What are some good screen protectors out there that doesn't cost a fortune?
I'm convinced that Martin Fields is the best screen protector on the market. I scratched my Martin Fields today badly in the middle; unfortunately at $27 a pop, I really don't want/can't afford to buy another one.
I got some screen protectors from dcmungen last month off ebay after hearing good/decent reviews, but upon applying them today. I can say that dcmungen protectors are hot garbage. The protector doesn't cover the whole screen, the cut is terrible, it feels like rubbery Saran wrap, not glass like Martin Fields.
Clarivue. Mine's been great. Only has cutouts for the front camera, earpiece, and light sensors.
You'll like it more if you have a case that covers the very edges of the screen, as the protector doesn't go all the way up to the edge.
I really like the Invisible Shield products. Had one on my G1 and have one now for the EVO. It covers everything but the Camera.
http://www.zagg.com/invisibleshield/htc-evo-4g-cases-screen-protectors-covers-skins-shields.php
fragchild said:
I really like the Invisible Shield products. Had one on my G1 and have one now for the EVO. It covers everything but the Camera.
http://www.zagg.com/invisibleshield/htc-evo-4g-cases-screen-protectors-covers-skins-shields.php
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
not if he doesn't like a rubbery feel and wants it to feel like glass, because the zagg's feel incredibly rubbery.
I picked up some case-mate protectors at a Sprint Store, precut and cover the whole front. [cmo11782] package of 3 $12.99
ghost armor is the best IMO, tried stealthgaurd and invisoshield and they just feel weird, never really liked any of the .99 cent ebay or $10 sprint store protectors. ghost armor feels natural on the screen and does a good job protecting it.
bryank930 said:
Clarivue. Mine's been great. Only has cutouts for the front camera, earpiece, and light sensors.
You'll like it more if you have a case that covers the very edges of the screen, as the protector doesn't go all the way up to the edge.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try this.
Ghostarmor and Invisibleshiled = garbage. I have tried both; doesn't feel smooth like Martin Fields.
I got some screen protectors from the ebay auctions with batteries, case, and cables, and am pleasantly surprised.
They cover the whole screen. I want to take a hole punch to the front camera slot. The clarity is way better than the Sprint's anti-glare one. I was really beginning to hate my screen until changing to a clearer screen protector.
My only gripe could just be my faulty install, but the edges are coming up every where my old screen protector didn't cover. I figure it's from the oils left behind. Also, if it gets dirty/oily, it tends to get sticky & make Swyping difficult.
bryank930 said:
Clarivue. Mine's been great. Only has cutouts for the front camera, earpiece, and light sensors.
You'll like it more if you have a case that covers the very edges of the screen, as the protector doesn't go all the way up to the edge.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I love my clairvue also. I've been using martin fields for my last 4 devices but lately their screen protectors have been much easier to scratch than their earlier material, and because of that, they became overpriced for me. I tried a clairvue as a replacement for my martin fields on my old TP2 and thought that it was good quality for much less cost, so then i went for it on my Evo.
My innocase rugged combo also came with a seidio screen protector, but it covered the front camera and sensors also. Although i don't think it should matter in theory, i appreciate the cutouts that clairvue has for their evo protectors.
BoxWave are the absolute best. They feel smooth like glass; can't tell the difference when they're on or off screen clarity/quality-wise; they have cut-outs for the light sensor, earpiece, and camera; and they go all the way to the edge so if you put it on right with no dust or air bubbles you can't even tell it's on.
I have had my Evo since release day. I have no screen protector on it and I show off how awesome the screen is by taking my keys to it at least once a week. I also have zero scratches. I can attest to how big a waste of money a screen protector is on the Evo.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
I got a scratch on mine from my keys in my pocket
Whattaya know....
I ordered a replacement digitizer/glass for 70 bucks and i absolutely WILL be using a screen protector from now on. After this post i'll be getting mine from boxwave. I like the hard, non flimsy films
skydeaner said:
I like the hard, non flimsy films
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what she (he?) said . . .
