherwise.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Where to buy:
$6.99 - Replica Nexus 4 Bumper Case for the Nexus 5
Alternate Sellers (in case your colour choice is not available):
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1-7-Colors-NEW-Metal-TPU-Frame-Bumper-Cover-Case-For-LG-Goole-Nexus-5-/360898185809?pt=US_Cell_Phone_PDA_Cases&var=630259271784&hash=item5407354a51
http://www.ebay.com/itm/NEW-Metal-TPU-Frame-Bumper-Cover-Case-For-LG-Goole-Nexus-5-7-Colors-for-choice-/321373805938?pt=US_Cell_Phone_PDA_Cases&var=510260397981&hash=item4ad35f1d72
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1-x-Metal-New-TPU-Frame-Bumper-Cover-Case-For-LG-Goole-Nexus-5-/271469986797?pt=US_Cell_Phone_PDA_Cases&var=570317942443&hash=item3f34df43ed
For UK Residents:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/271490214166
I had a lot of people asking where I bought this bumper from, so I figured I might as well do it justice and give a full review of it. I think I’m finally pretty happy with all of the accessories that I’ve got now, since I’ve bought so much for this phone already. I don’t think I’ve ever stockpiled this much stuff dedicated to one device before. So this will probably be my last review thread as I think that might be it.
As I mentioned in the transparent bumper case review thread, the options for a decent bumper case on the Nexus 5 are pretty crap. To put it bluntly, the vast majority of bumper cases out there for the Nexus 5 are trash. They look like crap, they feel like crap, the button feedback sucks, and the protection is substandard. You might as well just go naked as most available bumpers don’t offer much. Some come close to being pretty good cases, but still have some rather large flaws. It seems nobody really considered making a decent bumper case for the Nexus 5, instead focusing on TPU/Hybrid/Hardcases.
I guess the market for strictly true bumper cases isn’t very large, but there are people who would still like a true bumper case. Since I started putting skins on the back of my phone, a bumper was the best option. I still prefer minimalism (and would still be using the Quicksand hardcases if I didn’t put a skin on), so I opted not to have a normal case with a clear plastic window on the back as that would add too much bulk for my liking.
That’s where the Replica Nexus 4 Bumper comes in. When I initially saw it though, I dismissed it based on pricing alone! I mean who honestly would pay $25+ for a then unproven “Replica” of a last generation phone’s bumper case?
Not me!
I wouldn’t pay $25+ for any case, even if it was a big brand name. No piece(s) of plastic, regardless of what brand is stamped on it, is worth that price to me. The $0.99 Quicksand hardcases and semi-transparent hardcases also proved that you can have fantastic (IMO even better) cases for dirt cheap in comparison to the same style cases of the bigger brands (eg: Spigen Ultra Fit/Ringke Slim/Google Snap Case).
But enough ranting (sorry my bad, that was quite a long one…)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A little while later, the bumper dropped to something more reasonable, less than 1/4 of the price it was originally going for! Then I figured, “What the hell, why not? It’s only $6.99 now.”
And then… What turned out to be the best Nexus 5 bumper case was on its way.
“We have to go back!!”
So, it’s kind of funny that with all of these other bumper cases out for the Nexus 5 (I’ve bought a bunch and only put a review up for one other bumper as the rest just plain sucked), that my favorite would turn out to be not a new design, but an old design that was made for the Nexus 4! I guess that old saying of, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!” really holds true here. I will say it. This replica Nexus 4 bumper case, is the best bumper case you will find for the Nexus 5. Take an old design, stretch it out a bit, slap it on the Nexus 5, WIN!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Materials and Build Quality:
This bumper case is made of a two piece construction. The black portion is a very flexible yet hard (dense not rigid) TPU. It’s durable, and from the rather massive tumble my phone took after being knocked out of my hand, offers great drop protection too! The gray/silver portion is a flexible hard plastic that seems to have just as much bend to it as the TPU portion. Both together absorb impacts pretty well and from the looks of it, despite landing and bouncing around on pavement, only scuffed up the silver finish on the hard plastic with no other visible damage whatsoever to the case, and more importantly, the phone is still pristine! You can think of this two piece construction along the lines of other hard and soft combo cases like the Spigen Neo Hybrid, minus the back.
The black TPU portion also has a texture with a ton of little indentations for a nice feel. Your fingers will like it. It adds a lot of grip and gives it an overall nicer look than just having the standard flat TPU. The TPU is also a matte finish, so there won’t be any visible fingerprints on the bumper. This is true for the hard plastic as well. Since it isn’t a shiny finish, and sticks to gray/silver, fingerprints don’t show.
Proper buttons are such a welcome addition!!
Most cases just have buttons that are part of the mold or holes that are cut out.
