Hi there,
I'm currently trying to maximize my battery life and I ran into something weird.
I've currently have tasker on disabling and enabling data (screen on/off), greenifying, kt747 with under volt and under clock etc.
Under normal usage I can probably get 2-2.5 hours of screen time and a total of 6 hours of usage time at work. I was told this time wasn't great and I couldnt see how I can fix this problem.
Then at home I had my wifi enabled and left my phone sitting idle and noticed it drained a lot slower. I ended up with over 1.5 days of usage and 2-3 hours of on screen time.
The odd thing is...my screen was off most of the time, meaning data was both off. Wifi was on at home, also to note the signal strength was significantly weaker at home and its LTE. Thats why I'm so piuzzled why at home I can get much better battery life
To recap:
At work: (6 hours)
HSPA (not LTE)
Great signal (full bars or over 22 on the real signal app)
screen off during idle data is off
no wifi on
At home (36 hours)
LTE/HSPA (swapping back and forth trying to get a good signal)
Terrible signal 1-2 bars (0-5 on the real signal app)
Screen off and data off
wifi is left on the entire time
My question is what is causing this difference? What am I missing here. How can I get the longer battery life without being on wifi
mikoal said:
Hi there,
I'm currently trying to maximize my battery life and I ran into something weird.
I've currently have tasker on disabling and enabling data (screen on/off), greenifying, kt747 with under volt and under clock etc.
Under normal usage I can probably get 2-2.5 hours of screen time and a total of 6 hours of usage time at work. I was told this time wasn't great and I couldnt see how I can fix this problem.
Then at home I had my wifi enabled and left my phone sitting idle and noticed it drained a lot slower. I ended up with over 1.5 days of usage and 2-3 hours of on screen time.
The odd thing is...my screen was off most of the time, meaning data was both off. Wifi was on at home, also to note the signal strength was significantly weaker at home and its LTE. Thats why I'm so piuzzled why at home I can get much better battery life
To recap:
At work: (6 hours)
HSPA (not LTE)
Great signal (full bars or over 22 on the real signal app)
screen off during idle data is off
no wifi on
At home (36 hours)
LTE/HSPA (swapping back and forth trying to get a good signal)
Terrible signal 1-2 bars (0-5 on the real signal app)
Screen off and data off
wifi is left on the entire time
My question is what is causing this difference? What am I missing here. How can I get the longer battery life without being on wifi
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ever looked in BBS (betterbatterystats) to see what was using your battery?
Also, battery life depends on a lot of factors: kernel settings, widgets, refreshes, app running in background, etc.
Running on Wifi is much easier for our device than running on data, which can explain a bit of the difference but not 5x the battery life. UC/UV can be good like it can be bad, if it takes too much time to load something = more screen time = more battery drain.
Btw, you didn't mentioned what ROM/kernel you are running?
BWolf56 said:
Ever looked in BBS (betterbatterystats) to see what was using your battery?
Also, battery life depends on a lot of factors: kernel settings, widgets, refreshes, app running in background, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey bwolf56... oh yea definitely look at my BBS, thats another question i have to resolve since it stays awake quite a bit more than I would like........but I'll go into the BBS portion a bit later.........
To address your questions.....and whats puzzling is that in both the at home and at work scenarios
- bbs are the same
- kernel settings remain the same
- widgets have been the same, refresh have been the same
- no syncs
BWolf56 said:
Running on Wifi is much easier for our device than running on data, which can explain a bit of the difference but not 5x the battery life.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree that running on wifi is easier....but in both those scenario data is off. At home its wifi, and at work its no data. Shouldn't no data take less power than wifi?
Additionally at home its, LTE, low signal, etc. Which all supposedly drain batteries.
BWolf56 said:
UC/UV can be good like it can be bad, if it takes too much time to load something = more screen time = more battery drain.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is true, my underclock has nearly insignicant increase in load time. Plus I am comapring on screen time with on screen time, not data I've read or information processed/downloaded.
BWolf56 said:
Btw, you didn't mentioned what ROM/kernel you are running?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock TW JB 4.1.1
Kernel KT747 ktoonsez latest
BWolf56 said:
....... app running in background, etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hmmm ....app running in background.......I'm not sure......this could be it? Though I try to greenify everything.
I do leave items like smanager, tasker, BBS, GO SMS Pro, and all the chats Facebook, gtalk, whats app etc......
Could it be the attempt of using those apps causes more drain when theres no data vs wifi?
BWolf56 said:
Ever looked in BBS (betterbatterystats) to see what was using your battery?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As for BBS.........deep sleep for the processor accounts for majority of the processor state.
Though the "awake" bar on the battery status shows it gets woken up quite a bit.
Both at home and at work here are the BBS data I gathered.
Kernel Wakelock
Powermanagerservice
Deleted_wake_locks
Mmc1_detect
Sec-battery-monitor
Partial Wakelock
Alarm manager
Event log services
Alarms:
Android
Android.intent.action.date_changed
Com.android.server.lightservice.action.update_svc_led
Android.intent.action.time_tick
Com.android.server.wifimanager.action.device_idle
Com.android.server.action.network_stats_poll
Com.android.server.throttlemanager.action.poll
Android.appwidget.action.appwidget_update
Com.Android.internal.policy.impl.phonewindowmanager.delayed_keyguardandroid.app.backup.intent.run
Android.content.syncmanager.sync_alarm
Android.server.wifimanager.action.delayed_driver_stop
There is an additional finding.......... I did a brief test at home without the wifi on.........with screen off.......about 4 hours the battery drain 8%....I want to say its worse without the wifi, but not as bad as I would have had at work with the screen off.......I'm still inconclusive on this point.....
What would make this easier to test is if I had wifi at work. Then I can narrow it down to wifi only......but i dont.
I'm try to investigate as much and I'm stuck.
mikoal said:
hey bwolf56... oh yea definitely look at my BBS, thats another question i have to resolve since it stays awake quite a bit more than I would like........but I'll go into the BBS portion a bit later.........
To address your questions.....and whats puzzling is that in both the at home and at work scenarios
- bbs are the same
- kernel settings remain the same
- widgets have been the same, refresh have been the same
- no syncs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here, I meant more to safe battery in general. Playing with your kernel settings can make a big difference as well as what you have on auto-refresh and widgets.
I agree that running on wifi is easier....but in both those scenario data is off. At home its wifi, and at work its no data. Shouldn't no data take less power than wifi?
Additionally at home its, LTE, low signal, etc. Which all supposedly drain batteries.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your signal strength doesn't matter so much on newer devices (especially on Wifi). Being singal-less will drain your battery but as long as you have signal, it shouldn't affect it (too much).