I vote Ghost Armor, I absolutely love mine!
I will submit my vote for boxwave as well. I can hardly remember I have my screen covered most of the time.
skydeaner said:
I got a scratch on mine from my keys in my pocket
Whattaya know....
I ordered a replacement digitizer/glass for 70 bucks and i absolutely WILL be using a screen protector from now on. After this post i'll be getting mine from boxwave. I like the hard, non flimsy films
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got a tiny (very small) scratch on the glass, time to order up some screen protectors again
I bought a 3 pack from handhelditems.com and have been very happy with their feel and quality. They were cheap too...
They are a lot more slippery and feel better overall than the ghost armor on my girls Evo.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
bryank930 said:
Clarivue. Mine's been great. Only has cutouts for the front camera, earpiece, and light sensors.
You'll like it more if you have a case that covers the very edges of the screen, as the protector doesn't go all the way up to the edge.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Diddo. Best screen protector I've ever used period. Better finger feel than bare screen.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
Zagg and others
Guys and Gals, I made the mistake of putting a Zagg film on my Evo and let me tell you that they stain and yellow very quickly. These types of vinyl products stain badly and apart from turning yellow, it was getting a dark line across the front of the film which corresponded to the black leather holster I put the phone into...the black leather staining the film across the front. In addition, a fingerprint developed on the surface of the film that would not go away. All this happened in 4 weeks. In other words guys, the film offers great protection, but if you like the clarity of the screen and don't want to be looking through stains on the Zagg screen protector, save yourself some time and money and go find another screen protector. All these films, like Zagg, that claim that they're used to protect helicopter blades from nicks in the military are the same crap. They all stain. Yes, they'll gladly replace the product if you call them, but you're back to the same staining film. In my book, that's not worth the effort. That's my two cents worth.
Lyiondr said:
I will submit my vote for boxwave as well. I can hardly remember I have my screen covered most of the time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Boxwave has terrible customer service. I have been trying to get a replacement for over a month and I still do not have it. I would avoid at all costs.
Related
Ordered this screen protector( http://tinyurl.com/24pks3g) on Mon. Hope it comes today since that is when I will be getting this phone. Anybody ever use clearfreak screen protectors before? Any good? I hope it doesn't look orange peely like the zagg on my g1.
just got my clearfreak yesterday but won't have the phone until 7/23
it feels thinner & more flexible than the zagg , and the cutouts are correct for the vibrant where the zagg has the cutouts for the i9000
larryccf said:
just got my clearfreak yesterday but won't have the phone until 7/23
it feels thinner & more flexible than the zagg , and the cutouts are correct for the vibrant where the zagg has the cutouts for the i9000
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just ordered a Clearfreak myself.
(And found the coupon CLEARFREAK4 for 30% off )
Satertek said:
Just ordered a Clearfreak myself.
(And found the coupon CLEARFREAK4 for 30% off )
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for sharing the coupon! I just ordered one. It will probably get here before the phone does
Thanks, I'll be ordering one as well .
I'm thinking of picking one of these up.
I've used a Zagg on my G1 which was nice at first, but became real ugly after a while. I eventually removed it because it looked really gross on the edges.
How does this compare? I plan on only getting the screen cover, don't need the back covered.
Why is it cheaper on ebay? It appears to be the official clearfreak ebay account, but their prices are much better (even with coupon) than their website offers. What gives?
Any reason not to put this on my phone? What I liked about the Zagg was that I could just wipe it down once with my shirt and all the smudges were gone instantly. I also liked the smoother surface for gliding my finger. It seems without the Zagg my G1 screen had too much friction.
I've used lots of different brands of screen protectors and found the Invisible Shield to be my least favorite. They are a good product, I just don't like the texture of them - it's a personal preference.