With regards to the first type, when the button is just a part of the mold, most times the tactile feedback is almost nonexistent. You don’t know if you’ve pressed anything, or the button double presses, or sometimes it just doesn’t work at all… When it is just a cut out hole, unless it is a thin case, a lot of the times the proportions become out of whack and it feels like you have to dig your finger in to press the button, or sometimes you miss the location completely. Neither is a problem with this bumper case! The buttons here are real additional buttons inserted in the plastic frame!!
The feels baby, the feels!
There is a nice tactile feedback. The buttons are loose but not giggly/rattle loose. And the most important part, when you press the button, it feels like a damn button! It clicks when it’s supposed to click, and you know it clicks. It works and feels just the way it should. You’d be surprised how so many case manufacturers get this wrong with their cases...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fit and Feel in Hand:
The bumper fits the phone like a glove. There are no gaps, it isn’t loose, and the phone doesn’t move around in the case. It fits perfectly and feels solid in the hand. That’s not to say that it’s so tight that you can’t take it off if you needed to. It does take a bit of wiggling, but it does come off without too much difficulty. All you need to do is stretch out a corner first, pop out the corner of the phone, and then the rest slips right out, no problems.
The bumper does add a bit of girth to the sides, top, and bottom of the phone. This is unavoidable of course, as all cases (unless it’s a snap on hardcase) will have to add some bulk. Despite it adding a bit to the width, the phone still feels good in the hand and doesn’t feel very bulky. This is because there is no back to the case, so the phone still feels thin in the hand even though it’s wider! So unlike other cases that can make it seem like you have a brick in your hand instead of a phone because of both extra width and thickness, this one still feels good. You can still feel the slight rounded back of the Nexus 5 and the overall profile is still pretty thin.
The part that can be a bit annoying, and I guess this goes for a lot of cases out there, is the headphone cutout. The case was designed to only accommodate thin earbud style headphones with the thin input jack. This tends to happen with a lot of cases, and while it kind of sucks, it’s not a deal breaker. I guess they assume most people will just use earbuds, but I like using a proper set of headphones sometimes and it would have been nice to have a bigger hole (all case manufacturers should take this into consideration).
I did resort to buying an extension adapter cable that is thin and fits in the hole. Then I just plug my headphones into the adapter cable and all is well. I wish I didn’t have to do that though, but it isn’t too much of a hassle.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Protection:
Well of course being a bumper case it has to you know... protect from bumps and such. So does it fare well? I did mention earlier that the phone was knocked out of my hand and took a big fall and tumbled along the pavement. The bumper performed like a champ! The phone is still perfect, and there is very minimal damage done to the case, just scuffed paint. There are no dents, cracked plastic, or broken off pieces of TPU; the case is still pretty much in tip top shape. So in terms of drop protection, it’s all good!
There is a nice lip over the front of the phone for those of you who do the phone face down on a table thing. It is also good to note that the lip accommodates tempered glass screen protectors very well (and I assume plastic ones as well). You can see from the pic above that the lip perfectly presses against all sides of the glass screen protector but doesn’t lift it in any way. So for those of you who want additional protection for your screen, you won’t have any problems with this case messing with your screen protector. The lip, while high, doesn’t impede swiping at all. You can still easily swipe your fingers from the sides and screen feedback isn’t affected.
Another concern is the lift on the back. Being a bumper case, people may think the back still scrapes against the table, or that the camera might still scratch against things. Well you don’t have to worry. The top lip of the case lifts the phone up high enough that there is a nice gap between the phone and the table. You can see in the photos below how the top lip of the bumper case gives it a nice space. You can even see the camera lens hovering over the table. So don’t worry, the lens is lifted and the back of the phone won’t get scratches either. You may think that the sides help in lifting the phone, but the gap between the phone and the table is created entirely from the top and bottom lips of the bumper only.
In the last pic you can see better the nice lip at the top which is higher than the camera, the nice bottom lip as well, and the sides keeping a thin profile to keep the phone feeling slim overall.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Conclusions:
This is an easy one!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How to remove the bumper:
Some people were having a bit of difficulty removing the bumper case from the phone as it is a nice and snug fit. So here is a video demo of what I do when I take it off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great review, thanks for taking the time to share it with us.
Ordered it a week ago! Still waiting eagerly and excitedly for it to arrive!
I don't like this guy. He keeps posting great reviews and makes me buy **** I don't really need. Not cool dude.
^ Agreed.After seeing his phone I am now planning to order this case and a skin for my phone.And I actually ordered a special debit card cause the one I had didn't work for international transactions.
tridibsahabd said:
I don't like this guy. He keeps posting great reviews and makes me buy **** I don't really need. Not cool dude.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha, sorry dude!
This is probably going to be my last review thread though anyway, as I don't think I'll be buying anymore accessories for this phone. At least all of the accessories I made reviews for are not very expensive! They won't break the bank.
varunthapliyal999 said:
^ Agreed.After seeing his phone I am now planning to order this case and a skin for my phone.And I actually ordered a special debit card cause the one I had didn't work for international transactions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice! Be sure to post some pictures when you have it all put together.