That is true, my underclock has nearly insignicant increase in load time. Plus I am comapring on screen time with on screen time, not data I've read or information processed/downloaded.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A 30min to 1hr screen time difference it basically what data will do. If you compare screen on time, it means your data is on. So there's something else that is hard on your battery while your screen is off at work.
Stock TW JB 4.1.1
Kernel KT747 ktoonsez latest
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Might wanna look into AOSP or a TW custom ROM if you wanna get the best battery life.
hmmm ....app running in background.......I'm not sure......this could be it? Though I try to greenify everything.
I do leave items like smanager, tasker, BBS, GO SMS Pro, and all the chats Facebook, gtalk, whats app etc......
Could it be the attempt of using those apps causes more drain when theres no data vs wifi?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Most of those will use a lot of battery if GPS/location access is on. Data doesn't help of course.
As for BBS.........deep sleep for the processor accounts for majority of the processor state.
Though the "awake" bar on the battery status shows it gets woken up quite a bit.
Both at home and at work here are the BBS data I gathered.
Kernel Wakelock
Powermanagerservice
Deleted_wake_locks
Mmc1_detect
Sec-battery-monitor
Partial Wakelock
Alarm manager
Event log services
Alarms:
Android
Android.intent.action.date_changed
Com.android.server.lightservice.action.update_svc_led
Android.intent.action.time_tick
Com.android.server.wifimanager.action.device_idle
Com.android.server.action.network_stats_poll
Com.android.server.throttlemanager.action.poll
Android.appwidget.action.appwidget_update
Com.Android.internal.policy.impl.phonewindowmanager.delayed_keyguardandroid.app.backup.intent.run
Android.content.syncmanager.sync_alarm
Android.server.wifimanager.action.delayed_driver_stop
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Kernel wakelocks are the usual;
Partial wakelocks, I dunno what event log services is coming from but if it's low, it shouldn't matter. (if high though, look into it)
Alarms, you have a lot of managers in there. Sure you need all those? lol (Are they coming from 3rd party apps?)
The time and alarms # of the above would be quite useful to know if they're bad or not.
There is an additional finding.......... I did a brief test at home without the wifi on.........with screen off.......about 4 hours the battery drain 8%....I want to say its worse without the wifi, but not as bad as I would have had at work with the screen off.......I'm still inconclusive on this point.....
What would make this easier to test is if I had wifi at work. Then I can narrow it down to wifi only......but i dont.
I'm try to investigate as much and I'm stuck.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok this last part makes it seem like it's something with your area/carrier. You mentioned that you get LTE at home but only H+ at work, which means that either your work building is in a bad reception area (or simply hard on the signal), or your carriers' towers need update.
Are you able to do some testing outside your building? In the same general area (couple kms near it).
Have you tried to disable LTE while you are at work? You might be getting battery drain while looking for LTE. I could be wrong about this but it would seem logical.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747
BWolf56 said:
Here, I meant more to safe battery in general. Playing with your kernel settings can make a big difference as well as what you have on auto-refresh and widgets.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea... I think i tried to cut down on all syncs and auto refreshes. Kernel, i've applied the most battery saving one I can find in the team kernelizer's thread. Along with changing my second CPU governor to conservative. I've tested a ton of combination, so far this is the best one I have.....
BWolf56 said:
Your signal strength doesn't matter so much on newer devices (especially on Wifi). Being singal-less will drain your battery but as long as you have signal, it shouldn't affect it (too much).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ive been reading in a lot of threads that LTE supposedly drains more than H+ and other non 4G signals. Either case, it doesnt apply to me.
I also wasnt aware that signal-less was what caused the battery drain. I do know my LTE at home fluctuates from really bad signal and the odd signal-less.
As for Wifi, I wasn't comparing the signal strength of wifi. I was simply compairing that during the off screen state
At home uses wifi
At work uses nothing.
One would think the nothing drains less than wifi?
BWolf56 said:
A 30min to 1hr screen time difference it basically what data will do. If you compare screen on time, it means your data is on. So there's something else that is hard on your battery while your screen is off at work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
During screen on time, the draining speed is understandable to see H+ draining faster than wifi.
However during off screen time, you are right, something is draining during at work.......which is a bit of a mystery
BWolf56 said:
Might wanna look into AOSP or a TW custom ROM if you wanna get the best battery life.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried CM10, AOKP, PA
sort of reverted back to stock. I just like bug and glitch free over the small customizations.
If I can apply my hours that I had from wifi to regular use....i'd be happy........
BWolf56 said:
Most of those will use a lot of battery if GPS/location access is on. Data doesn't help of course.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
of the 3
- Use wireless network
-Use GPS satellites
-location and google search
I have location and google search checked, simply because I cannot find an action in Tasker to turn that on.
When I use map, it would automatically turn on the other two.
So during screen off when data is off.......do you think this is the culprit?
BWolf56 said:
Kernel wakelocks are the usual;
Partial wakelocks, I dunno what event log services is coming from but if it's low, it shouldn't matter. (if high though, look into it)
Alarms, you have a lot of managers in there. Sure you need all those? lol (Are they coming from 3rd party apps?)
The time and alarms # of the above would be quite useful to know if they're bad or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ALarm maanger was higher than event log services.......
As for Alarms......I really dont know where they are coming from. I would like to rid them if poissible
Sure thing! Im not too familiar with reading logcats and BBS dumps. I've attached them here. Maybe you can decipher them.
I may do the same over in Chamonix's thread.
BWolf56 said:
Ok this last part makes it seem like it's something with your area/carrier. You mentioned that you get LTE at home but only H+ at work, which means that either your work building is in a bad reception area (or simply hard on the signal), or your carriers' towers need update.
Are you able to do some testing outside your building? In the same general area (couple kms near it).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea at home its LTE but the signal is so bad i would lose all signal sometimes and sometimes get H+
At work its a constant powerful and strong H+ full bars.
aybarrap1 said:
Have you tried to disable LTE while you are at work? You might be getting battery drain while looking for LTE. I could be wrong about this but it would seem logical.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i can give this a try and test it out.
I assumed that since Im getting full H+ that they wont look for LTE......
mikoal said:
Yea... I think i tried to cut down on all syncs and auto refreshes. Kernel, i've applied the most battery saving one I can find in the team kernelizer's thread. Along with changing my second CPU governor to conservative. I've tested a ton of combination, so far this is the best one I have.....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your cpu_0 governor being.. Ktoonservative? And what about your scheduler? I personally get great results with row (noop screen off).
Ive been reading in a lot of threads that LTE supposedly drains more than H+ and other non 4G signals. Either case, it doesnt apply to me.
