What setting have you found that work well for you? Callers are reporting horrible echos, and I can't seem to work them out.
Also, does't really work at all over 4G, I can hear them fine, but my voice cuts in and out. Tested it while getting 20/16 with 30ms pings.
I am using it with the GSM GN on T-Mo and have had no complaints on 3G/H+/WiFi.
I have Echo Cancellation enabled + Post Processing and Auto detect for the Echo Tail
Speaker Volume at +1
Mic Gain at -2(default)
Yeah, I'm having the same problems. I've tried GrooveIP on my GN using my home wi-fi and Talkatone (iOS5 app that does the same thing) on my iPad 2 and Talkatone is much clearer without tweaking any of the settings.
Vandalet said:
I am using it with the GSM GN on T-Mo and have had no complaints on 3G/H+/WiFi.
I have Echo Cancellation enabled + Post Processing and Auto detect for the Echo Tail
Speaker Volume at +1
Mic Gain at -2(default)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had to boost the mic gain so the caller could hear me at all, now they can sorta hear me...but their voice echos like nuts (on their end)
Many forum members use CSipSimple+GNex, but I have not been able to switch from Sipdroid to CSipSimple due to an echo issue with speaker phone mode.
I am running Stock 4.1.1 with a low-latency patch.
Anyone have some settings they use with CSipSimple so not only normal phone use, but also speaker phone work well without echo problems?
Thanks in advance!
whitedragonz83 said:
Many forum members use CSipSimple+GNex, but I have not been able to switch from Sipdroid to CSipSimple due to an echo issue with speaker phone mode.
I am running Stock 4.1.1 with a low-latency patch.
Anyone have some settings they use with CSipSimple so not only normal phone use, but also speaker phone work well without echo problems?
Thanks in advance!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried the latest version? I was using Sipdroid, and the built in Android SIP function, but the latest version of CSipSimple is outstanding, and better than both. Change to expert mode, and play around with the echo settings in the 'Media' section.
There are tons of options, and you may be able to fix your issues there. Also, try a new codec. Speex works well if you're calling over 4g/3g or you have high latency. What "low latency patch" are you using?
osi13 said:
Have you tried the latest version? I was using Sipdroid, and the built in Android SIP function, but the latest version of CSipSimple is outstanding, and better than both. Change to expert mode, and play around with the echo settings in the 'Media' section.
There are tons of options, and you may be able to fix your issues there. Also, try a new codec. Speex works well if you're calling over 4g/3g or you have high latency. What "low latency patch" are you using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the latest Google Play version of CSipSimple, but still experiencing echo issues. Are there any settings you use specifically that I can check against?
Yeh, Speex is the best choice atm for 4g/3g I feel too.
The patch is this: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1777261
It takes the delay from 40ms to 18ms, but this was more critical in ICS, which had a delay of 118ms (?) I believe. I still applied it anyways.
Try turning on "voice audio detection" to on in media settings in CSipSimple to see if it helps.
krazykeyur said:
Try turning on "voice audio detection" to on in media settings in CSipSimple to see if it helps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No luck. Still overly sensitive when on speaker phone.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Anyone have settings they use that I can compare against?
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
what settings are you specifically looking for?
krazykeyur said:
what settings are you specifically looking for?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mic levels, echo settings, audio routing settings. From what I can tell the problem might be either the Nexus has to sensitive a mic or the audio routing is wrong with the default settings in csipsimple.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
whitedragonz83 said:
Mic levels, echo settings, audio routing settings. From what I can tell the problem might be either the Nexus has to sensitive a mic or the audio routing is wrong with the default settings in csipsimple.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mic amplification : 1.0 (default)
Speaker amplification : 1.0 (default)
Echo Cancellation ON
Echo Mode is set to Speex
Media Quality is set to 4.. which is default.
Voice Audio Detection ON
Codecs : G729 and then GSM. Rest are disabled. I have set "Codec priority list per bandwidth" to off.. so it uses G729/GSM for all cases
I havent touched any settings in Audio Troubleshooting.. "Focus Audio" and "Restart stream when change routing" are on under those settings by default
krazykeyur said:
Mic amplification : 1.0 (default)
Speaker amplification : 1.0 (default)
Echo Cancellation ON
Echo Mode is set to Speex
Media Quality is set to 4.. which is default.
Voice Audio Detection ON
Codecs : G729 and then GSM. Rest are disabled. I have set "Codec priority list per bandwidth" to off.. so it uses G729/GSM for all cases
I havent touched any settings in Audio Troubleshooting.. "Focus Audio" and "Restart stream when change routing" are on under those settings by default
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I will look at these settings tonight.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
I have a Nexus 4 and I'm having similar echo problems. The person talking to me hears themselves back with a 1/2 second delay. This goes away as I turn down the speaker volume from the earpiece. In Speakerphone mode its terrible and they can hear every word they say clear as a bell 1/2 second later. I'm going to start messing with the echo settings in expert mode. I have found that all SIP programs Vonage, sipdroid, csipsimple, and grooveIP all have this problem with the Nexus 4. Thankfully Csipsimple has more options for echo on the phone so I'll report back once I figure out what works best.