I'm considering not using a protector on this phone, though. I always used a screen protector in the past, even on my clamshell phones, but the durability videos floating around are pretty impressive. Not sure if it's technically Gorilla Glass, but whatever they use, it seems pretty damned tough.
For those of you with a unit in-hand, how durable does that glass seem?
rembonjaski said:
For those of you with a unit in-hand, how durable does that glass seem?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got mine yesterday but I am not quite ready to test the durability. Maybe a braver soul can help though.
BTW I am in for one from Clearfreak from eBay.
Also I don't recommend buying the T-Mobile screen protector, it doesn't cover the whole front, which on this phone is just weird.
I'm not sure about durability as I'm not willing to do any crazy test, but it's going to be hard going with a screen protector b/c the screen is just so nice to use.
That glass really does a nice job with fingerprints. Obviously they're still there, but the glass seems to reduce the effect and they aren't noticeable at all when you're using the phone.
I hear that most screen protectors make fingerprints more noticeable and aren't nearly as smooth.
yet but no matter how hard the glass, it will show degradation from windborne sand, grit etc, or grit/sand in your pocket, salt on your fingers etc
i've got watches with hardened sapphire crystals that i have to polish occasionlly with diamond grinding compound (same stuff used on optical lenses) cause the surface shows microscopic pitting, scratches etc
I've only every used clarivue protectors in the past. I liked them and I will probably post from them when available. Not sure how it will work with swype though.
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
hey when you get your clearfreaks on your vibrants, can you post how you feel about them. Im lookin for a protector for the captivate and am nitpicky about image quality and touch sensitivity.
I bought the T-Mobile screen protector and I'm not happy at all. It gives the screen a grainy look. I just ordered the Clearfreak one. Its $5.99 on Ebay sold by them.
http://cgi.ebay.com/CLEAR-FRONT-LCD...ewItem&pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item45f40a3346
flexnix said:
I bought the T-Mobile screen protector and I'm not happy at all. It gives the screen a grainy look.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I second this. I removed mine immediately! It turns an amazing display into an average one. Looking forward to the clearfreak reports.
From looking at the eBay pic the ClearFreak doesn't have cutouts for the front facing camera. I checked the Zagg site and their's does.
BradBot said:
From looking at the eBay pic the ClearFreak doesn't have cutouts for the front facing camera. I checked the Zagg site and their's does.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There isn't a Front Facing camera for the Vibrant. The one on Zagg is a cutout for the i9000.
Ok I just installed the clearfreak screen protector, followed the directions on their video and and it came out alright I guess, not perfect though. I'm sure it will take some time too set in , but I can see some fingerprints even though I had them wet the whole time. hopefully it improves. When the phone is lit up you can't see any of the flaws and swiping through screens is flawless and very responsive.
I have include two pics, mind you these were take within 30 min. of installing it.
Uploaded with ImageShack.us
Uploaded with ImageShack.us
Update: After a few hours it has settled in quite nicely. The finger prints that I thought were there initially are now gone and is super smooth almost too where I forget its even there. Good buy!
the martin fields video had a nice tip for handling the screen protector without getting fignerprints on the sticky side
check the video on their website, but it was a simple idea - using two pcs of scotch tape on either side with half of of the tape not on the protector - gives the user a small "handle" area to use to hold the screen while trying to position it correctly on the phone
just a suggestion
badaphooko01 said:
Ordered this screen protector( http://tinyurl.com/24pks3g) on Mon. Hope it comes today since that is when I will be getting this phone. Anybody ever use clearfreak screen protectors before? Any good? I hope it doesn't look orange peely like the zagg on my g1.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I go to walmart get 3-4 sheets for about 8.00 and cut them to size, they work great.
While I do like Swyping, I find that it becomes difficult as one's hands get a tiny bit sweaty or even dirty. You fingers seem to stick to the screen which makes Swyping fairly difficult and almost impossible to be accurate. While I do try to be as clean as possible, sometimes your hands get sweaty for whatever reasons such as if you wear gloves or keep them in your pockets for a while.