I also wasnt aware that signal-less was what caused the battery drain. I do know my LTE at home fluctuates from really bad signal and the odd signal-less.
As for Wifi, I wasn't comparing the signal strength of wifi. I was simply compairing that during the off screen state
At home uses wifi
At work uses nothing.
One would think the nothing drains less than wifi?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It isn't actually ''nothing''. It still has to communicate with the towers, if it only sends H+, it might be because it's having trouble (or that area doesn't have LTE just yet). That being said, your device might be perma looking for LTE and can't get it = causing battery drain.
During screen on time, the draining speed is understandable to see H+ draining faster than wifi.
However during off screen time, you are right, something is draining during at work.......which is a bit of a mystery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Answer *might* be just above.
I tried CM10, AOKP, PA
sort of reverted back to stock. I just like bug and glitch free over the small customizations.
If I can apply my hours that I had from wifi to regular use....i'd be happy........
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Might wanna look into a custom TW ROM that is stable then. Intergalactic, Rootbox and couple others are quite popular around here.
of the 3
- Use wireless network
-Use GPS satellites
-location and google search
I have location and google search checked, simply because I cannot find an action in Tasker to turn that on.
When I use map, it would automatically turn on the other two.
So during screen off when data is off.......do you think this is the culprit?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It definitely doesn't help. location access is a big battery drainer for sure. Might wanna look into manually turning it on when you need it.
ALarm maanger was higher than event log services.......
As for Alarms......I really dont know where they are coming from. I would like to rid them if poissible
Sure thing! Im not too familiar with reading logcats and BBS dumps. I've attached them here. Maybe you can decipher them.
I may do the same over in Chamonix's thread.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At work atm, can't take a look at them. Perhaps someone else can help you in the meantime for those.
Yea at home its LTE but the signal is so bad i would lose all signal sometimes and sometimes get H+
At work its a constant powerful and strong H+ full bars.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Like I mentioned above, powerful H+ doesn't mean it's good on your battery if it perma looking for LTE (this is a guess btw). Like it was mentioned, turning your LTE off while at work would help a lot if it's the case.
BWolf56 said:
Your cpu_0 governor being.. Ktoonservative? And what about your scheduler? I personally get great results with row (noop screen off).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CPU0 Ktoonservative with scheduler NOOP (on and off screen)
CPU1 Conservative instead of ondemand to further conserve power
UV like 100mv across the board.
UC to 1350
BWolf56 said:
It isn't actually ''nothing''. It still has to communicate with the towers, if it only sends H+, it might be because it's having trouble (or that area doesn't have LTE just yet). That being said, your device might be perma looking for LTE and can't get it = causing battery drain.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This could be a possibilty......and with Wifi on, it stops it from looking.
I can disable LTE, however that would mean disabling 2G as well......I looked into the disabling methods and I would like to keep my automatic setting but just without LTE........
I can test WCDMA only for a day or two to see if theres any improvements.
BWolf56 said:
Answer *might* be just above.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Isn't that sort of weird that with data OFF, that it still searches for LTE? Doesnt that defeat the purpose of having the data being off?
BWolf56 said:
Might wanna look into a custom TW ROM that is stable then. Intergalactic, Rootbox and couple others are quite popular around here.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I heard slim bean or sometihng laong the lines of that was good..... I may switch once I can iron the battery settings out.
BWolf56 said:
It definitely doesn't help. location access is a big battery drainer for sure. Might wanna look into manually turning it on when you need it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll add this to the list of trying things. LTE and this.
THough i always had this off and from what i remember my bat life was around the same as before.
BWolf56 said:
At work atm, can't take a look at them. Perhaps someone else can help you in the meantime for those.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ill try posting on chamonix's thread . thanks though!
BWolf56 said:
Like I mentioned above, powerful H+ doesn't mean it's good on your battery if it perma looking for LTE (this is a guess btw). Like it was mentioned, turning your LTE off while at work would help a lot if it's the case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll test this and get back to you later.
mikoal said:
Isn't that sort of weird that with data OFF, that it still searches for LTE? Doesnt that defeat the purpose of having the data being off?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think LTE is more than data, it's the signal.
I heard slim bean or sometihng laong the lines of that was good..... I may switch once I can iron the battery settings out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Custom ROMs definitely have better battery life than stock, whether it's on TW or AOSP.
I'll add this to the list of trying things. LTE and this.
THough i always had this off and from what i remember my bat life was around the same as before.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Worth trying
I'll test this and get back to you later.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Aight, I'll wait to hear back from ya.
mikoal said:
I can disable LTE, however that would mean disabling 2G as well......I looked into the disabling methods and I would like to keep my automatic setting but just without LTE........
I can test WCDMA only for a day or two to see if theres any improvements.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Assuming you are on an AT&T device running stock TW, you can disable LTE only. However it is only good until you reboot or switch in and out of airplane mode (it reverts to looking for LTE). Create a new APN with name and APN name only filled out and save. Select it. Wait 20 seconds and go into dialer and dial *#*#4636#*#* and select "Device information". It should say "WCDMA preferred" under preferred network type. You need to change it to GSM/CDMA auto (PRL). Exit and go back to your APN and select the one for LTE. After a couple seconds you will have data back and it can switch automatically between 2G and 3G.
aybarrap1 said:
Assuming you are on an AT&T device running stock TW, you can disable LTE only. However it is only good until you reboot or switch in and out of airplane mode (it reverts to looking for LTE). Create a new APN with name and APN name only filled out and save. Select it. Wait 20 seconds and go into dialer and dial *#*#4636#*#* and select "Device information". It should say "WCDMA preferred" under preferred network type. You need to change it to GSM/CDMA auto (PRL). Exit and go back to your APN and select the one for LTE. After a couple seconds you will have data back and it can switch automatically between 2G and 3G.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks but i got rogers and that dial code didnt work....
BWolf56 said:
I think LTE is more than data, it's the signal.
Custom ROMs definitely have better battery life than stock, whether it's on TW or AOSP.
Worth trying
Aight, I'll wait to hear back from ya.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So yesterday i left it idle with 8 hours and it drained .6%/hour, i lost 5% in 8 hours
I woke up turned off wifi and in 3 hours I lost 2% which is about .7%/hour.
I'll give it a try at work.....
the only change i made was wifi off.
The location is still on
I have a new radio firmware i want to try as well, but that will have to wait.
Attached are my BBS logs, seems like theres lots of wakeups
EDIT: i have battery spy, during idle it drains at .5%/hour, but when i wake it up then make it go to sleep, it hovers at 8% then 3 % for a while. Why is that? How can I make it drop to .5% immediately?