Update problem fixed on my Nexus 4. I was reading through the csipsimple bug mailing list on this issue, and one of the developers pointed to a possible way of fixing echo that completely fixed it for me.
go to csipsimple google code page in the FAQ go to audio routing troubleshooting.
Basically try the Use Mode API first (which worked for me) and go down the list till your echo is gone. To test your echo I would turn up the earpiece volume all the way and set the mic gain to about half during a call in the settings page. If the other person does not hear echo you should be good.
derjuden said:
I have a Nexus 4 and I'm having similar echo problems. The person talking to me hears themselves back with a 1/2 second delay. This goes away as I turn down the speaker volume from the earpiece. In Speakerphone mode its terrible and they can hear every word they say clear as a bell 1/2 second later. I'm going to start messing with the echo settings in expert mode. I have found that all SIP programs Vonage, sipdroid, csipsimple, and grooveIP all have this problem with the Nexus 4. Thankfully Csipsimple has more options for echo on the phone so I'll report back once I figure out what works best.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
did you manage to find what the problem was ?
derjuden said:
I have a Nexus 4 and I'm having similar echo problems. The person talking to me hears themselves back with a 1/2 second delay. This goes away as I turn down the speaker volume from the earpiece. In Speakerphone mode its terrible and they can hear every word they say clear as a bell 1/2 second later. I'm going to start messing with the echo settings in expert mode. I have found that all SIP programs Vonage, sipdroid, csipsimple, and grooveIP all have this problem with the Nexus 4. Thankfully Csipsimple has more options for echo on the phone so I'll report back once I figure out what works best.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm having the same problem.... did you figure this out?
EDIT: Oops, sorry, saw you did. I'm currently using Sipdroid, I may have to switch over to CSipSimple.
I have mad echo on CM9/CM10, not for me, rather for the person on the other end whenever I am using speakerphone. It is only with AOSP based ROMs, not Touchwiz based ROMs. Touchwiz based ROMs work perfectly.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
Bump. I know other people experience this and go unhelped
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
same problem here with echo in speakerphone mode, running CM9
same problem here, friends complaining about huge echo when i'm in speakerphone mode, they say it's their own voice they hear echoing.
i would assume this is an issue of echo cancellation missing when speakerphone mode is active.
ie. sound from my phone's speaker feeding back into the phone's microphone.
Currently running:
CM9 nightly 2012-08-19 mtd on SGS i9000 international.
with icy glitch kernel for the overclocking.
I should also note that i have installed the sipdroid app, could this interfere with the speakerphone?
joshie_boi2 said:
same problem here, friends complaining about huge echo when i'm in speakerphone mode, they say it's their own voice they hear echoing.
i would assume this is an issue of echo cancellation missing when speakerphone mode is active.
ie. sound from my phone's speaker feeding back into the phone's microphone.
Currently running:
CM9 nightly 2012-08-19 mtd on SGS i9000 international.
with icy glitch kernel for the overclocking.
I should also note that i have installed the sipdroid app, could this interfere with the speakerphone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The same issue was just reported to me on my Galaxy S (i9000), running last nightly build of CM10, so it's not just S2 issue.
Edit: I checked i9000 CM10 forum and found the solution. In Advanced Settings -> In-Call Volume Controls -> Speakerphone Mic -> reduced it from 31 to about 18. The other side can still hear me well, however the echo disappeared.
Did you try disabling "noise cancellation" in the dialers settings? Worked for me.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
anyone have an in call echo of your own voice.
tell the person you are calling to turn their speaker down. Make sure the other phone is not within ear shot of your phone
shawnten said:
anyone have an in call echo of your own voice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am experiencing this problem.
On Verizon and yes it had happened to me
This only happens on aosp CM ROMs....people are telling me they can hear themselves talking and echoing back when I try to use the voice call speakerphone. This doesn't happen on stock ROMs. Does anybody else have this issue or does anybody no of a fix or work around???
I'm running on cm13 and people tell me they have a hard time hearing me with echo when i put them on speakerphone, and i have to get off it. I don't hear any echo of my own voice on my end. Seems this is an issue that doesn't appear to have any resolutions (not that i can find thus far...).
geesedude said:
I'm running on cm13 and people tell me they have a hard time hearing me with echo when i put them on speakerphone, and i have to get off it. I don't hear any echo of my own voice on my end. Seems this is an issue that doesn't appear to have any resolutions (not that i can find thus far...).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am also interested if anyone has fixed this problem.
Same issue with echo on G3 VS985
I also noticed this after switching to CM 13 ROM and now with crDroid 1.5 which is based on CM 14.1.
The echo goes away for the caller when I mute my microphone, so I can still use the speaker and then unmute when I want to talk - obviously not ideal but it seems to work.