I am just wondering if there is a screen protector out there that allows for a totally smooth surface, despite any sweat, dirt or other things that could be on your fingers? I recently got the Realooks and while they are very clear and does a good job resembling the feeling of the bare screen, it has the same issues while Swyping. There may even be a little bit more of a finger resistance with the Realooks on.
I was thinking and thought that maybe a screen protector with a matte finish would be ideal for Swyping. Matte screen protectors are smooth and most are anti-fingerprint which I assume would be very good for Swyping.
Has anyone had any experience with a matte finish screen protector while Swyping?
Any suggestions overall?
i use an anti-glare screen protector from Clarivue (.com) that is matte finish and has a very smooth surface that makes using swype very comfortable and easy. I used clarivue on my N1 as well when i had swype, and i recently got the captivate and i couldnt live without the smooth surface from the screen protector so i had to buy another pack. it is anti scratch and anti smudge, although from what ive seen, it does affect the clarity of the amoled to a certain extent.
I use whatever screen protector that my AT&T store sold - works well with swype.
i have something similar to the invisashield body shield but i cant remember who made mine. i ordered off ebay an in came in an envelope with no branding. like someone with a laser etcher/cutter got a hold of the material and made it in his garage. it has the typical invisishield orange peel look but feels like it has natural oils in it. it is always very slick and doesn't show finger prints. it never feels greasy or sticky or dry. just slightly oily but i have heard that's not typical of the invisishield brand so it might not be the same material. if i come across the add ill post it.
also antiglare protectors are good for that but the ones i bought had bad adhesive on the edges, also i find that anti glare have a good amount of reflection to them and are only better than hard plastic protectors that can be milky, i can read through an invisishield in sunlight better than an anti glare and no screen protector at all is better than that.
Skinomi...I dig it.
kegobeer said:
I use whatever screen protector that my AT&T store sold - works well with swype.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed.
Plus these screen protectors cover the entire front of the phone. Can't even tell it's on there. I've seen others that only cover the display area.
Shovelhead84 said:
Skinomi...I dig it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Dm
Needmorechar
EpicEric said:
Agreed.
Plus these screen protectors cover the entire front of the phone. Can't even tell it's on there. I've seen others that only cover the display area.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
For $10 and you can go buy them locally, it was ideal. Seems to work just as well as without the protector.
Gorilla glass with no screen protector.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
I looking for the best screen protect for my capy
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Took three tries and a slight trim of the long edge, but 3 ANTI GLARE Screen LCD for Samsung Captivate Galaxy S off ebay gave me what I want: a bubble free matte screen installation. item #380262378182.
Thanks I going to order from ebay
You don't NEED a screen protector.
The Samsung Galaxy S has Gorilla Glass from Corning.
Check a torture test here (on a Dell Streak, which I also have - but it has the same glass) and tell me if you really need a lousy plastic sheet on your beautiful screen.
Check out the gorilla glass website. The got a pictireo of a gorilla with its arse up in the air kissing a pane of glass LOLS
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
FWIW, My phone hangs out in my pocket all day, every day, with keys and loose change etc. I have zero scratches on the glass and the naked glass feels much better than any screen protector IMHO.
Don't get yourself all worked up over choosing the "right" screen protector. Just buy the 3 pack from at&t and call it good
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Steinheil protectors are fantastic -- only ones I've found that don't leave smudges and fingerprints all over. (They do dull the screen a bit, but since the amoled screen is too bright to begin with, that's not a problem IMO.)
ninjuh said:
Don't get yourself all worked up over choosing the "right" screen protector. Just buy the 3 pack from at&t and call it good
+1
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
itsjustaphone said:
FWIW, My phone hangs out in my pocket all day, every day, with keys and loose change etc. I have zero scratches on the glass and the naked glass feels much better than any screen protector IMHO.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Look at it in the sun at an angle so it reflects the sun off the screen, you will see lots of micro scratches. This is on both our captivates. Sure, they're not "SCRATCHES" like the usually unsightly ones, they are just micro, or super thin.