Related
So I've been trying to get more life out of my battery, I get decent now, but not the 18+ hours I've seen other people getting. I think the main problem here is, if I go view the Applications -> Battery Usage screen, the "Wi-Fi" and "Awake" bars are always full blue, even when the phone hasn't been touched in a couple hours.
Does anyone know what actually causes these to now sleep? Is it push email? Or some other setting I'm missing?
Thanks
RubenRybnik said:
So I've been trying to get more life out of my battery, I get decent now, but not the 18+ hours I've seen other people getting. I think the main problem here is, if I go view the Applications -> Battery Usage screen, the "Wi-Fi" and "Awake" bars are always full blue, even when the phone hasn't been touched in a couple hours.
Does anyone know what actually causes these to now sleep? Is it push email? Or some other setting I'm missing?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Look and find out you can start by turning off wifi if not using it post your screen shots of battery use someone may help
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
RubenRybnik said:
So I've been trying to get more life out of my battery, I get decent now, but not the 18+ hours I've seen other people getting. I think the main problem here is, if I go view the Applications -> Battery Usage screen, the "Wi-Fi" and "Awake" bars are always full blue, even when the phone hasn't been touched in a couple hours.
Does anyone know what actually causes these to now sleep? Is it push email? Or some other setting I'm missing?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try Menu/Settings/Wireless and Network/Wi-Fi Settings. Then press Menu/Advanced/Wi-Fi- sleep policy.
Play with those settings. You are probably set to "Never". Folks have actually been reporting better battery life with this setting (powering on and shutting down the wifi eats up battery) You can play around with it to get your own results.
Hit thanks if this helps!
pojieps said:
Try Menu/Settings/Wireless and Network/Wi-Fi Settings. Then press Menu/Advanced/Wi-Fi- sleep policy.
Play with those settings. You are probably set to "Never". Folks have actually been reporting better battery life with this setting (powering on and shutting down the wifi eats up battery) You can play around with it to get your own results.
Hit thanks if this helps!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ah...yes, it is set to never. So leaving it on "never" gets better results, say if you're at home and always have a wifi connection? Also, if the wi-fi is on, does that mean the device can't sleep I take it, that's what's keeping the device awake with screen off?
Thanks for the tip.
RubenRybnik said:
Ah...yes, it is set to never. So leaving it on "never" gets better results, say if you're at home and always have a wifi connection? Also, if the wi-fi is on, does that mean the device can't sleep I take it, that's what's keeping the device awake with screen off?
Thanks for the tip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've heard both sides to this argument, and frankly I don't think most people understand why changing it does, or in other cases does not help.
I suspect that the answer to your issue isn't going to be found here. Here's the theory:
- Setting wifi policy to "Sleep - Never" results in better battery life for some; it's likely because these individuals have a fairly low 3g signal, which tends to draw more battery when periodic updates/synchronization occurs (e.g., gmail, calendar, facebook, etc.). By leaving wifi Sleep set to never, the wifi (which THEORETICALLY uses less power than 3g) can do the work instead.
- Setting wifi policy to "Sleep - When Screen is Off" can result in better battery life for a number of reasons, many of the underlying issues being hard to identify. For example, if your router tends to send a lot of 'noise' and wake up your phone, having wi-fi disabled will prevent this. Location services in the OS - which you've probably permitted to 'help locate you faster' - even when you are NOT connected to a wifi network - will periodically ping wireless networks around you to help facilitate faster geolocation. This uses battery as well.
But don't confuse the generalities that have spawned from people's anecdotal situations with what could be a very different problem.
Was your phone primarily located in one location during most of the 'awake' period? If so, then it was probably connected to the same router most of that time. If so, it really shouldn't matter what the setting was for Advanced Wifi - the phone should still sleep.
If you turn off wi-fi on the device, and the device then sleeps, then you've narrowed the issue some, but that is not a solution, because what are you going to do, not use wifi?
You've got to dig deeper; your issue may be any of the following - rogue app that keeps a wakelock, rogue app that updates too frequently, wifi modem issue, router issue, OS issue, etc.
In short, you need to figure out what's keeping the phone awake. Get CPU Spy and Better Battery Stats to help you get insight into what's keeping the device awake.
Capp5050 said:
I've heard both sides to this argument, and frankly I don't think most people understand why changing it does, or in other cases does not help.
I suspect that the answer to your issue isn't going to be found here. Here's the theory:
- Setting wifi policy to "Sleep - Never" results in better battery life for some; it's likely because these individuals have a fairly low 3g signal, which tends to draw more battery when periodic updates/synchronization occurs (e.g., gmail, calendar, facebook, etc.). By leaving wifi Sleep set to never, the wifi (which THEORETICALLY uses less power than 3g) can do the work instead.
- Setting wifi policy to "Sleep - When Screen is Off" can result in better battery life for a number of reasons, many of the underlying issues being hard to identify. For example, if your router tends to send a lot of 'noise' and wake up your phone, having wi-fi disabled will prevent this. Location services in the OS - which you've probably permitted to 'help locate you faster' - even when you are NOT connected to a wifi network - will periodically ping wireless networks around you to help facilitate faster geolocation. This uses battery as well.
But don't confuse the generalities that have spawned from people's anecdotal situations with what could be a very different problem.
Was your phone primarily located in one location during most of the 'awake' period? If so, then it was probably connected to the same router most of that time. If so, it really shouldn't matter what the setting was for Advanced Wifi - the phone should still sleep.
If you turn off wi-fi on the device, and the device then sleeps, then you've narrowed the issue some, but that is not a solution, because what are you going to do, not use wifi?
You've got to dig deeper; your issue may be any of the following - rogue app that keeps a wakelock, rogue app that updates too frequently, wifi modem issue, router issue, OS issue, etc.
In short, you need to figure out what's keeping the phone awake. Get CPU Spy and Better Battery Stats to help you get insight into what's keeping the device awake.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for that very informative post. My phone was on my desk all day today( worked from home ) and wi-fi is set to always on, and it never slept, not even once.
I'll try disabling wi-fi( should have done this earlier to be honest and checked ) and then I'll download those apps, I just got Badass Battery Monitor, I'll check out the two you recommended as well. Thanks for the info!
Your phone should still go into deep sleep with wifi on. If it doesn't then you have something else wakelocking your phone. However, if wifi is set to never sleep, and wifi is enabled, the bar on the battery chart will always be solid blue.
So just installed CPU Spy, it looks like IM+ is the biggest user of wakelocks. I like to always be signed in to my accounts, but not at such a huge cost of battery, does anyone know of a better multi IM client that will push updates to you? I used to have IM+ on the iPhone( yea I know, just switched two months ago, and never looking back ) and the push on it worked great. The 'push' IM+ says it has is awful, most of the time I never get my IMs sent to me at all.
