Related
Recently there's been an upswing in the number of stock AOSP ROMs posted in the Development section. At least, for me: I've been coming around for a couple of months and I don't think I've ever seen that many ROMs with just the 'standard' Google experience to offer.
I know these threads are a dime a dozen, but considering the many choices available, I figured I'd ask.
What is, in your opinion, the best stock AOSP ROM currently in development; and obviously why.
Just from the first two pages in Development, there's the following:
- gingerbread-evo-deck
- CM7
- Savaged-Zen RC3/RC4
- Salvage-Mod
& I'm sure there's others. So, which would you recommend and why? What features of one that the other doesn't have make it a better experience for you?
If you want bare bone stock, then pick salvage mod. CM7 has some tweaks to it, but great. Deck's is parallel to CM7, more stable fore some people. Savaged-zen built there own rom, designed to run perfect with their kernel, it has tweaks to it as well.
xfusejc said:
... I don't think I've ever seen that many ROMs with just the 'standard' Google experience to offer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The standard Google experience is just that...standard, however, it allows you the freedom to expand on their open environment, so to speak.
What is, in your opinion, the best stock AOSP ROM currently in development; and obviously why.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My friend, teh roxxorz, gave you an excellent response on this and I will reiterate. SalvageMod and OMGB is as close to the "standard Google experience" you aforementioned, as you're going to get. Yet, you have the ability to customize it to "your" liking. For example, I use SalvageMod 1.3 nightly #26 along with LauncherPro Plus that I've tweaked for speed and my device is very fast and stable. CM7, without question, has the greatest following and support and it has been modified & tweaked based on user requests. I've yet to flash the other 2 you referenced.
....What features of one that the other doesn't have make it a better experience for you?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Questions like these are difficult to answer because they are subjective. You listed 4 popular AOSP roms. I would suggest that you flash each one in the following order-- most basic to arguably the most advanced:
1. SalvageMod
2. CM7
3. Decks
4. Savaged-Zen
posting & replying via the XDA Premium app.
dougjamal said:
The standard Google experience is just that...standard, however, it allows you the freedom to expand on their open environment, so to speak.
My friend, teh roxxorz, gave you an excellent response on this and I will reiterate. SalvageMod and OMGB is as close to the "standard Google experience" you aforementioned, as you're going to get. Yet, you have the ability to customize it to "your" liking. For example, I use SalvageMod 1.3 nightly #26 along with LauncherPro Plus that I've tweaked for speed and my device is very fast and stable. CM7, without question, has the greatest following and support and it has been modified & tweaked based on user requests. I've yet to flash the other 2 you referenced.
Questions like these are difficult to answer because they are subjective. You listed 4 popular AOSP roms. I would suggest that you flash each one in the following order-- most basic to arguably the most advanced:
1. SalvageMod
2. CM7
3. Decks
4. SavageZen
posting & replying via the XDA Premium app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So Decks and SavageZen are more advanced than CM7? That's news to me.
& thanks for both replies. I really appreciate it.
xfusejc said:
So Decks and SavageZen are more advanced than CM7? That's news to me.
& thanks for both replies. I really appreciate it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did state that they are "arguably" more advanced, however, my use of the term advanced is not to say that they are better. Maybe I should state that they are "arguably" more modified. Would that suffice?
for what its worth ive tried cm7 and like it alot. I'm not running deck evo. i like that 2. thinkin of trying out savage-zen in the near future. just try them all n see what u like the most.. just play around with them
dougjamal said:
I did state that they are "arguably" more advanced, however, my use of the term advanced is not say that they are better. Maybe I should state that they are "arguably" more modified. Would that suffice?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I understood how you used it.
I just figured that CM7 had the most improvement on the Google source code, and was therefore the more advanced in the group.
Again, thanks for replying
xfusejc said:
No, I understood how you used it.
I just figured that CM7 had the most improvement on the Google source code, and was therefore the more advanced in the group.
Again, thanks for replying
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Understood and I thank you for the clarification........Take care and enjoy the rest of your day.
posting & replying via the XDA Premium app.