Just because it can handle an impact doesn't mean it's scratch resistant. Personally have used the Phantom Skinz protector in the past and am currently using the Realook protector now. If you like the slight rubbery feel of the "skinz" type of protector you have plenty of options. I used the Phantom Skinz because it seemed to have the least orange peel look. After exchanging my captivate for another one (I had the random shut down issue) I used the Realooks static style screen protector. I prefer this one since it's almost nake glass feeling and I can totally say it can take a decent scratch. I got a nice dent from a fall off my desk onto a barbell that dented my chasis and also nicked the screen protector but no scratches. Best thing is you get 2 so if one gets farked you still have a spare. Best screen protector is one you will use and be happy with.
It still scratches even with the Gorilla Glass. Not big scratches, but they are visible at certain angles - it may or may not bother you.
I've used two types, SGP and Realook. Both are highly regarded, and from my experience SGP doesn't have any rainbow effect like Realook, but Realook has a much more natural feel. Both are excellent.
i took off my screen protector a couple months ago and i sometimes regret it. theres a few scratches on the screen but you cant really see them unless you hold the phone at a specific angle in the light. it doesnt really bother me that much. it is kind of annoying having to clean the fingerprints though.
I have invisishield its great only paid twenty for it with a lifetime warranty you I've had mine for about 4 months and it has yet to get a scratch and I even took a knife and scraped it across the screen surely no scratches but in the end I guess it is all up preference
Sent from my Samsung captivate running 2.3b4
Dont mean to hi jack the thread but is there a way to clean a screen protector? I was installing mine and it slipped out of my hand. I have tried using scotch tape to the debris off of it but I cant get all of it. Any ideas????
Invisishield
I've had the Invisishield on my phone since late August. I just recently had to exchange that under warranty and the Invisishield removed easily and installed easily on the new phone, no air pockets at all. Still looks like the day I bought it.
jfuq20 said:
I have invisishield its great only paid twenty for it with a lifetime warranty you I've had mine for about 4 months and it has yet to get a scratch and I even took a knife and scraped it across the screen surely no scratches but in the end I guess it is all up preference
Sent from my Samsung captivate running 2.3b4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
possible one of the WORST things to put on a phone's screen. Especially a touch screen phone with one of the best glass and screens.
The invisishield and all others LIKE IT offer nothing but horrible viewing and use. The cover often resists your fingers movements, your fingers often drag on it and the smoothness of glass is all gone and replaced by a crappy rubbery and not to mention GRAINY protector.
Surprisingly, the only thing close to being clear, and smooth is the cheap stuff on ebay. I've used them and they offer great protection and are cheap enough to change out every month. I no longer use one.
for what its worth I got the BodyGuardz protectors when they were on thanks giving sale.
It does not feel like the glass, given, but i almost feel like i like that it gives just a little resistance to my touch. it does have the slightest orange peel effect but you can only see it if its off and at an angle.
Its not perfect, but I like it especially since I have a bit of OCD and it would drive me crazy if i got the smallest scratch on the screen. This gives me piece of mind.
ccdoggy said:
for what its worth I got the BodyGuardz protectors when they were on thanks giving sale.
It does not feel like the glass, given, but i almost feel like i like that it gives just a little resistance to my touch. it does have the slightest orange peel effect but you can only see it if its off and at an angle.
Its not perfect, but I like it especially since I have a bit of OCD and it would drive me crazy if i got the smallest scratch on the screen. This gives me piece of mind.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://cgi.ebay.com/3pcs-Clear-LCD-...218142?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item5add8f621e
you're better of with these. They're clear and dont have the resistance you feel with other rubbery protectors. I'd use the ebays ones before anything else, especially if you are OCD.
At $1.57 for 3, you can change it every month if you want, but I've had good luck with them in the past.