Also have skype signed on all the time, not sure if that is wakelock'ing anything, I'll have to keep an eye on it, it didn't show up on CPU Spy.
Try IMO, free from the Android Market. Its a multi-IM client that combines most common clients including Skype. I've used it. It creates some wakelocks, but not sufficient to wake the phone. I don't use IM very often so I'd be curious to hear how it works for you.
Capp5050 said:
Try IMO, free from the Android Market. Its a multi-IM client that combines most common clients including Skype. I've used it. It creates some wakelocks, but not sufficient to wake the phone. I don't use IM very often so I'd be curious to hear how it works for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks ... Giving it a try today, I'll let you know how it goes.
Capp5050 said:
Try IMO, free from the Android Market. Its a multi-IM client that combines most common clients including Skype. I've used it. It creates some wakelocks, but not sufficient to wake the phone. I don't use IM very often so I'd be curious to hear how it works for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So been trying IMO the past couple days. Seems much better than IM+. Haven't seen any disconnects, I get my IMs about 30sec - 1min after the computer gets them, which is fine, and the wake-locking is extremely minimal. IM+ was awful with the wake-locking.
So that clears up the Always awake issue, flashed Blazer 3.8 last night, so can't comment on battery too much yet, also calibrating today.
RubenRybnik said:
So been trying IMO the past couple days. Seems much better than IM+. Haven't seen any disconnects, I get my IMs about 30sec - 1min after the computer gets them, which is fine, and the wake-locking is extremely minimal. IM+ was awful with the wake-locking.
So that clears up the Always awake issue, flashed Blazer 3.8 last night, so can't comment on battery too much yet, also calibrating today.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the feedback, glad to hear it helped, and I now feel a little more confident leaving my IM 'on' more often.
To start off with; i get good battery life; right now I'm at 1 day 3 hours and I have 39% left.
I was wondering however, does setting the Wifi to go off when the screen is off help significantly on the battery? And if so...is there some other negative issue that I'm not aware of if I set it this way?
I'm pretty sure any sort of data connection will use more of your battery than WiFi will. So if you're always around a strong WiFi connection you probably should leave it on at all times.
MdX MaxX said:
I'm pretty sure any sort of data connection will use more of your battery than WiFi will. So if you're always around a strong WiFi connection you probably should leave it on at all times.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's one of the things that i was wondering about....thanks.
rpavich said:
To start off with; i get good battery life; right now I'm at 1 day 3 hours and I have 39% left.
I was wondering however, does setting the Wifi to go off when the screen is off help significantly on the battery? And if so...is there some other negative issue that I'm not aware of if I set it this way?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
how the hell are you getting 1 day 3 hours!?!?!??!?! what are your settings? teeeeeell meeeeeeeee!
thanks.
slicetwo said:
how the hell are you getting 1 day 3 hours!?!?!??!?! what are your settings? teeeeeell meeeeeeeee!
thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh that is funny.
I just do everything everyone else does:
1.) Screen off when not in use
2.) Screen brightness down as much as possible.
3.) Dark theme.
4.) Tasker profiles to turn off wifi when not near my house or work.
5.) Tasker profile to turn off GPS when not actively using certain apps.
6.) Tasker profile to turn off BT when not connected.
I also am probably a light user...the only thing that I do beyond normal phone use is to watch Netflix a slight bit a day and stream Spotify a bit.
I also don't play games except Words with friends.
No FB no locations, no nothing like that.
Wifi off and data off would be most helping when screen off
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using xda premium
i am new on note2 using custom rom 4.1.2 i feel last night my battery drain at least 13% whole night on standby.my early s3 take only 1% on standby whole night.
relisys667 said:
i am new on note2 using custom rom 4.1.2 i feel last night my battery drain at least 13% whole night on standby.my early s3 take only 1% on standby whole night.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
S3 only 1%? Wow that's awesome.. WiFi and Data On?
Sent from my GT-N7100 using xda premium
relisys667 said:
i am new on note2 using custom rom 4.1.2 i feel last night my battery drain at least 13% whole night on standby.my early s3 take only 1% on standby whole night.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
13% is ODD. Something is sucking up your battery.
Expand your Android system and post the Screenshot - want to look at cpu wake time.
What is your setting under - Advanced Wifi options - while asleep - wifi on or off ?
SAJdroid said:
13% is ODD. Something is sucking up your battery.
Expand your Android system and post the Screenshot - want to look at cpu wake time.
What is your setting under - Advanced Wifi options - while asleep - wifi on or off ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
now i set wifi sleep to never and watch this night
thnx for replying
SAJdroid said:
13% is ODD. Something is sucking up your battery.
Expand your Android system and post the Screenshot - want to look at cpu wake time.
What is your setting under - Advanced Wifi options - while asleep - wifi on or off ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To be honest I have done so many tweaks to help with wakelocks. It is definately not an app but the standby time is sooo much worse on my Note in comparision to my HTC One S. I'll get about a day regardless of screen time. On my One S I'll get 2 days with the same screen time and with the same apps.
The only thing I can think of it being is that mdm_hsic kernel wakelock. Have no clue what to do about that though, and it's clearly a Samsung/Note 2 bug given that the HTC doesn't have this sucking away the standby time.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
Do you have ebay app installed?
Try uninstalling and see if this makes a difference. The ebay process/service constantly runs in background even tho its disabled in app settings and doesn't show battery usage.
I had same problem and found that its to blame!
unFKNreal said:
Do you have ebay app installed?
Try uninstalling and see if this makes a difference. The ebay process/service constantly runs in background even tho its disabled in app settings and doesn't show battery usage.
I had same problem and found that its to blame!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The thing is, I also have the ebay app on my HTC and it doesn't suffer from this problem. The HTC is 4.1.1 though so I'm guessing this is either a Samsung problem or a 4.1.2 problem.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
relisys667 said:
i am new on note2 using custom rom 4.1.2 i feel last night my battery drain at least 13% whole night on standby.my early s3 take only 1% on standby whole night.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi,just a few pointers to think about ....?
i am on stock 4.1.2 not rooted ,and my avarage battery drain overnight (10/11 hrs +) is 2%..or ..3 %.
i also have a note8.0 and battery drain is normally 1% in standby mode overnight (10/11 hrs )also on 4.1.2
lucky ? no i don't think so .
(maybe i got my all "tweaks " right..no ?)
just a few pointers (things to think about, why others get better results and others not,in this case on 4.1.2 )
good luck
unFKNreal said:
Do you have ebay app installed?
Try uninstalling and see if this makes a difference. The ebay process/service constantly runs in background even tho its disabled in app settings and doesn't show battery usage.