Try Salvage Mod
"Googly eyes"
From my experience, (and I haven't seen it mentioned), Evervolv is the most basic and stock google gingerbread experience I've seen. It is basically completely stock GB, and has NO modifications at all, really. No lock screen mods, no notification toggles, no tweaks, just pure Gingerbread. Deck's and CM7 are very simlar, as Deck's is based off CM7. For some reason Decks is far more stable on my Evo though. I haven't used savaged zen in a good while, so can't comment on that. Salvage Mod is by far my favorite AOSP rom, and think you should give that a shot. It is simply a fabulous and tremendously stable rom. Have fun.
I wonder what'd be the differences among "sense kernels", "miui kernels" and "aosp kernels".
In my perception there should be no difference.
I mean, which kernel setting or device driver would harm, say, CM7 against MIUI?
Based on my humble knowledge, there is Sense kernel because of the closed sourced framework(?) used by HTC on their phone. It is done so as to prevent from people anyhow porting to other non-htc devices?
As for MIUI and AOSP, I personally believe because of the MIUI framework being different from AOSP as it tailored to be more iPhone look alike?
Above those are view coming from a noob, do correct me if i'm wrong. Thanks
ngsngn said:
Based on my humble knowledge, there is Sense kernel because of the closed sourced framework(?) used by HTC on their phone. It is done so as to prevent from people anyhow porting to other non-htc devices?
As for MIUI and AOSP, I personally believe because of the MIUI framework being different from AOSP as it tailored to be more iPhone look alike?
Above those are view coming from a noob, do correct me if i'm wrong. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's really new to me, that the Sense UI needs some kernel level (closed source) stuff to be included!
I thought that the Semse UI was something on top of the grapfics layer, well above the kernel.
But of course, I can easily be wrong.
Wrong section - It's a question - so Q & A
BigMrB said:
Wrong section - It's a question - so Q & A
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe you are right, but it's also related to development.
And, moreover, 50+% of posts here are questions.
How can I move this to Q&A?
Wrong section. Should be in the Q&A section.
I'm sure one of the mods will move it soon.
but this is not a post, its a new thread
"Silly question"
Appropriate thread title
Everything else totally inappropriate
ziggy1001 said:
"Silly question"
Appropriate thread title
Everything else totally inappropriate
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only really silly question is the unasked one.
Where there seems to be thousands of silly answers.
If mine is an "already asked and answered" question, please point me to the source.
Otherwise, please, either answer or refrain from posting.
Thanks in advance, as usual.
Uqbar said:
The only really silly question is the unasked one.
Where there seems to be thousands of silly answers.
If mine is an "already asked and answered" question, please point me to the source.
Otherwise, please, either answer or refrain from posting.
Thanks in advance, as usual.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you only wrong to open a thread to ask something in the dev section..you can post in dev only when u developed something that you wanna share..not to ask somethign related to dev
about the different kernels..for what i know aosp and miui are about the same
sense kernels are different because htc did a lot of changes in its kernels..and these changes make the kernel incompatible to work with every rom..it works only on sense rom...and in the same way a sense rom work only with a sense kernel
htc deliberately make different methods in the kernel, and different methods call in the frameworks..the only working match is sense rom+sense kernel..just that
Uqbar said:
I wonder what'd be the differences among "sense kernels", "miui kernels" and "aosp kernels".
In my perception there should be no difference.
I mean, which kernel setting or device driver would harm, say, CM7 against MIUI?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Instead of making comments about the question, we should answer
Sense Kernels: These kernels are modified kernels based on Google's Android kernels, but also includes some tweaks and options for Sense UI. If you're planning to use Sense included ROM, you must use these.
MIUI Kernels: These kernels are modified for MIUI release ROMs.
AOSP Kernels (Android Open Source Project Kernels): These kernels are the ones that Google developed and published the sources. If you are not planning to use Sense or other manufacturer based UI interfaces, you can use these with AOSP ROMs.
Can anyone please explain what AOKP is? I know it stands for Android Open Kang Project, but what is Kang? I've tried searching the forums here and in RootzWiki as well as a general Google search and I've come up with nothing that is helpful.
I've seen a lot of AOKP roms, but no explanation as to exactly what they are, although I've noticed that many of them have a lot of the CM9 mods.