I got gadgetshieldz they cost around $6 for full body protection. Worked for me, they are quite nice easy to install and quite good in performance. A word of caution though the it took 20 days for it to get to me in Canada.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Has anyone used Realook before? They have some on pre-order and will be avail 3/15. If it is good I'll probably put in a order. Thanks!
http://www.amazon.com/Motorola-Crystal-Premium-Protector-REALOOK/dp/B004QFKB7M/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1299478352&sr=8-1
bleuiko said:
Has anyone used Realook before? They have some on pre-order and will be avail 3/15. If it is good I'll probably put in a order. Thanks!
http://www.amazon.com/Motorola-Crystal-Premium-Protector-REALOOK/dp/B004QFKB7M/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1299478352&sr=8-1
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for posting the link: I have been looking for it the last coupple of weeks! I had it on my Samsung Vibrant and in my opinion it is the absolute best screen protector out there!
i'm using the ones from Skinomi and its pretty much impossible to tell its on there if u get it on right =)
djkinetic said:
i'm using the ones from Skinomi and its pretty much impossible to tell its on there if u get it on right =)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Skinomi is like InvisibleShield and require a wet application? I want a normal shield protector that just a stick on. Is Realook a wet application too?
bleuiko said:
Skinomi is like InvisibleShield and require a wet application? I want a normal shield protector that just a stick on. Is Realook a wet application too?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ya but in my experience they last longer then just the stick on ones
djkinetic said:
ya but in my experience they last longer then just the stick on ones
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My experience was just the opposite. My InvisibleShield kept peeling but my dry install screen protector was near perfect. I had the iPhone 3GS before the Atrix so I had a Power Support screen protector.
I just placed an order for Realook. I'll report in when I get it!
From the description, it is very similar to the Martin Fields protector which is slightly thick but strong and difficult to scratch.
I purchase this one early before the Realook was being sold:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004PDHS9Y
It also has good reviews from other Android phones and it comes in 3 pcs/pkg. I'll compare it to the Martin Fields.
i just bought skinomi ones for like 16$ :x
I think the Realook screens are some of the best out there. The surface feel of it is very good albeit not as slick as those anti-glare ones. They aren't the most anti-finger goo, but they're not any worse than any other screen. When the phone is off, and you look at the screen in just the right light and angle (usually 45deg oblique under a fluorescent bulb) you see a very obvious rainbow effect. Not very desirable, but is not visible at any other time so it's okay.
The protection is adequate (never really tested but it works for me). The fit is excellent. Its the regular stick on kind. No touch sensitivity impedance. I've been waiting for the realook one for the Atrix for a while now. Don't understand why it's so hard to just cut plastic sheets...
Best part is that they're not stupidly priced. $10 for 2. Good value.
My room mate got the otterbox case and it came with a screen protector also. I think its one of the best screens I've seen. It seems to be very very anti-finger goo. Gonna look into it.
So I got my Realook cover today so here is a short review:
The packaging came quite professionally and included the standard stuff you would expect from a premium screen protector: microfiber cloth, alcohol wipe for cleaning, and some applicator to aid in putting it on. Each protector was individually wrapped. So good so far.
Now the bad. Both protectors I received were slightly warped; this means that the protector is not very thick. When applied, the warp goes away and does not affect the adhesiveness. What really annoyed me was that they decided to cut out a hole for the front camera; that in itself is not bad, but they decided to cut a U-shape out to the edge of the phone instead of just a circle. This, to me, is laziness or cost-cutting. This cut leaves a part of my screen unprotected. The second issue is that the part around the speaker hole are slightly bent and bubbled, making the protector not stick perfectly on the screen.
See my attached photo for these two issues.