I had same problem and found that its to blame!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no dear brother i have not installed any ebay app
relisys667 said:
no dear brother i have not installed any ebay app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have any Battery manager apps installed? I had one that constantly pulled WiFi status and since I have WiFi disabled when outside of home or work it kept on turning it on/off and drained my battery. It was my error for configuring it wrongly, I admit but still, that may happen without control.
Check Wakelock Detector, click on this:
Awake.............................Statistics since..............................Deep sleep
bar after night of rest and post statistics that you find there, The most interesting is a difference between Screen-on and awake times. If your phone is awake much longer than it has it's screen on then there are some processes that keep it awake and drain battery.
mat9v said:
Do you have any Battery manager apps installed? I had one that constantly pulled WiFi status and since I have WiFi disabled when outside of home or work it kept on turning it on/off and drained my battery. It was my error for configuring it wrongly, I admit but still, that may happen without control.
Check Wakelock Detector, click on this:
Awake.............................Statistics since..............................Deep sleep
bar after night of rest and post statistics that you find there, The most interesting is a difference between Screen-on and awake times. If your phone is awake much longer than it has it's screen on then there are some processes that keep it awake and drain battery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Last night I disable wifi and battery takes 3% whole night I think wifi eat battery
relisys667 said:
Last night I disable wifi and battery takes 3% whole night I think wifi eat battery
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
WiFi by itself will not eat battery, something has to use it to create this drain. How do you have your wifi configured?
Check in Settings>WiFi>Advanced>Keep WiFi on during sleep>???
I have that set to Never
mat9v said:
WiFi by itself will not eat battery, something has to use it to create this drain. How do you have your wifi configured?
Check in Settings>WiFi>Advanced>Keep WiFi on during sleep>???
I have that set to Never
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wifi does seem to be messed up on this phone. I find, on standby, it causes more drain than 3G does. Usually something like 10% - 15% overnight.
This is not right and something is seriously a miss with Samsung. My HTC running the exact same apps does not have this problem. You shouldn't have to turn wifi off as opposed to 3G to get better battery life.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
fade2black101 said:
Wifi does seem to be messed up on this phone. I find, on standby, it causes more drain than 3G does. Usually something like 10% - 15% overnight.
This is not right and something is seriously a miss with Samsung. My HTC running the exact same apps does not have this problem. You shouldn't have to turn wifi off as opposed to 3G to get better battery life.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you thinking about some hardware problem that causes wifi to use more memory than usual? Like higher voltage or something? Because that is not very probable. I think there is some app there that is using wifi, high power usage happens when wifi is performing scans is being turned on or actively transmiting data. Please use wakelog detector to find what app is causing kernel wakelocks and from there we can find a real culprit.
I does not have to be malicious but may be an incompatibility between hardware and some software, one that works well on HTC and not on this Samsung model.
mat9v said:
Are you thinking about some hardware problem that causes wifi to use more memory than usual? Like higher voltage or something? Because that is not very probable. I think there is some app there that is using wifi, high power usage happens when wifi is performing scans is being turned on or actively transmiting data. Please use wakelog detector to find what app is causing kernel wakelocks and from there we can find a real culprit.
I does not have to be malicious but may be an incompatibility between hardware and some software, one that works well on HTC and not on this Samsung model.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No I don't think it's hardware.
I also don't think it is an app given what I have observed with wakelocks and deep sleep. I have made many adjustments to the phone and I'm clued up with wakelocks and the like and this doesn't seem to be a wakelock issue.
I have even assigned a static ip and made tweaks within my router but it hasn't helped. There seems to be a strange way this phone handles wifi and it is causing unnecessary drain.
In regards to Kernel wakelocks, it would appear something called mdm_hsic is causing lots of wakeups and more standby drain than it should be and this does not feature at all on my HTC. This is not related to wifi, but I'm pinning the general crappy standy drain im getting on this but there doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of it.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
Id download ds battery saver from the playstore and set it to agressive itll turn off wifi and data whenever screen is locked and turn it back on upon unlock. Its awesome on my sgs4
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda premium
fade2black101 said:
No I don't think it's hardware.
I also don't think it is an app given what I have observed with wakelocks and deep sleep. I have made many adjustments to the phone and I'm clued up with wakelocks and the like and this doesn't seem to be a wakelock issue.
I have even assigned a static ip and made tweaks within my router but it hasn't helped. There seems to be a strange way this phone handles wifi and it is causing unnecessary drain.
In regards to Kernel wakelocks, it would appear something called mdm_hsic is causing lots of wakeups and more standby drain than it should be and this does not feature at all on my HTC. This is not related to wifi, but I'm pinning the general crappy standy drain im getting on this but there doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of it.
Sent from my Galaxy Note II LTE using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
mdm_hsic is related to Modem part, you may try different modems (be mindfull of efs problem in newer firmwares), also try to enable/disable "fast dormancy". I think you could test that by selecting "GSM only" and observing.
mat9v said:
mdm_hsic is related to Modem part, you may try different modems (be mindfull of efs problem in newer firmwares), also try to enable/disable "fast dormancy". I think you could test that by selecting "GSM only" and observing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the reply
I have tried different radios in the past. If that's what you mean?
I've also tested around with fast dormancy (it is currently disabled)
My network only works on 3G and has no 2G coverage. It is purely a 3G network and therefore GSM only will not work. This problem still persisted when I was on a different network though and selected gsm only fornthe majority of the time.
fade2black101 said:
Thanks for the reply
I have tried different radios in the past. If that's what you mean?
I've also tested around with fast dormancy (it is currently disabled)
My network only works on 3G and has no 2G coverage. It is purely a 3G network and therefore GSM only will not work. This problem still persisted when I was on a different network though and selected gsm only fornthe majority of the time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I was talking about radios.
Have you ever tried changing CSC file? Full, four part flash in Odin, not only PDA?
What method did you use for modifying fast dormancy setting? Because the correct one includes full factory reset when changing CSC. Anyway fast dormancy would be a problem only if you used 3G network for data.
mat9v said:
Yes, I was talking about radios.
Have you ever tried changing CSC file? Full, four part flash in Odin, not only PDA?
What method did you use for modifying fast dormancy setting? Because the correct one includes full factory reset when changing CSC. Anyway fast dormancy would be a problem only if you used 3G network for data.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope have not tried changing the CSC.
The method I used for fastdormancy was with that app in the marketplace than allows you to toggle it on and off. I'm not sure if fastdormancy is linked the mdm_hsic though, to be honest.
Hi,
Have you guys noticed our phones tend to drain battery much much faster on 3G than WiFi? I have yet to measure the drains accurately yet but I think the difference is huge. I can drain the entire battery in 2-3 hours with data on and active data transfer.