Thank You!
I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure "Kang" is just the name of the team that develops the ROM.
Kinbote said:
I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure "Kang" is just the name of the team that develops the ROM.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
im not sure if that was what it meant to begin with, but these days it means a rom compiled by a person rather than a server.
so most of CM's roms are compiled automatically by there servers. However some people make CM Kangs by taking the source and compiling it them selves. This means they can add all the commits/mods/features which the servers have but dont have assisgned to the roms for various reasons.
So Kangs will often have slightly newer features and are also less likely to have issues because a user has gone through and made sure everything is in the rom(Hopefully). where as the servers wont know if a driver is broken/missing.
You can also get kangs of other roms i suppose. sorry if i repeated myself
Kang
The process of creating a code based of someone else's code or reapplying code that someone else created into your own code (e.g. git cherry-pick)
http://wiki.cyanogenmod.com/wiki/Terminology
AOKP is a play on AOSP, the Android Open Source Project.
AOKP is basically any rom made by or from the CyanogenMod source. It it NOT true CyanogenMod however.
Oh, well I was completely off. Thanks for the corrections.
neok44 said:
AOKP is a play on AOSP, the Android Open Source Project.
AOKP is basically any rom made by or from the CyanogenMod source. It it NOT true CyanogenMod however.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOKP is actually not from CM source. As you can see in his ROM thread, http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1402341 it has nothing to do with CM9 kangs.
It's just a play off AOSP and the general status of the Android community. AOKP is build from AOSP source, not CM9, even though I use bits and pieces of it. If you look, most of the features to AOKP are unique .
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
i stand corrected. i thought it was due to their use of the word in almost everything.
Interesting.
It certainly has the oddest boot animation of the lot. Trés cute..
Thanks Roman!
Romanbb said:
It's just a play off AOSP and the general status of the Android community. AOKP is build from AOSP source, not CM9, even though I use bits and pieces of it. If you look, most of the features to AOKP are unique .
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
oh....... I thought it was a reference to chess ....Android Opening King Pawn 1st...... Thx for clearing that up...........
Wow! Thanks for all the responses. I'm glad that I'm not the only one who didn't know what it meant, but I think I have a better idea now. But why use Kang instead of Source (AOKP instead of AOSP) if it's built from source? I was always afraid to flash an AOKP ROM because I didn't know what it was and just thought that it was a ROM in its early alpha stages and had a ton of bugs.
Thanks again!!!
erik1213 said:
Wow! Thanks for all the responses. I'm glad that I'm not the only one who didn't know what it meant, but I think I have a better idea now. But why use Kang instead of Source (AOKP instead of AOSP) if it's built from source? I was always afraid to flash an AOKP ROM because I didn't know what it was and just thought that it was a ROM in its early alpha stages and had a ton of bugs.
Thanks again!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because AOSP is pure stock Android. With AOKP, new features are being added in. So calling his ROM AOSP when its not AOSP is misleading.
AOKP is just simply a name of a ROM. Developers can give their ROM names anything they'd like. AOKP is certainly not buggy and I use it as a daily driver (even on nightlies). Very good ROM and maintained with updates
zephiK said:
Because AOSP is pure stock Android. With AOKP, new features are being added in. So calling his ROM AOSP when its not AOSP is misleading.
AOKP is just simply a name of a ROM. Developers can give their ROM names anything they'd like. AOKP is certainly not buggy and I use it as a daily driver (even on nightlies). Very good ROM and maintained with updates
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, great! I'm coming from the original Incredible and have never heard of AOKP til now, so thanks for helping clarify for me. Looks like AOKP might be my next ROM choice
Thanks to the OP for creating this thread, I was wondering the same thing.
erik1213 said:
Ok, great! I'm coming from the original Incredible and have never heard of AOKP til now, so thanks for helping clarify for me. Looks like AOKP might be my next ROM choice
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're welcome. I've never heard of it either but I just always assumed it was a name of a ROM
I recommend using franco's kernel with the ROM. Both of them push out updates every other day. You can always wait for feedback on the kernel before flashing but they're usually both good to go in terms of stability
There's a lot of debate about what kang actually means. From what I've read it's developed to mean anytime you take bits and pieces of code from other people and incorporate them into your own mod. If you didn't write it then you "kanged" it from someone else. Someone else probably knows the original origin of the word, but at least this gives a good definition.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
so they are or aren't based off of Klingon technology?