Overall, I would give this protector a 7/10. The protector also shows a rainbow hue when seen from an angle. This doesn't bother me too much, especially when the screen is on, but I expected more. All in all, for $11 bucks for 2, it's not a bad bang for the buck but I'll probably try a SGP. Does anyone have a reveiw for the SGP? Does it cover the camera hole?
the Skinomi has the same outline for the camera.. I think it's standard for our phone..
bleuiko said:
So I got my Realook cover today so here is a short review:
The packaging came quite professionally and included the standard stuff you would expect from a premium screen protector: microfiber cloth, alcohol wipe for cleaning, and some applicator to aid in putting it on. Each protector was individually wrapped. So good so far.
Now the bad. Both protectors I received were slightly warped; this means that the protector is not very thick. When applied, the warp goes away and does not affect the adhesiveness. What really annoyed me was that they decided to cut out a hole for the front camera; that in itself is not bad, but they decided to cut a U-shape out to the edge of the phone instead of just a circle. This, to me, is laziness or cost-cutting. This cut leaves a part of my screen unprotected. The second issue is that the part around the speaker hole are slightly bent and bubbled, making the protector not stick perfectly on the screen.
See my attached photo for these two issues.
Overall, I would give this protector a 7/10. The protector also shows a rainbow hue when seen from an angle. This doesn't bother me too much, especially when the screen is on, but I expected more. All in all, for $11 bucks for 2, it's not a bad bang for the buck but I'll probably try a SGP. Does anyone have a reveiw for the SGP? Does it cover the camera hole?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Trust me when I say cutting the U instead of the circle is better. With the circle, if they just punch it out, it warps the material between the speaker and the camera, and leaves a bubble. iPhone 4 screen protectors are bad for this. The AT&T official screen protectors do this too, and it works fine.
I will be putting mine and the gf's on tonight..
From Me
I've been considering getting a screen protector for a while now. The problem I have is my hands sweat very badly (gross I know) and then the touch screen on my phone goes crazy from the water on the screen. I have never had this problem with any phone I've had before now. I think it is because the Atrix touch screen is more sensitive than any other phone I've had. I was wondering if a screen protector would fix this problem and what some good brands were to try. Thanks
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
You should always have a screen protector on any smart device you care about. One grain of sand in your pocket can ruin your screen (and your day). That said....
A screen protector will likely NOT fix your problem, as water (sweat) registers as a capacative touch. For a screen protector to "fix" the registration of sweat, it would have to also "fix" the registration of a desired capacitive touch (finger, stylus, or otherwise).
The only manner in which a screen protector could help is if you could find a very hydrophobic one (the repells and beads water), though you would still need to soak up that water with your shirt or a handkerchief or something. I'm not sure they even sell these. Google is your friend, here. Use keywords hydrophobic and/or water-repellent. Good luck, my friend, and let us know if you find anything interesting!
-omni
I tried few of a kind and decided to go with Otterbox Defender case which has a transparent front panel.
Refurbished case is about $20-25 and as good as a new one.
No need for screen protector. No mess with applying one...
What if I put on an average screen protector and then sprayed it with some form of water repellent?
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
jadwv2210 said:
What if I put on an average screen protector and then sprayed it with some form of water repellent?
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Water repellent spray wouldn't work because the screen protectors are vinyl or polyurethane and are not absorbent. Those hydrophobic sprays only work with an absorbent material like cloth or real leather.
Use car wax, something like the rain-x.
jamesc760 said:
Use car wax, something like the rain-x.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I was talking about. It works on car windshields so it should work on a screen protector right?
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
jadwv2210 said:
That's what I was talking about. It works on car windshields so it should work on a screen protector right?
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
only one way to find out...!
I have to disagree with the statement that you have to have a screen protector, we have gorilla glass! I have never had a protector and my screen looks great! As for this situation, a protector that has a little rubberized feel might work well. I would read reviews on Amazon and buy the one that people complain the most about it sticking!
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
FWIW, my wife has been w/o a screen protector since April and I've been with / without one on and off since June.
Still not a single scratch on either phone, however, without one the screen is too smooth, so I'm thinking of going back installing one.
Hope this helps...