For example, stream some music on TuneIn on wifi and then on data (3G/H+). On data, the phone gets really hot and sometimes even with an AC charger plugged in the battery can barely hold charge (with screen also on). On Wi-Fi the phone stays cool and battery consumption seems to be much less.
I feel like it's ok for data to use a bit more power but I feel like this much of a difference is not normal. I have WCDMA preferred in mobile options, and it is displaying H+ in the status bar. I am assuming it isn't using LTE or looking for an LTE signal... How can I make sure of this? Is the LTE a different radio/chip that can be turned off separately?
I'm on CM10.1.2 with Wind Kernel 2.5.
what do u think requires more power receiving a signal from 30 meters away or a cell phone tower
having said that if your rom is pulling more than usual from data connection you can try switching to cdma only mode, also i think the stronger signal you are getting the less power it uses but im not sure on that, i think if u are in a basement or something it will pull more power.
or try switching roms
it is not the "phone" unless your phone is defective
try a differant rom if that doesn't work try a differant baseband if that doesn't work phone is probly defective or partially defective
first thing is try a stock based rom
btw i think the only time wifi will take more power than 3g/4g data is if you are sending huge amounts of data over it or have it on constantly scanning for networks, or have a rom that makes wifi stay on fullspeed while sleeping
KronicSkillz said:
what do u think requires more power receiving a signal from 30 meters away or a cell phone tower
having said that if your rom is pulling more than usual from data connection you can try switching to cdma only mode, also i think the stronger signal you are getting the less power it uses but im not sure on that, i think if u are in a basement or something it will pull more power.
or try switching roms
it is not the "phone" unless your phone is defective
try a differant rom if that doesn't work try a differant baseband if that doesn't work phone is probly defective or partially defective
first thing is try a stock based rom
btw i think the only time wifi will take more power than 3g/4g data is if you are sending huge amounts of data over it or have it on constantly scanning for networks, or have a rom that makes wifi stay on fullspeed while sleeping
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm just trying to gauge if people are seeing the same thing as I am. I haven't switched basebands in a while. Any further informative comments are welcome.
Flyview said:
I'm just trying to gauge if people are seeing the same thing as I am. I haven't switched basebands in a while. Any further informative comments are welcome.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i can guarentee you thats not normal
what have u tried? have u even tried reflashing cm 10.1.2?
KronicSkillz said:
i can guarentee you thats not normal
what have u tried? have u even tried reflashing cm 10.1.2?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No I haven't, I kind of just assumed it had to be normal. The phone gets hot just like when you're talking on the phone for a while so I thought it made sense.
I have some preliminary numbers (didn't let the test run long). If you want to replicate this, get Android System Tuner, and set up a widget to show "Average mA since last measure". Turn brightness to minimum and set the display to not turn off, start streaming TuneIn radio, unplug the phone (to reset "last measure), and let the battery go down at least 5%.
-360mA - wifi on streaming music, screen low brightness (20%/hour)
-760mA - 3g on streaming music, screen low brightness (note that's 41.5%/hour!)
-400mA - 3g on streaming music, screen off (22%/hour)
These preliminary numbers would suggest WiFi uses almost nothing, since the screen seems to be about 360mA, whereas the difference between WiFi and data is 400mA!
Flyview said:
No I haven't, I kind of just assumed it had to be normal. The phone gets hot just like when you're talking on the phone for a while so I thought it made sense.
I have some preliminary numbers (didn't let the test run long). If you want to replicate this, get Android System Tuner, and set up a widget to show "Average mA since last measure". Turn brightness to minimum and set the display to not turn off, start streaming TuneIn radio, unplug the phone (to reset "last measure), and let the battery go down at least 5%.
-360mA - wifi on streaming music, screen low brightness (20%/hour)
-760mA - 3g on streaming music, screen low brightness (note that's 41.5%/hour!)
-400mA - 3g on streaming music, screen off (22%/hour)
These preliminary numbers would suggest WiFi uses almost nothing, since the screen seems to be about 360mA, whereas the difference between WiFi and data is 400mA!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if it was me before i bothered with any of this i would have redownloaded and wipe/reflash rom, i just had my phone streaming music on 3g and it didn't even get warm
i don't mind helping you but please rule out the easy obvious steps first
KronicSkillz said:
if it was me before i bothered with any of this i would have redownloaded and wipe/reflash rom, i just had my phone streaming music on 3g and it didn't even get warm
i don't mind helping you but please rule out the easy obvious steps first
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will try that tonight. I wanted a baseline too...
Could you please check what baseband you're running (I'm on V20e)? Does flashing CM10.1.2 change the baseband?
Flyview said:
I will try that tonight. I wanted a baseline too...
Could you please check what baseband you're running (I'm on V20e)? Does flashing CM10.1.2 change the baseband?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ive never had to flash my own baseband everywhere i read people say only do it if you have issues and ive never had issues, the rom/kernel i'm using is in my sig
there is a baseband archive in the developement section if it comes down to trying differant basebands although i'm not the person to talk to about that as i've never done it, i'm sure if you end up doing that asking on that thread would be your best bet as you will probably get responses from people who have done it before.
here i'll even link it:
basebands
this is a last resort and be very careful when flashing these
KronicSkillz said:
if it was me before i bothered with any of this i would have redownloaded and wipe/reflash rom, i just had my phone streaming music on 3g and it didn't even get warm
i don't mind helping you but please rule out the easy obvious steps first
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I would have to second that, those mA are way too high. I am @ < 100 mA on H+ streaming off slacker now that is with stock, but when I was on cm10.1 I would have to say it was about the same. The ONLY time my phone gets warm is on GPS & charging, and my phone is over clocked to 1728 all the time.
Sent from my LG-P930 using xda app-developers app
KronicSkillz said:
ive never had to flash my own baseband everywhere i read people say only do it if you have issues and ive never had issues, the rom/kernel i'm using is in my sig
there is a baseband archive in the developement section if it comes down to trying differant basebands although i'm not the person to talk to about that as i've never done it, i'm sure if you end up doing that asking on that thread would be your best bet as you will probably get responses from people who have done it before.
here i'll even link it:
basebands
this is a last resort and be very careful when flashing these
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. I've changed basebands before with packages from that thread. That's why I'm asking if flashing CM will override those.
What basebands are you guys on?
Sent from my LG-P930 using Tapatalk 2
Flyview said:
Thanks. I've changed basebands before with packages from that thread. That's why I'm asking if flashing CM will override those.
What basebands are you guys on?