Any UK sellers? All those auction for some reason do not ship to UK?!
prb304 said:
Any UK sellers? All those auction for some reason do not ship to UK?!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've updated the OP with where you can buy it if you're in the UK. Unfortunately it's a little bit more expensive. But it seems that no sellers on ebay ship this case to the UK...
great!! thank you for this review...
i have this bumper too! is the best real bumper that i have bought
There weren't any problems putting the case with a dbrand skin on the back right? I have the white version of this case and I'm going to apply my dbrand back cover soon and was wondering if you had any trouble putting it on (i have dbrand matte frames on right now on mine)
charly_mad said:
great!! thank you for this review...
i have this bumper too! is the best real bumper that i have bought
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah! It really is a fantastic bumper. By far the best out of all the bumpers I've bought.
AHomelessGuy said:
There weren't any problems putting the case with a dbrand skin on the back right? I have the white version of this case and I'm going to apply my dbrand back cover soon and was wondering if you had any trouble putting it on (i have dbrand matte frames on right now on mine)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's just a back skin, there are no problems fitting the bumper on. The fit is pretty much perfect though on a naked phone, when I had side skins on, the bumper wouldn't fit. It would rub against the sides of the skin and start peeling it off.
I suggest if you are going to use this bumper, then remove the side skins from the phone first.
man I love your reviews!
thanks for the pics, I'm waiting for mine still
Bought one.
Hope it would be better with Mahogani dbrand skin.
Spigen Utlra Hybrid is a piece of crap for me.
Is this the same as the one that's on amazon by "notch it"??
carlost24 said:
Is this the same as the one that's on amazon by "notch it"??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, notch it is reselling the same cases on amazon for more than double the price.
Berthaconners524 said:
another great review. You make it difficult to make a decision.
You should be a professional salesman, if you aren't already.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hah, thanks bud!
Not a salesman though, I'm a P.E Teacher/student (with too many breaks between classes). Just a nerdy one I guess that might be in the wrong field! :laugh:
mmmmBACON said:
I opted not to have a normal case with a clear plastic window on the back as that would add too much bulk for my liking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They do make cases with clear backs that add very little bulk. The Ringke Fusion Crystal View case is a perfect example. I'm just very paranoid about scratching the back. I want maximum resale value.
wolfen69 said:
They do make cases with clear backs that add very little bulk. The Ringke Fusion Crystal View case is a perfect example. I'm just very paranoid about scratching the back. I want maximum resale value.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well it's not just the bulk thing for me. I'm not the biggest fan of clear plastic windows on the back. They are fingerprint magnets, and my hands tend to be moist a lot of the time. And once you get scratches on the plastic, the window looks like crap when it's marked up. I also kind of think it just looks tacky with a clear window. Just personal preference (not trying to knock you purchase or anything).
With the bumper, the back of the phone is lifted off of the table so there won't be any scratches as there is no contact. And with a skin on the back of the phone, if by chance anything did scrape, it would be the vinyl skin and not the back of the phone that got marked up. Despite it not looking like it offers much, the combo of skin + bumper + tempered glass on the front is giving me fantastic overall protection, and I prefer the feel and thinness that the case with no back provides.
mmmmBACON said:
And once you get scratches on the plastic, the window looks like crap when it's marked up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the whole point. Better that the case get scratched than the phone. What do I do once the phone gets scratched? Get a new back? I can always get a new case for real cheap. If you don't like them, that's OK. But as mentioned earlier, to me resale value is important.
wolfen69 said:
That's the whole point. Better that the case get scratched than the phone. What do I do once the phone gets scratched? Get a new back? I can always get a new case for real cheap. If you don't like them, that's OK. But as mentioned earlier, to me resale value is important.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It scratches the plastic because the back of the case is generally in contact with the table or surface. This bumper, if you saw all of the pics, raises the back of the phone off of the table making a nice gap. You don't scratch the back because the back of the phone is lifted. The skin also gives additional protection, and IMO looks better overall. Resale value is the same as the bumper lifts by a good margin and the skin gives additional scratch protection.
I understand you're all about resale, but you get just as good protection with this bumper and adding in the skin makes it that much more appealing to me without having to look through a plastic window. As much as possible, I went for protection, without sacrificing overall aesthetics. I love the look of the bumper + skin + tempered glass, and the thinness remains while still having all of the protection of a normal case. I bought the phone for me, I want to enjoy how it looks and feels in my hand.
Again, like I mentioned earlier, I'm not knocking your purchase, and I'm happy you enjoy your case. That style of case is just not appealing to me is all.
Which screen protector are you using on your N5? Looks really nice. Looking to replace my crappy plastic one.