I went without a screen protector for a few months. I took the phone outside and noticed TONS of very fine scratches. You could only see them in direct sunlight, but it bothered me enough that I got a screen protector shortly thereafter.
I was thinking to buy a Vikuiti ADQC27. Has anyone tried it?
Thanks
I have to second the rec for the Otterbox Defender case. Having the screen protector built in is pretty awesome and in my experience, it has withstood all kind of liquidy stuff on it and plenty of goopy stuff as well. Like those technical terms?
It hasn't hampered my touch screen through various roms with various sensitivities and my glowing review hasn't even hit all the protection benefits it gives.
Best part? I got mine for about $10 'used' on ebay and while the silicone part was a little loose, a quick email to Otterbox got me a free placement in the mail without any hassle.
I haven't used one myself, but if they make one for the Atrix and if it's what you are really looking for, Zagg stuff has made some of my friends really happy.
You should look into a Matte one where is almost smudge free
altho it looks slightly foggy and scratch easily, but its worth it
make sure u get like a few togehter on ebay so you have backup ones
I have to second the rec for the Otterbox Defender case. Having the screen protector built in is pretty awesome and in my experience, it has withstood all kind of liquidy stuff on it and plenty of goopy stuff as well. Like those technical terms?
It hasn't hampered my touch screen through various roms with various sensitivities and my glowing review hasn't even hit all the protection benefits it gives.
Best part? I got mine for about $10 'used' on ebay and while the silicone part was a little loose, a quick email to Otterbox got me a free placement in the mail without any hassle.
I haven't used one myself, but if they make one for the Atrix and if it's what you are really looking for, Zagg stuff has made some of my friends really happy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was looking for something less "bulky"
You should look into a Matte one where is almost smudge free
altho it looks slightly foggy and scratch easily, but its worth it
make sure u get like a few togehter on ebay so you have backup ones
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you suggest any brand? Something like the GreatShield Ultra Anti-Glare (Matte)?
I have one on mine, steinheil (SGP), while the protector gets scratched its better than the screen getting scratched.
Can't really tell the SGP ultra crystal protector is on the screen either, other than the few scratches that are on the protector now. Comes with 2 in a package if you get them.
They have an oleophobic one that is suppose to be oil resistant, maybe that one might be ideal? The ultra fine is their matted one.
If you look at the product on their webpage the 'Select a Color' changes the type of protector they have (took me a min to find the different versions they had when I looked again).
Last while the corning glass is tough, with a vickers hardness of 622kgf/mm2 in the unstrengthened and 701 in the strengthened stuff is pretty impressive.
Spec sheet for the glass can be found from corning's site using a google search, made me curious to check it.
While pretty hard something as simple and common as sand can scratch it which has a vickers hardness of about 1000....
Keys, lighters and the like are unlikely to scratch it though as unless its hardened tool steel its hardness will likely be below 650, an edge on a tungsten ring could probably do the trick though.
Anyhow I keep one on my phone, though maybe not really necessary I'd rather have a scratched screen protector than see the glass get scratched.
I'd rather have a scratched screen protector than see the glass get scratched.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am of the same mind.
Thanks for the opinion.
beaver6d9 said:
I haven't used one myself, but if they make one for the Atrix and if it's what you are really looking for, Zagg stuff has made some of my friends really happy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Zagg and Skinomi are quite nice. I like the Skinomi on my tablet maybe even a bit better than the Zagg on the Atrix, but the difference is very minimal. I'd say the Skinomi may slide slightly better than the Zagg, but you're splitting hairs.
I agree with BeakHill. SGP is great except they scratch easier than Zagg. The Ultra crystal is so clear that they don't even have a cut out for the front camera. The Ultra fine is their matte model and it is good and smooth, the crystal is nicer IMO..
The problem with SGP is they spoil you to the other brands, and they are more expensive.
ive always put a total body skin on my phone in addition to a case
http://www.bestskinsever.com/motorola-atrix-4g-skin