Sent from my LG-P930 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i'm honestly not sure if rom flashing changes baseband my gut instinct would be sometimes yes sometimes no but i'm honestly not sure, i dont even look at baseband unless i'm having problems with my radio signal and i never have.
ur problem is probly caused by you changing yours.
my baseband is: apq8060/mdm9200
have u tried what i suggested and flash a stock based rom to see if that fixes the error, then if you want to go back to cm10.1 u should be able to as long as you dont mess with basebands again
it's possible this doesn't fix the error if the stock rom doesn't flash a baseband, i'm honestly not sure if it will but it might
be careful that you don't flash one that reflashes a locked bootloader, most of the stock based roms on the developement forums have it disabled
KronicSkillz said:
i'm honestly not sure if rom flashing changes baseband my gut instinct would be sometimes yes sometimes no but i'm honestly not sure, i dont even look at baseband unless i'm having problems with my radio signal and i never have.
ur problem is probly caused by you changing yours.
my baseband is: apq8060/mdm9200
have u tried what i suggested and flash a stock based rom to see if that fixes the error, then if you want to go back to cm10.1 u should be able to as long as you dont mess with basebands again
it's possible this doesn't fix the error if the stock rom doesn't flash a baseband, i'm honestly not sure if it will but it might
be careful that you don't flash one that reflashes a locked bootloader, most of the stock based roms on the developement forums have it disabled
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, that's what I'll be trying today. I was on V20e (newest Bell one from that thread). Yesterday I tried V20c, V10j. All are pretty much the same in terms of power usage as I tested them yesterday. I will try a stock-ish ICS today and test there.
BTW, I tried the streaming test on a Nexus 4.
-550mA screen on lowest brightness streaming 3G (compared to -760mA for mine)
-360mA screen off streaming 3G (compared to -500mA for mine)
So the differences aren't THAT drastic, but still.
So here's some updates:
I flashed V20f mod V2 by HoNo (a stripped down and CWM flashable V20f stock image from Bell).
At first, I thought everything was fixed, as I was seeing battery use at about 500mA with screen on lowest brightness, streaming over 3G. However, I think this was due to the battery being low and the battery % dropping slower when it's under 15% (Android Tuner free uses battery % and battery capacity to estimate current draw).
I charged the phone overnight, then I flashed my CWM backup of CM10.1.2. The good thing is it kept the V20f baseband (and firmware) from flashing the V20f rom. That confirms that CM10.1.2 and CWM backups don't save/flash baseband.img and firmware.img. However, again, I was seeing 700+mA draw. There might be better idle usage with the new baseband, but it might be placebo.
I went back to a CWM restore of the V20f rom and tested again on the ICS-based stock-ish rom. Battery consumption is still high (700+mA streaming on data and screen on lowest brightness).
Could one of you guys please try running the same test I am? Here's how:
0) Ensure your battery is in the range of 50-90%
1) Download Android Tuner Free (AT)
2) Download TuneIn
3) Add a AT widget (1x1 text option) to a homescreen
4) Tap the widget, go to settings, widgets, widget content, central value, choose "avg mA since last measure"
5) Go back to AT settings, battery, calibration, battery capacity, enter 1830.
6) Start to stream music from a radiostation on TuneIn
7) Set screen timeout to 5 or 10min
8) Set brightness to minimum
9) Plug phone in
10) Unplug phone (this resets the "avg mA since last measure")
11) Watch the central value as your battery drops for 10-20minutes. Since drain is an estimate based on % dropping it will jump around a bit but level off the more time you let it run.
12) Don't do other stuff on the phone so you aren't using the CPU more than for this test
I've noticed lately my battery life has plummeted. When I get to work, I turn off wifi, and even after very light use throughout the day, 9-10 hours later it will be giving me the low battery warning. I checked the Battery screen, and noticed the Wifi bar is solid blue the whole day as seen in the attached picture. If I am reading this screen correctly, wouldn't that be an indication that wifi is actually on all day? As you can also see in the screenshot, the wifi logo is not on at the top, showing I do in fact have it turned off. Do I have a problem? Does anyone else know about this issue and have a fix for it, if it is in fact a "issue"?
Go in to your WiFi settings, hit your menu button and hit advanced. Uncheck "always allow scanning"
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
Thanks, doing that this morning and will check the battery screen in a couple hours.
OK, that seems to have taken care of the wifi appearing to be on in the battery stats. I will wait until later today to determine if that was the cause of my battery draining quicker. I know there were a few new apps I installed around the same time, and I may have to start digging through those too.
fermunky said:
OK, that seems to have taken care of the wifi appearing to be on in the battery stats. I will wait until later today to determine if that was the cause of my battery draining quicker. I know there were a few new apps I installed around the same time, and I may have to start digging through those too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are u in an area that has low lte strength. If its switching between LTE and hspa+ that is tough on battery. Or location settings, or random apps running in the background. Grab BBS and see what is eating up the battery, wake locks apps etc. Their is am Xposed module that dispatches of wake locks if that is your issue. But I'm guessing its one of your apps or signal.
jdidtht said:
Are u in an area that has low lte strength. If its switching between LTE and hspa+ that is tough on battery. Or location settings, or random apps running in the background. Grab BBS and see what is eating up the battery, wake locks apps etc. Their is am Xposed module that dispatches of wake locks if that is your issue. But I'm guessing its one of your apps or signal.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, yes. When in my office, I get VERY low signal and it is constantly in HSPA. Also, what is the full name of BBS? I am not finding any kind of tool just searching play store for BBS.
fermunky said:
Actually, yes. When in my office, I get VERY low signal and it is constantly in HSPA. Also, what is the full name of BBS? I am not finding any kind of tool just searching play store for BBS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Better battery stats is what you are looking for I believe.
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
phil.culler said:
Better battery stats is what you are looking for I believe.
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, found another battery thread on it. I downloaded it, but am not rooted, so not sure how helpful it will be. All the other data is greek to me on it, so someone have any pointers what to specifically look for?
fermunky said:
Yup, found another battery thread on it. I downloaded it, but am not rooted, so not sure how helpful it will be. All the other data is greek to me on it, so someone have any pointers what to specifically look for?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go in to your mobile network settings and change the network mode to wcdma/GSM instead of lte/wcdma/GSM if you're always switching between lte and 4g. Try that at least.
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
fermunky said:
Actually, yes. When in my office, I get VERY low signal and it is constantly in HSPA. Also, what is the full name of BBS? I am not finding any kind of tool just searching play store for BBS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
if possible grab WiFi at work, and use only that and I bet your battery significantly improves. then when u leave, hop back on normal data and see if that helps
Well, I've tried the setting the mode to not include lte, still getting pretty quick battery drain. There is no usable wifi here due to the level of security my facility enforces. Anything I can have BBS export to have you fine folks take a gander at and see if you find anything relevant?