õ_Ô
Is there a difference and if so, what is the difference?
each has changelogs afaik , im using aokp and love it. cant speak for cm yet and unless im mistaken arent they all kangs right now ?
Flash them both, and have a look. It takes all of 5 minutes to flash a ROM. I used the CM9 builds on my Desire, not much of the CM9 extras are working, I'm not sure if that's the same for the Prime.
AOKP has extensive working tweaks, that much I do know.
aokp
difference is its features. cm9 is still in the works so a lot of the options you find in CM7 devices arent present yet.
On zephiK's recommendation I installed AOKP and don't see myself changing. It's a solid ROM.
hondaboi20002 said:
Is there a difference and if so, what is the difference?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There will be. There will be.
But for starters, AOPK is like Cyanogenmod, in the sense that both are based in AOSP. Neither are finished, at their current stages.
Im going from CM9 Kang to AOKP right now. CM9 was getting a little laggy for me (when moving around homescreens). And im sold by the AOKP tweaks
Reading the op of both rom threads can answer this
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus
Uhm okay I was going to post a topic similar to this but ill save some room on the forums by asking it here:
What is AOSP and AOKP? What do they mean and what are they? Which one is better and what are the differences? Is it a specific ROM or is it like a category?
azn android said:
Uhm okay I was going to post a topic similar to this but ill save some room on the forums by asking it here:
What is AOSP and AOKP? What do they mean and what are they? Which one is better and what are the differences? Is it a specific ROM or is it like a category?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
AOSP is Android Open Source Project, Android before manufacturers get their hands on it and install Sense or Touch Wiz. Essentially the Nexus Primes OS. AOKP is Android Open Kang Project a modified AOSP ROM made by Team Kang, with more bells and whistles than the stock Nexus ROM. Hope this helps.
azn android said:
Uhm okay I was going to post a topic similar to this but ill save some room on the forums by asking it here:
What is AOSP and AOKP? What do they mean and what are they? Which one is better and what are the differences? Is it a specific ROM or is it like a category?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fresh blood
AOSP - Android Open Source Project. Simply put, this is Android straight from Google, with no modifications. This is what you have on your phone. All of the ROMs here are built on AOSP - most, like AOKP, add modifications, while some don't.
AOKP - Android Open Kang Project. A ROM by Romanbb and his friends, built on AOSP, that adds many modifications and tweaks that aim to improve the end-user experience.
Yes it does thank you! So basically AOSP and AOKP are categories of the type of ROM a ROM is? Are there any other projects or are these the only two ones? Which one offers more stability and fluidness in the OS?
azn android said:
Yes it does thank you! So basically AOSP and AOKP are categories of the type of ROM a ROM is? Are there any other projects or are these the only two ones? Which one offers more stability and fluidness in the OS?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Almost.
AOSP is the version of Android that comes straight from Google. Manufacturers (such as Samsung, HTC, Motorola, etc) usually like to take AOSP ROMs and add their own modifications to it - and that's how we got Samsung's Touchwiz, HTC's Sense, Motorola's MotoBlur, etc.
However, Google partners up each year with a manufacturer to release a Nexus device. These devices are special in that they always come with AOSP, and because of that, they are always the first to receive updates to the Android OS, and are for the most part the devices with the most developer support on forums such as XDA.
AOKP isn't a type of ROM in itself - it is just a name given to a specific ROM. Like AOKP, you have for example CyanogenMod, which is yet a different ROM. Because we have a Nexus device, all of the ROMs you'll see in our development section are all built straight on AOSP. There are many ROMs out there, all unique in their own way, and the best way to find out which one is right for you is simply to try them all out. It may be scary at first, but after your 1st or 2nd flash, you'll become addicted for a few weeks
Thanks! Do you have a ROM that you recommend? Also, if all of the nexus ROM's are built off of AOSP, why is CM9 built off of Kang?
azn android said:
Thanks! Do you have a ROM that you recommend? Also, if all of the nexus ROM's are built off of AOSP, why is CM9 built off of Kang?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not, where did you read that? CM9 will be built from the ground up using the AOSP released by Google back in November.
Kang are using the Cyanogen GitHub to compile a CM9 beta ROM, as as far as I know, CM haven't released any betas (do they even release beta ROMs?) As far as I know they just go for a final build which is as stable as stable can be, people can't wait for the final builds and build ROMs using their work so we can try them as they are developed by the CM team.
That's my understanding of it anyways.
Oh my bad. I jumped to conclusions when I read the title to this post haha.
azn android said:
Thanks! Do you have a ROM that you recommend? Also, if all of the nexus ROM's are built off of AOSP, why is CM9 built off of Kang?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
CM is not built off of Kang. Kang is simply a term used to denote a compiled build of a ROM by someone other than that ROM's team or "authorized dealer". For example, User A compiles CM, changed a few lines in the code, and then publishes it here as his own work. That is a kang, and its highly frowned upon.
The reason the CM thread is labeled a "kang" is because there are no official builds of CM9 coming straight from CM yet - they're just experimental builds as of now. The reason why its allowed, is because recognized members of the CM team are releasing them.
I unfortunately don't even have my Nexus yet, but its coming in two days and I'm getting my feet wet. However, from what I've been exposed to, one of the more popular combinations around here seem to be AOKP with Franco's kernel.
I strongly advise you not to flash anything yet, though. You seem motivated to be here, which is good - but you also seem to not know too much about the world of Android yet.
Please, take the time to read through the following links:
Basic Android Terminology
Galaxy Nexus Frequently Asked Questions
Different Guides and Tutorials for the Galaxy Nexus
After you've finished, you'll be a little more familiar with Android and how stuff works. If you have questions, I strongly advise you to search Google and XDA first - I can almost guarantee your question has already been answered before
If you searched, but couldn't find an answer, please post in the Q&A sub-forum - there are many members like myself who love to help new users who are willing to take the time to learn themselves, without expecting others to do their work for them.
Finally, as a general rule, don't post stuff in the development sub-forum that aren't specifically development related. Yes, if you'll go through them, you'll probably see a bunch of posts that aren't tied in directly to development - but two wrongs don't make a right if you have a question about a specific ROM, usually the answer is right in that ROM's thread - if it isn't, most ROMs have IRC chatrooms set up, and if they don't - consider making a thread in the Q&A sub-forum.
Pardon the noobish question, but with the release of AOSP Sources for 4.0.4, I'm wondering: How much duplication goes on between ROM devs and AOSP devs?
When ROM devs and Kernel devs are tweaking kernels, are they fixing and optimizing the same things as AOSP devs? Or are they more often working on two different sides of the code, and fixes from one side advance the state of the art for the other?
Another way to put this: Right now, I'm using a custom kernel. Is it likely that a 4.0.4-based custom kernel will actually offer improvements over the current 4.0.3-based version of the same dev's kernel? Or have devs already made most of the tweaks that the AOSP devs did, resulting in a very modest improvement.
I'm just trying to temper my excitement a bit. I know that 4.0.4 would likely be huge coming from stock 4.0.2, but if the ROM devs are already well ahead of the AOSP folks, I won't expect 4.0.4 Gummy to be that different than 4.0.3 Gummy (for instance).
The devs merge the new code and stay current. They keep their tweaks too etc.
RogerPodacter said:
The devs merge the new code and stay current. They keep their tweaks too etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand, but I'm wondering how often the Dev tweaks ARE the new changes in a new AOSP release.
wanderfowl said:
I understand, but I'm wondering how often the Dev tweaks ARE the new changes in a new AOSP release.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats pretty rare, though may happen once in a while. Mostly the devs work on new features code and additions. I'll try to think of an example and post if it comes to me.
RogerPodacter said:
Thats pretty rare, though may happen once in a while. Mostly the devs work on new features code and additions. I'll try to think of an example and post if it comes to me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only one I can think of is the swyping of the notifications
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium